A child with cystic fibrosis: II. Subsequent family planning decisions, reproduction and use of prenatal diagnosis

In 1984, we interviewed 105 Belgian families with a Cystic Fibrosis (CF) child in order to assess the impact of the birth of their CF-child on subsequent family planning and to evaluate their attitudes towards prenatal diagnosis. Three years later, in 1987, they received a mailed questionnaire for an updating of the reproduction data and to assess their knowledge and intentions with regard to the new possibilities of DNA diagnosis. The birth of a CF-child had a major impact upon subsequent family planning. This effect was found both in the reproductive plans reported by the parents and in the occurrence of pregnancies during the follow-up interval. This effect can be attributed mostly to the recurrence risk and consists of postponing pregnancies as well as of deciding against further offspring. If the CF-child was the firstborn, the chance of having another child was greater than if there was already a healthy child before the birth of the CF-child. Nevertheless, only 47% of the families in which the CF-child was the firstborn, and who could be followed for an average period of 7 years, had another pregnancy. A large majority of families intended to use prenatal diagnosis should a pregnancy occur. In half of the pregnancies that occurred between 1984 and 1987, a prenatal diagnosis was performed. On the other hand, there is less consensus about pregnancy interruption should prenatal diagnosis reveal an affected fetus.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Attitudes to predictive DNA testing in familial adenomatous polyposis.

Attitudes to predictive DNA testing for familial adenomatous polyposis were documented in 62 affected adults. Patient views on prenatal testing and termination of pregnancy for this disorder were sought, as were opinions on the most suitable age to offer predictive testing for at risk children and the most appropriate age to begin screening. While 15 (24%) of those questioned stated that they would proceed to termination of pregnancy if a prenatal test indicated that the unborn baby was affected, in clinical practice no one has yet requested this option. Six (10%) people who had refrained from having children for fear of passing on the polyposis gene felt that the arrival of prenatal testing would enable them to consider planning a family. The majority of patients (93%) said they would like their children tested by DNA analysis at birth or in infancy, but felt that 10 to 12 years was the most appropriate time to discuss the diagnosis with the child.     

Counseling needs and attitudes toward prenatal diagnosis and abortion in fragile-X families

The genetic counseling need of 32 women of normal intelligence at-risk for having children with the fragile-X syndrome (FXS) were determined by a questionnaire study which included assessment of their attitudes toward prenatal diagnosis and the option of pregnancy termination. Eighteen (56%) of the women had one or more children with the FXS and 14 (44%) had no affected children. Twenty-six (81%) of the subjects stated that they would choose to have prenatal diagnosis and 9 (28%) indicated they would terminate an affected pregnancy. There was no significant difference between women who had affected children and those who did not have affected children, nor between Catholics and non-Catholics regarding acceptance of prenatal diagnosis. Catholic women were less likely to consider pregnancy termination than non-Catholics, but the majority of subjects (56%) were unsure what they would do if a fetus they were carrying was found to be affected. Issues the subjects considered most important for discussion with a genetic counselor included: 1) availability of treatment, 2) risk for having an affected grand child, 3) expectations for future functioning of affected children, and 4) availability of prenatal diagnosis.     

Reproductive choices in hemophilic men and carriers

We have examined reproduction patterns in hemophilic men and carrier women seen at a hemophilia treatment center. The study group included 309 patients with hemophilia A or B: 194 adults and 115 children from 246 pedigrees; 93% of affected men and 96% of parents of affected children had received genetic counseling. In the collected pedigrees, 65% of affected males were born to women with family history of hemophilia. An additional 23% of mothers were later shown to be carriers. Fewer than 12% of cases could be due to a new mutation in the child. Among 209 hemophilia A carrier tests, 95% of obligate carriers were detectable, 87% of mothers of sporadic cases, 53% of sisters of hemophiliacs, and 24% of other relatives had a high risk of carriership. Of 49 high-risk women seen during or prior to pregnancy, one-half elected prenatal diagnosis. Amniocentesis was performed in 24 cases and 8 were referred for fetoscopy, resulting in 18 normal offspring. Among 25 pregnancies not tested, 14 continued and produced 3 affected males and 11 normal offspring. Of hemophilic men over age 25, 66% have married and 41% (62% of those married) have had children. These observations will serve as a baseline for assessing any change in reproductive patterns occurring with the introduction of new genetic techniques.     

Reproductive decision making of aunts and uncles of a child with cystic fibrosis: genetic risk perception and attitudes toward carrier identification and prenatal diagnosis.

This paper evaluates the perceived genetic risk, the perceived burden, the impact on reproductive decision making, and the attitudes of aunts and uncles of a child with cystic fibrosis toward carrier identification, prenatal diagnosis, and pregnancy termination. A mailed questionnaire was sent to the aunts and uncles of 32 CF children (1) who attended the Paediatric Department of the University Hospital and (2) whose parents agreed to give the names and addresses of their sibs. The results for the 109 respondents aged less than 40 years are discussed. About one-fourth of them was aware of the "approximate" level of the risk to be a carrier of the CF gene and/or of the risk of having a CF child themselves. Nevertheless the subjective evaluation of the genetic risk has played a part in the reproductive decision-making process of at least 39% of the respondents. About three-fourths would (probably) make use of heterozygote detection and would (probably) ask for prenatal diagnosis should they become pregnant. It is striking that less than half of the group would interrupt the pregnancy should the fetus be affected. The intention to use prenatal diagnosis was significantly correlated with age and educational level while the acceptance of pregnancy interruption was significantly correlated with perceived burden, respondents' age, and health situation of the proband.     

Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy: aspects of genetic counselling, acceptance of preclinical diagnosis, and fitness.

A questionnaire about the interest in and demand for preclinical diagnosis for facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSH) was sent to 46 patients. Most stated that they would have liked to have known their diagnosis earlier in order to seek more efficient help, to avoid strenuous activities, to prepare themselves emotionally, or to choose an appropriate profession. Similar arguments were used to explain their interest in preclinical diagnosis for their children. Most patients also favoured prenatal diagnosis although only two stated they would abort a pregnancy in the case of an affected fetus. Genetic counselling had apparently little influence on family planning. According to this study, FSH does not seem to reduce reproductive performance in our population.     

Carrier testing and prenatal diagnosis for hemophilia: experiences and attitudes of 549 potential and obligate carriers

Experiences with and attitudes toward carrier testing and prenatal diagnosis were evaluated among 549 potential and obligate carriers of hemophilia. Almost everybody considered carrier testing to be useful. Forty-nine percent had been tested for carriership, 10% had only received limited information, and 41% had not been tested and had never received information about the heredity of hemophilia. More married women, women with severe hemophilia in their family, and women closely related to a patient with hemophilia had been tested for carriership than others. Lack of information about the probability of carriership for female relatives and a similar ignorance of the possibility of carrier testing were important reasons for not having been tested. Eleven percent of the women with one or more children had undergone prenatal diagnosis in the past. Thirty-one percent of the study population would favour prenatal diagnosis with the implication of a potential abortion in early pregnancy and half of them would choose this option even in late pregnancy. Most of the women who objected to prenatal diagnosis did so because they did not consider hemophilia to be a sufficiently serious disorder to justify an abortion.     

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1): knowledge, experience, and reproductive decisions of affected patients and families.

Eighty-one subjects (56 affected patients and 25 parents of isolated affected cases) from 63 families with neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) on the North Western Regional Genetic Family Register (NWRGFR) were interviewed. Patients were interviewed either before (n = 26) or after (n = 55) genetic counselling. In the group as a whole, knowledge of the clinical features and the genetic aspects of the condition was poor (mean score 7 within the range of 0 to 18). The following factors were significantly associated with higher knowledge: (1) genetic counselling, (2) higher social class, (3) child with NF1, (4) when NF1 had influenced reproductive decisions, (5) young age at diagnosis, and (6) member of a patient support group. The majority of the affected subjects perceived themselves to be more severely affected than by medical classification, with persons who had been diagnosed later in life, had a child with NF1, or who were concerned about the cosmetic aspects of the disease perceiving themselves to be more severely affected. Assessment of the psychosocial effects of NF1 at different stages of life showed that 63% of affected subjects experienced difficulties at school and 48% said that the condition, particularly cosmetic aspects, caused anxiety during adolescence (n = 54). These difficulties may have contributed to later problems with career attainment and confidence in relationships. Seventy-seven percent of parents stated that their child was experiencing difficulties at school relating to NF1 (n = 51). Of the subjects at risk of having a child with NF1 and who knew about NF1 before having their family (n = 32), 45% said that it had influenced their reproductive decisions. Of 29 subjects who were still considering children, 41% wished to have prenatal diagnosis in a future pregnancy, but only three subjects stated that they would terminate an affected pregnancy.     

Attitudes towards prenatal diagnosis and carrier screening for cystic fibrosis among the parents of patients in a paediatric cystic fibrosis clinic.

The parents of all children attending the Royal Brompton National Heart and Lung Hospital cystic fibrosis paediatric clinic were asked to complete an anonymous postal questionnaire addressing attitudes towards prenatal diagnosis and population carrier screening for cystic fibrosis (CF); 65% (170/261) of parents responded. Of the respondents, 92% would support the introduction of a population screening test to detect carriers of CF and 19% felt such a test should be mandatory. A total of 64% of CF parents felt they would choose not to have any further children in the knowledge that they were both carriers, 74% would choose to have a prenatal test if they became pregnant, 44% would consider terminating an affected pregnancy, 33% would not, and 23% were unsure. Overall, 72% of respondents indicated they would choose to avoid having a further child with CF either by not having further children or by terminating an affected pregnancy.     

Do parental perceptions and motivations towards genetic testing and prenatal diagnosis for deafness vary in different cultures?

Surveys of attitudes of individuals with deafness and their families towards genetic testing or prenatal diagnosis have mostly been carried out in the West. It is expected that the perceptions and attitudes would vary amongst persons of different cultures and economic background. There is little information on the prevailing attitudes for genetic testing and prenatal diagnosis for deafness in developing countries. Therefore, this study evaluates the motivations of Indian people with inherited hearing loss towards such testing. Twenty‐eight families with history of congenital hearing loss (23 hearing parents with child/family member with deafness, 4 couples with both partners having deafness and 1 parent and child with deafness) participated in a semi‐structured survey investigating their interest, attitudes, and intentions for using genetic and prenatal testing for deafness. Participants opinioned that proper management and care of individuals with deafness were handicapped by limited rehabilitation facilities with significant financial and social burden. Nineteen (68%) opted for genetic testing. Twenty‐six (93%) expressed high interest in prenatal diagnosis, while 19 (73%) would consider termination of an affected fetus. Three hearing couples, in whom the causative mutations were identified, opted for prenatal diagnosis. On testing, all the three fetuses were affected and the hearing parents elected to terminate the pregnancies. This study provides an insight into the contrasting perceptions towards hearing disability in India and its influence on the desirability of genetic testing and prenatal diagnosis. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Ethical considerations in medical genetics--the prenatal diagnosis of hemophilia B

A couple is presented who underwent prenatal counseling and amniocentesis for sex determination because the wife was an obligate carrier of hemophilia B. Although the fetus was determined to be male, the parents elected not to have further testing to determine if he had hemophilia or not. The difficulties in the in utero diagnosis of hemophilia B are presented and discussed. In addition, the moral reasoning and decision-making process that this couple went through regarding the decision not to have further fetal testing and to continue the pregnancy is presented and analyzed. These moral decisions appear to be based on family and personal ties, and bonding to the fetus after perception of fetal movement. They combine considerations of the duties and rights involved in such situations, and attend to the anticipated consequences as well.     

Ethical considerations in medical genetics–the prenatal diagnosis of hemophilia B

A couple is presented who underwent prenatal counseling and amniocentesis for sex determination because the wife was an obligate carrier of hemophilia B. Although the fetus was determined to be male, the parents elected not to have further testing to determine if he had hemophilia or not. The difficulties in the in utero diagnosis of hemophilia B are presented and discussed. In addition, the moral reasoning and decision-making process that this couple went through regarding the decision not to have further fetal testing and to continue the pregnancy is presented and analyzed. These moral decisions appear to be based on family and personal ties, and bonding to the fetus after perception of fetal movement. They combine considerations of the duties and rights involved in such situations, and attend to the anticipated consequences as well.     

Reproductive patterns among mothers of males diagnosed with Duchenne or Becker muscular dystrophy

Diagnosis of a child with Duchenne or Becker muscular dystrophy (DBMD) may impact future maternal reproductive choice; however, little is known about the reproductive patterns of mothers with a male child diagnosed with DBMD. Using population‐based surveillance data collected by the muscular dystrophy surveillance, tracking, and research network, the proportion of mothers who conceived and delivered a live birth following the diagnosis of DBMD in an affected male child and factors associated with such reproductive choice were identified. To accomplish this, maternal demographic data were linked to birth certificate data to construct the reproductive history for 239 mothers. Univariable and bivariable analyses were conducted to determine the proportion of mothers delivering a live birth and associated factors. By the time of the current study, 96 (40.2%) of the 239 mothers had at least one live birth following delivery of their oldest affected male child; 53 (22.2%) of these mothers had a live birth before and 43 (18.0%) had a live birth after DBMD diagnosis of a male child. Mothers with a live birth after diagnosis were significantly younger at diagnosis of the oldest affected male child (26.2 ± 4.2 years vs. 31.5 ± 5.5 years), and were less likely to be white non‐Hispanic compared to those with no live birth after diagnosis. These results suggest that about one in five mothers deliver a live birth subsequent to DBMD diagnosis in a male child. Maternal age and race/ethnicity were associated with this reproductive choice. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

眼皮肤白化病Ⅳ型产前基因诊断及一种MATP基因新突变

目的 对3例眼皮肤白化病(oculocutaneous albinism,OCA)患儿进行分型诊断,并在此基础上开展OCA4产前基因诊断研究,为临床OCA遗传咨询和产前诊断提供指导.方法 应用聚合酶链反应及DNA序列测定技术,确定先证者及其父母的基因型后,取绒毛或羊水进行产前基因诊断.结果 3例患儿均为OCA4.家系1患儿母亲后来两次怀孕,第1次诊断为患儿,已选择流产,再次怀孕时诊断为父源G349R致病基因携带者.家系2产前诊断结果显示胎儿既未获得父源突变,也未获得母源突变.家系3产前诊断结果显示胎儿仅获得父源G349R突变.结论 检出MATP基因3种已报道的OCA4致病性突变G349R、D160H和P419L,发现1种致病性新突变c,870delC.

Abstract：

Objective To provide guidance for clinical genetic counseling and prenatal diagnosis of oculocutaneous albinism (OCA) in China. Methods PCR and automatic DNA sequencing were applied to obtain the genotypes of the patients and their parents in three Chinese albinism families. Prenatal gene diagnoses were performed at early pregnancy by chorionic villus sampling (CVS) or by amniocentesis at midpregnancy. Results The three patients were all OCA4, whose genotypes were G349R/c. 870delC, G349R/P419L, G349R/D160H, respectively. The three couples had been diagnosed as carriers. In family 1, the first fetus was diagnosed as affected. Termination of pregnancy was opted following genetic counseling. The second fetus (monozygotic twin) was heterozygous only with the paternal G349R mutation. The fetus in family 2 did not get either one of the two mutations. The fetus in family 3 was heterozygous only with the paternal G349R mutation. Conclusion This study detected three reported pathogenic mutations of the membrane associated transporter protein gene (MATP), including G349R, D160H and P419L, and identified a novel pathogenic mutation c. 870delC. The prenatal gene diagnosis of OCA4 will be important to prevent the birth of affected child.     

Attitudes about genetic risk of couples undergoing in-vitro fertilization

Many couples undergoing in-vitro fertilization (IVF) are at a higher risk of having a child with a genetic abnormality. In a sample of 55 consecutive couples starting IVF, only 33% had no genetic risk factor. The most common genetic risks were advanced maternal age and possible abnormalities associated with severe male infertility. Despite education on these risks, 71% of couples had no interest in receiving formal genetic counselling. Only 14% of couples at risk would consider using a gamete donor to avoid transmitting a genetic disorder to a child. The triple test to screen for fetal abnormalities was acceptable to 82% of couples, but only 47% planned to have amniocentesis or chorionic villi sampling. Couples were significantly more likely to opt for prenatal testing if they would consider terminating a pregnancy should the fetus have a severe genetic abnormality (P < 0.01). Roman Catholic couples tended to have more conservative attitudes about pregnancy termination. Socio-economic status and whether the infertility factor was male or female were not predictors of a couple's attitudes.      

Patient and parental attitudes toward genetic screening and its implications at an adult cystic fibrosis centre

General population screening for cystic fibrosis carrier status in the United Kingdom would detect 72% of at-risk couples. Proper counselling would allow these couples to make informed reproductive choices, including the possibility of prenatal diagnosis and the termination of an affected pregnancy. However, children with cystic fibrosis born in this decade, given optimum treatment, now have an average life expectancy of 40 years, and there is no unanimity of opinion on how, where, when, or even if, screening should be offered. The purpose of this questionnaire-based study was to examine the attitudes of an adult clinic population who have grown up with cystic fibrosis, and of their parents, towards genetic screening programmes and the controversies and ethical dilemmas surrounding such programmes in cystic fibrosis. Both patients and parents supported prenatal screening (88% and 90%) and the option of terminating an affected pregnancy (68% and 84%). Only 22% of patients and 10% of parents felt that screening should be limited to families with a history of cystic fibrosis, and 19% and 6%, respectively, that prenatal diagnosis should be restricted to those with a previous child with cystic fibrosis. Despite the negative aspects of any screening programme and the acknowledged ethical problems peculiar to cystic fibrosis, the conclusion of our patients and parents who have lived intimately with the illness is that there should be the option of utilising information available from genetic screening for cystic fibrosis to guide reproductive choices. Pilot programmes to define the optimum management of such screening should continue.     

Preparing for presymptomatic DNA testing for early onset Alzheimer''s disease/cerebral haemorrhage and hereditary Pick disease.

The acceptability of presymptomatic testing in 21 people at 50% risk for the APP-692 mutation causing presenile Alzheimer's disease or cerebral haemorrhage resulting from cerebral amyloid angiopathy (FAD-CH), and in 43 people at 50% risk for hereditary Pick disease (HPD) was assessed. Neither group differed in demographic variables. Thirty-nine people (64%) in the whole group would request presymptomatic testing if it were clinically available, although two-thirds did not yet feel ready to take it. The most important reasons in the HPD and FAD-CH group for taking the test were: to further basic research (42% and 47%, respectively), informing children (47% and 50%, respectively), future planning (29% and 47%, respectively), and relieving uncertainty (46% and 27%, respectively). The most commonly cited effect of an unfavourable test result concerned increasing problems for spouses (75% and 76%, respectively) and children (61% and 57%, respectively). Most respondents denied that an unfavourable result would have adverse effects on personal mood or relationship. One-third of all respondents favoured prenatal testing where one of the parents had an increased risk for HPD or FAD-CH. Participants would encourage their offspring to have the test before starting a relationship (35%) and before family planning (44%). Thirty-seven percent of the respondents would encourage their children to opt for prenatal diagnosis. People at risk for HPD were significantly more preoccupied with the occurrence of potential symptoms in themselves, compared with those at risk for FAD-CH, reflecting the devastating impact that disinhibition in the affected patient has on the family. Our findings underline the need for adequate counselling and the availability of professional and community resources to deal with the impact of test results in subjects and their relatives.     

Prenatal diagnosis of the Beckwith-Wiedemann syndrome

We report on the prenatal diagnosis of Beckwith-Wiedemann syndrome (BWS) in a pregnancy monitored because of a previously affected child. The proposita had classical stigmata of BWS including macroglossia, omphalocele, and typical ear creases. Chromosomes were 46,XX. Both parents and the extended maternal family were clinically normal. In a subsequent pregnancy by another father, the mother had serial ultrasound monitoring at 13.5, 18, and 19 weeks gestation which showed an enlarged abdominal circumference and a 2-cm omphalocele. At termination the female fetus weighed more than two times the expected weight, had striking hypertrophy of skeletal muscles, a protuberant abdomen, and a 2-cm omphalocele and characteristic facial appearance. Autopsy confirmed generalized organomegaly. This is the first report of the prenatal diagnosis of BWS prior to 20 weeks in an at-risk family. The recurrence in this family emphasizes the difficulty in providing accurate genetic recurrence risks in BWS and suggests that ultrasonographic prenatal diagnosis should be offered to families even when the case appears to be "sporadic."     

Thalassemia carrier screening and prenatal diagnosis among the British Columbia (Canada) population of Chinese descent

The goal of thalassemia screening is the identification, prior to the conception or birth of an affected child, of couples where both partners are thalassemia carriers. When both partners are identified as carriers for alpha- or beta-thalassemia, the risk of having a fetus who is homozygous or compound heterozygous for the abnormal gene is 25%. A study was performed to identify whether routine screening for thalassemia is indicated for the Chinese population in British Columbia (BC). In a population of 783 subjects, studied either prospectively or retrospectively, 5.0% were alpha-thalassemia carriers and 1.7% were beta-thalassemia carriers. In addition, a review of all BC cases of prenatal diagnosis for thalassemia over a 6-year period indicated that 26% of couples were identified as alpha-thalassemia carriers because of a second or third trimester diagnosis of fetal hydrops, and 17% of couples referred for beta-thalassemia already had an affected child. The experience with prenatal diagnosis shows that a significant proportion of at-risk couples are not identified prior to or early in a pregnancy. The prevalence of carriers for thalassemia would warrant a program of education and routine screening for this condition in the BC Asian population.     

Clinical utility of expanded carrier screening: results-guided actionability and outcomes

PurposeExpanded carrier screening (ECS) informs couples of their risk of having offspring affected by certain genetic conditions. Limited data exists assessing the actions and reproductive outcomes of at-risk couples (ARCs). We describe the impact of ECS on planned and actual pregnancy management in the largest sample of ARCs studied to date.MethodsCouples who elected ECS and were found to be at high risk of having a pregnancy affected by at least one of 176 genetic conditions were invited to complete a survey about their actions and pregnancy management.ResultsThree hundred ninety-one ARCs completed the survey. Among those screened before becoming pregnant, 77% planned or pursued actions to avoid having affected offspring. Among those screened during pregnancy, 37% elected prenatal diagnostic testing (PNDx) for that pregnancy. In subsequent pregnancies that occurred in both the preconception and prenatal screening groups, PNDx was pursued in 29%. The decision to decline PNDx was most frequently based on the fear of procedure-related miscarriage, as well as the belief that termination would not be pursued in the event of a positive diagnosis.ConclusionECS results impacted couples' reproductive decision-making and led to altered pregnancy management that effectively eliminates the risk of having affected offspring.