Methods for comparing the diversity of samples of the T cell receptor repertoire

Analysis of T cell receptor (TCR) data has become a crucial element in many studies aimed at better understanding the evolution of the T cell repertoire and the role of TCR diversity in immune responses. In this paper we focus on comparing the diversity between samples of the TCR repertoire. We discuss some of the limitations and potential problems inherent in some of the more popular approaches to comparing samples of the TCR repertoire and we suggest alternate methods that both avoid these problems and enrich the analysis of TCR data. Examples from published studies of the CD8(+) T cell responses to the influenza A virus D(b)NP(366) and D(b)PA(224) epitopes in mice are used to demonstrate the implementation of these methods. One example involves a comparison between the central and effector memory T cell subsets, defined on the basis of CD62L expression, and the other examines changes in the TCR repertoire over time.     

Analysis of the TCR alpha-chain rearrangement profile in human T lymphocytes

The size of the available human alphabeta T cell repertoire is difficult to determine and is open to debate. Empirical analysis of TCR beta-chain diversity reveals approximately 10(6) different beta chains in peripheral blood. Due in part to locus complexity, comparable information for TCR alpha is lacking. Rather, current estimates for human TCR alpha diversity, and hence, total repertoire diversity, are based on theoretical analyses that assume equal probabilities of rearrangement between any V alpha gene and J alpha gene. Here, we report on a systematic locus-wide rearrangement analysis of the TCR alpha-chain in human T cells. We first demonstrate that the V-J alpha recombination in the thymus is not random but depends on the reciprocal V alpha and J alpha position within the locus. Characterization of the frequency of gene usage combined with identification of five previously unrecognized pseudogenes enables us to empirically estimate the human TCR alpha combinatorial repertoire. The number of V-J alpha combinations achieved is approximately 44-56% of the total combinatorial possibilities, significantly lower than theoretical estimates. We also demonstrate that TCR alpha-chain diversity in peripheral T lymphocytes mimics the same general patterns of rearrangement as observed in the thymus, and these patterns appear conserved among different individuals. This unexpected observation indicates that, unlike the TCR beta locus, the human TCR alpha-chain repertoire is primarily predetermined by genetic recombination and its size is restricted by limits on the combinatorial repertoire rather than post-thymic selection.     

Quantitative analysis of T cell receptor diversity in clinical samples of human peripheral blood

The analysis of T cell receptor diversity provides a clinically relevant and sensitive marker of repertoire loss, gain, or skewing. Spectratyping is a broadly utilized technique to measure global TCR diversity by the analysis of the lengths of CDR3 fragments in each Vβ family. However the common use of large numbers of T cells to obtain a global view of TCR Vβ CDR3 diversity has restricted spectratyping analyses when limited T-cell numbers are available in clinical setting, such as following transplant regimens. We here demonstrate that one hundred thousand T cells are sufficient to obtain a robust, highly reproducible measure of the global TCR Vβ repertoire diversity among twenty Vβ families in human peripheral blood. We also show that use of lower cell number results not in a dwindling of observed diversity but rather in non-reproducible patterns in replicate spectratypes. Finally, we report here a simple to use but sensitive method to quantify repertoire divergence in patient samples by comparison to a standard repertoire profile we generated from fifteen normal donors. We provide examples using this method to statistically evaluate the changes in the global TCR Vβ repertoire diversity that may take place during T subset immune reconstitution after hematopoietic stem cell transplantation or after immune modulating therapies.     

Harnessing the diversity of the human T‐cell repertoire: A monitoring tool for transplantation tolerance?

There is significant diversity in the TCR repertoire in heterologous and allogeneic immunity. A paper in this issue of the European Journal of Immunology shows that changes in the TCR repertoire can be correlated with outcomes of renal transplantation. This indicates that the diversity of the TCR repertoire could be utilized to monitor clinical phenotypes, such as chronic humoral rejection and operational tolerance in organ transplantation. However, prior to the clinical use of monitoring changes in the TCR repertoire as a biomarker to monitor clinical status after organ transplantation, many questions regarding time dependency, triggering factors and specificity need to be addressed. A causative role for TCR repertoire disruption in organ transplantation will need to be proven by interventional trials that can demonstrate that the TCR repertoire is modifiable and predictive of graft outcome. In this Commentary, we discuss the strengths and opportunities of TCR repertoire monitoring, and point towards yet unanswered questions that will become important if the Vβ CDR3-length distribution assay will be clinically applied.     

T cell receptor repertoire and function in patients with DiGeorge syndrome and velocardiofacial syndrome

DiGeorge syndrome (DGS) and velocardiofacial syndrome (VCFS) are associated with chromosome 22q11.2 deletion. Limited information is available on the T cell receptor (TCR) Vbeta repertoire. We therefore investigated TCR Vbeta families in lymphocytes isolated from blood and thymic samples of seven patients with DGS and seven patients with VCFS, all with 22q11.2 deletion. We also studied activities related to TCR signalling including in vitro proliferation, anti-CD3-induced protein tyrosine phosphorylation, and susceptibility to apoptosis. Reduced CD3+ T cells were observed in most patients. Spontaneous improvement of T cell numbers was detected in patients, 3 years after the first study. Analysis of CD4+ and CD8+ TCR Vbeta repertoire in peripheral and thymic cells showed a normal distribution of populations even if occasional deletions were observed. Lymphoproliferative responses to mitogens were comparable to controls as well as anti-CD3-induced protein tyrosine phosphorylation. Increased anti-CD3-mediated apoptosis was observed in thymic cells. Our data support the idea that in patients surviving the correction of cardiac anomalies, the immune defect appears milder than originally thought, suggesting development of a normal repertoire of mature T cells.     

Fractal Organization of the Human T Cell Repertoire in Health and after Stem Cell Transplantation

T cell repertoire diversity is generated in part by recombination of variable (V), diversity (D), and joining (J) segments in the T cell receptor β (TCR) locus. T cell clonal frequency distribution determined by high-throughput sequencing of TCR β in 10 stem cell transplantation (SCT) donors revealed a fractal, self-similar frequency distribution of unique TCR bearing clones with respect to V, D, and J segment usage in the T cell repertoire of these individuals. Further, ranking of T cell clones by frequency of gene segment usage in the observed sequences revealed an ordered distribution of dominant clones conforming to a power law, with a fractal dimension of 1.6 and 1.8 in TCR β DJ and VDJ containing clones in healthy stem cell donors. This self-similar distribution was perturbed in the recipients after SCT, with patients demonstrating a lower level of complexity in their TCR repertoire at day 100 followed by a modest improvement by 1 year post-SCT. A large shift was observed in the frequency distribution of the dominant T cell clones compared to the donor, with fewer than one third of the VDJ-containing clones shared in the top 4 ranks. In conclusion, the normal T cell repertoire is highly ordered with a TCR gene segment usage that results in a fractal self-similar motif of pattern repetition across levels of organization. Fractal analysis of high-throughput TCR β sequencing data provides a comprehensive measure of immune reconstitution after SCT.     

Next generation sequencing for TCR repertoire profiling: Platform‐specific features and correction algorithms

The TCR repertoire is a mirror of the human immune system that reflects processes caused by infections, cancer, autoimmunity, and aging. Next generation sequencing (NGS) is becoming a powerful tool for deep TCR profiling; yet, questions abound regarding the methodological approaches for sample preparation and correct data interpretation. Accumulated PCR and sequencing errors along with library preparation bottlenecks and uneven PCR efficiencies lead to information loss, biased quantification, and generation of huge artificial TCR diversity. Here, we compare Illumina, 454, and Ion Torrent platforms for individual TCR profiling, evaluate the rate and character of errors, and propose advanced platform‐specific algorithms to correct massive sequencing data. These developments are applicable to a wide variety of next generation sequencing applications. We demonstrate that advanced correction allows the removal of the majority of artificial TCR diversity with concomitant rescue of most of the sequencing information. Thus, this correction enhances the accuracy of clonotype identification and quantification as well as overall TCR diversity measurements.     

Delayed expansion of a restricted T cell repertoire by low-density TCR ligands

The role of TCR ligand density (i.e. the number of antigen-MHC complexes) in modulating the diversity of a T cell response selected from a pool of naive precursors remains largely undefined. By measuring early-activation markers up-regulation and proliferation following stimulation with staphylococcal enterotoxin A (SEA), we demonstrate that decreasing the ligand dose below an optimal concentration leads to the delayed activation of a restricted set of TCRVbeta-bearing T cells, with the specific, non-stochastic exclusion of some TCRVbeta+ T cells from the activated pool. Our results suggest that the failure of these TCRVbeta-bearing T cells to reach the activation threshold at sub-optimal ligand concentration is due to the inefficiency of TCR engagement, as measured by TCR internalization, and does not correlate with the relative precursor frequency in the non-immune repertoire. Moreover, even at SEA concentrations that lead to the simultaneous proliferation of all SEA-reactive T cells, we observe marked differences in the ability to secrete cytokines among the different responsive TCRVbeta-bearing T cells. Altogether, our results indicate that the development of a T cell response to a scarce display of ligand significantly narrows TCR repertoire diversity by mechanisms that involve focusing of the repertoire on the expansion of those T cells with the highest avidity of TCR engagement.     

CD3+、CD4+和CD8+ T细胞Vβ亚家族中PD-1免疫表型检测方法的建立

 目的：建立分析CD3⁺、CD4⁺和CD8⁺ T细胞Vβ亚家族中免疫抑制性受体程序性细胞死亡蛋白1（PD-1）分子免疫表型的方法,从而了解人体外周血T细胞谱系中PD-1表型细胞的分布频率。方法：收集健康个体（HI）外周血10例,利用抗CD45、CD3、CD4、CD8、PD-1等多色荧光流式单抗,以及T细胞受体（TCR）Vβ谱系试剂盒[IOTest^® Beta Mark TCR Vβ Repertoire Kit,共8管,每一管均为FITC和PE偶联的复合抗体（A~H）,每一管复合抗体包含3个TCR Vβ亚家族的抗体],检测T细胞亚群TCR Vβ亚家族中PD-1的分布情况。结果：在10例HI的检测中,CD3⁺、CD3⁺CD4⁺和CD3⁺CD8⁺ T细胞亚群中检测的24个TCR Vβ亚家族总和符合试剂盒所提供的Quick Reference Card数据,初步结果显示,HI中CD3⁺ T细胞主要优势TCR谱系是Vβ2、Vβ3、Vβ8、Vβ9、Vβ5.1、Vβ13.1和Vβ13.2;而在CD3⁺CD4⁺ T细胞中的优势利用主要集中在Vβ2、Vβ3、Vβ8、Vβ9、Vβ5.1和Vβ13.1;在CD3⁺CD8⁺ T细胞中则主要为Vβ1、Vβ2、Vβ3、Vβ9、Vβ13.1和Vβ13.2等亚家族。进一步分析显示PD-1⁺细胞在HI的CD3⁺、CD3⁺CD4⁺和CD3⁺CD8⁺ T细胞24个TCR Vβ亚家族中均可以检测到,PD-1⁺细胞在T细胞各亚群中分布频率有个体差异,在CD4⁺ T细胞中,以Vβ5.2⁺ T细胞的分布频率较高,而在CD8⁺ T细胞中,以Vβ11⁺和Vβ13.6⁺ T细胞的分布频率较高。结论：本项工作利用健康人样本成功建立了多色荧光流式细胞术检测T细胞亚群TCR Vβ谱系中免疫抑制性受体PD-1分子免疫表型的方法,为进一步应用于分析白血病等病人TCR Vβ谱系的免疫抑制特点提供了新方法。     

HIV-1感染者CD4+T细胞受体基因多样性特点及其与病毒载量的相关性

目的 分析HIV-1感染者CD4+T细胞受体(TCR)基因的多样性特征及其与病毒载量的相关性.方法 应用抗CD4单克隆抗体从25份HIV-1感染者和10份HIV-1阴性对照样本外周血单个核细胞(PBMC)中分离CD4+T细胞,提取细胞总RNA,然后通过逆转录及巢式多聚酶链反应(nestedPCR)对TCR 22个Vβ基因家族的互补决定区3(CDR3)进行扩增,利用ABI3700测序仪对扩增的PCR产物进行扫描,定最分析HIV-1感染者TCRCDR3区多样性变化特征及其与病毒载量的相关性.结果 HIV-1感染者CD4+T细胞TCR CDR3区平均D(distance)值显著高于正常对照组(P＜0 05),TCR Vβ基因各家族CDR3长度谱型成寡克隆分布,TCR CDR3区的紊乱与病毒载量呈正相关(r=0 494,P＜0 05);HIV-1感染引起TCR多样性的改变不仅表现在不同Vβ基因家族上,而且也表现在CDR3长度上,其中感染者Vβ8、Vβ22、Vβ23基因家族的变化与正常人差异有统计学意义.结论 HIV-1感染能引起CD4+T细胞TCR基因多样性的减少及高斯(Gaussian)分布的破坏,TCR CDR3区的紊乱与病毒载量呈正相关.

Abstract：

Objective To assess the impact of the virus on the complementary determining region 3 (CDR3) length diversity of T cell receptor(TCR) Vβ repertoires of CD4+ T lymphocytes and to explore its association with viral load in individuals with HIV-1 infection. Methods The TCR repertoire was examined using spectratyping of CDR3 length diversity within CD4+ T cells in HIV infected and healthy adults. Separation of CD4+ T cells from peripheral blood mononuclear cells ( PBMCs) was carried out by using immunomagnetic beads coated with anti-CD4 antibody. Total RNAs from the purified CD4 + T lymphocytes were isolated and used to perform nested-PCR amplifications in CDR3 of 22 TCR gene families. CDR3 diversity and its association with viral load in individuals with HIV-1 infection were analyzed. Results An average diversity for all CDR3 profiles in CD4+ T cells from 25 HIV-infected individuals was significantly different as compared to 10 age-matched healthy donors (P＜0.05) with the HIV-infected individuals losing diversity in the CDR3 profiles. There was positive correlation between changes in TCR CDR3 diversity and viral load (r = 0. 494, P ＜ 0. 05). The changes in CDR3 length diversity of Vβ families in HIV-infected individuals, particular in Vβ8, Vβ22, Vβ23 were statistically different from the healthy controls. Conclusion HIV-1 infection might induce the loss of TCR Vp repertoire diversity and disrupt the CDR3 Gaussian distributions within CD4 + T cells. There should be positive correlation between changes in TCR CDR3 diversity and the viral load in HIV-1 infected patients.     

T cell receptor αβ diversity inversely correlates with pathogen-specific antibody levels in human cytomegalovirus infection

A diverse T cell receptor (TCR) repertoire capable of recognizing a broad range of antigenic peptides is thought to be central to effective pathogen-specific immunity by counteracting escape mutations, selecting high-avidity T cells, and providing T cell specificities with comprehensive functional characteristics. However, evidence that TCR diversity is important for the successful control of human infections is limited. A single-cell strategy for the clonotypic analysis of human CD8? TCRαβ repertoires was used to probe the diversity and magnitude of individual human cytomegalovirus (CMV)-specific CD8? T cells recovered directly ex vivo. We found that CD8? TCRαβ repertoire diversity, but not the size of the CD8? T cell response, was inversely related to circulating CMV-specific antibody levels, a measure that has been correlated epidemiologically with differential mortality risks and found here to be higher in persons with detectable (versus undetectable) CMV viral loads. Overall, our findings indicate that CD8? T cell diversity may be more important than T cell abundance in limiting the negative consequences of CMV persistence, demonstrate high prevalence of both TCRα and TCRβ public motif usage, and suggest that a highly diverse TCRαβ repertoire may be an important benchmark and target in the success of immunotherapeutic strategies.     

Post-Natal Ontogenesis of the T-Cell Receptor CD4 and CD8 Vβ Repertoire and Immune Function in Children with DiGeorge Syndrome

DiGeorge syndrome (DGS) is a congenital disorder characterized by typical facial features, hypoparatyroidism, conotruncal cardiac defects and thymic hypoplasia. Although there are some reports addressing lymphocytes counts and function in DGS children over time, few data have been reported on the T-cell receptor Vβ (TCRBV) repertoire in relation to disease progression. The aim of this study was to evaluate the degree and nature of immunodeficiency and to investigate a possible correlation to clinical findings.We used third complementary region (CDR3) size spectratyping as a tool for monitoring T-cell repertoire diversity in 7 DGS’s children. The rate of thymic output, the phenotype and function of peripheral T-cells and the humoral immunity were also investigated. At baseline a profound alteration of the TCR repertoire was noted, mainly in the CD8+ T-cells, in DGS patients when compared to a control group. Furthermore, analysis of thymic output showed a significant decrease in TCR rearrangement excision circles (TRECs) levels in the patient group. Immunoglobulin abnormalities were also detected. The observed TCR repertoire alterations, although not statistically significant, may suggest an increased susceptibility to infections. A parallel increase in the TCR repertoire diversity and clinical improvement occurred during the follow-up. Our results confirm that the extent of immunodeficiency is highly variable and could improve through childhood, and indicate that TCR repertoire may be a useful marker to clinically monitor thymic function in this primary immunodeficiency.C. Cancrini and M.L. Romiti contributed equally to this work.     

Restriction in T-cell receptor repertoire in a patient affected by trichothiodystrophy and CD4+ lymphopenia

Molecular analysis of T-cell receptor (TCR) repertoire, by measuring the CDR3 heterogeneity length of beta-variable regions (spectratyping), is useful for acquiring novel information on the status of immune system in primary immunodeficiency. Here, we evaluate TCR repertoire in a child with trichothiodystrophy (TTD) and combined immunodeficiency (CID). Spectratyping revealed marked alterations of TCR repertoire distribution: 21 and 10 out of 27 TCR Vbeta (TCRBV) families and subfamilies were skewed in CD8+ and CD4+ subsets, respectively. These findings revealed, for the first time in a TTD patient with CID, a marked reduction in the TCR repertoire complexity, which may reflect alterations in the mechanisms regulating the generation and homeostasis of T cells.     

Improved assessment of T-cell receptor (TCR) VB repertoire in clinical specimens: combination of TCR-CDR3 spectratyping with flow cytometry-based TCR VB frequency analysis

Antigen-specific T-cell responses may be described by combining three categories: (i) the specificity and effector functions of a T-cell population, (ii) the quantity of T-cell responses (i.e., the number of responding T cells within the CD4/CD8 population), and (iii) the "quality" of T cells (defined by the T-cell receptor [TCR] structure). Several methods to measure T-cell responses are now available including evaluation of T-cell precursors using limiting dilution, the enzyme-linked immunospot assay, ex vivo TCR variable (v)-segment analysis determined by flow cytometry, and TCR-CDR3 length analysis (spectratyping), as well as identification of peptide-specific T cells using major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I tetramers containing appropriate peptides. Until now, only a limited set of MHC-peptide complexes have been available as tetramer complexes. We demonstrate that CD8(+) or CD4(+) T cells in patients with cancer can be molecularly defined using a combination of spectratyping (TCR structure and "molecular composition") plus the implementation of an antibody panel directed against 21 individual VB TCR chains ("quantity" of T-cell families). This approach is instrumental in defining and comparing the magnitudes of CD4(+) or CD8(+) T-cell responses over time in individual patients, in comparing the TCR VA and VB repertoire in different anatomic compartments, and in comparing the TCR VA-VB diversity with that in normal healthy controls. This method provides the means of objectively defining and comparing the TCR repertoire in patients undergoing vaccination protocols and underlines the necessity to calibrate the TCR-CDR3 analysis with a qualitative assessment of individual TCR VB families.     

In vivo and in vitro death of mature T cells induced by separate signals to CD4 and alpha beta TCR.

To investigate whether a clonal deletion mechanism is responsible for the mature T cell tolerance that may be induced in vivo by TCR signal to anti-CD4 (H129.19 mAb) coated cells, we analyzed the T cell repertoire in anti-CD4 mAb treated BALB/c mice by flow cytometry following TCR signals through anti-alpha beta TCR mAb or SEB superantigen. Lymph nodes showed a strong reduction in the CD4+/CD8+ cell ratio, and a selective clonal loss of CD4+ V beta 8+ cells 4d following anti-alpha beta TCR or SEB injection, respectively. Following lymph node cell activation in a short-term in vitro assay with SEB or anti-V beta 8 mAb, a selective elimination of CD4+ V beta 8+ cells was again detected, and DNA fragmentation analysis disclosed a cell death by apoptosis. These findings suggest that TCR triggering transduces an apoptotic signal into CD4+ mAb saturated cells that in turn leads to specific holes in the mature T cell repertoire.     

Analysis of the CDR3 Length Repertoire and the Diversity of TCRα Chain in Human Peripheral Blood T Lymphocytes

Analysis of complementarity determining region 3 （CDR3） length of T lymphocyte receptors （TCRs） by immunoscope spectratyping technique has been used successfully to investigate the diversity of TCR in autoimmune diseases and infection diseases. In this study, we investigated the patterns of CDR3 length distribution for all 32 TCR AV gene families in human peripheral blood lymphocytes of four normal volunteers by the immunoscope spectratyping technique. It was found that PCR products exhibited an obscure band on 1.5% agarose gel electrophoresis. Each TCR AV family exhibited more than 8 bands on 6% sequencing gel electrophoresis. The CDR3 spectratyping of all TCR AV families showed a standard Gaussian distribution with different CDR3 length, and the expression frequency of CDR3 was similar among the gene families. Most of CDR3 in TCR AV family recombine in frame. However, some of the CDR3 showed out-of frame gene rearrangement. Additionally, we found that in some of TCR AV families there were 18 amino acid discrepancies between the longest CDR3 and shortest CDR3. These results may be helpful to further study the recombination mechanism of human TCR genes, the TCR CDR3 gene repertoire, and the repertoire drift in health people and disease state. Cellular ＆ Molecular Immunology.     

Characterization of peripheral blood TCR repertoire in patients with ankylosing spondylitis by high-throughput sequencing

Ankylosing spondylitis (AS) is a chronic and progressive autoimmune disease affecting the invasion of the spine, sacroiliac joints and peripheral joints. T cells play a vital role in the underlying pathogenesis of AS, which mediated autoimmune and inflammatory responses via specific recognition of autoantigen peptides presented by susceptibility HLA. Antigen-specific T cells triggered by HLA/antigen complexes will undergo a massive expansion that forming an uneven T cell repertoire. To enhance our understanding of T-cell-mediated autoimmune in AS, we applied TCR β chains high-throughput sequencing to AS patients for in-depth TCR repertoire analysis. A significantly lower TCR repertoire diversity was observed in peripheral blood of AS patients relative to controls. And severe patients in our AS cohort have a more restricted TCR repertoire than mild patients, suggesting that the TCR repertoire diversity might be associated with the clinical severity of disease. No V, J and VJ pairs with significant biased usage were identified, which indicated that the usage frequency deviation of certain V/J/V-J genes in AS patients is little. This is a pilot study with potentially interesting observation on reduced diversity of T cells repertoire in peripheral blood of AS patients and further studies are needed.