Weight of decision-making impairs clinical assessment of melanocytic lesions

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: We studied the weight of decision-making on clinical assessment of melanocytic lesions judging benign, atypical, and malignant lesions; common mistakes; and total removal rates, comparing dermatologists with nondermatologists. METHODS: Of 11,246 histopathology specimens, 3,768 had a clinical assessment of melanocytic lesions. Histopathologic diagnosis served as the gold standard. RESULTS: Benign nevi were assessed most accurately (77%). Dermatologists assessed benign nevi better (p < .0001). The accuracy of clinical assessment in atypical nevi and melanoma was lower (23% and 42%, respectively). Seborrheic keratosis was the most common mistaken diagnosis. Complete removal of clinically benign nevi, atypical nevi, and melanoma was 84%, 90%, and 89%. Decision-making impaired clinical assessement of melanocytic lesions by 5% for dermatologists and 9% for nondermatologists. CONCLUSION: The accuracy of clinical assessment of melanocytic lesions is high for benign nevi, with dermatologists outperforming nondermatologists. Clinicians overestimated malignant potential. Complete removal was more frequent in suspicious lesions. Clinical decision-making impaired assessment by 5 to 9%.     

768例黑素细胞痣及类似可疑损害切除活检的回顾性分析

目的：了解黑素细胞痣诊断准确性，病理特征，去除方法及复发等问题。方法：回顾分析我院1990年－2000年诊断或疑诊黑素细胞痣的768例活检病理资料，结果：诊断为黑素细胞痣447例，疑诊为黑素细胞痣296例，黑素细胞痣恶变待排25例，共有30例（3．91％）病理诊断为恶性肿瘤，其中恶性黑素瘤6例（0．78％），基底细胞癌22例（2．86％），Bowen病2例（0．26％），结论：黑素细胞痣的诊断应予重视，在有疑问时，手术切除并做病理检查十分必要。     

Morphologic changes of acquired melanocytic nevi with eccentric foci of hyperpigmentation ("Bolognia sign") assessed by dermoscopy

BACKGROUND: Melanocytic nevi with eccentric foci of hyperpigmentation ("Bolognia sign") can be considered as a melanoma-simulating type of acquired melanocytic nevus. We report on the morphologic changes of this type of melanocytic nevus over a 39-month period of dermoscopic follow-up. OBSERVATIONS: A 5-year-old girl had a 4-mm brown papule with a peripheral blue-black area on her right upper arm. The eccentric focus of the hyperpigmentation corresponded dermoscopically to a blue-gray area of pigmentation associated with irregular brown-black globules or dots and partially with a superficial black network. After 39 months, a globular type of acquired melanocytic nevus was detectable, which clinically and dermoscopically appeared to be completely benign. A nearly identical situation was observed in 5 other melanocytic nevi, underlining the involution of the pigmented foci in these nevi. The histopathologic diagnoses of 2 lesions were consistent with a compound type of acquired melanocytic nevus with eccentric foci of hyperpigmentation. CONCLUSIONS: Dermoscopy allows identification of a morphologic pathway of modifications, probably typical for this type of melanocytic nevus in children, and therefore enables avoidance of surgical excision with attendant hypertrophic scarring in children. Conversely, in adults, when dermoscopic follow-up of melanocytic nevi reveals eccentric foci of hyperpigmentation, surgical excision of the lesion is indicated.     

Nevo de Spitz y otros tumores spitzoides en la infancia. Parte 1: aspectos clínicos,histológicos e inmunohistoquímicos

A Spitz nevus is a melanocytic neoplasm of epithelioid and/or spindle cells that usually appears in childhood. These lesions are by nature benign, but their features can sometimes make them difficult to distinguish from melanomas. Spitzoid melanocytic lesions have been grouped into 3 types in recent decades: Spitz nevi, atypical Spitz tumors, and spitzoid melanomas. Atypical Spitz tumors are spitzoid melanocytic proliferations that have atypical histopathologic features that are insufficient to support a diagnosis of melanoma. The malignant potential of these lesions is at present uncertain. This review examines the clinical, dermoscopic, and histopathologic features of this group of lesions.     

Significant melanocytic lesions in infancy, childhood, and adolescence

Malignant melanoma is diagnosed yearly in approximately 300 persons under age 20 in the United States. Relatively recent advances in dermatology include the recognition of lesions felt to be potential precursors of malignant melanoma. Small congenital melanocytic nevi, present in 1 per cent of all newborn infants, may have a small but definite potential for developing malignant melanoma. Furthermore, despite inconclusive data, many leading dermatologists now advocate removal of these small congenital lesions. Giant congenital melanocytic nevi, with their strong predilection for undergoing malignant change, are removed surgically at an early age, often in multistaged procedures. Dermabrasion, once felt to have a role in the treatment of giant congenital nevi, does not remove the malignant potential of these lesions. The dysplastic nevus syndrome, recognized in 1976, identifies individuals at increased risk for developing melanoma. Adolescents who have the dysplastic nevus syndrome or who are members of families with the syndrome require close medical supervision and patient education. The benign Spitz nevus, with its histologic similarity to malignant melanoma, continues to challenge the dermatopathologist and clinician. These lesions--the Spitz nevus, dysplastic nevus, congenital melanocytic nevus, and malignant melanoma--must all be actively considered when regarding the many other benign melanocytic lesions found in infancy, childhood, and adolescence.     

Melanocytic neoplasia of the sole: diagnosis and therapeutic approach.

We examined retrospectively a series of 184 cases of melanocytic neoplasia of the sole observed and treated as out-patients from January 1977 to December 1987, comparing clinical and histological diagnoses. The original clinical diagnoses were divided into nevi, pigmented lesions of suspected malignancy, cutaneous melanomas and others. Of the 170 cases diagnosed clinically as nevus none was of melanoma. The risk that a pigmented skin lesion diagnosed as clinically benign is melanoma is so low as not to constitute a clinical problem. It is concluded that systematic removal of sole nevi is unjustified. If, however, there is the smallest doubt concerning a sole lesion, it should be removed and examined histologically.     

Desmoplastic melanocytic nevi with lymphocytic aggregates

Desmoplastic melanocytic nevi can be difficult to distinguish from desmoplastic melanoma. The presence of lymphocytic aggregates in association with a sclerosing melanocytic proliferation is commonly regarded as a feature in support of a diagnosis of desmoplastic melanoma. However, the finding is not specific for melanoma. Herein we report six cases of sclerosing melanocytic nevi with associated lymphocytic aggregates. They occurred in five women and one man, ranging in age from 11 to 61 years. Three lesions were sclerosing Spitz nevi; one was an amelanotic sclerosing blue nevus, one an acquired intradermal sclerosing nevus, and one was a congenital compound melanocytic nevus with sclerosis of its dermal component. The lesions were interpreted as benign, i.e. melanocytic nevi, because of their histopathologic attributes (symmetric silhouette, benign cytologic features) and results from immunohistochemical studies (all lesions strongly expressed Melan-A and p16) and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). Three lesions tested by FISH lacked copy number changes of 11p, 6q or 6p. None of the lesions recurred. The cases highlight that contextual information is essential for the diagnosis of desmoplastic melanoma and sclerosing nevus. The presence of lymphocytic aggregates per se does not prove that a sclerosing melanocytic proliferation is malignant.     

Clinical diagnosis of dysplastic melanocytic nevi: A clinicopathologic correlation

A prospective, community practice-based, clinicopathologic correlation was undertaken in 165 melanocytic nevi excised from a group of forty-three patients, each patient having previously had at least one clinically suspected and histologically confirmed dysplastic melanocytic nevus. Eighty-two percent of seventy-two lesions with histologic evidence of mild dysplasia had been diagnosed correctly as such clinically. The accuracy of clinical diagnosis of moderate dysplasia was low (20%); however, all cases of severe dysplasia with or without in situ melanoma were diagnosed correctly. In 75% of all cases in which dysplasia of any degree was diagnosed clinically, histologic evidence of dysplasia was found. In order to investigate further the clinical features of these nevi, 175 color enlargements of histologically confirmed dysplastic melanocytic nevi were examined. The following clinical features were found to be most common: ill-defined border (90%), irregularly distributed pigmentation (84%), maximum diameter greater than 5.0 mm (72%), erythema (64%), and accentuated skin markings (63%). Increasing darkness and confluence of pigmentation in these dysplastic melanocytic nevi correlated with increasing severity of dysplasia. We conclude that careful clinical examination of individual melanocytic nevi will separate severe dysplasia with or without in situ melanoma from low-grade (mild or moderate) dysplasia in a high percentage of nevi from patients with the dysplastic nevus syndrome. Clinical examination will yield a diagnosis of dysplasia in approximately 75% of nevi from such patients in whom histologic evidence of dysplasia is present. Clinical examination constitutes a practical and sufficiently reliable method for the assessment of melanocytic nevi in patients with the dysplastic nevus syndrome.     

Targetoid hemosiderotic nevus. A trauma-induced simulator of malignant melanoma

BACKGROUND: Simulators of malignant melanoma comprise a heterogenous group of melanocytic and nonmelanocytic lesions of the skin. Among frequent clinical mimickers of melanoma are injured melanocytic nevi. Any change in the clinical appearance of a pre-existing nevus should alert the clinician to exclude the possibility of malignant transformation in order to early identify a lesion at a stage when complete cure can still be achieved. OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to present the clinical, dermoscopic and histopathologic findings of a series of acquired melanocytic nevi which abruptly developed a pigmented peripheral halo, presumably following minor trauma. METHODS: A series of 6 cases of acquired melanocytic nevi which suddenly developed a targetoid halo were included in the study. All lesions were evaluated by dermoscopy. Three cases were surgically removed at different stages of evolution and submitted to histopathologic examination. In all cases, follow-up was obtained. RESULTS: All the lesions arose on trauma-prone skin sites of young women. The sudden development of an asymptomatic, targetoid halo on a long-lasting, acquired exophytic nevus was the main presentation. Whereas the central nevus persisted, the ecchymotic halo ultimately disappeared. Histopathologic examination disclosed changes of the traumatized nevus in the central part, whereas the ring showed hemorrhage and hemosiderin deposits. Increased numbers of small vessels with hobnail characteristics were associated features. CONCLUSIONS: Targetoid hemosiderotic nevus is a distinctive clinicopathologic variant of traumatized acquired melanocytic nevus which should be included in the list of clinical simulators of melanoma.     

Dermatoscopy turns histopathologist's attention to the suspicious area in melanocytic lesions

BACKGROUND: Histopathologically, the diagnosis of nevus-associated melanoma or melanoma close to a common nevus can be missed if the specimen is cut in a nonrepresentative area or if the section shows only the associated common nevus. OBJECTIVE: To find out whether dermatoscopy of suspicious areas within a nevus can improve the histological diagnosis of malignant melanocytic lesions of the skin. MATERIALS: The study was based on dermatoscopic images of more than 2000 benign and 115 malignant pigmented lesions and a collection of corresponding histopathologic slides. METHODS: The dermatoscopic images and the corresponding histopathologic diagnoses were compared. In case of differences, the histopathologic findings were reevaluated and compared with the dermatoscopic findings. RESULTS: Three cases were identified in which melanoma could have been histopathologically missed as a result of improper sectioning. After the dermatoscopic findings were evaluated, the specimens were reembedded and further sections were obtained. Finally, nevus-associated melanoma or melanoma close to a common nevus was diagnosed. CONCLUSIONS: Specific dermatoscopic patterns of malignancy can be found in highly suspicious areas, eg, broadened networks, radial streaming, pseudopods, or dots located at the periphery. The dermatoscopic-histopathologic correlation can improve the diagnosis of melanoma. Therefore, the clinician should point to the most suspicious area with a drawing or image, and the suspected diagnosis of melanoma and the history of the lesion should be also mentioned.     

Multiple skin metastases of malignant melanoma with unusual clinical and histopathologic features in an immunosuppressed patient

Immunosuppressive regimens may have significant impact on the number of pigmented lesions and the clinical appearance of nevi. Whether immunosuppression can also influence the clinical and histopathologic appearance of malignant melanocytic lesions is still a matter of debate. A patient was immunosuppressed because of heart and bone marrow transplantation. A clinically inconspicuous mole was removed from the left flank and was considered to be a papillomatous nevus. After 1 year, the patient developed multiple pigmented lesions over the entire body, which presented clinically as benign papillomatous nevi and histologically as atypical Spitz nevi. Three months later melanoma metastases were removed from the patient's left axilla, which finally resulted in the death of the patient. Thus, in retrospect, the eruptive pigmented lesions have to be considered as cutaneous melanoma metastases. The atypical clinical and histopathologic appearance of the melanocytic lesions as well as the course of disease may have been influenced by the immunosuppression.     

Malignant blue nevus with lymph node metastases

Background:  Malignant blue nevi arise within cellular blue nevi and contain atypical mitoses, necrosis, nuclear pleomorphism and prominent nucleoli. Malignant blue nevus has been described as a distinct identity, a rare form of malignant melanoma, and a misdiagnosed melanoma.
Methods:  We present a patient with metastatic malignant blue nevus and studies on the histopathologic, immunohistochemical, and molecular features of the neoplasm.
Results:  Histology showed a malignant blue nevus arising in a combined intradermal and cellular blue nevus. CD117 (c-kit) staining showed diffuse cytoplasmic expression within the cellular blue nevus, decreased staining in the malignant component, and variable positivity within the lymph node metastases. Molecular loss of heterozygosity analysis showed different allelic patterns at the hOGG-1 locus between the melanoma and control skin specimens with a varying heterozygous allelic pattern in both the benign and malignant blue nevus.
Conclusions:  Our case of malignant blue nevus with lymph node metastasis involved mutation of the hOGG-1 DNA repair gene. CD117 showed decreased staining of the primary malignant blue nevus with marked upregulation in the metastatic lesion, unlike most metastatic melanomas. Further study is needed to determine if hOGG-1 mutation or c-kit upregulation play a role in the pathogenesis of dendritic melanocytic lesions (either benign or malignant).     

Persistent melanocytic nevi: a review and analysis of 205 cases

Background: Melanocytic nevi can recur or persist if not completely excised and are capable of mimicking malignant melanoma, both clinically and histologically. Objective: To characterize the impact of anatomic site, biopsy method, size, margin involvement and type of original melanocytic nevus on recurrence/persistence of melanocytic nevi. Secondarily, we sought to determine if the original type of melanocytic nevus could be determined solely from microscopic examination of the recurrent/persistent nevus. Methods: One hundred and eighty‐five patients with 205 persistent nevi were identified. Of these, 108 cases had original biopsy specimens available for review. Location, original biopsy size, biopsy method, margins and interval to recurrence were recorded for each. A group of 232 non‐persistent nevi was established as a control population. Results: There was a female predominance in persistent nevi with the back being the most common site for persistence. Dysplastic melanocytic nevi were the most likely to persist. Accurate determination of the original type of melanocytic nevus from microscopic examination of the persistent nevus was possible in only 67% of the cases. Conclusion: Clinicians should take larger and deeper biopsies of clinically dysplastic and conventional melanocytic nevi on the back to prevent recurrences. Grading atypia of the persistent melanocytic nevi is unreliable. Sommer LL, Barcia SM, Clarke LE, Helm KF. Persistent melanocytic nevi: a review and analysis of 205 cases.     

Dysplastic changes in different types of melanocytic nevi. A unifying concept

We observed histopathologic changes previously described in dysplastic melanocytic nevi in association with a dermal component characteristic of other types of melanocytic nevi or overlapping with features of other varieties of nevi. In order to determine the frequency of these changes, we studied 2,164 cases of compound melanocytic nevi that fulfilled the histopathologic criteria for the diagnosis of compound dysplastic nevus, including architectural pattern, cytologic features, and mesenchymal changes. Of the 2,164 compound dysplastic melanocytic nevi, 1,895 (87.6%) had the histopathologic characteristics previously described for dysplastic nevus, 179 (8.3%) showed a dermal component with a congenital pattern, 67 (3.1%) demonstrated epidermal and dermal characteristics of Spitz's nevus, 8 (0.3%) had features of a combined blue nevus, 13 (0.6%) had a halo phenomenon and 2 (0.1%) showed dermal neuronevus. By considering these nevi as variants of dysplastic nevi, one may apply a unified conceptual basis for their nomenclature. In order to completely describe the appearance of the nevus, we named them by adding the term "dysplastic", to their main histopathologic subtype. Accordingly, six different varieties of dysplastic nevi were identified: 1) dysplastic nevus (original); 2) dysplastic nevus with a congenital pattern; 3) dysplastic Spitz's nevus; 4) dysplastic combined blue nevus; 5) dysplastic halo nevus; and 6) dysplastic neuronevus. In summary, we conclude that the histopathologic criteria previously reported for the diagnosis of dysplastic nevi may be found in association with a dermal component characteristic of other types of melanocytic nevi or may have overlapping features with other variants of nevi.     

Amelanotic blue nevus: a variant of blue nevus.

Blue nevi are typically heavily melanized. We report a variant of blue nevus that is minimally pigmented. Of the 1,358 blue nevi seen in our laboratory during the last 6 years, 38 (2.7%) were selected that had scant or absent melanin. We refer to these blue nevi as the amelanotic type. Approximately half of the cases in clinical diagnosis were nevus of some type, whereas other differential diagnoses were basal cell carcinoma, dermatofibroma, and lesion. Histologically all specimens were characterized by the spindle-shaped cells seen in blue nevi, but with very little or no obvious melanin. Some lesions were markedly cellular, resembling the features of cellular blue nevus. No hemosiderin was identified on Perls' stain, whereas Fontana-Masson stain was variably positive. Usually there was fibrous stroma. In most cases, the histologic differential diagnosis was dermatofibroma. Other histologic differential diagnoses included amelanotic and/or spindle cell melanoma, dermal Spitz nevus, neurofibroma, and scar. There was no pleomorphism or increased mitotic activity. Evidence of epidermal melanocytic hyperplasia was seen in two cases. Furthermore, the lesions had been present for many years without evidence of recent change. Immunohistochemistry showed all cases to be strongly positive with anti Mel-5 antibody, but only weakly positive or negative with anti S-100 and HMB-45 antibodies. We would like dermatologists and pathologists to be aware of this unusual and uncommon entity.     

Large atypical melanocytic nevi in recessive dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa: clinicopathological, ultrastructural, and dermoscopic study

A 3-year-old boy with recessive dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa developed a rapidly growing, large, acquired irregular melanocytic nevus on the lower aspect of the back. The lesion was clinically atypical and fulfilled the criteria for a malignant melanocytic proliferation. A complete surgical excision was performed. Histopathologic examination disclosed a compound melanocytic nevus without melanocytic atypia. Ultrastructural examination showed melanocytic cells located both at the roof and the floor of the blister. Several months later, three pigmentary lesions with a similar clinical appearance developed. Periodic clinical and dermoscopic examinations were recommended. Dermoscopic examination disclosed a globular pattern with brown globules and black dots distributed all over the lesions. The lesions also exhibited blue-greyish dots and multiple rounded white structures corresponding to milia-like cysts. No dermoscopic features suggestive of malignancy were noted. Acquired melanocytic nevi showing atypical clinical features have been reported to occur in areas of blistering in patients with epidermolysis bullosa. These nevi appear as large, asymmetrical pigmentary lesions with irregular borders. Initially, they are very dark in pigmentation, with color variegation and loss of pigment, and even becoming papillomatous over time. Histopathologic examination can show features of compound/junctional nevus as well as persistent/recurrent nevus. The concept of "epidermolysis bullosa nevus" has been proposed to define these peculiar lesions. The clinical, histopathologic and ultrastructural features of these nevi are reviewed. The usefulness of dermoscopic examination in the routine diagnosis and follow-up of these lesions are stressed.     

Correlation between clinical atypia and histologic dysplasia in acquired melanocytic nevi.

BACKGROUND: The validity of clinical and histologic criteria in identifying dysplastic nevi is controversial. Recognition of the dysplastic nevus as a distinct clinicopathologic entity requires demonstration of significant agreement between clinical atypia and histologic dysplasia. OBJECTIVE: We attempted to determine the correlation between clinical atypia and histologic dysplasia in acquired melanocytic nevi and to evaluate the sensitivity and specificity of clinical criteria for dysplastic nevi when compared with histopathologic features. METHODS: A total of 940 acquired melanocytic nevi 3 mm in diameter or larger were selected by initially choosing clinically unequivocal dysplastic and nondysplastic nevi and then, from these, histologically unequivocal dysplastic and nondysplastic lesions. The level of concordance between clinical atypia and histologic dysplasia was estimated by kappa statistics. RESULTS: Nevi were classified as clinically dysplastic (n = 499) or nondysplastic (n = 441). On the basis of histologic features, 739 were classified as dysplastic and 201 as nondysplastic. Agreement between clinical atypia and histologic dysplasia was found in 432 nevi, that is, a sensitivity of 58.4% (3-5 mm = 27.2%, >5 mm = 69.8%). Agreement between clinical and histologic criteria on the absence of dysplasia was found in 134 nevi, a specificity of 66.6% (3-5 mm = 92.4%, >5 mm = 47.9%). The kappa value was 0.17 (3-5 mm = 0.14, >5 mm = 0.10). CONCLUSION: The limited sensitivity and specificity together with the negligible kappa value indicate a poor agreement between clinical and histologic diagnoses of dysplastic nevus. The dysplastic nevus cannot be considered a distinct clinicopathologic entity because histologic dysplasia is found in a range of nevi that may or may not show clinical atypia.     

Molecular diagnosis of a benign proliferative nodule developing in a congenital melanocytic nevus in a 3-month-old infant

Small and intermediate congenital melanocytic nevi have a lifetime risk of developing melanoma estimated to range from 0% to 5%. Secondary benign melanocytic proliferations commonly arise in congenital melanocytic nevi; however, some are difficult to definitively distinguish from malignant melanoma based on clinical features and conventional histology. Herein, we describe the use of comparative genomic hybridization in supporting the diagnosis of a deep penetrating nevus developing within a congenital melanocytic nevus of a 3-month-old infant.     

The spectrum of Spitz nevi: a clinicopathologic study of 83 cases

OBJECTIVE: To achieve a clinicopathologic classification of Spitz nevi by comparing their clinical, dermoscopic, and histopathologic features. DESIGN: Eighty-three cases were independently reviewed by 3 histopathologists and preliminarily classified into classic or desmoplastic Spitz nevus (CDSN, n = 11), pigmented Spitz nevus (PSN, n = 14), Reed nevus (RN, n = 16), or atypical Spitz nevus (ASN, n = 14); the remaining 28 cases were then placed into an intermediate category (pigmented Spitz-Reed nevus, PSRN) because a unanimous diagnosis of either PSN or RN was not reached. SETTING: University dermatology and pathology departments and general hospital pathology departments. PATIENTS: A sample of subjects with excised melanocytic lesions. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Frequency of dermoscopic patterns within the different histopathologic subtypes of Spitz nevi. RESULTS: Overlapping clinical, dermoscopic, and histopathologic findings were observed among PSN, RN, and PSRN, thereby justifying their inclusion into the single PSRN diagnostic category. Asymmetry was the most frequent indicator of histopathologic ASN (79%; n = 11); in only 4 cases did dermoscopic asymmetry show no histopathologic counterpart, and in those cases the discrepancy was probably the result of an artifact of the gross sampling technique carried out with no attention to the dermoscopic features. CONCLUSIONS: Among Spitz nevi, histopathologic distinction between PSN and RN is difficult, not reproducible, and may be clinically useless. A simple clinicopathologic classification of these neoplasms might therefore be structured as CDSN, PSRN, and ASN. Asymmetry should be assessed using both dermoscopic and histopathologic analysis, and reliability in histopathologic diagnosis may be enhanced by the simultaneous evaluation of the corresponding dermoscopic images.     

Melanocytic nevi clinically simulating melanoma

Melanoma and other benign or malignant pigmented skin tumors can significantly overlap in their clinical and dermoscopical presentations. Thus, pigmented skin lesions may be misdiagnosed in a large number of cases. An extensive review of the published work provides numerous examples of benign lesions mimicking melanoma. Although a number of melanocytic nevi may have been identified as melanomas, information about their clinical appearance is limited. In this report, we present the clinical appearances of two melanocytic nevi on the vulva and the upper extremity that were difficult to diagnose clinically. Detecting melanoma at an early stage is of the utmost importance. However, more attention should be given to the diagnostic accuracy of benign pigmented skin lesions, which otherwise may be diagnosed and treated as melanoma.