Disorders of thought are severe mood disorders: the selective attention defect in mania challenges the Kraepelinian dichotomy a review

Kraepelin said severe mental illness was due to 2 diseases subsequently characterized as disorders of thought vs disorders of mood, ie, the Kraepelinian dichotomy. Schizophrenia, traditionally considered the disorder of thought, has been defined by the presence of hallucinations, delusions, catatonia, and disorganization. Tangentiality, derailment, loose associations, and thought blocking are typically considered pathognomonic of schizophrenia. By contrast, the mood disorders have been characterized only as disorders of the emotions, though both depression and mania, when severe, are now recognized to include the same psychotic features traditionally considered diagnostic of schizophrenia. This article addresses disordered thinking in mania in order to clarify the relationship between schizophrenia and psychotic mood disorders. Normally, the brain's selective attention mechanism filters and prioritizes incoming stimuli by excluding from consciousness extraneous, low-priority stimuli and grading the importance of more relevant data. Because this "filter/prioritizer" becomes defective in mania, tangential stimuli are processed without appropriate prioritization. Observed as distractibility, this symptom is an index of the breakdown in selective attention and the severity of mania, accounting for the signs and symptoms of psychotic thinking. The zone of rarity between schizophrenia and psychotic mood disorders is blurred because severe disorders of mood are also disorders of thought. This relationship calls into question the tenet that schizophrenia is a disease separate from psychotic mood disorders. Patients whose case histories are discussed herein gave their written informed consent to participate in this institutional human subjects committee-approved protocol.     

An overview of the genetics of psychotic mood disorders

This article presents a conceptual review of the genetic underpinnings of psychotic mood disorders. Both unipolar and bipolar forms of mood disorder sometimes feature psychotic symptoms. Some evidence from epidemiological research suggests that psychotic forms of mood disorder specifically might be heritable. Linkage studies of mood disorders in general have also provided some support for that notion, as have associated studies involving serotonin and dopamine genes and psychotic mood disorder. Some research suggests there might be a genetic connection between schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, undermining the Kraepelinian dichotomous classification of the psychoses. Future research should continue to examine psychotic forms of mood disorder using both epidemiological and molecular approaches.     

Differentiating childhood-onset schizophrenia from psychotic mood disorders

OBJECTIVE: The authors systematically examined a sample of patients who were referred to an ongoing National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) study of childhood-onset schizophrenia (COS), but who received diagnoses of mood disorders at the NIMH, to analyze the reliability of these research-setting diagnoses and to characterize the patients clinically. Pilot data regarding the clinical course of these patients over a 2- to 7-year follow-up period were also obtained. METHOD: Thirty-three cases were selected from the 215 pediatric patients who had been screened in person from 1991 to 1999 for admission to the COS study. These 33 patients had been excluded from the COS study on the basis of a day-long evaluation, including a structured diagnostic interview, which yielded a diagnosis of a mood disorder rather than schizophrenia. This subgroup, together with six COS subjects (for a total N= 39), were included in a diagnostic reliability study in which they were reevaluated by three psychiatrists who were blind to the initial research diagnosis. In addition, pilot follow-up data regarding current function and treatment status were obtained for 25 of the 33 patients with mood disorders. RESULTS: Overall, the interrater reliability of the three raters was excellent (kappa = 0.90). Global reliability between these raters and the NIMH research diagnoses was good (average kappa across diagnoses = 0.61), and agreement for those patients who had mood disorders was good (86% agreement; kappa = 0.60). Pilot follow-up data indicate that none of the subjects with a diagnosed mood disorder developed a clinical course resembling schizophrenia. CONCLUSIONS: Many of the patients referred to the NIMH COS study with clinical diagnoses of schizophrenia had psychotic mood disorders diagnosed on the basis of a comprehensive research evaluation including structured diagnostic interviews, and these research diagnoses were reliable. The diagnosis of COS is difficult and requires a time-consuming evaluation process.     

Prospective study of adolescents with subsyndromal psychosis: characteristics and outcome

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to examine the characteristics and outcome of adolescents with psychotic disorder not otherwise specified (PsyNOS) and brief psychotic disorder (BrPsy), two neglected subsyndromal diagnostic entities. METHODS: As part of an ongoing, naturalistic study investigating adolescents considered to be prodromal for schizophrenia, 29 youngsters (mean age, 16.2 +/- 2.7 years) with PsyNOS or BrPsy were identified as theoretically at highest risk for schizophrenia and followed for over 6 (mean, 22.8 +/- 19.4) months. RESULTS: Contrary to our expectations, only 7 of the 26 individuals (27.0%) with follow-up data developed schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder, and only 2 subjects (7.7%) retained their diagnosis of BrPsy/PsyNOS. The most frequent other diagnoses at follow-up were mood disorders (34.6%), personality disorders (11.5%), and obsessive-compulsive disorder (7.7%). Regarding severity of outcome, 38.5% of the patients progressed to a syndromal psychotic disorder, 23.1% continued to have attenuated positive symptoms, and 38.4% improved to having attenuated negative symptoms only, or no positive or negative symptoms. BrPsy was associated with lower maximum levels of negative symptoms (p = 0.02) and higher likelihood of symptom remission (p = 0.02). CONCLUSIONS: This study indicates that psychotic symptoms not fulfilling criteria for schizophrenia or a psychotic mood disorder are unreliable predictors of a syndromal psychotic disorder outcome at 2 years. Long-term studies of PsyNOS and BrPsy are needed to clarify where these disorders fall in the developmental course of schizophrenia.     

Hypothesis: grandiosity and guilt cause paranoia; paranoid schizophrenia is a psychotic mood disorder; a review

Delusional paranoia has been associated with severe mental illness for over a century. Kraepelin introduced a disorder called "paranoid depression," but "paranoid" became linked to schizophrenia, not to mood disorders. Paranoid remains the most common subtype of schizophrenia, but some of these cases, as Kraepelin initially implied, may be unrecognized psychotic mood disorders, so the relationship of paranoid schizophrenia to psychotic bipolar disorder warrants reevaluation. To address whether paranoia associates more with schizophrenia or mood disorders, a selected literature is reviewed and 11 cases are summarized. Comparative clinical and recent molecular genetic data find phenotypic and genotypic commonalities between patients diagnosed with schizophrenia and psychotic bipolar disorder lending support to the idea that paranoid schizophrenia could be the same disorder as psychotic bipolar disorder. A selected clinical literature finds no symptom, course, or characteristic traditionally considered diagnostic of schizophrenia that cannot be accounted for by psychotic bipolar disorder patients. For example, it is hypothesized here that 2 common mood-based symptoms, grandiosity and guilt, may underlie functional paranoia. Mania explains paranoia when there are grandiose delusions that one's possessions are so valuable that others will kill for them. Similarly, depression explains paranoia when delusional guilt convinces patients that they deserve punishment. In both cases, fear becomes the overwhelming emotion but patient and physician focus on the paranoia rather than on underlying mood symptoms can cause misdiagnoses. This study uses a clinical, case-based, hypothesis generation approach that warrants follow-up with a larger representative sample of psychotic patients followed prospectively to determine the degree to which the clinical course observed herein is typical of all such patients. Differential diagnoses, nomenclature, and treatment implications are discussed because bipolar patients misdiagnosed with schizophrenia are severely misserved.     

Schizoaffective disorder merges schizophrenia and bipolar disorders as one disease--there is no schizoaffective disorder

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Schizoaffective disorder was named as a compromise diagnosis in 1933, and remains popular as judged by its place in the International Classification of Diseases and the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, its frequent use in clinical practice, and its extensive discussion in the literature. Some, however, have questioned the validity of schizoaffective disorder as separate from psychotic mood disorder. We examined the literature to assess the rationale for the continuation of schizoaffective disorder as a legitimate diagnostic category. RECENT FINDINGS: The diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder depends on the disease specificity of the diagnostic criteria for schizophrenia; however, the psychotic symptoms for schizophrenia, traditionally held as specific, can be accounted for by psychotic bipolar. Further, the interrater reliability for diagnosing schizoaffective disorder is very low. A recent and expanding body of comparative evidence from a wide range of clinical and basic science studies, especially genetic, reveals multiple similarities between schizoaffective disorder, schizophrenia and psychotic bipolar. SUMMARY: Schizoaffective disorder unifies schizophrenia and bipolar, blurring the zones of rarity between them and suggesting that schizoaffective disorder is not a separate, 'bona-fide' disease. Patients diagnosed with schizoaffective disorder likely suffer from a psychotic mood disorder. The diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder, which can result in substandard treatment, should be eliminated from the diagnostic nomenclature.     

Changes in VA diagnosis of schizophrenic and affective disorders after DSM-III

DSM-III tightened the criteria for diagnosis of schizophrenia by excluding patients who exhibit a full affective syndrome before the onset of psychotic symptoms; such patients are to receive a diagnosis of affective disorder. The impact of this change on psychiatric diagnostic practices in Veterans Administration facilities before and after publication of DSM-III was assessed. Diagnoses of schizophrenia increased about half as much as would be expected based on the overall increase in psychiatric diagnoses, while diagnoses of affective disorders rose about two and a half times as much as would be expected. Patients whose diagnoses were changed from schizophrenic to affective disorders after publication of DSM-III had significantly fewer hospitalizations in both time periods than patients who retained diagnoses of schizophrenia. However, greater diagnostic inconsistency was found after implementation of DSM-III.     

Does operational diagnosis of schizophrenia significantly impact intellectual deficits in psychotic disorders?

Background Evidence suggests that, as a group, patients with schizophrenia have intellectual deficits that may precede the manifestation of psychotic symptoms; however, how successfully intelligence tests are able to discriminate schizophrenia from other psychotic disorders has yet to be investigated in detail. Methods Using Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale – Revised (WAIS‐R) data for 55 inpatients with schizophrenia and 28 inpatients with non‐schizophrenic psychotic disorders (NSPD) (schizophreniform disorder, brief psychotic disorder, delusional disorder, psychotic disorder due to a general medical condition, and psychotic disorders not otherwise specified), intelligence performance was compared between schizophrenia and NSPD and among different subtypes of schizophrenia. Results There were no significant differences in intelligence quotient (IQ), verbal IQ (VIQ) and performance IQ (PIQ) discrepancy, and subtest scores of WAIS‐R between the patients with schizophrenia and those with NSPD. These diagnostic groups were not discriminated well by any WAIS‐R variables. Schizophrenia patients with prominent negative symptoms, on the other hand, had a significantly larger IQ discrepancy (VIQ > PIQ) than those without prominent negative symptoms and NSPD patients. Intelligence performance in schizophrenia did not differ with respect to diagnostic subtypes and longitudinal courses. Conclusions The current study failed to show diagnostic usefulness of WAIS‐R in discriminating schizophrenia and other psychoses. A diagnosis of schizophrenia does not significantly impact intellectual deficits in psychotic disorders.     

Early onset psychotic disorders: Diagnostic stability and clinical characteristics

To examine the clinical features and diagnostic stability of early-onset psychotic disorders. These data are from a two-year longitudinal prospective study of youth with psychotic disorders. Standardized diagnostic assessments are administered at baseline and at one and two-year’s follow-up. Fifty-one subjects have been recruited to date; 18 with schizophrenia, 14 with bipolar disorder, 7 with schizoaffective disorder, 1 with an organic psychosis, and 11 subjects whose symptoms where either questionable and/or did not meet diagnostic criteria for another disorder (classified as psychosis nos). Thirty-nine subjects were reassessed at year one, twenty-four at year two. Three subjects have been lost to follow-up. The study diagnosis was the same as the first onset diagnosis (prior to entering the study) in 50% of subjects. Over the two-year period of the study, the diagnosis remained unchanged in over 90% of subjects. Subjects with schizophrenia had higher ratings of premorbid impairment, including social withdrawal and dysfunctional peer relationships, than those with bipolar disorder. At the one-year follow-up, subjects with schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder had significantly higher rates of delusions, bizarre behavior, and negative symptoms than those with bipolar disorder. Subjects with bipolar disorder tended to have cyclical courses, whereas those with schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder were often chronically impaired. Subjects with psychosis nos had higher rates of dissociative symptoms and histories of child maltreatment Early-onset psychotic disorders can be reliably diagnosed using standardized assessments and are stable over a two-year period. Compared to bipolar disorder, schizophrenia is associated with a poorer premorbid history, and persistent positive and negative symptoms.     

Diagnosis and treatment of mood disorders that co-occur with schizophrenia.

Affective syndromes, particularly mania and depression, often occur during the course of illness in patients who have a diagnosis of schizophrenia. Our current diagnostic system allows clear classification of the overlap of affective symptoms and psychotic symptoms. However, this diagnostic system will eventually require major revisions so that it will more accurately reflect the biologic mechanisms that underlie different symptoms. This article reviews the historical underpinnings of the diagnostic classification of affective and psychotic symptoms, including a discussion of current diagnostic practices and a review of the few studies on treatment of affective symptoms and syndromes in patients with schizophrenia. There is a great need for additional research on treatment of mood disorders that arise during the course of schizophrenia, especially with regard to newer mood stabilizers and antidepressants.     

Bipolar disorder,schizophrenia, and other psychotic disorders in adults with childhood onset AD/HD and/or autism spectrum disorders

Summary. Individuals with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (AD/HD) and autism spectrum disorders (ASD) often display symptoms from other diagnostic categories. Exclusion criteria in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV) and the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems (ICD-10) impede the use of categorical diagnoses to describe the particular problem constellation in a patient. In this study, we describe the prevalence and patterns of comorbid bipolar and psychotic disorders in 241 consecutively referred adult patients with AD/HD and/or ASD. Thirty per cent of patients with AD/HD had comorbid ASD and 38% of patients with ASD had comorbid AD/HD. Of the subjects with ASD, 7% had bipolar disorder with psychotic features, and 7.8% had schizophrenia or another psychotic disorder. The corresponding figures for the patients with AD/HD were 5.0% and 5.0%, respectively. Current diagnostic criteria have to be revised to acknowledge the comorbidity of bipolar and/or psychotic disorders in AD/HD and ASD.     

Psychosis in a pediatric mood and anxiety disorders clinic: phenomenology and correlates

OBJECTIVES: To examine the demographics and phenomenology of psychosis in a sample of children and adolescents referred to a mood and anxiety disorders clinic. METHOD: Patients (N = 2,031) were assessed with the Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia for School-Age Children-Present Episode version and classified as definite, probable, or nonpsychotic. Clinical and demographic characteristics of the groups were compared,and symptoms of psychosis were analyzed using factor analysis. RESULTS: Definite psychotic symptoms were seen in approximately 90 (4.5%) patients: 80% of these reported hallucinations (mainly auditory), 22% delusions, and 3.3% thought disorder. Of the patients with definite psychotic symptoms, 24% had bipolar disorder, 41% had major depression, 21% had subsyndromal depression, and 14% had schizophrenia spectrum disorders (schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorders). Factor analysis of the definite psychotic symptoms yielded 4 factors: hallucinations, thought disorder, delusions, and manic thought disorder. Psychotic patients had a higher frequency of comorbid disorders and suicidal ideation than nonpsychotic patients. CONCLUSIONS: Outpatient youngsters with mood disorders frequently present with psychotic symptoms, in particular auditory hallucinations. These patients commonly have comorbid psychiatric disorders and suicidal ideation.     

Schizoaffective disorder and affective disorders with mood-incongruent psychotic features: keep separate or combine? Evidence from a family study.

OBJECTIVE: This study investigated whether the distinction between schizoaffective disorder and affective disorders with mood-incongruent psychotic features as described in DSM-III-R is reflected by aggregation of schizophrenia in the families of probands with the former disorder and aggregation of affective disorders mainly among the relatives of probands with the latter type of disorders. METHOD: The probands were 118 inpatients with definite lifetime diagnoses of DSM-III-R schizoaffective disorder or a major mood disorder with incongruent psychotic features according to structured clinical interviews. Diagnostic information on 475 of the probands' first-degree relatives was gathered through direct interviews (with 80% of the living first-degree relatives) or the family history approach. The rates of affective and psychotic disorders among these relatives were then compared with those among the relatives of a comparison group of 109 interviewed individuals from the general population who were matched on sociodemographic factors to the inpatient probands. RESULTS: With regard to the familial aggregation of schizophrenia, the DSM-III-R distinction emerged as valid. However, the risk of unipolar affective disorders was enhanced in the families of all of the subgroups of patients studied. The unipolar/bipolar distinction in both DSM-III-R diagnostic groups was reflected by distinct patterns of bipolar disorders in the relatives. CONCLUSIONS: The results partly support the DSM-III-R dichotomy of schizoaffective disorder and affective disorders with mood-incongruent psychotic features. Although the differences between these two diagnostic groups were significant, the magnitude of the differences remained relatively modest.     

Early onset psychotic disorders: Diagnostic stability and clinical characteristics

Objectives: To examine the clinical features and diagnostic stability of early-onset psychotic disorders. Methods: These data are from a two-year longitudinal prospective study of youth with psychotic disorders. Standardized diagnostic assessments are administered at baseline and at one and two-year's follow-up. Results: Fifty-one subjects have been recruited to date; 18 with schizophrenia, 14 with bipolar disorder, 7 with schizoaffective disorder, 1 with an organic psychosis, and 11 subjects whose symptoms where either questionable and/or did not meet diagnostic criteria for another disorder (classified as psychosis nos). Thirty-nine subjects were reassessed at year one, twenty-four at year two. Three subjects have been lost to follow-up. The study diagnosis was the same as the first onset diagnosis (prior to entering the study) in 50 % of subjects. Over the two-year period of the study, the diagnosis remained unchanged in over 90 % of subjects. Subjects with schizophrenia had higher ratings of premorbid impairment, including social withdrawal and dysfunctional peer relationships, than those with bipolar disorder. At the one-year follow-up, subjects with schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder had significantly higher rates of delusions, bizarre behavior, and negative symptoms than those with bipolar disorder. Subjects with bipolar disorder tended to have cyclical courses, whereas those with schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder were often chronically impaired. Subjects with psychosis nos had higher rates of dissociative symptoms and histories of child maltreatment. Conclusions: Early-onset psychotic disorders can be reliably diagnosed using standardized assessments and are stable over a two-year period. Compared to bipolar disorder, schizophrenia is associated with a poorer premorbid history, and persistent positive and negative symptoms.     

Prevalence of item level negative symptoms in first episode psychosis diagnoses

The relevance of negative symptoms across the diagnostic spectrum of the psychoses remains uncertain. The purpose of this study was to report on prevalence of item and subscale level negative symptoms across the first episode psychosis (FEP) diagnostic spectrum in an epidemiological sample, and to ascertain whether items and subscales were more prevalent in a schizophrenia spectrum diagnoses group compared to an 'all other psychotic diagnoses' group. We measured negative symptoms in 330 patients presenting with FEP using the Scale for Assessment of Negative Symptoms (SANS), and ascertained diagnosis using the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM IV. Prevalence of SANS items and subscales were tabulated across all psychotic diagnoses, and logistic regression analysis determined which items and subscales were predictive of schizophrenia spectrum diagnoses. SANS items were most prevalent in schizophrenia spectrum conditions but frequently presented in other FEP diagnoses, particularly substance induced psychotic disorder and Major Depressive Disorder. Brief psychotic disorder and bipolar disorders had low levels of negative symptoms. SANS items and subscales which significantly predicted schizophrenia spectrum diagnoses, were also frequently present in some of the other psychotic diagnoses. Conclusions: SANS items have high prevalence in FEP, and while commonest in schizophrenia spectrum conditions are not restricted to this diagnostic subgroup.     

Bridging the gap between schizophrenia and psychotic mood disorders: Relating neurocognitive deficits to psychopathology

BackgroundThe neurobiological relationship between schizophrenia and psychotic mood disorders is not well understood. Neurocognitive deficits have been described in both types of disorders and have been proposed to reflect underlying neurobiological dysfunction. Examining the relationship between neurocognitive function and psychopathology could help illuminate the neurobiological relationship between schizophrenia and psychotic mood disorders.MethodsParticipants included 72 individuals with DSM-IV schizophrenia, 25 individuals with schizoaffective disorder or bipolar disorder with psychotic features, and 72 community controls. Standardized scores and correlations between four domains of neurocognition and psychopathology were examined.ResultsIndividuals with schizophrenia and psychotic mood disorders scored similarly on several dimensions of neurocognitive function and psychopathology. The relationships between neurocognitive function and psychopathology were similar in the two groups.ConclusionsIndividuals with schizophrenia and psychotic mood disorders were similar in terms of both the level of impairment in neurocognitive function and psychopathology, as well as in the relationship between the two dimensions of illness. These results suggest that schizophrenia and psychotic mood disorders such as schizoaffective disorder and bipolar disorder with psychotic features are on a neurobiological continuum.     

Neuropsychological function in subjects with psychotic and affective disorders. Relationship to diagnostic category and duration of illness.

OBJECTIVE: To explore the links between neuropsychological performance, diagnostic category and duration of illness in subjects with psychotic and affective disorders. METHODS: Memory and executive abilities were tested in consecutively admitted patients with schizophrenia (N = 20), other non-schizophrenic psychotic disorders (N = 29), bipolar disorder (N = 33) and major depression (N = 19). RESULTS: Subjects with schizophrenia had poorer global memory performances than subjects with major depression, and poorer delayed verbal memory abilities than those from the other three diagnostic groups. Executive abilities explored by the Stroop test and the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test did not differ between diagnostic groups. Neuropsychological performances were not influenced by previous duration of illness. CONCLUSION: Memory deficits are the most discriminatory cognitive features between subjects with schizophrenia and those with other psychotic or mood disorders. The fact that cognitive deficits are static whatever the diagnostic group indirectly suggests that they may have a neurodevelopmental origin in subjects with schizophrenia, but perhaps also in subjects with other psychotic and mood disorders.     

Putative psychotic symptoms in the Mexican American population: prevalence and co-occurrence with psychiatric disorders

It is reported that Latin Americans describe culturally normative experiences or express putative psychotic symptoms in medical and mental health treatment settings that complicate the diagnostic process. Previous research reported that Latinos were more likely than European Americans and African Americans to have their diagnoses changed from schizophrenia to other disorders. This study describes the prevalence and likelihood of putative psychotic symptoms being expressed independent of any psychiatric disorder or co-occurring with common disorders such as depression or anxiety within a Mexican American population sample. Epidemiologic data of the Mexican American Prevalence and Services Survey (N = 3012) were used to contrast rates and patterns of putatively psychotic features among adults by demographic variables and diagnostic status using DSM-III-R criteria and receipt of treatment. Putative psychotic symptoms were reported by 17% of US-born and 7% of immigrants without disorders, and by 38% of US-born and 28% of immigrants with lifetime disorders, totaling 18% lifetime prevalence for the entire study population of Mexican Americans. First-rank Schneiderian symptoms were higher in those with a disorder compared with those without a disorder for both sexes. The results of this study indicate that putative psychotic symptoms are common among Mexican Americans, and their presence is a strong precautionary signal for evaluating clinicians to correctly distinguish whether putative psychotic symptoms are indicators of nonorganic psychoses or other psychiatric disorders, or are simply cultural expressions. Research is needed to identify the determinants of misdiagnosis in clinical practice, and guidelines are needed to assist clinicians.