Results of different forms of therapy in vulvar neoplasms

In this retrospective study 216 patients who have been treated for malignant vulva neoplasms between the years 1968 and 1987 at the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology of the University of Kiel are reviewed. Staging according to the Figo-Classification revealed stage I in 13.0%, stage II in 63.0%, stage III in 20.2% and stage IV in 3.8%. During these years treatments applied to these elderly patients often with multimorbidity, aside from the combined treatment according to Berven (27.9%) was in the majority of cases a modified radical treatment (34.1%). The modified radical treatment consisted primarily of simple vulvectomy and tumor excision followed by radiation therapy. Primary radiation therapy was performed in the cases where either local or general noperabilityx was established (29.3%). The 5-years-survival rate of the investigated patients was 31.7%, whereby radical vulvectomy which was performed in a few cases offered the best results. A comparison between the modified radical therapy and the combined therapy according to Berven resulted in equally divided staging groups similar 5-years-survival rates of 39% and 38% respectively. However, the modified radical therapy group demonstrated better results in the first 4 years. Within the modified radical treatment group patients undergoing simple vulvectomy revealed a better survival rate after 3 years than did patients undergoing tumor excision followed by radiation therapy. The long term results of these two modes of modified treatment equal out over 10 years. Therefore, from the results presented we recommend in the case of elderly patients with multimorbidity the modified radical therapy via simple vulvectomy.     

外阴恶性肿瘤79例临床治疗方法及预后分析

目的:探讨外阴恶性肿瘤不同治疗方法的临床效果及预后。方法:对2000年1月至2010年6月本院收治的79例外阴恶性肿瘤的治疗及预后进行回顾性研究。结果:Ⅰ、Ⅱ、Ⅲ、Ⅳ期的3年、5年生存率比较差异均有统计学意义(P<0.05);部分性外阴根治术组与传统全外阴根治术组3年、5年生存率比较差异无统计学意义(P>0.05);外阴癌根治术加放疗与单纯放疗5年生存率比较差异有高度统计学意义及统计学意义(P<0.05);腹股沟淋巴结阴性患者的5年生存率与阳性患者比较及盆腔淋巴结阴性患者的5年生存率与阳性患者比较差异有高度统计学意义及统计学意义(P<0.01,P<0.05)。结论:临床分期及淋巴结转移状况是对外阴恶性肿瘤的预后具有显著影响的两个因素。外阴恶性肿瘤的治疗方式应具个体化。     

Radiation therapy versus pelvic node resection for carcinoma of the vulva with positive groin nodes

From 1977 to 1984, 114 eligible patients with invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva and positive groin nodes after radical vulvectomy and bilateral groin lymphadenectomy were randomized to receive either radiation therapy or pelvic node resection. Fifty-three of the 59 patients randomized to radiation therapy received a 4500- to 5000-rad tumor dose in five to 6.5 weeks bilaterally to the groins and to the midplane of the pelvis even if only unilateral positive groin nodes had been detected; no radiation was given to the central vulvar area. Fifty-three of the 55 patients randomized to further surgery had pelvic node resection performed on the side containing positive groin nodes either unilaterally or bilaterally. Acute and chronic morbidity was similar for both regimens. The two major poor prognostic factors were clinically suspicious or fixed ulcerated groin nodes and two or more positive groin nodes. The difference in survival for the 114 evaluable patients was significant, favoring the adjunctive radiation therapy group (P = .03). The estimated two-year survival rates were 68% for the radiation therapy group and 54% for pelvic node resection group. The most dramatic survival advantage for radiation therapy was in patients who had either of the two major poor prognostic factors present; at this time, the benefit of radiation therapy for the remaining patients is uncertain. In this randomized prospective study, the addition of adjunctive groin and pelvic irradiation therapy after radical vulvectomy and inguinal lymphadenectomy proved superior to pelvic node resection.     

Complications following combined surgery (radical vulvectomy versus wide local excision) and radiotherapy for the treatment of carcinoma of the vulva: report of 73 patients

Cancer of the vulva is uncommon, accounting for only 5% of all gynecologic malignancies, and usually occurs in women over 60 years of age. The historic treatment of choice for invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva is radical vulvectomy with bilateral inguinal lymphadenectomy, which has produced excellent long-term survival. We retrospectively analyzed the complications of wide local excision plus postoperative radiotherapy compared with those of radical vulvectomy and bilateral lymphadenectomy plus pre-or postoperative radiotherapy in 73 patients with vulvar cancer. There were no significant differences among these treatments in terms of primary tumor control, 5-year disease-free survival, and overall survival. Based on these results, the best treatment alternative for advanced vulvar cancer is wide local excision plus radiotherapy, as this method retains the high survival of traditional therapy but has less morbidity.     

A comparative study of radical vulvectomy and modified radical vulvectomy for the treatment of invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva.

Forty-five patients who underwent a modified radical vulvectomy for invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva were compared with forty-five patients who underwent radical vulvectomy for similar lesions. Vulvar wound infection and breakdown were infrequent in both groups. Anal incontinence developed postoperatively in five of the modified radical vulvectomy patients and in none of the radical vulvectomy patients. Urinary incontinence developed postoperatively in two of the modified radical vulvectomy patients and in seven of the radical vulvectomy patients. Possible reasons for these differences are discussed. One invasive local recurrence (2.2%) developed in the modified radical vulvectomy group and two (4.4%) local recurrences developed in the radical vulvectomy group. A modified radical vulvectomy appears to be efficacious for the vulvar phase of treatment of localized invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva.     

The modified radical vulvectomy with groin dissection: an eight-year experience

Fifty-one patients were admitted to a single practice at St. Joseph's Hospital between April 1, 1978, and April 1, 1986 with a diagnosis of squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva greater than 1 mm in depth. Five advanced lesions were treated with combinations of radiation and surgery. Four patients had recurrent squamous cell carcinoma. Of 42 patients treated surgically with intention of cure, 14 were treated with complete radical vulvectomy and bilateral inguinofemoral lymphadenectomies, and 28 patients were treated with complete radical vulvectomy and bilateral inguinofemoral lymphadenectomies, and 28 patients were treated in 26 instances with bilateral inguinofemoral lymphadenectomies in one of five different excision patterns individualized to the site of primary tumor. None of the 28 patients have had a recurrence. Five had positive nodes. Eight have died of unrelated causes. Lesions in 25 cases were stage I or II and in three cases they were stage III. Modified radical vulvectomy and bilateral groin dissection is a safe approach for most patients with stage I or II and occasionally even stage III lesions.     

Non mutilant radical vulvectomy vs radical vulvectomy

20 women, matched for age, site of primary tumor, histotype and stage, have been selected among patients affected with vulvar carcinoma for a study comparing classic radical vulvectomy vs "non mutilant" radical surgery. Detailed results actually available are discussed, showing that "non mutilant" technique gives results comparable to classic radical vulvectomy in terms of survival and recurrence rate; with minor functional and aesthetic damage, minor side effects and shorter post operative course.     

Preoperative radiotherapy followed by radical vulvectomy with inguinal lymphadenectomy for advanced vulvar carcinomas

A therapeutic alternative to exenteration for large locally advanced vulvar carcinoma involving the rectum, anus, or vagina is the use of preoperative radiation followed by radical surgery. Between 1980 and 1988, 13 patients with Stage III and 3 with Stage IV vulvar carcinoma involving the rectum/anus, urethra, or vagina were treated with 4000 rad to the vulva and 4500 rad to the inguinal and pelvic nodes followed by a radical vulvectomy and inguinal lymphadenectomy 4 weeks later. The overall 5 year cumulative survival was 45%. Twelve tumors regressed after radiation with 62.5% of the patients having visceral preservation while in 4 patients there was no major response to radiation and urinary or fecal diversion was required. Of the 6 recurrences 4 were central and 2 distant. Three patients with central recurrences had tumor within 1 cm of the vulvectomy margin. Complications included wet desquamation, inguinal wound separation, lymphedema, and urethral strictures. There were no operative deaths. It is concluded that the use of preoperative radiation followed by radical vulvectomy may be an alternative to pelvic exenteration in selected patients with advanced vulvar lesions.     

Epithelioid hemangioendothelioma of the clitoris: a case report with immunohistochemical and ultrastructural findings.

A 30-year-old woman was referred for evaluation of a small nodule of the clitoris. This was subsequently diagnosed as epithelioid hemangioendothelioma. This rare vascular tumor of intermediate malignancy has not been previously described in the vulva. The patient underwent a modified radical vulvectomy and bilateral inguinal lymph node dissection, and subsequently received photon therapy. She is alive with no evidence of disease 27 months after diagnosis.     

Relevance of microinvasion in carcinoma of the vulva.

Retrospective analysis of 22 cases of Stage I invasive carcinoma of the vulva showed 11 cases in which the depth of tumor invasion was 5 mm or less. All of these patients were treated with radical vulvectomy and lymphadenectomy. In 3 cases positive groin node metastases were discovered. A fourth patient with minimal stromal invasion (less than 5 mm) was prospectively managed with vulvectomy alone and subsequently developed groin node metastasis leading to death from disseminated tumor. Depth of the invasion alone, therefore, is not a reliable indicator of the likelihood of groin node involvement, and lymphadenectomy should continue to be considered for all patients with invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva.     

Advanced primary carcinoma of the Bartholin gland: report of 18 patients

Conservative surgery plus radiotherapy for vulvar cancer has been established as a therapeutic alternative to extensive radical surgery and produces a similar cumulative 5-year survival. We retrospectively analyzed the cases of 18 patients with advanced primary carcinoma of the Bartholin gland treated with wide local excision (WLE) or radical vulvectomy and lymphadenectomy followed by radiotherapy (RT) at the University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center from January 1978 through December 1990. All patients have been observed for a minimum of 7 months (maximum follow-up, 15 years; median follow-up, 9 years). Of the 18 patients, 7 were treated with wide local excision (WLE) followed by radiation therapy (RT) (Group 1), 9 had radical vulvectomy (RV) followed by RT to the vulvar and inguinal-femoral and pelvic node areas (Group II), and 2 were treated with RT alone after biopsy of the tumor (Group III). The 5-year disease-free survival rates were 86%, 78%, and 50% for groups I, II, and III, respectively, and 83% for the whole group. Of 2 patients treated with RT alone, one lived for 6 years with no evidence of disease, and the other lived for 20 months. The rate of local tumor control was 100% for all three treatment groups. There were no significant differences among the treatment groups in rate of primary tumor control or 5-year disease-free survival rate (p=0.1300). The present study demonstrated WLE followed by RT is the best treatment for advanced primary carcinoma of the Bartholin gland. Less radical surgery plus RT produces good long-term survival and has fewer complications.     

Radical vulvectomy and inguinal lymphadenectomy versus inguino-pelvic lymphadenectomy combined with radical vulvectomy and the role of radiotherapy

We studied 39 patients with stromal invasion exceeding 1 mm. Among them 3 underwent emivulvectomy and 8 simple vulvectomy; all had selective inguinal lymphadenectomy of one side the first and bilaterally the others. 17 women underwent radical vulvectomy and inguinal lymphadenectomy while 11 had radical vulvectomy and inguino-pelvic lymphadenectomy. Out of 21 patients with lymph nodal metastases, 11 had one side inguinal metastases, 2 had a single metastasis, 2 had double metastases, 1 had three metastases and 2 multiple ones. Survival rate decreased from 54.5% to 20.0% when patients had more than 3 monolateral inguinal metastases or bilateral ones, with increase of pelvic lymph nodal metastases; therefore, in those cases, pelvic lymphadenectomy can be associated to inguinal lymphadenectomy or, when the carcinoma is situated in the clitoridis, Bartolino's gland or vagina (the same could be done for melanoma of the vulva). The usefulness of radiotherapy is limited by the small response of vulvar tissue. In a series of 45 patients with clinical diagnosis of inguinal metastases, who could not undergo operation, only therapy, with electron beam therapy (9 meV) associated to inguinal fields (15 meV), had positive influence in 27% of the cases.     

Derzeitige Therapie des Vulvakarzinoms. Ergebnisse einer Umfrage an den deutschen Universitäts-Frauenkliniken

Treatments concepts for carcinoma of the vulva in German university clinics were surveyed in an inquiry made by letter. It was revealed that radical vulvectomy is standard therapy of invasive vulvar cancer. Patients with inguinal lymph-node metastases are treated by pelvic lymphadenectomy or radiation. Almost all clinics provide reconstructive procedures performed by a gynecologist and delineate an "early vulvar cancer" with less radical therapy. There is still some disagreement on the definition of criteria such as maximal tumor diameter and invasion.     

Management of vulvar melanoma.

Considerable debate centers on the optimal treatment for vulvar melanoma, as well as those clinicopathological factors influencing prognosis. We reviewed 80 patients with vulvar melanoma seen between 1949 and 1990. Primary tumors were assessed according to Chung (47 patients) and Breslow (65 patients) microstaging systems. Fifty-nine patients (76%) underwent radical vulvectomy, ten patients (13%) had a partial vulvectomy, and nine patients (12%) had a wide local excision. Fifty-six also underwent inguinal node dissection. Median follow-up was 193 months. Median survival was 63 months. Ten-year survival by Chung level was as follows: I 100%; II, 81%; III, 87%; IV, 11%; V, 33%. Ten-year survival by tumor thickness was as follows: 0.75 mm, 48%; 0.75-1.5 mm, 68%; 1.51-3.0 mm, 44%; greater than 3.0 mm, 22%. Increased depth of invasion was associated with increased incidence of inguinal node metastasis. Cox regression analysis demonstrated prognostic significance for tumor thickness (P less than 0.001), inguinal node metastasis (P less than 0.001), and older age at diagnosis (P less than 0.001). Radical vulvectomy did not seem to improve survival over less radical procedures. Based on this experience, we recommend radical local excision for patients with malignant melanoma of the vulva. Patients who have more than a superficially invasive melanoma should also have inguinal lymph node dissection.     

Radical wide excision and selective inguinal node dissection for squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva

Limited resection of some vulvar cancers may provide cure rates equivalent to those obtained with radical vulvectomy and bilateral inguinal node dissection. Rapid recovery, fewer complications, and better functional result have been described as advantages to less extensive procedures. Since 1978, 32 patients with invasive squamous cell cancer of the vulva (depth greater than 1 mm) and clinically negative inguinal lymph nodes underwent radical wide excisions as primary therapy. Mean age at diagnosis was 61 years. Seventeen patients had T1 and 15 had T2 tumors. Resection of the primary lesion was tailored to lesion location and size, and dissection was carried to the deep perineal fascia. Twenty-two patients had unilateral superficial inguinal lymph node dissections, five with midline lesions had bilateral superficial dissections, and five had node samplings which included deep inguinal nodes. Depth of invasion ranged from 1.5 to 13.0 mm. Mean largest lesion dimension was 23 mm. Five-year lifetable survival for the entire group was 84%. Univariate analysis of potential prognostic variables showed no significant recurrence or survival differences for patient age (P = 0.56), symptom duration (P = 0.57), FIGO stage (P = 0.67), tumor grade (P = 0.20), tumor location (P = 0.26), depth of invasion (P = 0.56), or resection margin status (P = 0.63). Thirty-one percent of patients had perioperative complications, and 16% developed delayed complications. Mean hospital stay was 10 days. Three patients (10%) developed new or recurrent vulvar disease and underwent additional therapy. None have died of disease, although one is alive with persistent tumor. Radical wide excision and selective inguinal lymphadenectomy constitute a reasonable alternative to radical vulvectomy with bilateral inguinal node dissections for squamous tumors clinically limited to the vulva. Outcome may not be strongly influenced by lesion size or depth of invasion.     

Infectious morbidity after radical vulvectomy

Objective: This retrospective investigation describes the infectious morbidity of patients following radical vulvectomy with or without inguinal lymph node dissection.Methods: The charts of patients undergoing radical vulvectomy between January 1, 1986, and September 1, 1989, were reviewed for age, weight, cancer type, tumor stage, operative procedure(s), prophylactic antibiotic and its length of use, febrile morbidity, infection site, culture results, significant medical history, and length of use and number of drains or catheters used.Results: The study group was composed of 61 patients, 14 of whom underwent a radical vulvectomy and 47 who also had inguinal lymph node dissection performed. Twenty-nine patients (48%) had at least 1 postoperative infection. Five patients (8%) had 2 or more postoperative infections. The site and incidence of the infections were as follows: urinary tract 23%, wound 23%, lymphocyst 3%, lymphatics (lymphangitis) 5%, and bowel (pseudomembranous colitis) 3%. The most common pathogens isolated from both urine and wound sites were Pseudomonas aeruginosa, enterococcus, and Escherichia coli. A significant decrease in wound infection was demonstrated when separate incisions were made for inguinal lymph node dissection (P <0.05). The mean number of days to onset of postoperative infection for wound, urine, lymphatics, lymphocyst, and bowel were 11, 8, 57, 48, and 5, respectively.Conclusions: We conclude that the clinical appearance of post-radical vulvectomy infections is delayed when compared with other post-surgical wound infections. Second, utilizing separate inguinal surgical incisions may reduce infectious morbidity. Finally, tumor stage and type do not necessarily increase the infectious morbidity of radical vulvar surgery.     

Local treatment of carcinoma of the rectum

LE is a management modality offered, at present, to less than 5 per cent of all patients with carcinoma of the rectum. It is indicated, as a primary curative procedure, in the subgroup of patients with early lesions of a favorable histologic grade. It has also been used, for palliation, in patients with overt disseminated malignant disease or in patients too old or too ill, or both, to withstand a radical operation or unwilling to accept a colostomy. Various techniques have been described and can be divided into two categories: excision of the intact tumor, best suited for a curative procedure when tumor characteristics can be accurately determined, and tumor destruction therapy, more generally used for palliation. The results of local excision, compared with those of radical operations, are very good when a strict selection policy is implemented and coupled with adequate patient follow-up study.     

Operative management of early invasive epidermoid carcinoma of the vulva.

The clinical records and surgical specimens of 60 patients with squamous cancers of the vulva less than 2 cm in size (TI) were studied. Fifty-eight patients had stromal invasion 5 mm. or less in depth. Three of the 60 patients (5 per cent) had pelvic lymph node metastases; two of these three showed invasion of vascular channels; the third patient's tumor showed cellular anaplasia. In an effort to reduce patient morbidity in radical surgery for vulvar carcinoma, while achieving comparable survival data, an operative approach less radical than radical vulvectomy, inguinal dissections, and/or pelvic lymphadenectomy is proposed for selected patients.     

CO2 laser for suppurative hidradenitis of the vulva

Chronic suppurative hidradenitis is a disease of the apocrine glands occurring predominantly in the axillae of the anogenital region. Treatment, to date, has been frustrating. Prolonged antibiotic therapy and multiple incisions and drainage have been the usual form of therapy, but those surgical procedures leave patients with ugly scars; retracted, hypertrophic skin edges; and pitted, indurated and disfiguring abscesses. The only successful treatment to date has been wide excision of the entire apocrine gland-bearing tissues, such as radical vulvectomy, which often necessitates grafts to cover the surgically exposed areas. That has left patients with unsatisfactorily functioning vaginas and a mutilated appearance. Recently we instituted the use of the CO2 laser to treat these patients with the goal of eradicating the suppurative sinus tracts and the infected apocrine glands without removing large volumes of adjacent, unaffected tissue. Over the past eight years we treated 11 patients who had extensive, chronic hidradenitis of the anogenital area with the CO2 laser. The use of laser therapy for these patients has produced effective and less-mutilating results. Such treatment has been a successful option for treating this debilitating disease.     

Morbidity and recurrence with modifications of radical vulvectomy and groin dissection.

Vulvar carcinoma has been managed in recent years with modifications of radical vulvectomy and groin dissection. Separate groin incisions, superficial inguinal lymphadenectomy, unilateral groin dissection, and wide excision have been utilized to reduce the morbidity of treatment. In this study, the surgical management of 82 patients with vulvar squamous cell carcinoma was reviewed in order to assess morbidity and risk of recurrence. A modification of radical vulvectomy and groin dissection was employed in 67 patients, while 15 patients underwent classical en-bloc vulvar and groin dissection. Wound complications of the vulva occurred in 1 of 12 patients undergoing hemivulvectomy, in 8 of 55 undergoing radical vulvectomy, and in 7 of 15 who had en-bloc vulvar resection and groin dissection (P = 0.01). Among the 46 patients undergoing bilateral groin dissection through separate incisions, groin breakdown, lymphocyst, and lymphedema occurred in 10 (22%), 7 (15%), and 7 (15%), versus 0, 1 (7%), and 2 (13%) of the 15 who had unilateral groin dissection. Modification of vulvar resection did not increase the risk of local recurrence. Groin recurrence developed in 2 of 15 patients who underwent en-bloc groin dissection and in 1 of 46 who underwent bilateral groin dissection through separate incisions. Two of 15 who had a unilateral groin dissection recurred in the contralateral groin. The risk of recurrence as well as morbidity following modifications of radical vulvectomy with groin dissection should be considered when planning treatment.