Effects of pubovaginal sling procedure on patients with urethral hypermobility and intrinsic sphincteric deficiency: would they do it again?

OBJECTIVE: This study was undertaken to assess the cure rate of stress urinary incontinence, long-term effects on other lower urinary tract symptoms, and quality of life in a cohort of patients who underwent pubovaginal sling procedures for treatment of incontinence related to intrinsic sphincteric deficiency and urethral hypermobility. STUDY DESIGN: This was a retrospective analysis of 57 patients with 90% follow-up who underwent pubovaginal autologous fascial sling procedures for stress urinary incontinence related to urethral hypermobility and intrinsic sphincteric deficiency. Objective postoperative urodynamic evaluation was performed in 34 (60%) of the cases. Telephone interviews to assess quality-of-life parameters were performed in all cases. RESULTS: The mean follow-up period was 42 months and the median follow-up period was 34 months, with a range of 0.5 to 134 months. The age at the time of the sling procedure ranged from 18 to 84 years, with a median parity of 3.0 (range, 0-6). Preoperative body mass index ranged from 19.5 to 39.1 kg/m(2). Five percent of patients had detrusor instability before the operation. Forty-one percent (41%) of the patients who underwent postoperative urodynamic evaluation had voiding dysfunction. The postoperative objective cure rate for stress urinary incontinence was 97%. Of all patients 88% indicated that the sling had improved the quality of life, 84% indicated that the sling relieved the incontinence in the long-term, and 82% would choose to undergo the procedure again. CONCLUSION: Construction of a pubovaginal sling is an effective technique for relief of severe stress urinary incontinence. Voiding dysfunction is a common side effect. Despite this problem, a significant number of patients would elect to undergo the procedure again.     

The effects of severe cystocele on urogynecologic symptoms and findings

BACKGROUND: To evaluate the effects of severe cystocele on lower urinary tract function. METHODS: Urogynecologic evaluation composed of patient questionnaire, urinary diary, pad test, Q-tip test, perineal ultrasonography and cystometry was performed on 60 patients with reducible grade III or IV cystocele before and after reduction of the prolapsed organs. The data were analyzed by Paired-t and Chi-square tests and Pearson's correlation analysis. RESULTS: One-hour pad test revealed that 17 (28.3%) of the 60 patients with reducible severe cystocele had no demonstrable urinary incontinence, while 26 (43.3%) had mild and 17 (28.3%) had moderate or severe incontinence. However, all patients had moderate or severe incontinence after reduction with vaginal packing (p<0.001). The vaginal packing had no significant effect on the maximum bladder capacity, the intravesical pressure at maximum capacity and the frequency of detrusor instability (33.3%). Whereas, urine loss after 1-hour pad test, bladder neck mobility, straining Q-tip angle and PUVA increased significantly after reduction of the cystocele (p<0.01). CONCLUSIONS: As grade III or IV cystocele may mask the presence and severity of urinary stress incontinence, preoperative urogynecological evaluation should be done after reduction of the cystocele.     

Burch procedure compared with sling for stress urinary incontinence: a decision analysis

OBJECTIVE: To compare the relative risks and benefits of Burch colposuspension and sling procedure for primary genuine stress urinary incontinence in women. METHODS: We developed a decision analytic model to compare Burch procedure and sling for primary surgical treatment of genuine stress incontinence with urethral hypermobility in women. Risks and benefits were estimated from published literature. The main outcome measure was effectiveness of treatment, defined as cure of incontinence after initial and secondary treatments. We considered four outcomes of primary surgical treatment: cure, persistent incontinence (either caused by intrinsic sphincter deficiency without urethral hypermobility or genuine stress incontinence with hypermobility), de novo detrusor instability, and permanent urinary retention. Secondary treatment included repeated surgery for genuine stress incontinence, collagen injection for intrinsic sphincter deficiency, medical treatment for detrusor instability, and urethrolysis for retention. One-way sensitivity analyses were used to estimate the effect of varying each characteristic through its range; all other characteristics were fixed at their baseline values. RESULTS: The overall effectiveness of Burch and sling operations (percentages of women cured after initial and secondary treatments) was similar (94.8% and 95.3%, respectively). In sensitivity analyses, the Burch arm of the model was more effective than sling when the risk of retention after sling was higher than 9.0% or when the risk of de novo detrusor instability after sling was higher than 10.3%. Conversely, when the risk of de novo detrusor instability after Burch was higher than 6.8%, the sling arm of the model was more effective. CONCLUSION: The Burch and sling procedures are similarly effective for primary surgical treatment of genuine stress incontinence in women. Overall effectiveness is substantially influenced by relative rates of complications.     

Use of a pedicled rectus abdominis muscle flap sling in the treatment of complicated stress urinary incontinence

OBJECTIVE: A pedicled rectus muscle flap sling in the treatment of complicated stress urinary incontinence was evaluated. STUDY DESIGN: Thirty-two women underwent a combined vaginal and abdominal sling operation for stress incontinence with a pedicled muscle flap developed from the rectus abdominis muscle. All operations were performed jointly by the same two surgeons. The procedure involved transecting one rectus abdominis muscle just above its first tendinous intersection and isolating the muscle as a flap on its inferior vascular pedicle. The muscle flap was then swung beneath the urethra and bladder neck, pulled into the retropubic space on the contralateral side, and sewn to the obturator internus fascia or to Cooper's ligament. All patients undergoing the procedure had demonstrable stress incontinence on physical examination and underwent preoperative fluoroscopic video urodynamics. The diagnosis of complicated stress incontinence was based on the presence of one or more of the following factors: previous failed antiincontinence surgery (33 operations in 22 patients, average 1.5 operations), open vesical neck on fluoroscopy (14 patients), urethral closure pressure ≤30 cm H₂O by the Brown-Wickham technique (16 patients), or massive vaginal prolapse and demonstrable stress incontinence with the prolapse reduced and the urethra supported in a normal position (16 patients). Follow-up ranged from 2 to 13 months (average 6 months). Surgical outcome was assessed by physical examination and a detailed telephone interview conducted by a physician who was not involved in the operations. RESULTS: Twenty-eight patients (87.5%) were satisfied with the results of the operation. There were four surgical failures (12.5%). Stress incontinence persisted in three patients after surgery, and one patient who had mixed incontinence before surgery was cured of stress incontinence but continued to have significant urinary leakage as a result of detrusor overactivity. There appears to be less voiding dysfunction with this technique than with other sling procedures for stress incontinence. CONCLUSIONS: The sling procedure with a rectus abdominis muscle flap appears to be a viable surgical technique in the treatment of complicated stress incontinence. Further study is needed to assess the long-term results of this operation and to evaluate its proper place in reconstructive pelvic surgery. (Am J Obstet Gynecol 1996;175:1460-6.)     

Patient characteristics that are associated with urodynamically diagnosed detrusor instability and genuine stress incontinence

OBJECTIVE: We sought to compare characteristics of patients with urodynamically diagnosed detrusor instability or genuine stress incontinence. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective audit of 293 consecutive women who were referred to a urogynecologist for evaluation of urinary incontinence between June 1996 and April 2000. RESULTS: Of the 293 patients, 289 women had a physical examination and urodynamic testing, which revealed genuine stress incontinence (35%), detrusor instability (32%), mixed incontinence (29%), or normal urodynamic function (4%). Compared with patients with detrusor instability, those women with genuine stress incontinence were more likely to be white than African American (P <.0001) and to have a cystocele(P =.027), rectocele (P <.0001), or paravaginal defect (P =.004). No differences in age, gravidity, parity, estrogen treatment, or previous anti-incontinence procedure were identified between women with detrusor instability and women with genuine stress incontinence. CONCLUSION: In a tertiary referral center, the distribution of urinary incontinence is evenly divided among genuine stress incontinence, detrusor instability, and mixed incontinence. Patients with genuine stress incontinence are more likely to be white and to have pelvic floor prolapse and symptoms of pure stress incontinence.     

Experience with Silastic Slings for Female Urinary Incontinence

Between September 1, 1985 and December 31, 1987, 54 patients with stress urinary incontinence were treated with a reinforced silastic sling using an abdominovaginal approach; 42 patients were cured, two improved and nine were the same or worse. Five patients who are continent required periodic intermittent self-catheterization. Eight patients developed detrusor instability postoperatively. One patient had to have the sling removed due to a persistent sinus. Fifteen patients had to have the sling adjusted.     

Prevalence of faecal incontinence among women with urinary incontinence

Four hundred and sixty-five women attending a urodynamic clinic were interviewed, and completed a detailed bowel questionnaire, about their urinary and bowel symptoms. All the women underwent video-cystourethrography with pressure and flow studies. The reported incidence of faecal incontinence was 15.3% (   n = 71  ) on direct questioning and 26% 0(  n = 121  ) on the postal questionnaire. Faecal incontinence was more common in women with a urodynamic diagnosis of detrusor instability (30'%1 (   n = 26  )) than among women diagnosed as having genuine stress incontinence (21% (   n = 38  )). Denervation and myogenic injuries sustained during childbirth have been suggested as a common cause for genuine stress and faecal incontinence, but there may be an alternative mechanism to explain why women with detrusor instability suffer from faecal incontinence.     

An Inexpensive Polypropylene Patch Sling for Treatment of Intrinsic Sphincteric Deficiency

Study ObjectiveTo evaluate an inexpensive polypropylene sling in patients with intrinsic sphincteric deficiency (ISD).DesignCase series (Canadian Task Force classification II-2).SettingCleveland Clinic Florida teaching hospital.PatientsAnalysis of 161 patients with ISD who underwent a surgeon-assembled polypropylene (Prolene) patch sling procedure.InterventionPolypropylene patch sling surgery was performed in all study patients with urinary stress incontinence due to ISD.Measurements and Main ResultsAll patients underwent urogynecologic evaluation including multichannel urodynamics. Outcome measures included a standardized stress test, patient-reported cure rate, surgical complications, and postoperative voiding dysfunction. Medical records for the 161 patients who underwent the procedure were available for review. Mean patient age was 62.4 years. Twenty-five patients (16%) had concomitant detrusor overactivity. Mean follow-up was 3.6 years. The stress test yielded negative findings in 93.4% of patients. Complete continence was reported by 80.3% of patients, and marked improvement by 7%. The estimated cost of the sling was $17 to $272, depending on the materials used. Two patients experienced urinary retention requiring urethrolysis. Three required sling revision because of healing problems.ConclusionUse of a polypropylene patch sling is an effective treatment for ISD and is less expensive than currently available sling kits.     

Midurethral Tissue Fixation System sling -- a 'micromethod' for cure of stress incontinence -- preliminary report

AIMS: To assess the effectiveness of the Tissue Fixation System (TFS) in patients with stress incontinence. The TFS uses two small plastic anchors to fix an (adjustable) midurethral polypropylene mesh sling into the soft tissues below the pubic bone. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Thirty-six patients with stress incontinence, mean age 55 (35-87), mean weight 76 kg (33-117 kg), mean 0.8 previous operations for stress incontinence, underwent a TFS midurethral sling operation. The patients were preoperatively assessed with a structured questionnaire, 24-h urinary diary, cough stress test, transperineal ultrasound, and urodynamics. Using the TFS delivery system, a midurethral mesh tape was attached to the fibromuscular tissues behind the perineal membrane. The suburethral vaginal fascia was also tightened. Post-operatively. the patients were reviewed at 6 weeks, and at 3-monthly intervals with ultrasound, and cough stress tests. RESULTS: Primary symptomatic cure rate at mean 9 months (3-15 months) was 83.4% (n = 36). Pad test loss decreased from a mean 12.7 g to a mean of 0.2 g; mean operating time was 5 min, and mean hospital stay was 24 h (12-48 h). There were no cases of obstructed micturition, and minimal analgesia only was required postoperatively. CONCLUSION: The TFS is a promising new method. The results at this stage are similar to those achieved previously with the 'tension-free' tape operations, but with greater safety and shorter operating time. Testing by other surgeons will be required to evaluate this method further.     

The fascia lata suburethral sling for treating recurrent urinary stress incontinence

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of the fascia lata suburethral sling procedure in the treatment of recurrent genuine urinary stress incontinence. STUDY DESIGN: This study was a retrospective analysis of 60 patients who had a suburethral fascia lata sling placement between January 1992 and December 1995. Follow-up ranged from 6 months to 3.5 years. The database was obtained by a retrospective chart review, a written questionnaire, and telephone interview. RESULTS: Between January 1992 and December 1995, 72 patients who had at least one previous incontinence procedure were assessed by urodynamic testing and cystourethroscopic examination before undergoing a fascia lata sling placement. Of this population, 60 were available for follow-up. Of this 60, 54, or 90%, had complete cure or marked improvement in the urinary incontinence. There were six failures, two of which had no bladder neck mobility and two of which had detrusor instability and were unable to take medication because of medical contraindications. In addition, two slings were sacrificed because of postoperative complications. The most common postoperative complication was urinary retention, which resulted in eight, or 13.4%, of slings needing to be released. CONCLUSION: Our data support the use of the suburethral fascia lata sling as an effective method for the treatment of recurrent genuine urinary stress incontinence, with urinary retention being the most common postoperative complication.(Am J Obstet Gynecol 1997;177:6)     

Repair of prolapse with vaginal sacrocolporectopexy: technique and results

OBJECTIVE: Axis and support of the vagina can be restored by sacrocolporectopexy with preservation of coital function. We developed a new technique of transvaginal sacrocolporectopexy for patients with prolapse of uterus and vagina or prolapse of the vaginal vault. STUDY DESIGN: During a 4-year period, 20 patients with vaginal vault prolapse and 83 patients with uterine and vaginal prolapse underwent transvaginal sacrocolporectopexy. Intra- and postoperative complications were recorded. After a mean follow-up period of 24 months (6-48), the result of surgery with respect to prolapse, incontinence, and sexuality was evaluated by patient interviews. RESULTS: No serious perioperative complications occurred with the exception of one patient with bleeding from a presacral vein. Subjectively, 84 patients (82%) were cured of prolapse symptoms. One patient had recurrent grade II vault prolapse and four patients developed a grade II rectocele. Five patients developed urge incontinence grade I. One patient developed fecal incontinence. No patient had coital problems as a sequelae of sacrocolporectopexy. CONCLUSION: Transvaginal sacrocolporectopexy is a safe procedure with a success rate comparable to sacrospinous fixation.     

Clinical and urodynamic assessment of the porcine dermis bladder sling in the treatment of genuine stress incontinence

Fifty women, aged between 37 and 76 years, underwent a bladder sling operation for urinary incontinence using porcine dermis. All patients had undergone previous unsuccessful vaginal surgery for genuine stress incontinence and had stable bladders. Thirty-nine patients (78%) were made continent of urine, both subjectively and on urodynamic testing.     

Is osteitis pubis associated with the use of bone anchors in urinary continence operations?

We studied 130 patients who underwent either a vaginal needle suspension procedure or a pubofascial sling procedure with Mitek titanium bone anchors to determine the association of osteitis pubis with bone anchoring in these procedures. Fifteen patients complained of postoperative suprapubic pain; five cases were due to wound infections and another five were associated with tying the suspension sutures too tightly. We suggest the use of the term 'periostitis pubis' to describe the remaining five patients who suffered suprapubic pain. We found no radiological evidence of osteitis pubis in any patients.     

Detrusor instability--an important but underestimated factor in urinary incontinence in women

157 consecutive female patients complaining of urinary incontinence were studied by history and urodynamics. 21 of them (13.4%) demonstrated urge-incontinence due to severe detrusor instability, 20 (12.7%) showed mixed (both urge and stress) incontinence, 14 (9%) only detrusor instability and 12 (7.6%)--stress incontinence accompanied by detrusor instability. Pure stress incontinence was diagnosed in 79 cases (50.3%) while 11 patients (7%) manifested no abnormality during the urodynamics. A total of 67 patients (42.7%) showed urodynamic evidence of detrusor overactivity. In 55 (35% of the studied subjects) it was the main urodynamic finding. The prevalence of detrusor instability was higher among those with recurrent incontinence and was the highest (60%) among the women with more than one previous operations. When urge incontinence was present it occurred at detrusor pressures lower than the maximum urethral closure pressure, which implies possible failure of the sphincteric mechanisms associated with detrusor instability. 14% of the women with detrusor instability did not report complaints typical for this disorder but had history of stress incontinence alone. The authors confirm the necessity of objective assessment of the lower urinary tract in all cases with history suspicious of detrusor instability as well as when surgical treatment for stress incontinence is planned.     

Pessary test to predict postoperative urinary incontinence in women undergoing hysterectomy for prolapse

OBJECTIVE: We sought to demonstrate that a positive pessary test could predict postsurgical stress urinary incontinence in women with severe pelvic organ prolapse and that performing tension-free vaginal taping (TVT) could effectively prevent its occurrence. METHODS: Among the 79 patients evaluated for severe pelvic organ prolapse without symptoms of stress urinary incontinence, all underwent meticulous urogynecologic evaluations and pessary testing. In group 1, 32 patients had positive pessary tests and underwent vaginal hysterectomy, anterior and posterior colporrhaphy, and TVT. In group 2, 47 patients (17 of whom had positive pessary tests and 30 of whom had negative pessary tests) underwent vaginal hysterectomy and anterior and posterior colporrhaphy alone. A comparison in terms of surgical outcome and clinical manifestations was made between these 2 groups of patients. RESULTS: After surgery, a small proportion of patients had de novo idiopathic detrusor overactivity (7.6%, n = 6), urinary tract infections (7.6%, n = 6), mild recurrent prolapse (5.1%, n = 4), and urinary retention (3.8%, n = 3). Eleven (64.7%) of 17 patients with positive pessary tests who did not undergo TVT had urine leakage after their hysterectomies in contrast with the 30 patients who had negative pessary test, none of whom developed symptomatic stress urinary incontinence after vaginal hysterectomy. Among the 32 patients with positive pessary tests who had TVT with their hysterectomies, 3 developed urine leakage later; the cure rate was 90.6%. CONCLUSION: Continent patients suffering from severe pelvic organ prolapse but with a positive pessary test are considered to be at high risk of developing postoperative symptomatic stress urinary incontinence. Among the patients in our medium-range study, TVT effectively prevented postsurgical urinary incontinence. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: II-1     

The triangular vaginal patch sling for stress urinary incontinence and hypermobile urethra

OBJECTIVE: We describe an alternative sling procedure that permits concomitant correction of urethral hypermobility and urinary incontinence through a single surgical exposure. STUDY DESIGN: Fifteen women with severe urinary stress incontinence and urethral hypermobility underwent a sling procedure by creation of a simple triangular patch from the anterior vaginal wall. RESULTS: The mean operative time for the vaginal sling procedure was 38 minutes (range 29 to 65 minutes) in addition to other operations. The mean postoperative hospital stay was 7.7 days (range 5 to 13 days) and all patients were routinely discharged with an indwelling Foley catheter. Spontaneous micturition occurred in 12 patients after a mean period of 25 days (range 13 to 36 days). In three cases long-term catheterization was necessary. By subjective and objective evaluations, all the patients were cured of their stress incontinence. CONCLUSION: The triangular vaginal patch with the single sutures on each side provides an alternative approach for bladder neck stabilization that may permit a more anatomic suspension of a hypermobile urethra.(Am J Obstet Gynecol 1997;177:31)     

Clinical and urodynamic assessment of the porcine dermis bladder sling in the treatment of genuine stress incontinence

Summary. Fifty women, aged between 37 and 76 years, underwent a bladder sling operation for urinary incontinence using porcine dermis. All patients had undergone previous unsuccessful vaginal surgery for genuine stress incontinence and had stable bladders. Thirty-nine patients (78%) were made continent of urine, both subjectively and on urodynamic testing.     

Delayed reaction to the Dacron buttress used in urethropexy

Eleven patients developed a delayed reaction to the Dacron buttress used in Stamey urethropexy. The reaction was characterized by pain, dyspareunia, vaginal discharge and/or bleeding, induration of the abdominal incision, vaginal granulation tissue and draining abdominal or vaginal sinus tracts. This complication occurred in 5% of the 163 patients we treated with the Stamey procedure for stress urinary incontinence. Treatment consisted of removal of the nylon suture and Dacron buttress. None of the 11 patients developed recurrent incontinence. The subjective cure rate for stress urinary incontinence was 92% using the Stamey procedure.     

Urethral sphincter morphology in women with detrusor instability.

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether sonographic urethral sphincter morphology is different in patients with detrusor instability than in those with normal urodynamic testing. METHODS: Patients from a population of women presenting for evaluation of urinary incontinence or pelvic organ prolapse underwent intraurethral ultrasonography before multichannel urodynamic testing. Maximal rhabdosphincter thickness, total urethral diameter, total urethral circumference, and longitudinal smooth muscle thickness, diameter, and circumference were measured. For patients with detrusor instability, the strength of the involuntary detrusor contraction and the bladder volume at its onset were recorded. These data were compared with information from history questionnaires and urodynamic evaluations. RESULTS: The 17 patients with detrusor instability and 16 patients with normal urodynamic testing did not differ with respect to age, vaginal parity, race, weight, body mass index, prior continence surgery, or maximal total urethral closure pressure. Patients with detrusor instability, had decreased urethral longitudinal smooth muscle thickness (3.0 +/- 0.9 mm vs 4.1 +/- 0.7 mm, P =.001), total urethral diameter (18.0 +/- 1.6 mm vs 19.4 +/- 1.4 mm, P =.01), and total urethral circumference (5.65 +/- 0.5 cm vs 6.1 +/- 0.4 cm, P =.012) compared with those with normal urodynamic tests. A linear relationship between rhabdosphincter thickness and strength of involuntary detrusor contraction was observed (r =.686, P =.002). CONCLUSION: Urethral sphincter morphology is different in patients with detrusor instability compared with those who have normal urodynamic tests. These findings provide an anatomic basis for the physiologic findings in patients with "urethrogenic" detrusor instability.