Manipulating the glial scar: Chondroitinase ABC as a therapy for spinal cord injury

Chondroitin sulphate proteoglycans (CSPGs) are potent inhibitors of growth in the adult CNS. Use of the enzyme chondroitinase ABC (ChABC) as a strategy to reduce CSPG inhibition in experimental models of spinal cord injury has led to observations of a remarkable capacity for repair. Here we review the evidence that treatment with ChABC, either as an individual therapy or in combination with other strategies, can have multiple beneficial effects on promoting repair following spinal cord injury. These include promoting regeneration of injured axons, plasticity of uninjured pathways and neuroprotection of injured projection neurons. More importantly, ChABC therapy has been demonstrated to promote significant recovery of function to spinal injured animals. Thus, there is robust pre-clinical evidence demonstrating beneficial effects of ChABC treatment following spinal cord injury. Furthermore, these effects have been replicated in a number of different injury models, with independent confirmation by different laboratories, providing an important validation of ChABC as a promising therapeutic strategy. We discuss putative mechanisms underlying ChABC-mediated repair as well as potential issues and considerations in translating ChABC treatment into a clinical therapy for spinal cord injury.     

Stem cell repair of central nervous system injury

Neural stem cells (NSCs) have great potential as a therapeutic tool for the repair of a number of CNS disorders. NSCs can either be isolated from embryonic and adult brain tissue or be induced from both mouse and human ES cells. These cells proliferate in vitro through many passages without losing their multipotentiality. Following engraftment into the adult CNS, NSCs differentiate mainly into glia, except in neurogenic areas. After engraftment into the injured and diseased CNS, their differentiation is further retarded. In vitro manipulation of NSC fate prior to transplantation and/or modification of the host environment may be necessary to control the terminal lineage of the transplanted cells to obtain functionally significant numbers of neurons. NSCs and a few types of glial precursors have shown the capability to differentiate into oligodendrocytes and to remyeliate the demyelinated axons in the CNS, but the functional extent of remyelination achieved by these transplants is limited. Manipulation of endogenous neural precursors may be an alternative therapy or a complimentary therapy to stem cell transplantation for neurodegenerative disease and CNS injury. However, this at present is challenging and so far has been unsuccessful. Understanding mechanisms of NSC differentiation in the context of the injured CNS will be critical to achieving these therapeutic strategies.     

Extrinsic inhibitors in axon sprouting and functional recovery after spinal cord injur y

The limited axonal growth after central nervous system （CNS） injury such as spinal cord injury presents a major challenge in promoting repair and recovery. The literature in axonal repair has focused mostly on frank regeneration of injured axons. Here, we argue that sprouting of uninjured axons, an innate repair mech- anism of the CNS, might be more amenable to modulation in order to promote functional repair. Extrinsic inhibitors of axonal growth modulate axon sprouting after injury and may serve as the first group of therapeutic targets to promote functional repair.     

A retinoic acid receptor β agonist (CD2019) overcomes inhibition of axonal outgrowth via phosphoinositide 3-kinase signalling in the injured adult spinal cord

After spinal cord injury in the adult mammal, axons do not normally regrow and this commonly leads to paralysis. Retinoic acid (RA) can stimulate neurite outgrowth in vitro of both the embryonic central and peripheral nervous system, via activation of the retinoic acid receptor (RAR) β2. We show here that regions of the adult CNS, including the cerebellum and cerebral cortex, express RARβ2. We show that when cerebellar neurons are grown in the presence of myelin-associated glycoprotein (MAG) which inhibits neurite outgrowth, RARβ can be activated in a dose dependent manner by a RARβ agonist (CD2019) and neurite outgrowth can occur via phosphoinositide 3-kinase (PI3K) signalling. In a model of spinal cord injury CD2019 also acts through PI3K signalling to induce axonal outgrowth of descending corticospinal fibres and promote functional recovery. Our data suggest that RARβ agonists may be of therapeutic potential for human spinal cord injuries.     

Expression of DA11, a neuronal-injury-induced fatty acid binding protein,coincides with axon growth and neuronal differentiation during central nervous system development

DA11 is the first fatty acid binding protein (FABP) for which gene expression has been shown to be upregulated following neuronal injury in the adult peripheral nervous system. To understand better the potential regulatory role(s) of this unique FABP in axonal growth and neuronal differentiation, we undertook a temporal and spatial study of DA11 gene expression in the developing rat central nervous system (CNS). Transient upregulation of DA11 mRNA and protein levels in CNS tissues were quantified by Northern blot hybridization and Western immunoblot analyses at different developmental ages. Homogenates of embryonic and neonatal cerebral cortex, cerebellum, brainstem, and hippocampal tissues contained 100-fold more DA11 mRNA and protein than corresponding adult tissues. Significant increase in DA11 mRNA was observed as early as embryonic day (E) 14 in cerebral cortex and cerebellum and E19 in brain stem and hippocampus. Postnatal levels of DA11 remained elevated through postnatal day (P) 10 in cerebral cortex, P14 in brain stem and hippocampus, and P20 in cerebellum. Localization of DA11-like immunoreactivity to specific CNS tissues, cell types, and intracellular compartments at P9 revealed a spatial pattern of neuronal expression different than that reported for other FABPs. DA11 protein was detected in the nucleus, cytoplasm, axons, and dendrites of differentiating neurons in cerebral cortex, hippocampus, cerebellum, brain stem, spinal cord, and olfactory bulb. The strong association of DA11 gene expression with development throughout the CNS suggests that this unique FABP plays an important role in axonal growth and neuronal differentiation in many different neuronal populations. J. Neurosci. Res. 48:551–562, 1997. © 1997 Wiley-Liss Inc.     

From neural stem cells to myelinating oligodendrocytes

The potential to generate oligodendrocytes progenitors (OP) from neural stem cells (NSCs) exists throughout the developing CNS. Yet, in the embryonic spinal cord, the oligodendrocyte phenotype is induced by sonic hedgehog in a restricted anterior region. In addition, neuregulins are emerging as potent regulators of early and late OP development. The ability to isolate and grow NSCs as well as glial-restricted progenitors has revealed that FGF2 and thyroid hormone favor an oligodendrocyte fate. Analysis of genetically modified mice showed that PDGF controls the migration and production of oligodendrocytes in vivo. Interplay between mitogens, thyroid hormone, and neurotransmitters may maintain the undifferentiated stage or result in OP growth arrest. Notch signaling by axons inhibits oligodendrocyte differentiation until neuronal signals--linked to electrical activity-trigger initiation of myelination. To repair myelin in adult CNS, multipotential neural precursors, rather than slowly cycling OP, appear the cells of choice to rapidly generate myelin-forming cells.     

Nerve growth factor-hypersecreting Schwann cell grafts augment and guide spinal cord axonal growth and remyelinate central nervous system axons in a phenotypically appropriate manner that correlates with expression of L1.

Schwann cells contribute to efficient axonal regeneration after peripheral nerve injury and, when grafted to the central nervous system (CNS), also support a modest degree of central axonal regeneration. This study examined (1) whether Schwann cells grafted to the CNS exhibit normal patterns of differentiation and association with spinal axons and what signals putatively modulate these interactions, and (2) whether Schwann cells overexpressing neurotrophic factors enhance axonal regeneration. Thus, primary Schwann cells were transduced to hypersecrete human nerve growth factor (NGF) and were grafted to spinal cord injury sites in adult rats. Comparisons were made to nontransfected Schwann cells. From 3 days to 6 months later, grafted Schwann cells exhibited a phenotypic and temporal course of differentiation that matched patterns normally observed after peripheral nerve injury. Schwann cells spontaneously aligned into regular spatial arrays within the cord, appropriately remyelinated coerulospinal axons that regenerated into grafts, and appropriately ensheathed but did not myelinate sensory axons extending into grafts. Coordinate expression of the cell adhesion molecule L1 on Schwann cells and axons correlated with establishment of appropriate patterns of axon-Schwann cell ensheathment. Transduction of Schwann cells to overexpress NGF robustly increased axonal growth but did not otherwise alter the nature of interactions with growing axons. These findings suggest that signals expressed on Schwann cells that modulate peripheral axonal regeneration and myelination are also recognized in the CNS and that the modification of Schwann cells to overexpress growth factors significantly augments their capacity to support extensive axonal growth in models of CNS injury.     

Axonal regeneration and neural network reconstruction in mammalian CNS

Following injury to the white matter of the adult mammalian central nervous system (CNS), severed axons fail to regenerate beyond the lesion site. Recent studies have revealed that the CNS white matter contains numerous axon growth inhibitors. These findings can easily lead to the concept that regenerating axons cannot grow in the CNS white matter because of the growth inhibition by these inhibitory molecules. This “misconception” appears to be generally accepted. However, it is erroneous because axons can grow along the CNS white matter very rapidly. Neurons cultured on a slice of adult rat brain can extend their neurites along the white matter tract, while axons of neurons transplanted into the adult rat spinal cord white matter can grow along the CNS white matter very rapidly, at more than 1 mm/day. Not only artificially transplanted neurons, but also in situ CNS neurons can elongate axons linearly within the CNS white matter at this rate. The idea that a CNS neuron can regenerate a severed axon along the CNS white matter has great significance when thinking about reconstruction of original neural networks after focal destruction due to CNS injury.

     

Induced pluripotent stem cell-derived neural stem cell therapies for spinal cord injury

The greatest challenge to successful treatment of spinal cord injury is the limited regenerative capacity of the central nervous system and its inability to replace lost neurons and severed axons following injury. Neural stem cell grafts derived from fetal central nervous system tissue or embryonic stem cells have shown therapeutic promise by differentiation into neurons and glia that have the potential to form functional neuronal relays across injured spinal cord segments. However, implementation of fetal-derived or embryonic stem cell-derived neural stem cell therapies for patients with spinal cord injury raises ethical concerns. Induced pluripotent stem cells can be generated from adult somatic cells and differentiated into neural stem cells suitable for therapeutic use, thereby providing an ethical source of implantable cells that can be made in an autologous fashion to avoid problems of immune rejection. This review discusses the therapeutic potential of human induced pluripotent stem cell-derived neural stem cell transplantation for treatment of spinal cord injury, as well as addressing potential mechanisms, future perspectives and challenges.     

Differential effects of distinct central nervous system regions on cell migration and axonal extension of neural precursor transplants

Transplantation of neural precursor cells (NPCs) is a promising therapeutic strategy in CNS injury. However, the adult CNS lacks instructive signals present during development and, depending on the region and type of transplant, may be inhibitory for neuron generation and axonal growth. We examined the effects of the white matter in different regions of the adult CNS on the properties of NPC transplants with respect to cell survival, differentiation, migration, and axonal growth. NPCs were prepared from day 13.5 embryonic spinal cord of transgenic rats that express the human placental alkaline phosphatase (AP) reporter. These NPCs were injected unilaterally into the cervical spinal cord white matter and into the corpus callosum of adult rats and were analyzed immunohistochemically 2 weeks later. NPCs survived in both regions and differentiated into astrocytes, oligodendrocytes, and neurons, with no apparent differences in survival or phenotypic composition. However, in the spinal cord white matter, graft‐derived cells, identified as precursors and glial cells, migrated from the injection site rostrally and caudally, whereas, in the corpus callosum, graft‐derived cells did not migrate and remained at the injection site. Importantly, graft‐derived neurons extended axons from the grafting site along the corpus callosum past the midline, entering into the contralateral side of the corpus callosum. These results demonstrate dramatic differences between white matter regions in the spinal cord and brain with respect to cell migration and axonal growth and underscore the importance of considering the effects of the local CNS environment in the design of effective transplantation strategies. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Mechanisms of CNS myelin inhibition: evidence for distinct and neuronal cell type specific receptor systems

Following injury to the adult mammalian central nervous system, regenerative growth of severed axons is very limited. The lack of neuronal repair is often associated with significant functional deficits, and depending on the severity of injury, may result in permanent paralysis distal to the site of injury. A detailed understanding of the molecular mechanisms that limit neuronal growth in the injured spinal cord is an important step toward the development of specific strategies aimed at restoring functional connectivity lost as a consequence of injury. While rapid progress is being made in defining the molecular identity of CNS growth inhibitory constituents, comparatively little is known about their receptors and downstream signaling mechanisms. Emerging new evidence suggests that the mechanisms for myelin inhibition are likely to be complex, involving multiple and distinct receptor systems that may operate in a redundant manner. Furthermore, the relative contribution of a specific ligand-receptor system to bring about growth inhibition may greatly vary among different neuronal cell types. Myelin-associated glycoprotein (MAG), for example, employs different mechanisms to inhibit neurite outgrowth of cerebellar, sensory, and retinal ganglion neurons in vitro. Nogo-A harbors distinct growth inhibitory regions, which employ different signaling mechanisms. The Nogo-66 receptor 1 (NgR1), a shared ligand binding component in a receptor complex for Nogo-66, MAG, and OMgp, participates in neuronal growth cone collapse to acutely presented myelin inhibitors, but is dispensable for longitudinal neurite outgrowth inhibition on substrate-bound Nogo-66, MAG, OMgp, or crude CNS myelin in vitro. Consistent with the idea of cell-type specific mechanisms for myelin inhibition, different types of CNS neurons possess very different regenerative capacities and respond differently to experimental treatment strategies in vivo. We speculate that differences in regenerative axonal growth among different fiber systems are a reflection of their intrinsic ability to elongate axons and their distinct cell surface receptor profiles to respond to the growth inhibitory extracellular milieu. The existence of cell type specific mechanisms to impair regenerative axonal growth in the CNS may have important implications for the development of treatment strategies. Depending on the fiber tract injured, different ligand-receptor systems may need to be targeted in order to elicit robust and long-distance regenerative axonal growth.     

Intraspinal transplants

Transplants of embryonic central nervous system tissue have long been used to study axon growth during development and regeneration, and more recently to promote recovery in models of human diseases. Transplants of embryonic substantia nigra correct some of the deficits found in experimental Parkinson's disease, for example, by mechanisms that are thought to include release of neurotransmitter and reinnervation of host targets, as well as by stimulating growth of host axons. Similar mechanisms appear to allow intraspinal transplants of embryonic brainstem to reverse locomotor and autonomic deficits due to experimental spinal cord injuries. Embryonic spinal cord transplants offer an additional strategy for correcting the deficits of spinal cord injury because, by replacing damaged populations of neurons, they may mediate the restoration of connections between host neurons. We have found that spinal cord transplants permit regrowth of adult host axons resulting in reconstitution of synaptic complexes within the transplant that in many respects resemble normal synapses. Transplants of fetal spinal cord may also contribute to behavioral recovery by rescuing axotomized host neurons that otherwise would have died. Electrophysiological and behavioral investigations of functional recovery after intraspinal transplantation are preliminary, and the role of transplants in the treatment of human spinal cord injury is uncertain. Transplants are contributing to our understanding of the mechanisms of recovery, however, and are likely to play a role in the development of rational treatments.     

Neurotrophic Factors Increase Axonal Growth after Spinal Cord Injury and Transplantation in the Adult Rat

The capacity of CNS neurons for axonal regrowth after injury decreases as the age of the animal at time of injury increases. After spinal cord lesions at birth, there is extensive regenerative growth into and beyond a transplant of fetal spinal cord tissue placed at the injury site. After injury in the adult, however, although host corticospinal and brainstem-spinal axons project into the transplant, their distribution is restricted to within 200 μm of the host/transplant border. The aim of this study was to determine if the administration of neurotrophic factors could increase the capacity of mature CNS neurons for regrowth after injury. Spinal cord hemisection lesions were made at cervical or thoracic levels in adult rats. Transplants of E14 fetal spinal cord tissue were placed into the lesion site. The following neurotrophic factors were administered at the site of injury and transplantation: brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), neurotrophin-3 (NT-3), neurotrophin-4 (NT-4), ciliary-derived neurotrophic factor (CNTF), or vehicle alone. After 1–2 months survival, neuroanatomical tracing and immunocytochemical methods were used to examine the growth of host axons within the transplants. The neurotrophin administration led to increases in the extent of serotonergic, noradrenergic, and corticospinal axonal ingrowth within the transplants. The influence of the administration of the neurotrophins on the growth of injured CNS axons was not a generalized effect of growth factors per se, since the administration of CNTF had no effect on the growth of any of the descending CNS axons tested. These results indicate that in addition to influencing the survival of developing CNS and PNS neurons, neurotrophic factors are able to exert aneurotropicinfluence on injured mature CNS neurons by increasing their axonal growth within a transplant.     

Spontaneous axonal regeneration in rodent spinal cord after ischemic injury

Here we present evidence for spontaneous and long-lasting regeneration of CNS axons after spinal cord lesions in adult rats. The length of 200 kD neurofilament (NF)-immunolabeled axons was estimated after photochemically induced ischemic spinal cord lesions using a stereological tool. The total length of all NF-immunolabeled axons within the lesion cavities was increased 6- to 10-fold at 5, 10, and 15 wk post-lesion compared with 1 wk post-surgery. In ultrastructural studies we found the putatively regenerating axons within the lesion to be associated either with oligodendrocytes or Schwann cells, while other fibers were unmyelinated. Immunohistochemistry demonstrated that some of the regenerated fibers were tyrosine hydroxylase- or serotonin-immunoreactive, indicating a central origin. These findings suggest that there is a considerable amount of spontaneous regeneration after spinal cord lesions in rodents and that the fibers remain several months after injury. The findings of tyrosine hydroxylase- and serotonin-immunoreactivity in the axons suggest that descending central fibers contribute to this endogenous repair of ischemic spinal cord injury.     

Neurotrophism without neurotropism: BDNF promotes survival but not growth of lesioned corticospinal neurons.

Neurotrophic factors exert many effects on the intact and lesioned adult central nervous system (CNS). Among these effects are prevention of neuronal death (neurotrophism) and promotion of axonal growth (neurotropism) after injury. To date, however, it has not been established whether survival and axonal growth functions of neurotrophins can be independently modulated in injured adult neurons in vivo. To address this question, the ability of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) to influence corticospinal motor neuronal survival and axonal growth was examined in two injury paradigms. In the first paradigm, a survival assay, adult Fischer 344 rats underwent subcortical lesions followed by grafts to the lesion cavity of syngenic fibroblasts genetically modified to secrete high amounts BDNF or, in control subjects, the reporter gene green fluorescent protein. In control subjects, only 36.2 +/- 7.0% of the retrogradely labeled corticospinal neurons survived the lesion, whereas 89.8 +/- 5.9% (P < 0.001) of the corticospinal neurons survived in animals that received BDNF-secreting grafts. However, in an axonal growth assay, BDNF-secreting cell grafts that were placed into either subcortical lesion sites or sites of thoracic spinal cord injury failed to elicit corticospinal axonal growth. Despite this lack of a neurotropic effect on lesioned corticospinal axons, BDNF-secreting cell grafts placed in the injured spinal cord significantly augmented the growth of other types of axons, including local motor, sensory, and coerulospinal axons. Immunolabeling for tyrosine kinase B (trkB) demonstrated that BDNF receptors were present on corticospinal neuronal somata and apical dendrites but were not detected on their projecting axons. Thus, single classes of neurons in the adult CNS appear to exhibit disparate survival and growth sensitivity to neurotrophic factors, potentially attributable at least in part to differential trafficking of neurotrophin receptors. The possibility of tropic/trophic divergence must be considered when designing strategies to promote CNS recovery from injury.     

Endogenous adult neural stem cells: limits and potential to repair the injured central nervous system

Mitotic activity persists in various regions of the adult mammal CNS. While evidences of neurogenesis appeared, many studies focused on the features of the adult stem cells from germinative areas such as the subventricular zone of the lateral ventricles, the dentate gyrus of the hippocampus, the cortex, the fourth ventricle and the central canal of the spinal cord. In the present paper, we review the potentialities of the adult germinative areas in terms of proliferation, migration and differentiation in non pathological situation and in response to different type of CNS injury. Adult endogenous stem cells are activated in response to various injuries but their capacities to migrate and to undergo either neurogenesis or gliogenesis differ according to the lesion-type and the germinative zone from which they arise. Different works demonstrated that epigenic factors such as growth factors can enhance the repair potential of the adult stem cells. Reactivation and mobilization of endogenous stem cells as well as demonstration of their long-term survival and functionality appear to be interesting strategies to investigate in order to promote endogenous repair of the adult CNS.     

Reorganization of Intact Descending Motor Circuits to Replace Lost Connections After Injury

Neurons have a limited capacity to regenerate in the adult central nervous system (CNS). The inability of damaged axons to re-establish original circuits results in permanent functional impairment after spinal cord injury (SCI). Despite abortive regeneration of axotomized CNS neurons, limited spontaneous recovery of motor function emerges after partial SCI in humans and experimental rodent models of SCI. It is hypothesized that this spontaneous functional recovery is the result of the reorganization of descending motor pathways spared by the injury, suggesting that plasticity of intact circuits is a potent alternative conduit to enhance functional recovery after SCI. In support of this hypothesis, several studies have shown that after unilateral corticospinal tract (CST) lesion (unilateral pyramidotomy), the intact CST functionally sprouts into the denervated side of the spinal cord. Furthermore, pharmacologic and genetic methods that enhance the intrinsic growth capacity of adult neurons or block extracellular growth inhibitors are effective at significantly enhancing intact CST reorganization and recovery of motor function. Owing to its importance in controlling fine motor behavior in primates, the CST is the most widely studied descending motor pathway; however, additional studies in rodents have shown that plasticity within other spared descending motor pathways, including the rubrospinal tract, raphespinal tract, and reticulospinal tract, can also result in restoration of function after incomplete SCI. Identifying the molecular mechanisms that drive plasticity within intact circuits is crucial in developing novel, potent, and specific therapeutics to restore function after SCI. In this review we discuss the evidence supporting a focus on exploring the capacity of intact motor circuits to functionally repair the damaged CNS after SCI.     

Adult neural progenitor cells provide a permissive guiding substrate for corticospinal axon growth following spinal cord injury

Adult neural progenitor cells (NPC) are an attractive source for cell transplantation and neural tissue replacement after central nervous system (CNS) injury. Following transplantation of NPC cell suspensions into the acutely injured rat spinal cord, NPC survive; however, they migrate away from the lesion site and are unable to replace the injury-induced lesion cavity. In the present study we examined (i) whether NPC can be retained within the lesion site after co-transplantation with primary fibroblasts, and (ii) whether NPC promote axonal regeneration following spinal cord injury. Co-cultivation of NPC with fibroblasts demonstrated that NPC adhere to fibroblasts and the extracellular matrix produced by fibroblasts. In the presence of fibroblasts, the differentiation pattern of co-cultivated NPC was shifted towards glial differentiation. Three weeks after transplantation of adult spinal-cord-derived NPC with primary fibroblasts as mixed cell suspensions into the acutely injured cervical spinal cord in adult rats, the lesion cavity was completely replaced. NPC survived throughout the graft and differentiated exclusively into glial cells. Quantification of neurofilament-labeled axons and anterogradely labeled corticospinal axons indicated that NPC co-grafted with fibroblasts significantly enhanced axonal regeneration. Both neurofilament-labeled axons and corticospinal axons aligned longitudinally along GFAP-expressing NPC-derived cells, which displayed a bipolar morphology reminiscent of immature astroglia. Thus, grafted astroglial differentiated NPC promote axon regrowth following spinal cord injury by means of cellular guidance.     

Spinal cord repair: strategies to promote axon regeneration

Neurons in the central nervous system have a remarkable capacity to regenerate their transected axons when provided with an appropriate growth environment. Advances in our understanding of axon regeneration have allowed the development of different experimental strategies to stimulate axon regeneration in animal models of spinal cord injury. Growth inhibitory proteins block axon regeneration in the CNS, and many of these proteins have been identified. Various methods that are now used to stimulate regeneration in the injured spinal cord are directed at overcoming the growth inhibitory environment of the CNS. Three general approaches tested in vivo stimulate regeneration in the spinal cord. First, antibodies that bind inhibitory proteins in myelin allow axon regeneration in the CNS. Second, methods that modulate neuronal intracellular signaling allow axons to grow directly on the inhibitory substrate of the CNS. Third, transplantation of cells to the lesioned spinal cord promotes repair. In this paper we review current advances in each of these research domains.