CD4+ T-epitope repertoire on the human acetylcholine receptor alpha subunit in severe myasthenia gravis: a study with synthetic peptides.

The alpha subunit of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) seems crucial in the pathogenesis of the autoimmune paralysis myasthenia gravis (MG) because it contains both the epitopes that dominate the antibody response against the AChR and those recognized by CD4+ AChR-specific T helper (Th) cells. To define the repertoire of anti-AChR Th cells, we investigated the response of unselected blood CD4+ cells or total lymphocytes, or both, from 22 MG patients to 20-residue overlapping synthetic peptides, screening the complete sequence of human-muscle AChR alpha subunit. Several epitopes were identified. Only the most severely affected patients recognized alpha subunit epitopes, and they were mainly young women. Detection of in vitro AChR-specific CD4+ response was facilitated by removal of the CD8+ cells because in two patients a clear response to several alpha subunit peptide sequences could be detected when CD(8+)-depleted cells were used, while their total peripheral blood mononuclear cell population did not respond to any alpha subunit peptide. Although each patient had a unique pattern of peptide recognition, four immunodominant regions recognized by long-term AChR-specific CD4+ T-cell lines, or flanking peptide sequences, were recognized most frequently (residues 48-67, 101-137, 293-337, and 308-437).     

Myasthenia in SCID mice grafted with myasthenic patient lymphocytes: role of CD4+ and CD8+ cells

OBJECTIVES: Acetylcholine receptor (AChR)-specific CD4+ cells are present in MG patients, and synthesis of the high-affinity immunoglobulin G (IgG) autoantibodies (autoAb) against the muscle AChR that causes MG symptoms requires intervention of CD4+ cells. The role of CD4+ cells in MG pathogenesis has been postulated but never proven. MG patients do not have anti-AChR cytotoxic phenomena, and it has been assumed that CD8+ cells do not have a pathogenic role in MG. However, CD8+ cells may facilitate rodent experimental MG, raising the possibility that CD8+ cells might be necessary also in MG. In this study we examined whether CD4+ and CD8+ cells play a role in the pathogenesis of MG and whether CD4+ cells specific for AChR epitope sequences recognized by most MG patients ("universal" epitopes) drive the synthesis of pathogenic antibodies. METHODS: First we characterized a chimeric human-mouse model of MG in severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) mice engrafted with blood lymphocytes (BL) from MG patients. We used that model to determine whether CD4+ and CD8+ cells are necessary for transfer of MG symptoms. We engrafted SCID mice intraperitoneum with BL from 19 MG patients and 5 healthy controls. We engrafted some mice with either BL, BL depleted in CD4+ or CD8+ cells from the same patient, or CD4+ depleted BL reconstituted with CD4+ T cells from the same patient, specific for "universal" AChR epitopes or for two unrelated antigens, tetanus and diphtheria toxoids. We tested the mice for myasthenic symptoms for 7 to 18 weeks. RESULTS: Mice transplanted with BL, or CD8+ depleted BL, or CD4+-depleted BL reconstituted with anti-AChR CD4+ cells from MG patients frequently developed myasthenic weakness. The mice had human anti-AChR Ab in the serum and bound to muscle AChR. Mice transplanted with BL from controls, or CD4+-depleted BL from MG patients, or CD4+-depleted BL from an MG patient reconstituted with CD4+ cells specific for tetanus or diphtheria toxoids did not develop myasthenic weakness or anti-AChR Ab. CONCLUSIONS: CD4+ cells are necessary for MG pathogenesis; CD8+ cells may not be. CD4+ cells specific for "universal" AChR epitopes help the synthesis of pathogenic Ab.     

Anti-acetylcholine receptor antibodies.

Early suggestions that a humoral factor might be implicated in the disorder of neuromuscular transmission in myasthenia gravis have been confirmed by the detection of anti-AChR antibody in 85-90% of the patients with generalised disease and in 75% of cases with restricted ocular myasthenia. Plasma exchange reveals that serum anti-AChR usually has an inverse relationship to muscle strength and present evidence indicates that patients responding to thymectomy and immunosuppressive durg treatment usually show a consistent decline in serum anti-AChR titres. The antibody is heterogeneous and can lead to a loss of muscle AChR by several mechanisms. Anti-AChR is produced in the thymus in relatively small amounts. Anti-AChR antibody synthesis by thymic lymphocytes and pokeweed stimulated peripheral lymphocytes in culture provides a means of studying the effect of different lymphocyte populations in vitro. Analysis of clinical, immunological and HLA antigen characteristics in MG suggest that more than one mechanism may underlie the breakdown in tolerance to AChR, leading to the production of anti-AChR antibodies.     

Generation of acetylcholine receptor-specific human T cell lines using heterobifunctional antibody-targeted antigen presentation.

Characterizing AChR-specific T lymphocyte clones is an important step towards the ability to induce antigen-specific tolerance in myasthenia gravis (MG). However, the limited supply of relatively inefficient autologous antigen presenting cells (APCs) makes establishing AChR-specific T lymphocyte lines difficult. In this study we targeted AChR to autologous surface IgM+ (sIgM+) APCs using heterobifunctional antibodies (bi-Ab) consisting of anti-sIgM linked to anti-AChR antibodies. FACScan analysis and whole cell-based radioimmunoassay (RIA) showed binding of bi-Ab/AChR conjugates to sIgM+ APCs. Using antigen targeting, AChR-presentation to a well-characterized AChR-specific T cell clone, and to T cell lines raised de novo from MG thymocytes, was improved. Thus, antigen targeting using bi-Ab improved the efficiency of presentation of the scarce autoantigen AChR, suggesting that this method might allow the use of relatively impure antigen preparations and normally inefficient non-antigen-specific APCs, including those which can be immortalized, to accelerate the characterization of the AChR epitopes recognized by pathogenic T helper lymphocytes.     

Anti-AChR antibodies, thymic histology, and T cell subsets in myasthenia gravis

The relationship between the titers of antibody against acetylcholine receptor (AChR) and T helper/suppressor balance (assessed by the OKT4/OKT8 ratio) were investigated in 74 patients with myasthenia gravis (MG). All patients with elevated AChR antibody titers (greater than 100 nM) had hyperplastic thymuses, while most patients with low or negative antibody titers (less than 1 nM) had involuted thymuses. All patients with thymoma had positive, though not very high, antibody titers. No correlation was found between anti-AChR antibody levels and OKT4/OKT8 ratios except for patients with thymoma. Thus, it appears that AChR antibody titers are more closely related to thymic pathology than to peripheral T cell imbalance. These results are consistent with the hypothesis giving a central role to thymic lymphocytes in the AChR antibody production, either as antibody producer B cells or helper T cells.     

Comparison of the histological and immunohistochemical features of the thymus in young- and elderly-onset myasthenia gravis without thymoma.

We performed histological and immunohistochemical analyses of the removed thymuses from 20 elderly (onset age > 60 years) and 23 young (onset age < 40 years) patients with myasthenia gravis (MG) who tested positive for serum anti-acetylcholine receptor (AChR) antibodies, but who did not have associated thymoma. In the elderly group, nine (45%) patients had accumulations of lymphocytes, indicating an atrophied thymus with loss of the basic structure. The elderly MG patients with atrophied thymic tissues had higher titres of anti-AChR antibody (59.6+/-81.0 nmol/L) than those with adipose infiltration of the thymus alone (20.1+/-20.9 nmol/L). In immunohistochemical studies using image analysis, both young patients and elderly patients with atrophied thymic tissues were found to have significantly higher levels of CD20 than age-matched controls (p < 0.005). Atrophied thymic tissues, often seen immunohistochemically in young MG patients, may also be found in elderly patients, particularly in those with high titres of the anti-AChR antibody, even though adipose infiltration is marked in these patients.     

A sensitive rosetting assay for detection of acetylcholine receptor antibodies using BC3H-1 cells: positive results in 'antibody-negative' myasthenia gravis

Antibodies to acetylcholine receptor (AChR) were measured in a group of patients with myasthenia gravis (MG), some of whom had previously been classified as 'antibody negative' using the standard anti-AChR radioimmunoassay (RIA). AChR antibodies were measured using the rosetting assay, a new detection method which utilizes protein A-coated red blood cells and live BC3H-1 cells, a murine cell line which expresses muscle nicotinic AChR. The results of the rosetting assay were compared with those obtained in the anti-AChR RIA. 76% of all myasthenic sera tested showed rosetting at titers higher than any of the control sera (from patients with non-myasthenic neurologic disease and normal individuals). Of the myasthenic patients previously classified as 'antibody negative' in the RIA using human AChR, 71% demonstrated positive rosetting. There was no correlation between the anti-AChR antibody titer obtained in the rosetting assay and that obtained in the RIA using either human or denervated rat AChR. The results suggest that the rosetting assay may measure a subpopulation of antibodies that differs from those detected in the RIA.     

Anti-acetylcholine receptor antibody specificities in serum and in thymic cell culture supernatants from myasthenia gravis patients

We investigated the role of the thymus in myasthenia gravis by comparing the antigenic specificities of anti-acetylcholine receptor antibodies (anti-AChR), defined by competition with mouse monoclonal antibodies that bind to five different regions on human muscle AChR, in thymic culture supernatants and in serum pre- and post-thymectomy. Anti-AChR specificities present in the serum were broadly unchanged in 16 non-thymoma and six thymoma patients 7-30 months after thymectomy compared with an initial sample, although total anti-AChR frequently fell. The fine specificities of the anti-AChR synthesized in vitro by cultured lymphocytes from the thymus of ten patients (without thymoma) correlated significantly with that of the anti-AChR in the serum at the same time. We conclude that AChR-specific B cells in the thymus are representative of the total AChR-specific repertoire, and that thymectomy does not selectively deplete particular B cell clones.     

Cross-reactivity of anti-acetylcholine receptor autoantibodies

The heterogeneity of the specificities of anti-acetylcholine receptor (anti-AChR) antibodies of myasthenia gravis (MG) patients has been demonstrated by comparing reactions against a panel of xenogeneic AChR. For each patient there was a more or less unique cross-reactivity profile. Such heterogeneity emphasizes the need to use human AChR for the routine detection of anti-AChR. In vitro cross-reactivity was important in predicting the effect of anti-AChR after passive transfer to rats. Specificity may influence the outcome in human neonates receiving maternal anti-AChR via the placenta. In contrast to the extreme heterogeneity seen in spontaneous MG, the antibodies associated with D-penicillamine–induced MG were more homogeneous.     

T cells in myasthenia gravis specific for embryonic acetylcholine receptor.

In myasthenia gravis (MG) there is an autoimmune response against muscle acetylcholine receptor (AChR). Embryonic and adult muscles express different AChRs; embryonic AChR contains a gamma subunit, instead of the homologous epsilon subunit that contributes to form adult AChR. We report propagation from the blood of MG patients of T helper (TH) cell lines specific for human embryonic AChR, by cycles of stimulation with a pool of synthetic peptides corresponding to the complete sequence of the gamma subunit (gamma pool). The TH lines strongly recognized AChR from embryonic mammalian muscle, and reacted less or not at all with adult muscle AChR. The existence of TH cells specific for embryonic AChR strongly suggests that the primary anti-AChR sensitization in MG occurs in a tissue other than the innervated skeletal muscle. This may be within the thymus, which expresses an AChR similar or identical to embryonic muscle AChR.     

The thymus in myasthenia gravis: Site of “innate autoimmunity”?

Myasthenia gravis (MG) is an autoimmune disorder caused, in most cases, by autoantibodies against components of the neuromuscular junction, frequently the acetylcholine receptor (AChR), and less often the muscle-specific kinase receptor. The thymus plays a major role in the pathogenesis of MG with anti-AChR antibodies: it shows marked pathologic alterations (hyperplastic or tumoral) in most AChR-positive patients and contains the elements required to initiate and sustain an autoimmune reaction (AChR autoantigen, AChR-specific T cells, and autoantibody-secreting plasma cells). In this study we review early and more recent findings implicating the thymus as site of AChR autosensitization in MG and briefly discuss the therapeutic role of thymectomy. We also summarize data showing that the MG thymus is in a state of chronic inflammation, and we review emerging evidence of a viral contribution to the onset and maintenance of the thymic autoimmune response.     

Specific immunoadsorption of the autoantibodies from myasthenic patients using the extracellular domain of the human muscle acetylcholine receptor alpha-subunit. Development of an antigen-specific therapeutic strategy

Antibodies against the acetylcholine receptor (AChR) are the main pathogenic factor in myasthenia gravis (MG). Clinical improvement correlates well with a reduction in levels of circulating anti-AChR antibodies, and plasmapheresis is an efficient short-term MG treatment. The Sepharose-immobilized N-terminal extracellular domain of human muscle AChR alpha-subunit was used to immunoadsorb anti-AChR autoantibodies from 50 MG patients sera. The immunoadsorbents removed 60-94% of the anti-AChR antibodies in 10 sera and a mean of 35% from all samples combined. Immunoadsorption was fast, efficient, and the columns could be used repeatedly without any release or proteolysis of the polypeptide, suggesting the feasibility of antigen-specific MG immunoadsorption therapy.     

Increased circulation of T lymphocytes bearing surface thymosin alpha 1 in patients with myasthenia gravis: effect of thymectomy

We studied the interaction of the thymic hormone thymosin alpha 1 with peripheral blood B and T lymphocytes in patients with myasthenia gravis (MG), using antibodies against thymosin alpha 1 in an immunofluorescence technique. Eleven of 16 patients with symptomatic MG had an increased number of T lymphocytes bearing surface thymosin alpha 1 (T alpha 1); 5 patients with asymptomatic disease had normal levels of T alpha 1. In six young adults with symptomatic MG who subsequently responded to thymectomy, the number of T alpha 1 cells returned to normal 1 month after thymectomy. Because levels of T alpha 1 correlated with symptoms and thymosin alpha 1 specifically recruits helper T cells, our findings suggest that T alpha 1 may play an immunoregulatory role in the pathogenesis of MG. Determination of T alpha 1 levels may prove to be helpful in assessing residual thymic activity after thymectomy.     

Canine and human myasthenia gravis autoantibodies recognize similar regions on the acetylcholine receptor

Serum from 35 cases of naturally occurring acquired canine myasthenia gravis (MG) were assayed for patterns of autoantibody specificities against canine acetylcholine receptor (AChR) using monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and antiserum against defined regions of the AChR as competitive inhibitors of autoantibody binding. In human MG patients and in animals immunized with AChR purified from fish electric organs or mammalian muscle, most of the antibodies are directed against the main immunogenic region (MIR), a conformationally dependent region located on the extracellular surface of the alpha subunit away from the ACh binding site. In our studies using canine MG serum, we found that, as in human MG and in animals immunized with AChR, the antibody response is heterogeneous and predominantly IgG, with a large proportion of the autoantibodies directed against the MIR. The mAbs to the MIR blocked an average of 68% of serum antibody binding. A mAb to the beta subunit and polyclonal antiserum to the gamma subunit blocked an average of 34% and 39% of serum antibody binding, respectively, indicating that these subunits also contain relevant antigenic determinants, a pattern that has also been observed in human MG serum. Anti-alpha bungarotoxin binding site antibodies made up only a small fraction of the autoantibody population in canine MG as in human MG. These and other features described here suggest that canine MG is a useful model of human MG.     

Characterization of ganglionic acetylcholine receptor autoantibodies

In myasthenia gravis (MG), autoantibodies bind to the alpha1 subunit and other subunits of the muscle nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR). Autoimmune autonomic ganglionopathy (AAG) is an antibody-mediated neurological disorder caused by antibodies against neuronal AChRs in autonomic ganglia. Subunits of muscle and neuronal AChR are homologous. We examined the specificity of AChR antibodies in patients with MG and AAG. Ganglionic AChR autoantibodies found in AAG patients are specific for AChRs containing the alpha3 subunit. Muscle and ganglionic AChR antibody specificities are distinct. Antibody crossreactivity between AChRs with different alpha subunits is uncommon but can occur.     

Thymic myoid cells as a myasthenogenic antigen and antigen-presenting cells

We investigated immune property of a myoid cell line, established from Fisher rat thymus. Immunization of syngeneic rats with the myoid cells induced anti-rat acetylcholine receptor (AChR). Implantation of them into the thymus failed to induce typical thymic pathology of human myasthenia gravis (MG) or anti-AChR responses. We also demonstrated that the myoid cells were able to present exogenous antigens to T cells and induce antigen-specific T cell proliferation. These results suggest that myoid cells have the potential antigenicity to induce anti-AChR and the functions of antigen-presenting cells, but their expansion in the thymus may not directly cause MG.     

Thymic abnormalities in patients with myasthenia gravis

Thymic abnormalities were first noticed at autopsies of patients with myasthenia gravis (MG) more than 100 years ago. The thymus is believed to play an important role in the pathogenesis of MG, an autoimmune disease mediated by antibodies against the acetylcholine receptor (AChR) of skeletal muscles. Production of these antibodies in B cells is T cell dependent. T cells potentially specific for AChR are probably generated in the thymus via nontolerogenic thymopoiesis by an aberrant function of thymic epithelial cells. However, generation of these AChR-specific T cells is not the cause of MG, because these cells are also found in healthy individuals. The pathogenetic step in MG involves the activation of these potentially AChR-specific T cells; this activation is the trigger to develop the disease and a therapeutic target. The intra-thymic activation of AChR-specific T cells is probably limited to particular types of MG patients: those with early-onset MG in whom the thymus exhibits lymphofollicular hyperplasia (TLFH) and a few patients in whom MG is associated with a thymoma. The majority of thymomas and atrophic thymuses of patients with late-onset MG, an increasingly common condition, do not exhibit this T cell-activation process. In this paper, we review the available literature on thymic changes (TLFH, thymoma, and atrophic thymus) and the relationship of these changes to the pathogenesis of MG.     

Antigenic difference of acetylcholine receptor between single and multiple form endplates of human extraocular muscle

The acetylcholine receptor (AChR) of human extraocular muscle (EOM) has been studied by the immunological method using anti-AChR antibodies obtained from the sera of patients with myasthenia gravis (MG) of ocular type, whose symptoms have been restricted to EOM. Those antibodies could distinguish the AChR of multiple (en grappe) form endplates from that of single (en plaque) form endplates. This result indicates the antigenic difference of AChR between those two forms of endplates of human EOM.     

The occurrence of anti-titin antibodies and thymomas: a population survey of MG 1970-1999

OBJECTIVE: To estimate the incidence of elevated anti-titin antibodies titers and of thymomas in a population of patients with MG using various statistics and associations. METHODS: Extensive epidemiology, systematic measurement of anti-titin antibodies, and histologic assessment of thymomas according to the new World Health Organization classification. RESULTS: The mean annual incidence rate of MG per million population was 8.3. The analogous mean rate of thymomas was 2.0, out of which MG was encountered in about 20%. A thymoma was coexistent in 7% of the patients with MG. The finding of titin autoantibodies and the coexistence of thymomas were both associated with age at the appearance of MG. In patients with MG with a thymoma, the frequency of seropositivity was 68%, whereas acetylcholine receptor (AChR) autoantibodies were detected in all such sera. Titin autoantibody-positive sera were also anti-AChR antibodies positive. Further, all serum samples negative for anti-AChR antibodies were devoid of anti-titin antibodies. Titin autoantibodies were not detected in nonthymoma early-onset MG. CONCLUSION: Apart from MG with a thymoma, the finding of the titin autoantibodies was observed to be an exclusive feature of late-onset MG, the frequency being 55%. No data were found to suggest that patients with MG were more likely to present with thymic tumors than other patients exhibiting thymic neoplasia. In about 80%, such tumors in MG were composed of cortical cells. The concept of the anti-titin antibodies merely as a paraneoplastic marker in MG was not supported by these data.     

Influence of T cell specificity on the heterogeneity and disease-causing capability of antibody against the acetylcholine receptor

Adoptive secondary anti-acetylcholine receptor (AChR) antibody responses were examined in rats to evaluate the influence of helper T cell specificity on the nature and disease-causing potential of antibody produced. Mixtures of B cells reactive with the intact AChR plus T cells reactive with purified AChR subunits (alpha, beta, gamma, delta) were transferred and antigen-challenged in immunologically naive recipient rats; the serum anti-AChR antibody produced was assessed by radioimmunoassay for differences in titers and by isoelectric focusing for differences in clonal heterogeneity as a function of the subunit specificity of T cells transferred. In addition, rats receiving different sources of AChR or AChR subunit-reactive T cells were examined for AChR-dependent muscle dysfunction. The results indicated a clear reduction in anti-AChR antibody concentrations and clonal heterogeneity in recipient rats receiving T cells of specificities restricted to individual subunits. However, except for a clear relationship between serum anti-AChR antibody concentration and disease induction, no particular AChR subunit-reactive helper T cell specificity appeared to preferentially cause muscle dysfunction. We conclude that if such relationships exists, T cells with specificities more restricted than those described here will have to be used.