Indicators of suicide over 10 years in a specialist mood disorders unit sample.

BACKGROUND: There are few firm data to guide the clinician in identifying individual depressed patients who may be at high risk for completing suicide. In particular, there have been few prospective studies of well-characterized depressed patients to determine indicators of such future events. METHOD: Eight hundred thirteen patients with a major depressive episode (DSM-III, DSM-III-R, or DSM-IV criteria) were assessed in detail in a specialist Mood Disorders Unit (MDU) over a 10-year period. Follow-up at the end of that period (mean = 5.1 years) confirmed that 31 patients (3.8%) had completed suicide. The suicide completers were compared on a broad range of clinical and demographic variables obtained at baseline with (1) the total remaining depressed sample, (2) 31 age- and sex-matched subjects who were confirmed to be alive and had never attempted suicide, and (3) 24 age- and sex-matched living subjects who had made at least 1 suicide attempt. RESULTS: The most consistent finding, across all 3 comparisons, was that the suicide completers were more likely to have been inpatients at the time of the index MDU assessment. Other characteristics of completers were a greater number of prior admissions for depression, being older and in a relationship, and being male and married or female and single. Somewhat paradoxically, suicide completers also evidenced fewer previous suicide attempts and less suicidal ideation compared with living subjects who had attempted suicide at the time of index assessment. CONCLUSION: Overall, we were able to find few predictors of later suicide in this sample. Those who completed suicide demonstrated evidence of more severe illness over a lifetime (for example, having more admissions). but revealed less suicidal ideation at the time of the index MDU assessment. While these features were statistically significant, they are of limited usefulness in predicting suicide in an individual patient.     

Clinical characteristics of adolescent psychiatric inpatients who have attempted suicide

 The clinical characteristics of 191 adolescent inpatients were examined in relation to frequency of previous suicide attempts, predictors of suicide attempts prior to hospitalization, and lifetime suicide attempts. Overall, more than 50% of the adolescent inpatients had attempted suicide during their lifetime, and of these more than half (58%) had made more than one attempt. Approximately half of the suicide attempters had made a serious attempt prior to hospitalization. Girls reported higher levels of depressive symptoms and suicidal ideation than boys, in addition to having attempted suicide prior to hospitalization (33%) or during lifetime (37%) more often than the boys (13% and 26%, respectively). Although about two thirds of the adolescent inpatients reported that they had received some help after a suicide attempt, approximately half of the repeaters had not received any help. The results of multivariate analyses showed that suicide attempts made prior to hospitalization were predicted by depressive symptom levels and a clinical diagnosis of depressive disorder, whereas frequency of lifetime suicide attempts was predicted by suicidal ideation levels and having a family member or a friend who had attempted (or committed) suicide. The high prevalence of lifetime and repeated suicide attempts among the psychiatric inpatients underscores the importance of identifying risk factors in the clinical evaluation of adolescent suicide attempters. Accepted: 1 April 1998     

Increased suicidality in depression: group or subgroup characteristic?

A lifetime history of depressive episodes and suicide attempts was ascertained from 172 depressed patients admitted to a psychiatric inpatient service. Fifty-five of these patients had made at least one suicide attempt. The correlation of depressive episodes and the total number of suicide attempts for this group was close to zero. However, when the data were converted into rate measures (number of episodes or attempts per year), the correlations were very high and significant. It appears that approximately one-third of severely depressed, hospitalized patients have a history of suicide attempts and, once a suicide attempt has occurred, the patient is at high risk for more suicide attempts if future depressions occur. Within the group of depressives with a history of suicide attempt, the risk of suicidal behavior is evenly distributed. No evidence in favor of a "hypervulnerable" subgroup was found.     

Suicidality in panic disorder: a comparison with schizophrenic, depressed, and other anxiety disorder outpatients

Recent findings by Weissman, Klerman, Markowitz, and Ouellette (1989) that subjects with panic disorder, with and without comorbid conditions, may be at increased risk for suicide attempts have been controversial. In an attempt to further investigate this finding, we utilized the original National Institute of Mental Health Epidemiological Catchment Area (ECA) suicide questions in an outpatient psychiatric clinic. We examined patients with panic disorder (n = 101). other anxiety disorders (n = 47), schizophrenia (n = 22). and major depression (n = 19). No significant differences were found among all four groups on any of the ECA suicide ideation questions. Only two (2%) of the panic disorder patients and none of the other groups made a suicide attempt in the past year. While 17% of patients with panic disorder and 9% of patients with other anxiety disorders reported having made a suicide attempt at some other time in their life, the schizophrenic (33%) and depressed groups (40%) reported significantly greater histories of suicide attempts. In a forward stepwise regression analysis for panic disorder patients, a history of substance abuse and comorbid depression predicted suicidality. The actual clinical risk for suicide attempts in panic disorder patients appears to occur when they suffer with comorbid diagnoses. These results highlight the need to aggressively treat panic disorder patients so they do not suffer the all-too-common sequelae of depression and substance abuse.     

Family functioning and suicidality in depressed adults

This study examined the association between suicidality, family factors, and clinical and diagnostic variables in depressed adult inpatients. The subjects were 121 depressed adult inpatients living with a family member or significant other. Demographic, clinical, and diagnostic information about the patient, and subjective and observer ratings of family functioning were obtained. Trained interviewers rated families of suicidal depressed patients as more dysfunctional than families of patients with no history of attempted suicide. In a logistic regression model, earlier age of depression onset, number of psychiatric hospitalizations, and objectively rated poorer family communication were associated with a history of a prior suicide attempt. Also, modest evidence suggested that patients with a prior suicide attempt perceived their families as more dysfunctional than did their respective family members. Variations in family functioning are associated with different degrees of suicidality. However, prospective longitudinal designs would elucidate the causal relation between family dysfunction and suicidal behavior. Copyright by W.B. Saunders Company     

Clinicians' assessments of bipolar disorder and substance abuse as predictors of suicidal behavior in acutely hospitalized psychiatric inpatients.

BACKGROUND: Suicide is a major risk for those with bipolar disorder, a risk amplified by comorbid substance abuse in some, but not all, previous studies. To further explore the relationships of substance abuse, suicide, and bipolarity as they present in clinical practice, we analyzed standardized clinical data from a large acute psychiatric inpatient service. METHODS: Standardized clinical evaluations of 7819 patients with diagnoses of bipolar depression (n=990), bipolar mania (n=948), unipolar depressive episode (n=3626), or schizophrenia-schizoaffective disorders (n=2255) were analyzed to evaluate the relationship between current substance-use problems, substance-induced symptoms, and a current suicide crisis, as well as lifetime suicide attempts, with logistic regressions adjusting for age, gender, and ethnicity. RESULTS: Across the combined groups, current substance-use problems were significantly associated with a lifetime suicide attempt (odds ratios [ORs] 1.6-2.5) and to a lesser degree to the admission suicide crisis (ORs 1-2.2). Among bipolar (depressed/manic) patients, but not other diagnostic groups, those with both current substance-use problems and substance-induced symptoms had even higher rates of a recent suicide crisis (ORs 1.5-3.1) and of a lifetime attempt (ORs 2.5-3.4). CONCLUSIONS: In bipolar patients, substance use disorder doubled and substance use disorder plus substance-induced symptoms tripled the suicidal risk. Implications for future research are discussed.     

Suicidal behavior in depression: relationship to platelet serotonin transporter

OBJECTIVE: Suicidal behavior in depressed patients is associated with low central serotonin. Thus, platelet serotonin uptake in relation to suicidal behavior in depression was examined. METHODS: Depressed patients who had never attempted suicide (n = 23) were compared with depressed patients who had never attempted suicide (n = 26) and normal controls (n = 71) for platelet serotonin uptake. RESULTS: Depressed patients who had a lifetime history of a suicide attempt had a significantly greater apparent Michaelis constant (Km) of platelet serotonin uptake than either depressed patients who had never attempted suicide or controls. Patients rated high for current suicidal ideation at the index admission had significantly higher Km values than patients rated low. Also, patients who reattempted or committed suicide during a 5-year follow-up period had significantly higher Km values than controls. Among women patients who had attempted suicide there was a significant correlation between extrapunitive hostility scores and Km values. CONCLUSION: The serotonin transporter warrants further study in relation to suicidal behavior in depression.     

Mortality and rate of suicide of first admission psychiatric patients. A 5-year follow-up of a prospective longitudinal study

Patients who commit suicide in a psychiatric hospital are, in general, patients who have had previous admission or who have already made at least one suicide attempt. The following study focuses upon an earlier time within the course of a psychiatric illness, that is the time of first admission, and examines the rate of suicide of 258 patients after 5 years. Two control groups were selected: first admitted psychiatric patients who did not commit suicide, and patients who died a 'natural death'. We analyzed how the suicides were integrated into the vocational, social and medical areas of life before they were admitted to the hospital. Further it was possible to identify predictors of future suicide.     

Suicides in males after the first episode of schizophrenia

The aim of this study was a retrospective analysis of available data on patients who committed suicide after the first episode of schizophrenia with focus on risk factors for suicide. Seven of 162 patients consecutively hospitalized at the Department of Psychiatry in Brno with first-episode schizophrenia and followed up for 10 years committed suicide by hanging (n = 4), shooting (n = 1), jumping from height (n = 1), and drowning (n = 1). All patients had more known risk factors and had visited a psychiatrist shortly before their suicide. However, according to the documentation, the patients were not asked about their intention to commit suicide and the potentially modifiable risk factors. Under the conditions of routine clinical practice, the prevention of suicide after the first psychotic episode should include early aggressive treatment and careful monitoring for suicidal behaviors in patients with known risk factors.     

Predictors of suicide in psychiatric hospital

OBJECTIVE: About 5% of all suicides occur in psychiatric hospitals. The aim of this study was to look for potential characteristics common to patients who committed suicide in psychiatric hospital. METHOD: All patients who committed suicide in University Psychiatric Hospital in Ljubljana, Slovenia, in the period 1984-1993 were included. The suicidal patients (SP) with schizophrenia (SCH) and affective psychoses (AP) were compared to an age-, sex- and diagnosis-matched control group. Data from files and (in control patients) patient interviews were gathered. Multivariate logistic regression analysis was used. RESULTS: A total of 79 patients (34 males and 45 females) committed suicide. The majority of them had SCH (n = 36) and AP (n = 23). The predictors of suicide among patients with AP and SCH were depression and lack of insight and, in addition in patients with SCH, past suicidal behaviour and poor relationships with family members. CONCLUSION: This study provides the clinician with information on risk factors for in-patient suicide.     

Treatment of suicide attempters prior to hospital admission

OBJECTIVE: Numerous authors have reported serious shortcomings in the treatment of suicidal patients. This study examined the treatment suicide attempters admitted to a psychiatric hospital in Switzerland had received prior to the suicide attempt. METHOD: Thirty-one patients were admitted to this hospital within a year, representing 36 suicide attempts, which corresponds to 6.5% of the annual admission number. Three of these patients were admitted twice, and one patient was admitted three times. Information on previous treatment was collected in personal interviews and included medication, and its dosage, at 1 month and 2 weeks prior to the suicide attempt, and whether the patient had received psychotherapy. In addition, details of the psychosocial event and the means of the suicide attempt were recorded. RESULTS: Twenty-one patients had been prescribed psychotropic drugs in 24 events, but only in 17 events concerning 15 patients, antidepressants were prescribed prior to hospitalisation. Antipsychotics and benzodiazepines were prescribed in 6 and 21 events, respectively (including 8 events with hypnotics). None of the patients was treated with lithium. In 19 events, 16 patients had received psychotherapy prior to admission. In 32 events, psychotropic drugs were used for the suicide attempt. CONCLUSION: The findings confirm the undertreatment of patients attempting suicide reported by other authors. In spite of the majority of patients being under psychiatric care, no adequate pharmacotherapy had been prescribed particularly for depressed patients.     

Extended suicide attempt: psychopathology, personality and risk factors

Delinquency among depressed patients plays a minor role in criminal behavior. Among the most tragic associations between depression and criminality are cases of extended suicide or suicide attempt. We studied psychopathology, personality, and psychosocial stressors of 9 Austrian females who committed a serious extended suicide attempt. They were admitted for treatment at a special department of the Justizanstalt Wien-Josefstadt, Aussenstelle Wilhelmsh?he. Patients were diagnosed according to ICD-10 as severely depressed with (n = 6) or without (n = 3) psychotic features. After stabilization we diagnosed the following personality disorders: anxious-avoidant (n = 5), paranoid (n = 1), combined (n = 1) and borderline type (n = 1). Traits of the typus melancholicus were found in 5 patients. Seven females were pretreated before the offence by a psychiatrist or a psychologist; 4 of them had committed at least one suicide attempt in the past. Main psychosocial stressors mentioned by patients in the context of the offence were overstrain, marital and/or financial problems. One female killed her child under the influence of acoustic hallucinations. Patients with traits of the melancholic type showed an altruistic and hypernomic motive for killing as well as a psychotic identification with the victim, whereas in the other cases egocentric motives were in the forefront. Potential risk factors for an extended suicide attempt will be discussed.     

Suicide attempts of schizophrenia patients: a case-controlled study in tertiary care

BACKGROUND: Schizophrenia is one of the disorders in which suicide attempts and death by suicide are pronounced. However, there is paucity of data regarding suicide attempts by schizophrenia patients. The aim of the present study was to characterize a large sample of schizophrenia patients in tertiary care who had attempted suicide. METHOD: Over a 15-year period all computerized records of admissions of adult schizophrenia patients were examined. Patients who had attempted suicide were defined as the index group and the comparison group was comprised of the next admission of a patient suffering from schizophrenia who did not attempt suicide prior to hospitalization. RESULTS: There were 10,006 admissions of patients suffering from schizophrenia during the study period. Of these, 1094 (10.9%) records comprise the index group (patients who had attempted suicide), 380 women and 714 men, mean age for the group 39.6+/-12.9 years. The comparison group of patients matched for diagnosis (N=1094), consisted of 302 women and 792 men, mean age for this group was 42.9+/-13.7 years. Four variables significantly differentiated between groups. Patients who had attempted suicide were younger (39.6 vs. 42.9 years; p=0.00), higher percentage of females (34.7% vs. 27.6%; p=0.00), with increased rates of co-morbid physical illness (27.5% vs. 20.4%; p=0.00) notably cardiovascular and diabetes and with a higher rate of alcohol and drug abuse (32.1% vs. 12.4%; p=0.00). CONCLUSIONS: The present study emphasizes several significant factors associated with attempted suicide amongst schizophrenia patients notably physical co-morbidity and abuse of alcohol and drugs. These need be integrated into existing risk assessment schemes thus aiding in decreasing adverse outcomes in this vulnerable group of patients.     

Modeling effects on suicidal behavior

Knowledge of suicidal behavior, i.e., psychiatric patients indicating that they have an acquaintance or relative who has attempted or committed suicide, has been cited as a risk factor in the assessment of suicide potential. The authors evaluated psychiatric patients hospitalized for a suicide attempt (N = 30), serious suicidal ideation (N = 26), or other non-suicide-related reasons (N = 20) and also a control group of 18 patients admitted for orthopaedic surgery. Information derived from a structured clinical interview revealed that suicide attempters have fewer suicidal models than individuals in the other patient groups, and they are more interpersonally distant from the models they do know. Depression level was not positively related to the recall and reporting of suicidal models. Measures assessing suicide-related beliefs revealed that suicide attempters rated suicide as an effective solution for problems to a greater extent that did patients in the remaining three groups. The implications of these results for social learning models of suicidal behavior are discussed.     

Outcome of attempted suicide and psychiatric consultation: risk factors and suicide mortality during a five-year follow-up.

A total of 1018 self-poisoned patients were treated during the year 1983 in the emergency room of Helsinki University Central Hospital. By the end of a 5-year follow-up period, 3.2% of these had committed suicide, making annual suicide mortality 589 per 100,000. During the first year after the index attempt, suicide mortality was 1768 per 100,000, a 50-fold risk compared with that of the total population in Helsinki. Risk factors were being male of advancing age, having mental disorders, previous suicide attempts, a nonimpulsive index suicide attempt, moderate to very serious lethality and severe intention to die during the index suicide attempt. When the lethality was assessed as being very serious or intention to die as certain, 21% later committed suicide. The relative risk for those left without psychiatric consultation was 0.6 when the lethality was mild and 1.6 when it was severe. Results indirectly indicate that psychiatric consultation seemed to have a positive effect on the outcome of these attempted suicides.     

Exposure to antidepressant medications and suicide attempts in adult depressed inpatients

The effects of antidepressant medication on suicide risk remain unclear. This study explores any association between antidepressant medication and suicide attempts leading to hospitalization in adult depressed patients.The medical records of 103 patients admitted after a suicide attempt were examined and compared with those of a matched control group of depressed patients (n = 103) admitted without suicide attempts as well as a patient group with and without suicide attempts on separate hospitalizations (n = 25). No significant difference in antidepressant medication exposure before hospitalization was found between groups. Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor exposure was higher in patients with suicide attempts, albeit nonsignificant, but was identical in patients admitted on two occasions with and without suicide attempts. The most common method for suicide attempt was drug overdose (52.4%). Patients in the group with suicide attempts had significantly more past suicide attempts. Study results do not confirm any relationship between antidepressants and suicide attempts. Close monitoring of depressed patients is advised especially in early treatment.     

A study of suicide in state mental hospitals in New York city

Suicides at five state hospitals for the mentally-ill located in NYC were studied over a 32 month period. The suicide rates at the individual hospitals appeared to be primarily related to the acuteness of inpatient population and secondarily to the socioeconomic-ethnic characteristics of the inpatient population. White young Puerto Rican male, better educated female involuntarily committed, schizophrenic, and affective disordered patients were overrepresented in the suicide group; black patients were underrepresented. From clinical data two profiles of psychiatric inpatients at high risk for suicide were constructed; 1) a male paranoid schizophrenic with previous suicide attempts involuntarily committed due to acute psychosis who hangs himself in his room or bathroom during the first weeks of hospitalization; 2) a chronic undifferentiated schizophrenic often with affective component who has been hospitalized for more than one month and who is considered by staff to be improving, but is having difficulty with discharge planning who commits suicide by jumping while out of the hospital on an authorized pass. Recommendations were made for reducing inpatient suicides.     

Are Psychiatrist Characteristics Associated With Postdischarge Suicide of Schizophrenia Patients?

Information on the relationship between characteristics of mental healthcare providers, including hospitals and psychiatrists, and postdischarge suicide is scanty. This study aims to identify the risk factors for suicide among schizophrenia patients in the 3-month postdischarge period. The study cohort comprised all patients with a principal diagnosis of schizophrenia discharged from psychiatric inpatient care from 2002 to 2004 who committed suicide within 90 days of discharge. The control cohort consisted of all surviving schizophrenia patients discharged from psychiatric inpatient care in the same period and were matched to cases for age, gender, and date of discharge. There were 87 and 348 cases in the study and control cohorts, respectively. For suicide cases, death most frequently occurred on the first day after leaving the hospital (16.1%). The adjusted hazard ratios for committing suicide during the 90-day postdischarge period were 2.639 times greater for patients without previous psychiatric admission than for those hospitalized more than 3 times in the year preceding the index hospitalization. The adjusted suicide hazard for schizophrenia patients treated by male psychiatrists was significantly higher than for patients treated by female psychiatrists, by a multiple of 5.117 (P = .032). The adjusted suicide hazard among patients treated by psychiatrists over age 44 years was 2.378 times (P = .043) that for patients treated by psychiatrists aged younger than 35 years. Risk factors related to psychiatric hospitalization, including number of psychiatric admissions in the previous year and length of stay, together with gender and age of the psychiatrist providing inpatient care, are identified.     

Le suicide dans l'institution

More than 50 % of suicides are by patients who have been or are still followed-up. The prevalence of suicidal crises is high (32 %) and stable in populations of chronic psychiatric patients. Suicidal risk factors are well known, nevertheless they are more particularly high during acute crises and are lower when the psychiatric illness is chronic. Five percent of the suicides are committed during hospitalization. Most of them occur on the first month following admission, in the first week of an acute psychotic crisis, within the year after hospitalization, prior to the hospital discharge. The rate of suicide is particularly important in psychiatric institutions because most of their patients are suffering from schizophrenia and/or depression, two diseases with high rates of suicide. Some suicidal risk factors specific to schizophrenia have been identified such as the schizoid-affective form of the disease, patient care that has been delayed, a chronic disease with numerous acute episodes, short and frequent admissions in a hospital, involuntary hospitalisations, extrapyramidal side effects and disruption of treatment. The vulnerability appears to be maximum during the first week and/or the three months after discharge from the hospital, during the first year following the diagnosis and during acute episodes, especially the first one. In the second part of this work, we will examine the legal aspects, based on the main recent court cases relative to hospital liability. The fault usually consists in lack of surveillance and involves the liability of the hospital. The assessment of the adequacy of the measures taken for the medical care of a patient and in particular his/her supervision depends on the predictability of the suicidal act; the severity of the psychiatric illness and more particularly on previous suicidal attempts; previous fugues from the hospital and previous violent acting out especially on the occasion of previous hospitalisations. To avoid reciprocal projections when there is a suicidal act it is essential to work with family and attendants, to obtain clear and exact information about the psychiatric illness and to ensure both medical and administrative care.     

Sex differences in clinical predictors of suicidal acts after major depression: a prospective study

OBJECTIVE: Whether sex differences exist in clinical risk factors associated with suicidal behavior is unknown. The authors postulated that among men with a major depressive episode, aggression, hostility, and history of substance misuse increase risk for future suicidal behavior, while depressive symptoms, childhood history of abuse, fewer reasons for living, and borderline personality disorder do so in depressed women. METHOD: Patients with DSM-III-R major depression or bipolar disorder seeking treatment for a major depressive episode (N=314) were followed for 2 years. Putative predictors were tested with Cox proportional hazards regression analysis. RESULTS: During follow-up, 16.6% of the patients attempted or committed suicide. Family history of suicidal acts, past drug use, cigarette smoking, borderline personality disorder, and early parental separation each more than tripled the risk of future suicidal acts in men. For women, the risk for future suicidal acts was sixfold greater for prior suicide attempters; each past attempt increased future risk threefold. Suicidal ideation, lethality of past attempts, hostility, subjective depressive symptoms, fewer reasons for living, comorbid borderline personality disorder, and cigarette smoking also increased the risk of future suicidal acts for women. CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest that the importance of risk factors for suicidal acts differs in depressed men and women. This knowledge may improve suicide risk evaluation and guide future research on suicide assessment and prevention.