Exon skipping for nonsense mutations in Duchenne muscular dystrophy: too many mutations, too few patients?

Introduction: Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), one of the most common and lethal genetic disorders, is caused by mutations of the dystrophin gene. Removal of an exon or of multiple exons using antisense molecules has been demonstrated to allow synthesis of truncated 'Becker muscular dystrophy-like' dystrophin. Areas covered: Approximately 15% of DMD cases are caused by a nonsense mutation. Although patient databases have previously been surveyed for applicability to each deletion mutation pattern, this is not so for nonsense mutations. Here, we examine the world-wide database containing notations for more than 1200 patients with nonsense mutations. Approximately 47% of nonsense mutations can be potentially treated with single exon skipping, rising to 90% with double exon skipping, but to reach this proportion requires the development of exon skipping molecules targeting some 68 of dystrophin's 79 exons, with patient numbers spread thinly across those exons. In this review, we discuss progress and remaining hurdles in exon skipping and an alternative strategy, stop-codon readthrough. Expert opinion: Antisense-mediated exon skipping therapy is targeted highly at the individual patient and is a clear example of personalized medicine. An efficient regulatory path for drug approval will be a key to success.     

ENA oligonucleotides as therapeutics

Oligonucleotides containing 2'-O,4'-C-ethylene-bridged nucleic acid (ENA) residues have two notable properties: (i) considerable affinity to complementary single-stranded RNA and double-stranded DNA; and (ii) dramatically high resistance against nucleases. On the basis of these properties, the in vitro and in vivo applications of ENA for gene silencing as antisense oligonucleotides, triplex-forming oligonucleotides and small interfering RNAs are discussed here. ENA oligonucleotides also have potential as therapeutic agents for Duchenne muscular dystrophy by a mechanism of exon skipping.     

Exon skipping for nonsense mutations in Duchenne muscular dystrophy: too many mutations,too few patients?

Introduction: Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), one of the most common and lethal genetic disorders, is caused by mutations of the dystrophin gene. Removal of an exon or of multiple exons using antisense molecules has been demonstrated to allow synthesis of truncated ‘Becker muscular dystrophy-like’ dystrophin.

Areas covered: Approximately 15% of DMD cases are caused by a nonsense mutation. Although patient databases have previously been surveyed for applicability to each deletion mutation pattern, this is not so for nonsense mutations. Here, we examine the world-wide database containing notations for more than 1200 patients with nonsense mutations. Approximately 47% of nonsense mutations can be potentially treated with single exon skipping, rising to 90% with double exon skipping, but to reach this proportion requires the development of exon skipping molecules targeting some 68 of dystrophin's 79 exons, with patient numbers spread thinly across those exons. In this review, we discuss progress and remaining hurdles in exon skipping and an alternative strategy, stop-codon readthrough.

Expert opinion: Antisense-mediated exon skipping therapy is targeted highly at the individual patient and is a clear example of personalized medicine. An efficient regulatory path for drug approval will be a key to success.     

Combination Antisense Treatment for Destructive Exon Skipping of Myostatin and Open Reading Frame Rescue of Dystrophin in Neonatal mdx Mice

The fatal X-linked Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), characterized by progressive muscle wasting and muscle weakness, is caused by mutations within the DMD gene. The use of antisense oligonucleotides (AOs) modulating pre-mRNA splicing to restore the disrupted dystrophin reading frame, subsequently generating a shortened but functional protein has emerged as a potential strategy in DMD treatment. AO therapy has recently been applied to induce out-of-frame exon skipping of myostatin pre-mRNA, knocking-down expression of myostatin protein, and such an approach is suggested to enhance muscle hypertrophy/hyperplasia and to reduce muscle necrosis. Within this study, we investigated dual exon skipping of dystrophin and myostatin pre-mRNAs using phosphorodiamidate morpholino oligomers conjugated with an arginine-rich peptide (B-PMOs). Intraperitoneal administration of B-PMOs was performed in neonatal mdx males on the day of birth, and at weeks 3 and 6. At week 9, we observed in treated mice (as compared to age-matched, saline-injected controls) normalization of muscle mass, a recovery in dystrophin expression, and a decrease in muscle necrosis, particularly in the diaphragm. Our data provide a proof of concept for antisense therapy combining dystrophin restoration and myostatin inhibition for the treatment of DMD.     

Engineering Multiple U7snRNA Constructs to Induce Single and Multiexon-skipping for Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a fatal muscle wasting disorder caused by mutations in the dystrophin gene. Antisense-mediated exon skipping is one of the most promising approaches for the treatment of DMD but still faces personalized medicine challenges as different mutations found in DMD patients require skipping of different exons. However, 70% of DMD patients harbor dystrophin gene deletions in a mutation-rich area or “hot-spot” in the central genomic region. In this study, we have developed 11 different U7 small-nuclear RNA, to shuttle antisense sequences designed to mask key elements involved in the splicing of exons 45 to 55. We demonstrate that these constructs induce efficient exon skipping both in vitro in DMD patients'' myoblasts and in vivo in human DMD (hDMD) mice and that they can be combined into a single vector to achieve a multi skipping of at least 3 exons. These very encouraging results provide proof of principle that efficient multiexon-skipping can be achieved using adeno-associated viral (AAV) vectors encoding multiple U7 small-nuclear RNAs (U7snRNAs), offering therefore very promising tools for clinical treatment of DMD.     

Exon Skipping and Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy Therapy: Selection of the Most Active U1 snRNA Antisense Able to Induce Dystrophin Exon 51 Skipping

One promising approach for the gene therapy of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is exon skipping. When thinking of possible intervention on human, it is very crucial to identify the most appropriate antisense sequences able to provide the highest possible skipping efficiency. In this article, we compared the exon 51 skipping activity of 10 different antisense molecules, raised against splice junctions and/or exonic splicing enhancers (ESEs), expressed as part of the U1 small nuclear RNA (snRNA). The effectiveness of each construct was tested in human DMD myoblasts carrying the deletion of exons 48–50, which can be treated with skipping of exon 51. Our results show that the highest skipping activity and dystrophin rescue is achieved upon expression of a U1 snRNA-derived antisense molecule targeting exon 51 splice sites in combination with an internal exon sequence. The efficacy of this molecule was further proven on an exon 45–50 deletion background, utilizing patient''s fibroblasts transdifferentiated into myoblasts. In this system, we showed that the selected antisense was able to produce 50% skipping of exon 51.     

Enhanced Exon-skipping Induced by U7 snRNA Carrying a Splicing Silencer Sequence: Promising Tool for DMD Therapy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a fatal muscle wasting disorder caused by mutations in the dystrophin gene. In most cases, the open-reading frame is disrupted which results in the absence of functional protein. Antisense-mediated exon skipping is one of the most promising approaches for the treatment of DMD and has recently been shown to correct the reading frame and restore dystrophin expression in vitro and in vivo. Specific exon skipping can be achieved using synthetic oligonucleotides or viral vectors encoding modified small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs), by masking important splicing sites. In this study, we demonstrate that enhanced exon skipping can be induced by a U7 snRNA carrying binding sites for the heterogeneous ribonucleoprotein A1 (hnRNPA1). In DMD patient cells, bifunctional U7 snRNAs harboring silencer motifs induce complete skipping of exon 51, and thus restore dystrophin expression to near wild-type levels. Furthermore, we show the efficacy of these constructs in vivo in transgenic mice carrying the entire human DMD locus after intramuscular injection of adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors encoding the bifunctional U7 snRNA. These new constructs are very promising for the optimization of therapeutic exon skipping for DMD, but also offer powerful and versatile tools to modulate pre-mRNA splicing in a wide range of applications.     

Comparative analysis of antisense oligonucleotide sequences for targeted skipping of exon 51 during dystrophin pre-mRNA splicing in human muscle

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is caused by mutations in the dystrophin gene that result in the absence of functional protein. In the majority of cases these are out-of-frame deletions that disrupt the reading frame. Several attempts have been made to restore the dystrophin mRNA reading frame by modulation of pre-mRNA splicing with antisense oligonucleotides (AOs), demonstrating success in cultured cells, muscle explants, and animal models. We are preparing for a phase I/IIa clinical trial aimed at assessing the safety and effect of locally administered AOs designed to inhibit inclusion of exon 51 into the mature mRNA by the splicing machinery, a process known as exon skipping. Here, we describe a series of systematic experiments to validate the sequence and chemistry of the exon 51 AO reagent selected to go forward into the clinical trial planned in the United Kingdom. Eight specific AO sequences targeting exon 51 were tested in two different chemical forms and in three different preclinical models: cultured human muscle cells and explants (wild type and DMD), and local in vivo administration in transgenic mice harboring the entire human DMD locus. Data have been validated independently in the different model systems used, and the studies describe a rational collaborative path for the preclinical selection of AOs for evaluation in future clinical trials.     

Disruption of the splicing enhancer sequence within exon 27 of the dystrophin gene by a nonsense mutation induces partial skipping of the exon and is responsible for Becker muscular dystrophy.

The mechanism of exon skipping induced by nonsense mutations has not been well elucidated. We now report results of in vitro splicing studies which disclosed that a particular example of exon skipping is due to disruption of a splicing enhancer sequence located within the exon. A nonsense mutation (E1211X) due to a G to T transversion at the 28th nucleotide of exon 27 (G3839T) was identified in the dystrophin gene of a Japanese Becker muscular dystrophy case. Partial skipping of the exon resulted in the production of truncated dystrophin mRNA, although the consensus sequences for splicing at both ends of exon 27 were unaltered. To determine how E1211X induced exon 27 skipping, the splicing enhancer activity of purine-rich region within exon 27 was examined in an in vitro splicing system using chimeric doublesex gene pre-mRNA. The mutant sequence containing G3839T abolished splicing enhancer activity of the wild-type purine-rich sequence for the upstream intron in this chimeric pre-mRNA. An artificial polypurine oligonucleotide mimicking the purine-rich sequence of exon 27 also showed enhancer activity that was suppressed by the introduction of a T nucleotide. Furthermore, the splicing enhancer activity was more markedly inhibited when a nonsense codon was created by the inserted T residue. This is the first evidence that partial skipping of an exon harboring a nonsense mutation is due to disruption of a splicing enhancer sequence.     

Autologous transplantation of muscle precursor cells modified with a lentivirus for muscular dystrophy: human cells and primate models.

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is characterized by the absence of dystrophin. We tested the ability of lentiviral vectors to deliver a transgene into myogenic cells before their transplantation. Enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP) transgene was efficiently transferred into cells and eGFP-positive fibers were generated following transplantation. An eGFP-micro-dystrophin transgene under the control of a cytomegalovirus promoter was then transferred with the same viral vector but caused some toxicity to the mono-nucleated cells. We then used instead a muscle creatine kinase promoter. Dystrophin expression was observed in the muscle fibers after the transplantation of such genetically modified cells into mdx and severe combined immunodeficient mice. Micro-dystrophin expression was also observed in monkey muscles a month after allogenic or autologous transplantation of genetically modified myoblasts. Therapeutic exon skipping was induced by infecting myoblasts of a DMD patient, deleted for dystrophin exons 49 and 50, with a lentivirus expressing a U7 small nuclear RNA containing antisense sequences against exon 51. The modification led to correct exon skipping and to the expression of a quasi-dystrophin in vitro and in vivo. These results demonstrate the feasibility of lentiviral-based ex vivo gene therapy for DMD.     

Rational Design of Antisense Oligomers to Induce Dystrophin Exon Skipping

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), one of the most severe neuromuscular disorders of childhood, is caused by the absence of a functional dystrophin. Antisense oligomer (AO) induced exon skipping is being investigated to restore functional dystrophin expression in models of muscular dystrophy and DMD patients. One of the major challenges will be in the development of clinically relevant oligomers and exon skipping strategies to address many different mutations. Various models, including cell-free extracts, cells transfected with artificial constructs, or mice with a human transgene, have been proposed as tools to facilitate oligomer design. Despite strong sequence homology between the human and mouse dystrophin genes, directing an oligomer to the same motifs in both species does not always induce comparable exon skipping. We report substantially different levels of exon skipping induced in normal and dystrophic human myogenic cell lines and propose that animal models or artificial assay systems useful in initial studies may be of limited relevance in designing the most efficient compounds to induce targeted skipping of human dystrophin exons for therapeutic outcomes.     

Targeted exon skipping in transgenic hDMD mice: A model for direct preclinical screening of human-specific antisense oligonucleotides.

The therapeutic potential of frame-restoring exon skipping by antisense oligonucleotides (AONs) has recently been demonstrated in cultured muscle cells from a series of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) patients. To facilitate clinical application, in vivo studies in animal models are required to develop safe and efficient AON-delivery methods. However, since exon skipping is a sequence-specific therapy, it is desirable to target the human DMD gene directly. We therefore set up human sequence-specific exon skipping in transgenic mice carrying the full-size human gene (hDMD). We initially compared the efficiency and toxicity of intramuscular AON injections using different delivery reagents in wild-type mice. At a dose of 3.6 nmol AON and using polyethylenimine, the skipping levels accumulated up to 3% in the second week postinjection and lasted for 4 weeks. We observed a correlation of this long-term effect with the intramuscular persistence of the AON. In regenerating myofibers higher efficiencies (up to 9%) could be obtained. Finally, using the optimized protocols in hDMD mice, we were able to induce the specific skipping of human DMD exons without affecting the endogenous mouse gene. These data highlight the high sequence specificity of this therapy and present the hDMD mouse as a unique model to optimize human-specific exon skipping in vivo.