Oral mucosal immunity and HIV/SIV infection

Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) transmission through genital and rectal mucosa has led to intensive study of mucosal immune responses to HIV and to the development of a vaccine administered locally. However, HIV transmission through the oral mucosa is a rare event. The oral mucosa represents a physical barrier and contains immunological elements to prevent the invasion of pathogenic organisms. This particular defense differs between micro-compartments represented by the salivary glands, oral mucosa, and palatine tonsils. Secretory immunity of the salivary glands, unique features of cellular structure in the oral mucosa and palatine tonsils, the high rate of oral blood flow, and innate factors in saliva may all contribute to the resistance to HIV/Simian Immunodeficiency Virus (SIV) oral mucosal infection. In the early stage of HIV infection, humoral and cellular immunity and innate immune functions in oral mucosa are maintained. However, these particular immune responses may all be impaired as a result of chronic HIV infection. A better understanding of oral mucosal immune mechanisms should lead to improved prevention of viral and bacterial infections, particularly in immunocompromised persons with Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS), and to the development of a novel strategy for a mucosal AIDS vaccine, as well as vaccines to combat other oral diseases, such as dental caries and periodontal diseases.     

HIV infection and specific mucosal immunity: workshop 4B

Most HIV infections are transmitted across mucosal epithelium. An area of fundamental importance is understanding the role of innate and specific mucosal immunity in susceptibility or protection against HIV infection, as well as the effect of HIV infection on mucosal immunity, which leads to increased susceptibility to bacterial, fungal, and viral infections of oral and other mucosae. This workshop attempted to address 5 basic issues-namely, HIV acquisition across mucosal surfaces, innate and adaptive immunity in HIV resistance, antiviral activity of breast milk as a model mucosal fluid, neutralizing immunoglobulin A antibodies against HIV, and progress toward a mucosal vaccine against HIV. The workshop attendants agreed that progress had been made in each area covered, with much recent information. However, these advances revealed how little work had been performed on stratified squamous epithelium compared with columnar epithelium, and the attendants identified several important biological questions that had not been addressed. It is increasingly clear that innate immunity has an important biological role, although basic understanding of the mechanisms of normal homeostasis is still being investigated. Application of the emerging knowledge was lacking with regard to homeostatic mucosal immunity to HIV and its role in changing this homeostasis. With regard to breast milk, a series of studies have demonstrated the differences between transmitters and nontransmitters, although whether these findings could be generalized to other secretions such as saliva was less clear. Important progress toward an oral mucosal HIV vaccine has been made, demonstrating proof of principle for administering vaccine candidates into oral lymphoid tissues to trigger anti-HIV local and systemic immune responses. Similarly, experimental data emphasized the central role of neutralizing antibodies to prevent HIV infection via mucosal routes.     

The effects of HIV infection on oral mucosal immunity

Oral mucosal infections, especially candidiasis, are a feature of HIV disease, suggesting that compromised mucosal immunity within the oral cavity is a consequence of the viral infection. However, how this mucosal immunity is compromised and at what stage of HIV infection this occurs are unclear. Better understanding of the protection of the oral cavity against infection has allowed us to gain some insight into the local consequences of HIV infection. From a humoral perpective, IgA2 subclasses are reduced in HIV infection in saliva, and total secretory IgA levels are reduced in later disease. Similarly, mucosal antibody responses appear near normal in early HIV infection but reduced in AIDS. There is now convincing evidence that salivary IgA can be neutralizing to HIV 1 and HIV 2, as well as block epithelial transmigration. Oral cellular immunity is also affected by HIV infection. Transmission of HIV from one oral cell type to another appears to be confirmed by work showing that HIV can bind to or infect epithelial cells, Langerhans cells, and other mucosal cells. CXCR4 tropic (via GalCer and CXCR4) and dual tropic HIV strains have been shown to be able to infect normal human oral keratinocytes (NHOKs), and infectious HIV virions can also be conveyed from NHOKs to activated peripheral blood lymphocytes, suggesting a potential role of oral epithelial cells in the transmission of HIV infection. There is evidence of up-regulation of various receptors, including HIV receptors, on the surface of oral epithelium, and the epithelium may become more permeable. HIV may exploit this antigen uptake mechanism to cross epithelial barriers during co-infection with damage-inducing pathogens such as Candida. Immune responsiveness to many of the co-pathogens associated with HIV has been demonstrated to depend on a family of innate recognition molecules, known as Toll-like receptors (TLR), and recognition of a single pathogen can involve activation of multiple TLRs. Consequently, TLR-pathogen interactions could play an indirect but major role in regulating HIV-associated disease in the oral cavity. Thus, HIV infection appears to have both direct and indirect effects on oral mucosal immunity, affecting both cellular and humoral immunity as well as both specific and innate immunity.     

Innate immunity and HIV-1 infection

HIV-1 is predominantly transmitted through mucosal tissues, targeting CD4(+)CCR5(+) T cells, 50% of which are destroyed within 2 weeks of infection. Conventional vaccination strategies have so far failed to prevent HIV-1 infection. Neither antibodies nor cytotoxic lymphocytes are capable of mounting a sufficiently rapid immune response to prevent early destruction of these cells. However, innate immunity is an early-response system, largely independent of prior encounter with a pathogen. Innate immunity can be classified into cellular, extracellular, and intracellular components, each of which is exemplified in this review by γδ T cells, CC chemokines, and APOBEC3G, respectively. First, γδ T cells are found predominantly in mucosal tissues and produce cytokines, CC chemokines, and antiviral factors. Second, the CC chemokines CCL-3, CCL-4, and CCL-5 can be upregulated by immunization of macaques with SIVgp120 and gag p27, and these can bind and downmodulate CCR5, thereby inhibiting HIV-1 entry into the host cells. Third, APOBEC3G is generated and maintained following rectal mucosal immunization in rhesus macaques for over 17 weeks, and the innate anti-SIV factor is generated by CD4(+)CD95(+)CCR7(-) effector memory T cells. Thus, innate anti-HIV-1 or SIV immunity can be linked with immune memory, mediated by CD4(+) T cells generating APOBEC3G. The multiple innate functions may mount an early anti-HIV-1 response and either prevent viral transmission or contain the virus until an effective adaptive immune response develops.     

The role of immunity in protection from mucosal SIV infection in macaques

The need for an effective vaccine against HIV has prompted a refocusing of attention on mucosal immunity. More than 75% of all infections are acquired across a mucosal surface. It is therefore a prerequisite for a vaccine to target directly the mucosal tissues or indirectly the regional lymph nodes in order to prevent or control viral replication. Although mucosal immunization has induced responses at the genital or rectal surfaces, immune mechanisms alone have not been shown to be sufficient to contain infections in macaques. A growing body of evidence suggests that a dual mechanism may be required for effective mucosal protection, mediated by specific CD4 and CD8 T cell and antibody responses to the immunizing agents, plus innate antiviral factors and β chemokines that down-regulate CCR5 coreceptors. Targeted iliac lymph node immunization with SIV gp120 and p27 in alum prevents SIV infection or significantly decreases the viral load when immunized macaques were challenged with SIV by the rectal route. Indeed, in addition to specific immunity, including significant SIgA antibody secreting cells in the iliac lymph nodes, CD8-suppressor factor and the 3β chemokines (RANTES, MIP-1α and MIP-1β) are significantly associated with protection against rectal mucosal SIV infection.     

Oral innate immunity in HIV infection in HAART era

Oral innate immunity, an important component in host defense and immune surveillance in the oral cavity, plays a crucial role in the regulation of oral health. As part of the innate immune system, epithelial cells lining oral mucosal surfaces not only provide a physical barrier but also produce different antimicrobial peptides, including human β‐defensins (hBDs), secretory leukocyte protease inhibitor (SLPI), and various cytokines. These innate immune mediators help in maintaining oral homeostasis. When they are impaired either by local or systemic causes, various oral infections and malignancies may be developed. Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection and other co‐infections appear to have both direct and indirect effects on systemic and local innate immunity leading to the development of oral opportunistic infections and malignancies. Highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART), the standard treatment of HIV infection, contributed to a global reduction of HIV‐associated oral lesions. However, prolonged use of HAART may lead to adverse effects on the oral innate immunity resulting in the relapse of oral lesions. This review article focused on the roles of oral innate immunity in HIV infection in HAART era. The following five key questions were addressed: (i) What are the roles of oral innate immunity in health and disease?, (ii) What are the effects of HIV infection on oral innate immunity?, (iii) What are the roles of oral innate immunity against other co‐infections?, (iv) What are the effects of HAART on oral innate immunity?, and (v) Is oral innate immunity enhanced by HAART?     

Oral mucosal Langerhans' cells as target, effector and vector in HIV infection

The mechanism underlying a transition of the oral cavity mucosal epithelium towards susceptibility to opportunistic infections in HIV-seropositive patients was investigated. Phenotypic markers CD1a, HLA-DR, and CD86 of oral mucosal Langerhans' cells (LCs), p17 core protein of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), and CD45RO of memory T cells were labeled on oral hairy leukoplakia lesional biopsies and clinically normal autologous tissue of HIV-infected patients. HIV p17 protein was detected in association with mucosal LCs, mainly within the lesional epithelium. There were significant correlations between the detection of HIV p17 and the depletion of LCs, and between the depletion of LCs and the presence of hairy leukoplakia lesions. Conjugates of activated LCs and memory T cells were also evident in the submucosal area of lesional biopsies. The findings from this study support the hypothesis that oral mucosal LCs are also the target of HIV infection. Cytopathic changes of LCs caused by productive HIV infection may contribute to selective depletion of LCs, which may impair the mucosal immunologic protection against colonization by microorganisms causing HIV-associated oral mucosal lesions.     

Osteopontin and mucosal protection

Protection of mucosal tissues of the oral cavity, intestines, respiratory tract, and urogenital tract from the constant challenge of pathogens is achieved by the combined barrier function of the lining epithelia and specialized immune cells. Recent studies have indicated that osteopontin (OPN) has a pivotal role in the development of immune responses and in the tissue destruction and the subsequent repair processes associated with inflammatory diseases. While expression of OPN is increased in immune cells--including neutrophils, macrophages, T- and B-lymphocytes--and in epithelial, endothelial, and fibroblastic cells of inflamed tissues, deciphering the specific functions of OPN has been difficult. In part, this is due to the broad range of biological activities of OPN that are mediated by multiple receptors which recognize several signaling motifs whose activities are influenced by post-translational modifications and proteolytic processing of OPN. Understanding the role of OPN in mucosal inflammation is further complicated by its contributions to the barrier function of the lining epithelia and the complexity of the specialized mucosal immune system. In an attempt to provide some insights into the involvement of OPN in mucosal diseases, this review summarizes current knowledge of the biological activities of OPN involved in the development of inflammatory responses and in wound healing, and indicates how these activities may affect the protection of mucosal tissues.     

Management of the oral mucosal lesions seen in association with HIV infection

Oral lesions cause considerable morbidity in association with HIV infection. Their successful management depends upon accurate diagnosis and the use of appropriate therapy. Various treatment approaches are described for some of the common oral lesions including Kaposi's sarcoma, oral candidiasis, hairy leukoplakia and recurrent oral ulcers associated with HIV disease. This paper will discuss the therapies available in the USA and UK. In other countries some of the drugs discussed will be available in different doses and preparations. In addition other drugs may be available in other parts of the world that are not licensed for use in the USA or UK, and their availability may vary.     

T-cell-mediated mucosal immunity in the absence of antibody: lessons from Helicobacter pylori infection

Approximately 50% of humanity is infected with Helicobacter pylori. This lifelong infection elicits a marked host response, including a robust gastric IgA response. However, natural infection fails to yield protective immunity. Rather than providing protection, the chronic inflammatory response associated with natural infection can contribute to tissue damage and the pathogenesis of gastroduodenal disease, including atrophic gastritis, peptic ulcer, and gastric cancer. These immune responses are attributed to a subset of helper T cells, so-called Th1 cells, that enhance cell-mediated immunity and induce damage to the gastric epithelium. Thus, it is desirable to have effective vaccines that could prevent and cure infection and that may modify the host response in a manner that prevents immune-mediated disease. Using animal models as a tool to understand the immunobiology of Helicobacter infections, several investigators have shown that effective vaccines can be developed. Thus, prophylactic and even therapeutic vaccines have been described in various animal models. The basis for the effectiveness of these vaccines appears related to their ability to alter the gastric immune response, from a homogeneous Th1 response to a mixed Th1 and Th2 response. Interestingly, immunity can occur in the absence of B cells, suggesting that novel IgA-independent mechanisms exist that confer protection against a luminal infection. Thus, H. pylori infection provides a model with which new mechanisms of immunological protection can be identified and applied to other mucosal infections.     

T-cell-mediated mucosal immunity in the absence of antibody: lessons from Helicobacter pylori infection

Approximately 50% of humanity is infected with Helicobacter pylori. This lifelong infection elicits a marked host response, including a robust gastric IgA response. However, natural infection fails to yield protective immunity. Rather than providing protection, the chronic inflammatory response associated with natural infection can contribute to tissue damage and the pathogenesis of gastroduodenal disease, including atrophic gastritis, peptic ulcer, and gastric cancer. These immune responses are attributed to a subset of helper T cells, so-called Th1 cells, that enhance cell-mediated immunity and induce damage to the gastric epithelium. Thus, it is desirable to have effective vaccines that could prevent and cure infection and that may modify the host response in a manner that prevents immune-mediated disease. Using animal models as a tool to understand the immunobiology of Helicobacter infections, several investigators have shown that effective vaccines can be developed. Thus, prophylactic and even therapeutic vaccines have been described in various animal models. The basis for the effectiveness of these vaccines appears related to their ability to alter the gastric immune response, from a homogeneous Th1 response to a mixed Th1 and Th2 response. Interestingly, immunity can occur in the absence of B cells, suggesting that novel IgA-independent mechanisms exist that confer protection against a luminal infection. Thus, H. pylori infection provides a model with which new mechanisms of immunological protection can be identified and applied to other mucosal infections.     

Dendritic cells and HIV infection: activating dendritic cells to boost immunity

Dendritic cells (DCs) are white blood cells that coordinate innate and adaptive immunity. They are distributed within epithelia and mucosal-associated lymphoid tissues, positioned to entrap incoming pathogens or vaccines. Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and the non-human primate equivalent (SIV) exploit DCs to amplify infection, underscoring the need to harness strategies that promote presentation of virus by DCs to stimulate potent anti-viral immunity instead of virus transmission. Two main subsets of DCs need to be considered: myeloid (MDC) and plasmacytoid (PDC) subsets. Using the SIV-macaque system to advance oral vaccine research, we examined macaque PDC and MDC biology, identifying ways to activate DCs and boost antiviral immunity. Immunostimulatory oligodeoxyribonucleotides (ISS-ODNs) stimulated PDC/MDC mixtures to up-regulate co-stimulatory molecule expression and to secrete both IFN-alpha and IL-12. Additionally, ISS-ODNs augmented SIV-specific IFN-gamma responses induced by virus-bearing DCs. ISS-ODN-driven DC activation is being pursued to improve oral/nasopharyngeal mucosal vaccines and therapies against HIV.     

Oral mucosal leishmaniasis as a presenting feature of HIV infection and its management

Leishmaniasis is a chronic parasitic protozoal disease transmitted by sandfly vectors and is endemic in some regions of South America, Asia, Africa and Mediterranean countries. This case report describes a British patient who presented with oral mucosal leishmaniasis and in whom it was also the first sign of HIV disease. We believe it is the first reported case of isolated oral mucosal leishmaniasis as a presenting feature of otherwise unknown HIV infection.     

A revisit of mucosal IgA immunity and oral tolerance

Induction of mucosal immunity by oral immunization with protein antigen alone is difficult: potent mucosal adjuvants, vectors, or other special delivery systems are required. Cholera toxin (CT) has been shown to be an effective adjuvant for the development of mucosal vaccines and, when given with vaccine, induces both mucosal and systemic immune responses via a Th2 cell-dependent pathway. However, and in addition to potential type-I hypersensitivity, a major concern for use of mucosal adjuvants such as CT is that this molecule is not suitable for use in humans because of its inherent toxicity. When we examined the potential toxicity of CT for the central nervous system, both CT and CT-B accumulated in the olfactory nerves/epithelium and olfactory bulbs of mice when given by the nasal route. The development of effective mucosal vaccines for the elderly is also an important issue; however, only limited information is available. When mucosal adjuvanticity of CT was evaluated in aged mice, an early immune dysregulation was evident in the mucosal immune system. The present review discusses these potential problems for effective mucosal vaccine development. Tolerance represents the most common and important response of the host to environmental antigens, including food and commensal bacterial components, for the maintenance of an appropriate immunological homeostasis. We have examined whether Peyer patches could play a more important role for the maintenance of oral tolerance. Using Peyer patch-null mice, we found that mice lacking this gut-associated lymphoid tissue retained their capability to produce secretory IgA antibodies but did not develop normal oral tolerance to protein antigens.     

Innate immunity including epithelial and nonspecific host factors: workshop 1B

The majority of HIV infections are initiated at mucosal sites. The oral mucosal tissue has been shown to be a potential route of entry in humans and primates. Whereas HIV RNA, proviral DNA, and infected cells are detected in the oral mucosa and saliva of infected individuals, it appears that the oral mucosa is not permissive for efficient HIV replication and therefore may differ in susceptibility to infection when compared to other mucosal sites. Since there is no definitive information regarding the fate of the HIV virion in mucosal epithelium, there is a pressing need to understand what occurs when the virus is in contact with this tissue, what mechanisms are in play to determine the outcome, and to what degree the mechanisms and outcomes differ between mucosal sites. Workshop 1B tackled 5 important questions to define current knowledge about epithelial cell-derived innate immune agents, commensal and endogenous pathogens, and epithelial cells and cells of the adaptive immune system and how they contribute to dissemination or resistance to HIV infection. Discovering factors that explain the differential susceptibility and resistance to HIV infection in mucosal sites will allow for the identification and development of novel protective strategies.