Revision Stapedectomy: Intraoperative Findings,Results, and Review of the Literature

Seventy-four revision stapedectomies performed consecutively over 10 years (1986 to 1995) were reviewed retrospectively. The most common intraoperative findings were incus erosion, prosthesis displacement, and oval window closure. Incus erosion was more frequently associated with multiple revisions. The postoperative results were reported using the conventional method (postoperative air minus preoperative bone) as well as the guidelines recently published by the American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery (postoperative air minus postoperative bone), with success rates of postoperative air-bone gap closure to within 10 dB after revision surgery of 51.6% and 45.6%, respectively. Patients with persistent conductive hearing loss(large residual air-bone gaps) after primary stapedectomy had poorer postrevision hearing results. Sensorineural hearing loss (defined as a drop in bone pure-tone average of more than 10 dB) occurred in four cases (5.4%). The number of revision surgeries, variations in operative techniques using laser or drill, and the ossicle to which the prosthesis was attached did not statistically affect the postoperative air-bone gaps. These results were compared with previously published data.     

A review of 308 cases of revision stapedectomy

Objective/Hypothesis: Identify causes of primary and revision stapedectomy failure in 308 patients, assess whether these are different based on source of initial surgery, and evaluate hearing results in revision stapedectomy to improve outcome. Study Design: Retrospective, nonrandomized chart review of patients undergoing revision stapedectomy in a referral otology practice in a large metropolitan region. Materials and Methods: Intraoperative findings, preoperative and postoperative revision stapedectomy air and bone conduction pure-tone averages, speech discrimination scores, postoperative air-bone gaps, complications, and repeated revisions were noted in 308 patients. Results: Leading causes of primary stapedectomy failure included dislocated prosthesis (24.4%), inadequate prosthesis length (14%), long process resorption (14%), and fibrous adhesions (13.6%). Revision stapedectomy air-bone gaps were less than 10 dB in 80% and greater than 30 dB in 6.8% of cases. Increased sensorineural hearing loss occurred in 0.8% of revision stapedectomy cases. Five of seven cases of vertigo associated with primary stapedectomy resolved after revision surgery. Conclusion: Revision stapedectomy by experienced surgeons is highly effective in attaining successful air-bone gap closure in 80% and improved closure in 84.8% of operative cases. Risk of vertigo and/or sensorineural hearing loss was not any higher in this patient population when compared with reports of primary stapedectomy.     

Primary and revision stapedectomy in elderly patients

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: This review discusses the recent literature on short- and long-term hearing results for primary and revision stapes surgery on young and elderly patients. RECENT FINDINGS: The epidemiology of clinical otosclerosis appears be changing. The average age for patients undergoing primary stapes surgery is increasing, and the percentage of revision stapedectomies is increasing. As the population ages, the otologist should expect to perform more surgeries on elderly patients. Short- and long-term hearing results after primary stapes surgery are good, regardless of age. Approximately 90% of patients obtain closure of their ABG to within 10 dB. Long-term results demonstrate that hearing decreases over time after stapedectomy at a rate of approximately 1 dB/y for both young and elderly populations. Sensorineural hearing loss accounts for most of this decrease and a relatively small ABG is maintained in many patients. However, at least 10 to 20% of patients will redevelop conductive hearing loss after undergoing stapes surgery and will desire revision surgery to correct this hearing loss. With modern otologic equipment, including the laser, most patients undergoing revision stapedectomy should obtain significant improvement in hearing, regardless of age. SUMMARY: Primary and revision stapedectomy are beneficial procedures in the elderly population. The success rate is similar to that in the younger population with otosclerosis.     

Stapedectomy outcomes: titanium versus teflon wire prosthesis

OBJECTIVE: To compare the effectiveness of two stapes prostheses in hearing improvement of patients undergoing stapes surgery for otosclerosis. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective chart review. METHODS: Titanium and Teflon wire stapes prostheses were compared with regard to effectiveness in closing the air-bone gap. The charts of 461 stapedectomies performed by one surgeon from 1996 to 2001 were reviewed. Patients who underwent stapedectomy for reasons other than otosclerosis, revision cases, and those with inadequate preoperative or postoperative bone-conduction threshold data were excluded. Small fenestra technique using either laser or drill was used for all patients. Inclusion criteria were met by 218 patients. Patients were then grouped according to type of prosthesis used, and hearing outcomes were compared. Measured outcomes were four frequency air-bone gap closure, pure-tone threshold, and rate of sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL). RESULTS: The study group was comprised of 35 titanium and 183 Teflon wire prostheses. Closure of the air-bone gap to less than 10 dB was achieved in 86% of the patients with Teflon prosthesis compared with 71% of those with titanium prostheses. The groups were equivalent in regard to site of otosclerotic disease as well as technique, laser or drill, used to create the fenestra. Rate of SNHL was low for both groups and not significantly different. CONCLUSIONS: Both prostheses provided comparable results, although the Teflon platinum wire prosthesis was slightly superior. The smaller numbers in the titanium group may confound these results. The design of the titanium prosthesis provides a crimp that is circumferential around the incus, and that prosthesis was selected in cases with a narrow incus. The selection bias may also influence the results seen in this study.     

Stapedectomy: Incus bypass procedures. A report of 203 operations

The records of 203 stapedectomy operations in which we used a prosthesis from the malleus handle or a columella from the tympanic membrane were reviewed; 63 operations were primary stapedectomies, and 85% had a postoperative conductive deficit of 15 dB or less. The most common single indication for an incus bypass procedure was idiopathic malleus head fixation. Sixty-six operations were revision stapedectomies; 65% had a postoperative deficit of 15 dB or less. In 50% the bypass indication was necrosis of the incus. There were 74 stapedectomies in a previously fenestrated ear; 60% had a postoperative deficit of 15 dB or less. Incus bypass procedures in stapedectomy, when indicated, yield satisfactory hearing results. Otolaryngologists who perform stapedectomy must be familiar with these procedures.     

Success rate in revision stapes surgery for otosclerosis.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to evaluate the hearing results of revision stapes surgery performed because of previously failed operations and to determine the causes of failure. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective review of revision stapes operations. SETTING: Tertiary referral center. PATIENTS: Sixty-three consecutive revision stapes operations were performed in 56 patients over a period of 12 years (1992-2004). The indication for revision surgery was recurrent or persistent air-bone gap greater than 20 dB after primary surgical treatment of otosclerosis of the oval window. RESULTS: All patients were operated on to improve hearing. Sixty-three revision stapes operations resulted in closure of the air-bone gap to 10 dB or less in 52.4% of cases. The average postoperative air-bone gap was 13.1 dB, and the mean pure-tone average improvement was 12.9 dB. In six patients (9.5%), revision surgery produced no change in hearing, and in four (6.3%) the hearing decreased by 5 dB or more. In one patient, the operation resulted in a profound hearing loss. Prosthesis malfunction was the most common primary cause of failure (60.3%). The original prosthesis was replaced with a new one in 48 cases. In 30 of these (62.5%), closure of the air-bone gap to within 10 dB was achieved. In 15 cases, the prosthesis was not replaced, and in only four of these (26.7%), closure of the air-bone gap within 10 dB was obtained (p < 0.022). CONCLUSION: Revision stapes surgery is less likely to be successful than the primary operation. Closure of the air-bone gap to within 10 dB was achieved in 52.4% of patients. The success rate was better in cases where the original prosthesis was replaced with a new one. The risk for decreased bone-conduction threshold does not seem to be higher than in primary surgery.     

Predictive factors in pediatric stapedectomy

OBJECTIVE/HYPOTHESIS: The objective of the study was to investigate predictive factors in the postoperative hearing outcomes in pediatric stapedectomy. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective case series. The study was performed in a tertiary academic otological practice. METHODS: The outcome of 66 stapedectomies in children 17 years of age and younger were analyzed according to the 1995 American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery Committee on Hearing and Equilibrium guidelines. Factors evaluated included patient age, underlying diagnosis (tympanosclerosis, otosclerosis, congenital fixation), type of footplate graft and type of prosthesis used, associated ossicular abnormalities, and revision surgery. RESULTS: The mean postoperative air-bone gap following stapedectomy in children with tympanosclerotic footplate fixation (24.9 dB [+/-11 dB]) was significantly worse than in patients with an underlying diagnosis of congenital stapes fixation (15.7 dB [+/-9 dB]) or otosclerosis (13.1 dB [+/-3 dB]) (P =.024). Revision stapedectomy was also associated with a poorer outcome, but patient age and prosthesis and graft type did not contribute to the outcome in a statistically significant manner. CONCLUSIONS: Pediatric patients with stapes fixation resulting from tympanosclerosis showed poorer outcomes from stapedectomy than patients with congenital or otosclerotic fixation. Outcomes for congenital or otosclerosis fixation more nearly matched the outcomes in the literature for adult series.     

Results after revision stapedectomy with malleus grip prosthesis

Revision stapedectomy with a malleus grip prosthesis is a technically challenging otologic procedure. The prosthesis is usually longer and extends deeper into the vestibule than a conventional stapes prosthesis, creating the potential to affect the vestibular sense organs. The prosthesis also bypasses the ossicular joints, which are thought to play a role in protecting the inner ear from large changes in static pressure within the middle ear. The prosthesis is in close proximity to the tympanic membrane, thus increasing the risk for its extrusion. We reviewed our experience with revision stapedectomy with the Schuknecht Teflon-wire malleus grip prosthesis in 36 ears with a mean follow-up of 23 months. The air-bone gap was closed to within 10 dB in 16 ears (44%) and to within 20 dB in 26 ears (72%). The incidence of postoperative sensorineural hearing loss was 8% (3 ears). There were no dead ears. Extrusion of the prosthesis occurred in 1 case (3%). Nearly 50% of patients reported various degrees of vertigo or disequilibrium during the first 3 weeks after surgery. These vestibular symptoms resolved by 6 weeks in all but 1 case. We did not find evidence of damage to the inner ear due to the length of the prosthesis or due to the potential for direct transmission of changes in static pressures within the middle ear to the labyrinth. Our results are similar to those published in the literature for malleus attachment stapedectomy and conventional revision incus stapedectomy.     

Hearing results with the titanium ossicular replacement prostheses

The purpose was to study the hearing results in patients receiving a Kurz titanium Bell partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) or an Aerial total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP). The study was a retrospective chart review in a tertiary otologic referral center. A computerized otologic database was used to identify 111 patients implanted with either a PORP or TORP prosthesis. Audiograms were reviewed and air-bone gaps were calculated for each patient. The improvement of the average air-bone gap (ABG) was 10.2 and 12.7 dB at 3 and 20 months after ossiculoplasty, respectively. Sixty-six percent of patients (73/111) had a postoperative air-bone gap of 20 dB or less. The ABG for the titanium PORP prosthesis was 14.3±9.7 dB, compared with 25.2±13.7 dB for the TORP prosthesis ( P <0.05). The ABG to within 20 dB or less was obtained in the PORP group in 77% of the cases, versus 52% of the cases in the TORP group ( P <0.05). Two extrusions of the prostheses were observed at 17 and 20 months after surgery (1.8%). Revision procedures for functional failure were carried out in 20 patients (18%). The rate of sensorineural hearing loss was 3.6%. The major factors influencing good audiometric results were the surgical procedure preserving the external auditory canal and the presence of the stapes. The best hearing results were achieved when a PORP was used in an intact canal wall (ICW) procedure, and the worst hearing results were achieved when a TORP was used in a canal wall down (CWD) procedure. The titanium Kurz prosthesis has been an effective implant at our institution for ossicular reconstruction.     

Hearing results after ossiculoplasty using Polycel prosthesis

CONCLUSIONS: Polycel is an effective material to use in ossiculoplasty. Good prognostic factors for hearing improvement after ossiculoplasty were healthy middle ear mucosa and the presence of stapes superstructure. OBJECTIVE: During the last decade, the surgical use of alloplasts has become increasingly widespread among otologists. This study aimed to evaluate the hearing results after ossiculoplasty using Polycel prosthesis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed 188 patients who underwent ossicular chain reconstruction using Polycel prosthesis and were followed up postoperatively for more than 12 months at Severance Eye-ENT Hospital from 1998 to 2002. Postoperative hearing results were assessed by measuring the postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) and closure of the ABG. Successful postoperative ABG criteria were defined as the following three measurements: ABG of 相似文献   

Revision stapedectomy

The need for revision stapedectomy surgery still exists despite the many changes that have occurred in the surgical technique for the treatment of stapedial otosclerosis over the past 30 years. Sixty-six revision stapes operations were analyzed to determine the causes of failure of previously operated cases of stapedial otosclerosis, and to evaluate the hearing results following a revision stapedectomy. Failure was most often due to erosion of the incus (41%), displacement of the prosthesis from the incus (24%), or migration of the prosthesis from the center portion of the oval window (24%). Postoperative improvement of hearing was observed in 81% of ears operated on for a conductive hearing loss. Closure to within 10 dB, however, occurred in 61%. Two ears suffered a deterioration in the sensorineural hearing level following the revision surgery. Speech discrimination scores following revision surgery were improved in 5% of ears and unchanged in the remainder. Although the overall hearing results are less favorable than those seen in primary stapedectomy, revision stapedectomy surgery should continue to be offered to patients whose primary stapes surgery failed or whose initial good result declined over time.     

Revision stapedectomy]

Early and delayed complications in the inner or middle ear may follow stapedectomy and require revision surgery. The records of 72 patients who had undergone revision stapedectomy were analyzed to determine: 1. the causes of failure. 2. how to revise the conditions due to the failure following previous operation. 3. hearing results. These 72 revision operations consisted of 66 case of conductive deafness and 6 sensorineural loss. The commonest cause of failure was dysfunction of prosthesis (23.6 per cent), followed by otosclerotic regrowth (22.2 per cent), incus dislocation (13.9 per cent), reparative granuloma (12.5 per cent), incus necrosis (11.1 per cent), and fibrous adhesions (9.7 per cent). A review of these cases demonstrates that the results of revision stapedectomy are different from those for primary stapedectomy. The revision operations resulted in post-operative air-born gaps of 15 dB or less in 39.4 per cent of cases. Primary stapedectomy resulted in successful closure of the air-bone gap to 15 dB or less in 97.2 per cent of cases. 'Dead ears' were encountered in 9.1 per cent as against 2.1 per cent in the primary cases. Thus the surgeon should be aware of the problems and risks involved in revision stapedectomy.     

Stapedectomy in the Pediatric Patient

The purpose of this study was to evaluate and compare the results of stapedectomy in pediatric patients with otosclerosis and tympanosclerosis. A retrospective review of 14 patients (15 ears) who underwent stapedectomy from 1993 to 1995 was conducted. In 5 ears stapedectomy for tympanosclerosis was performed; 9 patients had otosclerosis and 1 had Treacher Collins syndrome. Patients were evaluated for preoperative and postoperative air-bone gaps, preoperative and postoperative speech reception thresholds, postoperative air conduction hearing improvement, and preoperative and postoperative speech discrimination. Children with otosclerosis who underwent stapedectomies had an average postoperative airbone gap of 16 dB with an average air conduction hearing improvement of 17.6 dB. Children with tympanosclerosis who underwent stapedectomies had an average air-bone gap of 14 dB with an average air conduction hearing improvement of 28 dB. Stapedectomy is a safe and effective treatment for otosclerosis and tympanosclerosis in pediatric patients.     

Hearing results after ossiculoplasty using Polycel® prosthesis

Conclusions. Polycel® is an effective material to use in ossiculoplasty. Good prognostic factors for hearing improvement after ossiculoplasty were healthy middle ear mucosa and the presence of stapes superstructure. Objective. During the last decade, the surgical use of alloplasts has become increasingly widespread among otologists. This study aimed to evaluate the hearing results after ossiculoplasty using Polycel® prosthesis. Materials and methods. We retrospectively reviewed 188 patients who underwent ossicular chain reconstruction using Polycel® prosthesis and were followed up postoperatively for more than 12 months at Severance Eye-ENT Hospital from 1998 to 2002. Postoperative hearing results were assessed by measuring the postoperative air–bone gap (ABG) and closure of the ABG. Successful postoperative ABG criteria were defined as the following three measurements: ABG of ≤10 dB, ABG of ≤20 dB, and ABG of ≤30 dB. Several prognostic factors were analyzed, including the condition of the middle ear mucosa and ossicles, the presence or absence of cholesteatoma, surgical method, and staging and revision surgery. Results. Of the 188 cases, 22 cases (11.7%) showed an ABG of ≤10 dB, 96 cases (51.1%) presented with an ABG of ≤20 dB, and 158 cases (84.0%) had an ABG of ≤30 dB. In cases with healthy middle ear mucosa and the presence of stapes superstructure, the hearing results were good.     

One-stage surgery of middle ear cholesteatoma in adults: apropos of 180 cases]

OBJECTIVES: In order to evaluate the results of tympanoplasty in one stage middle ear cholesteatoma surgery, a retrospective study of 180 consecutive cholesteatomas operated on was undertaken. METHODS: 150 single procedures and 30 revision surgeries realized between 1992 and 1997 were analysed by studying anatomical and functional results with a mean follow-up of 24 months. RESULTS: Among the 150 adult patients, 85 (57%) were previously operated on in other centres and presented a recurrence of cholesteatoma. Closed technique was performed in 110 cases (61%) and opened one in the remaining cases (41%). Ossiculoplasty was made in 101 cases (56%) with different materials (15 incus autografts, 14 teflon prosthesis, 35 hydroxyapatite (HA) composite prosthesis and 37 all in HA prosthesis): 91 cases in a one-stage procedure but 10 worse functional results required a closed revision procedure. Twenty cases were also revised after one year of follow up at least: six recurrences of cholesteatoma were operated on by using canal down mastoidectomy (4%), 14 limited residual cholesteatomas (9.3%) had a revision closed technique procedure. CT Scan followed up all the patients operated on by a closed technique. Postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) was 20 +/- 11.3 dB and 27 +/- 10.1 dB in closed and opened techniques, respectively (p < 0.05). ABG was 20 +/- 9.2 dB and 26 +/- 13 dB in type II and type III tympanoplasty, respectively (p < 0.05). CONCLUSION: If the tympanic and posterior cavities are reasonably safe, middle ear cholesteatoma in adults can be well cured by a one-stage procedure including ossicular chain reconstruction with hydroxylapatite prosthesis covered with cartilage graft who achieved a valuable hearing restoration.     

Stapedectomy following tympanoplasty.

The aim of this study was to evaluate the success of stapedectomy in patients who have previously had a tympanoplasty because of chronic otitis media (COM). Fourteen patients from a private otology practice had undergone tympanoplasty for COM and subsequently underwent stapedectomy. Measurements were taken of the air-bone gap (ABG) closure and pure tone average (PTA) which showed hearing improvement. Patients had a mean 36.9 dB PTA hearing gain with 79 per cent closing the ABG to within 20 dB. The need for stapedectomy alone is a rare occurrence for patients with a history of COM requiring a tympanoplasty. Hearing improvement following stapedectomy in these cases was significant, although somewhat less than following traditional stapedectomy in otosclerosis alone.     

Ossiculoplasty with a cartilage-connecting hydroxyapatite prosthesis for tympanosclerotic stapes fixation

Many cases of tympanosclerotic stapes fixation are accompanied by fixation or erosion of malleus and/or incus. This status of the ossicular chain is one of the reasons that ossiculoplasty for tympanosclerotic stapes fixation is more difficult than that for otosclerosis. We conducted a retrospective review of seven patients who were operated on for tympanosclerotic stapes fixation between 2002 and 2006. All of the patients had abnormal conditions of the malleus and/or incus and underwent stapedectomy and total ossiculoplasty with hydroxyapatite prosthesis (Apaceram T-7 type), which has a planar-like head portion that contacts a piece of cartilage. Postoperative hearing results were assessed in all seven patients after at least 1 year. The postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) was closed within 10 dB in two of seven patients, and was less than 20 dB in six of seven patients. The mean postoperative ABG was closed within 10 dB at 1 and 2 kHz and less than 20 dB at low frequencies (0.25 and 0.5 Hz). There was almost no hearing improvement at high frequencies (4 and 8 kHz). There were no patients with postoperative sensorineural hearing loss. The present study shows that stapedectomy and total ossiculoplasty with cartilage-connecting hydroxyapatite prosthesis is effective and safe for stapes fixation accompanied by fixation or erosion of the malleus and/or incus.     

Stapedectomy in the treatment of otosclerosis in children

In the years 1994-2000 in the Laryngology Department Silesian Medical Academy in Zabrze 167 stapedectomy were performed in 143 patients with otosclerosis. In this group of patients 11 stapedectomies in 8 children aged from 9 to 17 years were performed. 5.6% of all the patients with otosclerosis treated in our Department were children. The purpose of this study was to analyze the audiologic results of stapedectomies in children. The postoperative evaluations were performed in the period from 6 months to 6 years after the surgical treatment. In the estimation of the hearing state we analyzed the change of the air-bone gap, an average air conduction hearing improvement, the rate of percentage hearing improvement and an average hearing loss by Bell Telephone Laboratories. In all the operated children we observed the decrease of the air conduction hearing level. Stapedectomy was successful (postoperative air bone gap within 10 dB of the preoperative bone conduction) in 63.6% of the patients. In 3 cases the air bone gap was lower than 20 dB (27.3%). In one case it was greater then 20 dB. The air bone gap closure was at the average of 5.75 dB level. The results were comparable with the other authors. Stapedectomy can be an effective procedure for correcting conducting hearing losses due to the otosclerosis in the pediatric patients.     

Closed tympanoplasty in cholesteatoma surgery: long-term (10 years) hearing results using cartilage ossiculoplasty

The aim of this retrospective study was to evaluate the long-term hearing results of using costal cartilage prostheses in ossicular chain reconstruction procedures in subjects operated on for a middle ear cholesteatoma with an intact canal wall tympanoplasty. Thirty-six patients (four with bilateral disease) followed up for 10 years who underwent an ossiculoplasty with a cartilage prostheses between January 1987 and December 1989 constituted the population studied. All the subjects underwent a staged intact canal wall tympanoplasty with mastoidectomy. Ossiculoplasty with total or partial chondroprosthesis was performed during the second stage. The long-term outcome was evaluated in terms of hearing according to the guidelines of the Committee on Hearing and Equilibrium (1995), and in terms of complications (anatomical and functional). In 18 patients a partial cartilage ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) was used, while in 22 a total cartilage ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP) was used. In the PORP group the mean preoperative air–bone gap (ABG) was 22.4 dB hearing level (HL); before the second stage the ABG was 37.9 dB HL, at 2 years it was 12.1 dB HL, at 5 years 15.3 dB HL and at 10 years 15.8 dB HL. In the TORP group the mean preoperative ABG was 31.6 dB HL; before the second stage the ABG was 41.1 dB HL, at 2 years it was 14.4 dB HL, at 5 years 17 dB HL and at 10 years 18.5 dB HL. In both groups the number of cases with a postoperative ABG of < 20 dB HL remained stable (P > 0.05) over time. The failure rate was 17.5%, but only in 5% of cases was a functional revision needed. No cases of extrusion of the prostheses were encountered. The use of a chondroprosthesis is associated with functional results similar to those obtained by other authors. The efficacy of the prostheses remains stable over time and is associated with a very low rate of complications and failures. In this series no extrusion occurred and in no case did an infectious disease develop after cartilage transplantation. Received: 7 August 2000 / Accepted: 2 November 2000     

外伤性听骨链中断和脱位的诊断及治疗

目的:探讨常见外伤性听骨链中断和脱位的诊断治疗及术后疗效。方法:8例(8耳)外伤性听骨链中断,其中6例为单侧传导性聋,2例混合性聋且以传导性为主;8耳均行鼓室探查,并行听骨链重建术,其中1耳行全听骨(TORP)重建术,4耳行部分听骨(PORP)重建术,2耳行听骨链复位,1耳用人工砧骨重建,通过术前术后气骨导差比较疗效。结果:术前听力检查示平均气骨导差为42.9dB,术后3周平均气骨导差为22.3dB,较术前缩小20.6dB(t=22.10,P<0.01),术后6～8个月平均气骨导差为18.6dB,较术前缩小24.3dB(t=12.813,P<0.01)。结论:外伤性听骨链中断或脱位引起的传导性听力下降,根据术中情况采用不同听骨链重建术可以明显提高听力,治疗首选手术。