Autologous blood transfusion following total knee arthroplasty: is it always necessary?

A retrospective study of 85 patients undergoing primary total knee replacement (TKR), who also received autologous blood transfusion (ABT) to compensate for the perioperative blood loss. In our series 16.4% of the patients needed allogenic blood transfusion. Of the remaining 83.4% only 49.5% received autologous transfusion. Autologous transfusion was withheld in 34.1% of cases either because the blood volume was inadequate or because the collection time exceeded the recommended time limit. The mean haemoglobin (Hb) level with or without autologous transfusion was 10 g, raising the question of the necessity of using autologous transfusion in primary total TKR.     

Lung biopsy: is it necessary?

OBJECTIVE: Lung biopsy is associated with substantial mortality rates. We reviewed our experience with this operation, primarily in patients with immunocompetence, to determine whether the results justify the continued performance of this procedure. METHODS: We conducted a retrospective review of all diagnostic lung biopsies performed at 3 university-affiliated hospitals between July 1, 1992, and December 31, 1998. RESULTS: There were 75 patients: 25 patients were treated electively, 17 were treated on an urgent basis, 27 patients on an emergency basis, and the urgency was unclear in 6 patients. Significant beneficial therapeutic changes were made in 15 of 25 elective procedures (60%), in 16 of 17 urgent procedures (94%), and in 11 of 27 emergency procedures (41%; P =.001). Significant beneficial therapeutic changes consisted of immunosuppression in 13 of 15 (87%) patients treated on an elective basis, in 9 of 16 (56%) treated on an urgent basis, and in 9 of 11 (82%) treated on an emergency basis in whom therapy was altered (P =.14). Operative death was 0 of 25 for elective operations (0%), 3 of 17 for urgent operations (18%), and 14 of 26 for emergency operations (54%). Multivariable analysis of operative death showed urgency to be the only significant predictor of death (P =.002). CONCLUSIONS: In patients with immunocompetence, elective and urgent lung biopsies have acceptable operative mortality rates and frequently result in important beneficial therapeutic changes. Consequently biopsies are appropriate in these patients. Emergency biopsies are associated with high operative mortality rates and rarely result in a therapeutic change other than immunosuppression. These patients should not undergo lung biopsy if they are in stable condition and should be treated empirically with immunosuppression without operation if their condition is deteriorating.     

Annual mammography screening: is it necessary?

Recent recommendations from the U.S. Preventative Services Task Force suggest that screening mammography for women should be biennial starting at age 50 years and continue to age 74 years. With these recommendations in mind, we proposed a study to evaluate women at our institution in whom breast cancer is diagnosed within 1 year of a previously benign mammogram. A retrospective chart review was performed over a 4-year period. Only patients who had both diagnostic mammograms and previous mammograms performed at our institution and a pathologic diagnosis of breast cancer were included. Benign mammograms were defined as either Breast Imaging Reporting And Data System 1 or 2. Analysis of the time elapse between benign mammogram and subsequent mammogram indicative of the diagnosis of breast cancer was performed. A total of 205 patients were included. The average age was 64 years. From our results, 48 patients, 23 per cent of the total, had a documented benign mammogram at 12 months or less before a breast cancer diagnosis. One hundred forty-three (70%) patients had a benign mammogram at 18 months or less prior. This study raises concern that 2 years between screening mammograms may delay diagnosis and possible treatment options for many women.     

Surgery for appendicitis: is it necessary?

ABSTRACT Background: Appendectomy for acute appendicitis is an effective, universally accepted procedure performed more than 300,000 times annually in the United States. It is generally believed that appendicitis progresses invariably from early inflammation to later gangrene and perforation, and that appendectomy is required for surgical source control. Although non-operative management with antibiotics of uncomplicated diverticulitis, salpingitis, and neonatal enterocolitis is now established, the non-operative management of appendicitis remains largely unexplored. Methods: Systematic review of published literature and derived expert opinion. Results: Clinical, epidemiologic, radiologic, and pathologic evidence is presented for spontaneous resolution of uncomplicated acute appendicitis. The pathogenesis of appendicitis is reviewed with specific consideration of the role of bacterial infection in the pathogenesis. Evidence is also provided documenting the clinical success of non-operative management. Conclusions: Appendectomy may not be necessary for the majority of patients with acute uncomplicated appendicitis, as many patients resolve spontaneously and others may be treatable with antibiotics alone. However, the supporting documentation is scant and of poor quality. A randomized, prospective trial of non-operative management versus early appendectomy of acute uncomplicated appendicitis corroborated by radiologic imaging is called for.     

Ureterovascular hydronephrosis in children: is pyeloplasty always necessary?

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the efficacy of the vessel transposition technique in ureterovascular hydronephrosis in children. METHODS: Over a 25-year period, we treated 111 patients with 112 instances of ureterovascular hydronephrosis. In order to determine the obstructive effect of the vessels, we performed an intraoperative diuretic test. Using this approach, 61 patients judged to have only vascular pyeloureteral junction obstruction underwent vessel transposition. However, 50 patients in whom the intraoperative diuretic test proved doubtful needed pyeloplasty. RESULTS: Surgical success was achieved in 98% of the patients. Only 1 child treated by vessel transposition had an unsatisfactory outcome which necessitated a subsequent pyeloplasty for persistent hydronephrosis. This was due to a previously unrecognized intrinsic pyeloureteral junction obstruction. CONCLUSION: Based on our clinical experience, the intraoperative diuretic test has proven to be a safe and effective diagnostic tool in children with ureterovascular hydronephrosis. Its use may contribute to treating some cases of ureterovascular hydronephrosis without resorting to pyeloplasty.     

The new consent form: is it any better?

BACKGROUND: The UK Department of Health (DoH) introduced a new consent form into the National Health Service (NHS) in April 2002 following the Bristol Royal Infirmary Inquiry. AIM: To compare the efficacy of the new consent form with the old on the quality of consent. METHODS: A questionnaire consisting of 11 questions was distributed to two groups of 100 patients before and after the introduction of the new consent form in the pre-assessment clinic at Glenfield Hospital, Leicester. RESULTS: Of the 11 questions, there were four significant differences that favoured the new consent form. These were: (i) success and benefits of the operation (old, 81%; new, 97%, P < 0.001; 95% CI, 7.3-24.4%); (ii) information that patients received about the operation from the doctor (old, 34%; new, 93%; P < 0.001; 95% CI, 46.7%-68.9%) and nurse (old, 21%; new, 67%; P < 0.001; 95% CI, 33.3-58.3%) in the pre-assessment clinic; (iii) postoperative recovery (old, 56%; new, 96%; P < 0.001; 95% CI, 30.0%-51.2%); and (iv) ability to list potential complications that could arise from the operation (old, 61%; new, 97%; P < 0.001; 95% CI, 26.4-52.6%). Despite the above differences, an overall assessment involving all questions failed to show a significant improvement with the new consent form (old, 57%; new, 67%; P = 0.264;, 95% CI, -35.6% to 12.6%). DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS: The new consent form resulted in improvement in some, but not all, aspects of consent and no question reached the ideal standard of 100%. We suggest a formatted consent form for procedures in conjunction with additional information.     

Routine pre-operative blood testing: is it necessary?

In order to determine the value of routine pre-operative screening investigations, the medical notes of 100 patients undergoing elective surgical procedures under general anaesthesia were subject to prospective audit. Pre-operative screening investigations (full blood count, urea and electrolytes and random glucose) were analysed in terms of frequency of abnormalities and whether or not the peri-operative management was changed when the result was abnormal. The frequency of results being present in the note at the time of operation and the costing of the tests was also examined. A total of 773 tests was performed of which 70 (9.1%) were abnormal. Peri-operative management was altered as a result of only two abnormal results (0.2%). Eight complications arose, none of which could have been predicted by the pre-operative screening tests. In only 57% of cases were the results present in the medical notes at the time of surgery. It is conservatively estimated that a saving of pound 50 000 per year could be made in our hospital alone by selective ordering of tests.     

Cure of multifocal panhepatic hepatoblastoma: is liver transplantation always necessary?

Purpose

Multifocal panhepatic hepatoblastoma (HB) without extrahepatic disease is generally considered as an indication for total hepatectomy and liver transplantation. However, after initial chemotherapy, downstaging of the tumor sometimes allows complete macroscopic resection by partial hepatectomy. This procedure is no longer recommended because of the risk of persistent viable tumor cells in the hepatic remnant. We report our experience with conservative surgery in such cases.

Method

Between 2000 and 2005, 4 children were consecutively referred to our unit with multinodular pan-hepatic HBs (classification PRETEXT IV of the International Society of Pediatric Oncology Liver Tumor Study Group SIOPEL). Three of them had extrahepatic disease at diagnosis. All patients were treated according to SIOPEL 3 and 4 protocols.

Results

Extrahepatic metastases were still viable in 2 of 3 patients after initial chemotherapy. These patients eventually died of tumor recurrence. In the 2 patients without residual extrahepatic disease, liver tumors had regressed, and complete macroscopic excision of hepatic tumor remnants could be achieved by conservative surgery. These 2 children are alive and well and free of tumor 7 years after diagnosis.

Conclusions

Conservative surgery may be curative in some multinodular PRETEXT IV HB patients, with a good response to preoperative chemotherapy and complete excision of all macroscopic tumor remnants. However, because of the lack of reliable predictors of sterilization of the microscopic disease in the residual liver, with subsequent poor prognosis, total hepatectomy and liver transplantation remain currently recommended in patients with multinodular PRETEXT IV HB without extrahepatic disease, even though some of these children are probably overtreated.     

Interlocking nail for femoral shaft fractures: is dynamization always necessary?

A series of 179 closed femoral fractures treated by static interlocking nailing (Grosse-Kempf nail) was reviewed to evaluate the effect of dynamization on the time to bony union. In 75 patients, dynamization was performed whereas in 104 the implant was left static. Union occurred in 178 patients. We observed one infection. Time to union was significantly shorter in the static group (103 days) compared to the dynamized group (126 days).

---

Résumé Une série de 179 fractures fémorales fermées traitées par enclouage verrouillé centro-médullaire statique (clou de Grosse-Kempf) a été examinée pour évaluer leffet de la dynamisation sur le temps de consolidation osseuse. Chez 75 malades la dynamisation a été exécuté, alors que pour 104 limplant était laissé statique. La consolidation sest effectuée chez 178 malades. Nous avons observé une infection. Le temps de consolidation était significativement plus court dans le groupe statique (103 jours) comparé au groupe dynamisé (126 jours).

     

Positive axillary sentinel lymph node: is axillary dissection always necessary?

There is considerable interest in foregoing axillary dissection (AD) when the sentinel node (SN) is positive in early breast cancer, particularly when axillary involvement is minimal (micrometastases or isolated tumor cells). In fact, clinical practice has run ahead of the evidence, since recent population-based data indicate that AD is 'underused' in breast cancer patients when the SN is positive. Several trials are addressing the problem (IBCSG 23-01, ASCOG Z0011, EORTC AMAROS). Only Z0011 has published interim results, finding, after a median follow-up of 6.3 years, no differences in locoregional recurrence or regional recurrence between patients, with a positive SN, who received AD vs. no further axillary treatment. Our own retrospective study evaluated patients with micrometastases or isolated tumor cells in the SN who received no further axillary treatment. We found high five-year survival and low cumulative incidence of axillary recurrence, supporting the findings of Z0011 and justifying the increasingly common practice of foregoing AD in women with minimal SN involvement. It is important to sound a note of caution however: If axillary dissection is not always necessary in women with a positive axilla, it seems important to be able to reliably identify the patients at high risk of developing overt axillary disease who should receive elective AD. Ancillary analyses of the IBCSG 23-01 and AMAROS trials, still in follow-up, may be able to do this.     

Urinary catheter in laparoscopic cholecystectomy: is it necessary?

The aim of this prospective study was to evaluate the necessity or urinary catheterization in elective laparoscopic cholecystectomy. From April 1996 to April 1998, 261 patients undergoing elective laparoscopic cholecystectomy at a county hospital were randomized to either receive or not receive preoperative urinary bladder catheterization. Data analyzed included age and gender of patients, length of surgery, and intraoperative and perioperative complications such as visceral injury, urinary tract infection, and urinary retention. Our results showed, although not statistically significant, more urinary tract complications in the "with Foley" group than in the "without Foley" group (four vs one, respectively). There was no significant difference between the two groups with respect to length of operation and perioperative complications. There was no visceral injury or operative mortality in this study. We conclude that urinary catheterization can be omitted safely in elective laparoscopic cholecystectomy.