Coevolution of host and virus: the pathogenesis of virulent and attenuated strains of myxoma virus in resistant and susceptible European rabbits

Myxoma virus was introduced into the European rabbit population of Australia in 1950. Although the virus was initially highly lethal in rabbits, there was rapid selection for less virulent strains of virus and innately resistant rabbits. To investigate the basis of resistance to myxoma virus, we have compared the pathogensis of the virulent strain of myxoma virus originally released into Australia and an attenuated, naturally derived field strain of myxoma virus. This was done in laboratory rabbits, which have not been selected for resistance, and in wild rabbits that have developed significant resistance. Wild rabbits were able to recover from infection with virus that was always lethal in laboratory rabbits. Laboratory rabbits were able to control and recover from infection with attenuated virus. This virus caused a trivial disease in wild rabbits. There was little difference between laboratory and wild rabbits in titers of either virulent or attenuated virus in the skin at the inoculation site. However, resistant wild rabbits had a 10- to 100-fold lower titer of virulent virus within the lymph node draining the inoculation site and controlled virus replication in tissues distal to the draining lymph node. Replication of virus in lymphocytes or fibroblasts cultured from wild and laboratory rabbits demonstrated that resistance was not due to altered cellular permissivity for replication. Neutralizing antibodies were present in both susceptible and resistant rabbits, suggesting that these have no significant role in resistance. We hypothesise that resistance is due to an enhanced innate immune response that allows the rabbit to mount an effective cellular immune response.     

Coevolution of host and virus: cellular localization of virus in myxoma virus infection of resistant and susceptible European rabbits

The coevolution of myxoma virus and the wild European rabbit in Australia and the development of resistance to myxomatosis in wild rabbits have been well described. However, the mechanism of resistance to myxomatosis in wild rabbits is not understood. To determine the basis of resistance, the pathogenesis of the virulent standard laboratory strain (SLS) and the attenuated Uriarra (Ur) strain of myxoma virus were examined in Australian wild rabbits that have been naturally selected in the field for resistance to myxomatosis and in laboratory rabbits which have never been selected for resistance. Virus was localized in tissue sections by immunofluorescence. In all cases virus antigen was initially present in dendritic cells of the dermis before localizing predominantly to the epidermis by Day 6. Antigen-containing cells were detected in the lymph nodes by 24 h after inoculation. Virus replication occurred predominantly in T lymphocytes of the paracortex but SLS also replicated in germinal centers. SLS replication induced loss of most lymphocytes from the lymph nodes of susceptible rabbits. Apoptosis of lymphocytes within the lymph nodes was a major feature of all infections. These apoptotic cells did not contain detectable viral antigen but were often adjacent to infected cells. Ongoing apoptosis of lymphocytes within lymph nodes was also a feature of the recovery phase when very few or no virus-infected cells could be detected. Differences between virulent and attenuated viruses in the wild and laboratory rabbits were predominantly in the degree of tissue pathology in the draining lymph node and distal lymph node and in the type of inflammatory responses, particularly in the skin. SLS infection of laboratory rabbits was associated with a very mild inflammatory response, often distant from the site of virus replication and comprised predominantly of neutrophils. In contrast, Ur-infected rabbits and SLS-infected wild rabbits had an intense inflammatory response adjacent to the site of virus replication and this was comprised predominantly of mononuclear cells. Both the initial infection of dendritic cells and the ongoing destruction of lymphocytes provide obvious mechanisms for the suppression of the immune response by myxoma virus.     

Isolation of an attenuated myxoma virus field strain that can confer protection against myxomatosis on contacts of vaccinates

Summary.  Twenty MV strains obtained from a survey of field strains currently circulating throughout Spain were analyzed for their virulence and horizontal spreading among rabbits by contact transmission. A virus strain with suitable characteristics to be used as a potential vaccine against myxomatosis in wild rabbit populations was selected. Following inoculation, the selected MV strain elicited high levels of MV specificantibodies and induced protection of rabbits against a virulent MV challenge. Furthermore, the attenuated MV was transmitted to 9 out of 16 uninoculated rabbits by contact, inducing protection against myxomatosis. Received June 10, 1999/Accepted October 7, 1999     

Induction of resistance to ectromelia virus infection by corynebacterium parvum in murine peritoneal macrophages

An in vitro model has been developed to study the replication of ectromelia virus in murine macrophages (M phi). Infection of mineral oil-elicited peritoneal M phi cultures with either the virulent (Moscow) or attenuated (Hampstead) strain of ectromelia virus led to productive infections. The kinetics of virus synthesis was similar to those seen following infection of murine fibroblasts. In contrast, peritoneal M phi s activated by intraperitoneal injection of Corynebacterium parvum vaccine were found to be totally refractory to infection by the attenuated strain and significantly more resistant to the virulent strain of ectromelia virus. Administration of C. parvum doses as small as 7 micrograms were sufficient to induce antiviral activity. M phi resistance became maximal at 5-9 days after C. parvum administration; however, M phi resistance was unstable during in vitro culture. Decay of antiviral activity was detected within the first 24 hr of culture and complete virus susceptibility returned after 5 days in culture. Peritoneal exudate cells (PEC) from C. parvum-immunized mice could induce resistance in susceptible M phi cultures during overnight cocultivation. In addition, cell-free culture supernatants from C. parvum-immune PEC could also induce resistance in susceptible M phi cultures, suggesting that a soluble factor, induced by C. parvum immunization and possessing interferon activity, may account for the intrinsic resistance to ectromelia virus by activated M phi s.     

A pox on thee! Manipulation of the host immune system by myxoma virus and implications for viral-host co-adaptation

The poxviruses have evolved a diverse array of proteins which serve to subvert innate and adaptive host responses that abort or at least limit viral infections. Myxoma virus and its rabbit host are considered to represent an ideal poxvirus-host system in which to study the effects of these immunomodulatory proteins. Studies of laboratory rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus) infected with gene knockout variants of myxoma virus have provided compelling evidence that several myxoma virus gene products contribute to the pathogenic condition known as myxomatosis. However, myxomatosis, which is characterized by skin lesions, systemic immunosuppression, and a high mortality rate, does not occur in the virus' natural South American host, Sylvilogus brasiliensis. Moreover, in Australia where myxoma virus was willfully introduced to control populations of O. cuniculus, myxomatosis-resistant rabbits emerged within a year of myxoma virus introduction into the field. In this review I discuss the characterized immunomodulatory proteins of myxoma virus, their biochemical properties, their pathogenic effects in laboratory rabbits, the role of the host immune system in the susceptibility or resistance to myxomatosis, and the evidence that immunomodulatory genes may have been attenuated during the co-adaptation of myxoma virus and O. cuniculus in Australia.     

Immune responses to myxoma virus

Myxoma virus causes the systemic disease myxomatosis in the European rabbit (Oryctolagus cuniculus). Originating in the South American rabbit Sylvilagus brasiliensis, where it causes a relatively localized fibroma, myxoma virus is a classic example of a virus that has jumped species to produce an exotic disease and then coevolved with its new host. Like other poxviruses, myxoma virus encodes multiple proteins capable of downregulating the host innate and acquired immune responses. Other virus-encoded proteins enable replication in host lymphocytes and monocytes, for example, by inhibiting apoptosis. Detailed studies on these proteins have demonstrated novel methods of interactions with the host immune system and added substantially to the understanding of the interaction of large DNA viruses with their hosts. Despite the increasingly detailed molecular knowledge of myxoma virus, relatively little is known about the dynamics of the interaction of the virus with the integrated host-immune system during infection and, in particular, about the evolution of resistance to the virus in wild rabbits or the species barrier. This review will focus on the detailed molecular studies that have been done with myxoma virus and discuss the more limited knowledge of the pathogenesis of myxoma virus in rabbits and the ways that the consolidated immune responses may determine genetic resistance to myxomatosis.     

The efficacy of two vaccination schemes against experimental infection with a virulent amyxomatous or a virulent nodular myxoma virus strain

Two types of myxomatosis vaccine are available commercially, namely, vaccine prepared from the Shope fibroma virus (SFV) and that prepared from an attenuated myxoma virus (MV) strain, e.gSG33. An experiment was designed to compare two vaccination schemes for their ability to protect rabbits against challenge with either a virulent amyxomatous MV strain or a virulent nodular MV strain. Apart from a difference in the cutaneous expression of the disease, the two challenge strains resembled each other in respect of mortality rate, naso-conjunctival shedding of virus, and tissue infection. Vaccination with SFV alone failed to prevent clinical signs, naso-conjunctival shedding or tissue infection. Vaccination with SFV followed by a booster inoculation with SG33 protected rabbits against the development of clinical signs and significantly reduced both viral shedding in naso-conjunctival exudates and viral infection of eyelids, lungs and testes; virus was, however, isolated from testes of some surviving animals.     

Myxoma virus M130R is a novel virulence factor required for lethal myxomatosis in rabbits

Myxoma virus (MV) is a highly lethal, rabbit-specific poxvirus that induces a disease called myxomatosis in European rabbits. In an effort to understand the function of predicted immunomodulatory genes we have deleted various viral genes from MV and tested the ability of these knockout viruses to induce lethal myxomatosis. MV encodes a unique 15 kD cytoplasmic protein (M130R) that is expressed late (12 h post infection) during infection. M130R is a non-essential gene for MV replication in rabbit, monkey or human cell lines. Construction of a targeted gene knockout virus (vMyx130KO) and infection of susceptible rabbits demonstrate that the M130R knockout virus is attenuated and that loss of M130R expression allows the rabbit host immune system to effectively respond to and control the lethal effects of MV. M130R expression is a bona fide poxviral virulence factor necessary for full and lethal development of myxomatosis.     

Genetics of natural resistance to salmonellae in mice.

The genetics of natural resistance to salmonellae were studied in F1 hybrid and backcross mice. Overall resistance to Salmonella typhimurium C5 is complex, but one parameter, the early net growth rate of the organism in vivo, is controlled by a single autosomal gene or cluster of genes. 'Slow' net growth rate is necessary but insufficient, for resistance to S. typhimurium C5. Resistance requires the participation of other mechanisms, detectable by the end of the first week, which presumably involve an immune response. F1 hybrids bred from parents of low, intermediate and high natural resistance showed either high or low resistance. Most of the F1 hybrids were of a similar high resistance, and were bred from pairs in which at least one parent showed slow net growth rate. Hybrids of low resistance were only obtained when neither parent showed slow net growth rate. No hybrid was less resistant than the parents, many were more resistant. Backcross analysis on two hybrids challenged with S. typhimurium C5 supports the hypothesis of complex genetic control of overall resistance but with single gene control of the early net growth rate of the organism. Similar experiments were performed using a much more virulent organism, S. enteritidis 5694. All mouse strains were very susceptible (LD 50 less than ten organisms) to this strain given either i.v. or s.c. This organism produced an overwhelming infection which did not allow the cell-mediated immune response time to develop. This, however, did not interfere with the mechanism controlling early net growth rate, and genetic analysis using this organism gave similar results to those obtained with S. typhimurium C5. These results suggest that the mechanism regulating early net growth rate does not operate via the cell-mediated immune response, which develops later in the course of the infection.     

Essential role of TGF-beta in the natural resistance to experimental allergic encephalomyelitis in rats

Experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) is a T cell-mediated autoimmune disease induced in susceptible rat strains by a single immunization with myelin basic protein (MBP). The Lewis (LEW) strain is susceptible to disease induction while the Brown Norway (BN) strain is resistant. This resistance involves non-MHC genes since congenic BN-1L rats, with LEW MHC on a BN-derived background, are also resistant. In the present study we show that, upon immunization with MBP, the non-MHC-encoded resistance to develop clinical EAE in BN-1L rats is associated with a decreased production of IFN-gamma. This may be due to a difference between LEW and BN-1L rats in their ability to produce regulatory cytokines such as IL-4, IL-10 and TGF-beta. In comparison to LEW rats, immune lymph node cells from BN-1L rats express an increased amount of IL-4 mRNA but produce less IL-10. Furthermore, the sera from BN-1L rats contain higher amounts of active TGF-beta1. Therefore, we have investigated the involvement of IL-4 and TGF-beta in the resistance of BN-1L rats to develop EAE using neutralizing mAb. Neutralization of TGF-beta, but not IL-4, renders BN-1L rats susceptible to clinical EAE without affecting the proliferation or the cytokine repertoire of immune lymph node cells. With respect to the origin of the endogenous TGF-beta production, we excluded the involvement of CD8 T cells and discuss a possible role of platelets and of CD4 T cells exhibiting the CD45RC(low) phenotype.     

Class II-restricted T cell responses in Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus (TMEV)-induced demyelinating disease. II. Survey of host immune responses and central nervous system virus titers in inbred mouse strains

Previous studies using mouse strains with limited genetic differences and H-2 haplotypes demonstrated that susceptibility to Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus (TMEV)-induced demyelinating disease strongly correlated with chronically high levels of TMEV-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH), but not with TMEV-specific T cell proliferation (Tprlf), serum antibody responses, or with CNS virus titers. To determine if this correlation would be supported by analysis of these parameters in a more thorough genetic survey, ten inbred mouse strains, representing a wide variety of genetic backgrounds and H-2 haplotypes, were inoculated intracerebrally (i.c.) with the BeAn strain of TMEV. Significant TMEV-specific DTH was observed in all highly susceptible strains, but was not detectable in intermediate and resistant strains. TMEV-specific serum antibody titers also appeared to correlate with susceptibility to demyelinating disease, however even resistant strains had high antibody responses. Significant differences in CNS TMEV titers existed between strains, but did not correlate with disease susceptibility. DTH and Tprlf responses were observed in 3/4 resistant strains following peripheral immunization with UV-inactivated TMEV indicating that most resistant strains are genetically capable of mounting virus-specific cell-mediated immune (CMI) responses. The data extends our knowledge of host immune responses and virus titers in many different inbred mouse strains persistently infected with TMEV, supports the hypothesis that the demyelination in highly susceptible mice involves a TMEV-specific DTH response, and suggests that the genetic ability to mount specific DTH responses is necessary, but not sufficient for development of the demyelinating disease.     

ECTV Abolishes the Ability of GM-BM Cells to Stimulate Allogeneic CD4 T Cells in a Mouse Strain-Independent Manner

Ectromelia virus (ECTV) is the etiological agent of mousepox, an acute and systemic disease with high mortality rates in susceptible strains of mice. Resistance and susceptibility to mousepox are triggered by the dichotomous T-helper (Th) immune response generated in infected animals, with strong protective Th1 or nonprotective Th2 profile, respectively. Th1/Th2 balance is influenced by dendritic cells (DCs), which were shown to differ in their ability to polarize naïve CD4⁺ T cells in different mouse strains. Therefore, we have studied the inner-strain differences in the ability of conventional DCs (cDCs), generated from resistant (C57BL/6) and susceptible (BALB/c) mice, to stimulate proliferation and activation of Th cells upon ECTV infection. We found that ECTV infection of GM-CSF-derived bone marrow (GM-BM) cells, composed of cDCs and macrophages, affected initiation of allogeneic CD4⁺ T cells proliferation in a mouse strain-independent manner. Moreover, infected GM-BM cells from both mouse strains failed to induce and even inhibited the production of Th1 (IFN-γ and IL-2), Th2 (IL-4 and IL-10) and Th17 (IL-17A) cytokines by allogeneic CD4⁺ T cells. These results indicate that in in vitro conditions ECTV compromises the ability of cDCs to initiate/polarize adaptive antiviral immune response independently of the host strain resistance/susceptibility to lethal infection.     

Effect of immunosuppression on the genetic resistance of A2G mice to neurovirulent influenza virus.

A2G mice are genetically resistant to lethal infection with neurotropic and pneumotropic influenza viruses. A possible immunological explanation for this resistance was sought by assessing the effect of cyclophosphamide and X irradiation immunosuppression on the infection of A2G mice with lethal doses of neurovirulent virus. Immunosuppressed A2G mice survived lethal infection enen though rendered unable to produce specific antiviral antibody or to generate cell-mediated delayed-type hypersensitivity responses. Measurement of infectious virus replication and detailed observation of the infection by immunofluorescence microscopy show that immunosuppression does not potentiate or allow spread of the virus in A2G brains. Interferon levels were essentially the same in normal and immunosuppressed A2G brains but were 3 to 5 times lower than in the brains of susceptible mice dying of the infection. The results strongly suggest that the genetic resistance of A2G mice to the acute lethal effects of neurovirulent influenza virus infection does not depend on the induction of primary immune mechanisms as we currently understand them. Other possible explanations for this resistance are considered.     

Susceptibility of germ-free pigs to challenge with protease mutants of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium

Salmonella protease mutants, clpP and especially htrA, are candidate live oral vaccines in humans. A functional and mature immune system is, however, required to cope with them in mice. Here, we test the cytokine response of highly susceptible germ-free pigs to infection with Salmonella Typhimurium clpP and htrA mutants. Cytokine levels (IL-4, IL-10, IL-18 and IFN-gamma) were measured by ELISA in plasma and washes from the terminal small bowel 24h after oral challenge. Unlike the infection with the wild type strain, no IFN-gamma response and low IL-18 intestinal levels were found in pigs infected with the protease mutants. Despite this and regardless of partially reduced ability of htrA and clpP mutants to invade and multiply in a 3D4 porcine macrophage-like cell line, both the mutants were as virulent as was the wild type LT2 strain and caused fatal septicaemia in germ-free pigs. IFN-gamma and IL-18 response therefore did not correlate with the virulence of Salmonella Typhimurium. Our results indicate that htrA and clpP attenuations should be used with caution in populations in which an increased number of immunocompromised individuals can be expected.     

The role of host responses in the recovery of mice from Sendai virus infection

The antiviral responses in mice to intranasal inoculation with Sendai virus are described. To investigate the relative importance of the humoral, cell-mediated and interferon responses, the pathogenesis of this infection was studied in animals which were immunocompetent, T cell-deprived or immunosuppressed with cyclophosphamide. Treatment with cyclophosphamide converted the mild, self-limiting infection observed in immunocompetent mice into a severe and frequently lethal pneumonic disease. This was associated with an enhanced interferon response but no detectable antibody or cell-mediated immune response. T cell-deprived mice suffer an infection of intermediate severity associated with an increased interferon response, a normal humoral immune response and no cell-mediated immune response. The implications of these results in relation to the role of the antiviral responses in recovery from Sendai virus infection are discussed.     

Poxvirus interleukin-4 expression overcomes inherent resistance and vaccine-induced immunity: pathogenesis, prophylaxis, and antiviral therapy

In 2001, Jackson et al. reported that murine IL-4 expression by a recombinant ectromelia virus caused enhanced morbidity and lethality in resistant C57BL/6 mice as well as overcame protective immune memory responses. To achieve a more thorough understanding of this phenomenon and to assess a variety of countermeasures, we constructed a series of ECTV recombinants encoding murine IL-4 under the control of promoters of different strengths and temporal regulation. We showed that the ECTV-IL-4 recombinant expressing the highest level of IL-4 was uniformly lethal for C57BL/6 mice even when previously immunized. The lethality of the ECTV-IL-4 recombinants resulted from virus-expressed IL-4 signaling through the IL-4 receptor but was not due to IL-4 toxicity. A number of treatment approaches were evaluated against the most virulent IL-4 encoding virus. The most efficacious therapy was a combination of two antiviral drugs (CMX001^® and ST-246^®) that have different mechanisms of action.     

Suppression of in vitro growth of virulent and avirulent herpes simplex viruses by cell-mediated immune mechanisms, antibody, and interferon.

A rounding cell-forming--GC strain, which is a variant of a syncytial giant cell-forming herpes simplex virus (+GC Miyama strain), was highly attenuated for Swiss, BALB/c nu/nu, and nu/+ mice, whereas +GC was highly virulent to all the mice tested. +GC and -GC were antigenically indistinguishable from each other by cross-neutralization and cross-immunization. Immunosuppression induced by cyclophosphamide converted the nonlethal -GC infection of mice into a fatal infection. -GC replication in tissue culture was more effectively suppressed by spleen cells immunized with either +GC or -GC than was the +GC replication. -GC replication was also inhibited more effectively by antibody or the antibody-dependent cell-mediated system than was the +GC replication. -GC is highly sensitive to mouse interferon, but +GC was relatively resistant. These findings indicate that attenuation of this avirulent -GC strain may be due to a high susceptibility of its replication to humoral and cell-mediated defense factors. The probable roles of each defense factor in recovery from the infection with virulent and attenuated herpes simplex virus are also discussed.