The efficacy and safety of subcision using CO2 gas combined with fractional laser for acne scars: Clinical and microscopic evaluation

Background: Various modalities have been used to treat acne scars. CO₂ fractional laser is an effective and commonly used treatment. CO₂ gas injection into the dermis by needle with high pressure can cause fibrotic collagen breakage, producing the effects of subcision. CO₂ also stimulates collagen synthesis by increasing neovascularization and releasing oxygen. Objective: This study evaluated the efficacy and the safety of the combined treatment with CO₂ gas subcision and CO₂ fractional laser for acne scars. Methods and materials: Fourteen patients with acne scars were treated with three sessions of CO₂ gas subcision at 2-week intervals and two sessions of fractional laser at 4-week interval. The clinical improvement was assessed using a 4-point scale. For histologic analysis, punch biopsy was performed before and after treatment in 10 patients. Results: All patients experienced clinical improvements. Excellent, marked, moderate, and mild response was achieved in 1 (7%), 8 (57%), 4 (29%), and 1 patient (7%), respectively. Histologic evaluation of the biopsy specimens showed increased dermal collagen with dermal thickening and elastic fiber straightening in the reticular dermis after the treatment. Conclusion: The combination therapy with CO₂ gas subcision and fractional laser was satisfactory and safe for treating acne scars.

Abbreviation and acronym:

CO₂: Carbon dioxide

GAS: Global assessment scale

H&E: hematoxylin and eosin; SD: standard deviation     

Evaluation of autologous platelet-rich plasma plus ablative carbon dioxide fractional laser in the treatment of acne scars

Introduction: Acne scar is a common distressing complication of acne vulgaris. CO₂ laser resurfacing proved effective for the treatment of this problem, but the associated complications may limit its use. Platelet-rich plasma (PRP) may increase the chance of favorable outcome. Aim of the work: To evaluate the synergistic effects of autologous PRP with fractional CO₂ laser resurfacing in the treatment of acne scars among Egyptian patients. Patients and method: This study included 30 patients suffering from post-acne scars. CO₂ laser treatment was applied to both sides of the face followed by PRP injection for the right side. Evaluation was carried out through operating physicians, two blinded physicians as well as through patient’s satisfaction. Result: The right side of the face (PRP-treated side) achieved excellent improvement in 13.3% of the patients, while there was no excellent improvement on the left side. Conclusion: Combination of fractional CO₂ laser resurfacing and intradermal PRP was superior to CO₂ laser alone for acne scar treatment.     

Treatment of acne scarring with fractional CO2 laser

Abstract

Background: Fractional ablative CO₂ laser therapy is based on the theory of fractional photothermolysis. It can be effective in treating acne scars in a less invasive fashion than conventional ablative CO₂ laser therapy. Objective: In this clinical study, the safety and efficacy of a novel CO₂ fractional ablative laser was investigated for the treatment of facial atrophic acne scarring in Chinese individuals. Materials and methods: A total of 31 patients (11 females, 20 males, Fitzpatrick skin phototypes III–IV) with facial acne scarring received three sequential fractional treatments over a 6-month period. Outcome measurements included blinded evaluations of before and after photographs by two physicians at 3 and 12 months after the final treatment. Global improvement was noted as well as any untoward events. Results: At the 12 months follow-up time period, 12.9% of the patients showed excellent improvement in their acne scars, while 38.71% noted good to fair results. The clinical response at the 12-month follow-up visit tended to be better than at the 3-month follow-up visit, but was not statistically significant. Four patients experienced post-treatment and transient PIH but three patients were noted to have prolonged erythema. There was no evidence hypopigmentation or worsening of the scarring in any of the study patients. Conclusion: This high-energy pulsed and cool-scanned fractional ablative CO₂ laser system is safe and effective for facial atrophic acne scarring. Improvement in scarring was noted in the majority of patients with minimal discomfort and minimal downtime. Continued improvement over time is also an important clinical finding.     

Combined subcision,autologous platelet-rich plasma,and CROSS technique in the treatment of atrophic acne scars: Prospective split face study.

Acne scars represent a therapeutic dilemma. This study aimed to evaluate the efficacy of combined subcision, autologous platelet-rich plasma (PRP), and chemical reconstruction of skin scars (CROSS) technique in the treatment of acne scars. In 20 patients with atrophic acne scars, one facial side was treated with subcision plus PRP, and the other was treated with the same combination plus CROSS technique (trichloroacetic acid 50%) for 3 sessions at 3-week intervals. Clinical evaluation, digital photography, quantitative global scarring grading system, and Lipper and Perez score were done at baseline, every session, and 1 month after the last session. Participants assessed their improvement at the end of the follow-up period using a scale (0 to 10). There was a significant reduction in quantitative global scarring grading system (P < .001) and Lipper and Perez score (P < .001) after treatment compared with baseline in both sides. No significant difference was found when the two treated sides were compared after treatment by both scores. Patients’ satisfaction was excellent (12 patients [60%]) and good (eight patients [40%]) with no significant difference between both sides. In conclusion, combined subcision and PRP is recommended for acne scars. Adding CROSS technique (trichloroacetic acid 50%) did not further ameliorate the condition.     

The clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of fractional CO2 laser in acne scars and skin rejuvenation: A meta-analysis and economic evaluation

Introduction: Fractional CO₂ has many indications in medicine including in treatment of acne scars and rejuvenation. The aim of this study was to evaluate the safety, efficacy, and cost-effectiveness of Fractional CO₂ Laser in comparison with other methods of rejuvenation and acne scar treatment. Materials and Methods: Several databases including Medline, OVID, EMBASE, CINHAL, SCOPUS, Web of science, CRD, and Cochrane were searched. After conducting the search and evaluation of selected publications, critical appraisal was done and eligible studies were accepted for inclusion in the systematic review. Results and Discussion: From 2667 identified publications two of the trials were eligible. The effectiveness and complications of Fractional CO₂ laser were comparable with Er:YAG but Fractional CO₂ laser was 14.7% (p = 0.01) more effective than Q-Switched ND:YAG laser. Cost affectivity of this method was the same as other alternative lasers. In conclusion Fractional CO₂ laser is an effective and safe method for curing of several kinds of skin diseases. Nevertheless there was not sufficient evidence to support its advantage. This device has equal or lower price in comparison to competent technologies except for the non- fractional ablative CO₂ laser that has the same or lower price and comparable effects.     

Efficacy of Punch Elevation Combined with Fractional Carbon Dioxide Laser Resurfacing in Facial Atrophic Acne Scarring: A Randomized Split-face Clinical Study

Background:

A number of treatments for reducing the appearance of acne scars are available, but general guidelines for optimizing acne scar treatment do not exist. The aim of this study was to compare the clinical effectiveness and side effects of fractional carbon dioxide (CO₂) laser resurfacing combined with punch elevation with fractional CO₂ laser resurfacing alone in the treatment of atrophic acne scars.

Materials and Methods:

Forty-two Iranian subjects (age range 18–55) with Fitzpatrick skin types III to IV and moderate to severe atrophic acne scars on both cheeks received randomized split-face treatments: One side received fractional CO₂ laser treatment and the other received one session of punch elevation combined with two sessions of laser fractional CO₂ laser treatment, separated by an interval of 1 month. Two dermatologists independently evaluated improvement in acne scars 4 and 16 weeks after the last treatment. Side effects were also recorded after each treatment.

Results:

The mean ± SD age of patients was 23.4 ± 2.6 years. Clinical improvement of facial acne scarring was assessed by two dermatologists blinded to treatment conditions. No significant difference in evaluation was observed 1 month after treatment (P = 0.56). Their evaluation found that fractional CO₂ laser treatment combined with punch elevation had greater efficacy than that with fractional CO₂ laser treatment alone, assessed 4 months after treatment (P = 0.02). Among all side effects, coagulated crust formation and pruritus at day 3 after fractional CO₂ laser treatment was significant on both treatment sides (P < 0.05).

Conclusion:

Concurrent use of fractional laser skin resurfacing with punch elevation offers a safe and effective approach for the treatment of acne scarring.     

Randomized clinical trial of CO2 LASER pinpoint irradiation technique versus chemical reconstruction of skin scars (CROSS) in treating ice pick acne scars

Abstract

Background: Pinpoint irradiation technique CO₂ LASER and Chemical Reconstruction Of Skin Scars (CROSS) are effective treatments for atrophic acne scars as fractional photothermolysis. Objective: This study was designed to prospectively compare the use of a pinpoint irradiation technique versus TCA CROSS in treating ice pick acne scars. Methods: Thirty-two patients with ice pick acne scars were included in this open, label pilot study. Pinpoint irradiation technique by CO₂ LASER and TCA CROSS were applied for the study and control group, respectively. Twenty-eight patients with ice pick acne scars were included in this open, label pilot study. They were randomly assigned to two groups: the first group (14 patients) received pinpoint irradiation by CO₂ LASER as a study group, and the second group (14 patients) received TCA CROSS as a control group. In both treatments, there were four sessions at 3-week interval, and 3 months of follow up. Results: There were statistically significant difference in acne scar severity index and qualitative scarring grading system in the improvement results between the study and control groups (p < 0.05). Conclusion: Pinpoint irradiation technique by CO₂ LASER is safe and more effective than TCA CROSS technique. Clinical improvement was achieved in all 14 patients without dramatic adverse effects.     

Atrophic acne scar treatment using triple combination therapy: Dot peeling,subcision and fractional laser

Abstract

Atrophic scars are a common complication of acne. Many modalities are proposed but each does not yield satisfactory clinical outcomes. Thus, a new combination therapy is suggested that incorporates (i) dot peeling, the focal application and tattooing of higher trichloroacetic acid concentrations; (ii) subcision, the process by which there is separation of the acne scar from the underlying skin; and (iii) fractional laser irradiation. In this pilot study, the efficacy and safety of this method was investigated for the treatment of acne scars. Ten patients received this therapy for a year. Dot peeling and subcision were performed twice 2–3 months apart and fractional laser irradiation was performed every 3–4 weeks. Outcomes were assessed using scar severity scores and patients’ subjective ratings. Acne scarring improved in all of the patients completing this study. Acne scar severity scores decreased by a mean of 55.3%. Eighty percent of the patients felt significant or marked improvement. There were no significant complications at the treatment sites. It would appear that triple combination therapy is a safe and very effective combination treatment modality for a variety of atrophic acne scars.     

Non‐ablative 1550‐nm erbium‐glass and ablative 10 600‐nm carbon dioxide fractional lasers for acne scars: a randomized split‐face study with blinded response evaluation

Background Non‐ablative 1550‐nm erbium‐doped fractional photothermolysis systems (FPS) and 10 600‐nm carbon dioxide fractional laser systems (CO₂ FS) have been effectively used to treat scars. Objective We compared the efficacy and safety of single‐session treatments of FPS and CO₂ FS for acne scars through a randomized, split‐face, evaluator‐blinded study. Methods Eight patients with acne scars were enrolled in this study. Half of each subject’s face was treated with FPS and the other half was treated with CO₂ FS. We used a quartile grading scale for evaluations. Results At 3 months after the treatment, the mean grade of improvement based on clinical assessment was 2.0 ± 0.5 for FPS and 2.5 ± 0.8 for CO₂ FS. On each side treated by FPS and CO₂ FS, the mean duration of post‐therapy crusting and scaling was 2.3 and 7.4 days respectively and that of post‐therapy erythema was 7.5 and 11.5 days respectively. The mean VAS pain score was 3.9 ± 2.0 with the FPS and 7.0 ± 2.0 with the CO₂ FS. Conclusion We demonstrated the efficacy and safety of single‐session acne scar treatment using FPS and CO₂ FS in East Asian patients. We believe that our study could be used as an essential reference when choosing laser modalities for scar treatment.     

Combined use of fractional CO2 laser and radiofrequency waves to treat acne scars: A pilot study on 15 patients

Abstract

Fractional laser resurfacing has become an important technique in the management of a number of skin conditions, such as photoaging and scars. A variety of laser wavelengths and delivery systems have been introduced to improve immediate and long-term therapeutic results. The simultaneous emission of CO₂ laser and radiofrequency waves combines epidermal coagulation for a resurfacing effect and dermal denaturization for deeper remodelling. The authors present this new machine together with a preclinical histological study and pilot study on 15 patients suffering from acne scars.     

A systematic review of comparative studies of CO2 and erbium:YAG lasers in resurfacing facial rhytides (wrinkles)

Background: Laser resurfacing is used to minimize wrinkles, solar scars and sequelae of acne. Objective: Purpose of the systematic review was to compare resurfacing outcomes of CO₂ laser and erbium: yttrium aluminium garnet (erb:YAG) laser therapies. Materials and methods: Medline, Cochrane Library, EMBASE and Google Scholar databases were searched until 9 April 2015 using the following terms: laser, carbon dioxide/CO₂, facial wrinkles, rhytides and erbium-doped yttrium aluminium garnet/erbium:YAG/Er:YAG. Two-armed controlled split faced studies that compared CO₂ laser and erbium:YAG laser in patients with mild-to-moderate facial wrinkles or rhytides were included. Results: The pooled data in this study and findings of other studies support the greater efficacy with the CO₂ laser in improving facial wrinkles, but the erb:YAG laser was associated with a better complication profile compared with the CO₂ laser. Except one case of hypopigmentation, other complications (i.e., erythema, hyperpigmentation and crusting) and their rates were reported by studies examining both lasers. Conclusion: In general, the CO₂ laser appeared to be more efficacious then the erb:YAG laser in treating facial wrinkles. Both lasers treatments were well tolerated.     

Laser treatment for facial acne scars: A review

Background and Objectives: Acne scarring is a widely prevalent condition that can have a negative impact on a patient’s quality of life and is often worsened by aging. A number of options are available for the treatment of acne scarring, including retinoids, microdermabrasion, dermal fillers, and surgical techniques such as subcision. The aim of this review is to evaluate the different laser modalities that have been used in peer-reviewed clinical studies for treatment of atrophic acne scars, and summarize current clinical approaches.

Materials and Methods: A Medline search spanning from 1990 to 2016 was performed on acne scarring. Search terms included “atrophic acne scars,” “ablative’’, “nonablative,” “fractional,” “nonfractional,” “neodymium,” “alexandrite,” “pulsed dye” lasers, and results are summarized.

Results: Various types of lasers have been evaluated for the treatment of atrophic acne scars. While they are efficacious overall, they differ in terms of side effects and clinical outcomes, depending on patients skin and acne scar type. A new emerging trend is to combine lasers with other energy-based devices and/or topicals.

Conclusion: Evaluation of the literature examining acne scar treatment with lasers, revealed that clinical outcomes are dependent on various patient factors, including atrophic acne scar subtype, patient skin type, treatment modality, and side-effect profile.     

Subcision in acne scarring: A review of clinical trials

Post-acne scarring is the most common permanent consequence of acne vulgaris. Subcision is an intervention in which a needle or blunt cannula is inserted under the scar and moved back and forth to cut fibrotic strands and form new connective tissue, thereby elevating the atrophic scars. In this study, we reviewed the efficacy and adverse effects of different subcision techniques alone or in combination with other modalities to manage acne scars. The terms (subcision), (subcision AND acne scar), and (subcision AND scar) were searched in PubMed and Google Scholar. We included all available reports on clinical trials written in English and published before June 2022. A total of 16 relevant articles were identified after reviewing the abstracts and full texts. Four articles compared blunt cannula-based subcision as a modified technique with needle-based subcision as a conventional method, while the others investigated the combination of subcision with other modalities. According to our findings, subcision is a safe and effective method for treating atrophic acne scars. Needle-based subcision and cannula-based subcision offer comparable efficacy, with the latter causing fewer side effects and inducing greater patient satisfaction. Combining subcision with the application of autologous tissues (platelet gel) or artificial materials (hyaluronic acid gels and threads) as fillers can improve outcomes and prevent the re-depressing of scars, as can its combination with frequent suctioning. Combinations with microneedling or fractionated microneedle radiofrequency have also been safe and effective. We conclude that modifications of the subcision procedure lessen its side effects, and combination therapies improve its efficacy.     

A randomized guinea pig study on external cell growth factors after fractional ultrapulsed CO2 laser therapy

Abstract

Background and objectives: The Fractional Ultrapulsed CO₂ laser has been successfully used in treating fine wrinkles, acne scars, and photoaged skin. However, the downtime typically lasts a week or more. The purpose of this study was to observe the efficacy of external cell growth factors after Fractional Ultrapulsed CO₂ laser therapy. Methods: The back skin of 20 male guinea pigs were divided into four regions after hair removal, then these four regions were irradiated with Fractional Ultrapulsed CO₂ laser, respectively. These 80 incised wounds were randomly divided into three therapeutic groups and a control group. The general condition of the wound healing was observed grossly. The determination of physiological functions was done and biopsies were harvested at different time points to compare the change of skin flexibility and fibroblasts number. Results: The wound healing time of therapeutic groups shortened when compared with the control group. The flexibility of skin and the number of fibroblasts were also more than the control group. The effects of combined application of rhEGF and rb-bFGF therapeutic group were most conspicuous. Conclusions: Combined application of rhEGF with rb-bFGF could be more beneficial to the wound after Fractional Ultrapulsed CO₂ laser therapy. It could accelerate the wound healing and increase the flexibility of wound skin, so the significance was important to direct clinical application.     

Retrospective analysis of earlobe keloids treated with the carbon dioxide laser ablation or cold steel debulking surgery

Abstract

Background: Treatment of keloids is a therapeutic challenge. Objectives: To determine the outcome and the risk of recurrence after debulking cold steel surgery or carbon dioxide (CO₂) laser ablation of earlobe keloids. Material and methods: The case records of 16 patients with earlobe keloids managed at Changi General Hospital, Singapore, from 2003 to 2009 were reviewed retrospectively. Results: Fourteen patients were females, and the mean age at presentation was 20 years. Eight patients underwent CO₂ laser ablation, six patients underwent cold steel surgery, one patient underwent both surgery and CO₂ laser ablation, and one patient received only 40 mg/ml of intralesional triamcinolone acetonide. Fourteen patients were followed up for 1–24 months post procedure, and two patients defaulted. Both modalities were equally effective in debulking the earlobe keloids. All 13 patients who had either CO₂ laser ablation or cold steel surgery had recurrence of keloid growth at 2–18 weeks post procedure. The patient who received intralesional triamcinolone acetonide therapy alone had only partial response to the therapy. Conclusions: Both the CO₂ laser ablation and cold steel surgery were equally useful in reducing the size of the earlobe keloids, but were not effective in preventing regrowth of the keloids, even with adjunctive intralesional steroids. Patients should be clearly counselled regarding this.     

Efficacy and safety of 1550-nm fractional laser in the treatment of acne scars in Chinese patients: A split-face comparative study

Objective: To evaluate the efficacy and side effects of 1550-nm fractional Er:Glass laser in treating atrophic acne scar. Materials and methods: Thirty Chinese patients aged 18–65 with atrophic acne scars on both cheeks received a split-face treatment, one side with four sessions of treatment with fractional 1550-nm Er:Glass laser at 20-day interval and the other with topical asiaticoside cream application three times daily as control. Clinical response and side effects were evaluated by a dermatologist three weeks after each treatment and again 12 weeks after the last laser treatment. In addition, self-evaluation of satisfaction by the patients was done at the end of treatment. Results: The study found that mean scores decrease after treatment was 5.65 ± 4.34 for the treated side and 1.23 ± 3.41 for the control side. The improvement in acne scars after the fractional Er:Glass laser 1550-nm treatment was more significant than the control side (p = 0.0001). The side effects were mainly local skin irritation and erythema, which disappeared within one week. Conclusion: The research results show that the fractional 1550-nm Er:Glass laser is an effective and safe treatment device for atrophic acne scars.     

Comparison of Q-switched Nd:YAG laser alone versus its combination with ultrapulse CO2 laser for the treatment of black tattoo

Background: Q-switched lasers are conventionally used for the treatment of black tattoo. However, they require multiple sittings, and the response may be slow due to competing epidermal pigment in dark skin. Objective: To compare the efficacy of Q-switched Nd:YAG laser alone with its combination with ultrapulse CO₂ for the removal of black tattoo. Materials and methods: Sixty patients with black tattoo were randomized into two groups viz., group A and group B. Group A was treated with QS Nd:YAG laser (1064 nm) alone, and group B received combination of ablative ultrapulse CO₂ followed by fixed-dose QS Nd:YAG laser (1064 nm), at 6-week interval for a maximum of 6 sittings. After each sitting, 3 independent physicians noted percentage of improvement that was evaluated using visual analogue scale (VAS) and grading system for tattoo ink lightening (TIL). Results: Combination laser (group B) showed statistically significant improvement in mean VAS score in the last 2 noted visits as compared to 1st session (p < 0.007, p < 0.001) and TIL mean score in last three noted visits as compared to 1st session (p < 0.008, p < 0.020, and p < 0.004). There was no statistically significant difference in the side effect profile of both the groups. Conclusion: For refractory professional tattoos, combination of ultrapulse CO₂ laser and QS Nd:YAG laser is superior to QS Nd:YAG laser alone.     

Clinical trial of a pinpoint irradiation technique with the CO2 laser for the treatment of atrophic acne scars

Ablative laser resurfacing is an effective treatment for atrophic acne scars. However, it often induces complications such as edema, prolonged erythema, scarring and hyperpigmentation. Therefore, a new concept of laser treatment called fractional photothermolysis has been designed to create microscopic thermal wounds to achieve skin rejuvenation treatment of atrophic acne scars. This study was designed to prospectively evaluate the use of a technique similar to fractional photothermolysis using only the standard CO₂ laser without the fractional laser device in the treatment of atrophic scars and demonstrates it as a safe, effective and economical treatment option. Clinical improvement was achieved in all 35 patients with minimal adverse effects.     

Treatment of atrophic facial acne scars with fractional Er:Yag laser

Background: Acne scars are often a permanent disfiguring sequel of acne vulgaris. Although many treatment modalities are available, they are often non satisfactory for all patients. Objective: To determine the effectiveness and safety of fractional 1540 nm erbium_glass laser treatment of facial acne scars in Iraqi patients. Patients and methods: Twenty one patients were enrolled in this prospective clinical study. Three sessions of the 1540 nm erbium glass laser were applied at 2-week intervals. The patients were assessed at 1, 3, and 6 months after the last session. The effect of treatment was assessed by objective (Sharquie scoring system for grading acne scarring and visual analog scale) and subjective (patient satisfaction) methods. Results: Two patients were defaulted. Eleven patients (57.9%) showed improvement from moderate to mild grade, and no grade changes were detected in eight patients (42.1%). The mean score of the visual analog scale prior to treatment was 8.61 ± 0.86 and decreased to 6.15 ± 1.28 (P = 0.037). Ten patients were satisfied to varying degrees. No significant side effects were noted. Conclusion: Non-ablative fractional 1540 nm erbium glass laser is an effective and safe method to treat acne scars and represent good alternative for patients who cannot use the ablative methods because of its longer downtime.     

Subcision in acne scar with and without subdermal implant: a clinical trial

Background Subcision is a procedure that has been reported to be beneficial in treatment of acne scars. Objective This stady aims to assess the efficacy of subcision in the treatment of rolling acne scars and evaluate a novel subdermal filler ‘absorbable plain catgut suture’ with subcision. Methods Twenty‐two patients with rolling acne scars underwent subcision, 20 of whom completed treatment and follow‐up period. One side of the face underwent subcision and another side subcision with subdermal implant. The patients and investigators’ assessment of improvement were both recorded. Results Subcision showed mild improvement in about 60% of patient and moderate improvement in about 40% of them. The rate of response showed no significant difference with the use of subdermal implant. The side‐effects of local oedema, bruising and infection were all transient. Conclusions Subcision seems to be a safe method to correct the rolling acne scars with long‐term improvement. However, the subdermal implant led to no significant superior results.