Clonality Analysis of Benign Parathyroid Lesions by Human Androgen Receptor (HUMARA) Gene Assay

Benign conditions of the parathyroid gland have been classified as adenomas and hyperplasias. These entities however are difficult to distinguish when only a single gland is enlarged. Adenomas are defined as neoplastic clonal growths whereas hyperplasias are considered to be reactive processes of polyclonal origin. In order to analyze the clonal pattern of these lesions, we have studied hyperplasias and adenomas of parathyroid glands from women by the human androgen receptor (HUMARA) assay, a recently reliable and highly-lnformative technique based on the X-chromosome inactivation pattern in females. Samples consisted of formalin-fixed as well as frozen tissues. Informativeness with HUMARA marker was 87% (13/15 cases). All hyperplasias (5/5) and 6/8 adenomas yielded polyclonal results, since two alleles of similar intensity appeared when the lesion was HpaIl-digested. Two parathyroid adenomas had a loss of one X-alIeIe for the HUMARA gene and they were interpreted as monoclonal. These results show that parathyroid hyperplasias and adenomas, considered as multigland or monogland involvement diseases respectively, may be both polyclonal in origin, and that only a small subset of adenomas is found to be clonal. Consequently, clonality analysis cannot allow a clear distinction between these two entities as classically diagnosed. A different approach should be considering hyperplasia or adenoma when a polyclonal or monoclonal result has been obtained by clonality analysis.     

Monoclonality and abnormal parathyroid hormone genes in parathyroid adenomas

Previous work based on the relative tissue content of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase isoenzymes suggested that parathyroid adenomas, like primary hyperplasia, may be multicellular (not clonal) in origin. We have reexamined this issue by using two independent molecular genetic methods. We report tumor-cell-specific restriction-fragment-length alterations involving the parathyroid hormone gene from two human parathyroid adenomas. These abnormal restriction fragments indicate that in each case a clonal proliferation of cells was present and also suggest that DNA alterations involving the parathyroid hormone locus may be important in the tumorigenesis or clonal evolution of some parathyroid adenomas. In addition, we used a restriction-fragment-length polymorphism in an X-linked gene (hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase) to examine the clonality of eight parathyroid adenomas in women. Of these eight adenomas, six had the DNA hybridization pattern of monoclonality, and two had an equivocal pattern. None of five hyperplastic parathyroid glands had a monoclonal pattern. We conclude that some (and perhaps many) single parathyroid adenomas are monoclonal neoplasms. Our observations suggest that there is a fundamental biologic difference between parathyroid adenomas and primary hyperplasia--a difference that could prove useful in distinguishing these entities clinically.     

Molecular evidence that the stromal and epithelial cells in pleomorphic adenomas of salivary gland arise from the same origin: clonal analysis using human androgen receptor gene (HUMARA) assay

Salivary gland pleomorphic adenomas are characterized by a biphasic growth of "epithelial" and "stromal" regions. The "epithelial" region is a compactly organized mixture of both luminal and nonluminal cells, whereas the stromal region is composed predominantly of the nonluminal cells. Using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based HUMARA assay on DNA from formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissues from pleomorphic adnomas of female patients, we intend to clarify the clonal relation between the luminal and nonluminal cells and the clonal nature of the morphologically diverse nonluminal cells in this tumor. HUMARA, the human androgen receptor gene, is located on the X chromosome and contains a segment of polymorphic CAG tandem repeats in exon 1. Several methylation-sensitive HhaI restriction sites are located 5' to these CAG repeats. It is an ideal tool to study clonality of female tissues by examining the methylation pattern. Of the 13 cases analyzed, 3 were homozygous at the HUMARA locus and therefore noninformative. The remaining 10 cases were informative. All 10 cases showed a monoclonal pattern in the stromal area, indicating that the morphologically diverse nonluminal cells are monoclonal. Eight of the 10 cases showed monoclonality in the "epithelial" areas, suggesting a common clonality between luminal and nonluminal cells. Of the remaining 2 samples, 1 was polyclonal for the "epithelial" region, and the other was not amplifiable. Our data provide the first molecular evidence that the luminal and nonluminal cells in pleomorphic adenomas arise from the same clone in most cases, and the morphologically diverse nonluminal cells are monoclonal.     

Chester-Erdheim disease: a neoplastic disorder.

Chester-Erdheim disease is a rare non-langerhans cell histiocytosis characterized by a xanthomatous infiltration of foamy macrophages. The cause and pathogenesis remain unclear. The aim of the present study was to determine whether Chester-Erdheim disease is a polyclonal reactive disease or a clonal neoplastic disorder. The clonal status of samples obtained from five patients with Chester-Erdheim disease was studied. DNA was extracted from fixed and paraffin-embedded sections after microdissection and clonal status was studied using the Xchromosome inactivation pattern of the human androgen receptor gene (HUMARA assay). One patient was homozygous for the HUMARA gene and noninformative. Three other cases were monoclonal. One was polyclonal, and this case showed a dense reactive infiltrate in association with spumous macrophages. This study suggests strongly that Chester-Erdheim disease is a monoclonal lesion consistent with neoplastic disorder. Thus, Chester-Erdheim disease may be considered as the "macrophage" counterpart of Langerhan's cell histiocytosis in the histiocytosis spectrum. Further studies are needed to establish the origin of this clonal proliferation.     

Chromogranin A and B in parathyroid tissue of cases of primary hyperparathyroidism: an immunohistochemical study

Summary Routinely processed parathyroid tissues from 26 cases with primary hyperparathyroidism (19 adenomas, 7 multiglandular hyperplasia) and 8 normal human parathyroid glands were investigated with antibodies against chromogranin A and B and parathyroid hormone (PTH). Normal parathyroids were immunohistochemically positive for PTH and chromogranin A but negative for chromogranin B. Hyperplastic glands showed a focal staining for PTH and chromogranin A without correlation of the staining pattern on serial sections. Adenomas were either uniformly positive for both PTH and chromogranin A or showed a staining pattern similar to that seen in hyperplastic glands. Focal chromogranin B positivity (less than 10% of cells) was found in 3 cases (1 hyperplastic gland and 2 cases of parathyroid adenoma with an immunohistochemical staining pattern similar to hyperplastic glands). Our immunohistochemical results may support previously published findings that most parathyroid adenomas are monoclonal neoplasms whereas hyperplastic glands are of polyclonal origin.     

Clonal analysis and mutations in the PTEN and the K-ras genes in endometrial hyperplasia.

The patterns of X chromosome inactivation and mutations of PTEN and K-ras were evaluated in cases of endometrial hyperplasia to determine the presence of potentially premalignant neoplastic versus polyclonal benign cell populations. Endometrial glandular epithelial cells were collected by laser capture microdissection, and genomic DNAs were extracted. Following treatment with the methylation sensitive restriction endonuclease Hha I, polymerase chain reaction amplification was performed targeting a highly polymorphic short tandem repeat of the human androgen receptor gene (HUMARA). PTEN and K-ras gene mutations were evaluated by analysis of single-strand conformation polymorphism. Two pathologists performed histologic diagnosis of the lesions independently. Monoclonal composition was demonstrated in 13 of 15 (87%) endometrial hyperplasias with atypia and 17 of 31 (55%) complex hyperplasias without atypia. Cytological atypia is significantly associated with the clonal status of the endometrial hyperplasia (13/15 vs 17/31, P = 0.049). In contrast, all 14 normal endometrial tissue samples were polyclonal. PTEN gene mutations were detected in 4 of 13 (30%) monoclonal endometrial hyperplasias with atypia and 2 of 17 (12%) monoclonal endometrial hyperplasias without atypia but were not detected in polyclonal endometrial hyperplasias, with or without atypia. K-ras gene mutations were present in 3 of 13 (23%) monoclonal endometrial hyperplasias with atypia but not in 2 cases of polyclonal endometrial hyperplasia with atypia or in 26 cases of endometrial hyperplasia without atypia. K-ras mutation is thus significantly more frequently found in endometrial hyperplasias with atypia than those without atypia (3/15 vs 0/31, P = 0.030). This study indicates that most cases of endometrial hyperplasia with atypia and a high proportion of cases of endometrial hyperplasias without atypia originate from a single progenitor cell, possibly as a result of genetic alterations, rather than as a result of benign reactive processes.     

Monoclonal origin of vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia and some vulvar hyperplasias.

Squamous neoplasms of the female genital tract, including vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia, presumably are derived from a single cell. This study addressed this hypothesis and determined the clonal status of other squamous epithelial alterations associated with vulvar carcinoma, including hyperplasia and lichen sclerosis. X chromosome inactivation patterns of 22 epithelial lesions and matched normal epithelium were determined using a polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based assay targeting the X-linked human androgen receptor gene (HUMARA). Clonality was inferred by comparing matched lesional and control tissues as follows: 1) monoclonal, if intensity of either PCR product was skewed relative to normal reference epithelium (control), 2) polyclonal, if both lesional and control were unskewed, and 3) unknown, if both lesion and control tissues were skewed toward the same allele. Two cases were excluded because of noninformative homozygous HUMARA alleles. Of 8 vulvar intraepithelial neoplasias analyzed, 7 were scored monoclonal and 1 polyclonal. Of 12 hyperplasias, 6 were monoclonal, including one with lichen sclerosis, 2 were polyclonal, and in 4, the clonal status could not be determined. The PCR-based clonal assay supports a monoclonal derivation for vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia and, in some cases, vulvar hyperplasia, and lichen sclerosis. The finding of monoclonal hyperplasia and lichen sclerosis suggests that clonal expansion may evolve before the development of morphological atypia in these epithelia.     

The Efficacy of In Situ PCR,CARD and Nanogold Systems for Gene Detection

Ovarian endometrial cysts, one of the typical manifestations of endometriosis, are generated by the retention of cyclic hemorrhages and are classified as tumor-like lesions rather than neoplasms. Clonality analysis provides important information about the histogenesis and progression of neoplastic diseases. As it is generally accepted that most neoplasms are monoclonal in origin, however, the clonality of endometrial cysts remains uncertain. Using the human androgen receptor gene (HUMARA) as an X-linked polymorphic marker, we examined the clonal status of epithelial cells in endometrial cysts. We separated 21 fresh epithelial cell samples from 11 endometrial cysts and found that all were monoclonal in the methylation pattern of the HUMARA alleles. Moreover, in each of the five cysts from which epithelial cells were sampled from multiple and distant areas, the methylation patterns of all samples from a single cyst were identical. These data indicate that endometrial cysts are monoclonal in origin and suggest their neoplastic potentiality.     

Molecular analysis of clonality of sporadic angiomyolipoma

Angiomyolipoma, which consists of three intimately intermixed components, smooth muscle, blood vessels, and adipose tissue, is variably considered a hamartoma, a choristoma or a true neoplasm. This study has investigated the clonality of sporadic angiomyolipomas in seven women, each with a single lesion, by determining the pattern of X-chromosome inactivation. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of the highly polymorphic human androgen receptor gene (HUMARA) was performed on the DNA extracted from the paraffin-embedded lesional tissue microdissected to sample the admixed smooth muscle and blood vessel component (SMC/BV) and the adipose tissue component. All seven patients were heterozygous for HUMARA polymorphism upon amplification of undigested DNA from non-lesional tissue and were therefore informative for further analysis. In all patients, lesional DNA, representative of the components, was predigested with HpaII restriction enzyme for amplification of the methylated allele. In six patients, the lesions were clonal, while in one, polyclonal. The polyclonal lesion was small and had less than 20 per cent SMC/BV component. Microdissected SMC/BV component was clonal in 6/7 lesions; the scanty SMC/BV in the remaining lesion did not yield amplifiable DNA. Microdissected adipose tissue was polyclonal in all seven lesions. Angiomyolipomas are three clonal lesions due to a clonal smooth muscle cell and blood vessel component, while the polyclonal adipose tissue is probably metaplastic or reactive. Copyright © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Clonality of Pituitary Tumours: More Complicated than Initially Envisaged?

The application of allelotype microsatellite polymorphisms and X chromosome inactivation analysis in samples from women allow assessment of clonality. Early studies showed that sporadic human pituitary tumors are benign adenomas of monoclonal origin. This implies that they arise from de novo somatic mutation(s) within a single pituitary cell. However, the evidence obtained from a number of studies indicate that morphology cannot predict clonality, clonality within a given tumour may be multiple or single, multiple tumours arising on the background of hyperplasia may be of identical or differing clonality, and multiple "sporadic" tumours within a gland may be of differing clonal origin. Thus, while the early available evidence indicated that pituitary tumours appear largely monoclonal, it is simplistic to assume that this is inevitable and that these cannot be multiclonal in origin. These observations would be entirely compatible with an initiating stimulus resulting in hyperplasia of specific cell types in the pituitary, which itself gives rise to several distinct clones with variable potential to develop into tumours. Such stimuli might include hypothalamic trophic factors, intrapituitary growth factors, or pituitary specific oncogenes.     

Clonality as a criterion in the differential diagnosis of chronic neutrophilic leukaemia

Chronic neutrophilic leukaemia (CNL) is a rare BCR/ABL negative myeloproliferative disorder of elderly patients, showing sustained neutrophilia and splenomegaly. Differentiation between CNL and leukaemoid reactions (LR) is problematic since both conditions share similar morphological features but is essential because CNL patients generally have a poor prognosis. We studied blood samples from 10 female patients with CNL or LR using the HUMARA assay to determine clonality patterns in neutrophils. T-lymphocytes of the patients were investigated as an internal control cell population. In all five CNL patients the neutrophils, and in four of them also T-lymphocytes were monoclonal, indicating that the latter may also originate from the neoplastic clone. In LR patients the neutrophils and T-lymphocytes were generally polyclonal except in one patient showing monoclonal neutrophils suggesting that this patient might be in the process of developing a myeloproliferative disorder. In females clonality studies of blood neutrophils using HUMARA aid in distinguishing patients with monoclonal CNL from polyclonal LR.     

Monoclonality of both pale cells and cuboidal cells of sclerosing hemangioma of the lung.

Sclerosing hemangioma of the lung remains poorly understood, and it is still unclear whether this lesion is neoplastic or not. It consists of two major cell types, pale cells and cuboidal cells. We analyzed the clonality of each cell types from six female cases of surgically resected sclerosing hemangioma. The pale cells and cuboidal cells were separated by microdissection from methanol-fixed sections, and DNA was extracted for clonal analysis based on an X-chromosome-linked polymorphic marker, the human androgen receptor (HUMARA) gene or the phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) gene. The HUMARA and PGK genes were found to be amplified with or without digestion by the methylation-sensitive restrictive endonuclease HpaII. Five of six cases were informative. Pale cells and cuboidal cells showed the same monoclonality in all of the informative cases, whereas the control cells showed a polyclonal pattern. Our results demonstrated that sclerosing hemangioma is caused by monoclonal expansion of cells, confirming that it is a neoplasia. Moreover, the present data indicate that both pale cells and cuboidal cells are derived from the same cell.     

Clonal analysis of a solitary follicular nodule of the thyroid with the polymerase chain reaction method.

Solitary follicular nodules of the thyroid occasionally create a diagnostic problem, especially in the differential diagnosis between adenoma and nodular hyperplasia To obtain confident histologic parameters of clonal lesions, we analyzed DNA samples prepared from paraffin-embedded archival tissue from 20 solitary follicular nodules of the thyroid for clonality with the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) method. On the base of X chromosome inactivation mosaicism, we tested restriction fragment-length polymorphism of the phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) gene and a highly polymorphic short tandem repeat of the human androgen receptor (HUMARA) gene. Of 18 informative cases, 10 were monoclonal, 7 were polyclonal, and 1 showed microsatellite instability. All of the five completely encapsulated nodules were monoclonal. Four of the five unencapsulated nodules showed polyclonality. Of the seven partially encapsulated nodules, four were monoclonal, and the others were polyclonal. The former showed 50% or more of encapsulation degree, whereas the latter showed less than 50%. The capsule tended to be thicker in monoclonal nodules (mean, 0.33 mm) than in polyclonal nodules (mean, 0.13 mm). Other histologic features of the nodules and surrounding parenchymal changes had no significance with respect to predicting clonality. This study suggests that the degree of encapsulation and capsular thickness are morphologically important for predicting the clonality of the thyroid nodule.     

Clonality as expression of distinctive cell kinetics patterns in nodular hyperplasias and adenomas of the adrenal cortex

Although histopathologic criteria for adrenal cortical nodular hyperplasias (ACNHs) and adenomas (ACAs) have been developed, their kinetics and clonality are virtually unknown. We studied 20 ACNHs and 25 ACAs (based on World Health Organization criteria) from 45 females. Representative samples were histologically evaluated, and the methylation pattern of the androgen receptor alleles was analyzed on microdissected samples. Consecutive sections were selected for slide cytometry, flow cytometry, and in situ end labeling (ISEL). Apoptosis was studied by flow cytometry (nuclear area/DNA content plotter analysis) and by ISEL. Appropriate tissue controls were run in every case. Polyclonal gel patterns were revealed in 14/18 informative ACNHs and in 3/22 informative ACAs, whereas monoclonal gel patterns were observed in 4/18 ACNHs and 19/22 ACAs. Overlapping proliferation rates (PRs) were observed in both clonal groups, and apoptosis was detected only in G(0)/G(1) cells, especially in monoclonal ACNHs (3/4; 75%) and in polyclonal ACAs (2/3; 67%). Significantly higher PRs were observed in ACNHs with polyclonal patterns and G(0)/G(1) apoptosis and in ACAs regardless of clonality pattern and presence of G(0)/G(1) apoptosis. All except one ACNH (19/20; 95%) and 15/25 ACAs (60%) showed diploid DNA content, whereas the remaining cases were hyperdiploid. A direct correlation between PR and ISEL was observed in polyclonal lesions (PR = 29.32 ISEL - 1.93), whereas the correlation was inverse for monoclonal lesions (PR = -9.13 ISEL + 21.57). We concluded that only simultaneous down-regulated apoptosis and high proliferation result in selective kinetic advantage, dominant clone expansion, and unbalanced methylation patterns of androgen receptor alleles in ACNHs and ACAs.     

Monoclonality of Atypical Adenomatous Hyperplasia of the Lung

Atypical adenomatous hyperplasia (AAH) of the lung has been postulated as a possible precursor lesion of bronchioloalveolar carcinoma (BAC). The clonality of AAHs from seven female patients was analyzed to determine whether AAH is a monoclonal expansion. All AAHs were identified in lungs surgically resected for BAC. The clonality of the BAC and bronchiolar metaplasia in each case was also analyzed. Approximately 500 cells in each lesion were precisely microdissected from methanol-fixed sections. Adjacent normal lung tissue was collected as a normal control. DNA was extracted for clonal analysis based on an X-chromosome-linked polymorphic marker, the human androgen receptor gene (HUMARA). HUMARA was found to be amplified with or without previous digestion by the methylation-sensitive restriction endonuclease HpaII. Five cases were informative. All 10 AAHs and 7 BACs obtained from the informative cases showed monoclonality, whereas the control cells showed polyclonality. Three different AAH lesions in a single case showed both possible patterns of monoclonality. BAC and contiguous AAH showed identical monoclonality in two cases. Two lesions of bronchiolar metaplasia, which was considered reactive, were polyclonal. Our results demonstrated the monoclonal nature of AAH, and this finding suggests that AAH is a precursor of BAC or a preneoplastic condition.     

Clonal analysis of esophageal squamous cell carcinoma with intraepithelial components.

OBJECTIVE: In tumors of the upper aerodigestive tract, field carcinogenesis is a prevailing concept which suggests that such tumors are commonly of multiclonal origin. METHODS: To test this possibility, we applied a PCR-based clonality assay utilizing the polymorphic locus of the human androgen receptor gene (HUMARA) in female patients with esophageal squamous cell carcinomas (SCCs). DNA was extracted from small pieces of tissues microdissected from multiple points of intraepithelial and invasive parts of each tumor and the adjacent epithelia in 12 cases. The HUMARA locus was PCR amplified with or without prior digestion with Hpa II. PCR products were analyzed by a genetic analyzer and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis followed by silver staining. RESULTS: In each of 8 informative cases, the pattern of X chromosome inactivation of the major cell population in each sample was common among the samples from the invasive part and among those samples, if any, from the intraepithelial part, and was concordant between the intraepithelial and invasive parts in 5 cases and discordant in 1 case. Out of the samples of adjacent epithelia, a monoclonal pattern was demonstrated in 8 basal cell hyperplasias and 3 dysplasias, of which 2 and 1, respectively, showed inactivation patterns discordant with those of the concomitant cancers. CONCLUSION: Esophageal SCCs may often be preceded or accompanied by multiclonal precancerous lesions, and may develop through the outgrowth of single or less commonly multiple dominant clones.     

Clonality studies in sacral chordoma

Chordomas are rare, slow-growing, primary malignant skeletal neoplasms. Chromosome analysis, telomere reduction and telomere activity, DNA microsatellite, and loss of heterozygosity studies have been performed on chordomas; however, the clonality status (monoclonal versus polyclonal proliferation) is unknown. The primary purpose of this study was to determine whether sacral chordoma is monoclonal or polyclonal in origin with the use of a polymorphic X-linked gene (AR; alias HUMARA) and X-chromosome inactivation studies. DNA was harvested from tumor and corresponding normal tissue from eight women (37-71 years) with chordoma. Clonality was determined using an X chromosome inactivation protocol and a polymorphic human androgen receptor gene (AR) located on the X chromosome. The procedure required a methylation-specific polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and determination of the ratio of active to inactive X chromosomes. Results were informative for seven of the eight women, with two separate X-linked alleles seen for the AR gene in the normal tissue. Expression of AR gene alleles from each of the two X chromosomes was present in the chordoma tumor, indicating a polyclonal proliferation in all seven women. Most solid tumors and skeletal neoplasms are polyclonal in nature. Our study indicates that chordoma is polyclonal in its pattern of proliferation.     

Flow cytometric immunophenotyping in posttransplant lymphoproliferative disorders.

We studied the flow cytometric immunophenotyping (FCI) and genotypic data of 11 specimens from 10 transplant recipients and categorized them based on a scheme for posttransplant lymphoproliferative disorders (PTLDs). Specimens had been analyzed by polymerase chain reaction and/or Southern blot for T-cell and B-cell (immunoglobulin heavy chain and light chain genes) gene rearrangements (BGR). The categories for PTLDs were as follows: 1, 1; 2, 6; and 3, 4. The plasmacytic and polymorphic B-cell hyperplasias (PBCHs) revealed no monoclonal/aberrant cells by FCI or genotypic studies (GS). Three of 4 polymorphic B-cell lymphomas (PBCLs) revealed monoclonal or aberrant (no surface light chain) B cells by FCI; 1 of 3 revealed a BGR. However, the 1 case with no monoclonal/aberrant B cells by FCI revealed a BGR. Both immunoblastic lymphomas revealed monoclonal or aberrant B cells by FCI; 1 revealed a BGR. Both multiple myelomas revealed monoclonal plasma cells by FCI; 1 revealed a BGR. In the 4 PTLDs with monoclonal/aberrant B cells by FCI and no clonality detected by GS, the GS were performed on fresh and paraffin-embedded tissue samples. FCI of the plasmacytic and PBCHs supported no clonal process by GS. FCI defined a clonal process in 2 PBCLs, I immunoblastic lymphoma, and 1 multiple myeloma that were negative by GS. However, 1 PBCL that was polyclonal by FCI was monoclonal by GS. Thus, FCI is useful for identifying a clonal process in PTLDs with negative results by GS; FCI and GS should be performed routinely in PTLDs to detect a clonal process.     

Clonal analysis of focal nodular hyperplasia of the liver.

Recent evidence suggests that focal nodular hyperplasia of the liver (FNH) may represent a hyperplastic response to a vascular malformation, but the precise etiology remains unclear. We performed a clonal analysis of ten FNHs from nine patients by patterns of X chromosome inactivation. DNA isolated from paraffin-embedded specimens was subjected to polymerase chain reaction amplification for a highly polymorphic region of the human androgen receptor gene (HUMARA). Predigestion of tumor DNA with the methylation-sensitive, restriction enzyme HpaII allowed for selective amplification of the methylated (inactivated) allele. Of the nine patients analyzed, seven were heterozygous for the HUMARA polymorphism and informative for analysis. One informative patient had two lesions, for a total of eight FNHS. Amplification of lesional DNA after HpaII digestion demonstrated clonality in six of the eight informative cases. Paired tissue samples from different lesional areas were available in four of the six FNHs with evidence of clonality. In three of the four cases, DNA extracted from the two tissue samples showed both evidence of clonality and an identical pattern of X chromosome inactivation. In the remaining case, one sample showed evidence of clonality whereas the other was nonclonal. Three hepatic adenomas from two informative patients were also analyzed for comparative purposes, all of which showed evidence of clonality after HpaII digestion. The current study illustrates that most cases of FNH show a uniform pattern of X chromosome inactivation consistent with clonality.     

Comparative analysis of clonality and pathology in primary and secondary hyperparathyroidism

Parathyroid adenoma and hyperplasia are the most common causes for hyperparathyroidism, and distinction between them is controversial based on the current criteria for pathological diagnosis. We studied the clonality of hyperparathyroidism and its correlation with the pathological features, analysing 39 female patients with hyperparathyroidism. Clonality was successfully detected in 12 heterozygous cases by PCR amplification ofPGK-1 gene. The 12 cases yielded 14 hypercellular glands, 8 affected by primary and 6 by secondary hyperparathyroidism. The results revealed that 7 of the 8 glands with primary hyperparathyroidism showed monoclonal proliferation. Only 1 gland pathologically diagnosed as adenoma showed a polyclonal pattern. In the 4 cases with secondary hyperparathyroidism, at least one monoclonal tumour was detected in each case. Our data indicate that monoclonal tumours are more common than expected in both primary and secondary hyperparathyroidism. Monoclonal tumours and polyclonal hyperplasia can co-exist in the same patient. Comparative study of the clonality and the pathological features showed that the clonality was consistent with the diagnosis of parathyroid adenoma, whereas it was in conflict with the diagnosis of hyperplasia with multigland involvement. One of the reasons for this is that we are ignorant of the true natures of hyperparathyroidism with multigland involvement.