平台转换种植体周围应力分布的三维有限元分析

目的:分析平台转换种植体周围的力学分布特点。方法:利用CATIA画图软件,建立种植体支持的上颌第一前磨牙三维模型,分析垂直向和斜向加载条件下平齐对接(PM)和平台转换(PS)种植体周围的应力分布差异;比较不同材料基台平台转换冠修复后种植体周围的应力分布差异。结果:①PS型种植体在垂直加载和斜向加载时种植体周围骨组织内最大von Mises应力值均较PM型小。②不同材料基台种植体周围应力分布云图相似,应力均集中在种植体颈部。结论:①PS种植体周围骨组织最大应力值较PM种植体小,但基台、中央螺丝、种植体的应力增大。②斜向加载较垂直向加载种植体周围应力值大大增加,特别是基台及种植体部位较为明显。③基台材料对种植体周围应力值无明显影响。     

Comparative finite element analysis of mandibular posterior single zirconia and titanium implants: a 3-dimensional finite element analysis

PURPOSEZirconia has exceptional biocompatibility and good mechanical properties in clinical situations. However, finite element analysis (FEA) studies on the biomechanical stability of two-piece zirconia implant systems are limited. Therefore, the aim of this study was to compare the biomechanical properties of the two-piece zirconia and titanium implants using FEA.MATERIALS AND METHODSTwo groups of finite element (FE) models, the zirconia (Zircon) and titanium (Titan) models, were generated for the exam. Oblique (175 N) and vertical (175 N) loads were applied to the FE model generated for FEA simulation, and the stress levels and distributions were investigated.RESULTSIn oblique loading, von Mises stress values were the highest in the abutment of the Zircon model. The von Mises stress values of the Titan model for the abutment screw and implant fixture were slightly higher than those of the Zircon model. Minimum principal stress in the cortical bone was higher in the Titan model than Zircon model under oblique and vertical loading. Under both vertical and oblique loads, stress concentrations in the implant components and bone occurred in the same area. Because the material itself has high stiffness and elastic modulus, the Zircon model exhibited a higher von Mises stress value in the abutments than the Titan model, but at a level lower than the fracture strength of the material.CONCLUSIONOwing to the good esthetics and stress controllability of the Zircon model, it can be considered for clinical use.     

Impact of dental and zygomatic implants on stress distribution in maxillary defects: a 3-dimensional finite element analysis study

The aim of this study was to evaluate the stress distribution in the bone around dental and zygomatic implants for 4 different implant-supported obturator prostheses designs in a unilaterally maxillary defect using a 3-dimensional finite element stress analysis. A 3-dimensional finite element model of the human unilateral maxillary defect was constructed. Four different implant-supported obturator prostheses were modeled; model 1 with 2 zygomatic implants and 1 dental implant, model 2 with 2 zygomatic implants and 2 dental implants, model 3 with 2 zygomatic implants and 3 dental implants, and model 4 with 1 zygomatic implant and 3 dental implants. Bar attachments were used as superstructure. A 150-N vertical load was applied in 3 different ways, and von Mises stresses in the cortical bone around implants were evaluated. When the models (model 1-3) were compared in terms of number of implants, all of the models showed similar highest stress values under the first loading condition, and these values were less than under model 4 conditions. The highest stress values of models 1-4 under the first loading condition were 8.56, 8.59, 8.32, and 11.55 Mpa, respectively. The same trend was also observed under the other loading conditions. It may be concluded that the use of a zygomatic implant on the nondefective side decreased the highest stress values, and increasing the number of dental implants between the most distal and most mesial implants on the nondefective side did not decrease the highest stress values.     

Comparison of implant body designs and threaded designs of dental implants: a 3-dimensional finite element analysis

PURPOSE: Stress analysis was performed for various implant designs using 3-dimensional finite element analysis approaches. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Six implant designs were included: 3 parallel-sided implants (no thread, triangular thread, and squared thread), 2 stepped configurations (non-thread and triangular thread), and a tapered body of implant with squared thread. All threads had spiral characteristics. The mandibular model was constructed from computed tomographic (CT) images of a human mandible, and the material properties were anisotropic (different in different directions). A 100-N oblique force was applied at a 45-degree angle to the long axis of the implants at the buccal cusp as the loading condition. RESULTS: Compared with cylindric implants, threaded implants (either triangular or squared) demonstrated increased peak stress at the crestal bone. The bone stress of stepped implants was decreased in the cortical region but was increased in the trabecular region. However, both threaded and stepped designs showed decreased interfacial stresses of bone near the valleys of the threaded and stepped areas. The tapered design decreased stresses by up to 32% in the cortical region and 17% in the trabecular region. CONCLUSIONS: Although threaded implants could not decrease the peak stress at the crestal bone, both threaded and stepped designs show an ability to dissipate the interfacial stresses of bone. The use of tapered implants could reduce peak stress in both cortical and trabecular bone.     

Biomechanical behavior of mandibular overdenture retained by two standard implants or 2 mini implants: A 3-dimensional finite element analysis

Statement of problemMini implants (<3 mm in diameter) are being used as an alternative to standard implants for implant-retained mandibular overdentures; however, they may exhibit higher stresses at the crestal level.PurposeThe purpose of this finite element analysis study was to evaluate the biomechanical behavior (stress distribution pattern) in the mandibular overdenture, mucosa, bone, and implants when retained with 2 standard implants or 2 mini implants under unilateral or bilateral loading conditions.Material and methodsA patient with edentulous mandible and his denture was scanned with cone beam computed tomography (CBCT), and a 3D mandibular model was created in the Mimics software program by using the CBCT digital imaging and communications in medicine (DICOM) images. The model was transferred to the 3Matics software program to form a 2-mm-thick mucosal layer and to assemble the denture DICOM file. A 12-mm-long standard implant (Ø3.5 mm) and a mini dental implant (Ø2.5 mm) along with the LOCATOR male attachments (height 4 mm) were designed by using the SOLIDWORKS software program. Two standard or 2 mini implants in the canine region were embedded separately in the 3D assembled model. The base of the mandible was fixed, and vertical compressive loads of 100 N were applied unilaterally and bilaterally in the first molar region. The material properties for acrylic resin (denture), titanium (implants), mucosa (tissue), and bone (mandible) were allocated. Maximum von Mises stress and strain values were obtained and analyzed.ResultsMaximum stresses of 9.78 MPa (bilaterally) and 11.98 MPa (unilaterally) were observed in 2 mini implants as compared with 3.12 MPa (bilaterally) and 3.81 MPa (unilaterally) in 2 standard implants. The stress values in the mandible were observed to be almost double the mini implants as compared with the standard implants. The stresses in the denture were in the range of 3.21 MPa and 3.83 MPa and in the mucosa of 0.68 MPa and 0.7 MPa for 2 implants under unilateral and bilateral loading conditions. The strain values shown similar trends with both implant types under bilateral and unilateral loading.ConclusionsTwo mini implants generated an average of 68.15% more stress than standard implants. The 2 standard implant–retained overdenture showed less stress concentration in and around implants than mini implant–retained overdentures.     

Influence of implant design and bone quality on stress/strain distribution in bone around implants: a 3-dimensional finite element analysis

PURPOSE: A 3-dimensional finite element analysis was performed to evaluate the influence of implant type and length, as well as that of bone quality, on the stress/strain in bone and implant. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two types (screw and cylinder) and 4 lengths (9.2, 10.8, 12.4, and 14.0 mm) of titanium implants were buried in 4 types of bone modeled by varying the elastic modulus for cancellous bone. Axial and buccolingual forces were applied to the occlusal node at the center of the abutment. RESULTS: Regardless of load direction, maximum equivalent stress/strain in bone increased with a decrease in cancellous bone density. Under axial load, especially in the low-density bone models, maximum equivalent strain in cancellous bone was lower with the screw-type implant than with the cylinder-type implant. It was also lower with the longer implants than with the shorter implants. Under buccolingual load, equivalent stress/strain was influenced mainly by bone density. DISCUSSION: This study confirms the importance of bone quality and its presurgical diagnosis for implant long-term prognosis. Implant length and type can also influence bone strain, especially in low-density bone. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study suggest that cancellous bone of higher rather than lower density might ensure a better biomechanical environment for implants. Moreover, longer screw-type implants could be a better choice in a jaw with cancellous bone of low density.     

种植体周围骨内应力分布的三维有限元分析

目的针对不同类型的牙槽骨科学地选用种植体,提高种植体临床疗效,延长使用寿命。方法采用三维有限元分析方法,将圆柱状、螺纹状和台阶状种植体分别植入4类骨质结构中,对此12种情况进行应力分析。结果在同种骨质模型中,圆柱状种植体颈部周围骨内的应力集中最小;就同种形态种植体而言,较低的骨质密度不利于种植体的应力分布。结论圆柱状是一种最有利于降低颈部骨质吸收的形态结构。螺纹状种植体周围骨内应力最大值大于圆柱状,而螺纹自身非力学优势极大的拓展了该型种植体的使用范围,但螺纹尖端处的高应力区域和螺纹之间的低应力区域是影响其长期使用效果的潜在不利因素。台阶状种植体相对较适合骨质好的情况,其根部出现局部高应力区域,若应力处于骨生理承受范围之内,将有利于减少根部骨质疏松。     

Effect of alveolar bone support on zygomatic implants: a finite element analysis study

The objective of this study was to investigate the influence of maxillary alveolar bone on the stress distribution of zygomatic implants. A three-dimensional finite element model was created of half of a skull. Two zygomatic implants were modelled, placed in the skull supported by the zygomatic bone and the maxillary alveolar bone and connected by a fixed bridge. This model was duplicated, and the area of the maxillary alveolar bone supporting the implants was removed. Occlusal and lateral forces were applied to both models and the maximum von Mises stresses were recorded. Higher maximum stresses were noted in the model with no alveolar support. Occlusal stresses were higher than lateral stresses in the model with no alveolar support. Low stresses were noted in the zygomatic bone in both models. In conclusion, maxillary alveolar bone support is beneficial in the distribution of forces for zygomatic implants.     

Evaluation of the cylinder implant thread height and width: a 3-dimensional finite element analysis

PURPOSE: To evaluate continuous and simultaneous variations of thread height and width for an experimental screw-type implant. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A finite element model of an implant with a V-shaped thread was created. The range of thread height was set at 0.20 to 0.60 mm, and the range of thread width was set at 0.10 to 0.40 mm. Forces of 100 N and 50 N were applied along the implant axis (AX) and an angle of 45 degrees in a buccolingual direction (45-degree BL), respectively. The maximum von Mises stresses in jawbone were evaluated, and the sensitivity of the stress in jawbone to the variables was also evaluated. RESULTS: Under AX load, the maximum von Mises stresses in cortical and cancellous bones increased by 4.3% and 63.0%, respectively, as thread parameters changed. Under 45-degree BL load, maximum von Mises stresses in cortical and cancellous bones increased by 19.3% and 118.0%, respectively. When thread height was from 0.34 to 0.50 mm and thread width was 0.18 to 0.30 mm, the tangent slope of the maximum von Mises stress response curve ranged from -1 to 1. The variation of the maximum von Mises stresses in jawbone was more sensitive to thread height than to thread width. CONCLUSIONS: Stress in cancellous bone is more likely to be influenced by thread parameters than stress in cortical bone. A 45-degree BL force is more likely to be influenced by thread parameters than an axial force. A thread height of 0.34 to 0.50 mm and a thread width of 0.18 to 0.30 mm is optimal from a biomechanical point of view. In the design of a screw-type implant, thread height is more important than thread width for the reduction of stress within the bone.     

Influence of off-axis loading of an anterior maxillary implant: a 3-dimensional finite element analysis

PURPOSE: To evaluate the influence of the stress/strain distribution in bone around an anterior maxillary implant using 2 types of bone and under 3 different loads. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A premaxillary finite element model featuring an implant and its superstructure was created. Six different testing conditions incorporating 2 types of cancellous bone (high density and low density) under 3 different loading angles (0, 30, and 60 degrees) relative to the long axis of the implant were applied in order to investigate resultant stress/strain distribution. RESULTS: The maximum equivalent stress/strain increased linearly with the increase of loading angle. For each 30-degree increase in loading angle, the maximum equivalent stress in cortical bone increased, on average, 3 to 4 times compared with that of the applied axial load. In addition to loading angle, bone quality also influenced resultant stress distribution. For the low-density bone model, a substantial strain in the cancellous bone was found not only near the implant neck but also at the implant apex. CONCLUSION: To achieve a favorable prognosis under off-axis loading of an anterior maxillary implant, careful case selection for appropriate bone quality and precise occlusal adjustment should be attempted to optimally direct occlusal force toward the long axis of the implant.     

3D finite element analysis to detect stress distribution: spiral family implants

Aim  

Spiral family implants are a root-form fixtures with increasing thickness of tread. This characteristic gives a self-tapping and self-condensing bone properties to implants. To study spiral family implant inserted in different bone quality and connected with abutments of different angulations a Finite Element Analysis (FEA) was performed. Once drawn the systems that were object of the study by CAD (Computer Aided Design), the FEA discretized solids composing the system in many infinitesimal little elementary solids defined finite elements. This lead to a mesh formation where the single finite elements were connected among them by nodes. For the 3 units bone-implant-abutments several thousand of tetrahedral elements having 10 parabolic nodes were employed.     

Splinting effect on posterior implants under various loading modes: a 3D finite element analysis

This three-dimensional finite element study compared stresses, intensities and displacements of three mandibular posterior implants restored with cemented crowns (two molars and a premolar in straight line), splinted versus non-splinted. Hundred newton occlusal loads were vertically or horizontally applied, either on one single crown or on all of them. Maximal stresses and implants displacements were higher under horizontal loading. Splinting major effects appeared under single horizontal load with a decrease in stresses (34-49%) and displacements (16-19%) of the loaded crown. Splinting seems more appropriate for implant-supported restorations submitted to frequent single horizontal or oblique loads than vertical ones.     

Two dental implants designed for immediate loading: a finite element analysis

PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to evaluate by finite element analysis the influence of the design of 3 different dental implants on micromovements, cervical shearing stress intensity, and stress distribution after occlusal loading. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The first investigated implant was a classical cylinder, the second was reinforced by 2 bicortical locking pins, and the third was an expanding dental implant. The parameters analyzed were the implant's geometry, the quality of the cancellous bone, and the orientation of occlusal loading. RESULTS: It was found that initial stability of the locking pin implant was greater than the initial stability of the other investigated implant designs, regardless of the quality of cancellous bone and orientation of occlusal loading; in low-rigidity cancellous bone, under a horizontal load (500 N), decreasing displacement compared to those of the other investigated implants was 16 microm. The apical expansion and locking pin implants exhibited favorable behavior regarding the distribution and intensity of cervical shearing stresses; in low-rigidity cancellous bone, under horizontal load, decreasing cervical stresses compared with those of the cylindric implant were 10 MPa for the apical expansion implant and 150 MPa for the locking pin implant. DISCUSSION: For the cylindric implant, stresses were concentrated in the neck region; for the apical expansion implant, stresses were evenly distributed from the neck to the apex of the implant. For the locking pin implant, stresses around the neck were moderate and appeared concentrated around the pins. CONCLUSIONS: Initial stability of the pin implant was greater than that of the expanding implant, but the expanding implant showed the most favorable stress distribution.     

Biomechanics of the mandible: Part II. Development of a 3-dimensional finite element model to study mandibular functional deformation in subjects treated with dental implants

PURPOSE: The purpose of the study was to develop a finite element model of the human mandible and to compare the functional deformation predicted by the model with that detected clinically. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Three patterns of mandibular deformation (medial convergence, corporal rotation and dorso-ventral shear) were studied clinically in 12 subjects using custom-fabricated displacement transducers mounted on endosseous implants in the premolar region. The mandibular arches of 12 patients with dental implants were modeled using finite element techniques based on computerized tomographic (CT) scan images of the jaw. RESULTS: The finite element model was found to closely replicate the patterns of observed mandibular deformation. Differences between the predicted and measured deformation values were expressed as a percentage of the measured value and ranged between 0.0% and 22.2%. Medial convergence ranged between 14.4 and 58.4 pm. Dorso-ventral shear and corporal rotation ranged between 0.4 and 2.7 degrees. CONCLUSIONS: Using the finite element model described in this study, which represents the living human mandible, and clinical testing, there was close agreement between the predicted and measured deformation values. This study provided a high level of confidence in the finite element model and its ability to provide better insight into understanding the complex phenomena of functional mandibular deformation.     

Micromotion and stress distribution of immediate loaded implants: a finite element analysis

Background: Primary stability and micromotion of the implant fixture is mostly influenced by its macrodesign.
Purpose: To assess and compare the peri-implant stress distribution and micromotion of two types of immediate loading implants, immediate loaded screw (ILS) Nisastan and Xive (DENTSPLY/Friadent, Monnheim, Germany), and to determine the best macrodesign of these two implants by finite element analysis.
Methods: In this experimental study, the accurate pictures of two fixtures (ILS: height = 13, diameter = 4 mm and Xive: height = 13, diameter = 3.8 mm) were taken by a new digital camera (Nikon Coolpix 5700 [Nikon, Japan], resolution = 5.24 megapixel, lens = 8× optical, 4× digital zoom). Following accurate measurements, the three-dimensional finite element computer model was simulated and inserted in simulated mandibular bone (D₂) in SolidWorks 2003 (SolidWork Corp., MA, USA) and Ansys 7.1 (Ansys, Inc., Canonsburg, PA, USA). After loading (500 N, 75° above horizon), the displacement was displayed and von Mises stress was recorded.
Results: It was found that the primary stability of ILS was greater (152 µm) than Xive (284 µm). ILS exhibited more favorable stress distribution. Maximum stress concentration found in periapical bone around Xive (≈30 MPa) was lesser than Nisastan (≈37 MPa).
Conclusions: Macrodesign of ILS leads to better primary stability and stress distribution. Maximum stress around Xive was less.