Routine placement of subdural drain after burr hole evacuation of chronic and subacute subdural hematoma: a contrarian evidence based approach

The objective of this paper was to evaluate whether available evidence supporting placement of subdural drain placement after evacuation of chronic subdural haematoma (CSDH) is applicable to a cohort of patients managed by us. In this observational cohort study, clinical follow-up was obtained in 166 patients who underwent burr hole evacuation of CSDH without placement of subdural drain followed by 3 days of bed rest. The primary outcome studied was recurrence requiring reoperation. Factors predicting recurrence were also analysed. We compared the patient characteristics and management protocols in our cohort with that in reports supporting drain placement to determine whether such evidence is relevant to our patient group. The mean age of our patients was 58 ± 17 years (range, 1 to 89 years). Sixteen of the 166 (9.6%) patients presented with symptomatic recurrence. The median time to reoperation for recurrence (15 of 16 patients) after the primary procedure was 17 days (range, 2 to 68 days). Antiplatelet and anticoagulant therapy was the only factor that was significantly associated with recurrence (p = 0.01). There were no infective or non-infective complications in our patient cohort. Our patient cohort and outcomes differed from those reporting drain placements in the following parameters: they were a decade younger, all patients received bed rest for 3 days after surgery and the recurrence rate was similar to that reported in the drained groups but significantly less than that reported in the non-drained groups. Routine placement of drain following burr hole evacuation of CSDH should only be done after careful comparison of the patient cohort under consideration and those reporting superior outcomes with drains. Evidence-based medicine supports such an approach.     

A comparative study of the treatment of chronic subdural hematoma—burr hole drainage versus burr hole irrigation

BACKGROUND

Several surgical procedures have been reported for the treatment of chronic subdural hematoma. Whether irrigation is required is not clear. We compared the results of treatment of chronic subdural hematoma obtained with burr hole drainage and burr hole irrigation retrospectively.

METHODS

Forty patients with chronic subdural hematoma underwent surgery at our institution in the last 3 years. The first 20 patients were treated by burr hole irrigation (irrigation group), while the last 20 patients underwent burr hole drainage (drainage group). The rates of recurrence, changes in hematoma size, and number of days of postoperative hospitalization for the two groups were compared. No significant differences were found between the two groups in the presence of head injury, alcohol consumption, age, gender, or preoperative hematoma size.

RESULTS

Duration of postoperative hospitalization was 14.1 days in the drainage group and 25.5 days in the irrigation group. Recurrence was observed in 1 case (5%) in the drainage group, and in 5 cases (25%) in the irrigation group. In the drainage group, postoperative hematoma size was significantly decreased compared to preoperative hematoma size on the first postoperative day, after which change in hematoma size was minimal. On the other hand, in the irrigation group, hematoma size was decreased on the first postoperative day, but not to a significant extent.

CONCLUSION

For treatment of chronic subdural hematoma, postoperative hospitalization was shorter and the recurrence was less frequent with drainage than with irrigation.     

A comparative study of the treatment of chronic subdural hematoma--burr hole drainage versus burr hole irrigation

BACKGROUND: Several surgical procedures have been reported for the treatment of chronic subdural hematoma. Whether irrigation is required is not clear. We compared the results of treatment of chronic subdural hematoma obtained with burr hole drainage and burr hole irrigation retrospectively. METHODS: Forty patients with chronic subdural hematoma underwent surgery at our institution in the last 3 years. The first 20 patients were treated by burr hole irrigation (irrigation group), while the last 20 patients underwent burr hole drainage (drainage group). The rates of recurrence, changes in hematoma size, and number of days of postoperative hospitalization for the two groups were compared. No significant differences were found between the two groups in the presence of head injury, alcohol consumption, age, gender, or preoperative hematoma size. RESULTS: Duration of postoperative hospitalization was 14.1 days in the drainage group and 25.5 days in the irrigation group. Recurrence was observed in 1 case (5%) in the drainage group, and in 5 cases (25%) in the irrigation group. In the drainage group, postoperative hematoma size was significantly decreased compared to preoperative hematoma size on the first postoperative day, after which change in hematoma size was minimal. On the other hand, in the irrigation group, hematoma size was decreased on the first postoperative day, but not to a significant extent. CONCLUSION: For treatment of chronic subdural hematoma, postoperative hospitalization was shorter and the recurrence was less frequent with drainage than with irrigation.     

氨甲环酸联合钻孔引流术治疗慢性硬膜下血肿

目的研究慢性硬膜下血肿钻孔引流术联合血肿腔内应用氨甲环酸对慢性硬膜下血肿(CSDH)术后复发率的影响。方法采用前瞻性随机对照研究,将本院近2年内慢性硬膜下血肿50例随机分为实验组和对照组,每组25例。实验组行钻孔引流术,同时血肿腔注入氨甲环酸治疗,对照组仅行钻孔引流术,其它常规治疗两组均相同。分别检测两组患者手术冲洗前后血肿液及手术后血肿腔引流液的D-二聚体,术后随访6个月,分析复发率。结果两组患者血肿液D-二聚体在术中冲洗前均高于正常,在术中冲洗后均降低,两组比较均无统计学差异(P>0.05)。术后2天,实验组血肿腔引流液D-二聚体显著低于对照组,统计有显著差异(P<0.05)。50例患者术后均全部治愈出院,实验组25例有2例复发,对照组有8例复发,实验组复发率显著低于对照组,统计有显著差异(P<0.05)。结论血肿腔局部纤溶功能亢进在慢性硬膜下血肿发病机制及复发中起重要作用,术中氨甲环酸在血肿腔内局部应用可抑制其纤溶功能亢进,显著降低术后血肿腔引流液D-二聚体浓度,从而显著降低慢性硬膜下血肿患者的术后复发率,值得临床推广应用。     

Remote cerebellar hemorrhage after single burr hole drainage of chronic subdural hematoma of the elderly

Remote cerebellar hemorrhage is a usual complication after supratentorial craniotomy. Especially, only several cases have been reported regarding the occurrence of remote cerebellar hemorrhage after burr hole drainage for the treatment of chronic subdural hematoma (CSDH). In this paper, we present an elder patient with this rare postoperative complication. A 73-year-old man presented with dysarthria and right hemiparesis. Computed tomography (CT) demonstrated a left chronic subdural hematoma. Hematoma drainage through a single burr hole was perfomed. About 3 hours after the surgery, the patient became restless and presented nausea and dizziness with a relatively large amount of drainage of hematoma. CT revealed resolution of the subdural hematoma and bilateral cerebellar hemorrhage appearing as "zebra sign". Magnetic resonance angiography and 3D-CT angiography showed the normal structure of posterior circulation in both the arterial and venous phases. The remote cerebellar hemorrhage was suspected to have happened as a result of overdrainage of hematoma. Finally, he was discharged without any neurological deficits. Although remote cerebellar hemorrhage after drainage through a burr hole for the treatment of chronic subdural hematoma is a rare complication, it is necessary to be aware of the possibility of such a complication after supratentorial surgery.     

Single burr hole irrigation without drainage in chronic subdural hematoma

The surgical treatment of chronic subdural hematoma has evolved from membranectomy through craniotomy to burr hole irrigation. The latter approach is based on utilization of the natural absorptive process that is thought to be part of the life cycle of the hematoma. To test this theory, the authors treated fifty-nine patients with chronic subdural hematoma according to the following protocol. Local anesthesia was induced with a modified neuroleptanalgesic procedure. A single burr hole was drilled, usually in the posterior frontal region, and irrigation was carried out until the washing was clear. Subdural drainage was not employed. Patients were permitted to walk about on the following day. The outcome was better than that achieved with conventional treatment. Such complications as tension pneumocephalus and intracranial hematoma were not observed, and only one patient (1.7%) had a recurrence. The results of this study indicate that single burr hole irrigation without drainage is a very simple and effective treatment for chronic subdural hematoma. The absence of subdural drainage may be an important feature, since drainage may contribute to the development of certain postoperative complications. Also, the simplified procedure allows patients early mobility, which may be of particular benefit to the elderly.     

Single burr hole surgery for acute spontaneous subdural hematoma in the aged: patient reports of three cases

The method of treatment for acute spontaneous subdural hematoma in aged patients is controversial. Three cases of acute spontaneous subdural hematoma in aged patients, treated by single burr hole drainage without irrigation, were reported. The first case, an 80-year-old male was admitted with complaints of headache and stupor without any history of head trauma. CT revealed a left subdural hematoma with mixed density. Intractable facial convulsion occurred three days after admission. Single burr hole drainage was performed to remove the hematoma, and facial convulsion disappeared one week after the surgery. The second case, a 70-year-old male was admitted with complaints of consciousness disturbance without any history of head trauma. CT showed a right subdural hematoma with mixed density. The next day, he recovered consciousness and CT demonstrated shrinkage of the hematoma. However, his consciousness deteriorated again 11 days after admission, and CT revealed progression of the hematoma. We performed single burr hole drainage, and the next day, his neurological condition recovered. The third case, an 84-year-old female was admitted with complaints of consciousness disturbance without any history of head trauma. CT revealed a left subdural hematoma with mixed density. Single burr hole drainage was performed to remove the hematoma. She recovered completely and was discharged and return home 1 month after the surgery. Single burr hole drainage is less invasive than craniotomy. Our three cases indicate that this method may be one of the best methods for aged patients with acute spontaneous subdural hematoma which manifests mixed density in CT.     

Surgical complications of chronic subdural haematoma: A 5‐year audit

Objective: To review the outcome of surgical treatment for chronic subdural haematoma (CSDH) at a local neurosurgical centre, with emphasis on major treatment‐related complications. Method: A total of 108 patients received operations for chronic subdural haematoma at the University of Hong Kong Medical Centre between January 1995 and December 1999. Medical records and imaging studies were studied retrospectively. Patients’ clinical features and treatment modalities were analysed and major postoperative complications, including mortality, haematoma recurrence, infection and epileptic seizure, were studied. Results: All 108 patients underwent burr hole craniostomy for the drainage of CSDH; one patient also underwent formal craniotomy. Recurrence occurred in six (5.5%) patients, seizure in two (1.8%) and intracranial infection in one (0.9%). There were four deaths, giving rise to a mortality of 3.7%. All four patients who died were elderly and had presented in an unconscious state and died subsequently of chest infection after surgery. Conclusion: Although surgical drainage of CSDH is often considered to be a straightforward, effective and safe procedure, it is not entirely without risks. The surgical outcome of the present series is in accordance with the current standard of neurosurgical care.     

Number of burr holes as independent predictor of postoperative recurrence in chronic subdural haematoma

Chronic subdural haematoma (cSDH) is one of the most frequent neurosurgical entities. Current treatment options include burr hole craniostomy, twist drill craniostomy or craniotomy. While burr hole craniostomy is the most often used technique, there are no studies analysing the use of one vs. two burr holes in respect to recurrence rates and complications. This retrospective study included 76 (age: 60 +/- 12 years) patients presenting with cSDH admitted in our institution from January 2004 to December 2005. A total of 21 (27%) patients underwent bilateral craniostomy. The patients were assessed using the Markwalder Scale (2 +/- 0.71), Glasgow Coma Scale (14 +/- 1) and measuring the haematoma thickness (1.8 +/- 0.7 cm). The decision to perform one or two burr hole was made according to the personal preference of the treating neurosurgeon. All patients underwent irrigation and placement of closed-system drainage. Out of the 97 haematoma, 63 (65%) haematomas were treated with two burr holes, whereas 34 (35%) were treated with one burr hole. Patients with one burr hole had a statistically significant (p < 0.05) higher recurrence rate (29 vs. 5%), longer average hospitalization length (11 vs. 9 days) and higher wound infection rate (9% vs. 0%). A multivariate regression analysis identified the number of holes as single predictor for postoperative recurrence rate (r(2) = 0.12; p < 0.001). In this study, the treatment of cSDH with one burr hole only is associated with a significantly higher postoperative recurrence rate, longer hospitalization length and higher wound infection rate.     

Life threatening hyponatraemia following evacuation of spontaneous chronic subdural haematoma

We report the case of a 43-year-old woman who developed life threatening hyponatraemia 4 days following burr hole drainage of a spontaneous chronic subdural haematoma (CSDH). Syndrome of inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hormone was confirmed. This is the first report of delayed life threatening hyponatraemia developing postoperatively in CSDH. The mechanism remains unclear but may involve brain shift on the pituitary stalk following subdural evacuation.     

Volume and densities of chronic subdural haematoma obtained from CT imaging as predictors of postoperative recurrence: a prospective study of 107 operated patients

Background

Chronic subdural haematoma (CSDH) is a common entity in neurosurgery with a considerable postoperative recurrence rate. Computerised tomography (CT) scanning remains the most important diagnostic test for this disorder. The aim of this study was to characterise the relationship between the recurrence of CSDH after treatment with burr-hole irrigation and closed-system drainage technique and CT scan features of these lesions to assess whether CT findings can be used to predict recurrence.

Methods

We investigated preoperative and postoperative CT scan features and recurrence rate of 107 consecutive adult surgical cases of CSDH and assessed any relationship with univariate and multivariate regression analyses.

Results

Seventeen patients (15.9 %) experienced recurrence of CSDH. The preoperative haematoma volume, the isodense, hyperdense, laminar and separated CT densities and the residual total haematoma cavity volume on the 1st postoperative day after removal of the drainage were identified as radiological predictors of recurrence. If the preoperative haematoma volume was under 115 ml and the residual total haematoma cavity volume postoperatively was under 80 ml, the probability of no recurrence was very high (94.4 % and 97.4 % respectively).

Conclusions

These findings from CT imaging may help to identify patients at risk for postoperative recurrence.     

脑膜中动脉栓塞治疗高危复发性慢性硬膜下血肿

目的 观察脑膜中动脉栓塞（MMAE）治疗高危复发性慢性硬膜下血肿（HR-CSDH）的有效性及安全性。方法 回顾性分析12例接受MMAE治疗的HR-CSDH患者,其中10例单侧CSDH、2例双侧CSDH,观察治疗效果及并发症。结果 5例首次诊断HR-CSDH患者于钻孔引流术后次日接受MMAE;4例首次诊断HR-CSDH但未达外科钻孔引流术指征者接受单纯MMAE;3例钻孔引流术后复发HR-CSDH患者中,1例于MMAE后次日接受再次钻孔引流术,2例接受单纯MMAE。MMAE中,共栓塞14支脑膜中动脉（MMA）,均栓塞成功。术后6个月内头部CT显示10例（11侧）CSDH血肿完全吸收,2例（3侧）CSDH血肿厚度缩小>50%,未见血肿增大进展者,均无需进一步外科处理。随访期间临床症状均有不同程度改善甚至消失,未见MMAE相关并发症。结论 MMAE治疗HR-CSDH安全、有效。     

Chronic subdural hematomas treated by burr hole craniotomy with continuous drainage

60 cases of chronic subdural hematoma (CSDH) are reported in this paper. 59 cases were treated through burr holes, irrigation and drainage and 57 cases were completely cured after operation. The cure rate is 95%. In this group only three cases died due to neurological condition in grade III-IV (Stupor and Coma). The external membrane of hematoma is very rich in neocapillary and deposit with hemosiderin and exudate by fresh red blood cell. These findings support that the enlargement of a CSDH are not caused by hyperosmotic fluid within the hematoma but by continuous bleeding from the neocapillary of its outer membrane. The result of this surgical treatment is satisfactory, the operative procedure is safe and easy to perform, and there are no severe operative complications or accidents.     

Strict Closed-System Drainage for Treating Chronic Subdural Haematoma

Summary. A comparative study chiefly of the recurrence rate of chronic subdural haematoma after two treatment modalities was conducted. Patients were divided into a burr hole strict closed-system drainage group (SCD group; n=56) and a burr hole closed-system drainage with irrigation group (CDI group; n=45). The burr hole strict closed-system drainage involved simply inserting a drainage tube into the haematoma cavity as quickly as possible after minimally incising the haematoma capsule. The introduction of air into the haematoma cavity was prevented, and irrigation was not performed. Symptoms in both groups disappeared soon after surgery, with no postoperative complications. Haematoma recurred in one patient (1.8%) of the SCD group compared with 5 (11.1%) of the CDI group. The rate of recurrence was significantly lower for the SCD than for the CDI group (p<0.05). In 4 of 5 recurrences in the CDI group, the volume of residual intracapsular air was sufficient after initial surgery. These results suggested that postoperative residual intracapsular air is a factor contributing to recurrence. Burr hole strict closed-system drainage is a simple, less invasive procedure with which to treat chronic subdural haematoma and the outcome is excellent. Furthermore, prevention of intracapsular air intrusion during surgery might help prevent recurrence.     

Prediction of in-hospital mortality and morbidity using high-sensitivity C-reactive protein after burr hole craniostomy

Background

The purpose of this study was to assess whether preanesthetic laboratory values can predict in-hospital mortality and morbidity in patients who have undergone burr hole craniostomy due to chronic subdural hematoma.

Methods

From January 2007 to February 2016, the records of 502 consecutive patients who underwent burr hole craniotomy were analyzed. All cases of burr hole craniostomy were fitted with a drain, as required by our institutional protocol.

Results

Patients’ demographic data and preoperative laboratory values were subjected to logistic regression analysis to predict in-hospital mortality and morbidity after burr hole craniostomy. Hemoglobin, prothrombin time, activated partial thromboplastin time, serum glucose, and high-sensitivity C-reactive protein (hsCRP) were found to be significantly associated with in-hospital mortality and morbidity by univariate regression analysis, but of these, only hsCRP (hazard ratio 1.210, 95 % confidence interval 1.089–1.345, P < 0.001) was found to significantly predict in-hospital mortality and morbidity by multivariate regression analysis. Areas under the curve for predicting in-hospital mortality and morbidity were 0.765 (95 % confidence interval 0.624–0.906, P = 0.002) and 0.646 (0.559–0.733, P = 0.001), respectively.

Conclusions

Preoperative hsCRP was found to be an independent predictor of in-hospital mortality and morbidity after burr hole craniostomy due to chronic subdural hematoma.

     

Recurrence of chronic subdural haematomata with and without post-operative drainage

Chronic subdural haematoma is a common disease causing morbidity and mortality. Recurrence after surgical treatment is common, varying from 5% to 30% of cases. Several methods for reducing recurrence have been advocated. The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of post-operative subdural drainage. Three hundred forty-four patients were included in a retrospective study. Treatment was performed by burr hole irrigation. Groups were separated into those with post-operative drainage compared to those without. Recurrence occurred in 14% in the drained group, significantly less than 26% in the undrained group (p=0.011). There were no differences in the complication rates. Post-operative drainage reduces recurrence of chronic subdural haematoma without increasing the complication rate. These results support those reported in several other studies. We recommend the use of post-operative subdural drainage.     

Emergency management of epidural haematoma through burr hole evacuation and drainage. A preliminary report

Summary Background. Blood clot evacuation through an osteoplastic craniotomy, a procedure requiring neurosurgical expertise and modern medical facilities, is the accepted method for treatment of a pure traumatic epidural haematoma following closed head injury. In certain emergency situations and/or in less sophisticated settings, however, use of this procedure may not be feasible. The present study was undertaken to ascertain whether placement of a burr hole and drainage under negative pressure constituted a rapid, effective and safe approach to manage patients with simple epidural haematomas. Methods. Thirteen patients suffering from a traumatic epidural haematoma were treated from January, 1999 to October, 2002. Twelve patients presented with skull fracture but no fracture was depressed. Placement of flexible tubes through a burr hole, followed by continuous suction under negative pressure, enabled aspiration of the clot and drainage of the cavity. In 8 cases, the procedure was performed under local anaesthesia with 2% Xylocaine™ and with intravenous sedation with propofol as needed. The operative procedure was accomplished within 30 min, and the drainage tube was left in place for 3–5 days. CT scans were performed daily from days 1 to 5. Results. In 11 of 13 cases, clots were evacuated successfully and patients regained consciousness within 2 hours. Recoveries occurred without significant sequelae. In the remaining 2 cases, the drainage tube was found to be obstructed by a blood clot such that the haematoma was unaffected. A traditional craniotomy was performed within 8–12 hours, and these 2 patients recovered consciousness within the subsequent 6 hours. Conclusion. Burr hole evacuation followed by drainage under negative pressure is a safe and effective method for emergency management of a pure traumatic epidural haematoma. To assure safety patients given this procedure should be monitored by daily CT scans. Decompressive craniotomy should be performed if consciousness does not improve within several hours.     

The experience of severe complication in the surgical treatment of chronic subdural hematoma: the usefulness of the burr hole and continuous closed system drainage

Seventy-four cases of chronic subdural hematoma were treated by burr hole with irrigation (31 cases), and burr hole and closed system drainage with slow decompression (43 cases). The postoperative changes of the clinical symptoms and CT findings in both groups were compared. Markwalder's clinical grading was used for evaluating the clinical symptoms. Preoperative grade distribution was as follows, 16 cases in grade 1, 12 cases in grade 2, 3 cases in grade 3 and no case in grade 4 in the irrigation group, and 22 cases in grade 1, 17 cases in grade 2, 3 cases in grade 3 and no case in grade 4 in the drainage group. There were two cases in the preoperative grade 2 which deteriorated after surgical decompression by burr hole with irrigation. One of them was considered due to brain swelling after abrupt decompression brought on by removal of the hematoma. This case was a 54-year-old male who lost consciousness during operation because of acute brain swelling. Severe neurological deficit such as speech disturbance and gait disturbance remained with him even three years after the operation. No case deteriorated in the drainage group. The postoperative improvement of the midline shift seen by CT scanning was of the same degree in both groups. Air accumulation in the subdural space was found in the irrigation group in all cases. However, it was found in only 5 cases in the drainage group. This study and available literature suggested that slow decompression should be carried out for all cases of chronic subdural hematoma, and we presented a closed system drainage as an example method.     

Continuous subgaleal suction drainage for the treatment of chronic subdural haematoma

Summary Background. Chronic subdural haematoma is one of the most common entities encountered in daily practice. Many methods of treatment have been reported, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. Method. The authors present a novel technique for the management of chronic subdural haematoma which is a variation of a closed drainage system. After evacuation of the haematoma through a single burr hole, we inserted a Jackson Pratt drain into the subgaleal space, with suction facing the burr hole, allowing for continuous drainage of the remaining haematoma. Findings. We used the method for over 4 years to treat 224 patients. Seventeen patients (7.6%) needed a second operation for a recurrence of the haematoma no patient required a third operation. Postoperative complications developed in 3 patients. Two patients died while in the hospital, a mortality rate of 0.9%. Conclusions. The use of suction assisted evacuation, is followed by results that compare satisfactorily to reports of previous methods, with a low rate of recurrence and complications. It is relatively less invasive and can be used in high risk patients.     

Single burr hole evacuation for traumatic acute subdural hematoma of the posterior fossa in the emergency room

A 57-year-old man and a 55-year-old man presented with acute subdural hematoma of the posterior cranial fossa due to trauma. Both were comatose preoperatively. Emergent single burr hole evacuation in the posterior cranial fossa was performed in the emergency room immediately after computed tomography. Neurological symptoms improved dramatically just after initiating the burr hole evacuation in both patients. A 57-year-old man became alert and could walk unassisted 1 month after surgery. The other could walk with assistance 4 months after surgery, although psychic disturbance resulting from cerebral contusion remained. Single burr hole evacuation in the emergency room is a useful treatment for acute subdural hematoma of the posterior cranial fossa because the procedure can be performed easily and rapidly, thus achieving reduction of intracranial pressure. Progressing neurological deterioration, reversibility of brainstem function by mannitol administration and the sign of brainstem compression and noncommunicating hydrocephalus are good indicators for this treatment.