Role of the thymus in transplantation tolerance in miniature swine: V. Deficiency of the graft-to-thymus pathway of tolerance induction in recipients of cardiac transplants

BACKGROUND: We have previously shown that both thymic immigrants (graft to thymus pathway) and thymic emigrants (thymus to graft pathway) are involved in tolerance to renal allografts in miniature swine treated with a short course of calcineurin inhibitors. This study investigates the role of these pathways in cardiac transplant survival in recipients treated with a short course of tacrolimus. METHODS: Eleven animals received two-haplotype fully MHC-mismatched cardiac grafts with a 12-day course of tacrolimus. Recipients were thymectomized on day -21 (n=5) or day 0 (n=3), or were left euthymic (n=3). Two of the day -21 thymectomized animals received a day 0 host-MHC matched thymocyte infusion. RESULTS: Euthymic recipients of cardiac grafts treated with an immunosuppressive regimen identical to that previously shown to induce tolerance in euthymic recipients of renal allografts all rejected their grafts. Although no animal became tolerant, animals that were euthymic or thymectomized on day 0, as well as recipients of day 0 host-type thymocyte infusions following thymectomy on day -21, developed donor-specific hyporesponsiveness and maintained their cardiac grafts for markedly prolonged periods. In contrast, all animals thymectomized on day -21 that did not receive thymocyte infusions developed strong antidonor CTL responses and rejected their grafts by day 35. CONCLUSIONS: The graft-to-thymus pathway that plays an important role in tolerance induction to renal allografts appears to be relatively deficient in recipients of cardiac grafts. Strategies to increase donor antigen migration to the host thymus might therefore assist in tolerance induction to cardiac allografts.     

Irradiation before and donor splenocyte infusion immediately after transplantation induce tolerance to lung,but not heart allografts in miniature swine

Solid organs may differ in their potential to induce and maintain a state of donor‐specific tolerance. Previously, we induced stable immunological tolerance in a lung transplantation model in miniature swine. Here, we wished to transfer this established protocol into a heart transplantation model in miniature swine. Heterotopic heart transplantation (HTX) was performed in four and left‐sided lung transplantation (LTX) in seven minipigs from gender‐ and SLA‐mismatched donors. All recipients received nonmyeloablative irradiation, donor splenocyte infusion and intravenous pharmacologic immunosuppression for 28 postoperative days. All transplanted hearts were rejected within 95 days. In contrast, four animals of the LTX group developed stable tolerance surviving beyond 500 days, and three further animals rejected 119, 239 and 360 days post‐transplantation. In both groups, peripheral blood donor leucocyte chimerism peaked 1 h after reperfusion of the allograft. Importantly, the early chimerism level in the LTX group was significantly higher compared to the HTX group and remained detectable throughout the entire observation period. In conclusion, lungs and hearts vary in their potential to induce a state of tolerance after transplantation in a protocol with pre‐operative recipient irradiation and donor splenocyte co‐transplantation. This could be due to differential early levels of passenger leucocyte chimerism.     

Spontaneous acceptance or rejection of orthotopic liver transplants in outbred and partially inbred miniature swine.

BACKGROUND: Results of clinical liver transplantation have shown that rejection and loss of human liver allografts occurs despite immunosuppression. Because genetic disparity and liver immunogenicity remain a matter of controversy, we reexamined the fate of outbred liver allografts without immunosuppression and used partially inbred miniature swine, in which the genetics of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens have been characterized and can be controlled. METHODS: Orthotopic liver transplantation was performed between pairs of outbred domestic farm pigs and between pairs of inbred miniature swine with genetically defined major histocompatibility (SLA) loci. A passive splenic and vena caval to jugular vein shunt with systemic heparinization prevented hypotension during the anhepatic phase. Immunological responses were monitored by mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC), CML, skin graft rejection, liver biopsies, and serial serum chemistries. RESULTS: Median survival of technically successful liver allografts between pairs of outbred pigs (n=20) was 38 days and between partially inbred swine matched at the SLA locus (n=17) was 79 days. MLC responsiveness did not correlate with the development of rejection. Five of 20 (25%) outbred pigs and 6 of 17 (35%) MHC matched inbred miniature swine survived more than 100 days. In the long-term survivors, donor, but not third party, MHC matched skin graft survival times were prolonged. In contrast, all SLA-mismatched inbred recipients (n=26) died rapidly from massive liver rejection, with a median survival time of 9 days. In these rejecting animals, the marked MLC responsiveness to donor lymphocytes evident pretransplant diminished rapidly after transplantation, but an undiminished PHA responsiveness and a blunted third party MLC response persisted. CONCLUSION: The length of survival and the degree and incidence of rejection were similar in outbred pigs and in SLA-matched inbred miniature pigs, indicating that the outbred animals were, therefore, probably closely related and shared relevant genes. However, survival was significantly shortened and liver allograft rejection was accelerated in SLA-mismatched inbred swine. These results indicate that major histocompatibility differences play an important role in the rejection of liver allografts, as is true for other vascularized grafts in the unimmunosuppressed recipient. The development of liver allograft rejection across non-MHC differences is variable and, when present, appears to be a chronic process.     

Skin-specific alloantigens in miniature swine

BACKGROUND: The acceptance of skin allografts has historically been among the most challenging problems in the field of transplantation, attributed, at least in part, to the existence of antigens expressed by skin but not by other tissues. Many studies have suggested the existence of skin-specific antigens in rodents, but data in large-animal models are more limited. METHODS: We have recently developed protocols for attaining stable mixed hematopoietic chimerism in miniature swine, using MHC-matched donors and recipients. We have now assessed tolerance to donor-derived skin and cardiac allografts in these chimeric animals. RESULTS: Skin-graft rejection was seen in four of six animals receiving skin grafts taken from the respective hematopoietic donors. In the other two animals, donor-derived skin grafts survived indefinitely. No cardiac-allograft rejection was observed in mixed-chimeric animals that received heart transplants from their hematopoietic donors, even in animals that had already rejected skin allografts from the same donors. In all animals assessed, in vitro hyporesponsiveness to donor hematopoietic cells persisted. CONCLUSION: These findings support the concept that skin expresses immunogenic alloantigens that either are not expressed or are not immunogenic in cardiac or hematopoietic tissue.     

Detection of regulatory cells as an assay for allograft tolerance in miniature swine.

BACKGROUND: There is currently a great need for an in vitro assay to assess the presence of tolerance following allotransplantation to determine whether immunosuppressive medications can be discontinued. Our laboratory has recently developed an assay involving coculture inhibition of cell-mediated lympholysis that correlates with tolerance to allografts in swine leukocyte antigen (SLA) Class I-mismatched miniature swine. The potential for clinical application of this assay may depend on 2 important factors: (1) whether the assay can be used in the presence of immunosuppression; and (2) whether frozen-stored naive responder cells can be utilized. METHODS: Long-term tolerant MGH miniature swine that had accepted SLA Class I-mismatched kidney transplants after a 12-day course of cyclosporine or tacrolimus were studied. Two long-term tolerant and 2 naive control animals were treated with a clinically relevant dose of cyclosporine for 2 weeks (trough level 100 to 400 ng/ml) to simulate the ongoing "chronic" immunosuppression used in human recipients of allografts. Cells from tolerant or naive, recipient-matched animals were stimulated for 6 days with donor or third-party SLA. These primed cells were then cocultured with naive unstimulated recipient major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-matched responders and irradiated stimulators. Responder cells were tested both fresh and frozen. RESULTS: Suppression of cytotoxic responses of naive responder cells was observed in all coculture assays using cells from tolerant animals primed against donor antigen in vitro, but not in assays using similarly primed cells from naive animals. Responder cells from tolerant animals receiving immunosuppression had a suppressive activity similar to that from cells of the same animals not receiving immunosuppression. Similar suppression was also observed in coculture assays using either fresh or frozen naive responder cells. CONCLUSIONS: This coculture assay appears to correlate with the presence of tolerance under conditions applicable to the clinical setting. The assay appears to identify peripheral regulatory mechanisms of tolerance in allogeneic transplant recipients, and therefore may provide an approach for determining an appropriate timepoint at which to test withdrawal of immunosuppressive medications.     

Acceptance reaction: intragraft events associated with tolerance to renal allografts in miniature swine

Inbred miniature swine that are treated for 12 d with a high dose of cyclosporin A develop tolerance to MHC class II matched, class I-mismatched renal allografts. The aim of this study was to clarify the intrarenal allograft events associated with the development of tolerance in this protocol. Morphologic and immunologic studies were performed in serial biopsies from accepting grafts after 12 d of cyclosporin A treatment (n = 4) and were compared with those from untreated control rejecting grafts (n = 4). In accepting grafts with stable function, a transient interstitial infiltrate developed. The cellular infiltrate had many similarities to that in rejecting grafts; both had T cells and macrophages, similar proportions of T-cell subsets, and a similar frequency of in situ nick end labeling (TUNEL)+ apoptotic infiltrating cells. However, the cellular infiltrate in the acceptance reaction was distinguished by less T-cell activation (interleukin-2 receptor+), less proliferation (proliferating cell nuclear antigen+) of infiltrating cells, and less graft cell apoptosis in arteries, tubules, glomeruli, and peritubular capillaries. Thereafter, the infiltrate in the accepting grafts progressively resolved with decreased cell proliferation, activation, and apoptotic graft parenchymal cell injury, but the high frequency of apoptosis persisted in graft-infiltrating cells. In parallel to the intragraft events, donor-specific unresponsiveness developed as assessed by cell-mediated cytotoxicity by blood mononuclear cells in vitro. In conclusion, the acceptance reaction in transplanted grafts is characterized by progressive resolution of T-cell proliferation and activation and of cell-mediated graft injury, as well as prolonged T-cell apoptosis. These intragraft events suggest that both T-cell anergy and T-cell deletion occur in the graft during the development of tolerance. Some of the described immunopathologic findings (activation, proliferation, apoptosis) may be useful in distinguishing acceptance from rejection, as well as in predicting later graft acceptance in tolerance induction protocols.     

Role of the thymus in transplantation tolerance in miniature swine. III. Surgical manipulation of the thymus interferes with stable induction of tolerance to class I-mismatched renal allografts

BACKGROUND: Previous studies have demonstrated that long-term tolerance of class I mismatched renal allografts in miniature swine is induced by a short course of cyclosporine (CyA), and that a total thymectomy 21 days before transplantation abrogates the induction of stable tolerance. We have now examined the effects of surgical manipulation of the thymus, with or without a reduction in the thymic volume, on the induction of tolerance. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Miniature swine receiving a transplant of a class I-mismatched renal allograft and 12 days of CyA underwent either (1) a partial thymectomy 21 days before kidney transplantation (day -21), (2) serial thymic biopsies (to evaluate the effect of surgical trauma and reduction in volume of the thymus) or serial incisions of the thymus thymus (to evaluate the effect of surgical trauma without changes in thymic volume), (3) a sham thymectomy on day -21, or serial sham thymic surgery on the same POD as the thymic biopsies and incisions (control animals). RESULTS: Control animals had a stable plasma creatinine, had donor-specific unresponsiveness in cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) assays, had absence of rejection in kidney biopsy specimens, and did not develop anti-donor class I immunoglobulin (Ig)G alloantibodies. Animals undergoing a partial thymectomy on day -21 or serial thymic biopsies showed severe renal dysfunction, histological evidence of rejection in kidney biopsy specimens and anti-donor reactivity in CML assays; all but one animal developed anti-donor class I IgG alloantibodies. Serial incisions of the thymus induced an increase in plasma creatinine and histological rejection in 1 of 3 animals and anti-donor cytotoxic T cells in vitro in all 3 animals. CONCLUSIONS: A partial thymectomy or serial thymic biopsies markedly interfere with the induction of tolerance to renal allografts. Serial thymic incisions also interfere with the induction of tolerance, but to a lesser degree. These studies may have implications for tolerance-inducing protocols that involve thymic manipulation.     

Viral interleukin-10 gene therapy to induce tolerance to solid organ transplants in mice

In this study, a novel gene therapy approach to prolong allograft survival was designed. Autologous (syngeneic) hematopoietic stem cell-enriched bone marrow cells (HSC; lin(-)) engineered with the vIL-10 gene (vIL-10-HSC) were injected (4 to 6 x 10(6) cells, i.v.) into lethally (9.5 Gy) or sublethally (4 Gy) irradiated CBA/J mice 6 weeks prior to allogeneic heart (C57BL/6) transplantation (Tx). Cardiac allograft survival was significantly (P <.004) prolonged in lethally (71 +/- 40 days) and sublethally (114 +/- 15 days) irradiated mice that received vIL-10-HSC compared to controls that received no HSC (11 +/- 1 days), unengineered HSC, or vector-DNA-engineered HSC (12 to 16 days). Tolerant graft histopathology demonstrated mild arteritis/venulitis (grade 0.7) and rejection (grade 1.0). Intragraft expression of costimulatory molecules (B7.1, B7.2), cytokines (IL-2, IL-4, mIL-10, IFN-gamma), and iNOS molecules were markedly lower in tolerant grafts that survived for >100 days; recipient T lymphocytes demonstrated hyporeactivity to donor and third-party antigens in mixed lymphocyte cultures. These findings have important implications and potential therapeutic applications in transplantation and autoimmune diseases.     

Successful induction of long-term specific tolerance to fully allogeneic renal allografts in miniature swine.

Major histocompatibility complex class II matching is of overwhelming importance for achieving tolerance to kidney transplants (KTX) in miniature swine. When class II antigens are matched, long-term specific tolerance across complete MHC class I antigen barriers can uniformly be induced by a 12-day perioperative course of cyclosporine. This same regimen is ineffective in fully MHC-mismatched combinations. We hypothesized that initial induction of tolerance to kidney donor class II antigens by bone marrow transplantation might allow tolerance to be induced to a subsequent fully allogeneic KTX in combination with CsA therapy. We report here the results of such fully allogeneic KTX performed in 4 recipients of prior single-haplotype class II-mismatched BMT. All animals received KTX from donors class II matched to the BMT donor and received a 12-day course of intravenous CsA (10 mg/kg/day). All four animals have maintained normal serum creatinine values (less than 2.0 mg/dl) for greater than 200 days posttransplant. Specific hyporesponsiveness to both BMT and KTX donor-type MHC antigens was found in mixed lymphocyte culture and cell-mediated lympholysis assays. Compared with third-party grafts, significantly prolonged survival of BMT donor-specific (P = 0.031) and KTX donor-specific (P = 0.031) skin grafts was observed. These results demonstrate that induction of tolerance to class II antigens by BMT allows a short course of CsA to induce specific tolerance to fully allogeneic renal allografts.     

Induction of specific tolerance to class I-disparate renal allografts in miniature swine with cyclosporine.

Previous studies in miniature swine have suggested that the mechanism underlying the spontaneous development of tolerance in one third of one-haplotype class I disparate renal allografts (i.e., ag----ad) involves a relative T cell help deficit at the time of first exposure to antigen. If this hypothesis were correct, then one might expect the administration of an immunosuppressive agent capable of inhibiting lymphokine production during this period to lead to the induction of tolerance to class I MHC antigens in two-haplotype class I mismatched renal allografts (i.e., gg----dd), which are otherwise uniformly and acutely rejected. This hypothesis was tested in eight two-haplotype class I disparate, class II matched donor-recipient pairs, in which recipients were treated with cyclosporine 10 mg/kg, i.v. q.d. for 12 days. This protocol led to the induction of long-term (greater than 100 days) specific tolerance in 100% of recipients, as compared with control animals that rejected grafts in 13.7 +/- 0.9 days (P less than 0.0001). The specificity of tolerance was assessed both in vivo with subsequent skin grafts and in vitro by mixed lymphocyte response (MLR) and cell-mediated lymphocytotoxicity (CML). Survival of donor-specific skin grafts was prolonged compared with skin grafts bearing third-party class I antigens (19.5 +/- 2.0 versus 11.5 +/- 2.0 days, n = 4, P less than 0.05). Tolerant recipients had markedly diminished or absent anti-donor MLR and CML responses, but maintained normal reactivity to third party. Four of eight CsA-treated recipients showed detectable levels of anti-donor IgM, while none demonstrated the presence of anti-donor IgG, which was found in all rejecting controls.     

Induction of transplantation tolerance with a short course of tacrolimus (FK506): I. Rapid and stable tolerance to two-haplotype fully mhc-mismatched kidney allografts in miniature swine

BACKGROUND: Inbred miniature swine provide a large animal model in which the effects of selective major histocompatibility complex (MHC) matching can be reproducibly studied. We have previously demonstrated that although a 12-day course of cyclosporine uniformly induces tolerance to class I-mismatched renal allografts, it does not induce tolerance across full MHC barriers. In this study, we assessed whether and at what dose tacrolimus might permit allografts to induce tolerance across different MHC barriers. METHODS: Recipients of MHC disparate renal allografts were treated with a 12-day course of tacrolimus by continuous intravenous infusion. Groups were divided as follows: (1) class I-mismatched kidneys with 0.3 mg/kg/day tacrolimus (n=3); (2) fully MHC-mismatched kidneys with 0.3 mg/kg/day tacrolimus (n=2); and (3) fully MHC-mismatched kidneys with 0.12-0.16 mg/kg/day tacrolimus (n=4). RESULTS: In groups 1 and 2, recipients with tacrolimus levels of 45-80 ng/ml accepted renal allografts long-term with stable renal function. Donor-specific hyporesponsiveness was demonstrated by cell-mediated lymphocytotoxicity and mixed lymphocyte response, and subsequent donor-matched grafts were also accepted, without further immunosuppression (n=4), confirming systemic tolerance. In group 3, recipients that achieved tacrolimus levels of 35 ng/ml (n=2) accepted their grafts without chronic changes, whereas recipients with levels of 20-26 ng/ml (n=2) developed chronic allograft glomerulopathy, suggesting 35 ng/ml as the threshold blood level for tolerance induction. In vitro assays demonstrated that peripheral blood lymphocytes from tolerant animals produced inhibitory cytokines, suggesting the involvement of regulatory mechanisms. CONCLUSIONS: To our knowledge, this study represents the first demonstration of the induction of transplant tolerance across a two-haplotype full MHC barrier with a short course of immunosuppression in a large animal model. These studies may also have clinical applicability, because the time course required to induce tolerance was sufficiently short that the high drug levels required might be expected to be tolerated clinically with only transient toxicity.     

Transplantation in miniature swine. VIII. Recombination within the major histocompatibility complex of miniature swine

Offspring of heterozygous parents derived from three herds of miniature swine, each of which is homozygous at the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), were screened for recombination within the MHC. The swine were typed serologically at weaning and later typed by mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). Two intra-MHC recombinants were discovered, both of which involved the exchange of D region specificities without apparent dissociation of ABC region specificities, confirming the localization of the SLA-D region outside of the SLA-ABC regions. The first recombinant was the offspring of an SLAc/d (cd) by dd mating and typed serologically as cd but typed by MLR as dd. The second recombinant was the offspring of a cd by cd mating. It typed serologically as cc but stimulated cc in one-way MLR and retained its reactivity to dd, thus suggesting a possible recombination within the D region. Sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) analysis of 3H-leucine-labeled lymphocyte surface antigens demonstrated that corresponding Ia antigens were also exchanged during these recombinant events supporting the hypothesis that genes coding for Ia antigens are identical or closely linked to D region genes encoding the MLR specificities.