Clinical study of 28 cases of cervical lymph node metastasis from an unknown primary carcinoma

From 1989 to 2005, 28 patients--20 men and 8 women--with cervical lymph node metastasis from an unknown primary carcinoma were treated and studied retrospectively. In histological diagnosis, open biopsy was conducted in 11 patients and non-open biopsy (FNA or frozen section diagnosis during surgery) in 17. Blind biopsy under general anesthesia was conducted in 10 patients, showing one primary tumor in the nasopharynx. Tonsillectomy for diagnosis was not done. In region of maximum-size lymph node metastasis, the upper cervical region accounted for 22 cases (79%). The N stage of cervical lymph nodes was as follows: N2a in 4, N2b in 14, N2c in 3, and N3 in 7. The histopathological diagnosis of cervical lymph node was as follows: squamous cell carcinoma in 21, adenocarcinoma in 3, mucoepidermoid carcinoma in 2, and others in 2. Therapy was as follows: only neck dissection in 7, neck dissection with postoperative radiation therapy in 13, and irradiation and chemotherapy in 8. All patients treated with irradiation and chemotherapy had been judged to be inoperable. Seven patients were found to have a subsequent primary tumor. Primary tumor sites were as follows: tonsils in 3 and upper gingiva, base of tongue, lung, and nasopharynx in 1 each. FDG-PET was conducted in 7 patients but revealed no primary tumor. Overall 5-year survival in this study was 46%. We should pay particular attention to the tonsils for detecting primary tumors in patients with cervical metastasis from an unknown primary carcinoma.     

Clinical analysis of cervical metastatis from an unknown primary carcinoma

From 1997 to 2004, 19 cases-18 men and 1 woman-with cervical lymph node metastasis from an unknown primary carcinoma were retrospectively investigated regarding the clinical observation and the treatment outcome. With respect to the histopathological types, 16 cases had squamous cell carcinoma, 2 cases had adenocarcinoma and 1 case had ductal carcinoma. As for the region of lymph node metastasis with maximum size, metastasis located in the upper deep cervical region arrounted for 84%. The presence of primary lesions was comfirmed in 11 cases (3 tonsil, 1 nasopharynx, 1 base of tongue, 2 hypopharynx, 1 esophagus, 1 larynx, 1 gallduct, 1 mammary gland) after the treatment of their metastatic leisions. Tonsillectomy and Blind biopsy were effective for 5 patients. Seventeen patients were treated with neck dissection. Eleven patients with neck dissection underwent radiotherapy. The overall 3-year survival rate as determined by the Kaplan-Meier method was 62%. The 3-year survival rate of the 17 cases whose metastatic leisions were treated with radical neck dissection was 66%. The 3-year survival rate of cases with known primary sites and cases with unknown primary sites after treatment were 55% and 83%, respectively. Radiotherapy with radical neck dissection was thought more effective than radical neck dissection for local and neck control.     

Fluorodeoxyglucose imaging using a coincidence gamma camera to detect head and neck squamous cell carcinoma and response to chemotherapy

This prospective study was performed to evaluate the ability of a dual-head gamma camera with fluorine-18 fluorodeoxyglucose coincidence detection emission tomography (FDG-CDET) to detect primary tumor and cervical lymph nodes in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC), and to show the response of the carcinoma to chemotherapy. The findings were compared with those of physical examination, computed tomography (CT), and histopathology, before treatment in 61 patients, and after induction chemotherapy in 34 of them. Before treatment, the primary was detected in 93%, 79%, and 95% of cases on panendoscopy, CT, and FDG-CDET, respectively. After chemotherapy, 34 patients were evaluable for response of the primary tumor. Surgical resection was performed in 23 of them: agreement with histopathologic results for response to treatment was 74%, 69%, and 78% for panendoscopy, CT, and FDG-CDET, respectively. No surgical resection was performed in 11 of the 34 patients, but biopsies were performed before radiotherapy, and their rates of agreement with histopathologic results for response to treatment were 75%, 75%, and 67% on panendoscopy, CT, and FDG-CDET, respectively. For cervical lymph nodes, 245 sites were resected in 41 patients, and FDG-CDET appeared competitive with CT in detecting metastatic neck disease, especially after neoadjuvant chemotherapy; the accuracy was 93%. These results demonstrated the ability of FDG-CDET to detect primary tumors and cervical lymph nodes in HNSCC and to show its response to chemotherapy, as compared to the ability of CT and panendoscopy. It may be a complementary tool to evaluate residual disease after induction chemotherapy, although higher sensitivity would be required for FDG-CDET to be considered as a staging modality.     

Diagnostic strategies in cervical carcinoma of an unknown primary (CUP)

In patients with cervical cancer of an unknown primary (CUP), no established concept exists for the necessary diagnostic procedures. In order to find the primary tumor, extensive diagnostic steps are generally recommended; however, they are often not performed consistently. In the current study, we consistently used a diagnostic algorithm and analyzed its consequences on patients' prognoses. We retrospectively studied 57 patients who were found to have a cervical metastasis of the upper- or midneck and an unknown primary tumor after routine examination of the head and neck region. Patients were analyzed for the value of applied diagnostic measures, tumor classification, survival rates and frequencies of subsequent lymph node or distant metastases after the initial treatment. Our results showed that a diagnostic algorithm (lymph node biopsy, rigid panendoscopy with systematic biopsies of suspect regions as well as blind biopsies of endoscopically inconspicuous regions, including the tongue base and nasopharynx and bilateral tonsillectomy) led to the detection of 14 occult oropharyngeal and 5 nasopharyngeal primary tumors in the patients. These tumors were primarily diagnosed as CUP. Oropharyngeal tumors either grew submucosally or were so small that only microscopic evaluation of the entire tonsil uncovered the tumor. Imaging procedures (X-ray, ultrasound, CT, MRT and FDG-PET) as well as gynecological, urological and gastroenterological consultations did not reveal the primary tumors in any of the cases. The 3-year survival rate for the patients with occult oropharyngeal primary tumors was 100% after treatment, while the patients in which our diagnostic schedule did not reveal a primary tumor showed a survival rate of 58%. The prognosis of all of the patients with cervical carcinoma metastasis was dependent on the initial nodal stage. Metachronous metastasis after completion of the initial treatment was prognostically infaust, while secondary detection of the primary tumor was worthwhile during follow-up as long as further treatment options were offered. The prognosis of patients with cervical carcinoma metastases of the upper- and midneck is much more favorable than that of patients with a CUP syndrome of other localizations. Identification of an occult pharyngeal tumor is prognostically relevant, since it opens up the possibility of specific locoregional treatment. In patients with cervical CUP, blind but systematic pharyngeal biopsies, including bilateral tonsillectomy, should be performed.     

A study of cervical metastases from unknown primary tumor

Cervical metastases of cancer of an unknown primary tumour (CMUPT) are infrequent but they represent botha diagnostic and therapeutic challenge for ENT physicians. We present a retrospective study over 22 patients with CMUPT diagnosed in our hospital during 13 years (3.4% of the patients with head and neck cancer). The sensitivity of the fine-needle aspiration technique was 94.7%. 54% were N2a, 36% N3 and 9% N2b. 73% were squamous cell carcinoma and 27% were undifferentiated carcinoma. We established our protocol on diagnosis and management: panendoscopy with biopsies of nasopharynx, vallecula and pyriform sinus and ipsilateral tonsillectomy. The primary source was identified in 23% of the series. All squamous cell carcinoma were treated with radical neck surgery plus radiotherapy and the undifferentiated carcinoma with chemotherapy and radiotherapy. The overall survival was 64% at 3 years. The N-stage affected the survival rate.     

Usefulness and pitfall of Narrow band imaging combined with magnifying endoscopy for detecting an unknown head and neck primary site with cervical lymph node metastasis

Objective

Cervical nodal metastasis from clinically undetectable primary squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) accounts for 1–2% of head and neck malignancies. We retrospectively evaluate the ability of Narrow band imaging combined with magnifying endoscopy (NBI-ME) to detect the primary sites of superficial SCC in the head and neck region.

Methods

This was a report of 11 patients. We performed with NBI-ME to detect unknown primary sites in the head and neck.

Results

Among 11 patients, primary sites were detected in eight. Primary sites were detected in the head and neck in 6 (54.5%) of 11 patients on NBI-ME, all 6 primary lesions were a flat lesion. Two patients in whom primary lesions could not be detected on NBI-ME, one had submucosal tumor like lesion, the other featured by a detectable primary lesion 19 months after neck dissection.

Conclusion

NBI-ME can be recommended as an essential procedure for the detection of primary lesions in patients with primary unknown cervical lymph node metastasis.     

Detection of FDG-PET and FDG-PET/CT in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma

We evaluated the accuracy of staging in 159 patients with head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) scanned by FDG-PET and 116 patients with the same cancer scanned by FDG-PET/computed tomography (CT). The accuracy was measured by comparing the FDG-PET/FDG-PET/CT findings at the primary tumor site, cervical node sites and distant metastatic sites with the clinical diagnosis. Especially, accuracy at cervical sites was evaluated from the screening point of view. Both examinations yielded an accuracy rate of more than 80% for each site, and a negative predictive value of more than 90% for the cervical sites. For the cervical sites, the positive predictive value (PPV) of FDG-PET was 78% and of FDG-PET/CT was 82%. When one cervical lymph node metastasis was detected by FDG-PET, the PPV was 63%, which appears to be comparatively low. Both examinations showed high accuracy for staging of HNSCC. In the near future, excellent screening examination might become possible with the spread of FDG-PET/CT. However, both examinations do not yield the direct image of the carcinoma itself, but only the status of glucose metabolism in the carcinoma. Care must always be exercised in the interpretation, as there are not a few false negative and false positive cases.     

声门上型喉癌颈淋巴结转移方式及其对预后的影响

目的：探讨影响声门上型喉癌颈淋巴结转移的临床病理因素及颈淋巴结转移对预后的影响。方法：用x^2检验和Logistic回归分析，对55例声门上型喉癌患者的肿瘤临床病理学因素与颈淋巴结转移的关系进行回顾性分析；并对颈淋巴结转移状态，转移颈淋巴结大小、数目、累及区域、最低受累区域等病理学因素对预后的影响进行Cox回归分析。结果：单因素分析显示，肿瘤病理分级、肿瘤大小、肿瘤浸润深度与发生颈淋巴结转移有关；多因素分析显示，肿瘤病理分级、肿瘤大小与发生颈淋巴结转移明显相关；声门上型喉癌患者5年生存率为52．7％。Cox回归分析表明，临床N分期、颈淋巴结转移状态、转移颈淋巴结大小影响患者预后。结论：声门上型喉癌颈淋巴结转移的发生受原发癌病理学因素的影响，它从多个角度明显影响患者预后；对影响预后的淋巴结因素采取相应治疗措施，对提高声门上型喉癌的治疗效果具有重要意义。     

Positron emission tomography in the management of unknown primary head and neck carcinoma

OBJECTIVE: To assess the role of positron emission tomography (PET) in the management of unknown primary carcinoma of the head and neck region. DESIGN AND SETTING: Prospective case series at an academic medical center. PATIENTS: Twenty-six patients with an open excisional biopsy or a fine-needle aspiration biopsy finding that confirmed squamous cell carcinoma of the cervical lymph nodes and no visible primary tumor (as determined by results of a comprehensive physical examination and computed tomography and/or magnetic resonance imaging) underwent PET. The standard evaluation consisted of a comprehensive head and neck examination that included fiberoptic laryngoscopy/nasopharyngoscopy, computed tomography and/or magnetic resonance imaging, and PET followed by panendoscopy with selected biopsies and tonsillectomy. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of PET to detect an occult primary tumor. RESULTS: The PET detected 8 occult primary tumors in 26 patients (detection rate, 30.8%). Four occult primary tumors (2 at the base of the tongue and 2 in the tonsil) were detected during routine panendoscopy with negative PET findings. The sensitivity of PET was 66.0%, with a specificity of 92.9%. The positive predictive value was 88.8%, and the negative predictive value was 76.5%. CONCLUSIONS: Positron emission tomography can be a valuable tool to identify a subset of patients with an occult primary tumor in the head and neck region. In addition, it can be used to screen for primary tumors below the clavicle. Early identification of the primary tumor may allow for more accurate tumor staging and targeted radiotherapy to minimize adverse effects and complications. A normal PET finding, however, does not eliminate the need for a careful panendoscopy with directed biopsies and tonsillectomy.     

Malignant cervical epithelial adenopathy from unknown primary source. Apropos of a series of 54 cases]

Fifty four patients with cervical lymph node metastasis from an unknown primary tumor underwent treatment from 1969 to 1988. Fourty five underwent radical neck dissection. 69% had node capsular effraction and 36% perinodal vascular embolism. Thirty four patients underwent postoperative radiotherapy including rhinopharynx, cervical oesophagus and all the bilateral cervical nodes. The primary tumor appeared after treatment in 7 cases. Total survival rate is 36% 5 years after treatment. Vascular embolism aggravates the prognosis. Radiosurgical association allow effective control of loco-regional cancer but does not improve survival rate. Prognosis is aggravated by metastases arising (18%).     

Carcinoma Of the Mobile Tongue: Incidence of Cervical Metastases in Early Lesions Related to Method of Primary Treatment

One hundred thirty-eight patients receiving initial treatment for squamous cell carcinoma of the mobile tongue from 1960 to 1978 were reviewed to determine the frequency of cervical metastasis in early carcinoma (T1N0 and T2N0).Occult cervical node metastasis in an elective neck dissection or subsequent neck recurrence in an initially negative neck was found in 14.5% (9/62) of patients staged T1N0 and 30.6% (11/36) of patients staged T2N0. Refinement of the staging system demonstrated that 9.7% (3/31) of patients with a primary lesion less than or equal to 1.0 cm and a clinically negative neck (T1aN0) subsequently developed a cervical metastasis. Patients with primary lesions greater than 1.0 cm but less than or equal to 2.0 cm (T1bN0) had twice the risk of occult cervical metastasis (19.4% or 6/31). The crude 5-year survivals in Stage I for radium alone, partial glossectomy, and partial glossectomy with neck dissection were 64%, 58% and 75% respectively and in Stage II were 31%, 66% and 71% respectively. Local-regional failure is the principal mechanism of failure In patients treated locally particularly in Stage II.     

Metastatic carcinoma of the neck from unknown primary sites

Encountering a metastatic carcinoma of the neck from an unknown primary site is not unusual, despite intensive examinations of the entire body. In previous reports, the pathological diagnosis of these carcinomas was usually squamous cell carcinomas and rarely adenocarcinoma. We treated eight patients with metastatic carcinoma of the neck from unknown primary sites, including 4 cases of squamous cell carcinoma, 2 cases of adenocarcinoma, one case of small cell carcinoma, and one case of clear cell carcinoma, during a 10-year period from January 1992 to December 2001. We clinically examined these eight cases, and focusing on the two cases of metastatic cervical adenocarcinoma from unknown primary sites. The 8 cases consisted of 5 cases of N2 and 3 cases of N3 disease. Three of the 5 N2 patients underwent a neck dissection, but all three of the N3 cases were judged to be inoperable. Disease-free survival was achieved in all 3 patients who underwent surgery. In this paper, we review 36 reports on metastatic carcinomas of the neck from unknown primary sites and statistically analyze 1454 cases. Pathologically, the majority of them (81.1%) were squamous cell carcinoma; adenocarcinomas accounted for only 7.6% of the cases. Notably, 65.0% of the patients with cervical metastatic adenocarcinomas were confirmed to have primary lesions outside the head and neck region. The prognosis of primary unknown metastatic cervical adenocarcinoma is reportedly poor, and the optimal treatment is still unclear, although surgery is recommended for primary unknown metastatic cervical squamous cell carcinoma. However, we suggest that intensive treatment, including surgery, radiotherapy, and chemotherapy, of metastatic lesions of the neck may play a key role in improving patient prognosis.     

下咽癌颈淋巴结转移的临床病理学特点及其对预后的影响

目的探讨影响下咽癌颈淋巴结转移的临床病理因素和颈淋巴结转移对预后的影响。方法采用X^2检验和Logistic回归分析，对98例下咽癌患者的临床病理学因素与颈淋巴结转移的关系进行回顾性研究。并对颈淋巴结转移状态、转移颈淋巴结大小、转移颈淋巴结数目、转移颈淋巴结累及区域数、转移颈淋巴结最低受累区域等淋巴结病理学因素对生存率的影响，进行Cox回归分析。结果下咽癌患者5年生存率为28．6％。单因素和多因素分析均证实，肿瘤生长方式、肿瘤大小与发生颈淋巴结转移关系密切。而肿瘤突破基底膜达黏膜下层后对下咽癌颈淋巴结转移发生率不再产生进一步影响。Cox回归分析表明，临床N分期、颈淋巴结转移状态、转移颈淋巴结大小、转移颈淋巴结最低受累区域因素影响患者生存率，特别是转移颈淋巴结大小、转移颈淋巴结最低受累区域因素与下咽癌患者生存率明显相关。结论下咽癌颈淋巴结转移是影响患者预后的重要因素，预测下咽癌颈淋巴结，对其作出早期正确诊断，并对影响预后的淋巴结因素采取相应治疗措施是提高下咽癌治疗效果的关键。     

Combined radiotherapy with planned neck dissection for small head and neck cancers with advanced cervical metastases

BACKGROUND: We have previously described our treatment algorithm for patients with small head and neck cancers with advanced cervical metastases (stage N2 or greater). Primary radiotherapy is given to the primary site and neck, followed 6 weeks later with endoscopy and biopsy of the primary site. If biopsy of the primary site is negative by frozen section, an immediate neck dissection is performed even when no clinical residual neck disease is present. Our initial review found that 36% of patients with a complete clinical response to radiotherapy had positive nodes on histological examination. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective. METHODS: The medical records of 71 patients treated at UCLA Medical Center from 1986 to 1999 by this algorithm were reviewed. RESULTS: After radiotherapy, 69 of 71 patients had a complete response at their primary site. Forty-two patients had a complete clinical response in the neck. Seventy-one neck dissections were performed. Overall, 31 of 71 neck dissections (44%) had positive nodes. Among the 42 patients with a complete response to radiotherapy, 13 (31%) had positive histological nodes. Among the 29 patients with a partial response to radiotherapy, 17 (59%) had positive nodes. Follow-up and incidence of neck recurrence are discussed. CONCLUSION: Planned neck dissection for advanced cervical metastases remains controversial for patients with a complete clinical response to radiotherapy. However, our results suggest that clinical assessment after radiotherapy cannot assure the absence of neck disease. Until there are reliable methods to distinguish which patients are truly free of neck disease, we believe the benefits of a planned neck dissection outweigh the low morbidity of this procedure.     

Cervical lymph node metastases from occult squamous cell carcinoma: analysis of 82 cases

PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to analyze the prognostic value of some clinical factors and to compare the survival of different treatment plans in patients with cervical lymph node metastases from occult squamous cell carcinoma (SCC). METHODS: A retrospective review was conducted of patients who were diagnosed as having cervical lymph node metastases from occult SCC. Overall cumulative survival was analyzed using the standard Kaplan-Meier method. Tests of significance were based on log-rank statistics. RESULTS: The 82 patients in the study consisted of 69 males (84.2%) and 13 females (15.8%). The average age at diagnosis was 64.7 years. Fifty patients (60.9%) underwent surgical treatment of cervical metastasis. Radiotherapy was performed in 79 patients. Thirty-two patients (40.5%) received primary fractioned external beam radiotherapy; 47 patients (59.5%) received postoperative fractioned external beam radiotherapy. Ipsilateral radiotherapy was performed on 37 patients (46.8%), bilateral neck plus mucosal irradiation was performed in 42 patients (53.2%). Ten patients (12.2%) developed a primary tumor during the follow-up. The actuarial survival rates of all patients 2, 5 and 10 years after diagnosis were 50.9, 25.3 and 18.5%, respectively. Patients with nodal stage N2b, N2c and N3 had a significantly poorer prognosis than those with nodal stage N1 and N2a (p = 0.0239). The survival in patients with metastatic nodes in the supraclavicular region (level IV) was significantly poorer than that of patients with involvement of the upper-middle jugular lymph nodes (p = 0.0003). We observed a statistically significant better survival in patients receiving bilateral neck plus mucosal irradiation (p = 0.0003). CONCLUSIONS: Initial N-category and metastasis localization were the most important prognostic factors and nodal relapse the major cause of treatment failure, thus optimal management of cervical nodes appears crucial for the success of treatment. Patients receiving bilateral neck plus mucosal irradiation had a higher survival rate than those who received ipsilateral irradiation.     

Treatment of metastatic neck nodes secondary to an occult epidermoid carcinoma of the head and neck

One hundred thirty-eight patients, who were followed for a minimum of 5 years, had either surgery and postoperative radiotherapy (48 patients) or radiotherapy only (90 patients) for metastatic epidermoid carcinoma in cervical nodes from an unknown head and neck primary. All received radiotherapy to the presumed occult sites. Forty-five percent presented with a single unilateral adenopathy. Those who were initially operable had a neck recurrence rate of 17% and a survival rate of 53%. Forty-three percent of initially inoperable patients recurred and only 25% survived. Patients with adenopathy which completely regressed or became resectable after irradiation had an 80% locoregional control. Only 4% developed an overt cancer at an occult site within 5 years.     

Evaluation of selective lymph node sampling in the node-negative neck

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether intraoperative selective lymph node sampling before neck dissection in the node-negative (N0) neck accurately reflects the disease content of the neck and can be used to assist in treatment selection. STUDY DESIGN: A prospective clinical study at a university medical center. METHODS: Over a 2-year period, 36 patients with head and neck squamous cell carcinoma scheduled to undergo 41 elective neck dissections were enrolled. At the initiation of the neck dissection, biopsy of the "most suspicious" lymph node within the tumor's primary nodal drainage basin was performed, and the specimen was measured and sent for frozen-section evaluation. The results of lymph node sampling were compared with the final histopathologic interpretation of the resected primary and neck dissection. RESULTS: Of the 41 N0 necks, 29% (12 of 41) were positive for occult metastases. Results of selective lymph node biopsy correlated with the results of neck dissection in 34 of 41 specimens (83%). The specificity and positive predictive value of node sampling were both 100%. The proportion of cases with a positive neck dissection with a positive sampled node (sensitivity) was 42% (5 of 12). CONCLUSION: The results of selective lymph node biopsy with frozen-section analysis in the N0 neck, as defined in the current study, did not reflect a technique with adequate sensitivity to alter intraoperative treatment strategy.     

Simultaneous bilateral neck dissections

From April 1985 to December 1989, 65 patients with advanced head and neck squamous cell carcinoma, underwent simultaneous bilateral neck dissection (SBND) at Saitama Cancer Center. Three and five year survival percentages were 53 and 42%, respectively. In patients without histologic involvement of cervical nodes, five year survival rate was 83%, whereas in those with nodal involvement five year survival fell to 32% (p less than 0.005). The conclusion were the following: (1) Of 38 patients diagnosed to have lymph node involvements on one side of neck before operation, 8 patients (22%) were found to have bilateral lymph node metastasis in clinicopathological study. Of 13 patients having no clinical lymph node metastasis on both sides of neck, 7 patients (54%) were found to have unilateral lymph node metastasis. Of 16 patients diagnosed to have bilateral lymph nodes involvement, 10 patients were found to have bilateral neck metastasis and 2 had unilateral neck metastasis. (2) Of 35 cases of hypopharyngeal canners, 19 cases had clinically positive lymph nodes on one side of neck. Of these 19 cases, 5 cases (26%) had histologically positive nodes on the opposite side. 14 (40%) of 35 cases had metastasis on the opposite side. In conclusion, SBND is a proper treatment for metastatic cervical cancer from a primary lesion of the head and neck, especially in hypopharyngeal cancers, because the rate of recurrence seems to be related more to the difficulty in controlling lymph node metastasis than to the failure in treatment of the primary cancer.     

Incidence of metastatic well-differentiated thyroid cancer in cervical lymph nodes

OBJECTIVE: To determine the incidence of clinically positive lateral cervical nodes at presentation and after initial treatment in patients with well-differentiated thyroid cancer. DESIGN: Retrospective chart review. SETTING: University-affiliated teaching hospitals. PATIENTS: A total of 508 patients who underwent a thyroidectomy as part of their initial treatment for well-differentiated thyroid carcinoma between January 1978 and December 1999. Neck dissections were performed only for clinically palpable cervical nodes. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Recurrence in the neck and survival. RESULTS: Forty-four patients (9%) had palpable lateral cervical lymph nodes at the time of surgery. All 31 patients younger than 45 years presenting with palpable positive nodes are alive and free of disease; 4 of 13 patients 45 years or older have died of thyroid cancer. Only 16 (3%) of 464 patients who did not undergo initial neck dissection had recurrence in lateral cervical nodes. Recurrence is more likely when the initial tumor is larger than 4 cm. In 216 patients younger than 45 years, there were 5 (2%) recurrences in lateral cervical nodes; these patients remain alive and free of disease. In 248 patients 45 years or older, there were 11 (4%) with recurrent disease in the lateral neck; 4 of these patients have died of thyroid cancer. CONCLUSIONS: An aggressive approach to detecting and treating occult lateral cervical nodes by techniques such as jugular node sampling, sentinel node biopsy, or image-guided needle biopsy is not necessary in most patients. Attempts to detect and remove occult lateral cervical lymph node metastases might be considered in older patients with large primary tumors.     

Significance of Node Biopsy Before Definitive Treatment of Cervical Metastatic Carcinoma

A survey was made of 714 radical neck dissections done alone or in combination with resection of a primary malignancy. Sixty-four (8.9%) of the patients had had a cervical node biopsy before diagnosis and definitive treatment. The complications of wound necrosis, local cervical recurrence, and distant metastasis were significantly higher in those patients than in patients who had had no biopsy or who had had biopsy only at the time of definitive treatment. When 40 of the 64 patients were matched on the basis of age, sex, histological diagnosis, site and stage of the lesion and treatment protocol with 40 patients who had had no biopsy, this trend toward a higher complication rate when previous biopsy was done continued and was significantly higher for distant metastasis. The authors believe that these findings quantitatively confirm the accepted belief that, except for instances when no primary lesion can be found and the cervical mass must be biopsied for the purposes of diagnosis, such biopsy increases local complications and, by increasing the incidence of distant metastasis, decreases the chance for survival.