Helper-dependent adenoviral vectors for gene therapy

Helper-dependent adenoviral vectors possess a number of characteristics that make them attractive gene therapy vectors. These vectors are completely devoid of viral coding sequences and are able to mediate high-efficiency transduction in vivo to direct sustain high-level transgene expression with negligible chronic toxicity. This review focuses on advances in helper-dependent adenoviral vector technology, selected examples of in vivo studies of particular interest, and the issue of vector-mediated acute toxicity.     

Determination of molecules regulating gene delivery using adenoviral vectors in ovarian carcinomas

Gene therapeutic approaches currently favor adenoviral vectors over alternatively available vector systems. Ovarian cancer represents an attractive model for an intraperitoneal adenovirus-based gene therapy, which is now under intensive clinical investigation. Adenovirus-mediated gene transfer depends on adequate virus uptake and thus on the presence of sufficient amounts of high-affinity coxsackie-adenovirus receptor (CAR) and alphavbeta3- and alphavbeta5 integrins on target cells. This fact has been ignored in most ongoing clinical trials. This investigation, therefore, determined expression of CAR by immunohistochemistry in 37 ovarian carcinomas and compared it with that of alphavbeta3 and alphavbeta5 integrins. In all samples, except one undifferentiated carcinoma, CAR was immunohistochemically demonstrable. Grade 1 tumors exhibited stronger CAR immunostaining as compared with higher-grade cancers (P < 0.03). Integrins alphavbeta3 and alphavbeta5 were detectable in 62% and 65% of carcinomas, respectively, and staining for both classes correlated positively (P < 0.005). Cancers classified as undifferentiated completely lacked alphavbeta3 expression. Furthermore, in undifferentiated and grade 3 carcinomas the three molecules studied exhibited marked distributional heterogeneity with regard to focal positivity and negativity within the same tumor. Either the absence of CAR, alphavbeta3 and alphavbeta5 or the pronounced heterogeneity in their expression might seriously compromise the efficiency of adenovirus-based gene therapy in ovarian cancer.     

High-capacity adenoviral vectors for gene transfer and somatic gene therapy.

The availability of efficient and nontoxic gene delivery technologies is fundamental to the translation of therapeutic concepts into clinical practice by gene transfer. High-capacity adenoviral (HC-Ad) vectors are characterized by the ability to transduce cells in vitro and in vivo with more than 30 kb of nonviral DNA. This quality allows simultaneous gene transfer of several expression cassettes, large promoters, and some genes in their natural genomic context. Because all viral coding sequences are removed from these vectors, safety is considerably improved compared with previous-generation adenoviral vectors.     

Antiangiogenic gene therapy for cancer via systemic administration of adenoviral vectors expressing secretable endostatin

A growing number of antiangiogenesis strategies have been investigated for the treatment of cancer and other angiogenesis-dependent diseases. One of the most promising strategies is to systemically administer one or more antiangiogenic proteins frequently enough to achieve a sufficient long-term steady state level of the protein(s) to achieve the maximum beneficial effect. However, the utility of this strategy is limited because of many technical difficulties, including obtaining both the quantity and quality of the protein(s) necessary for optimal therapeutic benefit. To overcome these difficulties, we hypothesized that a single administration of a replication-defective adenoviral vector expressing a secretable antiangiogenic protein could achieve an optimal long-term systemic concentration. We constructed a recombinant adenoviral vector, Av3mEndo, which encodes a secretable form of murine endostatin. We demonstrated secretion of endostatin from several cell lines transduced with Av3mEndo. Partially purified endostatin secreted from Av3mEndo-transduced mammalian cells was shown to potently inhibit endothelial cell migration in vitro. A single intravenous administration of Av3mEndo in mice was shown to result in (1) prolonged and elevated levels of circulating endostatin, (2) partial inhibition of VEGF-induced angiogenesis in a VEGF implant angiogenesis model, and (3) prolonged survival and in 25% of mice the complete prevention of tumor growth in a prophylactic human colon/liver metastasis xenograft murine model. These results support our contention that adenoviral vector-mediated expression of an antiangiogenic protein(s) represents an attractive therapeutic approach to cancer and other angiogenesis-dependent diseases.     

Head and neck cancer: gene therapy approaches. Part 1: adenoviral vectors

Treatment options for recurrent or refractory head and neck cancer are limited. The goal of gene therapy is to introduce new genetic material into cancer cells without affecting toxicity to surrounding malignant cells. The most common vehicles for delivery of genes are adenoviruses. Adenoviruses gain access to malignant and normal cell cytoplasm via viral ligand binding to a unique cell surface receptor (the coxsackie adenovirus receptor [CAR]). However, this receptor is not cancer specific. Genetic modification of adenoviral DNA can create cancer specific targeting. Adenoviruses can be modified to express cancer specific ligands thereby focusing binding to malignant tissue. Furthermore, adenoviral delivered genes can be put under cancer specific promoter control to further limit gene expression in malignant tissue. Increased antitumour activity from such modifications has been demonstrated preclinically and several clinical trials have been completed demonstrating safety and clinical activity of non-replicating and conditional replicating adenoviral vector thereby opening the door for gene delivery and cancer specific targeting.     

Targeting the replication of adenoviral gene therapy vectors to lung cancer cells: the importance of the adenoviral E1b-55kD gene

It has been proposed that an adenovirus with the E1b-55kD gene deleted has a selective advantage in replicating in cancer cells that have mutations in the p53 gene (Bischoff et al., 1996). We have explored this hypothesis in several lung cancer cell lines, and evaluated potential mechanisms that might regulate the replication of Ad338, an E1b-55kD-deleted virus, with the objective of developing a rational approach for targeting gene therapy to lung tumors. Our data show that Ad338 replicates poorly in three lung cancer cell lines with various p53 mutations (H441, H446, and Calu1), yet this virus replicates to a high level in a lung cancer cell line with wild-type p53 (A549) and in a normal lung fibroblast line (IMR90). Viral DNA replication, expression of viral proteins, and shutoff of host cell proteins were not important variables in limiting the replication of the E1b-55kD-deleted virus. However, the cell lines resistant to host cell protein shutoff were also the most resistant to the cytopathic effect induced by mutant and wild-type virus and the only cells to survive for 8 days following infection. The E1b-55kD protein clearly has an important role in viral replication beyond its interaction with p53. Thus, an E1b-55kD-deleted virus cannot be used to specifically target viral replication to p53-mutated lung cancer cells.     

Parvovirus vectors for cancer gene therapy

Parvoviruses comprise a group of single-stranded DNA viruses with greater potential for gene therapy applications. Unique characteristics of paroviruses, such as non-pathogenicity, antioncogenicity and methods of efficient recombinant vector production, have drawn more attention towards utilising parvovirus-based vectors in cancer gene therapy. Although > 30 different parvoviruses have been identified so far, recombinant vectors derived from adeno-associated virus (AAV), minute virus of mice (MVM), LuIII and parvovirus H1 have been successfully tested in many preclinical models of human diseases, including cancer. The present article will focus on the potential of non-replicating and autonomously replicating parvoviral vectors in cancer gene therapy, including strategies that target tumour cells directly or indirectly.     

Interferon-alpha gene therapy by lentiviral vectors contrasts ovarian cancer growth through angiogenesis inhibition

Ovarian cancer represents a suitable disease for gene therapy because of the containment of neoplastic cells in the peritoneal cavity even at advanced tumor stages. The aim of this study was to investigate whether intraperitoneal administration of a lentiviral vector encoding murine interferon-alpha (LV-IFN) could have therapeutic activity in a transplantable ovarian cancer model. Multiple injections of low amounts of LV-IFN into severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) mice bearing IGROV-1 or OC316 ovarian cancer cells elicited remarkable antitumor activity, leading to prolongation of survival in the majority of animals. A definitive cure was obtained in animals bearing PD-OVA#1 tumors, generated by injecting tumor cells isolated from the ascitic fluid of a patient into SCID mice. Interferon-alpha levels were detected in the peritoneal fluids but not in the serum of treated mice, indicating that production of the cytokine is mainly local, by both tumor and normal cells of the host. Antitumor effects were associated with a remarkable decrease in the formation of hemorrhagic ascites, an increase in ischemic tumor necrosis, and a reduction in microvessel density. In conclusion, our findings show that intracavitary IFN-alpha gene therapy, using a lentiviral vector, provides strong antitumor effects in murine models of ovarian cancer and reinforces the evidence that angiogenesis inhibition is a promising strategy for the treatment of localized tumors.     

Conditionally replication-competent adenoviral vectors with enhanced infectivity for use in gene therapy of melanoma

To generate vector Ad.Tyr-E1A, which is cytolytic for tyrosinase-positive melanoma cells, we replaced the adenoviral E1A promoter with a human tyrosinase enhancer/promoter. To overcome the low transduction efficiency in populations of melanoma cells that exhibit a low level of the coxsackievirus-adenovirus receptor (CAR), we inserted an RGD-4C peptide into the HI loop of the fiber knob domain of the Ad.Tyr-E1A vector. The resulting vector was named Ad.Tyr-E1A(RGD). As a result of these changes, the transduction efficiency of the RGD-modified vector was increased both in vitro and in vivo. Western blot analysis proved that infection of cells with the Ad.Tyr-E1A(RGD) vector led to expression of the E1A gene selectively in tyrosinase-positive melanoma cell lines, but not in tyrosinase-negative cell lines. The Ad.Tyr-E1A(RGD) vector was as potent in its cytotoxic effect as a tumor nonselective vector (Ad.CMV-E1A) in tyrosinase-positive melanoma cell lines. The Ad.Tyr-E1A(RGD) vector produced a higher vector particle yield in tumor cells than did the Ad.Tyr-E1A vector. Intratumoral injection of the Ad.Tyr-E1A(RGD) vector into xenotransplanted human melanoma tumors led to tumor regression in vivo. The combination of tumor-specific replication and enhanced infectivity generates a more potent CRAD vector for gene therapy of melanoma.     

Progress and prospects: gene therapy for genetic diseases with helper-dependent adenoviral vectors

Preclinical studies in small and large animal models using helper-dependent adenoviral vectors (HDAds) have generated promising results for the treatment of genetic diseases. However, clinical translation is complicated by the dose-dependent, capsid-mediated acute toxic response following systemic vector injection. With the advancements in vectorology, a better understanding of vector-mediated toxicity, and improved delivery methods, HDAds may emerge as an important vector for gene therapy of genetic diseases and this report highlights recent progress and prospects in this field.     

Pseudo-hydrodynamic delivery of helper-dependent adenoviral vectors into non-human primates for liver-directed gene therapy.

Helper-dependent adenoviral vectors (HDAds) are attractive for liver-directed gene therapy because they can mediate long-term, high-level transgene expression without chronic toxicity. However, systemic delivery requires high vector doses for efficient hepatic transduction, resulting in dose-dependent acute toxicity. Clearly, strategies to improve hepatic transduction with low vector doses are needed. In this regard, we have previously shown that hydrodynamic injection of helper-dependent adenoviral vectors into mice results in increased hepatic transduction, reduced systemic vector dissemination, and reduced pro-inflammatory cytokines compared with conventional injection and thus has the potential to improve dramatically the therapeutic index of helper-dependent adenoviral vectors. Unfortunately, the rapid, large-volume injection used in this method cannot be applied to larger animals. Therefore, we have developed a novel balloon occlusion catheter-based method to mimic hydrodynamic injection of helper-dependent adenoviral vectors into non-human primates that does not require rapid, large-volume injection. Using a low, clinically relevant vector dose, this minimally invasive method results in high-efficiency hepatic transduction with minimal toxicity and stable long-term transgene expression for at least 413 days.     

Gene therapy progress and prospects: adenoviral vectors

In September 1999, the perceptions of the use of adenoviral (Ad) vectors for gene therapy were altered when a patient exposed via the hepatic artery to a high dose of adenoviral vector succumbed to the toxicity related to vector administration. Appropriately, concerns were raised about continued use of the Ad vector system and, importantly, there were increased efforts to more fully understand the toxicity. Today it is recognized that there is no ideal vector system, and that while Ad vectors are not suitable for all applications, the significant advantages over other vector systems including efficient transduction of a variety of cell types, both quiescent and dividing, make it optimal for certain applications. These include protocols where high levels of short-term expression are sufficient to provide a therapeutic benefit. Potential target applications include therapeutic angiogenesis, administration into immune-privileged sites such as the CNS, or treatments where the adjuvant effect of adenovirus can be of benefit such as cancer vaccines. Broader applicability of Ad vectors will require resolution of toxicity issues. This review will therefore focus on studies conducted over the last 2 years that have advanced our understanding of the toxicity associated with Ad vectors, studies that have employed methods to reduce toxicity and improvements in Ad vectors themselves that will reduce toxicity by one of several mechanisms. These mechanisms include retargeting vector to the tissue of interest, minimizing or eliminating viral gene expression that is thought to result in loss of transduced cells, or by methods that seek to reduce the vector dose required for therapeutic benefit. An area where there remains significant room for improvement is when readministration of vector is required because transgene expression has decreased to background levels.     

Folate-targeted non-viral DNA vectors for cancer gene therapy

The vitamin folic acid exhibits high affinity for the endocytosed, membrane-bound folate receptor. Conjugation of folic acid via its gamma-carboxyl group to various macromolecules results in binding to, and endocytosis into, cells expressing the folate receptor. The folate receptor is overexpressed on a wide range of cancers, therefore folic acid has been investigated as a targeting ligand for the specific delivery of therapeutic compounds to cancer cells. This review will introduce folate-targeting of macromolecules to cancer cells in vitro and in vivo, and discuss the accumulation of such compounds in non-target tissues in vivo. Folate-targeting of non-viral DNA vectors in vitro and in vivo will be discussed in detail, with particular emphasis on the recent advances in this field.     

Progress towards the clinical application of helper-dependent adenoviral vectors for liver and lung gene therapy

This review focuses on recent developments in helper-dependent adenoviral technology and preclinical studies for helper-dependent adenovirus-mediated liver- and lung-directed gene therapy. Studies highlighting the tremendous potential of these vectors are reviewed, together with some important obstacles that will need to be addressed before clinical utility.     

A model for optimizing adenoviral delivery in human cancer gene therapy trials

Optimization of adenoviral delivery to the target volume is required for adenovirus-mediated cancer gene therapy to reach its maximal potential. The purpose of these studies was to develop a model of gene expression to improve adenovirus-mediated cancer gene therapy in the clinic. We measured the distribution of gene expression after a single deposit of a replication-competent adenovirus carrying the human sodium iodide symporter (hNIS) reporter gene was delivered to naive canine prostate and to human tumor xenografts. We generated hypothetical treatment plans for two prospective prostate cancer patients, using standard brachytherapy algorithms. In both models, the gene expression distribution from a single adenoviral deposit could be accurately described by a Gaussian function. In the naive canine prostate, a 0.1-ml deposit of 3 x 10(11) viral particles (VP) resulted in a gene expression volume of 1.14 +/- 0.70 cm(3), indicating that a minimum of 40 adenoviral deposits would be required to cover a 40-cm(3) prostate with therapeutic gene expression. On a viral particle basis, the gene expression volume obtained in human tumor xenografts (7 x 10(-12) cm(3)/VP) was twice that (3.5 x 10(-12) cm(3)/VP) measured in the naive canine prostate. Hypothetical treatment plans for two prostates indicated that 26 and 57 0.1-ml adenoviral deposits would be required to cover, respectively, 24- and 49-cm(3) prostates with gene expression. Although our studies focused on prostate, we believe the methodology to model gene expression presented here has much broader application to optimize treatment plans in other solid tumor sites; this assertion should be confirmed experimentally.     

Evaluation of twenty human adenoviral types and one infectivity-enhanced adenovirus for the therapy of soft tissue sarcoma

The clinical course of sarcoma warrants the development of new therapeutic options, such as gene therapy. However, the lack of coxsackievirus-adenovirus receptor (CAR) on sarcoma cells limits the efficacy of adenovirus type 5 (Ad5)-based gene therapy. In this study we evaluated 20 different adenoviral types and 1 Ad5 vector with RGD-containing fiber for their internalization efficiency in sarcoma cells. We demonstrated that adenovirus types 35, 3, 7, 11, 9, and 22 and Ad5lucRGD virions (ranked in descending order) have significantly higher internalization efficiency in the tested sarcoma cells when compared with Ad5. On the basis of these results we developed a conditionally replication-competent adenoviral vector, Ad5Delta24.Ki.COX, and compared its oncolytic efficacy with that of Ad5/35Delta24.Ki.COX, an Ad5-based vector with the Ad35 fiber shaft and knob domains. Because both vectors differed only in the fiber, we were able to assess whether the adenoviral type with the most efficient internalization resulted also in enhanced treatment efficacy. We evaluated the antineoplastic activity of the oncolytic adenoviral vectors alone or in combination with the expression of measles virus fusogenic membrane glycoproteins and/or ifosfamide. The findings of our xenograft model were as follows: animals that received Ad5/35-based therapy had significantly smaller tumors than animals treated with the homologous Ad5-based vectors. In addition, we demonstrated that the combination of virotherapy, intratumoral expression of fusogenic membrane glycoproteins, and ifosfamide was clearly superior compared with treatment with individual components alone or as combinations of two components. In conclusion, Ad35-based vectors are promising for the treatment of sarcoma.     

Advances in gene transfer into haematopoietic stem cells by adenoviral vectors

Until recently, the cells of haematopoietic origin were not considered good adenoviral (Adv) targets, primarily because they lacked the specific Adv receptors required for productive and efficient Adv infections. In addition, because of limitations inherent in Adv infections, such as short-term expression and a non-integrating nature, their application has been precluded from haematopoietic stem cell (HSC) and bone marrow transduction protocols where long-term expression has been required. Therefore, limited research utilising Adv-mediated gene transfer into haematopoietic cells had been conducted. With recent insights into the critical interactions between adenovirus (Adv) and cells, new Adv-mediated gene transduction strategies have now been reported that may overcome these limitations. These new strategies include Adv possessing synthetic polymer coatings, genetically modified capsid proteins or antibody-redirected fibres that can efficiently redirect and retarget Adv to transfer genes into HSC. Additionally, new hybrid Advs, engineered with both modified capsid proteins and novel cis-acting integration sequences, are also being developed which can efficiently deliver and integrate Adv delivered genes into HSC. This is an area of research that is now rapidly gaining momentum in terms of techniques and applications. Here we review the current status of adenovirus-based vectors as a means to achieve high-level gene transfer into haematopoietic cell types.