The Effects of Lesions to the Mammillary Region and the Hippocampus on Conditional Associative Learning by Rats

Rats with extensive lesions to the mammillary body region, the hippocampus, or rats which had received a control operation were trained postoperatively on two visuo-spatial conditional associative learning tasks in which they had to learn to associate spatial cues with particular visual/auditory stimuli. The animals were subsequently trained on a spatial working memory task, the eight-arm radial maze. Rats with lesions to the mammillary body region were able to acquire the conditional associative learning tasks at a rate comparable to that of operated control animals, whereas those with hippocampal lesions were not. By contrast, rats with a lesion of the mammillary body region or the hippocampus were significantly impaired in comparison with the operated control animals in the radial maze. The findings suggest that lesions to the mammillary body region impair spatial working memory without affecting the capacity to associate particular exteroceptive cues with spatial locations.     

Double dissociation between hippocampal and prefrontal lesions on an operant delayed matching task and a water maze reference memory task

The hippocampus and prefrontal cortex have both been implicated in various aspects of the acquisition, retention and performance of delayed matching to position (DMTP) tasks in the rat, although their precise respective contributions remain unclear. In the present study, rats were trained preoperatively on DMTP before receiving excitotoxic bilateral lesions of either the entire hippocampus or the medial prefrontal cortex. Rats with lesions of the prefrontal cortex exhibited a significant delay-dependent impairment on retention of the DMTP task, whereas hippocampal lesions were without effect. Rats were also exposed to a switch in the contingencies to a 'non-matching' rule, as an analogue of switching between decision rules in the human Wisconsin Card Sorting Test, in which human patients with prefrontal damage are impaired. Both lesion groups acquired the new contingency at control levels, providing no evidence towards a role for either of these areas in this type of rule-switching. The same rats were also assessed in a spatial reference memory task in the water maze, which revealed an impairment in escape latencies and path length that was specific to the hippocampal lesions. The results corroborate previous evidence that the hippocampus is not necessary for at least some aspects of working memory performance in the DMTP task, whereas the delay-dependent deficit in the prefrontal lesion group support this task as a potentially powerful tool for assessing the cognitive changes associated with frontal damage and repair.     

Functional difference between rat perirhinal cortex and hippocampus in object and place discrimination tasks

The present study was designed to determine the degree of functional dissociation between the rat perirhinal cortex and hippocampus for reference memory performance on object and place discrimination tasks. In one experiment, 30 rats were trained on a two-pair concurrent object discrimination task in an elevated radial arm maze. Rats with a perirhinal cortex lesion needed significantly more days to attain the criterion in the relearning of a pre-operatively acquired object discrimination task than the control rats and rats with a hippocampal lesion. However, there were no significant differences between the three groups in the days to attain the criterion in learning post-operatively the original object discrimination task with new discriminanda and its relearning. The rats with a hippocampal lesion did not show any impairment in object discrimination. In a second experiment, 27 rats were trained on a place discrimination task in the same maze. Rats with a hippocampal lesion required more days to attain the criterion than the control rats to relearn the pre-operatively acquired place discrimination task, and they had fewer correct responses in the first three sessions with new discriminanda than the control rats. Rats with a perirhinal cortex lesion, on the other hand, showed mild relearning impairment. These results suggest that there is a functionally single dissociation between the perirhinal cortex and hippocampus for reference memory performance on object and place discrimination tasks. They also suggest the possible involvement of the perirhinal cortex in spatial reference memory performance.     

Contribution of the anterior thalamic nuclei to conditional learning in rats

The anterior thalamic region is intimately linked anatomically and functionally with the hippocampus, which is critical for various forms of spatial learning. Rats with lesions to the anterior thalamic nuclei and a control group were trained on a visual-spatial conditional associative learning task in which they had to learn to go to one of two locations depending on the particular visual cue presented on each trial; the rats approached the cues from different directions. The animals were subsequently tested on a spatial working memory task, the eight-arm radial maze. Performance on both these tasks had previously been shown to be impaired by hippocampal lesions. Rats with anterior thalamic damage were able to acquire the conditional associative task at a rate comparable to that of the control animals, but were impaired on the radial maze task. The finding of a dissociation between the effects of lesions of the anterior thalamic nuclei on two different classes of behavior known to be associated with hippocampal function suggest that while different neural stations within the extended hippocampal circuit may all play a role in spatial learning, the role of each of these regions in such learning may be more selective than previously considered.     

Effects of enriched postoperative housing conditions on spatial memory deficits in rats with selective lesions of either the hippocampus,subiculum or entorhinal cortex

Long-Evans male, adult rats received selective and bilateral lesions of either the hippocampus, subiculum or lateral entorhinal cortex, and were then housed for 30 days in either enriched or standard conditions. Rats were then tested in the eight-arm radial maze to assess spatial working memory and the strategies that were employed (i.e. pattern of arms visited). Lesions of the hippocampus induced both a working-memory impairment and a loss in the use of allocentric strategies to perform the task. Rats with lesions of the subiculum were also impaired but less than hippocampectomized rats and showed a similar pattern of arm visits as control rats. In contrast with other lesioned rats, rats with lateral entorhinal cortex lesions performed the task like control rats. Postoperative enriched housing conditions (EHC) globally enhanced performance of rats, but did not affect the strategies selected by the rats to solve the task. The beneficial effect of EHC was particularly obvious in rats with lesions of the subiculum. In enriched rats with such lesions, performance was not significantly different from that of control rats housed in standard conditions. The present results indicate that 1) the structures within the hippocampal formation are not similarly involved in spatial learning and memory processes and in the management of navigational demands of the radial maze, and 2) enriched conditions may enhance the spared spatial abilities of some lesioned rats thus promoting functional recovery.     

Preoperative training modifies radial maze performance in rats with ischemic hippocampal injury

Rats exposed to 30 minutes of four-vessel occlusion reliably develop severe bilateral CA1 hippocampal injury; under certain conditions of radial maze training, such rats perform the reference memory component as well as controls yet perform the working memory component worse than controls. Reference memory is thought to depend on invariable and working memory on variable spatial information. We assessed the effect of training before ischemia. In Experiment 1, rats trained for 36 trials on 12-arm radial mazes before ischemia demonstrated a persistent impairment on the working memory task but eventually performed the reference memory task comparable to controls. Ischemic rats made more working memory errors as the number of choices increased. This pattern of working memory errors was similar to that in controls except, as expected, ischemic rats made many more errors. In Experiment 2, training for 80 trials before ischemia in rats decreased the severity of both the working and the reference memory impairment. Ischemia did not affect motor behavior in either experiment. These results characterize the working memory deficit in ischemic rats and demonstrate the importance of experimental factors, particularly in the design of treatment strategies to reduce functional impairments caused by ischemia.     

Effects of clozapine on memory function in the rat neonatal hippocampal lesion model of schizophrenia

Clozapine is an effective atypical antipsychotic drug used to treat schizophrenia. It has the advantage of producing fewer extrapyramidal motor side effects than typical antipsychotic drugs such as haloperidol. Schizophrenia involves more than the hallmark symptom of psychosis. Substantial cognitive impairment is also seen. Effective drug treatments against the cognitive impairment of schizophrenia need to be developed. The current study was conducted to determine the effects of clozapine on working memory in the rat neonatal hippocampal lesion model of schizophrenia, which includes symptoms of cognitive impairment. Infant Sprague-Dawley rats were given ibotenic acid lesions of the hippocampus on day 7 of age (using the day of birth as day 0). Controls were given vehicle infusions. In adulthood, the rats were trained on the 8-arm radial maze using the win-shift procedure. After 6 sessions of training, the lesioned rats and their controls were administered repeated injections of saline or clozapine (2.5 mg/kg) for the next 12 sessions of training. The females had significant radial-arm maze choice accuracy impairments caused by either clozapine or the hippocampal lesion, but the combination of the two treatments had no additive effect. The males showed a different pattern of effects. Intact males did not show a significant clozapine-induced impairment, whereas males with hippocampal lesions did show significant clozapine-induced impairment although hippocampal lesions by themselves did not significantly impair male choice accuracy. These data show that clozapine can cause memory impairment and it potentiates rather than reverses hippocampal lesion-induced deficits. There are critical sex-related differences in these effects.     

Differential effects of fornix and caudate nucleus lesions on two radial maze tasks: evidence for multiple memory systems

The present experiments were designed to examine the hypothesis that the mammalian brain contains anatomically distinct memory systems. Rats with bilateral lesions of caudate nucleus or fimbria-fornix and a control group were tested postoperatively on 1 of 2 versions of the radial maze task. In a standard win-shift version, each of the 8 arms of the maze was baited once, and the number of errors (revisits) in the first 8 choices of each trial was recorded. Fimbria-fornix rats were impaired in choice accuracy, while caudate animals were unimpaired relative to controls. Different groups of rats with similar lesions were tested on a newly developed win-stay version of the radial maze, in which the location of 4 randomly selected baited arms was signaled by a light at the entrance to each arm, and which required rats to revisit arms in which reinforcement had been previously acquired within a trial. Rats with fimbria-fornix lesions were superior to controls in choice accuracy on the win-stay radial maze task, while caudate animals were impaired relative to controls. The results demonstrate a double dissociation of the mnemonic functions of the hippocampus and caudate nucleus. Some implications of the presence of 2 memory systems in the mammalian brain are discussed.     

Dissociating hippocampal subregions: double dissociation between dentate gyrus and CA1.

This study presents a double dissociation between the dentate gyrus (DG) and CA1. Rats with either DG or CA1 lesions were tested on tasks requiring either spatial or spatial temporal order pattern separation. To assess spatial pattern separation, rats were trained to displace an object which covered a baited food-well. The rats were then allowed to choose between two identical objects: one covered the same well as the sample phase object (correct choice), and a second object covered a different unbaited well (incorrect choice). Spatial separations of 15-105 cm were used to separate the correct object from the incorrect object. To assess spatial temporal order pattern separation, rats were allowed to visit each arm of a radial eight-arm maze once in a randomly determined sequence. The rats were then presented with two arms and were required to choose the arm which occurred earliest in the sequence. The choice arms varied according to temporal separation (0, 2, 4, or 6) or the number of arms that occurred between the two choice arms in the sample phase sequence. On each task, once a preoperative criterion was reached, each rat was given either a DG, CA1, or control lesion and then retested. The results demonstrated that DG lesions resulted in a deficit on the spatial task but not the temporal task. In contrast, CA1 lesions resulted in a deficit on the temporal task but not the spatial task. Results suggest that the DG supports spatial pattern separation, whereas CA1 supports temporal pattern separation.     

Inactivation of ventral midline thalamus produces selective spatial delayed conditional discrimination impairment in the rat

The reuniens (Re) and rhomboid (Rh) nuclei are organized to influence activity in distributed limbic networks involving hippocampus and medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC). To elucidate the role of these nuclei in spatial memory we inactivated Re and Rh in rats with the GABA(A) agonist muscimol and compared effects on two spatial delayed conditional discriminations: delayed nonmatching to position (DNMTP) and varying choice radial maze delayed nonmatching (VC-DNM). DNMTP is trained in operant chambers and requires rats to choose between the same two levers on all trials. VC-DNM is trained in automated radial mazes and requires rats to choose between two arms, randomly selected from eight alternatives on each trial. DNMTP is affected by hippocampal and mPFC lesions while VC-DNM is affected by hippocampal, but not mPFC lesions (Porter et al. (2000) Behav Brain Res 109:69-81). We found evidence of a localized (low dose) effect of ReRh inactivation on DNMTP but not VC-DNM. This was confirmed by comparison with muscimol injections in an anatomical control site. These results are consistent with evidence that Re and Rh affect measures of spatial working memory that depend on interactions between hippocampus and mPFC, but not measures that depend on hippocampus alone.     

The hippocampus, time and working memory

Rats were trained on a discrete trial working memory leverpress alternation task, following hippocampal lesions (HC), cortical control lesions (CC) or sham operations (SO). Each trial consisted of a forced information response, for which a randomly selected lever was presented followed by a free choice stage, when both levers were presented. The rats were rewarded for pressing the lever which had not been presented at the information stage. When the information response was not rewarded, all rats learnt the task equally well at IRIs of up to 12.75 sec. When the information response was rewarded, the HC rats showed impaired choice accuracy. The extent of this impairment depended on the IRI, being greatest at long IRIs, and least at short ones. Varying the number of leverpresses required to complete the information response affected choice accuracy equivalently in all groups: all rats chose significantly less accurately when only one leverpress was required than when ten leverpresses were required. There was no interaction between the lesion treatments and the information response requirements. It was concluded that both the length of the IRI and the occurrence of events during the IRI determine the extent of the hippocampal lesion-induced performance deficit in working memory tasks. It is proposed that hippocampal damage disrupts an intermediate-term, high-capacity memory buffer, but leaves both a residual short-term memory system and the long-term retention of associations unaffected. This proposal leads to the prediction that reference memory tasks should also be affected by hippocampal lesions when a delay is introduced between making a response and being rewarded for doing so.     

Rats with lesions of the hippocampus are impaired on the delayed nonmatching-to-sample task

Rats with ibotenic acid lesions of the hippocampus (H-IBO) were trained on the trial-unique delayed nonmatching-to-sample task (DNMS) using a short delay of 4 s. The H-IBO group learned the nonmatching rule as quickly as control animals. However, performance was impaired on the DNMS task when the delay between the sample and choice phase was increased to 1 or 2 min. The use of 4-s delay (probe) trials indicated that the H-IBO animals retained the nonmatching-to-sample rule throughout testing. In a second experiment, using the same groups of rats, extended training at the 1-min delay did not ameliorate the deficit produced by H-IBO lesions. The finding of impaired recognition memory in rats after hippocampal lesions is consistent with findings from humans and monkeys. Several methodological issues are considered that have complicated the interpretation of earlier studies of recognition memory in rats following hippocampal lesions. The capacity for recognition memory in humans, monkeys, and rodents is discussed as a straightforward example of hippocampus-dependent (declarative) memory.     

Effects of reversible inactivation of thalamo-striatal circuitry on delayed matching trained with retractable levers

The intralaminar thalamic nuclei are characterized by their prominent projections to striatum. Lesions of the intralaminar nuclei have been found to impair delayed matching trained with retractable levers. Comparable impairments have been observed for rats with lesions of the olfactory tubercle, involving ventral areas of striatum and pallidum. We conducted two experiments to test the functional dependence of thalamic and striatal lesions on the delayed matching task. In experiment 1, we determined the effects of inactivating the intralaminar nuclei with bilateral lidocaine infusions. In experiment 2, we compared the effects of unilateral thalamic inactivations in rats with unilateral olfactory tubercle lesions. We trained rats to perform the delayed matching task to criterion and then implanted dual cannulas aimed at the bilaterally symmetrical areas in the intralaminar nuclei. Rats in experiment 2 were also given a unilateral olfactory tubercle lesion. The results of experiment 1 showed dose-dependent impairments for bilateral infusions that were qualitatively similar, although of lesser severity than delayed matching impairments observed in previous studies for rats with lesions involving extensive areas of the intralaminar nuclei. A comparable impairment was observed in experiment 2 when thalamus was inactivated on the side opposite the olfactory tubercle lesion. Performances were significantly worse when thalamus was inactivated on the contra-lesion than on the ipsi-lesion side of the brain. These results are discussed in terms of the role of ventral striatum and related thalamic nuclei in memory.     

Preserved configural learning and spatial learning impairment in rats with hippocampal damage.

This study was undertaken to compare the effect of hippocampal neurotoxic lesions in rats on two behavioral tasks, one a test of spatial learning, and the other an operant discrimination task that is acquired by forming nonspatial configural associations. Lesions of the hippocampus were made with microinjections of ibotenic acid. After postoperative recovery, rats were trained initially to locate a camouflaged escape platform in a water maze using distal spatial cues. Rats also were trained in the maze apparatus with a visible escape platform under conditions in which spatial information was made irrelevant to performance, i.e., cue learning. In an operant task, the same rats were then trained on a discrimination that included simultaneous feature positive and feature negative components (trial types XA+, A-, XB-, B+). After completion of this nonspatial configural learning task, rats received additional training in the water maze using a new platform location for spatial learning. To the extent that proficient performance in both the maze and operant tasks depends on a common function of the hippocampus, i.e., configural learning, the expectation was that hippocampal lesions would prove equally detrimental to performance in both tasks. Contrary to this expectation, lesioned rats were severely impaired in spatial learning but readily acquired the operant discrimination, even exhibiting some evidence of enhanced performance on this nonspatial configural learning task. Performance of the lesioned rats during cue training in the water maze was also enhanced relative to the control group.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Intradentate colchicine disrupts the acquisition and performance of a working memory task in the radial arm maze

Rats were given bilateral injections of colchicine into the dorsal and ventral hippocampus to study the role of the dentate gyrus granule cells in the acquisition and performance of a spatial, working memory task in the radial arm maze. Three weeks after intradentate injections, rats were trained in a task in which all eight arms were baited prior to each daily trail. For up to 20 days of training, colchicine-treated rats were significantly impaired in the performance of the task. In another study, rats received 20 days of training and then were given intradentate colchicine. Three weeks later, the performance of the colchicine-treated rats was impaired for up to 20 days of testing. A third experiment tested the ability of colchicine-treated rats to learn a task in which the same four arms of the maze were baited, while the remaining arms were never baited. Colchicine-treated rats were significantly impaired in their ability to perform this version of the task. Histological verification indicated that colchicine resulted in a relatively select loss of granule cells, while sparing pyramidal cells in the hippocampus. These data suggest that the hippocampus plays an integral role in the performance of the place tasks used in these experiments.     

Basal forebrain lesions produce a dissociation of trial-dependent and trial-independent memory performance

The behavioral effects of lesions in the basal forebrain (BF) of rats were evaluated using two tasks. The BF lesions included both the nucleus basalis magnocellularis (NBM) and the medial septal area (MSA). The first task was a Stone maze, which has 14 consecutive choice points and is a task of complex, trial-independent memory. BF lesions did not impair choice accuracy in this task. The second task was a win-shift spatial discrimination in a radial arm maze, which requires trial-dependent memory. BF lesions produced a significant decrease in choice accuracy in this task. These results demonstrate that BF lesions impair trial-dependent (working) memory but not trial-independent reference memory, and that task difficulty is not the sole factor determining whether BF lesions produce behavioral impairments.     

Dissociable roles of the medial prefrontal cortex, the anterior cingulate cortex, and the hippocampus in behavioural flexibility revealed by serial reversal of three-choice discrimination in rats

Contributions of different limbic cortical areas to mediation of behavioural flexibility were examined using repeated acquisition of three-choice discrimination in operant chambers. Rats were trained on a series of positional discrimination tasks with three levers, where position of the correct lever remained the same within a task but shifted across tasks. Ibotenic acid lesions of the medial prefrontal cortex impaired acquisition of each discrimination task by increasing errors specifically in the early phase of each task. These errors were characterised by perseveration to the previously correct lever. By contrast, lesions of the anterior cingulate cortex resulted in the impairment of discrimination in general without inducing perseveration; the impairment was instead characterised by disruption of general error-correction processes. Hippocampal lesions severely impaired learning by increasing perseverative tendencies that were present throughout the learning stages in each task. These results extend our understanding of the contributions of the different nodes of the limbic cortico-striatal circuit to different aspects of behavioural flexibility.     

Attenuation of context-specific inhibition on reversal learning of a stimulus-response task in rats with neurotoxic hippocampal damage

Rats with hippocampal or sham lesions were trained on a stimulus-response task developed for the 8-arm radial maze. After reaching a stringent learning criterion, different context manipulations were performed. In Experiment I, the different groups were transferred to an identical radial maze in a different room to determine the context specificity of the discrimination learning. Experiment I revealed that although rats with hippocampal lesions did not show a normal context detection effect, the expression of the discrimination was not context dependent for either the lesion or sham groups. In Experiment II, animals were trained to criterion on the discrimination task and then both groups were divided into sub-groups based on whether they would experience reversal training in the same or different context from original training. Experiment II indicated that animals with hippocampal lesions and shams reversed in a different context were significantly enhanced in reaching the learning criterion compared to either counterparts that were reversed in the same context. Reversal learning in rats with hippocampal lesions was faster than sham animals in the same context suggesting that the context-specific inhibition effect was hippocampal-based. After learning the reversal task, the groups of animals trained and reversed in different contexts were brought back into the original training context to test for competitive effects. Animals with hippocampal lesions that were reversed in the different context, did not show a competition between the most recently acquired discrimination and a context-specific association acquired during original training whereas sham animals in the same condition did. Taken together these results suggest that rats with hippocampal lesions do not acquire normal context-specific inhibition during discrimination learning.     

The effects of lesions to the anterior thalamic nuclei on object-place associations in rats

Rats with lesions of the anterior nuclei of the thalamus were trained postoperatively on two spatial conditional associative learning tasks. In the first task, the rats were required to choose one or the other of two objects depending on the location in which they were found. In the second task, the animals learned to turn left or right depending on which one of two visual cues was presented. A third experiment examined the effects of damage to the anterior thalamic nuclei on the eight-arm radial maze, a spatial working memory task. Damage of the anterior thalamic nuclei impaired performance on the radial maze task and the conditional task requiring associations between objects and their location. By contrast, rats with anterior thalamic lesions were able to acquire, at a rate comparable with that of operated control animals, the conditional task requiring associations between objects and body turns. These findings suggest that lesions to the anterior thalamic nuclei result in a general impairment in learning about allocentric spatial information without disrupting the learning of egocentric spatial information.     

Effects of electrolytic lesions of the medial prefrontal cortex or its subfields on 4-arm baited, 8-arm radial maze, two-way active avoidance and conditioned fear tasks in the rat

The present study tested the effects of electrolytic lesions in two mPFC subregions, the dorsal anterior cingulate area (dACA) and prelimbic cortex, as well as the effects of a larger medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) lesion which included both subregions, on 4-arm baited, 4-arm unbaited, 8-arm radial maze task and its reversal (Experiments 1 and 4), two-way active avoidance (Experiments 2 and 5) and conditioned emotional response (Experiments 3 and 6). Rats with large or small lesions of the mPFC learned the location of the 4 baited arms in the training and reversal stages of the radial maze task similarly to sham rats, indicating that these lesions did not affect animals' capacity to process and remember spatial information. dACA and mPFC lesions produced a transient deficit in the acquisition of the radial maze task, suggestive of an involvement of these regions in mnemonic processes. However, in view of the normal performance of these groups by the end of training and during reversal, this deficit is better interpreted as stemming from a difficulty to learn the memory-based strategy used to solve the task. Only mPFC lesion led to better avoidance performance at the beginning of training and tended to increase response during the presentation of a stimulus previously paired with shock, compared to sham rats. Both effects can be taken as an indication of reduced emotionality following mPFC lesion. The results are discussed in relation to known behavioral functions of the mPFC and the suggested functional specialization within this region.