Clinical predictors of suicidal acts after major depression in bipolar disorder: a prospective study

Objective:  This study determined the clinical predictors of suicidal behavior during a 2-year follow-up of patients with bipolar disorder presenting with a major depressive episode (MDE).
Method:  Sixty four patients with DSM-III-R bipolar disorder were assessed at presentation for treatment of an MDE. Correlates of past suicidal behavior were determined by comparing patients with and without a history of suicide attempts using a t -test, Wilcoxon test or chi-squared test of independence on individual explanatory variables. Putative predictors of attempts during the follow-up period were tested separately using Cox proportional hazards regression analysis.
Results:  Twelve of 64 patients had at least one suicide attempt in the follow-up period, five of them attempted in the first 2 months and seven around or shortly after the 1-year follow-up visit. All attempters had a history of past suicide attempts. Most predictors of future suicidal behavior were correlates of past suicidal behavior. Family history of suicide acts and comorbid borderline personality disorder predicted early attempts, while younger age, high hostility scores, number of past attempts, subjective pessimism as reflected in depression and suicidal ideation, and few reported reasons for living predicted suicidal acts during the whole period.
Conclusion:  In this data set of bipolar patients we noted an intriguing picture of two clusters of suicide attempts. Hostility was the strongest risk factor. These findings may have implications in both the identification of at-risk patients and the timing of clinical interventions including aggressive pharmacotherapeutic prophylaxis to prevent relapse or recurrence of depressive symptomatology.     

Adequacy of antidepressant treatment after discharge and the occurrence of suicidal acts in major depression: a prospective study

OBJECTIVE: Suicide attempts predict repeat attempts and suicide completion. Major depression requiring hospitalization is a risk factor for suicidal acts, particularly in the 2 years following discharge. The authors prospectively studied the adequacy of antidepressant treatment and its impact on suicidal acts in the 2 years after hospitalization for major depression. METHOD: Patients (N=136) with major depression were interviewed at 3 months, 1 year, and 2 years after admission. At each interview, the presence of major depression and suicidal acts and the adequacy of antidepressant treatment were assessed. Cox's proportional hazards analysis with time-varying covariates was used to model the risk of a suicide attempt during the follow-up period. RESULTS: Major depression in the follow-up period increased the risk of a suicide attempt sevenfold. For each suicide attempt in a subject's history, the risk for an attempt in the follow-up period increased by 30%. Antidepressant treatment during the follow-up period was mostly inadequate. Consequently, a relationship between adequacy of antidepressant treatment during follow-up and the risk of a suicide attempt could not be found. Furthermore, subjects with a history of a suicide attempt at baseline were not treated more vigorously than nonattempters. CONCLUSIONS: Antidepressant treatment of depressed patients is strikingly inadequate, even in suicide attempters, known to be at higher risk for suicidal acts. This deficiency undermines the ability to measure the antisuicidal effects of antidepressants in naturalistic studies. Controlled studies of antidepressants are needed to evaluate effects on suicidal acts.     

Prospective study of clinical predictors of suicidal acts after a major depressive episode in patients with major depressive disorder or bipolar disorder

OBJECTIVE: The authors investigated the predictive potential of a stress-diathesis model for suicidal behavior based on correlates of past suicidal acts. In this model, suicidal acts are precipitated by stressors such as life events or a major depressive episode in the setting of a propensity for acting on suicidal urges. This diathesis is expressed as the tendency to develop more pessimism in response to a stressor and/or the presence of aggressive/impulsive traits. The predictive potential of the diathesis was tested by determining whether clinical correlates of past suicidal behavior predict suicidal acts during a 2-year follow-up of patients with a major depressive episode. METHOD: Patients with DSM-III-R major depressive disorder or bipolar disorder (N=308) were assessed at presentation for treatment of a major depressive episode. Potential predictors of suicidal acts in the 2 years after study enrollment were identified on the basis of an association with previous suicidal behavior and were tested by using Cox proportional hazards regression analysis. In addition, pessimism and aggression/impulsivity factors were generated, and their predictive ability was tested by using Cox proportional hazards regression analysis. RESULTS: The three most powerful predictors of future suicidal acts were a history of suicide attempt, subjective rating of the severity of depression, and cigarette smoking, each of which had an additive effect on future risk. The pessimism and aggression/impulsivity factors both predicted suicidal acts, and each factor showed an additive effect. CONCLUSIONS: In addition to obtaining a history of suicidal behavior, clinicians may find it useful to assess patients' current level of pessimism, aggressive/impulsive traits, and comorbidity with substance use disorders, including nicotine-related disorders, to help identify patients at risk for suicidal behavior after major depression. Interventions such as aggressive pharmacotherapeutic prophylaxis to prevent relapse or recurrence of depressive symptoms may protect such at-risk individuals from future suicidal behavior.     

Protective factors against suicidal acts in major depression: reasons for living

OBJECTIVE: Over 30,000 people a year commit suicide in the United States. Prior attempted suicide and hopelessness are the most powerful clinical predictors of future completed suicide. The authors hypothesized that "reasons for living" might protect or restrain patients with major depression from making a suicide attempt.METHOD: Inpatients with DSM-III-R major depression were assessed for depression, general psychopathology, suicide history, reasons for living, and hopelessness. Of the 84 patients, 45 had attempted suicide and 39 had not.RESULTS: The depressed patients who had not attempted suicide expressed more feelings of responsibility toward family, more fear of social disapproval, more moral objections to suicide, greater survival and coping skills, and a greater fear of suicide than the depressed patients who had attempted suicide. Scores for hopelessness, subjective depression, and suicidal ideation were significantly higher for the suicide attempters. Reasons for living correlated inversely with the combined score on these measures, considered an indicator of "clinical suicidality." Neither objective severity of depression nor quantity of recent life events differed between the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: During a depressive episode, the subjective perception of stressful life events may be more germane to suicidal expression than the objective quantity of such events. A more optimistic perceptual set, despite equivalent objective severity of depression, may modify hopelessness and may protect against suicidal behavior during periods of risk, such as major depression. Assessment of reasons for living should be included in the evaluation of suicidal patients.     

Sex differences in inpatients with major depression

To assess sex-related differences, 53 inpatients with major depression were evaluated with the Zung, Dempsey , and Hamilton depression scales, and part of the Beck scale. Women had more fitful sleep, easy crying, social withdrawal, agitation, somatic anxiety, gastrointestinal symptoms, genital symptoms, crying spells, constipation, and fast heartbeat. Men had more self-dislike and lack of clear mind. Differences in manifestations of major depression may account for misdiagnosis of female depressives as suffering from anxiety or functional insomnia and lead to treatment with anxiolytics rather than antidepressants. Self-dislike and mental clouding may lead male depressives to serious suicide attempts and work failures.     

Characterization of suicidal depression: A 1 year prospective study

BackgroundSuicidal ideation (SI) is an important risk factor of death by suicide. Recent data suggest that suicidal depression (i.e., moderate to severe depression with SI) could be a specific depression subtype with worse clinical outcomes than nonsuicidal depression (i.e., without SI).MethodsAmong 898 French adult inpatients (67% women, mean age: 41.23 [SD: 14.33]) with unipolar depression, 71.94% had moderate to severe depression (defined using the cut-offs of validated scales: beck depression inventory, clinician-rated 30-item inventory depression symptomatology, and quick inventory of depressive symptomatology) and among them, 63.6% had SI according to the suicidal item (score ≥ 2) of the depression scale they filled in. Clinical features (anxiety, psychological pain, and hopelessness) were assessed at baseline. The occurrence of a suicide attempt (SA) or a suicide event (SE) (i.e., actual, aborted or interrupted SA, or hospitalization for SI) was recorded during the 1-year follow-up. The risk of actual SA and SE was compared between groups with adjusted Cox regression models.ResultsThe risk of actual SA and SE during the follow-up was 2- and 1.8-fold higher, respectively, in patients with suicidal depression, independently of potential cofounders such as history of lifetime SA, age, sex, and baseline depression severity.ConclusionsSuicidal depression is associated with poorer prognosis in terms of actual SA/SE, despite optimal care (i.e., care in a hospital department specialized in the management of suicidal crisis). Specific therapeutic strategies might be needed for these patients.     

Instability of symptoms in recurrent major depression: a prospective study

OBJECTIVE: Recurrent episodes of major depressive disorder are reported to have similar or stable characteristics across episodes. However, symptoms appear to be moderately stable only in consecutive depressive episodes or if episode severity is considered. The authors prospectively studied major depressive episodes occurring within 2 years to determine whether symptoms in the second episode could be predicted on the basis of symptoms in the first. METHOD: Inpatients (N=78) with major depressive disorder were rated with the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale during two separate episodes. Patients had a baseline assessment at index hospitalization and follow-up visits at 3, 12, and 24 months after discharge. Information regarding the presence of a major depressive episode, its duration, and its severity was documented. Baseline and follow-up data were analyzed by using Pearson correlations with and without adjustments for severity of depression. RESULTS: Subtype of depression appeared not to be stable. The most robust, although still weak, correlations across episodes were for anxiety and suicidal behavior. Only modest correlations were identified for a few depressive symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: The lack of robust consistency of symptoms or depressive subtype across episodes is striking given the requirement of five of nine predetermined symptoms for depression, increasing the chances of finding an association. These findings suggest that there is a superfamily of mood disorders with pleomorphic manifestations across major depressive episodes within individual patients with unipolar depression.     

Sex differences in anxiety and depression clinical perspectives

Sex differences are prominent in mood and anxiety disorders and may provide a window into mechanisms of onset and maintenance of affective disturbances in both men and women. With the plethora of sex differences in brain structure, function, and stress responsivity, as well as differences in exposure to reproductive hormones, social expectations and experiences, the challenge is to understand which sex differences are relevant to affective illness. This review will focus on clinical aspects of sex differences in affective disorders including the emergence of sex differences across developmental stages and the impact of reproductive events. Biological, cultural, and experiential factors that may underlie sex differences in the phenomenology of mood and anxiety disorders are discussed.     

Sex differences in symptom patterns of recurrent major depression in siblings

The objectives of this study were to examine sex differences in depressive symptom patterns in 475 sib pairs with well-defined recurrent major depression and to test the hypotheses that (a) symptom patterns show higher intraclass correlations within same sex sib pairs versus mixed sex sib pairs; and (b) symptoms more associated with women, e.g. atypical depressive and anxiety symptoms, account for differences between male and female siblings within the same family. A total of 878 individuals, with a past history of at least two depressive episodes, were interviewed using the Schedules for Clinical Assessment in Neuropsychiatry interview and diagnosed according to DSM-IV using a computerized scoring program (CATEGO5). Intraclass correlations were compared between mixed and same sex sibs, and a conditional regression analysis in mixed sex sib pairs was performed to test whether specific symptoms account for differences between male and female siblings within the same family. Women showed a significantly earlier onset of depression compared with men (23.0 years, SD=10.6 versus 25.5, SD=12.5 years, P=0.0004), and a significantly greater frequency of several aspects of depressed mood was found in women compared with men, including atypical depressive features of fatiguability, appetite gain, weight gain and hypersomnia. Discordant sib-pair data analyses revealed five symptoms that accounted for the sex differences between siblings (P=.000035): phobia (exp(B)=2.04, P=0.017), hypersomnia (exp(B)=1.37, P=0.055), appetite loss (exp(B)=1.38, P=0.004) and appetite gain (exp(B)=2.19, P<0.001). Sex significantly modifies clinical features of depression and an earlier onset of depression and atypical depressive symptoms occur more frequently in women.     

对抑郁症患者自杀态度的研究

目的研究不同类别抑郁症患者对自杀的态度。方法应用自杀态度问卷（QSA）作为调查工具，测试不同抑郁症患者的自杀态度。结果不同抑郁症患者有不同自杀态度，有自杀念头并有过自杀行为者，对自杀行为持肯定、理解、宽容的态度，而有自杀念头但无自杀行为者对自杀行为持矛盾或中立的态度，在对自杀者、自杀者家属、安乐死方面两者无显著性差异，均持肯定、理解、认可、宽容的态度。无自杀念头、无自杀行为者对自杀行为持反对、否定、排斥态度，且对自杀者、自杀者家属、安乐死也持矛盾、中立或反对、否定、排斥态度。结论应用自杀态度问卷将抑郁症患者加以区分，对重点人群重点关注，在预防自杀方面做到有的放矢，可提高工作效率，节省人力、物力。     

Sex differences in diencephalon serotonin transporter availability in major depression.

BACKGROUND: Major depression is more prevalent in women than men. The present study evaluated if previous findings that demonstrated decreased 5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT) transporter availability in depressed patients would be confirmed in a larger sample and also evaluated sex differences. METHODS: Depressed (n = 32) and healthy subjects (n = 32), including 16 pairs of women and men, participated in an iodine-123-2 beta-carbomethoxy-3beta-(4-iodophenyltropane) ([(123)I]beta-CIT) single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) and a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan. Participants were administered [(123)I]beta-CIT (225.7 +/- 3.7 MBq) and imaged 23.0 +/- 1.6 hours later. Statistical analyses included analysis of variance and a regression analysis of the main and interactive effects of age, sex, and depression. RESULTS: Overall, depressed patients demonstrated 12% lower diencephalon and no change in striatal or brainstem [(123)I]beta-CIT uptake. Significant age by sex, sex by depression, and age by sex by depression interactions were noted due to 22% lower diencephalon [(123)I]beta-CIT uptake in depressed women compared with less than a 1% decrease in depressed men. CONCLUSIONS: As observed previously, diencephalon 5-HT transporter availability is decreased in depressed patients. However, the decrease appears to be sex-specific and age-dependent. These findings suggest that serotonergic mechanisms mediating depressed mood differ between men and women in an age-dependent manner and may explain why young women respond better to treatment with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) antidepressants.     

Sex differences in predictors of illness intrusiveness 1 year after a cardiac event

OBJECTIVE: This prospective study examined sex differences in illness intrusiveness and in baseline predictors of illness intrusiveness in cardiac patients' 1-year postcardiac event. METHODS: Patients diagnosed with a myocardial infarction (MI) or unstable angina (UA) completed a baseline questionnaire during their hospitalization (139 men and 104 women). Eighty-one men and 67 women completed the follow-up questionnaire 1-year postcardiac event. The questionnaire included measures of illness intrusiveness in three life domains, depressive symptomatology, social support, medical information, risk factors for heart disease, and sociodemographic information. RESULTS: A MANCOVA with the three Illness Intrusiveness subscales as dependent variables, sex as the between-group factor, and partnership status as a covariate found a sex effect for the Intimacy subscale, but not for the Instrumental and the Relationships/Personal Development subscales. Men reported more intrusiveness in the Intimacy domain of their life as compared to women. After controlling for sociodemographic factors and risk factors for heart disease, hierarchical regressions indicated sex differences in baseline predictors of 1-year follow-up illness intrusiveness in the three life domains. For men, being satisfied with support from partner at baseline was associated with less intrusiveness in the Instrumental Life domain 1 year after the cardiac event. For women, surprisingly, more satisfaction with support from their partner at baseline was associated with more intrusiveness in their intimate lives 1 year after their cardiac event. In addition, emotional symptoms of depression at baseline were predictive of increased illness intrusiveness in Relationship/Personal Development and Intimacy domains for men and in Instrumental and Intimacy domains for women. CONCLUSION: Support from partner may have a differential impact for men and women after a cardiac event. Depressive symptomatology during initial hospitalization, particularly emotional symptoms, is a prominent indicator of illness intrusiveness for both sexes 1 year after the cardiac event.     

The risk of minor depression in families of probands with major depression: Sex differences and familiality

Summary Currently it is not clear whether minor forms of unipolar depression not matching the criteria of major depression should be considered as a separate diagnostic category. A controlled family study examined the familial aggregation of minor depression among probands with unipolar major depression. In the families of these probands the relative risk for minor depression was elevated by a similar magnitude to the risk for major depression. Threrefore, the diagnostic category minor depression would not increase diagnostic sensitivity at the expense of diagnostic specificity as far as familiality is the criterion. In agreement with recent epidemiological studies, minor depression did not reveal a similar excess prevalence in females compared with males as major depression does. The variation of the sex ratio for any subtype of unipolar depression was not associated with the familiality of this disorder.     

抑郁症自杀行为遗传流行病学对照研究

目的　探讨遗传因素在抑郁症自杀行为中的作用。方法　采用病例对照研究方法对 10 3例抑郁症自杀行为先证者和 10 3例对照的亲属资料进行遗传流行病学研究。结果　 2 4 2 7%的先证者的Ⅰ级亲属有自杀行为 ;Ⅰ级亲属、Ⅱ级亲属发生率依次为 4 5 6 %、1 6 0 % ,显著高于对照组Ⅰ级亲属发生率 0 2 6 4 % (P <0 0 1) ,其OR值及95 %可信区间分别为 18 0 7(4 33～ 75 4 0 )、6 16 (1 4 3～ 2 6 6 3) ,且Ⅰ级亲属自杀行为发生率 >Ⅱ级亲属 >Ⅲ级亲属>群体自杀行为发生率。采用Li mantel Gart法得分离比及 95 %可信区间为 0 12 88(0 0 991～ 0 15 85 )。多基因阈值模型估计 ,抑郁症自杀行为先证者Ⅰ、Ⅱ、Ⅲ级亲属的遗传度分别为 71 5 2± 11 0 2 %、4 1 92± 11 81%、31 0 9±13 2 9% ,三者加权平均遗传度为 4 9 38± 3 99%。结论　抑郁症自杀行为具有多基因遗传的特点 ,遗传因素在决定抑郁症自杀行为的易患性上起到重要的作用。     

Sex differences in the relationship between social support and risk for major depression: a longitudinal study of opposite-sex twin pairs

OBJECTIVE: Compared to men, women have larger and more intimate social networks and higher rates of major depression. Prior studies have suggested that women are more sensitive to the depressogenic effects of low social support, but most of these studies had substantial methodologic limitations. METHOD: In two interview waves at least 1 year apart, 1,057 pairs of opposite-sex dizygotic twin pairs ascertained from a population-based register were assessed. The authors predicted risk of major depression in the year before the wave 2 interview from levels of social support assessed at wave 1. RESULTS: Women reported higher levels of global social support than their twin brothers. Global social support at wave 1 predicted risk for major depression at wave 2 significantly more strongly in female than in male members of these pairs, and the same effect was seen when the analysis controlled for the history of major depression in the year prior to wave 1. Women were more sensitive than men to the depressogenic effects of low levels of social support, particularly from the co-twin, other relatives, parents, and spouses. Levels of social support did not explain the sex difference in risk for major depression. CONCLUSIONS: Emotionally supportive social relationships are substantially more protective against major depression for women than for men. While these effects cannot explain sex effects on the prevalence of major depression, they do suggest important sex differences in pathways of risk. Clarification of the nature of the causal links between low social support and depression in women is needed.     

Factors associated with outcome in major depression: a 6-month prospective study

A number of authors have indicated in recent years that the course of depression is not as favourable as previously expected. Research conducted in order to identify predictors of recovery has shown widely different results. In this paper a sample of 90 consecutive patients with non-chronic major depressive disorders (index episode <6 months) attending four mental health centres in Madrid were followed up prospectively for 6 months, and clinical social and cognitive variables were studied. The patients were treated pharmacologically and controlled. The rate of recovery was measured according to the Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression (HAM-D). Other tools used were: Life Events and Chronic Difficulties, Global Assessment Functioning in the 6 months prior to the onset of episode, Brown Rating Scale for Self-Esteem and Mannheim Interview of Social Support. The results showed that 41 cases recovered (HAM-D score <8), 29 cases achieved a partial remission, and major depressive disorder persisted in 17 cases (HAM-D score ≥18). The presence of personality disorders, having suffered a previous episode, GAF score and some aspects of social support were the variables most associated with non full remission in the logistic regression analysis. Personality disorders and the initial HAM-D score were related to non-improvement. Some clinical and cognitive variables maintain a weak relation to outcome and are rejected in logistic regression. This study emphasizes the relationship of personality, and social variables such as social support and previous global functioning, with incomplete recovery in major depression. Accepted: 11 May 1998     

Partial remission in major depression: a two-phase, 12-month prospective study

We conducted an interview-based survey to predict the clinical course of major depressive disorder during a follow-up period of 12 months. Altogether 86 patients were investigated. A SCID I interview for DSM-III-R axis-I diagnosis was conducted at baseline and a SCID II interview for personality disorders at the 6-month follow-up. Beck Depression Inventory scores indicated the level of depression and were compiled at baseline and at 6 and 12 months. A BDI score between 9 and 14 was considered to indicate partial remission, and score of 0-8 indicated remission. At the 6-month assessment 33% of the patients had remission, 20% were in partial remission, and 47% were in the depressive phase. Older age, personality disorder, and alexithymia were associated with poor response at 6 months. At 12 months 37% had remission, 28% were in partial remission, and 35% were still in the depressive phase. Treatment at the early stage should be effective enough to achieve remission. If the response is not satisfactory within 6 months, a renewed search should be conducted for factors hindering recovery. Comorbid personality disorder is the main factor predicting a poor short-term response in major depressive disorder.     

Sex differences in late-life depression

OBJECTIVE: The primary aim of this study was to assess sex differences in depression in later life. METHOD: In a random, age and sex-stratified community sample of 3056 older Dutch people (55 85 years) the prevalence, symptom-reporting and risk factors associated with depression in later life were studied. Depression was measured with the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression scale (CES-D). Bivariate, multivariate and factor analyses were used. RESULTS: Prevalence of depression in women was almost twice as high as in men. Controlling for age and competing risk factors reduced the relative risk for females with more than half. Symptom-patterns in men and women were very much alike. Sex differences in associations with risk factors were small, but exposure to these risk factors was considerably higher in females. CONCLUSION: Very little evidence for a typical 'female depression' was found. Female preponderance in depression was related to a greater exposure to risk factors.