Fifteen-year survivorship of a collarless,cemented, normalized femoral stem in primary hybrid total hip arthroplasty with a modified third-generation cement technique

This prospective review aimed to evaluate 15-year survivorship of the collarless, third-generation cemented, normalized, Omnifit (Osteonics, Allendale, NJ) femoral stem in hybrid total hip arthroplasty (THA). Between January 1986 and June 1990, a single surgeon prospectively implanted 250 consecutive hybrid THAs (215 patients) using a modified third-generation cement technique in selected patients. A Harris-Galante (I or II) (Zimmer, Warsaw, IN) cementless shell with modular polyethylene (4150 resin) liners gamma-sterilized in air were implanted. Kaplan-Meier survivorship of the femoral or acetabular component with mechanical failure (revision for aseptic loosening) as the end-point was 100% ± 0% at 15 years. Wear couple exchange and bone grafting was performed in 1 case (0.4%) for progressive acetabular osteolysis. This report supports femoral component centralization and good cement mantle to ensure durability of the collarless, cemented, normalized femoral stem with a surface roughness of 30–40 microinches.     

The Charnley versus the Spectron hip prosthesis: radiographic evaluation of a randomized, prospective study of 2 different hip implants.

A total of 410 hips were randomized to treatment with either a Charnley (206 hips) or a Spectron (204 hips) total hip arthroplasty. The patients were operated on by a standardized procedure using a contemporary cementing technique and were followed after 1, 3, 5 to 6, and 10 years. The postoperative radiographs showed a significantly increased rate of malalignment and consequently low grade of cement mantle quality of the Charnley stem compared to the Spectron. No differences concerning cement mantle quality or positioning were found between the Charnley ogee cup and the metal-backed Spectron. Evaluation of the follow-up radiographs revealed 10 loose Charnley stems and 1 loose Spectron stem and 4 loose Charnley ogee cups and 23 loose Spectron metal-backed cups. The differences of revision rate for the femoral and acetabular components of the 2 prostheses were significant (P = .03, Charnley femoral component more frequent; P = .03, Spectron acetabular component more frequent). The radiographic evaluation strengthened this disparity. Poor wear characteristics of the metal-backed Spectron cup are perhaps the main reason for the highly significant difference in mechanical failure rate between the 2 cups. We therefore propose that metal-backing of cemented cups should be avoided, at least when combined with larger femoral heads. The difficulty in positioning the Charnley stem with an adequate cement mantle, especially in the absence of trochanteric osteotomy, might explain the inferior Charnley stem longevity in this study.     

Staged bilateral total hip arthroplasty using rough and smooth surface femoral stems with similar design: 10-year survivorship of 48 cases

BACKGROUND: Various studies have reported good long-term results using femoral stems with either smooth or rough surfaces. In this retrospective cross-sectional survivorship study, we reviewed the 10-year results of 51 bilateral staged cemented total hip arthroplasties using the Harvard or the Charnley femoral stems-which have almost similar geometry but a different surface finish. METHODS: 51 patients were reviewed at median interval of 10 (Harvard group) and 11 years (Charnley group) after the primary operation. We evaluated cement mantle thickness, alignment of the components, presence of radiolucent lines, and aseptic loosening. Kaplan-Meier analysis was performed to calculate the survival rate using various endpoints. RESULTS: 8 hips in the Harvard group were revised for aseptic loosening of the femoral component at a median interval of 6.3 years after the primary procedure. 3 hips in the Charnley group were revised for aseptic loosening of the femoral and acetabular components between 10 and 11 years after the primary procedure. The 10-year survival rate for the femoral component using revision surgery for aseptic loosening as an endpoint was 80% (95% CI: 31-42) and 95% (95% CI: 44-47) in the Harvard and the Charnley group, respectively. Cox regression analysis did not reveal any statistically significant effect of various radiographical parameters on the survival rate (p < 0.05). INTERPRETATION: Our results demonstrate that in the group of patients studied, the femoral stem component with the matt surface finish had less satisfactory 10-year survival than the femoral stem of similar design which had a smooth surface finish.     

Early revision among 12,179 hip prostheses: A comparison of 10 different brands reported to the Norwegian Arthroplasty Register, 1987-1993

On the basis of data from the Norwegian Arthroplasty Register during the period 1987-1993, we have compared times to revision for 10 different cemented total hip prostheses. A total of 11,169 patients, with 12,179 primary total hip replacements (THRs), performed with high viscosity cement for primary arthrosis and followed for a maximum of 6.4 years, were included in this study.

The Kaplan-Meier estimate of the overall percentage revised after 5 years was 2.5 (95% Confidence Interval: 2.1-3.0). For the Charnley prosthesis (n6,694), 2.9% were revised after 5 years (95% CI: 2.3-3.4). Using Cox regression to adjust for gender, age, type of cement and use of systemic antibiotic prophylaxis, the Charnley prosthesis was compared with the 9 other brands. The revision rate for the SpectrodlTH combination (Spectron acetabulum, ITH femur) (n 1,034) was only 0.35 (p 0.04) times that of the Charnley prostheses. The EliteKharnley combination (Elite acetabulum, Charnley femur) (n 507) and the Mirller Type prosthesis (n 11 6) showed poorer results with failure rates 2.3 (p 0.01) and 2.7 times (p 0.04) that of Charnley, respectively.

Although the overall results for cemented THRs in general were good, clinically important differences in revision rates were demonstrated among the cemented prosthesis brands. Our findings underline the need for careful evaluation of different total hip replacements.     

Results of cemented metal-backed acetabular components: A 10-year-average follow-up study

The clinical and radiographic results of 86 primary total hip arthroplasties performed in 74 patients from 1983 to 1987 with a cemented metal-backed acetabular component and a cemented collared straight femoral stem with a 32-mm head were reviewed at a mean follow-up of 10.1 years. Seven patients (9.2%) underwent acetabular component revision at a mean of 9.0 years after implantation; an additional 24 components (31.6%) demonstrated evidence of radiographic loosening, resulting in a total failure rate of 40.8%. Periacetabular radiolucencies were noted in Charnley zones at the following rates: 34.2% in zone I, 18.4% in zone II, and 27.6% in zone III. In addition, 18.4% and 38.2% of implants demonstrated evidence of migration and excessive polyethylene wear. Excessively vertical cup placement (>49° inclination) at the time of initial arthroplasty was statistically correlated with polyethylene wear, implant migration, and fixation failure. A trend of increasing implant failure was also noted with decreasing polyethylene liner thickness. Periacetabular cement mantle thickness was not statistically correlated with subsequent component loosening or failure. Results of Kaplan-Meier survivorship analysis using revision as an endpoint showed 93.6% survivorship at 10 years and 88.4% at 12 years. The mean modified Harris hip scores were 46.9 preoperatively and 81.8 at final follow-up. The significant overall rates of radiographic loosening, migration, polyethylene wear, and implant revision confirm the suspected trend of increasing failure rates of cemented metal-backed acetabular components over time.     

Ten-year survivorship of rough-surfaced femoral stem with geometry similar to Charnley femoral stem

The aim of this study is to review the 10-year results of 269 cemented total hip arthroplasties performed using the Harvard femoral stem with matte surface finish and Charnley stem-like geometry. This is a retrospective cross-sectional survivorship study. We retrospectively reviewed the results of 269 cemented total hip arthroplasties performed using the Harvard femoral stem in 257 patients (men/women 93:164, mean age 71.2 years) between 1990 and 1994. The median duration of follow-up for the surviving implants was 118 (range 60-129) months. Radiographs were reviewed to evaluate the type of osteoarthritis, cement mantle thickness, alignment of the components, presence of aseptic loosening, and radiolucent lines. Kaplan-Meier survival analysis and Cox proportional hazards analysis were performed to evaluate 10-year survival and the impact of various radiological parameters on the prosthesis survival respectively. Of the 248 eligible patients (260 hips), 6 patients (7 hips) were lost to follow-up, and 67 patients had died at the time of the study; 36 hips (35 patients) underwent revision surgery for aseptic failure (median duration 60 months, range 12-125 months), and 11 hips were revised for septic failure (median duration 24 months, range 10-53 months from the index procedure). The femoral component was revised in all patients, whereas the acetabular component was revised in 27 patients. Ten-year survival for the femoral and acetabular components using aseptic loosening (with and without revision surgery) as an end point was 77.5% (71.5%-83.5%) and 91.1% (87.2%-95%), respectively. Cox regression analysis did not reveal a statistically significant (P > 0.05) effect of various radiological parameters on survival rate. Our results demonstrate that the matte surface finish femoral component (with geometry similar to Charnley femoral component) has less satisfactory long-term survival rate.     

Primary hybrid total hip arthroplasty with a roughened femoral stem: integrity of the stem-cement interface

One hundred and two consecutive cemented femoral stems were evaluated in 92 patients at an average 9-year follow-up and a minimum 5-year follow-up (range, 5-14 years). The stem used was cobalt chromium with a collar, normalization steps, and a roughened surface (Ra 40); the stem was inserted using contemporary cementing techniques. This series demonstrated a femoral component aseptic loosening rate of 2.0% and a femoral component survivorship of 97.2 +/- 2.0% at 10 years. One of 2 failed stems was revised at 95 months for failure at the cement-bone interface. The second failed stem showed failure at the cement-bone interface with incomplete debonding radiographically at 65 months. The remaining femoral components did not demonstrate any evidence of debonding at the stem-cement interface. These results compare favorably with other series of cemented femoral stems, as well as with those with a polished surface.     

Influence of stem geometry on mechanics of cemented femoral hip components with a proximal bond

Nonlinear, three-dimensional, finite element models of cemented femoral hip components with a proximal stem-Cement bond were developed with use of a Charnley stem geometry and a modified Charnley stem geometry that had a cylindrical cross section over the distal two-thirds of the stem (Distal-Round). Peak tensile stresses in the proximal cement mantle increased 63 and 74% for the Charnley and Distal-Round stems, respectively, when the proximal stem-cement interface was debonded, The shear stresses over the stem-cement interface with a proximal bond were 29%. larger for the Distal-Round stem than for the Charnley stem. After the proximal stem-cement interface was debonded. the peak tensile stresses in the cement mantle were 15% larger for the Distal-Round stem than for the Charnley stem. The results illustrate that stresses within the proximal cement mantle could be substantially reduced for both Charnley and Distal-Round stems through use of a proximal stem-cement bond. However, the risk of debonding may be higher for the Distal-Round stem because of increased shear stresses, and once debonded the risk of further loosening due to failure of the cement mantle would also be higher for the Distal-Round stem.     

Long-term comparison of the Charnley, Muller, and trapezoidal-28 total hip prostheses: A survival analysis

Seven hundred ninety-one total hip arthroplasties (242 Charnley prostheses, 146 Muller prostheses, and 403 Trapezoidal-28) performed between 1969 and 1980 by one surgeon were evaluated using survival analysis to predict success and/or failure over time. Only 6.4% of the population was excluded because of failure to return for follow-up evaluation. All other patients were included in the analysis. It is expected that at 10 years after operation, 91% of the Charnley, 88% of the T-28, and 80% of the Muller prostheses will survive (P less than .05). The acetabular cup of the Muller prosthesis showed significant premature loosening, compared with the Charnley and T-28 prostheses (P less than .0001 and P less than .05, respectively). The Muller femoral stem was inferior only to the Charnley (P less than .025). The T-28 femoral stem showed no difference in success compared with the other two prostheses, despite 10 T-28 femoral stem fractures. Multivariate survivorship regression analysis revealed significant factors that may have predisposed the above failures. Women (P less than .0005) and older patients (P less than .0005) had significantly higher success rates. Significant intrinsic factors included radiolucency about the entire acetabular bone-cement interface (P less than .0005), fracture in the acetabular cement (P less than .005), and radiolucency about the entire femoral bone-cement interface (P less than .0005).     

Staged bilateral total hip arthroplasty using rough and smooth surface femoral stems with similar design: 10-year survivorship of 48 cases

Background?Various studies have reported good long-term results using femoral stems with either smooth or rough surfaces. In this retrospective cross-sectional survivorship study, we reviewed the 10-year results of 51 bilateral staged cemented total hip arthroplasties using the Harvard or the Charnley femoral stems—which have almost similar geometry but a different surface finish.

Methods?51 patients were reviewed at median interval of 10 (Harvard group) and 11 years (Charnley group) after the primary operation. We evaluated cement mantle thickness, alignment of the components, presence of radiolucent lines, and aseptic loosening. Kaplan-Meier analysis was performed to calculate the survival rate using various endpoints.

Results?8 hips in the Harvard group were revised for aseptic loosening of thefemoral component at a median interval of 6.3 years after the primary procedure. 3 hips in the Charnley group were revised for aseptic loosening of the femoral and acetabular components between 10 and 11 years after the primary procedure. The 10-year survival rate for the femoral component using revision surgery for aseptic loosening as an endpoint was 80% (95% CI: 31–42) and 95% (95% CI: 44–47) in the Harvard and the Charnley group, respectively. Cox regression analysis did not reveal any statistically significant effect of various radiographical parameters on the survival rate (p < 0.05).

Interpretation?Our results demonstrate that in the group of patients studied, the femoral stem component with the matt surface finish had less satisfactory 10-year survival than the femoral stem of similar design which had a smooth surface finish.

?     

Outcome of revision for mechanical stem failure using the cemented Charnley's stem: A Study of 399 Cases

Three hundred ninety-nine cemented stem revision total hip arthroplasties performed in cases with mechanical stem failure without infection and having a minimum follow-up period of 3 years were prospectively studied. Two hundred eighty-three were revised for aseptic stem loosening and 116 were revised for fractured stem. Bone-grafting was not performed in any of the cases. The average follow-up period was 7 years 5 months. At the last follow-up evaluation, 70.4% of the patients were pain free and 20.6% had only mild or occasional discomfort. On radiographic evaluation, 31 stems (7.8%) were loose. Thirty-five hips (8.8%) required a rerevision, of which only 20 (5.0%) were for recurrence of mechanical stem failure. Clinical survivorship of the revised stem was 93.9% at 10 years, whereas radiographic survivorship was 91.5% at 10 years. On radiographic analysis, the mechanical failure rate at the last follow-up evaluation was greater after revision for fractured stem than after revision for aseptic stem loosening. Prerevision femoral cortical bone stock did not appear to adversely affect the outcome of the procedure. The clinical and radiologic results achieved with cemented stem revision arthroplasty for mechanical stem failure are excellent.     

A comparison of cortical strain after cemented and press-fit proximal and distal femoral replacement.

Proximal and distal femoral replacements with intramedullary stems are usually cemented in place but frequently show severe bone remodeling changes in the long term, which can contribute to a loosening process. The remodeling is likely to be associated with stress and strain distribution. This study compared the strain patterns, particularly the maximum principal strains, between cemented and press-fit components in five cadaveric femurs by using a photoelastic coating technique. The specimens were loaded with 2,000 N in the sequences of intact femur and press-fit and cemented stems. On the medial side of the bone for proximal femoral replacements, the strain values for the press-fit stems on the proximal, middle, and distal regions were 73 +/- 11%, 78 +/- 15%, and 80 +/- 15% of normal, respectively, but for the cemented stems they were 53 +/- 15%, 57 +/- 19%, and 60 +/- 20%. The differences were statistically significant (p less than 0.05). On the lateral side, the overall strain values for the press-fit stem were higher than those for the cemented stem, but the differences were not statistically significant (p greater than 0.05). On the medial side of the distal femoral replacement, the strain values for the press-fit stems in the proximal and middle regions were significantly closer to normal than for the cemented stems. Because the press-fit femoral stems (both the proximal and distal replacement) transferred closer to normal strains than the cemented stems, less adverse bone remodeling may be expected, which could be reflected in increased longevity.     

Total hip reconstruction in the anatomically distorted hip

Recent reports in the literature strongly support the idea that cement is the optimum form of fixation of the femoral component in total hip replacement. For hybrid total hip arthroplasty, we used a cemented cup instead of an uncemented cup since this was inevitable in cases of poorly developed acetabulum. The uncemented cone femoral component is also beneficial in cases of extremely narrow and cylindrical configuration of the medullary cavity of untreated congenital dislocation of the hips (CDH) and tuberculosis or septic arthritis in childhood. We reviewed the clinical result of a consecutive series of patients with cemented total hip arthroplasty (THA) compared with recent studies on hybrid reconstruction using survivorship analysis. This subsequent study involved a hybrid uncemented Wagner cone femoral component and a cemented acetabular component with roof reinforcement by additional impacted cancellous allograft with hydroxyapatite (HA). We believe that early failure of the cemented components was due to an adverse effect of thin cement mantles around cemented femoral stems as well as the cemented cup in THA. In addition, 8 patients who received our modification of the Charnley CDH component had poor results even though we reduced the stem geometry and thickness. Furthermore, intraoperative fracture and splitting of the proximal femur was a major complication during implantation. Contrary to expectations, the results of these hybrid reconstructions were extremely encouraging (average follow-up period of 2–4.5 years). In addition to our experience of the cemented versus hybrid THA involving the uncemented Wagner femoral component, we have determined positive indications for the untreated and severely distorted anatomy of bilateral CDH for which surgical interventions for reconstruction were not recommended before.     

The Charnley versus the Spectron hip prosthesis: clinical evaluation of a randomized, prospective study of 2 different hip implants.

Prospective, randomized studies must be performed when new surgical techniques or implants are evaluated. In this study, a new implant system was compared with the Charnley prosthesis, which over the years has been the most used hip implant in Sweden. Between 1985 and 1989, 410 hips were randomized to treatment with a Charnley or a Spectron total hip arthroplasty: 206 Charnley and 204 Spectron prostheses were implanted. The patients were operated on by a standardized procedure using a contemporary cementing technique. The patients were followed prospectively by an independent observer after 1, 3, 5 to 6, and 10 years. Harris Hip Score and patient satisfaction were recorded in the outcome evaluation. A total of 144 patients with 164 hips were deceased, and 15 patients (8 Charnley and 7 Spectron) have required a revision. Nine hips were revised because of aseptic loosening (5 Charnley stems and 4 Spectron metal-backed cups). The Charnley stem as well as the metal-backed Spectron cup had a higher risk for revision because of aseptic loosening. The Charnley ogee cup and the Spectron stem have performed remarkably well with no revision of these components. Seven Charnley prostheses dislocated, but no dislocation was recorded in the Spectron group. Survivorship calculations with a mean follow-up of 10 years revealed an overall 11-year survivorship of 94.5% +/- 3.4% (Charnley, 93.2% +/- 5.8%; Spectron, 95.9% +/- 3.0%). The clinical outcome did not differ between the 2 systems. The overall results in this old population, using a contemporary surgical technique, illustrate that cemented hip arthroplasty is an excellent treatment alternative for elderly patients.     

A prospective outcomes analysis of femoral component fixation in revision total hip arthroplasty

A prospective, surgeon-allocated, matched cohort analysis of patient outcomes compared cementless, modular metaphyseal and cemented femoral fixation used for revision total hip arthroplasty. First-time femoral revision operations (with and without acetabular revision) with Paprosky types I and II femoral bone stock were included. This series of 86 patients was matched for age, weight, diagnosis, Charnley class, Demand category, femoral bone stock, and outcome measures. At 8-year average follow-up (range, 4-13 years), there were no significant differences in visual analog pain scores (VAPS), Harris Hip Scores (HSS), and SF-36 Physical Function and Bodily Pain scores. One femoral rerevision (2.3%) occurred in the cementless group, and 2 (4.6%) occurred in the cemented group (P = .557). Five-year survivorship for femoral rerevision was 94% for patients with cementless, modular metaphyseal fixation and 92% for patients with cemented fixation. In this study, cementless, modular metaphyseal fixation and cemented femoral fixation were both successful at intermediate-term follow-up in Paprosky types I and II femoral bone (level of evidence: therapeutic study; level II, prospective comparative study).     

Twenty-five-year results after Charnley total hip arthroplasty in patients less than fifty years old: a concise follow-up of a previous report

We report the updated results for a previously evaluated cohort of patients who were less than fifty years old when they underwent Charnley total hip arthroplasty with cement. The original cohort consisted of ninety-three total hip arthroplasties performed in sixty-nine patients. The patients were followed for a minimum of twenty-five years after surgery or until death. The present report describes the findings of the radiographic and functional follow-up, which was performed for forty-two of the forty-three living patients. At the time of the latest follow-up, twenty-nine (31%) of the ninety-three total hip replacements had been revised or removed. Eighteen acetabular and five femoral components were revised secondary to aseptic loosening. The combined prevalence of radiographic failure or revision because of aseptic loosening was 13% for the femoral components and 34% for the acetabular components. Comorbid medical conditions significantly hindered results on each functional subscale (p < 0.05). This study demonstrates the durability of cemented total hip replacements in a young patient population. Sixty-nine percent of the original hip replacements were functioning well at the latest follow-up examination or at the time of death, and only 5% required more than one revision arthroplasty.     

Radiological factors influencing femoral and acetabular failure in cemented Charnley total hip arthroplasties

We have made a retrospective review of 185 cemented Charnley total hip arthroplasties performed between 1970 and 1974 to determine the relationships between radiological variables and failure of the femoral and acetabular components. We measured the acetabular wear, the orientation of the cup, the thickness and consistency of acetabular and femoral cement mantles, radiolucency and femoral alignment. The mean follow-up was for 11.7 years. Femoral loosening was demonstrable radiologically in 15 hips (8.1%), ten (5.4%) of which were revised during the period of follow-up. Only when the first postoperative radiograph showed a thin cement mantle in Gruen zone 5 was there a significant association with failure of the femoral component. There were 12 loose acetabular components (6.5%), nine (4.8%) of which were revised. When the initial radiograph after operation showed radiolucency in DeLee and Charnley zone 1, the incidence of acetabular loosening was 28.21%. If such radiolucency was not present, the incidence of acetabular loosening was only 0.69%. Our findings emphasise the importance of careful cementing.     

Radiographic performance of two different total hip cemented arthroplasties. A survivorship analysis

Detailed serial radiographic analysis of the femoral and acetabular components of 367 Charnley (cobalt-chrome alloy) and 383 STH (titanium alloy) primary cemented total hip prostheses was conducted. The follow-up of the Charnley prosthesis ranged from 1 to 16 years (mean follow-up, 9 years), and for the STH from 1 to 11 years (mean follow-up, 80 months). Both single period and survivorship analyses were done to evaluate the radiographic performance. The analysis revealed that the curved STH prostheses' overall radiographic performance was less satisfactory than the Charnley prostheses. However, the STH with a straight stem had significantly better radiographic performance compared with the Charnley prostheses in all parameters except in the incidence of bone-cement radiolucent lines.     

Excellent results of a femoral press-fit stem cemented with a thin mantle: 116 hips followed for 11–18 years

We report the outcome of a femoral stem designed for press-fit insertion and cemented with a thin mantle. During the years 1986–1992 we performed 346 primary total hip replacements in 305 patients. Their mean age at the time of the surgery was 75 (range, 52–91 years). During the follow-up, 206 patients had died (227 hips) and 3 were lost. This left us with 96 patients (116 hips), who were followed for a mean of 13 years (range, 11–18 years). Stem survivorship according to Kaplan–Meier analysis indicated a total survival of 0.982 (confidence intervals, 0.952–1). The mechanical survival rate was 0.985 (confidence intervals, 0.955–1) at 17 years with one patient at risk. Fifty-nine (70%) of the surviving patients were very satisfied with the operated hip, 22 (26%) were satisfied, 2 (2.5%) were content, and 1 (1.5%) was dissatisfied. Then, the press-fit stem allowing minimal cement has a 17-year survival rate of 0.98.     

Survival of cemented total hip replacements

A Kaplan-Meier survival analysis of 240 Charnley, 149 Mueller (Depuy, Warsaw, IN), 576 Trapezoidal 28 (Zimmer, Warsaw, IN), and 100 Miami Orthopaedic Surgical Clinics (Biomet, Warsaw, IN) cemented total hip replacements with all polyethylene acetabular components, performed by the senior author (M.A.R.) should be the basis that all noncemented total hip replacements must exceed to be a reasonable alternative. Failure, ie, revision and a loose prosthesis, shows that 80%, 61%, and 63% of the Charnley, Mueller, and Trapezoidal 28, respectively, survive longer than 15 years. The Miami Orthopaedic Surgical Clinics prosthesis, which uses current cement technology, has been observed for only 8 years. Despite the fact that there are no differences noted between all four prostheses at 8 years, more time is needed to judge the usefulness of current cement technology.