The T12I mutation within the SP1 region of Gag restricts packaging of spliced viral RNA into human immunodeficiency virus type 1 with mutated RNA packaging signals and mutated nucleocapsid sequence

Specific packaging of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) RNA is attributable to the high affinity of nucleocapsid (NC) sequence of Gag for the cis-acting RNA packaging signals located within the 5' un-translated region (5' UTR). Interestingly, we have previously reported that the T12I mutation (named MP2) within SP1 of Gag prevented incorporation of spliced viral RNA into mutated viruses that lacked the stem-loop 1 (SL1) RNA element (also named dimerization initiation site, DIS), suggesting a role for the SP1 sequence in viral RNA packaging. In this study, we have further tested this activity of MP2 in the context of a variety of mutations that affect viral RNA incorporation. The results showed that MP2 was able to effectively restrict packaging of spliced viral RNA into viruses containing either NC mutations R10A and K11A or mutated 5' UTR sequence, such as DeltaGU3 that lacked the 112-GUCUGUUGUGUG-123 sequence of U5, D1 that was deleted of a 27 nt fragment immediately downstream of the primer binding site (PBS), Delta(306-325) that had the SL3 RNA element removed and MD2 that was missing the 328-GGAG-331 sequence. As a result, MP2 contributed increased infectivity to the related viruses. Therefore, the MP2 mutation demonstrates a distinct role in HIV-1 RNA packaging that is neither pertained to the specific viral RNA packaging signal nor to the NC sequence.     

Deficient dimerization of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 RNA caused by mutations of the u5 RNA sequences

The human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) virion contains two copies of genomic RNA that are noncovalently attached along a region at their 5' ends, in which two contact sites have been observed by electron microscopy. One of these sites is believed to be the stem-loop 1 (SL1) sequence which serves as the dimerization initiation site (DIS), and the other site, closer to the 5' end of the viral RNA, may involve the R or U5 RNA sequences. In this study, we present biochemical evidence showing that alteration of the U5 RNA sequence in the context of full-length viral RNA leads to diminished dimerization of virion RNA. In particular, two stretches of GU-rich sequences, which are located at nucleotides (nt) 99 to 108 and nt 112 to 123 within U5, were either deleted or substituted with exogenous sequences. The mutated viruses thus generated all exhibited deficient RNA dimerization. This dimerization deficit was not corrected by second-site mutations that preserved local RNA structures, such as the poly(A) hairpin, and was overcome to only a limited extent by compensatory mutations within Gag; these mutations were identified after long-term culture of the relevant mutant viruses in permissive cell lines and were able to restore viral infectiousness and RNA packaging to wild-type levels. Therefore, these GU sequences do not regulate RNA dimerization by the formation of local secondary structures nor by the maintenance of efficient viral RNA packaging; instead, they may mediate direct RNA-RNA interactions in the dimer structure. In contrast, mutation of palindrome 5'-AAGCUU-3', which resides within R and crowns the poly(A) hairpin, did not affect either RNA dimerization or RNA packaging.     

Distinct viral determinants for the packaging of human cytidine deaminases APOBEC3G and APOBEC3C

Human APOBEC3G and other APOBEC3 cytidine deaminases inhibit a variety of retroviruses, including Vif-deficient HIV-1. These host proteins are packaged into viral particles and inhibit the replication of virus in new target cells. A3G and A3F are known to be efficiently packaged into HIV-1 virions by binding to 7SL RNA through the Gag NC domain; however, the packaging mechanisms of other APOBEC3 proteins are poorly defined. We have now demonstrated that APOBEC3C (A3C) can be efficiently packaged into HIV-1 virions that are deficient for viral genomic RNA. Inhibition of the encapsidation of 7SL RNA into HIV-1 virions blocked the packaging of A3G, but not A3C. While the NC domain is required for efficient packaging of A3G, deletion of this domain had little effect on A3C packaging into HIV-1 Gag particles. A3C interacted with HIV-1 Gag which was MA domain-dependent and RNA-dependent. Deletion of the MA domain of HIV-1 Gag inhibited A3C but not A3G packaging into HIV-1 Gag particles. Thus, A3G and A3C have evolved to use distinct mechanisms for targeting retroviruses.     

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 preferentially encapsidates genomic RNAs that encode Pr55(Gag): functional linkage between translation and RNA packaging

Full-length retroviral RNA serves as both messenger and genomic RNA. Therefore, an unspliced RNA could play both roles: viral mRNA could be bound in cis by the same Gag polyprotein that it produced, becoming a packaged genomic RNA. To test this possibility, we used in vivo packaging experiments which coexpressed wild-type NL4-3 RNA and NL4-3-based mutant RNA that, ideally, could not translate Gag. However, mutating the gag initiator produced a mutant (pNLX) that expressed a truncated Gag, Gag*, initiated at methionine 10 in the CA region (142 of Pr55(Gag)). Gag* can be rescued into virions by Gag and, as it contains the NC domain, could package RNA in cis. To eliminate NC and the CA dimerization domain, a nonsense mutation in CA at residue 99 was introduced into pNLX to produce pNLXX, which expresses an RNA that should only be packaged in trans. Cotransfection packaging experiments revealed that wild-type genomic RNA was packaged at an 8-fold greater level than NLXX RNA given equal expression of both RNAs. Experiments that varied the relative amounts of these RNAs in the cell found that the wild-type RNA was encapsidated with a packaging preference (i.e., the relative amount of this RNA in virions versus cells) of 6- to 13-fold over the NLXX RNA, showing that the NLXX RNA did not efficiently compete with NL4-3 RNA. These data suggest that the wild-type RNA's ability to express Pr55(Gag) and, by inference, actively translate Gag confers an advantage in packaging over the nearly identical NLXX RNA. In contrast, the NLX RNA competed with wild-type RNA at a 1-to-3 preference. This ratio is similar to the amounts of Gag* rescued by Gag, suggesting that the presence of Gag* assists in the encapsidation of NLX RNA. Together, our data link translation and particle formation to the packaging of viral RNA and support a model of cis packaging where nascent Gag proteins encapsidate their cognate RNA.     

Mutational analysis of the predicted secondary RNA structure of the Mason-Pfizer monkey virus packaging signal

The 5' end of the Mason-Pfizer monkey virus (MPMV) genomic RNA has been predicted to fold into a complex stem/loop structure that is thought to play a role in specific RNA encapsidation. In this study, we used a set of mutations that either abrogated or recreated the first four stem loops predicted within the 5' untranslated region (5' UTR) for effects on RNA packaging. Test of these mutations in our biological assay revealed that only stem loop 1 (SL1) was important for the packaging potential of MPMV, while mutations in none of the other stem loops affected packaging significantly. Interestingly, it was the primary sequence of SL1 RNA and not its secondary structure that affected packaging since compensatory mutations that reformed SL1 were unable to restore the packaging efficiency of the retroviral vector. Additionally, our mutational analysis reveals that stem loop 4, predicted to be the major packaging determinant of MPMV, does not seem to have a significant role in packaging. Finally, results of the biological effects of the structural mutations are discussed in relation to their effects on the folding potential of the various stem loops.     

Role of capsid sequence and immature nucleocapsid proteins p9 and p15 in Human Immunodeficiency Virus type 1 genomic RNA dimerization

HIV-1 genomic RNA (gRNA) dimerization is important for viral infectivity and is regulated by proteolytic processing of the Gag precursor protein (Pr55gag) under the direction of the viral protease. The processing occurs in successive steps and, to date, the step associated with formation of a wild-type (WT) level of gRNA dimers has not been identified. The primary cleavage divides Pr55gag into two proteins. The C-terminal polypeptide is termed NCp15 (NCp7-p1-p6) because it contains the nucleocapsid protein (NC), a key determinant of gRNA dimerization and packaging. To examine the importance of precursor polypeptides NCp15 and NCp9 (NCp7-p1), we introduced mutations that prevented the proteolytic cleavages responsible for the appearance of NCp9 or NCp7. Using native Northern blot analysis, we show that gRNA dimerization was impaired when both the secondary (p1-p6) and tertiary (p7-p1) cleavage sites of NCp15 were abolished, but unaffected when only one or the other site was abolished. Though processing to NCp9 therefore suffices for a WT level of gRNA dimerization, we also show that preventing cleavage at the p7-p1 site abolished HIV-1 replication. To identify the minimum level of protease activity compatible with a WT level of gRNA dimers, we introduced mutations Thr26Ser and Ala28Ser in the viral protease to partially inactivate it, and we prepared composite HIV-1 resulting from the cotransfection of various ratios of WT and protease-inactive proviral DNAs. The results reveal that a 30% processing of Pr55gag into mature capsid proteins (CA/CA-p2) yielded a WT level of gRNA dimers, while a 10% Pr55gag processing hardly increased gRNA dimerization above the level seen in protease-inactive virions. We found that full gRNA dimerization required less than 50% WT NC in complementation asssays. Finally, we show that if we destroy alpha helix 1 of the capsid protein (CA), gRNA dimerization is impaired to the same extent as when the viral protease is inactivated. Cotransfection studies show that this CA mutation, in contrast to the NC-disabling mutations, has a dominant negative effect on HIV-1 RNA dimerization, viral core formation, and viral replication. This represents the first evidence that a capsid mutation can affect HIV-1 RNA dimerization.     

Mutational analysis of the replication signals in the 3'-nontranslated region of citrus tristeza virus

Citrus tristeza virus (CTV), a member of the Closteroviridae, has a 19.3-kb messenger-sense RNA genome consisting of 12 open reading frames with nontranslated regions (NTR) at the 5' and 3' termini. The 273 nucleotide (nt) 3'-NTR is highly conserved ( approximately 95%) among the sequenced CTV isolates in contrast to the highly diverse 5'-NTR sequences. The 3' replication signals were mapped to the 3' 234 nts within the NTR. This region of CTV does not contain a poly-A tract nor does it appear to fold as a tRNA-mimic. Instead, a computer-predicted thermodynamically stable secondary structure comprised of 10 stem-and-loop (SL) structures, referred to as SL1 to SL10 (5' to 3'), was common to all CTV isolates. This putative structure was used as a guide to examine the 3' requirements for replication in vivo. The resulting data suggest that a complex 3' structure is required for those functions that provide for efficient replication of CTV in vivo such as minus-strand initiation, regulation of strand asymmetry, effective translation of the myriad of viral mRNAs, or stability of RNAs. Deletions into the 3'-NTR, up to 66 nts from the 5' direction and 11 nts from the 3' direction, deleting or disrupting putative SL1, SL2 and SL3, or SL10, resulted in continued replication, suggesting that these sequences are not essential for basal-level replication, but are required for efficient replication. Predicted stem loops 3 through 10 were examined by mutations designed to alter the primary structures while preserving the secondary structures. Mutations designed to disrupt the predicted stems of SL3, SL5, SL7, SL9, or SL10 resulted in substantially reduced levels of replication, while compensatory mutations resulted in partial restorations of replication, suggesting that these predicted secondary structures are involved in replication. Also, the putative loop sequences of SL5, SL6, SL7, and SL9 tolerated mutagenesis with continued but reduced levels of replication. In contrast, all mutations introduced into putative SL4, SL8, and the stem of SL6 prevented replication, suggesting that the primary structure of these regions make up the core of the 3' replication signal. The 3' triplet, CCA, was shown to be necessary for efficient replication, but deletion of eleven nts to expose an internal CCA resulted in continued replication.     

Interaction of HIV-1 Gag with the clathrin-associated adaptor AP-2

The capsid (CA) sequence of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Gag protein consists of two independently folded domains named the N-terminal domain (NTD) and C-terminal domain (CTD) that are connected by a flexible linker. Most of the CTD sequence adopts rigid structure except for the last 11 amino acids (positions 354 to 364) that are disordered even in the context of the downstream SP1 and nucleocapsid (NC) sequence. Although disordered, this short peptide region plays a crucial role in HIV-1 replication. In this study, we identified three second-site mutations within Gag named A238T, G358S, and N373K that rescued a deleterious mutation R362A located at the C-terminus of CA. A238T is located within the NTD of CA, G358S and N373K are positioned proximal to R362A. One of the mechanisms underlying this compensation event is correction of reduced packaging of viral RNA into the R362A mutated viruses, as shown by the results of RNase protection assays, native Northern blots experiments as well as filter-binding assays. These data suggest that one potential function for the C-terminal disordered sequence of CA in HIV-1 replication is to regulate HIV-1 RNA packaging.     

Mapping of nucleocapsid residues important for HIV-1 genomic RNA dimerization and packaging

Retroviral genomic RNA (gRNA) dimerization appears essential for viral infectivity, and the nucleocapsid protein (NC) of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) facilitates HIV-1 gRNA dimerization. To identify the relevant and dispensable positions of NC, 34 of its 55 residues were mutated, individually or in small groups, in a panel of 40 HIV-1 mutants prepared by site-directed mutagenesis. It was found that the amino-terminus, the proximal zinc finger, the linker, and the distal zinc finger of NC each contributed roughly equally to efficient HIV-1 gRNA dimerization. The N-terminal and linker segments appeared to play predominantly electrostatic and steric roles, respectively. Mutating the hydrophobic patch of either zinc finger, or substituting alanines for their glycine doublet, was as disabling as deleting the corresponding finger. Replacing the CysX(2)CysX(4)HisX(4)Cys motif of either finger by CysX(2)CysX(4)CysX(4)Cys or CysX(2)CysX(4)HisX(4)His, interchanging the zinc fingers or, replacing one zinc finger by a copy of the other one, had generally intermediate effects; among these mutations, the His23-->Cys substitution in the N-terminal zinc finger had the mildest effect. The charge of NC could be increased or decreased by up to 18%, that of the linker could be reduced by 75% or increased by 50%, and one or two electric charges could be added or subtracted from either zinc finger, without affecting gRNA dimerization. Shortening, lengthening, or making hydrophobic the linker was as disabling as deleting the N-terminal or the C-terminal zinc finger, but a neutral and polar linker was innocuous. The present work multiplies by 4 and by 33 the number of retroviral and lentiviral NC mutations known to inhibit gRNA dimerization, respectively. It shows the first evidence that gRNA dimerization can be inhibited by: 1) mutations in the N-terminus or the linker of retroviral NC; 2) mutations in the proximal zinc finger of lentiviral NC; 3) mutations in the hydrophobic patch or the conserved glycines of the proximal or the distal retroviral zinc finger. Some NC mutations impaired gRNA dimerization more than mutations inactivating the viral protease, indicating that gRNA dimerization may be stimulated by the NC component of the Gag polyprotein. Most, but not all, mutations inhibited gRNA packaging; some had a strong effect on virus assembly or stability.     

Mutations that alter a repeated ACCA element located at the 5' end of the Potato virus X genome affect RNA accumulation

The repeated ACCA or AC-rich sequence and structural (SL1) elements in the 5' non-translated region (NTR) of the Potato virus X (PVX) RNA play vital roles in the PVX life cycle by controlling translation, RNA replication, movement, and assembly. It has already been shown that the repeated ACCA or AC-rich sequence affect both gRNA and sgRNA accumulation, while not affecting minus-strand RNA accumulation, and are also required for host protein binding. The functional significance of the repeated ACCA sequence elements in the 5' NTR region was investigated by analyzing the effects of deletion and site-directed mutations on PVX replication in Nicotiana benthamiana plants and NT1 protoplasts. Substitution (ACCA into AAAA or UUUU) mutations introduced in the first (nt 10-13) element in the 5' NTR of the PVX RNA significantly affected viral replication, while mutations introduced in the second (nt 17-20) and third (nt 20-23) elements did not. The fourth (nt 29-32) ACCA element weakly affected virus replication, whereas mutations in the fifth (nt 38-41) significantly reduced virus replication due to the structure disruption of SL1 by AAAA and/or UUUU substitutions. Further characterization of the first ACCA element indicated that duplication of ACCA at nt 10-13 (nt 10-17, ACCAACCA) caused severe symptom development as compared to that of wild type, while deletion of the single element (nt 10-13), DeltaACCA) or tripling of this element caused reduced symptom development. Single- and double-nucleotide substitutions introduced into the first ACCA element revealed the importance of CC located at nt positions 11 and 12. Altogether, these results indicate that the first ACCA element is important for PVX replication.     

Mutational patterns in the frameshift-regulating site of HIV-1 selected by protease inhibitors

Sustained suppression of viral replication in HIV-1 infected patients is especially hampered by the emergence of HIV-1 drug resistance. The mechanisms of drug resistance mainly involve mutations directly altering the interaction of viral enzymes and inhibitors. However, protease inhibitors do not only select for mutations in the protease but also for mutations in the precursor Gag and Pol proteins. In this study, we analysed the frameshift-regulating site of HIV-1 subtype B isolates, which also encodes for Gag and Pol proteins, classified as either treatment-naïve (TN) or protease inhibitor resistant (PI-R). HIV-1 Gag cleavage site mutations (G435E, K436N, I437V, L449F/V) especially correlated with protease inhibitor resistance mutations, but also Pol cleavage site mutations (D05G, D05S) could be assigned to specific protease resistance profiles. Additionally, two Gag non-cleavage site mutations (S440F, H441P) were observed more often in HIV-1 isolates carrying protease resistance mutations. However, in dual luciferase assays, the frameshift efficiencies of specific clones did not reveal any effect from these mutations. Nevertheless, two patterns of mutations modestly increased the frameshift rates in vitro, but were not specifically accumulating in PI-resistant HIV-1 isolates. In summary, HIV-1 Gag cleavage site mutations were dominantly selected in PI-resistant HIV-1 isolates but also Pol cleavage site mutations influenced resistance profiles in the protease. Additionally, Gag non-cleavage site mutations accumulated in PI-resistant HIV-1 isolates, but were not related to an increased frameshift efficiency.     

Sequences in the 5' leader of Mason-Pfizer monkey virus which affect viral particle production and genomic RNA packaging: development of MPMV packaging cell lines.

We used a series of deletion mutations in the 5' untranslated region of the prototype D type retrovirus, Mason-Pfizer Monkey Virus (MPMV), to analyse RNA encapsidation. A region was identified upstream of the major splice donor which reduced particle production but had a proportionally greater effect on RNA packaging. A small deletion downstream of the splice donor had little effect on RNA production and caused no significant packaging defect. A large deletion encompassing the end of the primer binding site down to the splice donor had a dramatic effect, disrupting viral protein synthesis. Stable cell lines were produced containing packaging-defective virus. These first-generation packaging cell lines were used to package and transfer an MPMV-based vector.     

Moloney murine leukemia virus genomic RNA packaged in the absence of a full complement of wild type nucleocapsid protein

The current model for MLV genomic RNA (gRNA) packaging predicts that of the thousands of Gag proteins in a budding virion, only a small number (≤1%) may be necessary to recruit gRNA. Here, we examined the threshold limits of functional Gag required to package gRNA using wild-type (WT) and packaging deficient mutant nucleocapsid (NC) phenotypically mixed virions. Although gRNA packaging was severely diminished for the NC mutant, the residual encapsidated RNA dimer displayed motility on gels, thermostability, and integrity that was indistinguishable from that of WT. In phenotypically mixed virions, gRNA encapsidation recovered to within approximately two-fold of WT levels when the amount of WT NC was 5-10% of the total. Our results demonstrate that NC's roles in gRNA dimerization and packaging are genetically separable. Additionally, MLV gRNA packaging does not require 100% WT NC, but the amount of functional NC required is greater than the predicted minimum.     

The primary nucleotide sequence of the bovine leukemia virus RNA packaging signal can influence efficient RNA packaging and virus replication

Two RNA stem-loop structures in the gag gene have been implicated as representing the primary encapsidation (packaging) signal for bovine leukemia virus (BLV), a member of the Delta retrovirus of the Retroviridae. In this study, we conducted an analysis of these RNA structures, stem loop 1 (SL1) and stem loop 2 (SL2), to determine if both the loop and the stem nucleotide bases are important for RNA encapsidation. We have found that the primary sequence of the unpaired bases located in the loop regions of both SL1 and SL2 are important for efficient RNA encapsidation and virus replication. The primary sequence of the bases that form the stems for both SL1 and SL2 was observed to aid in efficient encapsidation and replication. We also observed that the order of SL1 and SL2 is important for RNA encapsidation and virus replication efficiency. A viral RNA with two copies of either SL1 or SL2 was found to replicate and package RNA as efficiently as a viral RNA with only one copy of SL1 or SL2. This provides evidence that SL1 and SL2 are not functionally equivalent. Sequences from human T cell leukemia virus type 1 (HTLV-1) that are located in the same region of HTLV-1 as the SL1 and SL2 of BLV were used to replace the BLV SL1, SL2, or both in a BLV RNA. These BLV RNAs were still encapsidated and replicated, suggesting that these sequences may function as an encapsidation signal in HTLV-1. The chimeric RNAs did not replicate as well as the parental, indicating that the primary nucleotide sequence along with the secondary and tertiary structure of the RNA plays a role in efficient RNA encapsidation and replication.     

The critical role of proximal gag sequences in feline immunodeficiency virus genome encapsidation

Retroviral RNA encapsidation is mediated by specific interactions between viral Gag proteins and cis-acting packaging sequences in genomic RNA. Feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) RNA encapsidation determinants have been shown to be discrete and noncontinuous, comprising one region at the 5' end of the genomic mRNA (R-U5) and another region that mapped within the proximal 311 nt of gag. To aid comparative understanding of lentiviral encapsidation and refinement of FIV vector systems, we used RNase protection assays (RPAs) of cellular and virion RNAs to investigate in detail the gag element. mRNAs of subgenomic vectors as well as of full-length molecular clones were optimally packaged into viral particles and resulted in high-titer FIV vectors when they contained only the proximal 230 nucleotides (nt) of gag. Further 3' truncations of gag sequences progressively diminished encapsidation and transduction. Deletion of the initial ninety 5' nt of the gag gene abolished mRNA packaging, demonstrating that this segment is indispensable for encapsidation. Focusing further on this proximal sequence, we found that a deletion of only 13 nt at the 5' end of gag impaired encapsidation of subgenomic vector and proviral RNAs.     

Role of distal zinc finger of nucleocapsid protein in genomic RNA dimerization of human immunodeficiency virus type 1; no role for the palindrome crowning the R-U5 hairpin

Genomic RNA isolated from HIV-1 variously mutated in nucleocapsid protein (NC) was characterized by nondenaturing gel electrophoresis. Mutations in the C-terminal, the N-terminal, and the linker regions had no effect on genomic RNA dimerization [they are R7R10K11S, P31L, R32G, S3(32-34), and K59L], while a C36S/C39S mutation in the distal zinc knuckle (Cys-His box or zinc finger) inhibited genome dimerization as much as disrupting the kissing-loop domain. The four mutations which inhibited tRNA(Lys3) genomic placement (i.e., the in vivo placement of tRNA(Lys3) on the primer binding site) had no effect on genome dimerization. Among five mutations which inhibited genome packaging, four had no effect on genome dimerization. Thus the N-terminal and linker regions of NC control genome packaging/tRNA(Lys3) placement (two processes which do not require mature NC) but have little influence on genome dimerization and 2-base extension of tRNA(Lys3) (two processes which are likely to require mature NC). It has been suggested, based on electron microscopy, that the AAGCUU82 palindrome crowning the R-U5 hairpin stimulates genomic RNA dimerization. To test this hypothesis, we deleted AGCU81 from wild-type viruses and from viruses bearing a disrupted kissing-loop hairpin or kissing-loop domain; in another mutant, we duplicated AGCU81. The loss of AGCU81 reduced dimerization by 2.5 +/- 4%; its duplication increased it by 3 +/- 6%. Dissociation temperature was left unchanged. We reach two conclusions. First, the palindrome crowning the R-U5 hairpin has no impact on HIV-1 genome dimerization. Second, genomic RNA dimerization is differentially influenced by NC sequence: it is Zn finger dependent but independent of the basic nature of the N-terminal and linker subdomains. We propose that the NC regions implicated in 2-base extension of tRNA(Lys3) are required for a second (maturation) step of tRNA placement. Genome dimerization and mature tRNA placement would then become two RNA-RNA interactions sharing similar NC sequence requirements.