Effects of a sodium fluoride solution and a varnish with different fluoride concentrations on enamel remineralization in vitro

Abstract – To study the efficacy of sodium fluoride varnishes and a NaF solution in remineralization of enamel, 120 slabs of non-carious human enamel enamel were presoftened for 6 h and randomly divided into six groups. The slabs were stored in synthetic saliva for 9 days, except for a daily 30-min immersion in 0.1 M lactic acid-NaOH buffer. During the 9-day period, one group of the slabs received no treatment, and the rest were treated once or three times with 2.3% or 1.1% sodium fluoride varnish Duraphat, or nine times with a 0.1% NaF solution. Finally, the slabs were demineralized for 1 h, and the amount of dissolved Ca and F was determined. Microhardness of enamel was determined initially, after presoftening, after the 9- day period, and after the 1-h demineralization. All fluoride treatments prevented enamel softening almost completely during the 9 days, but the control slabs softened markedly. Fluoride varnishes were more effective than NaF solution. Three applications of 2.3% Duraphat were slightly more effective than any of the other varnish treatments, but one treatment with 2.3% varnish was not more effective than treatments with 1.1% varnish. Enamel treated three times with 1.1% varnish showed the greatest acid resistance during the 1-h demineralization. The results suggest that the efficacy of the varnish was not proportional to the fluoride concentration but rather to the number of applications. Fluoride uptake by enamel was greatest with the most concentrated varnish. Enamel solubility was not, however, directly proportional to the fluoride content of enamel.     

Effects of a sodium fluoride solution and a varnish with different fluoride concentrations on enamel remineralization in vitro

To study the efficacy of sodium fluoride varnishes and a NaF solution in remineralization of enamel, 120 slabs of non-carious human enamel enamel were presoftened for 6 h and randomly divided into six groups. The slabs were stored in synthetic saliva for 9 days, except for a daily 30-min immersion in 0.1 M lactic acid-NaOH buffer. During the 9-day period, one group of the slabs received no treatment, and the rest were treated once or three times with 2.3% or 1.1% sodium fluoride varnish Duraphat, or nine times with a 0.1% NaF solution. Finally, the slabs were demineralized for 1 h, and the amount of dissolved Ca and F was determined. Microhardness of enamel was determined initially, after presoftening, after the 9-day period, and after the 1-h demineralization. All fluoride treatments prevented enamel softening almost completely during the 9 days, but the control slabs softened markedly. Fluoride varnishes were more effective than NaF solution. Three applications of 2.3% Duraphat were slightly more effective than any of the other varnish treatments, but one treatment with 2.3% varnish was not more effective than treatments with 1.1% varnish. Enamel treated three times with 1.1% varnish showed the greatest acid resistance during the 1-h demineralization. The results suggest that the efficacy of the varnish was not proportional to the fluoride concentration but rather to the number of applications. Fluoride uptake by enamel was greatest with the most concentrated varnish. Enamel solubility was not, however, directly proportional to the fluoride content of enamel.     

Deposition of fluoride on enamel surfaces released from varnishes is limited to vicinity of fluoridation site

The aim of the in-situ study was to determine fluoride uptake in non-fluoridated, demineralized enamel after application of fluoride varnishes on enamel samples located at various distances from the non-fluoridated samples. All enamel samples used were demineralized with acidic hydroxyethylcellulose before the experiment. Intra-oral appliances were worn by ten volunteers in three series: (1, Mirafluorid, 0.15% F; 2, Duraphat, 2.3% F and 3, unfluoridated controls) of 6 days each. Each two enamel samples were prepared from 30 bovine incisors. One sample was used for the determination of baseline fluoride content (BFC); the other was treated according to the respective series and fixed in the intra-oral appliance for 6 days. Additionally, from 120 incisors, each four enamel samples were prepared (one for BFC). Three samples (a–c) were placed into each appliance at different sites: (a) directly neighboured to the fluoridated specimen (=next), (b) at 1-cm distance (=1 cm) and (c) in the opposite buccal aspect of the appliance (=opposite). At these sites, new unfluoridated samples were placed at days 1, 3 and 5, which were left in place for 1 day. The volunteers brushed their teeth and the samples with fluoridated toothpaste twice per day. Both the KOH-soluble and structurally bound fluoride were determined in all samples to determine fluoride uptake and were statistically analyzed. One day, after fluoridation with Duraphat, KOH-soluble fluoride uptake in specimen a (=next) was significantly higher compared to the corresponding samples of both the control and Mirafluorid series, which in turn were not significantly different from each other. At all other sites and time points, fluoride uptake in the enamel samples were not different from controls for both fluoride varnishes. Within the first day after application, intra-oral-fluoride release from the tested fluoride varnish Duraphat leads to KOH-soluble fluoride uptake only in enamel samples located in close vicinity to the fluoridation site.     

Evaluation of fluoride release from experimental TiF4 and NaF varnishes in vitro

Fluoride varnishes play an important role in the prevention of dental caries, promoting the inhibition of demineralization and the increase of remineralization.

Objective

This study aimed to analyze the amount of fluoride released into water and artificial saliva from experimental TiF₄ and NaF varnishes, with different concentrations, for 12 h.

Material and Methods

Fluoride varnishes were applied on acrylic blocks and then immersed in 10 ml of deionized water and artificial saliva in polystyrene bottles. The acrylic blocks were divided in seven groups (n=10): 1.55% TiF₄ varnish (0.95% F, pH 1.0); 3.10% TiF₄ varnish (1.90% F, pH 1.0); 3.10% and 4% TiF₄ varnish (2.45% F, pH 1.0); 2.10% NaF varnish (0.95% F, pH 5.0); 4.20% NaF varnish (1.90% F, pH 5.0); 5.42% NaF varnish (2.45% F, pH 5.0) and control (no treatment, n=5). The fluoride release was analyzed after 1/2, 1, 3, 6, 9 and 12 h of exposure. The analysis was performed using an ion-specific electrode coupled to a potentiometer. Two-way ANOVA and Bonferroni''s test were applied for the statistical analysis (p<0.05).

Results

TiF₄ varnishes released larger amounts of fluoride than NaF varnishes during the first 1/2 h, regardless of their concentration; 4% TiF₄ varnish released more fluoride than NaF varnishes for the first 6 h. The peak of fluoride release occurred at 3 h. There was a better dose-response relationship among the varnishes exposed to water than to artificial saliva.

Conclusions

The 3.10% and 4% TiF₄ -based varnishes have greater ability to release fluoride into water and artificial saliva compared to NaF varnish; however, more studies must be conducted to elucidate the mechanism of action of TiF₄ varnish on tooth surface.     

In vitro fluoride uptake, distribution and retention by human enamel after 1- and 24-hour application of various topical fluoride agents

The in vitro fluoride acquisition by human enamel after a 1-hour and 24-hour application of APF, Duraphat (a resin varnish) or Fluor Protector (a polyurethane varnish) and subjection to various procedures was determined. Fluoride acquisition was the greatest in teeth treated with Fluor Protector and the least in APF-treated teeth. Fluoride uptake and distribution were increased by prolonging the contact time between the varnishes and enamel, and fluoride retention was decreased after subsequent exposure to synthetic saliva.     

成膜基质对氟化物涂膜抑制釉质早期龋的效果

目的:比较含不同成膜基质的氟化物涂膜抑制釉质早期龋的效果。方法:将制备的90个釉质试样块随机分成6组,分别应用以5种成膜基质(珂巴树脂、渗透型丙烯酸树脂、甲基丙烯酸乙酯共聚树脂、聚合松香、聚乙烯醇缩丁醛)配制的氟涂膜材料和Duraphat氟涂膜进行处理。采用荧光显微镜和显微硬度计测定各组釉质试样块在pH循环前后的荧光值和硬度值的变化;并通过偏光显微镜观察其脱矿深度。结果:pH循环后各组釉质试样块的荧光值和硬度值均较pH循环前明显降低,其中渗透型丙烯酸组与其他组相比,荧光损失率和硬度值变化率最小,与其他各组相比差异均有统计学意义(P<0.05);偏光显微镜观察显示:各组釉质表面均无实质性缺损,渗透型丙烯酸组釉质脱矿深度最浅。结论:氟化物涂膜具有明显的抑制釉质脱矿的作用,含渗透型丙烯酸树脂的氟涂膜效果最好。     

Studies of fluoride varnishes in Finland.

Despite the artificial fluoridation of drinking water in Kuopio, part of the children have high caries incidence. We therefore started our studies on fluoride varnishes in 1977 in an attempt to find a feasible means of applying fluoride topically in children at high risk of caries. In our first trial, the sodium fluoride varnish Duraphat was found to be effective in preventing caries, but the effectiveness of the silane fluoride varnish Fluor Protector could not be unequivocally established, despite the fact that Fluor Protector deposited markedly more fluoride in enamel than Duraphat. In a second study in children in a low-fluoride area, use of Duraphat was found to be more effective than fortnightly fluoride rinses or Fluor Protector. Increasing the frequency of application from two to four times a year did not increase the effectiveness of Duraphat even in highly caries-prone children in a 2-year trial. On the basis of peak values of fluoride in parotid saliva after application, use of either fluoride varnishes was considered safe. Although the fluoride content of the enamel remained elevated for at least two years after discontinuation of treatment with both varnishes, the caries preventive effect did not continue after the applications were stopped. This shows that increasing the fluoride content of enamel is not the main mechanism by which fluoride varnishes prevent caries, and that the applications need to be continued as long as caries is a problem.     

Fluoride varnishes and caries development in primary tooth enamel: an in vitro study

This in vitro study evaluated the effect of fluoride varnishes on caries development in primary tooth enamel using polarized light microscopic techniques. A total of forty extracted or exfoliated primary teeth with intact, caries-free smooth surfaces underwent a fluoride-free prophylaxis and soft tissue were assigned to one of the following groups: 1) duraphat (5 percent sodium fluoride, vanish, Colgate, n=10); 2) Duraflor (5 percent sodium fluoride, Pharmascience, n = 10); 3 Cavity Shield (5 percent sodium fluoride varnish, Omni, n=10); and 4) Control (n=10). An acid-resistant coating was applied to the specimens leaving an exposed window of sound enamel (5mm x 1mm). The fluoride varnishes were applied to the primary teeth according to the manufacturer's recommendation. Following thermocycling (500 cycles, 5-50 degrees C) of the fluoride varnish-treated and control teeth, a fluoride-free pumice toothbrushing was performed to remove visible and macroscopically (dissecting microscope at 16x) detectable fluoride varnish. An acid resistant coating was reapplied where necessary, leaving the fluoride varnish treated sound enamel window exposed. Following in vitro caries formation (2.2mM Ca, 2.2mM PO4 50mM acetic acid, 0.5ppm fluoride, pH 3.90), longitudinal sections (5 per specimen) were obtained and evaluated by polarized light microscopy for mean lesion depth. Comparisons were made among treatment and control groups.     

In vitro fluoride uptake by enamel and dentin. A comparative study of two varnishes

The uptake of fluoride in enamel and dentin after application of an experimental fluoride varnish has been studied and compared with the uptake from a commercially available varnish (Duraphat). Each varnish was applied to 10 extracted human cuspid teeth. Successive etchings with perchloric acid were carried out separately in enamel and root dentin to obtain samples at three different depths. The concentrations of fluoride and calcium in the samples were determined, and the fluoride uptake was calculated. The experimental varnish gave a significantly greater fluoride uptake at all three sample depths in both enamel and dentin.     

Effect of a 4% titanium tetrafluoride (TiF4) varnish on demineralisation and remineralisation of bovine enamel in vitro

OBJECTIVES: This in vitro study assessed the effect of a 4% TiF4 varnish on demineralisation and remineralisation of sound enamel and artificial carious enamel lesions, respectively. METHODS: Bovine sound and carious enamel (n=110) were randomly allocated to each type of varnish: Duraphat-D (NaF, 2.26%F, pH 4.5, Colgate-Brazil, n=30), Duofluorid-F (NaF, 2.71%F, pH 8.0, FGM-Brazil, n=30), TiF4-T (2.45%F, pH 1.0, FGM-Brazil, n=30) and no-fluoride-P (FGM-Brazil, pH 5.0, n=20). For the formation of artificial enamel caries, half of the blocks were immersed in 32 mL buffer acetate solution (16 h), whereas the other half was maintained sound. The varnishes were applied onto the enamel surfaces. Thus, the samples were subjected to pH cycles (37 degrees C) for 7 days. The response variables tested were surface and cross-sectional hardness. Data were tested using Kruskal-Wallis test (p<0.05). RESULTS: All F varnishes significantly reduced demineralisation and increased remineralisation in comparison to placebo. The TiF4 did not significantly reduce the surface enamel softening when compared with the other F varnishes, but it decreased the loss of subsurface hardness to the same extent. In enamel blocks with previous artificial carious lesions, the TiF4 significantly improved the rehardening compared to the other varnishes up to 30 microm depth. CONCLUSIONS: The TiF4 varnish was able to decrease the demineralisation and increase the remineralisation of previously sound and carious enamel, respectively. It was equally effective compared to NaF varnishes on reducing the demineralisation at subsurface, but it was more effective on improving the remineralisation at surface and subsurface.     

Assessing the effect of fluoride varnish on early enamel carious lesions in the primary dentition

BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of fluoride varnish on enamel caries progression in the primary dentition. METHODS: One hundred forty-two children in Head Start schools (3 to 5 years old) were randomized into the varnish and control groups. Children in the varnish group received fluoride varnish (Duraphat, Colgate-Palmolive Co.) at baseline and after four months, and children in the control group received no professional fluoride applications. Two calibrated examiners performed the examinations at baseline and at nine months. RESULTS: At nine months, the authors found that in the control group, 37.8 percent of active enamel lesions on occlusal, buccal and lingual surfaces became inactive, 3.6 percent progressed and 36.9 percent did not change. In the varnish group, 81.2 percent became inactive, 2.4 percent progressed and 8.2 percent did not change. The difference between the groups was statistically significant (P < .0001). The mean decayed surfaces, or ds, value in the varnish group was significantly lower after nine months than it was at baseline (P < .0001). When enamel lesions were included in the data analysis (along with dentinal lesions), the decayed with initial enamel lesions, missing and filled surfaces, or dEmfs, values; decayed with initial enamel lesions, missing and filled teeth, or dEmft, values; and decayed surfaces with initial enamel lesions, or dEs, values were significantly lower in the varnish group after nine months than they were at baseline (P < .0001). CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that fluoride varnish applications may be an effective measure in reversing active pit-and-fissure enamel lesions in the primary dentition. CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS: Fluoride varnishes are safe, easy to apply and well-accepted by patients. This study shows that fluoride varnish may offer an efficient, nonsurgical alternative for the treatment of decay in children.     

Fluoride and calcium release from peppermint-flavored fluoride varnish containing dicalcium-phosphate-dihydrate coated with xylitol

Bakground: Fluoride varnish with high initial fluoride and calcium release can help patients with high-risk caries. Ample quantities of free fluoride and calcium ions in the oral cavity can enhance enamel remineralization. This study aimed to investigate the effect of dicalcium phosphate dihydrate coated with xylitol (DCPD-xylitol), in fluoride varnish, on the release of fluoride and calcium ions in the oral cavity.Materials and methodsDCPD powder with xylitol was synthesized by preparing a 60% xylitol solution and mixed it with DCPD solution. The mixture was stirred for 1 h at room temperature and dried at 80 °C for 18 h to reduce the water content. Then, the powder was used in the formulation of peppermint-flavored fluoride varnish as an active agent. The amounts of fluoride and calcium ion released in deionized water at 37 °C for 6 h were assessed with an ion-selective electrode. The cumulative fluoride and calcium ion release data were analyzed using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and the post hoc Tukey test with α = 0.05.ResultsThe results showed that the addition of DCPD coated with xylitol provided better bioavailability of the ions than DCPD without coating. Peppermint-flavored fluoride varnish (PFFV) with DCPD-xylitol 1% gave the highest fluoride ion release (296.90 mg/L) compared to the varnishes with other xylitol concentrations and the positive control. In contrast, PFFV DCPD-xylitol 5% afforded the highest calcium ion release at 111.20 mg/L.ConclusionsThis study concluded that xylitol affects the bioavailability of free fluoride and calcium ions in varnishes. However, the efficacy of fluoride and calcium uptake in enamel and under different in vitro media conditions requires further investigation.     

The effect of an experimental 4% Tif4 varnish compared to NaF varnishes and 4% TiF4 solution on dental erosion in vitro

This in vitro study assessed the effect of an experimental 4% TiF(4) varnish compared to commercial NaF and NaF/CaF(2) varnishes and 4% TiF(4) solution on enamel erosion. For this, 72 bovine enamel specimens were randomly allocated to the following treatments: NaF varnish(2.26% F), NaF/CaF(2) varnish (5.63% F), 4% TiF(4) varnish (2.45% F), F-free placebo varnish, 4% TiF(4 )solution (2.45% F) and control (not treated). The varnishes were applied in a thin layer and removed after 6 h. The solution was applied to the enamel surface for 1 min. Then, the specimens were alternately de- and remineralized (6 times/day) in an artificial mouth for 5 days at 37 degrees C. Demineralization was performed with the beverage Sprite (1 min, 3 ml/min) and remineralization with artificial saliva (day: 59 min, 0.5 ml/min; during the night: 0.1 ml/min). The mean daily increment of erosion and the cumulative erosion data were tested using ANOVA and ANCOVA, respectively, followed by Tukey's test (alpha = 0.05). The mean daily erosion increments and cumulative erosion (micrometers) were significantly less for the TiF(4) varnish (0.30 +/- 0.11/0.65 +/- 0.75) than for the NaF varnish (0.58 +/- 0.11/1.47 +/- 1.07) or the NaF/CaF(2) varnish (0.62 +/- 0.10/1.68 +/- 1.17), which in turn showed significantly less erosion than the placebo varnish (0.78 +/- 0.12/2.05 +/- 1.43), TiF(4) solution (0.86 +/- 0.11/ 2.05 +/- 1.49) and control (0.77 +/- 0.16/2.06 +/- 1.49). In conclusion, the TiF(4) varnish seems to be a promising treatment to reduce enamel loss under mild erosive conditions.     

The effect of ammonium fluoride solution at various concentrations on enamel

The fluoride concentrations of ammonium fluoride solution (NH4F,pH 4.4), which has the same effect on enamel powder as conventional APF solution, were studied. Human enamel powder (200 mesh passed) was treated with solutions of NH4F (1,000 ppmF-, 3,000 ppmF-, 5,000 ppmF-, 7,000 ppmF-, 9,000 ppmF-, pH 4.4) and APF (9,000 ppmF-, pH 3.4) for 5 min. at 37 degrees C. Some of the specimen was washed with 1MKOH solution for 48 hours. Fluoride uptake by enamel powder was analyzed by means of chemical analysis and reaction products identified using X-ray diffractometry. The fluoride uptake of 5,000 ppmF- of NH4F-treated enamel was the same as that of APF-treated enamel. X-ray diffractometry showed that CaF2 was formed in the experimental groups. CaF2 with high crystallinity was formed in the NH4F-treated enamel, and the peak height of X-ray diffraction pattern of CaF2 in 3,000 ppmF- of NH4F-treated enamel was the same as that of APF-treated enamel. In conclusion, the ammonium fluoride solution of 3,000-5,000 ppmF- had a similar effect on enamel powder as conventional APF solution.     

Fluoride varnish application: a new prophylactic method in Albania. Effect on enamel carious lesions in permanent dentition

AIM: The aim of this study is to assess the effects of fluoride varnishes on enamel caries lesions on permanent dentition. MATERIALS AND METHODS: 92 children from primary school (Vasil Shanto, Tirana, Albania) aged 11-12 years were divided into varnish (experimental) and control group. The experiment group received the first fluoride varnish application (Fluoridin, Voco) at baseline, the second application after 3 months and the third application at 6 months from baseline, while the children in the control group received no professional fluoride application. Examinations were performed at baseline and after 7 months. RESULTS: We observed a slight increase in caries prevalence in the control group compared with the varnish group at the 7 month interval (P <0.1 for DMFT and P <0.5 for DMFS and DS). When enamel lesions were included the mean of DeMFT, DeMFS, DeS the caries prevalence was significantly lower in the varnish group after 7 months (P <0.001 for DeMFT, DeMFS). CONCLUSION: Fluoride varnish is an effective mean for arresting early enamel lesions. It is a safe, convenient and well accepted method by patients.     

不同浓度的含氟涂料对人牙釉质抗酸性的影响

目的：确定4种浓度的含氟涂料对人牙釉质抗酸性的影响。方法：采用22000ppm,10000ppm,5000ppm及2200ppm等4种不同浓度的含氟涂料处理离体人牙釉质后经脱矿实验，然后测量酸蚀液中钙的溶出量，并用激光荧光诊断仪对人工龋损进行定量诊断。结果：22000ppm组与10000ppm组的抗酸性无差别，而其余各组之间均有差别。结论：22000ppm及10000ppm的含氟涂料抑制牙釉质脱矿的效果比5000ppm及2200mmp的含氟涂料好，而将22000ppm的含氟涂料浓度降至10000ppm，并不影响它的防龋效果，因此，在临床应用时，可以考虑适应降低含氟涂氟浓度以提高安全性。     

Effect of a combination of fluoride dentifrice and varnish on enamel surface rehardening and fluoride uptake in vitro

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of combining fluoride dentifrice (FD) and varnish (FV) on in vitro enamel surface rehardening and on fluoride uptake under a pH-cycling regimen. Seventy-eight bovine enamel blocks with early lesions were used and 52 were divided into four treatment groups: (a) placebo non-fluoridated dentifrice (PD); (b); FD (1100 p.p.m. F as NaF); (c); FV (Duraphat) + PD; and (d) FV + FD. The FV was applied to enamel blocks of groups FV + PD and FV + FD before the pH-cycling regimen, and all of them were submitted to dentifrice during cycling. Surface enamel microhardness was determined on the dental blocks before and after demineralization, and after the pH-cycling regimen. The percentage of surface microhardness recovery (%SMHR) was calculated. Fluoride in the blocks was also determined, after removing three layers of enamel. The highest values of percentage SMHR were observed for the FD group. The greatest fluoride uptake was found in the FD and FV + FD groups, but the difference between them was not statistically significant. It was found that the frequent use of fluoride dentifrice resulted in greater benefit in enamel surface rehardening, with a similar effect on fluoride uptake, when compared with its combination with a single fluoride varnish application.     

Fluoride concentration in plaque in adolescents after topical application of different fluoride varnishes

The aim of the study was to measure the fluoride (F) concentration in plaque after a single topical application of different fluoride varnishes with contrasting levels of F. Thirty adolescents (12–17 years) with fixed orthodontic appliances were randomly assigned to one of three groups: Bifluoride (6% F), Duraphat (2.23% F) and Fluor Protector (0.1% F). The varnishes were applied after professional cleaning in one upper quadrant, leaving the opposite quadrant untreated according to the split-mouth technique. Pooled plaque samples from each quadrant were collected at baseline and 3 days, 7 days and 30 days after the varnish treatment, and fluoride was analysed by microdiffusion. All fluoride varnishes increased the fluoride concentration in plaque compared with baseline, and the mean values varied between 23 and 138 ng F/mg after 3 days, depending on varnish F concentration. Compared with the control quadrant, statistically significant elevations were recorded for Bifluoride after 3 days and 7 days and Duraphat after 3 days, while no significant differences were revealed in the Fluor Protector group. The fluoride concentration in plaque was back to baseline levels for all participants in the Duraphat group after 7 days, while some individuals in the Bifluoride and Fluor Protector groups still registered slightly increased levels after 30 days. The results suggest that fluoride varnish treatments resulted in elevated fluoride levels in plaque adjacent to fixed orthodontic appliances for a period of up to 1 week, although different patterns was disclosed for the various brands. Received: 5 October 1999 / Accepted: 18 November 1999     

Efficacy of TiF4 and NaF varnish and solution: a randomized in situ study on enamel erosive–abrasive wear

Objectives

This in situ/ex vivo study analysed the anti-erosive/abrasive effect of TiF₄ and NaF varnish and solution on enamel wear.

Materials and methods

Twelve subjects took part in this study which was performed in three periods (phases) with the duration of 5 days each. Each two human enamel specimens per subject were pretreated with experimental NaF varnish or solution (phase A), experimental-TiF₄ varnish or solution (phase B) and placebo varnish or untreated control (phase C). The specimens were worn in palatal appliances; one enamel specimen, from each treatment, was subjected to erosion (ERO; cola soft drink, 4?×?90 s/day), and the other specimen was subjected to erosion plus abrasion (ERO + ABR; tooth brushing, 2?×?10 s/day). The tooth wear was quantified by a contact profilometer (micrometre) and analysed using two-way repeated measures ANOVA and Bonferroni’s test (n?=?12 subjects, p?<?0.05).

Results

All fluoride varnishes and solutions reduced the enamel wear (around 25 %) significantly compared to the control and placebo varnish. There were no significant differences among the fluoride formulations and between the conditions ERO and ERO + ABR.

Conclusions

Therefore, it can be concluded that TiF₄ has the same protective potential as NaF formulations to reduce human enamel wear under this experimental in situ model.

Clinical significance

In vitro studies have indicated a better anti-erosive/abrasive effect of TiF₄ compared to NaF varnish. The present in situ study does not support the previous findings. Therefore, any of the tested professional fluoride varnishes in principle could be able to partially reduce enamel wear.     

Fluoride varnishes containing sodium trimetaphosphate reduce enamel demineralization in vitro

Objective: This study evaluated the effects of fluoride varnishes containing sodium trimetaphosphate (TMP) on bovine enamel demineralization in vitro.

Material and methods: Enamel bovine discs were randomly assigned into six groups (n?=?20/group): placebo, 2.5% NaF, 2.5% NaF/5% TMP, 5% NaF, 5% NaF/5% TMP, and a commercial formulation (Duraphat, 5% NaF). Varnishes were applied on all enamel discs and kept for 6?h. Loosely and firmly bound fluoride formed on/in enamel after treatment were analyzed in 10 discs from each group. The other 10 discs were subjected to a pH-cycling regimen for 7 days, and analyzed for surface (SH) and cross-sectional hardness (ΔKHN), as well as for loosely and firmly bound fluoride in/on enamel. Data were analyzed by analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by Student–Newman–Keuls’ test (p?Results: The lowest SH change and ΔKHN were observed for the 5%NaF/5%TMP varnish, which was significantly different from all the other groups. Both fluoridated varnishes containing TMP promoted significantly lower SH change and ΔKHN when compared with their counterparts without TMP. Loosely and firmly bound fluoride was significantly lower in groups treated with varnishes containing TMP.

Conclusion: TMP and fluoride added to varnishes have a synergistic effect against enamel demineralization in vitro.