Respiratory average CT for attenuation correction in myocardial perfusion SPECT/CT

Objective

Cine average CT (CACT) and interpolated average CT (IACT) have been proposed to improve attenuation correction (AC) for PET/CT in oncologic and cardiac studies. This study aims to evaluate their effectiveness on myocardial perfusion SPECT/CT using computer simulation and physical phantom experiments.

Methods

We first simulated normal male with ^99mTc-sestamibi distribution using digital XCAT phantom with respiratory motion amplitudes of 2, 3, and 4 cm. Average activity and attenuation maps represented static SPECT and CACT, while the attenuation maps of end-inspiration and end-expiration represented two helical CTs (HCTs), respectively. Sixty noise-free and noisy projections were simulated over 180° using an analytical parallel-hole projector. We then filled 673 MBq ^99mTc into an anthropomorphic torso phantom with normal heart or heart with a defect which placed on a programmable respiratory platform to model various respiratory amplitudes. Sixty projections were acquired over 180° using a clinical SPECT/CT scanner. The CACT, standard HCT, and 2 HCTs at extreme phases were acquired. Interpolated CT phases were generated between them using affine plus b-spline registration, and IACT was obtained by averaging the interpolated phases and the 2 original extreme phases for both simulation and phantom experiments. Projections were reconstructed with AC using CACT, IACT, and HCTs, respectively. Polar and 17-segment plots were analyzed by relative difference (RD) of the uptake. Two regions-of-interest (ROI) were drawn on the defect and background area to obtain the intensity ratio (IR).

Results

No substantial difference was observed on the polar plots generated from different AC methods, while the quantitative RD measurements showed that SPECT_CACT were most similar to the original phantom, followed by SPECT_IACT, with RD_max <8 and <10% in the simulation study. The RD of SPECT_HCTs deviated from the original phantom and SPECT_CACT in various segments, with RD_max of 19.76 and 16.68% in the simulation and phantom experiment, respectively. The IR of SPECT_HCTs fluctuated more from the truth for higher motion amplitude.

Conclusions

Both CACT-AC and IACT-AC reduced respiratory artifacts and improved quantitation in myocardial perfusion SPECT as compared to HCT-AC. The use of IACT further reduced the radiation dose.

     

Coronary calcium score scans for attenuation correction of quantitative PET/CT 13N-ammonia myocardial perfusion imaging

Purpose  

The aim of this study was to evaluate whether ECG-triggered coronary calcium scoring (CCS) scans can be used for attenuation correction (AC) to quantify myocardial blood flow (MBF) and coronary flow reserve (CFR) assessed by PET/CT with ¹³N-ammonia.     

Cine CT for attenuation correction in cardiac PET/CT.

In dual-modality PET/CT systems, the CT scan provides the attenuation map for PET attenuation correction. The current clinical practice of obtaining a single helical CT scan provides only a snapshot of the respiratory cycle, whereas PET occurs over multiple respiratory cycles. Misalignment of the attenuation map and emission image because of respiratory motion causes errors in the attenuation correction factors and artifacts in the attenuation-corrected PET image. To rectify this problem, we evaluated the use of cine CT, which acquires multiple low-dose CT images during a respiratory cycle. We evaluated the average and the intensity-maximum image of cine CT for cardiac PET attenuation correction. METHODS: Cine CT data and cardiac PET data were acquired from a cardiac phantom and from multiple patient studies. The conventional helical CT, cine CT, and PET data of an axially translating phantom were evaluated with and without respiratory motion. For the patient studies, we acquired 2 cine CT studies for each PET acquisition in a rest-stress (13)N-ammonia protocol. Three readers visually evaluated the alignment of 74 attenuation image sets versus the corresponding emission image and determined whether the alignment provided acceptable or unacceptable attenuation-corrected PET images. RESULTS: In the phantom study, the attenuation correction from helical CT caused a major artifactual defect in the lateral wall on the PET image. The attenuation correction from the average and from the intensity-maximum cine CT images reduced the defect by 20% and 60%, respectively. In the patient studies, 77% of the cases using the average of the cine CT images had acceptable alignment and 88% of the cases using the intensity maximum of the cine CT images had acceptable alignment. CONCLUSION: Cine CT offers an alternative to helical CT for compensating for respiratory motion in the attenuation correction of cardiac PET studies. Phantom studies suggest that the average and the intensity maximum of the cine CT images can reduce potential respiration-induced misalignment errors in attenuation correction. Patient studies reveal that cine CT provides acceptable alignment in most cases and suggest that the intensity-maximum cine image offers a more robust alternative to the average cine image.     

Clinical myocardial perfusion PET/CT.

The field of nuclear cardiology is witnessing growing interest in the use of cardiac PET for the evaluation of patients with coronary artery disease (CAD). The available evidence suggests that myocardial perfusion PET provides an accurate means for diagnosing obstructive CAD, which appears superior to SPECT especially in the obese and in those undergoing pharmacologic stress. The ability to record changes in left ventricular function from rest to peak stress and to quantify myocardial perfusion (in mL/min/g of tissue) provides an added advantage over SPECT for evaluating multivessel CAD. There is growing and consistent evidence that gated myocardial perfusion PET also provides clinically useful risk stratification. Although the introduction of hybrid PET/CT technology offers the exciting possibility of assessing the extent of anatomic CAD (CT coronary angiography) and its functional consequences (ischemic burden) in the same setting, there are technical challenges in the implementation of CT-based transmission imaging for attenuation correction. Nonetheless, this integrated platform for assessing anatomy and biology offers a great potential for translating advances in molecularly targeted imaging into humans.     

Respiration-averaged CT for attenuation correction in canine cardiac PET/CT.

Heart disease is a leading cause of death in North America. With the increased availability of PET/CT scanners, CT is now commonly used as a transmission source for attenuation correction. Because of the differences in scan duration between PET and CT, respiration-induced motion can create inconsistencies between the PET and CT data and lead to incorrect attenuation correction and, thus, artifacts in the final reconstructed PET images. This study compared respiration-averaged CT and 4-dimensional (4D) CT for attenuation correction of cardiac PET in an in vivo canine model as a means of removing these inconsistencies. METHODS: Five dogs underwent respiration-gated cardiac (18)F-FDG PET and 4D CT. The PET data were reconstructed with 3 methods of attenuation correction that differed only in the CT data used: The first method was single-phase CT at either end-expiration, end-inspiration, or the middle of a breathing cycle; the second was respiration-averaged CT, which is CT temporally averaged over the entire respiratory cycle; and the third was phase-matched CT, in which each PET phase is corrected with the matched phase from 4D CT. After reconstruction, the gated PET images were summed to produce an ungated image. Polar plots of the PET heart images were generated, and percentage differences were calculated with respect to the phase-matched correction for each dog. The difference maps were then averaged over the 5 dogs. RESULTS: For single-phase CT correction at end-expiration, end-inspiration, and mid cycle, the maximum percentage differences were 11% +/- 4%, 7% +/- 3%, and 5% +/- 2%, respectively. Conversely, the maximum difference for attenuation correction with respiration-averaged CT data was only 1.6% +/- 0.7%. CONCLUSION: Respiration-averaged CT correction produced a maximum percentage difference 7 times smaller than that obtained with end-expiration single-phase correction. This finding indicates that using respiration-averaged CT may accurately correct for attenuation on respiration-ungated cardiac PET.     

Impact of metallic dental implants on CT-based attenuation correction in a combined PET/CT scanner

Our objective was to study the effect of metal-induced artifacts on the accuracy of the CT-based anatomic map as a prerequisite for attenuation correction of the positron emission tomography (PET) emission data. Twenty-seven oncology patients with dental metalwork were enrolled in the present study. Data acquisition was performed on a PET/CT in-line system (Discovery LS, GE Medical Systems, Milwaukee, Wis.). Attenuation correction of emission data was done twice, using an 80-mA CT scan (PET_CT80) and a ⁶⁸Ge transmission scan (PET_68Ge). Average count in kBq/cc was measured in regions with and without artifacts and compared for PET_CT80 and PET_68Ge. Data analysis of region of interests (ROIs) revealed that the ratio (ROIs PET_CT80/ROIs PET_68Ge) and the difference (ROIs PET_CT80 minus ROIs PET_68Ge) had a higher mean of values in regions with artifacts than in regions without artifacts (1.2±0.17 vs 1.06±0.06 and 0.68±0.67 vs 0.15±0.17 kBq/cc, respectively). For most of the studied artifactual ROIs, the PET_CT80 values were higher than those of the PET_68Ge. Attenuation correction of PET emission data using an artifactual CT map yields false values in regions nearby artifacts caused by dental metalwork. This may falsely estimate PET quantitative studies and may disturb the visual interpretation of PET scan. Electronic Publication     

CT衰减校正对IQ-SPECT/CT和LEHR-SPECT/CT心肌灌注显像的影响

目的 探讨CT衰减校正（CTAC）对智能（IQ）-SPECT/CT和低能高分辨率（LEHR）-SPECT/CT心肌血流灌注显像（MPI）图像的影响。 方法 收集2018年5月至10月在山西医科大学第一医院行静息心肌灌注显像（MPI）的31例确诊或者可疑的冠心病患者,其中男性21例、女性10例,年龄（49.4±12.01）岁。所有患者同日分别行IQ-SPECT/CT+CTAC及LEHR-SPECT/CT+CTAC。视觉分析IQ-SPECT/CT CTAC前后图像及手动配位后图像、LEHR-SPECT/CT CTAC前后断层图像;同时比较左心室各个室壁（心尖、前壁、侧壁、间壁、下壁）IQ-SPECT/CT和LEHR-SPECT/CT CTAC前后与重新配位后的放射性摄取值（%）。两组间比较采用配对t检验,率的比较采用卡方检验,一致性分析采用Kappa检验。 结果 ①视觉分析:IQ-SPECT/CT与LEHR-SPECT/CT CTAC前图像比较,具有很高的一致性（Kappa值=0.795,P<0.001）。IQ-SPECT/CT CTAC后心肌节段出现放射性分布明显稀疏的比例为77%（24/31）,远高于LEHR- SPECT/CT CTAC后的23%（7/31）,差异有统计学意义（χ2=16.52,P<0.001）。将MPI与CT图像手动重新配位后,IQ-SPECT/CT左心室心尖的放射性分布为16%（5/31）,与LEHR-SPECT/CT的23%（7/31）相比,差异无统计学意义（χ2=0.103,P=0.748）。②放射性摄取值（%）:IQ-SPECT/CT CTAC前后比较,左心室心尖[（65.71±25.69）%对（58.68±20.39）%]、前壁[（204.23±43.24）%对（184.66±41.22）%]及间壁[（316.19±47.43）%对（270.03±65.33）% ] 的放射性摄取值明显降低,且差异均有统计学意义（t=4.014、4.232、5.473,均P<0.05）;LEHR-SPECT/CT CTAC前后比较,左心室前壁[（204.68±41.14）%对[（211.81±35.04）%]、间壁[（319.13±44.90）%对（350.87±44.24）%]及下壁[（185.48±31.06）%对（228.67±29.45）% ]的放射性摄取值显著增高,且差异均有统计学意义（t=?2.471,P =0.019;t=?5.968,P<0.001;t=?11.311,P<0.001）。IQ-SPECT/CT CTAC配位后与IQ-SPECT/CT CTAC前比较,左心室前壁[（212.06±33.59）%对（204.23±43.24）%]、侧壁[（372.84±39.37）%对（355.81±46.79）%]、下壁[（219.13±25.10）%对（191.58±33.06）%]和间壁[（335.00±36.84）%对（316.19±47.43）%]的放射性摄取值均明显增高,且差异均有统计学意义（t=?2.497,P=0.018;t=?2.672,P=0.012;t=?7.632,P<0.001;t=?3.557,P<0.001） 。 结论 LEHR-SPECT/CT CTAC后左心室间壁及下壁的放射性分布得到补偿;而IQ-SPECT/CT CTAC后左心室心尖、前壁及间壁的放射性分布却更加稀疏。在IQ-SPECT/CT采集模式下,CTAC后容易出现矫枉过正,重新手动配位后这种情况将得到明显改善。     

Automatic alignment of myocardial perfusion PET and 64-slice coronary CT angiography on hybrid PET/CT

Background

Hybrid PET/CT allows for acquisition of cardiac PET and coronary CT angiography (CCTA) in one session. However, PET and CCTA are acquired with differing breathing protocols and require software registration. We aimed to validate automatic correction for breathing misalignment between PET and CCTA acquired on hybrid scanner.

Methods

Single-session hybrid PET/CT studies of rest/stress ¹³N-ammonia PET and CCTA in 32 consecutive patients were considered. Automated registration of PET left ventricular (LV) surfaces with CCTA volumes was evaluated by comparing with expert manual alignment by two observers.

Results

The average initial misalignments between the position of LV on PET and CCTA were 27.2?±?11.8, 13.3?±?11.5, and 14.3?±?9.1?mm in x, y, and z axes on rest, and 26.3?±?10.2, 11.1?±?9.5, and 11.7?±?7.1?mm in x, y, and z axes on stress, respectively. The automated PET-CCTA co-registration had 95% agreement as judged visually. Compared with expert manual alignment, the translation errors of the algorithm were 5.3?±?2.8?mm (rest) and 6.0?±?3.5?mm (stress). 3D visualization of combined coronary vessel anatomy and hypoperfusion from PET could be made without further manual adjustments.

Conclusion

Software co-registration of CCTA and PET myocardial perfusion imaging on hybrid PET/CT scanners is necessary, but can be performed automatically, facilitating integrated 3D display on PET/CT.     

Emission-based attenuation correction of myocardial perfusion studies

Background  Nonuniform attenuation in the thorax can generate artifacts in single-photon emission computed tomographic myocardial perfusion studies that mimic coronary artery disease. In this article we present both phantom and simulation data, as well as clinical data, in support of an emission-based method that provides reliable correction for attenuation effects without the need for a transmission measurement. Methods and Results  The attenuation map is derived from the measured distribution of ^99mTc-labeled macroaggregated albumin in the lungs and a radioactive binder wrapped about the thorax. This information is acquired as part of a dual-isotope acquisition during the rest ²⁰¹TI study. Segmentation is used to define the interiors of lung and body compartments, which are assigned a single attenuation coefficient for each of the two tissue types. The appropriateness of this approach was investigated by examining the measured attenuation coefficients in a group of 80 individuals (40 male, 40 female) from positron emission tomographic transmission studies. The correction technique was evaluated with computer simulations, a physical phantom, and clinical data acquired from 20 patients. Analysis of the positron emission tomographic data found a small SD in the mean attenuation coefficients for the body (<5%) and lungs (<15%). The application of emission-based attenuation-correction technique produced a substantial reduction in the magnitude of the attenuation artifact in images obtained from both the phantom and the simulation studies. The emission-based attenuation-correction technique was easily applied to myocardial perfusion studies, where it had a significant effect, resulting in changes in interpretation for nine of 20 patients. Conclusions  The results of this study provide strong support for the concept that an attenuation map can be generated with fixed attenuation values in place of those that are directly measured. Thus the emission-based attenuation-correction technique can be considered an inexpensive alternative to transmission-based correction methods. Because the emission-based correction technique does not require any additional hardware, it has the major advantage of being applicable to all single-photon emission computed tomographic systems.     

A technique for using CT images in attenuation correction and quantification in SPECT

A technique is described for using computed tomography (CT) images for attenuation correction and quantification in SPECT. The CT images are aligned with the corresponding SPECT slices and the Hounsfield units are converted to linear attenuation coefficient values for the SPECT radionuclide. The attenuation coefficient map thus produced is used to provide the attenuation correction required in the SPECT reconstruction. The technique has been evaluated in both a non-anatomical and an anatomical phantom giving a mean accuracy in quantifying activity of various features in the phantoms of 2.6% (range 0.3%-4.0%). The value of performing scatter correction prior to attenuation correction in obtaining accurate quantification is demonstrated. The practicalities of applying the technique in patient studies are discussed.     

Value of attenuation correction in stress-only myocardial perfusion imaging using CZT-SPECT

Background

Attenuation correction (AC) improves the diagnostic outcome of stress-only myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI) using conventional SPECT. Our aim was to determine the value of AC using a cadmium zinc telluride-based (CZT)-SPECT camera.

Methods and results

We retrospectively included 107 consecutive patients who underwent stress-optional rest MPI CZT-SPECT/CT. Next, we created three types of images for each patient; (1) only displaying reconstructed data without the CT-based AC (NC), (2) only displaying AC, and (3) with both NC and AC (NC + AC). Next, two experienced physicians visually interpreted these 321 randomized images as normal, equivocal, or abnormal. Image outcome was compared with all hard events over a mean follow-up time of 47.7 ± 9.8 months. The percentage of images interpreted as normal increased from 45% using the NC images to 72% using AC and to 67% using NC + AC images (P < .001). Hard event hazard ratios for images interpreted as normal were not different between using NC and AC (1.01, P = .99), or NC and NC + AC images (0.97, P = .97).

Conclusions

AC lowers the need for additional rest imaging in stress-first MPI using CZT-SPECT, while long-term patient outcome remained identical. Use of AC reduces the need for additional rest imaging, decreasing the mean effective dose by up to 1.2 mSv.

     

Evaluation of attenuation correction in cardiac PET using PET/MR

Background

Simultaneous acquisition Positron emission tomography/magnetic resonance (PET/MR) is a new technology that has potential as a tool both in research and clinical diagnosis. However, cardiac PET acquisition has not yet been validated using MR imaging for attenuation correction (AC). The goal of this study is to evaluate the feasibility of PET imaging using a standard 2-point Dixon volume interpolated breathhold examination (VIBE) MR sequence for AC.

Methods and Results

Evaluation was performed in both phantom and patient data. A chest phantom containing heart, lungs, and a lesion insert was scanned by both PET/MR and PET/CT. In addition, 30 patients underwent whole-body ¹⁸F-fluorodeoxyglucose PET/CT followed by simultaneous cardiac PET/MR. Phantom study showed 3% reduction of activity values in the myocardium due to the non-inclusion of the phased array coil in the AC. In patient scans, average standardized uptake values (SUVs) obtained by PET/CT and PET/MR showed no significant difference (n = 30, 4.6 ± 3.5 vs 4.7 ± 2.8, P = 0.47). There was excellent per patient correlation between the values acquired by PET/CT and PET/MR (R ² = 0.97).

Conclusions

Myocardial SUVs PET imaging using MR for AC shows excellent correlation with myocardial SUVs obtained by standard PET/CT imaging. The 2-point Dixon VIBE MR technique can be used for AC in simultaneous PET/MR data acquisition.

     

Impact of improved attenuation correction featuring a bone atlas and truncation correction on PET quantification in whole-body PET/MR

Purpose

Recent studies have shown an excellent correlation between PET/MR and PET/CT hybrid imaging in detecting lesions. However, a systematic underestimation of PET quantification in PET/MR has been observed. This is attributable to two methodological challenges of MR-based attenuation correction (AC): (1) lack of bone information, and (2) truncation of the MR-based AC maps (μmaps) along the patient arms. The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of improved AC featuring a bone atlas and truncation correction on PET quantification in whole-body PET/MR.

Methods

The MR-based Dixon method provides four-compartment μmaps (background air, lungs, fat, soft tissue) which served as a reference for PET/MR AC in this study. A model-based bone atlas provided bone tissue as a fifth compartment, while the HUGE method provided truncation correction. The study population comprised 51 patients with oncological diseases, all of whom underwent a whole-body PET/MR examination. Each whole-body PET dataset was reconstructed four times using standard four-compartment μmaps, five-compartment μmaps, four-compartment μmaps + HUGE, and five-compartment μmaps + HUGE. The SUV_max for each lesion was measured to assess the impact of each μmap on PET quantification.

Results

All four μmaps in each patient provided robust results for reconstruction of the AC PET data. Overall, SUV_max was quantified in 99 tumours and lesions. Compared to the reference four-compartment μmap, the mean SUV_max of all 99 lesions increased by 1.4 ± 2.5% when bone was added, by 2.1 ± 3.5% when HUGE was added, and by 4.4 ± 5.7% when bone + HUGE was added. Larger quantification bias of up to 35% was found for single lesions when bone and truncation correction were added to the μmaps, depending on their individual location in the body.

Conclusion

The novel AC method, featuring a bone model and truncation correction, improved PET quantification in whole-body PET/MR imaging. Short reconstruction times, straightforward reconstruction workflow, and robust AC quality justify further routine clinical application of this method.

     

Impact of CT attenuation correction by SPECT/CT in brain perfusion images

Purpose  

The aim of this study was to elucidate the regional differences between brain perfusion single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) images reconstructed with a uniform attenuation correction using Chang’s method (AC-Chang) and a non-uniform attenuation correction with CT using SPECT/CT (AC-CT).     

Comparison of attenuation, dual-energy-window, and model-based scatter correction of low-count SPECT to 82Rb PET/CT quantified myocardial perfusion scores

Background

New reconstruction algorithms allow reduction in acquisition times or the amount of injected radioactivity. We examined the impact of different corrections on low-count clinical SPECT myocardial perfusion images (MPI) and compared to ⁸²Rb PET/CT. We compared no corrections (NC) to attenuation correction (AC) with and without scatter correction by either a dual-energy-window (AC-DEW) or model-based (AC-ESSE) approach. All reconstructions included resolution recovery.

Methods

56 Patients were imaged using a standard rest/stress Tc-99m-tetrofosmin MPI SPECT/CT protocol with an additional half-time acquisition. A ⁸²Rb-rest/stress PET/CT MPI was acquired within 4 weeks. Reconstruction methods were compared using summed rest/stress/difference scores from an objective algorithm (SRS/SSS/SDS).

Results

The SRS and SSS for NC were significantly (P < .01) higher than for AC, but well correlated (r ≥ 0.87). The correlation in SRS/SSS among AC, AC-DEW, and AC-ESSE was excellent (r ≥ 0.98). AC-ESSE and AC-DEW had higher SRS (P ≤ .05) than AC, but the SDS values were not significantly different. Concordance with PET normal/abnormal classification was 76% for NC and ≥85% for the AC methods.

Conclusion

AC significantly improves the accuracy of low-count myocardial perfusion SPECT half-time imaging for the detection of disease compared to NC. Compared to PET, there was no significant difference among AC, AC-DEW, and AC-ESSE.