Biologic interactions between HSV-2 and HIV-1 and possible implications for HSV vaccine development

Development of a safe and effective vaccine against herpes simplex virus type 2 (HSV-2) has the potential to limit the global burden of HSV-2 infection and disease, including genital ulcer disease and neonatal herpes, and is a global sexual and reproductive health priority. Another important potential benefit of an HSV-2 vaccine would be to decrease HIV infections, as HSV-2 increases the risk of HIV-1 acquisition several-fold. Acute and chronic HSV-2 infection creates ulcerations and draws dendritic cells and activated CD4+ T cells into genital mucosa. These cells are targets for HIV entry and replication. Prophylactic HSV-2 vaccines (to prevent infection) and therapeutic vaccines (to modify or treat existing infections) are currently under development. By preventing or modifying infection, an effective HSV-2 vaccine could limit HSV-associated genital mucosal inflammation and thus HIV risk. However, a vaccine might have competing effects on HIV risk depending on its mechanism of action and cell populations generated in the genital mucosa. In this article, we review biologic interactions between HSV-2 and HIV-1, consider HSV-2 vaccine development in the context of HIV risk, and discuss implications and research needs for future HSV vaccine development.     

Meeting report: Initial World Health Organization consultation on herpes simplex virus (HSV) vaccine preferred product characteristics,March 2017

The development of vaccines against herpes simplex virus (HSV) is an important global goal for sexual and reproductive health. A key priority to advance development of HSV vaccines is the definition of preferred product characteristics (PPCs), which provide strategic guidance on World Health Organization (WHO) preferences for new vaccines, specifically from a low- and middle-income country (LMIC) perspective. To start the PPC process for HSV vaccines, the WHO convened a global stakeholder consultation in March 2017, to define the priority public health needs that should be addressed by HSV vaccines and discuss the key considerations for HSV vaccine PPCs, particularly for LMICs. Meeting participants outlined an initial set of overarching public health goals for HSV vaccines in LMICs, which are: to reduce the acquisition of HIV associated with HSV-2 infection in high HIV-prevalence populations and to reduce the burden of HSV-associated disease, including mortality and morbidity due to neonatal herpes and impacts on sexual and reproductive health. Participants also considered the role of prophylactic versus therapeutic vaccines, whether both HSV-2 and HSV-1 should be targeted, important target populations, and infection and disease endpoints for clinical trials. This article summarizes the main discussions from the consultation.     

Effects of herpes simplex virus type 2 glycoprotein vaccines and CLDC adjuvant on genital herpes infection in the guinea pig

Genital herpes simplex virus (HSV) infections are common but results from vaccine trials with HSV-2 glycoprotein D (gD) have been disappointing. We therefore compared a similar HSV gD2 vaccine, to a further truncated gD2 vaccine, to a vaccine with gD2 plus gB2 and gH2/gL2 and to a vaccine with only gB2 and gH2/gL2 in a guinea pig model of genital herpes. All vaccines were administered with cationic liposome-DNA complexes (CLDC) as an adjuvant. All vaccines significantly decreased the severity of acute genital disease and vaginal virus replication compared to the placebo group. The majority of animals in all groups developed at least one episode of recurrent disease but the frequency of recurrent disease was significantly reduced by each vaccine compared to placebo. No vaccine was significantly more protective than gD2 alone for any of the parameters described above. No vaccine decreased recurrent virus shedding. When protection against acute infection of dorsal root ganglia and the spinal cord was evaluated all vaccines decreased the per cent of animal with detectable virus and the quantity of virus but again no vaccine was significantly more protective than another. Improvements in HSV-2 vaccines may require inclusion of more T cell targets, more potent adjuvants or live virus vaccines.     

Vaccine prevents genital herpes in subgroup of women

The herpes simplex virus (HSV) type-2 vaccine studied here prevented genital herpes only in women who were seronegative for HSV-1 and HSV-2 at baseline. Ten of these women would need to be vaccinated to prevent 1 case of genital herpes. The vaccine did not prevent infection with HSV-2 in these women. It did not prevent genital herpes in women with other HSV serologic status or in men. The usefulness of this vaccine is limited by the small subgroup in which it is efficacious. Determining which women fall into this subgroup could prove costly. It is possible that asymptomatic infected persons may spread HSV more readily. Emphasis on the use of condoms and antiviral agents should still be the first line in preventing the spread of genital herpes.     

Genital herpes vaccines--cause for cautious optimism

The high prevalence of herpes simplex virus infections in many communities, its numerous serious physical and psychological complications and its importance in enhancing the transmission of HIV make this virus an obvious target for prevention by vaccination. Randomised clinical trials of only one genital herpes vaccine has shown efficacy so far. Analysis of clinical results is complicated by the difference between disease and infection, different results for males and females and the interaction between HSV-1 and HSV-2 immunity.     

Herpes simplex virus vaccines

Herpes simplex virus (HSV) infections are common and produce not only a primary infection, but also latent and recurrent infections. Therefore, the goals of a HSV vaccine are different from other vaccines. In this review, the goals of both prophylactic and therapeutic HSV vaccines are discussed and related to the immunobiology of acute and recurrent HSV infections. Next, the vaccine strategies that have been and are being evaluated for control of HSV disease are described. Current approaches take advantage of many of the modern methodologies for vaccine development. Thus, as we await final evaluations of subunit HSV glycoprotein vaccines, early phase I trails are evaluating newer vaccine approaches including DNA-based vaccines and replication-impaired viruses. The definitive HSV vaccine may await increased knowledge of the optimal viral antigen(s) and routes to induce genital tract immunity.     

Review of mathematical models of HSV-2 vaccination: Implications for vaccine development

Development of a vaccine against herpes simplex virus type 2 (HSV-2), a life-long sexually-transmitted infection (STI), would be a major step forward in improving global sexual and reproductive health. In this review, we identified published literature of dynamic mathematical models assessing the impact of either prophylactic or therapeutic HSV-2 vaccination at the population level. We compared each study’s model structure and assumptions as well as predicted vaccination impact. We examined possible causes of heterogeneity across model predictions, key gaps, and the implications of these findings for future modelling efforts. Only eight modelling studies have assessed the potential public health impact of HSV-2 vaccination, with the majority focusing on impact of prophylactic vaccines. The studies showed that even an imperfect prophylactic HSV-2 vaccine could have an important public health impact on HSV-2 incidence, and could also impact HIV indirectly in high HIV prevalence settings. Therapeutic vaccines also may provide public health benefits, though they have been explored less extensively. However, there was substantial variation in predicted population-level impact for both types of vaccine, reflecting differences in assumptions between model scenarios. Importantly, many models did not account for heterogeneity in infection rates such as by age, sex and sexual activity. Future modelling work to inform decisions on HSV vaccine development and implementation should consider cost-effectiveness, account for additional HSV-2 sequelae such as neonatal transmission, and model greater heterogeneity in infection rates between individuals, more realistic vaccine deployment, and more thorough sensitivity and uncertainty analyses.     

The HSV-1 live attenuated VC2 vaccine provides protection against HSV-2 genital infection in the guinea pig model of genital herpes

Background

Although development of an HSV vaccine is a priority there is currently no vaccine available. The recent failure of subunit vaccines suggest that presentation of more antigens via a live attenuated vaccine may be required for protection. We therefore evaluated VC2, a live attenuated HSV vaccine, engineered to be unable to enter into neuronal axons.

Current status and prospects for development of an HSV vaccine

Herpes simplex virus type 2 (HSV-2) infects 530 million people, is the leading cause of genital ulcer disease, and increases the risk of HIV-1 acquisition. Although several candidate vaccines have been promising in animal models, prophylactic and therapeutic vaccines have not been effective in clinical trials thus far. Null results from the most recent prophylactic glycoprotein D2 subunit vaccine trial suggest that we must reevaluate our approach to HSV-2 vaccine development. We discuss HSV-2 pathogenesis, immunity, and vaccine efforts to date, as well as the current pipeline of candidate vaccines and design of trials to evaluate new vaccine constructs.     

Population-level effect of potential HSV2 prophylactic vaccines on HIV incidence in sub-Saharan Africa

Herpes simplex virus type-2 (HSV2) infection increases HIV transmission. We explore the impact of a potential prophylactic HSV2 vaccination on HIV incidence in Africa using STDSIM an individual-based model. A campaign that achieved 70% coverage over 5 years with a vaccine that reduced susceptibility to HSV2 acquisition and HSV2 reactivation by 75% for 10 years, reduced HIV incidence by 30–40% after 20 years (range 4–66%). Over 20 years, in most scenarios fewer than 100 vaccinations were required to avert one HIV infection. HSV2 vaccines could have a substantial impact on HIV incidence. Intensified efforts are needed to develop an effective HSV2 vaccine.     

Reduction of recurrent HSV disease using imiquimod alone or combined with a glycoprotein vaccine

The aim of this study is to evaluate the effects of an immune modulator, imiquimod, given alone or in combination with an HSV vaccine on HSV immune responses and as immunotherapy of a genital recurrence model. After recovery from primary genital HSV infection, animals were randomized to placebo, 21 days of imiquimod plus a placebo vaccine, or 21 days of imiquimod plus an HSV-2 glycoprotein vaccine. Placebo or HSV vaccine was given in the footpad on days 16 and 37 after HSV-2 genital inoculation. Daily imiquimod or placebo was given subcutaneously in the shoulder on days 16 through 37. Genital recurrences were monitored and HSV specific NK activity, IL-2 response and ELISA antibody were assayed. For the entire 15 week observation period, imiquimod alone reduced recurrences 62.6%, while addition of HSV vaccine to imiquimod reduced recurrences 80.6% compared to placebo/placebo. The duration of significant recurrence reduction was more notable with the addition of vaccine. Imiquimod alone significantly reduced the weekly HSV recurrent disease in the first 10 weeks (53-94% reduction, mean 75.9%), as did imiquimod plus HSV-vaccine (71-98% reduction, mean 89.5%). In weeks 10-15, imiquimod alone reduced recurrences significantly only in week 10 (20-53% reduction, mean 33%), whereas the addition of vaccine extended the significant recurrence reduction to 14 weeks (44-71% reduction, mean 56.8%). The recurrence reduction is correlated to an increased HSV-induced in vitro IL-2 response and NK activity against HSV targets in treated groups. Both imiquimod and the imiquimod/vaccine combination significantly reduced genital HSV recurrences, but the combination extended the duration and extent of protection for recurrences compared to imiquimod alone. Enhanced HSV specific immune responses correlated to the protection.     

Development of a therapeutic vaccine for HSV-2

A therapeutic vaccine for genital herpes is clearly needed. Vaccines recently developed for HSV-2 in humans have been aimed at eliciting CD4+ T cell responses and neutralizing antibody responses to two HSV-2 glycoproteins (gB and gD). These vaccines have had no therapeutic effect against HSV-2 in human clinical trials. To enable development of an efficacious vaccine, Corixa Corporation has made a major effort to identify novel antigens that can be recognized by human HSV-2-specific CD8+ and CD4+ T cells. Corixa Corporation's proprietary adjuvants and delivery systems, when combined with appropriate antigens, may allow the development of an effective therapeutic vaccine for HSV-2.     

Immunological properties of a DNA plasmid encoding a chimeric protein of herpes simplex virus type 2 glycoprotein B and glycoprotein D

A DNA plasmid containing a chimeric sequence encoding both herpes simplex virus type 2 (HSV-2) glycoprotein B (gB) and glycoprotein D (gD) external domains (pcgDB) was used to immunize BALB/c mice against genital HSV-2 infection. To determine the efficacy of this vaccine, groups of mice immunized with the pcgDB plasmid were compared with animals immunized with plasmids corresponding to the individual proteins (pcgBt or pcgDt), administered separately or in combination (pcgBt + pcgDt). We studied the response of the different mouse groups to viral challenge by analyzing clinical disease (vaginitis), serum antibody levels, as well as lymphoproliferative responses and cytokine production by spleen cells. Increased IFN-gamma levels correlated with prolonged survival in mice immunized with the plasmid pcgDB, relative to mice immunized with plasmids coding for the individual proteins alone or in combination. Our results show that immunization with the plasmid encoding the chimeric protein is advantageous over separate proteins. These findings may have important implications for the development of multivalent DNA vaccines against HSV and other complex pathogens.     

Cross protective efficacy of the Non-Neurotropic live attenuated herpes simplex virus type 1 vaccine VC-2 is enhanced by intradermal vaccination and deletion of glycoprotein G

Herpes simplex virus type 1 and 2 (HSV-1 and HSV-2 respectively) cause life-long latent infections resulting in recurrent orofacial and genital blisters or sores. Ensued disease can be painful and may lead to significant mental anguish of infected individuals. Currently, there are no FDA-approved vaccines for either prophylactic or therapeutic use, and recent clinical trials of subunit vaccines failed to achieve endpoints goals. Development of a safe live-attenuated herpes simplex vaccine may provide the antigenic breadth to ultimately protect individuals from acquiring HSV disease. We have previously shown that prophylactic use of the non-neurotropic live attenuated HSV-1 vaccine, VC-2, provides potent and durable protection from genital HSV-2 disease in the guinea pig model. Here, we investigated the effects of intradermal administration as well as the deletion of the viral glycoprotein G (gG) on the efficacy of prophylactic vaccination. Vaccination with either VC-2, VC-2 gG null, or gD2 MPL/Alum offered robust protection from acute disease regardless of route of vaccination. However, both the VC-2 gG-null and the ID vaccination route were more effective compared to the parent VC2 administered by the IM route. Specifically, the VC-2 gG-null administered ID, reduced HSV-2 vaginal replication on day 2 and day 4 as well as mean recurrent lesion scores more effectively than VC2 administered IM. Most importantly, only VC-2 gG null IM and VC-2 ID significantly reduced the frequency of recurrent shedding, the most likely source for virus transmission. Similarly, while all vaccinated groups demonstrated a significant reduction in the number of animals testing PCR-positive for HSV-2 in their dorsal root ganglia following challenge only VC2 ID vaccinated animals demonstrated a significant reduction in DRG viral load. All vaccinations induced neutralizing antibodies to HSV-2 MS when compared to unvaccinated guinea pigs. Therefore, further investigation of VC-2 gG null delivered ID is warranted.     

The adjuvant CLDC increases protection of a herpes simplex type 2 glycoprotein D vaccine in guinea pigs

Herpes simplex virus (HSV) infections are common but there is no vaccine available. We evaluated cationic liposome–DNA complexes (CLDC) as an adjuvant for an HSV gD2 vaccine and compared it to an MPL/Alum adjuvant in a guinea pig model of genital herpes. The addition of CLDC to the gD2 vaccine significantly decreased acute and recurrent disease and most importantly the number of days with recurrent virus shedding compared to gD2 alone. Reductions in these outcomes were also detected when gD2 + CLDC was compared to gD2 + MPL/Alum. When the vaccine and adjuvants were evaluated as therapeutic vaccines, they were ineffective. CLDC enhanced protection compared to MPL/Alum and is the first vaccine to reduce recurrent virus shedding, a key to decreasing the spread of HSV-2.     

A randomized controlled trial of a replication defective (gH deletion) herpes simplex virus vaccine for the treatment of recurrent genital herpes among immunocompetent subjects

BACKGROUND: A replication incompetent herpes virus lacking the glycoprotein H gene has been developed as a potential therapeutic vaccine for genital herpes. GOAL: To determine vaccine efficacy on reducing HSV reactivation and clinical disease among immunocompetent persons with recurrent genital HSV-2 infection. STUDY DESIGN: Randomized multicenter placebo-controlled trial. Healthy volunteers who had six or more recurrences of genital herpes per year were randomized to receive injections of vaccine at 0 and 8 or 0, 4, and 8 or 0, 2, 4, and 8 weeks or placebo and were followed for subsequent recurrences for 1 year. RESULTS: The median times to first recurrence of genital herpes (40 days versus 30 days versus 37 days versus 42 days, respectively), mean number of recurrences (3 versus 3 versus 2.4 versus 1.9, respectively), and time to lesion healing of the first recurrence (8 days versus 7.8 days versus 7.4 days versus 7.5 days, respectively), were similar for all treatment groups. Asymptomatic viral shedding was detected by PCR in 61/74 (82%) persons performing daily sample collection following completion of the vaccination series. No differences were noted in the proportion of days with shedding between treatment groups (11.9% versus 17.2% versus 13.1% versus 16.4%, respectively). CONCLUSION: This replication incompetent HSV-2 vaccine lacking the glycoprotein H gene was safe but had no clinical or virologic benefit in the amelioration of genital HSV-2 disease among immunocompetent men and women.     

The challenges and opportunities for the development of a T-cell epitope-based herpes simplex vaccine

Herpes simplex virus type 1 and type 2 (HSV-1 & HSV-2) infections have been prevalent since the ancient Greek times. To this day, they still affect a staggering number of over a billion individuals worldwide. HSV-1 infections are predominant than HSV-2 infections and cause potentially blinding ocular herpes, oro-facial herpes and encephalitis. HSV-2 infections cause painful genital herpes, encephalitis, and death in newborns. While prophylactic and therapeutic HSV vaccines remain urgently needed for centuries, their development has been difficult. During the most recent National Institute of Health (NIH) workshop titled “Next Generation Herpes Simplex Virus Vaccines: The Challenges and Opportunities”, basic researchers, funding agencies, and pharmaceutical representatives gathered: (i) to assess the status of herpes vaccine research; and (ii) to identify the gaps and propose alternative approaches in developing a safe and efficient herpes vaccine. One “common denominator” among previously failed clinical herpes vaccine trials is that they either used a whole virus or a whole viral protein, which contain both “pathogenic symptomatic” and “protective asymptomatic” antigens and epitopes. In this report, we continue to advocate developing “asymptomatic” epitope-based sub-unit vaccine strategies that selectively incorporate “protective asymptomatic” epitopes which: (i) are exclusively recognized by effector memory CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ T cells (T_EM cells) from “naturally” protected seropositive asymptomatic individuals; and (ii) protect human leukocyte antigen (HLA) transgenic animal models of ocular and genital herpes. We review the role of animal models in herpes vaccine development and discuss their current status, challenges, and prospects.     

Neonatal herpes simplex virus infection following Jewish ritual circumcisions that included direct orogenital suction - New York City, 2000-2011

Herpes simplex virus (HSV) infection commonly causes "cold sores" (HSV type 1 [HSV-1]) and genital herpes (HSV-1 or HSV type 2 [HSV-2]); HSV infection in newborns can result in death or permanent disability. During November 2000-December 2011, a total of 11 newborn males had laboratory-confirmed HSV infection in the weeks following out-of-hospital Jewish ritual circumcision, investigators from the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DOHMH) learned. Ten of the 11 newborns were hospitalized; two died. In six of the 11 cases, health-care providers confirmed parental reports that the ritual circumcision included an ultra-Orthodox Jewish practice known as metzitzah b'peh, in which the circumciser (mohel, plural: mohelim) places his mouth directly on the newly circumcised penis and sucks blood away from the circumcision wound (direct orogenital suction). In the remaining cases, other evidence suggested that genital infection was introduced by direct orogenital suction (probable direct orogenital suction). Based on cases reported to DOHMH during April 2006-December 2011, the risk for neonatal herpes caused by HSV-1 and untyped HSV following Jewish ritual circumcision with confirmed or probable direct orogenital suction in New York City was estimated at 1 in 4,098 or 3.4 times greater than the risk among male infants considered unlikely to have had direct orogenital suction. Oral contact with a newborn's open wound risks transmission of HSV and other pathogens. Circumcision is a surgical procedure that should be performed under sterile conditions. Health-care professionals advising parents and parents choosing Jewish ritual circumcision should inquire in advance whether direct orogenital suction will be performed, and orogenital suction should be avoided.     

A vaccine containing highly purified virus particles in adjuvant provides high level protection against genital infection and disease in guinea pigs challenged intravaginally with homologous and heterologous strains of herpes simplex virus type 2

Infection with Herpes Simplex Viruses (HSVs) represents a significant health burden worldwide with HSV-1 and HSV-2 causing genital disease and HSV-2 contributing to human immunodeficiency virus acquisition. Despite great need, there is currently no licensed vaccine against HSV. In this report, we evaluated the protective efficacy of a vaccine containing highly purified, inactivated HSV-2 particles (with and without additional recombinant glycoprotein D) formulated with a monophosphoryl lipid A/Alhydrogel adjuvant in a guinea pig HSV genital model. The key results from 3 independent studies were: (1) vaccination consistently provided significant 3–3.5 Log10 reductions in vaginal HSV-2 titers on day 2 postchallenge; (2) following homologous or heterologous challenge with two U.S. isolates, all vaccine groups showed complete protection against lesion formation, significant 3 Log10 reductions in day 2 virus shedding, enhanced virus clearance, significant reductions in HSV-2 DNA within ganglia, and no detectable shedding (<2 PFU) or latent viral DNA in some immunized animals; (3) following challenge with a third heterologous strain, vaccination provided complete protection against primary and recurrent lesions, significant reductions in primary virus shedding, a 50% reduction in recurrent shedding days, and undetectable latent virus in the ganglia and spinal cords of most animals; and (4) adding glycoprotein D provided no enhanced protection relative to that elicited by the inactivated HSV-2 particles alone. Together, these data provide strong support for further development of this exceedingly protective and highly feasible vaccine candidate for human trials.     

Protection against herpes simplex virus type 2 infection in a neonatal murine model using a trivalent nucleoside-modified mRNA in lipid nanoparticle vaccine

Neonatal herpes is a dreaded complication of genital herpes infection in pregnancy. We recently compared two vaccine platforms for preventing genital herpes in female mice and guinea pigs and determined that HSV-2 glycoproteins C, D and E expressed using nucleoside-modified mRNA in lipid nanoparticles provided better protection than the same antigens produced as baculovirus proteins and administered with CpG and alum. Here we evaluated mRNA and protein immunization for protection against neonatal herpes. Female mice were immunized prior to mating and newborns were infected intranasally with HSV-2. IgG binding and neutralizing antibody levels in mothers and newborns were comparable using the mRNA or protein vaccines. Both vaccines protected first and second litter newborns against disseminated infection based on virus titers in multiple organs. We conclude that both vaccines are efficacious at preventing neonatal herpes, which leaves the mRNA vaccine as our preferred candidate based on better protection against genital herpes.