Radiation-induced DNA damage and repair in quiescent and proliferating human tumor cells in vitro

The purpose of this study was to examine radiation-induced DNA strand breakage and repair in quiescent and proliferating human tumor cells in vitro and determine their relationship to radiation sensitivity and potentially lethal damage repair (PLDR). Using centrifugal elutriation we have isolated from fed plateau-phase cultures of HEp-3 human squamous carcinoma cells, relatively pure populations of quiescent and proliferating cells. This was confirmed by both [3H]-thymidine labelling and acridine orange (AO) staining with flow cytometry. Quiescent cells were more sensitive to ionizing radiation (Do = 0.97 Gy) than were proliferating cells (Do = 1.28 Gy). However, quiescent cells showed higher repair of potentially lethal damage (PLDR) than did proliferating cells. Repair of single-strand breaks (ssb) and double-strand breaks (dsb) as measured by filter elution did not differ significantly between quiescent and proliferating cells. For both populations, ssb and dsb repair kinetics and final damage remaining were the same, suggesting that repair of DNA strand breaks is not entirely responsible for the difference in radiation sensitivity between quiescent and proliferating cells.     

A comparison of the chemical repair rates of free radical precursors of DNA damage and cell killing in Chinese hamster V79 cells.

One of the important temporal stages of radiation action in cellular systems is the chemical phase, where oxygen fixation reactions compete with chemical repair reactions involving reducing agents such as GSH. Using the gas explosion technique it is possible to follow the kinetics of these fast (greater than 1 ms) reactions in intact cells. We have compared the chemical repair kinetics of the oxygen-dependent free radical precursors leading to DNA single-strand and double-strand breaks, measured using filter elution techniques, with those leading to cell killing in V79 cells. The chemical repair rates for DNA dsb (670s-1 at pH 7.2 and 380s-1 at pH 9.6) and cell killing (530s-1) were similar. This is in agreement with the important role of DNA dsb in radiation induced cell lethality. The rate for DNA ssb precursors was significantly slower (210s-1). The difference in rate between DNA ssb and dsb precursors may be explained on the basis of a dsb free radical precursor consisting of a paired radical, one radical on each strand. The instantaneous probability of one or other of these radicals being chemically repaired and not proceeding to form a dsb will be twice that of ssb radical precursor. This agrees well with the concept of locally multiply damaged sites (LMDS) produced from clusters of ionizations in DNA (Ward 1985).     

Reduction of Intracellular Glutathione Content and Radiosensitivity

Summary

The intracellular glutathione (GSH) content of HeLa, CHO and V79 cells was reduced by incubating the cells in growth medium containing buthionine sulphoximine or diethyl maleate (DEM). Clonogenicity, single-strand DNA breaks (ssb) and double-strand DNA breaks (dsb) were used as criteria for radiation-induced damage after X- or γ-irradiation. In survival experiments, DEM gave a slightly larger sensitization although it gave a smaller reduction of the intracellular GSH. In general, sensitization was larger for dsb than for ssb, also the reduction of the o.e.r. was generally larger for dsb than for ssb. This may be due to the higher dose rate in case of dsb experiments resulting in a higher rate of radiochemical oxygen consumption. In general, no effect was found on post-irradiation repair of ssb and dsb.     

Cell killing and DNA damage in Chinese hamster V79 cells treated with hydrogen peroxide

Hydrogen peroxide induces lesions in cells similar to those from ionizing radiation, by a Fenton-type production of hydroxyl radicals. At 4 degrees C significant levels of DAN single-strand breaks (ssb) could be measured using the alkaline elution technique, after a 20-min incubation with 10(-5) mol dm-3 H2O2. Only at higher concentrations of H2O2 (greater than 10(-4) mol dm-3) where the levels of ssb measured corresponded to that induced by more than 18 Gy of X-rays, was any significant cell killing detected in a clonogenic assay. Cell killing was observed to coincide with the measurement of significant levels of DNA double-strand breaks (dsb) using the filter elution technique at pH 9.6. This suggests that dsb and not ssb are important as regards hydroxyl-radical-induced cell kill, as found for ionizing radiation. The correlation of induced dsb with lethal events showed that the predicted lethal effect of the H2O2-induced dsb was approximately 5 times less than that of X-ray-induced dsb. This is compared with data previously obtained which showed differences in the lethality of dsb with the quality of radiation (Prise et al. 1987).     

A Comparison of the Chemical Repair Rates of Free Radical Precursors of DNA Damage and Cell Killing in Chinese Hamster V79 Cells

One of the important temporal stages of radiation action in cellular systems is the chemical phase, where oxygen fixation reactions compete with chemical repair reactions involving reducing agents such as GSH. Using the gas explosion technique it is possible to follow the kinetics of these fast (> 1 ms) reactions in intact cells. We have compared the chemical repair kinetics of the oxygen-dependent free radical precursors leading to DNA single-strand and double-strand breaks, measured using filter elution techniques, with those leading to cell killing in V79 cells. The chemical repair rates for DNA dsb (670 s^?1 at pH 7·2 and 380 s^?1 at pH 9·6) and cell killing (530 s^?1) were similar. This is in agreement with the important role of DNA dsb in radiation induced cell lethality. The rate for DNA ssb precursors was significantly slower (210 s^?1). The difference in rate between DNA ssb and dsb precursors may be explained on the basis of a dsb free radical precursor consisting of a paired radical, one radical on each strand. The instantaneous probability of one or other of these radicals being chemically repaired and not proceeding to form a dsb will be twice that of a ssb radical precursor. This agrees well with the concept of locally multiply damaged sites (LMDS) produced from clusters of ionizations in DNA (Ward 1985).     

DNA damage and repair in rodent and human cells after exposure to JANUS fission spectrum neutrons: a minor fraction of single-strand breaks as revealed by alkaline elution is refractory to repair

We have examined the induction and repair of breaks induced in the DNA of Chinese hamster V79 and human P3 epithelial teratocarcinoma cells by JANUS fission-spectrum neutrons (mean energy 0.85 MeV) and 60Co gamma radiation in the biological dose range, using alkaline filter elution methods. Fission-spectrum neutrons induce fewer immediate single-strand breaks (ssb) per gray of absorbed dose than do gamma rays, as measured by alkaline elution methods. Previous survival measurements have indicated incomplete recovery after neutron exposures. The present data demonstrate that whereas most ssb caused by exposure to fission-spectrum neutrons can be rapidly repaired by both cell lines, a small but statistically significant fraction of the ssb induced by exposure to 6 Gy of neutrons is refractory to repair. In contrast, all measurable ssb induced by 3 Gy gamma rays are rapidly repaired.     

Comparative effect of the thiols dithiothreitol, cysteamine and WR-151326 on survival and on the induction of DNA damage in cultured Chinese hamster ovary cells exposed to gamma-radiation

We compared the ability of three thiols--dithiothreitol (DTT), cysteamine and WR-151326--to protect aerated Chinese hamster ovary cells from the lethal and DNA-damaging effects of gamma-radiation. These results were compared with earlier measurements for WR-1065 and WR-255591. The time-course and the concentration dependence of protection against cell killing was determined after 10 Gy of gamma-rays. The aminothiols cysteamine and WR-151326 protected at much lower extracellular concentrations than the simple thiol DTT; however, there was no clear difference between the behaviour of cysteamine, WR-151326, WR-1065 and WR-255591 in this respect. Protection by DTT and cysteamine was complete within 1 min, whereas for WR-151326, WR-1065 and WR-255591 about 30 min was required before protection began to reach a plateau. Based on these data, complete radiation survival curves were generated for each thiol and protection factors calculated. Effects on the induction of DNA single-strand breaks (ssb) and double-strand breaks (dsb) by gamma-rays were measured using alkaline (pH 12.1) and neutral (pH 7.0 and 9.6) elution, respectively. All three thiols protected against ssb induction, although to a significantly lower extent than against cell killing measured under identical conditions. Each thiol also protected against dsb induction. After high radiation doses the protection factors for dsb induction were also less than the protection factors for cell survival; however, when dsb were assayed using the low-dose replicate plating neutral elution method, the relative effect of each thiol on cell survival and on dsb induction appeared to be equivalent. The hierarchy of protection against both ssb and dsb induction (based on the extracellular thiol concentration required to produce a given degree of protection) was similar to that for cell survival, i.e., WR-151326 congruent to cysteamine less than DTT.     

Correlation between non-repairable DNA lesions and fixation of cell damage by hypertonic solutions in Chinese hamster cells

In Chinese hamster HA-1 cells, killing induced by gamma-rays was enhanced by post-irradiation treatment with hypertonic solution (0.5 mol/l NaCl in phosphate buffered saline, pH 7.2) for 20 min. The initial DNA double-strand breaks (dsb) induced by gamma-rays were repaired during post-irradiation treatment with hypertonic solution. However, hypertonic treatment following gamma-irradiation enhanced the frequency of non-repairable dsb, as compared with the frequency after incubation at 37 degrees C following gamma-irradiation. Hypertonic treatment did not affect the initial half-time for rejoining of dsb. Hypertonic treatment did not enhance cell killing, nor did it enhance the non-repairable dsb when the irradiated cells were incubated at 37 degrees C for 2 h. These results suggest that fixation of gamma-ray-induced potentially lethal damage by hypertonic treatment results from inhibition of the rejoining of dsb.     

The rejoining of DNA double-strand breaks following irradiation with 238Pu alpha-particles: evidence for a fast component of repair as measured by neutral filter elution

The induction and repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSB) following exposure to 238Pu alpha-particles was examined in V79-379A cells. The technique of neutral filter elution was used in these investigations at both pH 9.6 and pH 7.2. The initial dsb yield was found to be similar to that seen after 250 kVp X-ray or 2.3 MeV neutron exposure. However, the pattern of dsb rejoining after alpha-particle irradiation did not follow that seen after X-rays or neutrons. A very fast initial component, complete within 2 min of incubation following irradiation, removed 70 per cent of the dsb seen after 40 Gy alpha-particles; very little slow rejoining was seen. This contrasts sharply with the dsb rejoining seen after X-ray or neutron exposure, and presumably reflects the differences in the nature of the dsb induced and the way they are repaired.     

Radioprotection of cultured Chinese hamster ovary cells by WR-255591

We examined the radioprotective effect of the aminothiol WR-255591 and its phosphorothioate derivative WR-3689 on aerated cultured Chinese hamster ovary cells. At concentrations up to 10 mmol dm-3, WR-3689 afforded little protection from the lethal effects of gamma-radiation. The free thiol WR-255591, on the other hand, efficiently protected these cells, giving a protection factor (PF) for cell survival of 2.3 at a concentration of 6 mmol dm-3. The effects of WR-255591 on the induction and rejoining of gamma-ray-induced DNA single-strand breaks (ssb) and double-strand breaks (dsb) were measured using alkaline (pH 12.1) and neutral (pH 7.0 or 9.6) elution, respectively. PFs calculated from these data were compared with the PFs measured for cell survival. WR-255591 (6 mmol dm-3) protected against the induction of both DNA ssb and dsb; however, the magnitude of the modification of both ssb (PF of 1.23) and dsb (PF of 1.83 at pH 7.0 and 1.70 at pH 9.6) was less than that for cell survival (PF of 2.3) measured under identical conditions (irradiation on ice). Treatment of cells with WR-255591 prior to irradiation retarded the subsequent rate of ssb rejoining but had no effect on dsb rejoining. Postirradiation treatment with the drug slightly retarded ssb rejoining but had no effect on cell survival. The observation of lower PFs for DNA strand breaks than for cell survival suggests that radioprotection by WR-255591 probably does not result from a uniform decrease in the induction of all types of DNA lesions. Rather, the drug may differentially protect against the induction of subclasses of DNA damage--which could also explain the effects on the kinetics of ssb rejoining--and/or enhance cellular recovery processes.     

Poly(ADP-ribose) metabolism in proliferating versus quiescent cells and its relationship to their radiation responses

In the murine tumour cell lines 66 and 67 growing in vitro, quiescent (Q; unfed plateau-phase) cells are more sensitive to X-ray-induced cell killing than are proliferating (P) cells, while St4 cells (Q cells that have been re-fed and returned to 37 degrees C for 4h) are similar to P cells in radiosensitivity. We have been investigating parameters of poly(ADP-ribose) metabolism in order to determine whether such factors contribute to the variations in radiosensitivity of these growth states. These parameters were cellular NAD content, the activity of poly(ADP-ribose) transferase (ADPRT) in permeabilized cells and the activity of poly(ADP-ribose)-degrading enzymes. The results suggest that in line 66, but not 67, a reduced ability to regenerate NAD following irradiation was associated with the reduced survival of Q cells. However, neither the baseline activity of ADPRT nor the degree of stimulation of ADPRT by X-rays was found to correlate with survival, or with the induction and repair of DNA strand breaks. Stimulation of ADPRT by X-rays was dependent on dose and was greatest for a 2-min incubation with 3H-NAD. For a 2-min incubation the stimulation of ADPRT following a dose of 50 Gy was 7- and 10-fold in 66 and 67 P cells, respectively, versus 3-4-fold in Q cells. Detectable stimulation was observed in 66 P and Q cells for doses as low as 5 Gy. P and Q cells did not differ in the rate of degradation of the poly(ADP-ribose) polymers.     

Cell Killing and DNA Damage in Chinese Hamster V79 Cells Treated with Hydrogen Peroxide

Summary

Hydrogen peroxide induces lesions in cells similar to those from ionizing radiation, by a Fenton-type production of hydroxyl radicals. At 4°C significant levels of DNA single-strand breaks (ssb) could be measured using the alkaline elution technique, after a 20-min incubation with 10^?5 mol dm^?3 H₂O₂. Only at higher concentrations of H₂O₂ (> 10^?4 mol dm^?3) where the levels of ssb measured corresponded to that induced by more than 18 Gy of X-rays, was any significant cell killing detected in a clonogenic assay. Cell killing was observed to coincide with the measurement of significant levels of DNA double-strand breaks (dsb) using the filter elution technique at pH 9·6. This suggests that dsb and not ssb are important as regards hydroxyl-radical-induced cell kill, as found for ionizing radiation. The correlation of induced dsb with lethal events showed that the predicted lethal effect of the H₂O₂-induced dsb was approximately 5 times less than that of X-ray-induced dsb. This is compared with data previously obtained which showed differences in the lethality of dsb with the quality of radiation (Prise et al. 1987).     

Level of DNA double-strand break rejoining in Chinese hamster xrs-5 cells is dose-dependent: implications for the mechanism of radiosensitivity.

Rejoining of DNA double-strand breaks (dsb) was measured in a dsb repair-deficient mutant of CHO cells, xrs-5, after exposure to various doses of X-rays in the range between 15 and 50 Gy. For the experiments plateau-phase cultures were employed and dsb assayed by a pulsed field gel electrophoresis assay, the asymmetric field inversion gel electrophoresis (AFIGE). The half-times of dsb rejoining were larger in xrs-5 than in parental CHO cells and increased in both cell lines with increasing dose of radiation. The fraction of dsb remaining unrejoined after 240 min incubation at 37 degrees C was also higher in xrs-5 than in CHO cells, but decreased with decreasing dose of radiation. Although a decrease in the fraction of unrepaired dsb with decreasing dose has also been reported for repair-proficient cell lines, the extent of the phenomenon and its dependence on dose are entirely different in xrs-5 cells. We propose that this decrease in the fraction of unrejoined dsb with decreasing dose of radiation derives from the genetic alterations underlying the increased sensitivity to radiation of xrs-5 cells, and should be considered whenever results at the DNA level are correlated to results at the cell level. It is likely that similar responses will also be observed in other radiation-sensitive mutant cell lines deficient in dsb repair. There was no difference in the induction of dsb per Gy and dalton, as measured with AFIGE, between CHO and xrs-5 cells tested either in the exponential or in the plateau phase of growth.     

Relationship between cellular radiosensitivity and non-repaired double-strand breaks studied for different growth states, dose rates and plating conditions in a normal human fibroblast line

PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to test under which conditions non-repaired DNA double-strand breaks (dsb) could be used as an indicator of cellular radiosensitivity of normal human fibroblasts. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The experiments were performed with a primary normal skin fibroblast line (NFHH) derived from a healthy donor. Cells were X-irradiated either in exponential or confluent state with high (4 Gy/min) or low dose rate (0.04 Gy/min) and either plated immediately or delayed after irradiation. The fraction of clonogenic cells was determined after doses up to 12 Gy using colony forming assay and the number of non-repaired dsb were measured 24 h after X-irradiation with doses up to 180 Gy using constant-field gel electrophoresis. RESULTS: Cellular radiosensitivity of NFHH cells was found to depend on all three conditions tested. In contrast, the number of non-repaired dsb was found to depend on dose rate and growth state only. There were, however, no differences for the plating conditions tested. This result was attributed to the almost complete inhibition of cell-cycle progression when cells were plated immediately after irradiation. For the two dose rates and growth conditions, differences in non-repaired dsb were found to correspond with the respective differences measured for the cellular radiosensitivity, and these data agreed fairly well with the correlation previously found for 11 fibroblast lines varying in dsb repair capacity. CONCLUSIONS: For irradiation followed by delayed plating only, non-repaired dsb can be used to predict the cellular radiosensitivity.     

The Rejoining of DNA Double-strand Breaks Following Irradiation with 238Pu α-particles: Evidence for a Fast Component of Repair as Measured by Neutral Filter Elution

Summary

The induction and repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSB) following exposure to ²³⁸Pu α-particles was examined in V79-379A cells. The technique of neutral filter elution was used in these investigations at both pH 9·6 and pH 7·2. The initial dsb yield was found to be similar to that seen after 250 kVp X-ray or 2·3 MeV neutron exposure. However, the pattern of dsb rejoining after α-particle irradiation did not follow that seen after X-rays or neutrons. A very fast initial component, complete within 2 min of incubation following irradiation, removed 70 per cent of the dsb seen after 40 Gy α-particles; very little slow rejoining was seen. This contrasts sharply with the dsb rejoining seen after X-ray or neutron exposure, and presumably reflects the differences in the nature of the dsb induced and the way they are repaired.     

Comparison of repair of DNA double-strand breaks caused by neutron or gamma radiation in cultured human cells.

The dose-response for the induction of initial double-strand breaks (dsb) in DNA of human epithelioid cells by JANUS 0.85 MeV fission-spectrum neutrons was parabolic as assayed by a calibrated neutral filter elution technique. The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of these neutrons relative to 60Co gamma-rays was unity. The kinetics of repair after a 60 Gy gamma-ray exposure were biphasic. About 65% of these dsb were rapidly repaired (T 1/2 of approximately 2 min), and the remainder were almost completely removed after 150 min at a slower rate (T 1/2 = 30 min). After the same dose of JANUS neutrons, the rapid repair component was markedly reduced (possibly not a significant repair component), and the bulk of the dsb were sealed more slowly (T 1/2 = 90 min). After 150 min, 25% remained unsealed. Even after a lower neutron dose (20 Gy), a proportion of the dsb were refractory to repair. Thus, unrepaired (or irreparable) dsb induced by high energy neutrons might explain the high RBE of neutrons for cell killing.     

Radiation-induced DNA double-strand break frequencies in human squamous cell carcinoma cell lines of different radiation sensitivities.

DNA neutral (pH 9.6) filter elution was used to measure radiation-induced DNA double-strand break (dsb) frequencies in eight human squamous cell carcinoma cell lines with radiosensitivities (D0) ranging from 1.07 to 2.66 Gy and D values ranging from 1.46 to 4.08 Gy. The elution profiles of unirradiated samples from more radiosensitive cell lines were all steeper in slope than the profiles from resistant cells. The shapes of the dsb induction curves were curvilinear and there was some variability from cell line to cell line in the dose-response for the induction of DNA dsb after exposures to 5-100 Gy 60Co gamma-rays. There was no relation between the shapes of the survival curves and the shapes of the dose-responses for the induction of DNA dsb. At low doses (5-25 Gy), three out of four of the more sensitive cell lines (D less than 2.5 Gy) had larger initial break frequencies than the more resistant lines (D greater than 3.0 Gy). Although the low-dose (5-25 Gy) elution results were variable, they do suggest that DNA neutral elution will detect differences between sensitive and resistant tumour cells in initial DNA dsb frequencies.     

Effect of heat on dsb repair in G1- and S-phase studied in the human HeLa S3 cell line

Purpose : The aim of this study was to investigate the relation between double-strand breaks and thermal radiosensitization in dependence on cell-cycle position. Materials and methods : The experiments were performed with the human tumour cell line HeLa S3. Cells synchronized in G1- and S-phase were exposed to X-rays alone or in combination with prior heating at 44° C for 20 min. Cell kill was determined by means of colony forming assay, double-strand breaks (dsb) using constant-field gel electrophoresis and apoptotic cell death was scored using the fraction of detached cells. Results : In both cell-cycle phases heating at 44° C for 20min prior to irradiation resulted in an increased cellular radiosensitivity, whereby the thermal enhancement ratio (TER) was significantly higher in S- than in G1-phase cells with TER=2.1 and 1.2, respectively. Prior heating at 44° C did not affect the number of radiation-induced dsb but was found to modify their repair as measured for a X-ray dose of 40Gy. In both cell cycle phases dsb repair kinetics measured after irradiation alone could be described by a fast and a slow component with the majority of dsb being repaired with fast kinetics. Prior heating at 44° C was found to have only a minor effect on these half-times but mainly to affect the number of slowly rejoined dsb. In G1-phase cells the number of slowly rejoined dsb measured 300min after irradiation was enhanced by a factor of 1.8 and in S-phase cells even by a factor of 3.2. Fraction of apoptotically dying cells was low after X-irradiation alone but was clearly enhanced after combined treatment, which was especially pronounced for S-phase cells. Conclusions : The pronounced thermal radiosensitization found for S-phase cells was attributed to the heat-mediated increase in the number of slowly rejoined dsb and partly also to the enhanced fraction of apoptotically dying cells when compared to G1-phase cells.     

Radiation-induced DNA Double-strand Break Frequencies in Human Squamous Cell Carcinoma Cell Lines of Different Radiation Sensitivities

Summary

DNA neutral (pH 9·6) filter elution was used to measure radiation-induced DNA double-strand break (dsb) frequencies in eight human squamous cell carcinoma cell lines with radiosensitivities (D₀) ranging from 1·07 to 2·66 Gy and D¯ values ranging from 1·46 to 4·08 Gy. The elution profiles of unirradiated samples from more radiosensitive cell lines were all steeper in slope than the profiles from resistant cells. The shapes of the dsb induction curves were curvilinear and there was some variability from cell line to cell line in the dose-response for the induction of DNA dsb after exposures to 5–100 Gy ⁶⁰Co γ-rays. There was no relation between the shapes of the survival curves and the shapes of the dose-responses for the induction of DNA dsb. At low doses (5–25 Gy), three out of four of the more sensitive cell lines (D¯ < 2·5 Gy) had larger initial break frequencies than the more resistant lines (D¯ > 3·0 Gy). Although the low-dose (5–25 Gy) elution results were variable, they do suggest that DNA neutral elution will detect differences between sensitive and resistant tumour cells in initial DNA dsb frequencies.     

DNA double-strand break repair determines the RBE of alpha-particles

Radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks (dsb) were studied in Ehrlich ascites tumour cells (EATC) by sedimentation in neutral sucrose gradients at low centrifuge speed. Dsb induction was found to be linear with dose with a frequency of: ndsbmr-1D-1 = (11.7 +/- 2) x 10(-12)Gy-1 for 140 kV X-rays and ndsbmr-1D-1 = (19.1 +/- 4) x 10(-12)Gy-1 for 3.4 MeV 241Am-alpha-particles. Postirradiation incubation of cells under non-growth conditions leads to repair of dsb, reaching a maximum after trep = 24 h. More than 97 per cent of dsb were repaired after an X-ray dose of 25 Gy. The number of residual dsb was found to be a linear-quadratic function of dose: nresmr-1 = (0.0161 +/- 0.0008) x 10(-12)Gy-2D2 for X-rays and nresmr-1 = (1.2 +/- 0.7) x 10(-12)Gy-1D + (0.105 +/- 0.017) x 10(-12)Gy-2D2 for alpha-particles. Thus, after cellular repair the RBE value of alpha-particles was increased from RBE = 1.6 +/- 0.4 (induction of dsb) to a dose-dependent value of RBE = 2.7 +/- 0.4 (at 100 Gy alpha-particles) to 3.8 +/- 1.2 (at 10 Gy alpha-particles) for residual dsb. From the data presented it is concluded that residual dsb are a major cause for loss of the reproductive capacity of EATC after irradiation with X-rays as well as alpha-particles.