No evidence for ventrally migrating neural tube cells from the mid- and hindbrain.

Abstract The neural crest is a migratory population of cells that originates from the dorsal neural tube in vertebrates. Recently, the existence of a group of ventrally emigrating neural tube (VENT) cells has been proposed, based upon cell labelling studies in the hindbrain of avian embryos. Like crest cells, these VENT cells have been reported to give rise to numerous cell types. VENT cell emigration is thought to occur after embryonic day (E) 3, when neural crest cell production has ceased. Migration of cells from the ventral neural tube into the periphery was inferred retrospectively after examining numerous embryos harvested at different stages. We have attempted to label VENT cells in vivo by using a green fluorescent protein (GFP) expression vector, electroporated into the ventral neural tube after crest cell migration and before the putative migration of the ventrally localised cells. Because GFP can be visualised strongly in living tissue a few hours after electroporation, the migration of labelled cells within the same embryo can be followed. Fluorescent cells labelled in the mid-hindbrain region were examined in ovo and in explant culture. No GFP-expressing cells were detected emigrating from the ventral neural tube from E3 to E5. Our findings are, thus, in disagreement with those of previous studies, which have indicated the existence of VENT cells in the cranial region.     

The myth of ventrally emigrating neural tube (VENT) cells and their contribution to the developing cardiovascular system

The cardiac neural crest cells are a group of cells that emigrate from the dorsal side of the neural tube during a specific time window and contribute to the pharyngeal arch arteries and the aorticopulmonary septum of the heart. Recent publications have suggested that another group of cells emigrating from the ventral side of the neural tube also contributes to the developing cardiovascular system. The first aim of our study was to define the specific time window of cardiac neural crest cell migration by injecting a retrovirus containing a lacZ reporter gene into a chick embryo at different stages during development. The second aim was to study the contribution of the supposed ventrally emigrating neural tube cells to the cardiovascular system using three approaches. One approach was to inject a lacZ retrovirus into the lumen of the chick hindbrain. Secondly, we injected the retrovirus into the neural tube at the position of the 10-12 somite pair. Finally, we used the chimera technique in which we transplanted a quail neural tube segment into a chick embryo. Cardiac neural crest cells were shown to emigrate from the dorsal side of the neural tube between HH9 and HH13(-). The HH13(+) neural tube has ceased to produce cardiac neural crest cells between the level of the otic placode and the fourth pair of somites. Retroviral injection directly into the chick hindbrain at HH14 resulted in 50% of the embryos with minimal labeling of the hindbrain and intense labeling of the adjacent mesenchyme, suggesting that virus was spilled. This implies that this technique is not useful for confirming the existence of ventrally emigrating cells. Both retroviral injections into the neural tube lumen at HH14 at the position of the 10-12 somite pair and the chimeras showed no signs of ventrally emigrating neural tube cells. We conclude that there is no contribution of ventral neural tube cells to the developing cardiovascular system.     

Hoxb1 neural crest preferentially form glia of the PNS.

The vertebrate cranial neural crest cells give rise to many complex derivatives of the head, neck, and face, including neuronal and glial cells that act in concert for proper development of the anterior-peripheral nervous system. Several genes have been implicated in the processes of neural crest specification, migration, and differentiation; among these are the hox gene clusters. To determine the fates of hox-expressing cranial neural crest, we describe the results of a genetic lineage analysis by using the Cre/loxP system to drive the activation of different ROSA26 reporter alleles under the regulation of the hoxb1 locus. By targeting the 3' untranslated region of the hoxb1 gene, we have preserved endogenous gene activity and have been able to accurately follow the fates of the cells derived from the hoxb1 expression domain. Emphasis was placed on identifying the cell and tissue types that arise from the rhombomere 4-derived neural crest. Our results demonstrate that, in addition to forming much of the cartilage, bones, and muscle of the ears and neck, a significant population of rhombomere 4-derived neural crest is fated to generate the glial component of the seventh cranial nerve.     

Distribution of different regions of cardiac neural crest in the extrinsic and the intrinsic cardiac nervous system.

In this study we focused upon whether different levels of postotic neural crest as well as the right and left cardiac neural crest show a segmented or mixed distribution in the extrinsic and intrinsic cardiac nervous system. Different parts of the postotic neural crest were labeled by heterospecific replacement of chick neural tube by its quail counterpart. Quail-chick chimeras (n = 21) were immunohistochemically evaluated at stage HH28+, HH29+, and between HH34-37. In another set of embryos, different regions of cardiac neural crest were tagged with a retrovirus containing the LacZ reporter gene and evaluated between HH35-37 (n = 13). The results show a difference in distribution between the right- and left-sided cardiac neural crest cells at the arterial pole and ventral cardiac plexus. In the dorsal cardiac plexus, the right and left cardiac neural crest cells mix. In general, the extrinsic and intrinsic cardiac nerves receive a lower contribution from the right cardiac neural crest compared with the left cardiac neural crest. The right-sided neural crest from the level of somite 1 seeds only the cranial part of the vagal nerve and the ventral cardiac plexus. Furthermore, the results show a nonsegmented overlapping contribution of neural crest originating from S1 to S3 to the Schwann cells of the cranial and recurrent nerves and the intrinsic cardiac plexus. Also the Schwann cells along the distal intestinal part of the vagal nerve are derived exclusively from the cardiac neural crest region. These findings and the smaller contribution of the more cranially emanating cardiac neural crest to the dorsal cardiac plexus compared with more caudal cardiac neural crest levels, suggests an initial segmented distribution of cardiac neural crest cells in the circumpharyngeal region, followed by longitudinal migration along the vagal nerve during later stages.     

Lumbo-sacral neural crest contributes to the avian enteric nervous system independently of vagal neural crest.

Most of the avian enteric nervous system is derived from the vagal neural crest, but a minority of the neural cells in the hindgut, and to an even lesser extent in the midgut, are of lumbo-sacral crest origin. Since the lumbo-sacral contribution was not detected or deemed negligible in the absence of vagal cells, it had been hypothesised that lumbo-sacral neural crest cells require vagal crest cells to contribute to the enteric nervous system. In contrast, zonal aganglionosis, a rare congenital human bowel disease led to the opposite suggestion, that lumbo-sacral cells could compensate for the absence of vagal cells to construct a complete enteric nervous system. To test these notions, we combined E4 chick midgut and hindgut, isolated prior to arrival of neural precursors, with E1. 7 chick vagal and/or E2.7 quail lumbo-sacral neural tube as crest donors, and grafted these to the chorio-allantoic membrane of E9 chick hosts. Double and triple immuno-labelling for quail cells (QCPNA), neural crest cells (HNK-1), neurons and neurites (neurofilament) and glial cells (GFAP) indicated that vagal crest cells produced neurons and glia in large ganglia throughout the entire intestinal tissues. Lumbo-sacral crest contributed small numbers of neurons and glial cells in the presence or absence of vagal cells, chiefly in colorectum, but not in nearby small intestinal tissue. Thus for production of enteric neural cells the avian lumbo-sacral neural crest neither requires the vagal neural crest, nor significantly compensates for its lack. However, enteric neurogenesis of lumbo-sacral cells requires the hindgut microenvironment, whereas that of vagal cells is not restricted to a particular intestinal region.     

Inactivation of TGFbeta signaling in neural crest stem cells leads to multiple defects reminiscent of DiGeorge syndrome

Specific inactivation of TGFbeta signaling in neural crest stem cells (NCSCs) results in cardiovascular defects and thymic, parathyroid, and craniofacial anomalies. All these malformations characterize DiGeorge syndrome, the most common microdeletion syndrome in humans. Consistent with a role of TGFbeta in promoting non-neural lineages in NCSCs, mutant neural crest cells migrate into the pharyngeal apparatus but are unable to acquire non-neural cell fates. Moreover, in neural crest cells, TGFbeta signaling is both sufficient and required for phosphorylation of CrkL, a signal adaptor protein implicated in the development of DiGeorge syndrome. Thus, TGFbeta signal modulation in neural crest differentiation might play a crucial role in the etiology of DiGeorge syndrome.     

An in vitro model for characterizing the post-migratory cranial neural crest cells of the first branchial arch.

The cranial neural crest (CNC) is a transient cell population that originates at the crest of the neural fold and gives rise to multiple cell types during craniofacial development. Traditionally, researchers have used tissue explants, such as the neural tube, to obtain primary neural crest cells for their studies. However, this approach has inevitably resulted in simultaneous isolation of neural and non-neural crest cells as both of these cells migrate away from tissue explants. Using the Wnt1-Cre/R26R mouse model, we have obtained a pure population of neural crest cells and established a primary CNC cell culture system in which the cell culture medium best supports the proliferation of E10.5 first branchial arch CNC cells and maintains these cells in their undifferentiated state. Differentiation of CNC cells can be initiated by switching to a differentiation medium. In this model, cultured CNC cells can give rise to neurons, glial cells, osteoblasts, and other cell types, faithfully mimicking the differentiation process of the post-migratory CNC cells in vivo. Taken together, our study shows that the Wnt1-Cre/R26R mouse first branchial arch provides an excellent model for obtaining post-migratory neural crest cells free of any mesodermal contaminants. The cultured neural crest cells are under sustained proliferative, undifferentiated, or lineage-enhanced conditions, hence, serving as a tool for the investigation of the regulatory mechanism of CNC cell fate determination in normal and abnormal craniofacial development.     

Neural crest and placodal contributions in the development of the glossopharyngeal-vagal complex in the chick

By using the method of quail-to-chick transplantation of neural crest in one series (VNG) and placodal ectoderm in a second series (VPG) we were able to determine the relative contribution of cranial neural crest and placodal ectoderm to the formation of the Glossopharyngeal-vagal complex. In chimeric embryos, quail cells originating from cranial neural crest grafts of postotic levels end up in the root ganglia, while quail cells originating from placodal ectoderm of postotic levels end up in the trunk ganglia. The results clearly indicate that the caudal levels of the medulla and rostral cervical segments represent the site, and the neural crest the source, for the neurons of the root ganglia. The neurons form a homogenous population of the small-cell type. This clearly rules out any contribution to the root ganglia from placodal ectoderm. On the basis of our experiments, it is also concluded that the neurons of the trunk ganglia are purely placodal in origin and are composed of a population of cells of the large-cell type. Our experiments also provide convincing evidence for a neural crest origin for Schwann cell and ganglionic Satellite cells.     

The development of the neural crest in the human

The first systematic account of the neural crest in the human has been prepared after an investigation of 185 serially sectioned staged embryos, aided by graphic reconstructions. As many as fourteen named topographical subdivisions of the crest were identified and eight of them give origin to ganglia (Table 2). Significant findings in the human include the following. (1) An indication of mesencephalic neural crest is discernible already at stage 9, and trigeminal, facial, and postotic components can be detected at stage 10. (2) Crest was not observed at the level of diencephalon 2. Although pre-otic crest from the neural folds is at first continuous (stage 10), crest-free zones are soon observable (stage 11) in Rh.1, 3, and 5. (3) Emigration of cranial neural crest from the neural folds at the neurosomatic junction begins before closure of the rostral neuropore, and later crest cells do not accumulate above the neural tube. (4) The trigeminal, facial, glossopharyngeal and vagal ganglia, which develop from crest that emigrates before the neural folds have fused, continue to receive contributions from the roof plate of the neural tube after fusion of the folds. (5) The nasal crest and the terminalis-vomeronasal complex are the last components of the cranial crest to appear (at stage 13) and they persist longer. (6) The optic, mesencephalic, isthmic, accessory, and hypoglossal crest do not form ganglia. Cervical ganglion 1 is separated early from the neural crest and is not a Froriep ganglion. (7) The cranial ganglia derived from neural crest show a specific relationship to individual neuromeres, and rhombomeres are better landmarks than the otic primordium, which descends during stages 9-14. (8) Epipharyngeal placodes of the pharyngeal arches contribute to cranial ganglia, although that of arch 1 is not typical. (9) The neural crest from rhombomeres 6 and 7 that migrates to pharyngeal arch 3 and from there rostrad to the truncus arteriosus at stage 12 is identified here, for the first time in the human, as the cardiac crest. (10) The hypoglossal crest provides cells that accompany those of myotomes 1-4 and form the hypoglossal cell cord at stages 13 and 14. (11) The occipital crest, which is related to somites 1-4 in the human, differs from the spinal mainly in that it does not develop ganglia. (12) The occipital and spinal portions of the crest migrate dorsoventrad and appear to traverse the sclerotomes before the differentiation into loose and dense zones in the latter. (13) Embryonic examples of synophthalmia and anencephaly are cited to emphasize the role of the neural crest in the development of cranial ganglia and the skull.     

Spatiotemporally separated cardiac neural crest subpopulations that target the outflow tract septum and pharyngeal arch arteries

We used lacZ-retrovirus labeling combined with neural crest ablation in chick embryos to determine whether the cardiac neural crest cells constitute one group of multipotent cells, or they emigrate from the neural tube in time-dependent groups with different fates in the developing cardiovascular system. We demonstrated that early-migrating cardiac neural crest cells (HH9-10) massively target the aorticopulmonary septum and pharyngeal arch arteries, while the late-migrating cardiac neural crest cells (HH12) are restricted to the proximal part of the pharyngeal arch arteries. These results suggest a prominent role for early-migrating cells in outflow tract septation, and a function for late-migrating cells in pharyngeal arch artery remodeling. We demonstrated in cultures of neural tube explants an intrinsic difference between the early and late populations. However, by performing heterochronic transplantations we showed that the late-migrating cardiac neural crest cells were not developmentally restricted, and could contribute to the condensed mesenchyme of the aorticopulmonary septum when transplanted to a younger environment. Our findings on the exact timing and migratory behavior of cardiac neural crest cells will help narrow the range of factors and genes that are involved in neural crest-related congenital heart diseases.     

Lineage specification in neural crest cell pathfinding.

There are two principal models to explain neural crest patterning. One assumes that neural crest cells are multipotent precursors that migrate throughout the embryo and differentiate according to cues present in the local environment. A second proposes that the neural crest is a population of cells that becomes restricted to particular fates early in its existence and migrates along particular pathways dependent on unique cell-autonomous properties. Although it is now evident that the neural crest cell population, as a whole, is actually heterogenous (composed of both multipotent and restricted progenitors), evidence supporting the model of prespecification has increased over the past few years. This review will begin by telling the story of melanoblasts: a neural crest subpopulation that is biased toward a single fate and subsequently acquires intrinsic properties that guide cells of this lineage to their final destination. The remainder of this review will explore whether this model is exclusive to melanoblasts or if it can also be used to explain the patterning of other neural crest cells like those of the sensory, sympathoadrenal, and enteric lineages.     

Relative expression of Slug, RhoB, and HNK-1 in the cranial neural crest of the early chicken embryo.

The neural crest constitutes a complex population of cells that originates at the edges of the neural plate of vertebrate embryos and gives rise to a high diversity of tissues and cell types. Molecular markers are very useful to identify cell populations, and in the case of the neural crest at early stages, many of them have been described. Here, we show a series of chicken embryos double labeled for several of the most commonly used crest markers that evidence the existence of different subpopulations. Slug is a very good marker for premigratory and early migratory cranial neural crest, RhoB labels delaminating cells and the very early migratory population, and the HNK-1 epitope is acquired in the migratory crest cells at a distance from the neural tube, with a significant proportion of the Slug-expressing migratory cells negative for HNK-1. The existence of these crest subpopulations should be considered when analyzing both wild-type embryos and the phenotype of experimentally manipulated chick embryos. Developmental Dynamics 229:136-139, 2004.     

Disruption of actin cytoskeleton and anchorage-dependent cell spreading induces apoptotic death of mouse neural crest cells cultured in vitro

In vertebrate embryos, neural crest cells emigrate out of the neural tube and contribute to the formation of a variety of neural and nonneural tissues. Some neural crest cells undergo apoptotic death during migration, but its biological significance and the underlying mechanism are not well understood. We carried out an in vitro study to examine how the morphology and survival of cranial neural crest (CNC) cells of the mouse embryo are affected when their actin cytoskeleton or anchorage-dependent cell spreading is perturbed. Disruption of actin fiber organization by cytochalasin D (1 microg/ml) and inhibition of cell attachment by matrix metalloproteinase-2 (MMP-2; 2.0 units/ml) were followed by morphologic changes and apoptotic death of cultured CNC cells. When the actin cytoskeleton was disrupted by cytochalasin D, the morphologic changes of cultured CNC cells preceded DNA fragmentation. These results indicate that the maintenance of cytoskeleton and anchorage-dependent cell spreading are required for survival of CNC cells. The spatially and temporally regulated expression of proteinases may be essential for the differentiation and migration of neural crest cells.     

Filling in the phylogenetic gaps: Induction,migration, and differentiation of neural crest cells in a squamate reptile,the veiled chameleon (Chamaeleo calyptratus)

Neural crest cells comprise a migratory progenitor cell population that differentiate into cell types such as neurons and glia of the peripheral nervous system, pigment cells, hormone secreting cells in glands, and skeletal and connective tissue in the head, thus making important contributions to most tissues and organs throughout the vertebrate body. The evolutionary appearance of neural crest cells is considered synonymous with the origin of vertebrates and their subsequent diversification and radiation. While the comparative biology of neural crest cells has been studied for a century and a half beginning with their discovery by Wilhelm His in 1868, most of our understanding of their development and function has come from a small number of species. Thus, critical gaps exist in our understanding of how neural crest cells mediate evolution and development. This is particularly true with respect to squamate reptiles (lizards, snakes, amphisbaenians), which account for approximately one-third of all living tetrapods. Here, we present veiled chameleons (Chamaeleo calyptratus) as a model system for studying neural crest cell development in squamates. Chameleons exhibit various morphological specializations associated with an arboreal lifestyle that may have been facilitated through neural crest cells acting as a conduit for evolutionary change.     

Sema3E is required for migration of cranial neural crest cells in zebrafish: Implications for the pathogenesis of CHARGE syndrome

CHARGE syndrome is a congenital disorder with multiple malformations in the craniofacial structures, and cardiovascular and genital systems, which are mainly affected by neural crest defects caused by loss‐of‐function mutations within chromodomain helicase DNA‐binding protein 7 (CHD7). However, many patients with CHARGE syndrome test negative for CHD7. Semaphorin 3E (sema3E) is a gene reported to be mutated in patients with CHARGE syndrome. However, its role in the pathogenesis of CHARGE syndrome has not been verified experimentally. Here, we report that the knockdown of sema3E results in severe craniofacial malformations, including small eyes, defective cartilage and an abnormal number of otoliths in zebrafish embryos, which resemble the major features of CHARGE syndrome. Further analysis reveals that the migratory cranial neural crest cells are scattered in the region of the hindbrain, and the postmigratory neural crest cells are reduced in the pharyngeal arches upon sema3E knockdown. Notably, immunostaining and time‐lapse imaging analyses of a neural crest cell‐labelled transgenic fish line, sox10:EGFP, show that the migration of cranial neural crest cells is severely impaired, and many of these cells are misrouted upon sema3E knockdown. Furthermore, the sox10‐expressing cranial neural crest cells are scattered in chd7 homozygous mutants, which phenocopied the phenotype in sema3E morphants. Overexpression of sema3E rescues the phenotype of scattered cranial neural crest cells in chd7 homozygotes, indicating that chd7 may control the expression of sema3E to regulate cranial neural crest cell migration. Collectively, our data demonstrate that sema3E is involved in the pathogenesis of CHARGE syndrome by modulating cranial neural crest cell migration.     

Origin of spinal cord meninges, sheaths of peripheral nerves, and cutaneous receptors including Merkel cells

Summary The origin of cells covering the nervous system and the cutaneous receptors was studied using the quail-chick marking technique and light and electron microscopy. In the first experimental series the brachial neural tube of the quail was grafted in place of a corresponding neural tube segment of the chick embryo at HH-stages 10 to 14. In the second series the leg bud of quail embryos at HH-stages 18–20 was grafted in place of the leg bud of the chick embryos of the same stages and vice versa. It was found that all meningeal layers of the spinal cord, the perineurium and the endoneurium of peripheral nerves, as well as the capsular and inner space cells of Herbst sensory corpuscles, develop from the local mesenchymal cells. Schwann cells and cells of the inner core of sensory corpuscles are of neural crest origin. The precursors of Merkel cells migrate similarly to the Schwann cells into the limb bud where they later differentiate. This means that in addition to the Schwann cells and the melanocytes a further neural crest-derived subpopulation of cells enters the limb.     

Induction of chondrogenesis in neural crest cells by mutant fibroblast growth factor receptors.

Activating mutations in human fibroblast growth factor receptors (FGFR) result in a range of skeletal disorders, including craniosynostosis. Because the cranial bones are largely neural crest derived, the possibility arises that increased FGF signalling may predispose to premature/excessive skeletogenic differentiation in neural crest cells. To test this hypothesis, we expressed wild-type and mutant FGFRs in quail embryonic neural crest cells. Chondrogenesis was consistently induced when mutant FGFR1-K656E or FGFR2-C278F were electroporated in ovo into stage 8 quail premigratory neural crest, followed by in vitro culture without FGF2. Neural crest cells electroporated with wild-type FGFR1 or FGFR2 cDNAs exhibited no chondrogenic differentiation in culture. Cartilage differentiation was accompanied by expression of Sox9, Col2a1, and osteopontin. This closely resembled the response of nonelectroporated neural crest cells to FGF2 in vitro: 10 ng/ml induces chondrogenesis, Sox9, Col2a1, and osteopontin expression, whereas 1 ng/ml FGF2 enhances cell survival and Sox9 and Col2a1 expression, but never induces chondrogenesis or osteopontin expression. Transfection of neural crest cells with mutant FGFRs in vitro, after their emergence from the neural tube, in contrast, produced chondrogenesis at a very low frequency. Hence, mutant FGFRs can induce cartilage differentiation when electroporated into premigratory neural crest cells but this effect is drastically reduced if transfection is carried out after the onset of neural crest migration.     

On the differentiation and migration of some non-neuronal neural crest derived cell types

Summary Neural tubes containing premigratory neural crest cells from head and trunk levels as well as somites containing neural crest cells that have migrated away from the neural crest were grafted orthotopically and heterotopically from quail embryos to chicken embryos. Schwann cells and melanocytes of donor origin developed after all grafting procedures. Cartilage developed only from neural crest cells of head levels. No skeletal muscle was ever observed to develop from the neural crest. The development of these different cell types from heterotopically grafted premigratory neural crest cells indicates that the neural crest is not a population of pluripotent undeterminated cells, but that at least some determinated cells are present within it before the onset of emigration of neural crest cells from the neural crest. Different neural-crest-derived cell populations exhibit different migratory behaviour: After heterotopically grafting quail neural crest cells to the wing buds of chicken embryos. Schwann cells and non-epidermal melanocytes were found to have migrated proximally and distally away from the grafts. Epidermal melanocytes of donor origin were found to have migrated in a distal direction essentially.This work was supported by the Österreichischer Fonds zur Förderung der wissenschaftlichen Forschung (P 4680)     

Contributions of placodal and neural crest cells to avian cranial peripheral ganglia

The method of embryonic tissue transplantation was used to confirm the dual origin of avian cranial sensory ganglia, to map precise locations of the anlagen of these sensory neurons, and to identify placodal and neural crest-derived neurons within ganglia. Segments of neural crest or strips of presumptive placodal ectoderm were excised from chick embryos and replaced with homologous tissues from quail embryos, whose cells contain a heterochromatin marker. Placode-derived neurons associated with cranial nerves V, VII, IX, and X are located distal to crest-derived neurons. The generally larger, embryonic placodal neurons are found in the distal portions of both lobes of the trigeminal ganglion, and in the geniculate, petrosal and nodose ganglia. Crest-derived neurons are found in the proximal trigeminal ganglion and in the combined proximal ganglion of cranial nerves IX and X. Neurons in the vestibular and acoustic ganglia of cranial nerve VIII derive from placodal ectoderm with the exception of a few neural crest-derived neurons localized to regions within the vestibular ganglion. Schwann sheath cells and satellite cells associated with all these ganglia originate from neural crest. The ganglionic anlagen are arranged in cranial to caudal sequence from the level of the mesencephalon through the third somite. Presumptive placodal ectoderm for the VIIIth, the Vth, and the VIIth, IXth, and Xth ganglia are located in a medial to lateral fashion during early stages of development reflecting, respectively, the dorsolateral, intermediate, and epibranchial positions of these neurogenic placodes.