Effect of recipient gender and donor‐specific antibodies on antibody‐mediated rejection after heart transplantation

Gender‐difference regarding antibody‐mediated rejection (AMR) after heart transplantation has been described. However, no study accounted for the presence of preformed donor‐specific antibodies (pfDSA), a known risk factor of AMR, more common among women than men. In a single‐institution 6‐year cohort (2010‐2015), time to AMR was assessed, comparing men with women by survival analysis with a 1‐year death‐censored follow‐up. All AMRs were biopsy proven. Confounding variables that were accounted for included mean intensity fluorescence (MFI) of pfDSA, recipient age, HLA‐, size‐ and sex‐mismatch. 463 patients were included. Overall incidence of AMR was 10.3% at 1 year. After adjusting for confounding variables, independent risk factors of AMR were female recipient gender (adjusted hazard‐ratio [adj. HR] = 1.78 [1.06‐2.99]), P = .03) and the presence of pfDSA (adj. HR = 3.20 [1.80‐5.70], P < .001). This association remained significant when considering pfDSA by their MFI; female recipient gender had an adj. HR = 2.2 (P = .026) and MFI of pfDSA (per 1 MFI‐increase) adj. HR = 1.0002 (P < .0001). In this cohort, women were at higher risk of AMR than men and this risk increase was additive to that of pfDSA. These findings may suggest a gender‐related difference in the severity of pfDSA.     

Thymic function is a major determinant of onset of antibody‐mediated rejection in heart transplantation

Thymic function decreases progressively with age but may be boosted in certain circumstances. We questioned whether heart transplantation was such a situation and whether thymic function was related to the onset of rejection. Twenty‐eight antithymocyte globulin–treated heart transplant recipients were included. Patients diagnosed for an antibody‐mediated rejection on endomyocardial biopsy had a higher proportion of circulating recent thymic emigrant CD4+ T cells and T cell receptor excision circle levels than other transplanted subjects. Thymus volume and density, assessed by computed tomography in a subset of patients, was also higher in patients experiencing antibody‐mediated rejection. We demonstrate that thymic function is a major determinant of onset of antibody‐mediated rejection and question whether thymectomy could be a prophylactic strategy to prevent alloimmune humoral responses.     

Mechanisms of organ transplant injury mediated by B cells and antibodies: Implications for antibody‐mediated rejection

Recent adjustments to the histological diagnosis and the introduction of molecular classification are providing renewed support for the paradigm that antibody‐mediated rejection (ABMR) is an important clinical problem for which there is an urgent need for better therapies. Acute ABMR is observed when the graft is exposed to rapid increases in high‐titer donor‐specific antibodies (DSA) that are most often generated as anamnestic responses in sensitized recipients or de novo responses in nonsensitized patients who are nonadherent. Chronic ABMR is associated with slower increases in DSA, which may be high or low titer and transient or persistent. These DSA elicit cycles of injury and repair that manifest as multilamination of the peritubular capillary basement membrane or arteriopathy manifesting as intimal fibrosis. Mitigating the problem of AMBR requires the anamnestic and de novo DSA responses to be prevented and established DSA responses to be reversed. To this end, a better understanding of the immunobiology of DSA production is necessary and also the development of assays capable of detecting early humoral immune responses.Recent advances in understanding the immunobiology of B cells and areas requiring further investigation that might lead to new therapies or better diagnosis are discussed in this review.     

The role of C4d deposition in the diagnosis of antibody‐mediated rejection after lung transplantation

Antibody‐mediated rejection (AMR) is an increasingly recognized form of lung rejection. C4d deposition has been an inconsistent finding in previous reports and its role in the diagnosis has been controversial. We conducted a retrospective single‐center study to characterize cases of C4d‐negative probable AMR and to compare these to cases of definite (C4d‐positive) AMR. We identified 73 cases of AMR: 28 (38%) were C4d‐positive and 45 (62%) were C4d‐negative. The two groups had a similar clinical presentation, and although more patients in the C4d‐positive group had neutrophilic capillaritis (54% vs. 29%, P = .035), there was no significant difference in the presence of other histologic findings. Despite aggressive antibody‐depleting therapy, 19 of 73 (26%) patients in the overall cohort died within 30 days, but there was no significant difference in freedom from chronic lung allograft dysfunction (CLAD) or survival between the two groups. We conclude that AMR may cause allograft failure, but that the diagnosis requires a multidisciplinary approach and a high index of suspicion. C4d deposition does not appear to be a necessary criterion for the diagnosis, and although some cases may respond initially to therapy, there is a high incidence of CLAD and poor survival after AMR.     

Monocyte Recruitment by HLA IgG‐Activated Endothelium: The Relationship Between IgG Subclass and FcγRIIa Polymorphisms

It is currently unclear which donor specific HLA antibodies confer the highest risk of antibody‐mediated rejection (AMR) and allograft loss. In this study, we hypothesized that two distinct features (HLA IgG subclass and Fcγ receptor [FcγR] polymorphisms) which vary from patient to patient, influence the process of monocyte trafficking to and macrophage accumulation in the allograft during AMR in an interrelated fashion. Here, we investigated the contribution of human IgG subclass and FcγR polymorphisms in monocyte recruitment in vitro by primary human aortic endothelium activated with chimeric anti‐HLA I human IgG1 and IgG2. Both subclasses triggered monocyte adhesion to endothelial cells, via a two‐step process. First, HLA I crosslinking by antibodies stimulated upregulation of P‐selectin on endothelium irrespective of IgG subclass. P‐selectin‐induced monocyte adhesion was enhanced by secondary interactions of IgG with FcγRs, which was highly dependent upon subclass. IgG1 was more potent than IgG2 through differential engagement of FcγRs. Monocytes homozygous for FcγRIIa‐H131 adhered more readily to HLA antibody‐activated endothelium compared with FcγRIIa‐R131 homozygous. Finally, direct modification of HLA I antibodies with immunomodulatory enzymes EndoS and IdeS dampened recruitment by eliminating antibody‐FcγR binding, an approach that may have clinical utility in reducing AMR and other forms of antibody‐induced inflammation.     

Allospecific Memory B Cell Responses Are Dependent on Autophagy

Long‐lived, donor‐reactive memory B cells (Bmems) can produce alloantibodies that mediate transplant injury. Autophagy, an intrinsic mechanism of cell organelle/component recycling, is required for Bmem survival in infectious and model antigen systems, but whether autophagy affects alloreactive Bmem is unknown. We studied mice with an inducible yellow fluorescent protein (YFP) reporter expressed under the activation‐induced cytidine deaminase (AID) promoter active in B cells undergoing germinal center reactions. Up to 12 months after allogeneic sensitization, splenic YFP⁺ B cells were predominantly IgD^–IgM^–IgG⁺ and expressed CD73, CD80, and PD‐L2, consistent with Bmems. Labeled cells contained significantly more cells with autophagosomes and more autophagosomes per cell than unlabeled, naïve B cells. To test for a functional link, we quantified alloantibody formation in mice with B cells conditionally deficient in the requisite autophagy gene ATG7. These experiments revealed absent B cell ATG7 (1) prevented B cell autophagy, (2) inhibited secondary alloantibody responses without altering primary alloantibody formation, and (3) diminished frequencies of alloreactive Bmems. Pharmacological autophagy inhibition with 3‐methyladenine had similar effects on wild‐type mice. Together with new documentation of increased autophagosomes within human Bmems, our data indicate that targeting autophagy has potential for eliminating donor‐reactive Bmems in transplant recipients.     

Pediatric heart transplantation across a positive crossmatch: First year results from the CTOTC‐04 multi‐institutional study

Sensitization is common in pediatric heart transplant candidates and waitlist mortality is high. Transplantation across a positive crossmatch may reduce wait time, but is considered high risk. We prospectively recruited consecutive candidates at eight North American centers. At transplantation, subjects were categorized as nonsensitized or sensitized (presence of ≥1 HLA antibody with MFI ≥1000 using single antigen beads). Sensitized subjects were further classified as complement‐dependent cytotoxicity crossmatch (CDC‐crossmatch) positive or negative and as donor‐specific antibodies (DSA) positive or negative. Immunosuppression was standardized. CDC‐crossmatch–positive subjects also received perioperative antibody removal, maintenance corticosteroids, and intravenous immunoglobulin. The primary endpoint was the 1 year incidence rate of a composite of death, retransplantation, or rejection with hemodynamic compromise. 317 subjects were screened, 290 enrolled and 240 transplanted (51 with pretransplant DSA, 11 with positive CDC‐crossmatch). The incidence rates of the primary endpoint did not differ statistically between groups; nonsensitized 6.7% (CI: 2.7%, 13.3%), sensitized crossmatch positive 18.2% (CI: 2.3%, 51.8%), sensitized crossmatch negative 10.7% (CI: 5.7%, 18.0%), P = .2354. The primary endpoint also did not differ by DSA status. Freedom from antibody‐mediated and cellular rejection was lower in the crossmatch positive group and/or in the presence of DSA. Follow‐up will determine if acceptable outcomes can be achieved long‐term.     

Rapamycin Interferes With Postdepletion Regulatory T Cell Homeostasis and Enhances DSA Formation Corrected by CTLA4‐Ig

Previously, we demonstrated that alemtuzumab induction with rapamycin as sole maintenance therapy is associated with an increased incidence of humoral rejection in human kidney transplant patients. To investigate the role of rapamycin in posttransplant humoral responses after T cell depletion, fully MHC mismatched hearts were transplanted into hCD52Tg mice, followed by alemtuzumab treatment with or without a short course of rapamycin. While untreated hCD52Tg recipients acutely rejected B6 hearts (n = 12), hCD52Tg recipients treated with alemtuzumab alone or in conjunction with rapamycin showed a lack of acute rejection (MST > 100). However, additional rapamycin showed a reduced beating quality over time and increased incidence of vasculopathy. Furthermore, rapamycin supplementation showed an increased serum donor‐specific antibodies (DSA) level compared to alemtuzumab alone at postoperation days 50 and 100. Surprisingly, additional rapamycin treatment significantly reduced CD4⁺CD25⁺FoxP3⁺ T reg cell numbers during treatment. On the contrary, ICOS⁺PD‐1⁺CD4 follicular helper T cells in the lymph nodes were significantly increased. Interestingly, CTLA4‐Ig supplementation in conjunction with rapamycin corrected rapamycin‐induced accelerated posttransplant humoral response by directly modulating Tfh cells but not Treg cells. This suggests that rapamycin after T cell depletion could affect Treg cells leading to an increase of Tfh cells and DSA production that can be reversed by CTLA4‐Ig.     

CD68/CD31 immunohistochemistry double stain demonstrates increased accuracy in diagnosing pathologic antibody‐mediated rejection in cardiac transplant patients

Pathologic antibody‐mediated rejection (pAMR) occurs in 10% of cardiac transplant patients and is associated with increased mortality. The endomyocardial biopsy remains the primary diagnostic tool to detect and define pAMR. However, certain challenges arise for the pathologist. Accurate identification of >10% of intravascular macrophages along with endothelial swelling, which remains a critical component of diagnosing pAMR, is one such challenge. We used double labeling with an endothelial and histiocytic marker to improve diagnostic accuracy. Twenty‐two cardiac transplant endomyocardial biopsies were screened using a CD68/CD31 immunohistochemical (IHC) double stain. To determine whether pAMR diagnosis would change using the double stain, intravascular macrophage staining was compared to using CD68 alone. Twenty‐two cardiac pAMR cases from patients were included. Fifty‐nine percent of cases previously called >10% intravascular macrophage positive by CD68 alone were called <10% positive using the CD68/CD31 double stain. Not using the double stain was associated with a significant overcall. In C4d‐negative cases, using the CD68/CD31 double stain downgraded the diagnosis of pAMR2 to pAMR1 in 32% of cases. It was concluded that more than one third of patients were overdiagnosed with pAMR using CD68 by IHC alone. We demonstrate the value of using a CD68/CD31 double stain to increase accuracy.     

Reversing donor‐specific antibody responses and antibody‐mediated rejection with bortezomib and belatacept in mice and kidney transplant recipients

Active antibody‐mediated rejection (AMR) is a potentially devastating complication and consistently effective treatment remains elusive. We hypothesized that the reversal of acute AMR requires rapid elimination of antibody‐secreting plasma cells (PC) with a proteasome inhibitor, bortezomib, followed by the sustained inhibition of PC generation with CTLA4‐Ig or belatacept (B/B). We show in mice that B/B therapy selectively depleted mature PC producing donor‐specific antibodies (DSA) and reduced DSA, when administered after primary and secondary DSA responses had been established. A pilot investigation was initiated to treat six consecutive patients with active AMR with B/B. Compassionate use of this regimen was initiated for the first patient who developed early, severe acute AMR that did not respond to steroids, plasmapheresis, and intravenous immunoglobulin after his third kidney transplant. B/B treatment resulted in a rapid reversal of AMR, leading us to treat five additional patients who also resolved their acute AMR episode and had sustained disappearance of circulating DSA for ≤30 months. This study provides a proof‐of‐principle demonstration that mouse models can identify mechanistically rational therapies for the clinic. Follow‐up investigations with a more stringent clinical design are warranted to test whether B/B improves on the standard of care for the treatment of acute AMR.     

Value of monitoring circulating donor‐reactive memory B cells to characterize antibody‐mediated rejection after kidney transplantation

Antibody‐mediated rejection (ABMR) is defined by specific histopathological lesions and evidence of circulating donor‐specific antibodies (DSA). Although DSA are not always detectable, monitoring donor‐reactive memory B cells (mBC) could identify patients at risk of developing ABMR. Peripheral donor‐reactive mBC using a novel HLA B cell ELISpot assay, serum DSA, and numbers of different B cell subsets were assessed in 175 consecutive kidney transplants undergoing either for‐cause or 6‐ and 24‐month surveillance biopsies for their association with main histological lesions of ABMR and impact on allograft outcome. In 85 incident for‐cause biopsies, high frequencies of donor‐reactive mBC were detected in all 16 (100%) acute ABMR/DSA+ and most chronic ABMR, with or without DSA (24/30[80%] and 21/29[72.4%], respectively). In a longitudinal cohort of 90 nonsensitized patients, a progressively higher expansion of donor‐reactive mBC than de novo DSA was observed at 6 and 24 months (8.8% vs 7.7% and 15.5% vs 11.1%, respectively) and accurately identified patients with ongoing subclinical ABMR (area under the curve = 0.917 and area under the curve = 0.809, respectively). An unsupervised hierarchical cluster analysis revealed a strong association between donor‐reactive mBC with main fundamental allograft lesions associated with ABMR and conferred a significant deleterious impact on graft outcome. Monitoring donor‐reactive mBC may be useful to further characterize humoral rejection after kidney transplantation.     

Histological picture of antibody‐mediated rejection without donor‐specific anti‐HLA antibodies: Clinical presentation and implications for outcome

In this cohort study (n = 935 transplantations), we investigated the phenotype and risk of graft failure in patients with histological criteria for antibody‐mediated rejection (ABMR) in the absence of circulating donor‐specific anti‐human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies (DSA), and compared this to patients with definite ABMR and HLA‐DSA‐positivity. The histological picture did not differ between HLA‐DSA‐positive (n = 85) and HLA‐DSA‐negative (n = 123) cases of ABMR histology, apart from increased complement split product 4d (C4d) deposition in the peritubular capillaries in HLA‐DSA‐positive cases. Histology of ABMR without HLA‐DSA was more transient than DSA‐positive ABMR, and patients with ABMR histology without HLA‐DSA had graft survival superior to that of HLA‐DSA‐positive patients, independent of concomitant T cell–mediated rejection (38.2%) or borderline changes (17.9%). Multivariate analysis showed that the risk of graft failure was not higher in patients with histological picture of ABMR (ABMR_h) in the absence of HLA‐DSA, compared to patients without ABMR_h. Despite an association between C4d deposition and HLA‐DSA‐positivity, using C4d deposition as alternative for the DSA criterion in the diagnosis of ABMR, as proposed in Banff 2017, did not contribute to the prognosis of graft function and graft failure. We concluded that biopsies with ABMR_h but without detectable HLA‐DSA represent a distinct, often transient phenotype with superior allograft survival.     

Donor‐Specific Antibodies Are Produced Locally in Ectopic Lymphoid Structures in Cardiac Allografts

Cardiac allograft vasculopathy (CAV) is a transplant pathology, limiting graft survival after heart transplantation. CAV arteries are surrounded by ectopic lymphoid structures (ELS) containing B cells and plasma cells. The aim of this study was to characterize the antigenic targets of antibodies produced in ELS. Coronary arteries and surrounding epicardial tissue from 56 transplant recipients were collected during autopsy. Immunofluorescence was used to identify antibody‐producing plasma cells. Immunoglobulin levels in tissue lysates were measured by enzyme‐linked immunosorbent assay and analyzed for donor‐specific HLA antibodies by Luminex assay. Cytokine and receptor expression levels were quantified using quantitative polymerase chain reaction. Plasma cells in ELS were polyclonal and produced IgG and/or IgM antibodies. In epicardial tissue, IgG (p < 0.05) and IgM levels were higher in transplant patients with larger ELS than smaller ELS. In 4 of 21 (19%) patients with ELS, donor‐specific HLA type II antibodies were detected locally. Cytokine and receptor expression (CXCR3, interferon γ and TGF‐β) was higher in large ELS in the epicardial tissue than in other vessel wall layers, suggesting active recruitment and proliferation of T and B lymphocytes. ELS exhibited active plasma cells producing locally manufactured antibodies that, in some cases, were directed against the donor HLA, potentially mediating rejection with major consequences for the graft.     

Banff survey on antibody‐mediated rejection clinical practices in kidney transplantation: Diagnostic misinterpretation has potential therapeutic implications

The aim of this study was to determine how the Banff antibody‐mediated rejection (ABMR) classification for kidney transplantation is interpreted in practice and affects therapy. The Banff Antibody‐Mediated Injury Workgroup electronically surveyed clinicians and pathologists worldwide regarding diagnosis and treatment for 6 case‐based scenarios. The participants' (95 clinicians and 72 renal pathologists) assigned diagnoses were compared to the Banff intended diagnoses (reference standard). The assigned diagnoses and reference standard differed by 26.1% (SD 28.1%) for pathologists and 34.5% (SD 23.3%) for clinicians. The greatest discordance between the reference standard and clinicians' diagnosis was when histologic features of ABMR were present but donor‐specific antibody was undetected (49.4% [43/87]). For pathologists, the greatest discordance was in the case of acute/active ABMR C4d staining negative in a positive crossmatch transplant recipient (33.8% [23/68]). Treatment approaches were heterogeneous but linked to the assigned diagnosis. When acute/active ABMR was diagnosed by the clinician, treatment was recommended 95.3% (SD 18.4%) of the time vs only 77.7% (SD 39.2%) of the time when chronic active ABMR was diagnosed (P < .0001). In conclusion, the Banff ABMR classification is vulnerable to misinterpretation, which potentially has patient management implications. Continued efforts are needed to improve the understanding and standardized application of ABMR classification in the transplant community.     

Incidence,characterization, and impact of newly detected donor‐specific anti‐HLA antibody in the first year after pediatric heart transplantation: A report from the CTOTC‐04 study

Data on the clinical importance of newly detected donor‐specific anti‐HLA antibodies (ndDSAs) after pediatric heart transplantation are lacking despite mounting evidence of the detrimental effect of de novo DSAs in solid organ transplantation. We prospectively tested 237 pediatric heart transplant recipients for ndDSAs in the first year posttransplantation to determine their incidence, pattern, and clinical impact. One‐third of patients developed ndDSAs; when present, these were mostly detected within the first 6 weeks after transplantation, suggesting that memory responses may predominate over true de novo DSA production in this population. In the absence of preexisting DSAs, patients with ndDSAs had significantly more acute cellular rejection but not antibody‐mediated rejection, and there was no impact on graft and patient survival in the first year posttransplantation. Risk factors for ndDSAs included common sensitizing events. Given the early detection of the antibody response, memory responses may be more important in the first year after pediatric heart transplantation and patients with a history of a sensitizing event may be at risk even with a negative pretransplantation antibody screen. The impact on late graft and patient outcomes of first‐year ndDSAs is being assessed in an extended cohort of patients.     

Heterogeneity of memory B cells

Potential solid organ transplant recipients broadly sensitized to HLA have long wait times, low transplant rates and poor outcomes. The new kidney allocation system has improved access to the most highly sensitized recipients; however, their long‐term outcomes are unknown. Emerging data suggest that memory B cell repertoire is broader than the plasma cell repertoire, therefore, despite refinements in anti‐HLA antibody detection technology, donor‐specific HLA‐ specific memory B cells may in fact be present in some, if not most, highly sensitized recipients with no detectable donor‐specific antibodies. In addition, new findings have underscored the heterogeneity in memory B cell generation, and in the signals that determine memory versus plasma cell fate during primary antigen encounter, as well as memory B cell differentiation upon antigen reencounter into plasma cells or reentry into germinal centers to subsequently emerge as higher affinity and class‐switched plasma cells. Thus, heterogeneity memory B cells generation may affect the efficacy of specific immunomodulation during the recall response. We propose that the ability to quantify donor‐specific B cell in transplant recipients is urgently required to provide insights into the mechanisms of sensitization and recall, and for the early detection of acute and chronic AMR.     

The role of novel therapeutic approaches for prevention of allosensitization and antibody‐mediated rejection

Modification of pathogenic antibodies and their effector functions in autoimmune diseases or use of B cell/plasma cell‐directed anticancer therapies have illuminated the biologic relevance of B cells, plasma cells (PCs), and pathogenic antibodies and complement in alloimmunity. They have also rejuvenated interest in how B cells mediate multiple effector functions that include antibody production, antigen presentation to T cells, costimulation, and the production of immune stimulating and immune modulatory cytokines that drive dysfunctional immune responses. Current methods to reduce alloantibodies are only modestly successful. Rituximab is used for desensitization and antibody‐mediated rejection (AMR) treatment by targeting CD20 found on B‐lymphocytes. However, PCs do not express CD20, likely explaining the limited success of this approach. Intravenous immunoglobulin and plasmapheresis (PLEX) have limited success due to antibody rebound. Despite attempts to develop tolerable therapeutics for management of AMR, none, to date, have been universally accepted or obtained Food and Drug Administration approval. Lack of approved therapeutics often results in patients having a much shorter graft survival due to AMR. Repurposing drugs from autoimmunity and cancer immunotherapy has rapidly yielded important advancements in the care of AMR patients. Here we discuss emerging therapeutics aimed at prevention and treatment of AMR.     

Anti‐Donor HLA Antibody Response After Pancreatic Islet Grafting: Characteristics,Risk Factors,and Impact on Graft Function

Pancreatic islet grafting restores endogenous insulin production in type 1 diabetic patients, but long‐term outcomes remain disappointing as a result of immunological destruction of allogeneic islets. In solid organ transplantation, donor‐specific anti‐HLA antibodies (DSA) are the first cause of organ failure. This retrospective multicentric study aimed at providing in‐depth characterization of DSA response after pancreatic islet grafting, identifying the risk factor for DSA generation and determining the impact of DSA on graft function. Forty‐two pancreatic islet graft recipients from the Groupe Rhin‐Rhône‐Alpes‐Genève pour la Greffe d'Ilots de Langerhans consortium were enrolled. Pre‐ and postgrafting sera were screened for the presence of DSA and their ability to activate complement. Prevalence of DSA was 25% at 3 years postgrafting. The risk of sensitization increased steeply after immunosuppressive drug withdrawal. DSA repertoire diversity correlated with the number of HLA and eplet mismatches. DSA titer was significantly lower from that observed in solid organ transplantation. No detected DSA bound the complement fraction C3d. Finally, in contrast with solid organ transplantation, DSA did not seem to negatively affect pancreatic islet graft survival. This might be due to the low DSA titers, specific features of IgG limiting their ability to activate the complement and/or the lack of allogenic endothelial targets in pancreatic islet grafts.