Knotless anatomic double-layer double-row rotator cuff repair: a novel technique re-establishing footprint and shape of full-thickness tears

The standard technique for restoring footprint after full-thickness tears of the rotator cuff includes double-row or transosseous-equivalent techniques. However, the anatomically typical bird’s beak shape and profile of tendon insertion may not be originally restored and biomechanics may be altered. In this report, the authors describe a technique that involves creating two intratendinous stitches at different levels of the torn tendon. The first passes through the bursal-side layer, the second stitch through the joint-side layer. Both stitches may be performed in mattress suture configuration. The anchorage is performed by knotless anchors in order to avoid knots lying within the insertion area. The footprint is restored first medially then laterally by the use of double-row principles. The joint-side suture is anchored within the medially placed anchor. The bursal-side suture is anchored by a laterally placed anchor. The anatomic insertion and restoration of the shape and profile may be enabled by the described double-layer suture technique. Using a double-layer double-row repair may potentially improve functional results of rotator cuff repair constructs.     

Mattress suture-bridge technique for bursal-side partial-thickness rotator cuff tears

The standard procedure used to repair partial-thickness tears involves initial progression of the lesion to a full-thickness tear prior to tendon repair. However, the option for a bursal-side partial-thickness rotator cuff tear includes the preservation of as much of the remaining intact fibers as possible. Instead of inserting suture anchors in the medial row, as in the conventional suture-bridge technique, two mattress sutures are inserted into the rotator cuff. Full-thickness access is achieved using a percutaneous spinal needle and medial mattress sutures to preserve the articular bone attachment of the remnant fibers and to compress the repaired tendon on the footprint. Our method can help preserve the remnant rotator cuff tendon without tissue damage and can restore the normal rotator cuff footprint.     

Arthroscopic rotator cuff repair

Arthroscopic rotator cuff repair is being performed by an increasing number of orthopaedic surgeons. The principles, techniques, and instrumentation have evolved to the extent that all patterns and sizes of rotator cuff tear, including massive tears, can now be repaired arthroscopically. Achieving a biomechanically stable construct is critical to biologic healing. The ideal repair construct must optimize suture-to-bone fixation, suture-to-tendon fixation, abrasion resistance of suture, suture strength, knot security, loop security, and restoration of the anatomic rotator cuff footprint (the surface area of bone to which the cuff tendons attach). By achieving optimized repair constructs, experienced arthroscopic surgeons are reporting results equal to those of open rotator cuff repair. As surgeons' arthroscopic skill levels increase through attendance at surgical skills courses and greater experience gained in the operating room, there will be an increasing trend toward arthroscopic repair of most rotator cuff pathology.     

Editorial Commentary: Delaminated Rotator Cuff Tears—Does the Suture Pattern Matter?

The configuration of the suture placed in the rotator cuff tendon in the presence of a delaminated tear may be an important determinant of outcome. Delaminated rotator cuff tears are difficult to repair and probably occur more frequently than appreciated. The goal of anatomic reduction of the tendon to the footprint, attaching the deep tendon layer to the medial aspect of the footprint while approximating the superior tendon layer to the more lateral aspect of the footprint, may best result in complete healing.     

Current Biomechanical Concepts for Rotator Cuff Repair

For the past few decades, the repair of rotator cuff tears has evolved significantly with advances in arthroscopy techniques, suture anchors and instrumentation. From the biomechanical perspective, the focus in arthroscopic repair has been on increasing fixation strength and restoration of the footprint contact characteristics to provide early rehabilitation and improve healing. To accomplish these objectives, various repair strategies and construct configurations have been developed for rotator cuff repair with the understanding that many factors contribute to the structural integrity of the repaired construct. These include repaired rotator cuff tendon-footprint motion, increased tendon-footprint contact area and pressure, and tissue quality of tendon and bone. In addition, the healing response may be compromised by intrinsic factors such as decreased vascularity, hypoxia, and fibrocartilaginous changes or aforementioned extrinsic compression factors. Furthermore, it is well documented that torn rotator cuff muscles have a tendency to atrophy and become subject to fatty infiltration which may affect the longevity of the repair. Despite all the aforementioned factors, initial fixation strength is an essential consideration in optimizing rotator cuff repair. Therefore, numerous biomechanical studies have focused on elucidating the strongest devices, knots, and repair configurations to improve contact characteristics for rotator cuff repair. In this review, the biomechanical concepts behind current rotator cuff repair techniques will be reviewed and discussed.     

Muscle Fibers are Injured at the Time of Acute and Chronic Rotator Cuff Repair

BackgroundRotator cuff tears are a common source of shoulder pain and disability. Even after surgical repair, some patients continue to have reduced function and progression of fatty degeneration. Because patients with chronic cuff tears often experience muscle shortening, it is possible that repairing the tendon to its anatomic footprint induces a stretch-induced muscle injury that could contribute to failures of the repair and perhaps ongoing pain.Questions/purposesWe hypothesized that, compared with acutely torn and repaired muscles, the stretch that is required to repair a chronically torn cuff would result in more muscle fiber damage. Specifically, we asked: (1) Is there muscle fiber damage that occurs from repair of an acutely torn rotator cuff and does it vary by location in the muscle; and (2) is the damage greater in the case of repair of a chronic injury?MethodsWe used an open surgical approach to create a full-thickness rotator cuff tear in rats, and measured changes in muscle mass, length, and the number of fibers containing the membrane impermeable Evans Blue Dye after acute (1 day) or chronic (28 days) cuff tear or repair in rats. Differences between groups were tested using a one-way ANOVA followed by Tukey’s post hoc sorting.ResultsChronic tears resulted in 24% to 35% decreases in mass and a 20% decrease in length. The repair of acutely and chronically torn muscles resulted in damage to 90% of fibers in the distal portion of the muscle. In the proximal portion, no differences between the acutely torn and repaired groups and controls were observed, whereas repairing the chronically torn group resulted in injury to almost 70% of fibers.ConclusionsIn a rat model, marked injury to muscle fibers is induced when the tendons of torn rotator cuffs are repaired to their anatomic footprint.

Clinical Relevance

In this animal model, we found that repair of chronically torn cuff muscles results in extensive injury throughout the muscle. Based on these findings, we posit that inducing a widespread injury at the time of surgical repair of chronically torn rotator cuff muscles may contribute to the problems of failed repairs or continued progression of fatty degeneration that is observed in some patients that undergo rotator cuff repair. Therapeutic interventions to protect muscle fiber membranes potentially could enhance outcomes for patients undergoing rotator cuff repair. To evaluate this, future studies that evaluate the use of membrane sealing compounds or drugs that upregulate endogenous membrane-sealing proteins are warranted.     

关节镜下单排带线锚钉修补结合大结节骨髓刺激治疗大到巨大肩袖撕裂

目的研究关节镜下单排带线锚钉修补结合大结节骨髓刺激技术治疗大到巨大肩袖撕裂的临床效果。 方法对24例大到巨大肩袖撕裂患者,在关节镜下采用肩袖止点内移单排带线锚钉修补,并在修补肌腱外侧大结节裸露足印区打孔。术后按照康复计划渐进性康复训练。手术前和术后12个月对患肩采用VAS、UCLA、ASES评分系统进行疼痛和功能评估;并在术后第3天、3个月和12个月进行肩关节磁共振检查,观察肩袖修补和大结节足印区软组织覆盖情况。 结果所有患者随访12个月,术前和术后12个月VAS评分分别为（6.3±1.9）分和（0.4±0.1）分（P<0.05）,UCLA评分分别为（10.1±4.5）分和（30.4±4.2）分（P<0.05）,ASES评分分别为（27.9±17.8）分和（77.6±17.5）分（P<0.05）,所有手术肩关节疼痛和运动能力均较术前明显改善。术后12个月磁共振随访发现2例肩袖再撕裂发生,矢状位显示撕裂宽度均<1 cm;冠状位盂上切迹平面大结节足印区组织覆盖率在术后第3天、3个月、12个月平均分别为34.3%、89.1%和88.7%。 结论关节镜下肩袖单排带线锚钉修补结合大结节骨髓刺激技术治疗大到巨大肩袖撕裂能够提供可靠的修补,显著缓解疼痛,恢复肩关节功能并促进术后大结节足印区软组织覆盖。     

Arthroscopic Intratendinous Repair of the Delaminated Partial-Thickness Rotator Cuff Tear in Overhead Athletes

A distinct type of partial-thickness rotator cuff tear has been observed in overhead athletes, characterized by partial failure of the undersurface of the posterior supraspinatus and anterior infraspinatus tendons with intratendinous delamination. We present a technique of percutaneous intratendinous repair using nonabsorbable mattress sutures designed for the management of articular-side delaminated partial-thickness tears. After tear evaluation and preparation, the torn rotator cuff undersurface is held in a reduced position with a grasper through an anterolateral rotator interval portal while viewing intra-articularly. Two spinal needles are then placed percutaneously through the full thickness of the torn and intact rotator cuff. A polydioxanone suture is passed through each needle, retrieved out the anterior portal, and used to shuttle a single nonabsorbable No. 2 suture through the tissue, creating a mattress suture. Multiple mattress sutures can be placed as dictated by tear size and morphology, with suture retrieval and knot securing then proceeding in the subacromial space. We have adopted this approach with the goals of anatomically re-establishing the rotator cuff insertion and sealing the area of intratendinous delamination while preventing significant alteration to the anatomy of the rotator cuff insertion, which could lead to motion deficits, internal impingement, and potential tear recurrence.     

Why Repair the Subscapularis? A Logical Rationale

Tears of the subscapularis tendon are now more frequently recognized and are often associated with tears of the posterosuperior rotator cuff tendons. This has been facilitated by arthroscopic approaches, and repair techniques have been developed. In the setting of a rotator cuff repair, when a subscapularis tendon tear is found in continuity with a supraspinatus tendon tear, it is essential to recognize how the repair of both tendon tears can influence the overall security of the entire repair construct. When a repairable subscapularis tendon tear is left unrepaired, the function of the subscapularis muscle will be lost. In addition, the posterosuperior rotator cuff tear will be more difficult to repair, and it will be less securely repaired. When the subscapularis tendon is repaired initially, the posterosuperior rotator cuff repair can be more easily and more reliable achieved.     

Mode of failure for rotator cuff repair with suture anchors identified at revision surgery

Rotator cuff tears are a common cause of shoulder pain and dysfunction. After surgical repair, there is a significant re-tear rate (25%-90%). The aim of this study was to determine the primary mode of mechanical failure for rotator cuffs repaired with suture anchors at the time of revision rotator cuff repair. We prospectively followed 342 consecutive torn rotator cuffs, repaired by a single surgeon using suture anchors and a mattress-suturing configuration. Of those shoulders, 21 (6%) subsequently underwent a revision rotator cuff repair by the original surgeon, and 1 underwent a second revision repair. Intraoperative findings, including the mode of failure, were systematically recorded at revision surgery and compared with the findings at the primary repair. In addition, 81 primary rotator cuff repairs had a radiographic and fluoroscopic evaluation at a mean of 37 weeks after repair to assess for any loosening or migration of the anchors. At revision rotator cuff repair, the predominant mode of failure was tendon pulling through sutures (19/22 shoulders) (P <.001). Two recurrent tears occurred in a new location adjacent to the previous repair, and one anchor was found loose in the supraspinatus tendon. The mean size of the rotator cuff tear was larger at the revision surgery (P =.043), the tendon quality ranked poorer (P =.013), and the tendon mobility decreased (P =.002), as compared with the index procedure. The radiographs and fluoroscopic examination showed that all 335 anchors in 81 patients were in bone. Rotator cuff repairs with suture anchors that underwent revision surgery failed mechanically by three mechanisms, the most common of which was tendon pulling through sutures. This suggests that the weak link in rotator cuff repairs with suture anchors and horizontal mattress sutures, as determined at revision surgery, is the tendon-suture interface.     

Editorial Commentary: Yet Another Arrow in the Quiver for Surgical Treatment of the Rotator Cuff–Deficient Shoulder: Will It Fly Fast and Far or Fall Short Like Other Options Have?

Rotator cuff tears are common. When indicated, surgical repair is a highly successful procedure. There are circumstances when there is not enough tendon to perform an anatomic repair because of tear size, retraction, and/or atrophy. This clinical scenario, massive irreparable rotator cuff tear, has no perfect solution. Many options exist in treating massive irreparable rotator cuff tears: partial tendon repairs, debridement, tuberoplasty, intercalary allograft repairs, tendon transfers, superior capsular reconstruction, hemiarthroplasty, arthrodesis, and reverse total shoulder arthroplasty. No superior technique has been described. Another treatment has been added to this list: inserting a biodegradable balloon within the subacromial space to reduce the articulation of the humeral head on the acromion and aid in recentering the humeral head to restore balance to the remaining rotator cuff and improve deltoid function.     

Arthorscopic assessment of rotator cuff tear reparability

To evaluate the efficacy of arthroscopic techniques in determining the potential reparability of complete rotator cuff tears, a clinical investigation was performed. The parameters of tear size measurement, tendon quality, tendon mobility, and suture ancho placement were evaluated. These parameters were determined using both arthroscopic and open surgical technique. No statistically significant differences were noted when the arthroscopic findings were compared with the findings at open rotator cuff repair. Arthroscopic techniques can reliably assess rotator cuff tear size, tendon quality, tendon mobility, and suture anchor placement.     

Mini-Open Suture Bridge Repair with Porcine Dermal Patch Augmentation for Massive Rotator Cuff Tear: Surgical Technique and Preliminary Results

Background

The aim of this study was to describe the mini-open suture bridge technique with porcine dermal patch augmentation for massive rotator cuff tear and to assess preliminary clinical and radiological results.

Methods

Five patients with massive rotator cuff tear for which it was not possible to restore the anatomical footprint underwent mini-open suture bridge repair using a porcine dermal patch. The patients'' average age was 53.4 years (range, 45 to 57 years), and the average duration of follow-up was 20.6 months (range, 14 to 26 months). Patients were evaluated with preoperative and postoperative outcome measures, including a visual analog scale (VAS) for pain, the University of California Los Angeles (UCLA) score, and the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) score. The structural integrity of repaired rotator cuffs was assessed by magnetic resonance imaging 6 months postoperatively.

Results

The average VAS pain score, UCLA score, and ASES score improved from 6.8, 15.4, and 39.4 preoperatively to 0.8, 31.2, and 86.4 postoperatively (p = 0.041, 0.042, and 0.043, respectively). Magnetic resonance images obtained at an average of 8 months after surgery showed that four patients had intact repair integrity with graft incorporation. One patient had a re-tear with partial healing but still had a satisfactory clinical outcome. There was no intraoperative or postoperative complication in any patient.

Conclusions

Mini-open suture bridge repair with porcine dermal patch augmentation can be an option in young patients with high physical demands and massive rotator cuff tears for which it is not possible to restore the anatomical footprint.     

Arthroscopic Fixation of Bursal-Sided Rotator Cuff Tears

Subacromial decompression and debridement of partial-thickness bursal-sided rotator cuff tears are often reported with a high rate of unsatisfactory outcomes. We describe an arthroscopic procedure to repair partial-thickness bursal-sided rotator cuff tears without converting to a full-thickness tear in patients with a normal articular-sided rotator cuff and an A0B2 or A0B3 pattern of tear (minimum thickness of 25% to 75%). The articular side of the rotator cuff experiences greater tension than the bursal side of the cuff. As such, by leaving the articular footprint intact, we accomplish 3 goals: the intact articular fibers act as an internal splint to protect the bursal-sided repair, a wide and anatomic footprint is recreated, and we are able to minimize any length-tension mismatch because the tissue is not excessively lateralized with repair. After bursectomy and acromioplasty, the frayed edges of the bursal flap are gently debrided and the tuberosity is excoriated to bleeding bone. One or two bioabsorbable anchors are placed, and both sutures are placed through the full thickness of the rotator cuff (one anterior and one posterior) by use of a percutaneous suture lasso in this manner: (1) the lasso is passed through the full thickness of the cuff, and the nitinol wire is shuttled out of a single cannula along with the more medial of the suture limbs; (2) the nitinol wire is then pulled back out of the percutaneous portal along with the suture limb, with the suture being passed through the full thickness of the cuff; and (3) the procedure is repeated for the posterior limb of the suture after a lasso is again passed through the full thickness of the rotator cuff in a more posterior position. This subset of patients is treated with an aggressive rehabilitation protocol because the intact articular rotator cuff fibers act as an internal splint to protect the bursal repair.     

The low-profile Roman bridge technique for knotless double-row repair of the rotator cuff

With advances in arthroscopic surgery, many techniques have been developed to increase the tendon–bone contact area, reconstituting a more anatomic configuration of the rotator cuff footprint and providing a better environment for tendon healing. We present a low-profile arthroscopic rotator cuff repair technique which uses suture bridges to optimize rotator cuff tendon–footprint contact area and mean pressure. A 5.5 mm Bio-Corkscrew suture anchor (Arthrex, Naples, FL, USA), double-loaded with No. 2 FiberWire sutures (Arthrex, Naples, FL, USA), is placed in the anteromedial aspect of the footprint. Two suture limbs from a single suture are both passed through a single anterior point in the rotator cuff. One suture limb is retrieved from the cannula. The second suture limb is passed through a single posterior point in the rotator cuff producing two points of fixation in the tendon, with a tendon bridge between them. The same suture limb is retrieved through the lateral portal, and then inserted into the bone by means of a Pushlock (Arthrex, Naples, FL, USA), placed approximately 1.5–2 cm posterior to the first anchor. This second suture is passed again in the posterior aspect of the cuff. The limbs of the first suture are pulled to compress the tendon in the medial aspect of the footprint. The two free suture limbs are used to produce suture bridges over the tendon by means of a Pushlock (Arthrex, Naples, FL, USA), placed 1 cm distal to the lateral edge of the footprint relative to the medially placed suture anchors anterior to posterior. This technique allows us to perform a low-profile (single pulley–suture bridges) repair for knotless double-row repair of the rotator cuff.     

Editorial Commentary: Monitoring Tendon and Muscle Recovery After Rotator Cuff Repair Using Diagnostic Ultrasound Demonstrates that Early Repair is Beneficial for Many Patients With Reparable Tears

Rotator cuff repair is performed to effect healing of the enthesis; to restore shoulder comfort, strength, and function; to prevent tear propagation; and to prevent progression of atrophic muscle changes (fatty degeneration, fatty infiltration, and fatty atrophy) that eventually occur. Non-retracted and moderately retracted rotator cuff tears usually heal after repair, and muscle atrophy may recover over time. It follows that early rotator cuff repair is beneficial for many patients with chronic but reparable rotator cuff tears. Diagnostic ultrasound can provide quantitative information about the recovery of both muscle and tendon and represents a viable alternative to magnetic resonance imaging for evaluating healing after rotator cuff repair.     

A Modified Suture-Bridge Technique for a Marginal Dog-Ear Deformity Caused During Rotator Cuff Repair

Recently, the suture-bridge technique was found to maximize the utility of a single-row construct by using the suture limbs from the medial mattress sutures to bridge and compress the repaired tendon. However, the formation of marginal dog-ear deformities at a repaired rotator cuff is not uncommon with the suture-bridge technique. If a dog-ear deformity is observed at the margin after completion of the rotator cuff repair, the detached marginal cuff is pierced via a suture hook. One strand of the uncut suture in the lateral row is transported through the deformed cuff. A nonsliding knot is seated on top of the detached cuff and presses this area of soft tissue firmly onto the bone. If necessary, these steps are repeated for the other side of the detached rotator cuff. After completion of the rotator cuff repair, a “zigzag” pattern of compression of the cuff against the bone footprint without detachment of the rotator cuff is observed. After repair of the rotator cuff tear via the suture-bridge technique, the benefit of our simple technique for treating a marginal detached cuff is that the footprint contact area of the rotator cuff is restored completely, without the need for additional suture anchors.