A randomized cross-over study of auto-continuous positive airway pressure versus fixed-continuous positive airway pressure in patients with obstructive sleep apnoea

Background and objectives:   To compare the efficacy of auto-CPAP (AutoSet Spirit, ResMed) versus fixed-CPAP (S6 Elite, ResMed) in improving daytime sleepiness, health status, objective compliance and the ultimate treatment preference in patients with severe OSA.
Methods:   The study recruited 43 subjects aged 18–65 years with newly diagnosed severe OSA (AHI >30/h). Patients were initially treated with either auto-CPAP or fixed-CPAP for 2 months and then crossed over after a washout period of 1 week for another 2 months.
Results:   The study was completed by 41 patients. Results are presented as mean (SE). Use of auto-CPAP in the first and the second month was significantly higher than that of fixed-CPAP [129.7 (9.9) and 130.5 (10.7) h vs 115.2 (9.5) and 113.2 (9.4) h, P  = 0.04 and 0.01], whereas mean hourly use per night was 4.3 and 4.4 h versus 3.8 and 3.7 h, respectively. The Epworth sleepiness scores improved after 1 month in both treatments (13.4 to 8.5 and 8.2, P  < 0.01 for both). The Sleep apnoea quality of life index improved in the first month in both compared with baseline [4.6 (0.2) to 5.0 (0.2) for auto-CPAP and 4.9 (0.2) for fixed-CPAP, P  = 0.01 and 0.04, respectively], with no difference between the two treatments. Nine and 30 patients preferred auto-CPAP and fixed-CPAP, respectively, at the end of the trial, whereas 14 and 25 patients would have chosen the same treatments if cost had not been a consideration.
Conclusions:   Auto-CPAP and fixed-CPAP were equally effective in improving symptoms and health status in patients with severe OSA. Usage was higher with auto-CPAP, but more patients ultimately chose fixed-CPAP.     

AutoCPAP治疗阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停低通气综合征40例疗效观察

目的探讨自动调节持续气道正压通气呼吸机(Auto-CPAP)治疗不同程度阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停低通气综合征(OS-AHS)患者的短期临床疗效。方法给予经多导睡眠图(PSG)确诊的不同程度OSAHS患者使用Auto-CPAP治疗(2d),观察治疗前后患者呼吸暂停/低通气指数(AHI)、最低血氧饱和度(LSaO2)和血氧饱和度<90%的累积时间(<90%SaO2时间)的变化。结果应用Auto-CPAP呼吸机治疗OSAHS患者,治疗后AHI由(49.03±21.82)次/h降为(7.49±5.34)次/h、LSaO2由(71.78±11.41)%升至(90.43±3.49)%和<90%SaO2时间由(73.16±84.80)min减至(0.82±3.17)min,与治疗前比较差异有统计学意义。结论应用Auto-CPAP治疗可以使不同程度OSAHS患者的呼吸事件和夜间低氧血症在短期内明显改善。     

Efficacy of expiratory positive airway pressure nasal device

Sleep and Breathing -     

Unsupervised self-testing of airway obstruction by forced oscillation at the patient's home.

As active patient cooperation is not required, the forced oscillation technique (FOT) could be suitable for measuring airway obstruction in routine home applications. Nevertheless, FOT has never been used at the patient's home to date. The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility of FOT and the reproducibility of measured respiratory resistance (Rrs) in routine patient self-testing at home. Altogether, nine asthmatic patients self-measured their Rrs with a portable FOT device and spirometry for 10-14 days, in the morning and evening, and before and after bronchodilator inhalation. During each measurement session, the patients carried out four consecutive FOT measurements. Grubbs' discordancy test for detecting outliers was used to evaluate intermeasure reliability. Only 4.9% of Rrs data reported by patients were rejected as artefacts. The coefficient of variation of Rrs was 7.9 +/- 6.3% (mean +/- SD). When compared with spirometry, the per cent change in Rrs for detecting a positive bronchodilator response showed an 83% sensitivity and 72% specificity. Unsupervised self-measurement of respiratory resistance at the patient's home provided results similar to those obtained by a technician in a lung function lab. Forced oscillation technique could be a useful tool for the routine follow-up of asthmatic patients at home.     

Sensitivity of a simplified forced oscillation technique for detection of upper airway obstruction

The sensitivity of a simplified variant of forced oscillation technique (FOT) was studied for assessment of dynamic upper airway obstruction during nasal continuous positive airway pressure (nCPAP) therapy for obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA). The airway impedance P[FOT] was measured by FOT and the oesophageal pressure (P(oes)) was recorded during stable stage II sleep in 11 patients with OSA. The CPAP level was initially set high enough to completely abolish upper airway obstruction. To induce gradually increasing upper airway re-obstruction, the CPAP pressure was then lowered stepwise. Thirty six such manoeuvres were analysed, blind, to define the first inspiration at which upper airway re-obstruction was detectable by analysis of P[FOT](t(FOT)) and by P(oes)(t(oes)), respectively. On seven occasions t(FOT) and t(oes) occurred together, in the remaining 29 cases t(FOT) preceded t(oes) with a mean latency of 6.0+/-7.7 (0-32) breath cycles. In no case did t(oes) preceed t(FOT). FOT is a highly sensitive tool for the assessment of incipient upper airway obstruction during nCPAP therapy.     

Assessment of bronchial reactivity by forced oscillation admittance avoids the upper airway artefact.

The forced oscillation technique (FOT) allows easy assessment of bronchial reactivity. The use of a standard FOT generator (SG) results in changes in respiratory system resistance (delta Rrs,SG) which are affected by an artefact caused by the extrathoracic upper airway (EUA). The aim was to improve the FOT assessment of bronchial reactivity with the SG by computing the change in FOT admittance (delta Ars,SG), which is theoretically unaffected by this artefact. Delta Rrs,SG and delta Ars,SG after bronchial challenge in 17 children were compared with the values measured with a head generator (HG) FOT setup (delta Rrs,HG and delta Ars,HG, respectively), which were taken as a reference, since HG provides data virtually freed from the EUA artefact. At 10 Hz, the SG significantly underestimated the resistance change: delta Rrs,SG=1.77+/-0.62 versus delta Rrs,HG=6.09+/-1.23 hPa x L(-1) x s. Delta Rrs,SG and delta Rrs,HG did not show a significant correlation. By contrast, the amplitude of the change in admittance measured by SG was close to the one obtained with the reference HG: /delta Ars,SG/=29.5+/-4.6 versus /delta Ars,HG/=32.7+/-3.9 mL x hPa(-1) x s(-1). /Delta Ars,SG/ and /delta Ars,HG/ showed a significant correlation (r=0.65, p>0.01). Similar results were found up to 20 Hz. The extrathoracic upper airway artefact was minimized when computing the change in admittance with the standard generator. This forced oscillation technique index may improve the sensitivity in assessing bronchial reactivity with the standard generator setup, which is the most common and easiest to use method for routine lung function testing.     

Constant vs auto-continuous positive airway pressure in patients with sleep apnea hypopnea syndrome and a high variability in pressure requirement

STUDY OBJECTIVES: Auto-continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) has been reported to have no more efficacy than constant CPAP in unselected patients with sleep apnea hypopnea syndrome (SAHS). The aim of this study was to evaluate patients judged to be good candidates for auto-CPAP because of a high within-night variability in pressure requirement. DESIGN: Single-blind, randomized, cross-over study (2 x 8 weeks) to compare auto-CPAP with constant CPAP. PATIENTS: Outpatients with moderate-to-severe SAHS attending the chest clinic. INTERVENTIONS: Patients were equipped at home in the auto-CPAP mode (model GK418A; Malinckrodt; Nancy, France), using a 4- to 14-cm H(2)O pressure range. Those individuals having a high within-night variability in pressure requirement, assessed at the end of a 14-day run-in period, were included in the cross-over study. Auto-CPAP was compared with constant CPAP (according to a titration night in the sleep laboratory) in terms of compliance, efficacy on apneas (assessed from the pressure monitor), and sleepiness (assessed on the Epworth sleepiness scale). MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS: Of 90 consecutive patients with SAHS, 27 patients were selected for a within-night variability in pressure requirement exceeding a given threshold. After completion of the cross-over, 24 patients were evaluable. The median percentage of nights the machine was used was 95.5% (range, 45 to 100%) on constant CPAP, and 96.5% (range, 40 to 100%) on auto-CPAP; the median apnea index recorded by the device was 0.40/h (range, 0 to 2.40/h) on constant CPAP, and 0.45/h (range, 0 to 5.80/h) on auto-CPAP (differences not significant). The mean Epworth sleepiness score was significantly (p < 0.01) lower on auto-CPAP (5.1; SD, 2.8) than on constant CPAP (6.1; SD, 2.8). CONCLUSIONS: In patients selected for a high within-night variability in pressure requirement, auto-CPAP administered via a GK418A device was equivalent to constant CPAP based on a titration night in the sleep laboratory. Subjective ratings for sleepiness were slightly lower on auto-CPAP.     

Evaluation of airway responsiveness using colored three-dimensional analyses of a new forced oscillation technique in controlled asthmatic and nonasthmatic children

BackgroundBronchodilator response (BDR) is routinely used in asthma management. A new forced oscillation technique (FOT) is able to quickly measure respiratory system resistance (Rrs) and reactance (Xrs) at each tidal breath phase. The present study evaluated bronchial changes by using the new FOT.MethodsRespiratory resistance and reactance were measured using FOT in 132 children (age, 10.86±4.78 years; M:F=88:44), including asthmatic (n=98) and nonasthmatic children (n=34), pre- and post-bronchodilator inhalation in an asymptomatic state. Whole-breath or within-breath changes in Rrs and Xrs were measured and compared pre- and post-bronchodilator inhalation and between each group. All patients performed spirometry and forced expiratory nitric oxide pre- and post-bronchodilator inhalation.ResultsSpirometric parameters showed significant positive changes at V₅₀ and V₂₅ in both groups; however, these changes were not significantly different between the groups. eNO was significantly higher in the asthmatic group than in the nonasthmatic group; however, there was no significant change pre- and post-inhalation in either group. Rrs in the asthma group was significantly higher in the expiratory phase than in the inspiratory phase. Rrs and Xrs before and after bronchodilator inhalation were significantly different in the asthma group alone, except for the expiratory–inspiratory phase of each of these parameters. Changes in Rrs and Xrs at 5 Hz (R5 and X5) in a whole-breath and the inspiratory phase were significantly different between the groups.ConclusionsChanges in X5 and R5 reflect bronchial reversibility. The new FOT is useful for asthmatic children.     

A portable forced oscillation device for respiratory home monitoring.

The increase in the prevalence of chronic respiratory diseases has resulted in a rise in health services provided at home. The forced oscillation technique (FOT) proves to be a useful tool when it is desired to assess lung function noninvasively, and particularly for patients in whom spirometry cannot be applied. As no portable FOT device is currently available, the aim of this study was to design and test a portable FOT system for ambulatory and home care applications. The system devised is based on a microprocessor, which allows online computation of respiratory resistance (Rrs) and reactance (Xrs) and reliability indices. The portable device was compared with a conventional FOT system by using signals from 14 patients with chronic respiratory disease. This device has the same computation capabilities and flexibility as conventional FOT systems and meets the requirements for home application. Rrs (14.2 +/- 6.0 cmH2O x s x L(-1), mean +/- SD) and Xrs (-5.3 +/- 2.7 cmH2O x s x L(-1)) measured at 5 Hz by the portable system virtually coincided with those computed with the reference conventional FOT system: mean differences +/-SD were 0.074 +/- 0.025 and 0.005 +/- 0.009 cmH2O x s x L(-1), respectively. This portable forced oscillation technique device could be a useful tool for monitoring respiratory mechanics in ambulatory and home care applications.     

Expiratory flow limitation detected by forced oscillation and negative expiratory pressure.

The within-breath change in reactance (Delta(rs)) measured by forced oscillation technique (FOT) at 5 Hz reliably detects expiratory flow limitation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). The present study compared this approach to the standard negative expiratory pressure (NEP) method. In total, 21 COPD patients were studied by applying both techniques to the same breath and in 15 patients the measurements were repeated after bronchodilator. For each patient and condition five NEP tests were performed and independently scored by three operators unaware of the FOT results. In 180 tests, FOT classified 53.3% as flow limited. On average, the operators scored 27.6% of tests flow limited and 47.6% non-flow limited, but could not score 24.8%. The methods disagreed in 7.9% of cases; in 78% of these the NEP scores differed between operators. Bronchodilation reduced NEP and DeltaX(rs) scores, with only the latter achieving significance. Averaging the operators' NEP scores, a threshold between 24.6-30.8% of tidal volume being flow limited by NEP produced 94% agreement between methods. In conclusion, when negative expiratory pressure and forced oscillation technique were both available they showed good agreement. As forced oscillation technique is automatic and can measure multiple breaths over long periods, it is suitable for monitoring expiratory flow limitation continuously and identifying patients' breathing close to the onset of expiratory flow limitation, where intermittent sampling may be unrepresentative.     

Usefulness of the forced oscillation technique in assessing the therapeutic result of tracheobronchial central airway obstruction

Background

Pulmonary function tests (PFTs) comprise the traditional method for detecting central airway obstruction (CAO) and evaluating therapeutic effects, but are effort-dependent. By contrast, the forced oscillation technique (FOT) is performed during tidal breathing in an effort-independent mode and is universally used to assess respiratory function in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and asthma. We used the FOT to measure airway resistance and reactance in patients with CAO before and after interventional bronchoscopy and compared the results to data obtained using PFTs.

Comparison of the forced oscillation technique and the interrupter technique for assessing airway obstruction and its reversibility in children

The forced oscillation technique (FOT) and interrupter technique are particularly attractive for pediatric use as they require only passive cooperation from the patient. We compared the sensitivity and specificity of these methods for detecting airway obstruction and its reversibility in 118 children (3-16 yr) with asthma or chronic nocturnal cough. FOT (R(0) and R(16)) and interruption (Rint) parameters were measured at baseline and after bronchodilator inhalation (n = 94). Rint was significantly lower than R(0), especially in children with high baseline values. Baseline parameters were normalized for height and weight [R(SD)]. In children able to perform forced expiratory maneuvers (n = 93), the best discrimination between those with baseline FEV(1) < 80% or > or = 80% of predicted values was obtained with R(0)(SD). At a specificity of 80%, R(0)(SD) yielded 66% sensitivity, whereas Rint(SD) yielded only 33% sensitivity. Similarly, postbronchodilator changes in R(0)(SD) [DeltaR(0)(SD)] yielded the best discrimination between children with and without significant reversibility in FEV(1). At a specificity of 80%, DeltaR(0)(SD) yielded 67% sensitivity and DeltaRint(SD) yielded 58% sensitivity. In children unable to perform forced expiratory maneuvers (n = 25), FOT, contrary to the interrupter technique, clearly identified a subgroup of young children with high resistance values at baseline, which returned to normal after bronchodilation. We conclude that, in asthmatic children over 3 yr old, FOT measurements provide a more reliable evaluation of bronchial obstruction and its reversibility compared with the interrupter technique, especially in young children with high baseline values.     

应用强迫振荡技术优化慢性阻塞性肺疾病患者经鼻罩无创通气压力水平的探讨

目的 探讨利用强迫振荡阻抗和电抗方法优化COPD患者经鼻罩无创通气压力水平的合理性.方法 研究对象为2007年6月至2008年2月在广州呼吸疾病研究所住院的8例COPD合并2型呼吸衰竭患者,分别给予不同压力水平的双水平气道正压通气和连续气道正压通气(CPAP),采用5 Hz强迫振荡信号检测各呼吸周期的吸气相阻抗,以食道测压法测定的吸气相肺阻力为参照,比较两者的一致性和相关性;计算CPAP分别为4、8和12 cm H2O(1 cm H2O=0.098 kPa)时各呼吸周期的呼气相与吸气相电抗之差(△Xrs),分析各呼吸周期的跨肺压与流量的关系,将上述各呼吸周期划分为有或无呼气流速受限(EFL),比较CPAP水平、△Xrs值和显示为EFL的呼吸周期数之间的数量关系,计算检测EFL呼吸周期敏感度和特异度均最高的△Xrs阈值.正态分布资料均数的比较采用配对t检验,非正态分布资料采用非参数检验,相关分析采用直线相关分析方法.结果 8例COPD患者的吸气相阻抗和吸气相肺阻力的均值分别为(6.5±1.6)cm H2O·s-1·L-1和(9±5)cm H2O·s-1·L-1(相关系数为0.64,P<0.01),两者差值的中位数为-2.7(-5.7～0.7)cm H2O·s-1·L-1,一致性范围在(-10.6～4.9)cm H2O·s-1·L-1,吸气相肺阻力=-1.62+1.69吸气相阻抗(F=109.6,P<0.01).CPAP水平增高,△Xrs显著降低,显示为EFL的呼吸周期数显著减少,区分呼吸周期有或无EFL的△Xrs阈值为1.83 cm H2O·s-1·L-1,敏感度为94%,特异度为97%.结论 5 Hz强迫振荡吸气相阻抗可用于预测吸气相肺阻力,参照吸气相肺阻力设置无创通气的吸气相止压水平,能有效克服增高的肺阻力;△Xrs反映EFL程度,逐步增高CPAP或呼气末正压的水平,使△Xrs≤1.83 cm H2O·s-1·L-1,可消除绝大部分呼吸周期的EFL.     

Changes in respiratory mechanics with increasing degrees of airway obstruction in COPD: detection by forced oscillation technique

The Forced Oscillation Technique (FOT) is a method for non-invasively assessing respiratory mechanics during spontaneous breathing, demanding little cooperation. The aim of this study was to test the ability of FOT to describe the changes in respiratory mechanics in progressive COPD. The study was performed in a control group formed by 21 healthy subjects and 79 outpatients with COPD, which were classified by spirometry, according to the degree of airway obstruction, in mild, moderate and severe groups. Resistive impedance data were submitted to linear regression analysis over the 4-16 Hz frequency range, which yielded the total respiratory system resistance extrapolated at 0 Hz (R0), the respiratory system conductance (Grs), mean respiratory resistance (Rm), and the resistance/frequency slope (S). Reactance data were interpreted using the mean values (Xm) over the 4-32 Hz frequency range, the dynamic compliance (Crs,dyn), the dynamic elastance (E(rs,dyn)), and the resonant frequency (fr) data. Considering the control and mild groups, the increase of airway obstruction resulted in a significant increase of R0 (P<0.008), Rm (P<0.001), and a significant reduction in Grs (P<0.002). Reactive parameters, Crs, dyn and Ers,dyn also presented significant modifications. The subsequent increase (mild to moderate) showed a significant raise of R(0) (P<0.007), S (P<0.001), and a reduction in Grs (P<0.015), while significant increases in Xrs (P<0.001), and Ers,dyn (P<0.02), and also a reduction in Crs, dyn (P<0.02) were also observed. In contrast to earlier stages, in the late stage of the airway obstruction increase (moderate to severe obstruction), resistive parameters did not present statistically significant modifications, while significant modifications were observed in Xrs (P<0.02), Crs, dyn (P<0.003) and Ers,dyn (P<0.003). The results of this study demonstrated that the FOT is useful for detecting the respiratory mechanics modifications in COPD patients. The initial phases of airway obstruction in COPD can be described mainly by resistive parameters, while in more advanced phases, reactive parameters seem to be more useful. Since the FOT has the advantage of being a simple method, such a technique may give a significant clinical contribution, representing an alternative and/or complement to the evaluation of respiratory mechanics by means of forced expiration.     

Validating respiratory index of auto-titrating positive airway pressure device with polysomnography

Purpose

Positive airway pressure (PAP) devices have been widely used as the first line of treatment in obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). Most advanced PAP devices support the estimation of respiratory index (RI) using the patient’s mask airflow. In addition to the compliance factor for PAP device use, which is important for monitoring patient sleep health, RI is also becoming important for monitoring. However, there are few reports that validate RI of a PAP device with polysomnography.

Methods

Between January 2015 and December 2017, 50 participants were enrolled who were diagnosed with OSA and prescribed auto-titration PAP (APAP) devices. The RIs of participants were measured at night using APAP devices, concurrently with electroencephalography, respiratory inductance plethysmography sensors, and other polysomnographic sensors in a sleep laboratory. The respiratory-related data of APAP were prospectively analyzed with the manually scored polysomnographic data.

Results

The apnea-hypopnea index and apnea index showed a statistically close relationship between the auto-scored respiratory data from the APAP device and the manually scored respiratory data from polysomnographic sensors. Obstructive apnea and central apnea indices showed relatively low correlations. The differences between the auto-scored RI and manually scored RI were influenced by BMI, waist circumference, weight, oxygen saturation, and respiratory distress indices of diagnostic polysomnographic factors.

Conclusions

The RIs of APAP devices have a tendency to be underestimated or mismatched when compared with polysomnography. Sleep specialists are advised to consider additional anthropometric and diagnostic factors to account for these differences during PAP treatment.

     

Detection of changes in respiratory mechanics due to increasing degrees of airway obstruction in asthma by the forced oscillation technique

Forced expiratory airflows and volumes are often used to assess the airway obstruction in asthmatics. However, forced maneuvers may change bronchial tone and modify airway patency. The aim of this study was to determine whether the Forced Oscillation Technique (FOT), which does not require forced manoeuvres, may be useful to describe the changes in respiratory mechanics in progressive asthma. This study involved 25 healthy and 84 asthmatics, including patients with normal spirometric exam (NE), mild moderate and severe obstruction. Resistive data were interpreted using the respiratory system resistance extrapolated at 0 Hz (R0), the mean respiratory resistance (Rm), and the resistance/frequency slope (S). Reactance data were interpreted by its mean values (Xm), the dynamic compliance (Crs,dyn), and resonant frequency (fr). Receiver operating characteristics curves were used to determine the sensitivity (Se) and specificity (Sp) of FOT parameters in identifying asthma. There were not statistically significant differences between the control and NE groups. Comparing the control and mild groups, significant increases of R0 (P<0.0007), Rm (P<0.003), and S (P<0.003) were observed. In reactive parameters, a significant reduction in Crs,dyn (P<0.04) was observed, while Xm and fr presented significant increases (P<0.0007 and P<0.006, respectively). Comparison between mild and moderate groups showed non-significant modifications in all of the parameters, except for Xm (P<0.02). In the late stages (moderate to severe obstruction), all of the resistive parameters, as well as the reactive ones Xm (P<0.007) and Crs,dyn (P<0.03), presented statistically significant modifications. Among the studied parameters, the effects of airway obstruction in asthma seem to be well described by R0, Rm, S and Xm, which were in close agreement with physiological fundamentals. The best parameters for detecting asthma were R0 (Se=81%, Sp=76%), S (Se=78%, Sp=72%) and Xm (Se=81%, Sp=80%). In conclusion, the results of this study suggest that the FOT can be proposed as an alternative method for the assessment of the respiratory mechanics in asthmatic patients, representing a promising solution to the problem of effort dependence.     

Walking with continuous positive airway pressure.

A ventilator-dependent child had been in the paediatric intensive care unit (PICU) ever since birth. As a result, she had fallen behind considerably in her development. After 18 months, continuous positive airway pressure was successfully administered via a tracheostomy tube with a novel lightweight device. This enabled her to walk in the PICU. With this device, the child was discharged home where she could walk with an action range of 10 m. Subsequently, her psychomotor development improved remarkably. To the authors' knowledge, this is the first case report of a patient, adult or paediatric, who could actually walk with a sufficient radius of action while receiving long-term respiratory support.