recA protein-catalyzed strand assimilation: stimulation by Escherichia coli single-stranded DNA-binding protein.

The single-stranded DNA-binding protein of Escherichia coli significantly alters the strand assimilation reaction catalyzed by recA protein [McEntee, K., Weinstock, G. M. & Lehman, I. R. (1979) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 76, 2615--2619]. The binding protein (i) increases the rate and extent of strand assimilation into homologous duplex DNA, (ii) enhances the formation of a complex between recA protein and duplex DNA in the presence of homologous or heterologous single-stranded DNA, (iii) reduces the rate and extent of ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by recA protein in the presence of single-stranded DNA, (iv) reduces the high concentration of recA protein required for strand assimilation, and (v) permits detection of strand assimilation in the presence of the ATP analog, adenosine 5'-O-(O-thiotriphosphate). Single-stranded DNA-binding protein purified from a binding protein mutant (lexC) is considerably less effective than wild-type binding protein in stimulating strand assimilation, a result which suggests that single-stranded DNA-binding protein participates in general recombination in vivo.     

Polar branch migration promoted by recA protein: effect of mismatched base pairs.

Escherichia coli recA protein makes joint molecules from single-stranded circular phage DNA (viral or plus strand) and homologous linear duplex DNA by a polar reaction that displaces the 5' end of the plus strand from the duplex molecule [Kahn, R., Cunningham, R. P., DasGupta, C. & Radding, C. M. (1981) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 78, 4786-4790]. Growth of the heteroduplex joint, which results from strand exchange or branch migration, stopped at the borders of regions of nonhomologous DNA that were variously located 145, 630, or 1202 nucleotides from the end. Accumulation of migrating branches at heterologous borders demonstrates that their migration is not the result of random diffusion but is actively driven by recA protein. Growth of the heteroduplex joint was blocked even when a heterologous insertion was located in the single-stranded DNA, a case in which the flexible single-stranded region might conceivably fold out of the way under some condition. The recA protein did not make joint molecules from phage phi X174 and G4DNAs, which are 70% homologous, but did join phage fd and M13DNAs, which are 97% homologous. In the latter case, heteroduplex joints extended through regions containing isolated mismatched base pairs but stopped in a region where the fd and M13 sequences differ by an average of 1 base pair in 10. These results suggest that in genetic recombination the discrimination of perfect or near-perfect homology from a high degree of relatedness may be attributable in part to the mechanism by which recA protein promotes strand transfer.     

Isolation and visualization of active presynaptic filaments of recA protein and single-stranded DNA.

In the presence of ATP, recA protein forms a presynaptic complex with single-stranded DNA that is an obligatory intermediate in homologous pairing. Presynaptic complexes of recA protein and circular single strands that are active in forming joint molecules can be isolated by gel filtration. These isolated active complexes are nucleoprotein filaments with the following characteristics: (i) a contour length that is at least 1.5 times that of the corresponding duplex DNA molecule, (ii) an ordered structure visualized by negative staining as a striated filament with a repeat distance of 9.0 nm and a width of 9.3 nm, (iii) approximately 8 molecules of recA protein and 20 nucleotide residues per striation. The widened spacing between bases in the nucleoprotein filament means that the initial matching of complementary sequences must involve intertwining of the filament and duplex DNA, unwinding of the latter, or some combination of both to equalize the spacing between nascent base pairs. These experiments support the concept that recA protein first forms a filament with single-stranded DNA, which in turn binds to duplex DNA to mediate both homologous pairing and subsequent strand exchange.     

recA protein promotes homologous-pairing and strand-exchange reactions between duplex DNA molecules.

Purified recA protein, product of the recA+ gene, promotes homologous pairing between intact covalent circular duplex DNA and circular single-stranded DNA carrying a short hybridized fragment [West, S. C., Cassuto, E. & Howard-Flanders, P. (1981) Nature (London) 290, 29-33.]. In this paper we investigate the interaction of duplex fragments with circular single-stranded DNA carrying the hybridized fragment and find that recA protein promotes an efficient strand-exchange reaction between interacting DNA molecules. The exchange is dependent upon linear duplex DNA fragments that are homologous to, but extend beyond, the short fragment present on the hybridized DNA substrate. The reactions require stoichiometric amounts of recA protein and the presence of ATP.     

recA protein of Escherichia coli promotes branch migration, a kinetically distinct phase of DNA strand exchange.

The recA protein of Escherichia coli promotes the complete exchange of strands between full-length linear duplex and single-stranded circular DNA molecules of bacteriophage phi X-174, converting more than 50% of the single-stranded DNA into heteroduplex replicative form II-like structures. Kinetically, the reaction can be divided into two phases, formation of short heteroduplex regions (D loops) and extension of the D loops via branch migration. recA protein participates directly in both phases. D loops are formed efficiently in the presence of ATP or the nonhydrolyzable ATP analog adenosine 5'-[gamma-thio]triphosphate, whereas D-loop extension requires continuous ATP hydrolysis. Complete strand exchange requires a stoichiometric amount of recA protein and is strongly stimulated by the single-stranded-DNA-binding protein of E. coli.     

Polarity of heteroduplex formation promoted by Escherichia coli recA protein.

When recA protein pairs circular single strands with linear duplex DNA, the circular strand displaces its homolog from only one end of the duplex molecule and rapidly creates heteroduplex joints that are thousands of base pairs long [DasGupta, C., Shibata, T., Cunningham, R. P. & Radding, C. M. (1980) Cell 22, 437-446]. To examine this apparently polar reaction, we prepared chimeric duplex fragments of DNA that had M13 nucleotide sequences at one end and G4 sequences at the other. Circular single strands homologous to M13 DNA paired with a chimeric fragment when M13 sequences were located at the 3' end of the complementary strand but did not pair when the M13 sequences were located at the 5' end. Likewise circular single-stranded G4 DNA paired with chimeric fragments only when G4 sequences were located at the 3' end of the complementary strand. To confirm these observations, we prepared fd DNA labeled only at the 5' or 3' end of the plus strand, and we examined the susceptibility of these labeled ends to digestion by exonucleases when joint molecules were formed. Eighty percent of the 5' label in joint molecules became sensitive to exonuclease VII. Displacement of that 5' end by recA protein was concerted because it did not occur in the absence of single-stranded DNA or in the presence of heterologous single strands. By contrast, only a small fraction of the 3' label became sensitive to exonuclease VII or exonuclease I. These observations show that recA protein forms heteroduplex joints in a concerted and polarized way.     

Heteroduplex formation by recA protein: polarity of strand exchanges.

Purified recA protein promotes strand exchanges between linear duplex DNA and homologous circular single-stranded phage phi X174 DNA that carries a short hybridized fragment [West, S. C., Cassuto, E. & Howard-Flanders, P. (1981) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 78, 2100-2104]. In this paper we investigate the mechanism of this strand exchange reaction. We show that recA protein initiates strand exchanges by pairing the free end of the duplex fragment with the single-stranded DNA. In addition, we find that strand exchanges are polar, stable heteroduplex molecules being formed by the directional transfer transfer of the (-) strands starting at 3' termini.     

Stable three-stranded DNA made by RecA protein.

When RecA protein, in the form of a nucleoprotein filament containing circular single-stranded DNA (plus strand only), reacts with homologous linear duplex DNA, a directional transfer ensues of a strand from the duplex DNA to the nucleoprotein filament, resulting in the displacement of the linear plus strand in the 5' to 3' direction. The initial homologous synapsis, however, can occur at either end of the duplex DNA, or anywhere in between, and when homology is restricted to different regions of the duplex DNA, the joint molecules that form in each region show striking differences in stability upon deproteinization: distal joints greater than proximal joints much greater than medial joints. In the deproteinized distal joints, which are thermostable, 2000 nucleotide residues of the circular plus strand are resistant to P1 nuclease; both strands of the original duplex DNA remain resistant to P1 nuclease, and the potentially displaceable linear plus strand, which has a 3' homologous end, remains resistant to Escherichia coli exonuclease I. These observations suggest that RecA protein promotes homologous pairing and strand exchange via long three-stranded DNA intermediates and, moreover, that, once formed, such triplex structures in natural DNA are stable even when RecA protein has been removed.     

3'' homologous free ends are required for stable joint molecule formation by the RecA and single-stranded binding proteins of Escherichia coli.

The RecA protein of Escherichia coli is important for genetic recombination in vivo and can promote synapsis and strand exchange in vitro. The DNA pairing and strand exchange reactions have been well characterized in reactions with circular single strands and linear duplexes, but little is known about these two processes using substrates more characteristic of those likely to exist in the cell. Single-stranded linear DNAs were prepared by separating strands of duplex molecules or by cleaving single-stranded circles at a unique restriction site created by annealing a short defined oligonucleotide to the circle. Analysis by gel electrophoresis and electron microscopy revealed that, in the presence of RecA and single-stranded binding proteins, a free 3' homologous end is essential for stable joint molecule formation between linear single-stranded and circular duplex DNA.     

Recognition of duplex DNA containing single-stranded regions by recA protein.

Genetic recombination in Escherichia coli requires recA protein, the product of the recA+ gene. In this paper we show that purified recA protein, which binds strongly to denatured DNA, cooperatively recognizes DNA containing short single-stranded regions. The interaction of varying amounts of recA protein with DNA molecules was investigated by measuring its DNA-dependent ATPase activity. In 3mM Mg2+, the ATPase activity was stimulated by excess single-stranded DNA and was minimal with either intact circular or blunt-ended linear duplexes. Single-strand gaps of about 30 nucleotides were sufficient to increase the ATPase activity to a level almost as great as that observed with single-stranded DNA. Sedimentation studies at neutral pH showed cooperative binding of recA protein to single-stranded DNA or to duplex DNA containing single-stranded regions. In the presence of ATP, an intermediate rate of sedimentation was observed; in contrast, adenosine 5'-gamma-thiotriphosphate (ATP[S]) caused the formation of fast-sedimenting DNA-protein complexes. Gapped plasmid DNA plus recA protein and ATP[S] formed large aggregates containing thousands of molecules. Complex formation and stimulation of the ATPase activity of recA protein with duplex DNA containing single-stranded regions indicates that recA protein may change the conformation of the normally duplex molecules to a conformation prepared for homologous pairing.     

Initiation of genetic recombination: homologous pairing between duplex DNA molecules promoted by recA protein.

recA protein has been shown to promote hydrogen bonding between single-stranded DNA fragments and duplex DNA molecules homologous to them. However, genetic and biochemical evidence indicates that genetic exchanges generally take place between duplex molecules. We therefore chose to study the interactions promoted by recA protein between intact duplex DNA molecules and molecules containing gaps that are believed to increase the frequency of genetic exchanges. In the present paper, we show that incubation of intact and gap-containing plasmid DNA in the presence of recA protein leads to homologous pairing between duplex molecules which can be detected by centrifugation analysis and electron microscopy. The reaction is completely dependent on an active recA gene product, on genetic homology between the DNA species involved, and on the presence of ATP; under certain conditions, its efficiency can be increased considerably by the presence of the single-stranded DNA binding protein of Escherichia coli.     

Enzyme-catalyzed DNA unwinding: Studies on Escherichia coli rep protein

Replication in vitro of the replicative form (RF) I DNA of bacteriophage varphiX174 requires the phage-induced cistron A (cisA) protein, the host rep protein, DNA-binding protein, ATP, and DNA polymerase III plus replication factors. The rep protein is a single-stranded DNA-dependent ATPase. In this paper we show that varphiX174 RF I DNA cut by the cisA protein acts as a duplex DNA cofactor for the rep protein ATPase activity, provided that DNA-binding protein is present. In this latter reaction the duplex DNA is unwound by the rep protein with concomitant hydrolysis of ATP. The extents of ATP hydrolysis, DNA unwinding, and, where appropriate, DNA synthesis are proportional to the amounts of DNA-binding protein present. Two ATP molecules are hydrolyzed per base pair unwound. We propose that the obligatory requirement for the cisA protein in the unwinding of varphiX174 RF I DNA is not simply due to its endonuclease activity but rather is due to its provision of a site for the binding of the rep protein. The rep protein in the presence of DNA-binding protein, but in the absence of cisA protein, unwinds duplex DNA when one strand extends to generate a single-stranded leader region preceding the duplex. We show that rep protein translocates along the leader single strand in a 5'-to-3' direction only and then invades the duplex DNA. The rep protein shows a directional specificity for translocation and unwinding. A model is presented to explain the mechanism of DNA unwinding catalyzed by the rep protein.     

The 2B domain of the Escherichia coli Rep protein is not required for DNA helicase activity

The Escherichia coli Rep protein is a 3' to 5' SF1 DNA helicase required for replication of bacteriophage phiX174 in E. coli, and is structurally homologous to the E. coli UvrD helicase and the Bacillus stearothermophilus PcrA helicase. Previous crystallographic studies of Rep protein bound to single-stranded DNA revealed that it can undergo a large conformational change consisting of an approximately 130 degrees rotation of its 2B subdomain about a hinge region connected to the 2A subdomain. Based on crystallographic studies of PcrA, its 2B subdomain has been proposed to form part of its duplex DNA binding site and to play a role in duplex destabilization. To test the role of the 2B subdomain in Rep-catalyzed duplex DNA unwinding, we have deleted its 2B subdomain, replacing it with three glycines, to form the RepDelta2B protein. This RepDelta2B protein can support phiX174 replication in a rep(-) E. coli strain, although the growth rate of E. coli containing the repDelta2B gene is approximately 1.5-fold slower than with the wild-type rep gene. Pre-steady-state, single-turnover DNA unwinding kinetics experiments show that purified RepDelta2B protein has DNA helicase activity in vitro and unwinds an 18-bp DNA duplex with rates at least as fast as wild-type Rep, and with higher extents of unwinding and higher affinity for the DNA substrate. These studies show that the 2B domain of Rep is not required for DNA helicase activity in vivo or in vitro, and that it does not facilitate DNA unwinding in vitro.     

Resolution of an early RecA-recombination intermediate by a junction-specific endonuclease

The nucleoprotein filament formed on a circular single strand by Escherichia coli RecA protein in vitro can pair with homologous duplex DNA even when the latter lacks a free homologous end, but subsequent progression of the reaction through strand exchange requires an end in at least one strand of the duplex DNA. We purified from E. coli an endonuclease activity that cleaves the outgoing strand of duplex DNA at the junction of homologous and heterologous sequences in three-stranded RecA-recombination intermediates. This endonuclease activity also cleaves specifically at the junctions of duplex and single-stranded regions in synthetic double-stranded oligonucleotides whose central portion consists of unpaired heterologous sequences. These activities are consistent with a role in recombination and repair of DNA.     

Strand specificity of DNA unwinding by RecBCD enzyme.

RecBCD enzyme (exonuclease V) of Escherichia coli unwinds DNA, frequently forming asymmetric structures with two single-stranded tails of unequal length abutting a single-stranded loop at the junction with double-stranded DNA. Their lengths are consistent with the longer tail being one strand of the duplex and the loop plus the shorter tail being the other strand. The strand polarity of the unwinding was determined by labeling the 3' or 5' ends of duplex DNA with biotinylated nucleotides, reacting the DNA with RecBCD enzyme, and distinguishing the labeled ends, in the electron microscope, by their binding to streptavidin-gold complex. The shorter tail was formed from the DNA strand with its 3' terminus at the duplex end where RecBCD enzyme entered. We conclude that RecBCD enzyme unwinds DNA by forming a loop on the strand with a 3' end at the entry point. This result is concordant with a previously proposed model of recombination, which we discuss.     

Recombinational bypass of pyrimidine dimers promoted by the recA protein of Escherichia coli.

recA protein, in the presence of single-stranded DNA binding protein and ATP, promotes the complete exchange of strands between circular single-stranded DNA containing pyrimidine dimers and a homologous linear duplex, converting the pyrimidine dimer-containing single-stranded DNA to a circular duplex. Bypass of a pyrimidine dimer during the branch-migration phase of the reaction requires approximately 20 seconds, a rate 1/50th of that in the absence of the dimer. The circular duplex product is specifically incised by the pyrimidine dimer-specific T4 endonuclease V, and the resulting 3' hydroxyl termini can serve as primers for deoxynucleotide polymerization by DNA polymerase I. These findings indicate that recA protein serves a direct role in recombinational repair and demonstrate that the pyrimidine dimers that have been bypassed can be processed by enzymes of the excision-repair pathway.     

A mechanism of duplex DNA replication revealed by enzymatic studies of phage phi X174: catalytic strand separation in advance of replication.

The enzyme system for duplicating the duplex, circular DNA of phage phi X174 (replicative form) in stage II of the replicative life cycle was shown to proceed in two steps: synthesis of the viral (+) strand ]stage II(+)], followed by synthesis of the complementary (-) strand ]stage II(-)] [Eisenberg et al. (1976) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 73, 3151-3155]. Novel features of the mechanism of the stage II(+) reaction have now been observed. The product, synthesized in extensive net quantities, is a covalently closed, circular, single-stranded DNA. The supercoiled replicative form I template and three of the four required proteins--the phage-induced cistron A protein (cis A), the host rep protein (rep), and the DNA polymerase III holoenzyme (holoenzyme)--act catalytically; the Escherichia coli DNA unwinding (or binding) protein binds the product stoichiometrically. In a reaction uncoupled from replication, cis A, rep, DNA binding protein, ATP, and Mg2+ separate the supercoiled replicative form I into its component single strands coated with DNA binding protein. In the presence of Mg2+, cis A, nicks the replicative form I; rep, ATP, and Mg2+ achieve strand separation with a concurrent cleavage of ATP and binding of DNA binding protein to the single strands. rep exhibits a single-stranded DNA-dependent ATPase activity. These observations suggest that the rep enzymatically melts the duplex at the replicating fork, using energy provided by ATP; this mechanism may apply to the replication of the E. coli chromosome as well.     

Homologous pairing in genetic recombination: complexes of recA protein and DNA.

recA protein, which is essential for general genetic recombination in Escherichia coli, promotes the homologous pairing of single-stranded DNA with double-stranded DNA to form a D loop. The amount of recA protein required for the reaction was directly proportional to the amount of single stranded DNA and was unaffected by similar variations in the amount of double-stranded DNA. The ATP analog, adenosine 5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate) (ATP gamma S), which was not rapidly hydrolyzed by recA protein, blocked the formation of D loops but promoted the formation of stable complexes of recA protein and single-stranded DNA. These complexes, in turn, bound homologous or heterologous double-stranded DNA and partially unwound it. Because ATP gamma S competitively inhibited the ATPase activity of recA protein (Km/Ki approximately 300), we infer that ATP gamma S binds at a site that overlaps the site for ATP and that the functional complexes formed in the presence of the analog probably represent partial steps in the overall reaction. If the complexes formed in the presence of ATP gamma S reflect natural intermediates in the formation of D loops, recA protein must promote homologous pairing either by moving juxtaposed single-stranded and double-stranded DNA relative to one another or by forming and dissociating complexes reiteratively until a homologous match occurs.     

Initiation of general recombination catalyzed in vitro by the recA protein of Escherichia coli.

Homogeneous recA protein catalyzes the hybridization of single-stranded DNA to homologous regions in duplex DNA. The products are D-loops, which are formed with equal efficiency in linear and supercoiled molecules. This assimilation reaction can be separated into two partial reactions. In the first, recA protein binds to duplex DNA and produces a reA protein-DNA complex. The binding shows a sigmoidal dependence on recA protein concentration, requires ATP, GTP or the gamma-thio analog of ATP, and Mg2+, but does not require hydrolysis of the nucleoside triphosphate. In the second reaction, single-stranded regions of the recA protein-ATP-duplex DNA intermediate hybridize with free complementary single strands to produce D-loop structures. This reaction is coupled to ATP hydrolysis and is analogous to the renaturation of single-stranded DNA catalyzed by the recA protein [Weinstrock, G.M., McEntee, K. & Lehman, I.R. (1979) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 76, 126-130]. Hydrolysis of ATP appears to be required in these reactions for dissociation of recA protein from the DNA.     

Ability of RecA protein to promote a search for rare sequences in duplex DNA.

RecA nucleoprotein filaments found homologous targets even when the latter was mixed with 200,000 times as much heterologous duplex DNA. By contrast, mixing of the single-stranded probe with only 100 times as much heterologous single strands markedly reduced the rate of finding homologous duplex molecules. Titration of the reaction with different proportions of homologous single-stranded DNA distinguished a condition under which the search for homology itself was rate limiting from a condition under which some later step was limiting. Less than 1 min was required to scan 6.4 kilobase pairs of duplex DNA for homology to a RecA-coated single strand of the same size, but these experiments revealed that rapid searching by RecA nucleoprotein filaments was largely confined to neighboring duplex molecules. These observations provide guidelines for the use of RecA protein in locating rare sequences in complex mixtures of duplex DNA, and we describe a simple protocol by which rare sequences can be rapidly enriched at least a thousandfold.