Deletion of major porins from meningococcal outer membrane vesicle vaccines enhances reactivity against heterologous serogroup B Neisseria meningitidis strains

Detergent-extracted detoxified outer membrane vesicle (dOMV) vaccines are effective at preventing invasive serogroup B meningococcal (MenB) disease caused by the homologous Neisseria meningitidis strain from which they are produced, but offer limited protection from heterologous strains. Differences in vaccine efficacy are partially due to strain-specific variations in the antigenic sequence types and expression levels of outer membrane proteins (OMPs), including the immunodominant OMP PorA. In this study, dOMV vaccines deficient in major OMPs, including PorA, PorB, and RmpM were isolated and used to immunize rabbits and mice. Serum samples were obtained from each animal and tested for antibody responses against five MenB strains. Immunization with wild type dOMVs elicited antibodies to major antigens including PorA, PorB, RmpM, and lipooligosaccharide (LOS), and demonstrated limited bactericidal activity against heterologous strains. In contrast, OMP-deficient dOMV vaccines elicited broadly cross-reactive bactericidal antibodies, with PorA/PorB-dual deficient dOMVs inducing antibodies exhibiting the greatest cross-reactivity. Enhanced killing of heterologous strains correlated with binding to unique protein bands in immunoblots, suggestive of improved immunogenicity of antigens under-represented in the wild type vaccine.     

Characterisation and immune responses to meningococcal recombinant porin complexes incorporated into liposomes

We have analysed the structure of meningococcal outer membrane complexes and found that the main complexes are formed by different combinations of PorA and/or PorB molecules, associated to other proteins such as RmpM. In view of the growing knowledge of the importance of conformational epitopes in the immune responses to many pathogens, our aim in this study was to analyse the interactions of PorA and PorB by reconstitution of both recombinant porins into liposomes and determine the relevance of these interactions for the immune response. Recombinant PorA and PorB incorporated into liposomes associate forming complexes that are homomeric when only one of the porins is present, but heteromeric when both neisserial porins are present, mimicking those found previously in native outer membrane vesicles (OMVs). Association of PorA and PorB to form heterocomplexes modifies the immunogenicity of at least PorB, allowing the production of antibodies that recognise conformational epitopes, and produces new epitopes that react with a 50 kDa outer membrane protein not yet identified.     

Development and characterisation of outer membrane vesicle vaccines against serogroup A Neisseria meningitidis

Neisseria meningitidis bacteria of serogroup A are causing recurring meningitis epidemics on the African continent. An outer membrane vesicle (OMV) vaccine against serogroup A meningococci made from a subgroup III serogroup A meningococcal strain was previously shown to induce antibodies with serum bactericidal activity (SBA) in mice. We have here further investigated the properties of OMV vaccines made from five different subgroup III serogroup A meningococcal strains grown in a synthetic medium with low iron content. In addition to the major outer membrane proteins (PorA, PorB, RmpM, Opa and OpcA), small amounts of the NadA, TdfH, Omp85, FetA, FbpA and NspA outer membrane proteins, as well as lipooligosaccharides, were detected in the vaccines. The OMV vaccines were used to immunise mice. Anti-meningococcal IgG antibodies in the mouse sera were analysed by immunoblotting and by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay against OMVs, and against live meningococcal cells in SBA and a flow-cytometric assay. The vaccines induced antibodies with high SBA and opsonophagocytic activity. The strongest IgG responses were directed against PorA. Significant SBA responses were also observed against a subgroup III strain, which did not express PorA, whereas no SBA was observed against a clone IV-1 serogroup A strain. An OMV vaccine from serogroup A meningococci may be an alternative to polysaccharide and conjugate polysaccharide vaccines for Africa.     

Evaluation of cross-reactive antigens as determinants of cross-bactericidal activity in pathogenic and commensal Neisseria

Several antisera raised against outer membane vesicles obtained from invasive and carrier Neisseria meningitidis strains and commensal Neisseria and Moraxella catharralis species were assayed to test cross-bactericidal activity on Neisseria meningitidis strains. Results demonstrate that, despite the wide antigenic cross-reactivity previously shown by Western-blotting for the major outer membrane antigenic proteins of all Neisseria species, complement mediated killing shows very variable patterns that can not be predicted on the basis of antigenic cross-reactivity. Results of antibody tritations on homologous and heterologous strains, isotyping, and bactericidal activity of sera raised against denatured purified outer-membrane vesicle proteins, suggest that the responsibility for most of the bactericidal activity of the sera must be conformational and/or shared epitopes not detectable by Western-blotting.     

Restored functional immunogenicity of purified meningococcal PorA by incorporation into liposomes

The impact of the conformation, lipooligosaccharide (LOS)-depletion and the presentation form of outer membrane protein PorA from Neisseria meningitidis (PorA) subtype P1.7-2,4 on the immune response in mice was studied. Native PorA was purified from outer membrane vesicles (OMVs) derived from meningococci and reconstituted into liposomes. The conformation of PorA after purification from OMVs and reconstitution in liposomes was monitored by use of electrophoretic and spectroscopic techniques and compared with the conformation of PorA in outer membrane complexes (OMCs) and heat-denatured PorA. The antigenicity of the PorA formulations was measured by ELISA by using a bactericidal anti-P1.4 monoclonal antibody. Immunogenicity was determined in Balb/c mice. PorA-specific IgG, isotype distribution and bactericidal activity were measured after subcutaneous immunization. In all formulations except in heat-denatured OMVs, PorA was present as trimers. The lipooligosaccharide (LOS) content was reduced by 96% in the purified protein with respect to the original OMVs. The antigenicity of purified PorA (i.e. ELISA response) was substantially higher as compared to PorA in liposomes, OMVs or OMCs. The results of the immunogenicity studies showed that all formulations were able to induce comparable IgG titers. However, whereas the antibodies raised by OMVs were bactericidal, the antibodies elicited by immunization with purified PorA were unable to kill meningococci. Remarkably, the ability to induce bactericidal antibodies was fully recovered by incorporation of the purified PorA into liposomes, in the absence of other adjuvants, as compared to LOS-containing OMVs.     

Immunogenicity and bactericidal activity in mice of an outer membrane protein vesicle vaccine against Neisseria meningitidis serogroup A disease

Serogroup A Neisseria meningitidis organisms of the subgroup III have caused epidemics of meningitis in sub-Saharan Africa since their introduction into the continent in 1987. The population structure of these bacteria is basically clonal, and these meningococci are strikingly similar in their major outer membrane antigens PorA and PorB. Protein-based vaccines might be an alternative to prevent epidemics caused by these meningococci; thus, we developed an outer membrane vesicle (OMV) vaccine from a serogroup A meningococcal strain of subgroup III. The serogroup A OMV vaccine was highly immunogenic in mice and elicited significant bactericidal activity towards several other serogroup A meningococci of subgroup III. The IgG antibodies generated were in immunoblot shown to be mainly directed towards the PorA outer membrane protein. The results presented demonstrate the potential of an OMV vaccine as an optional strategy to protect against meningococcal disease caused by serogroup A in Africa.     

Multivalent liposome-based vaccines containing different serosubtypes of PorA protein induce cross-protective bactericidal immune responses against Neisseria meningitidis

Four serosubtypes (P1.7, 16, P1.7-2, 4, P1.19, 15 and P1.5-1, 10-4) of the PorA outer-membrane protein of Neisseria meningitidis were purified as recombinant proteins and incorporated into liposomes to investigate their immunogenicity. Each serosubtype induced high levels of bactericidal activity against the homologous strain. In addition, liposome preparations containing multiple serosubtypes induced high levels of bactericidal activity against each of the four strains. Significantly, antisera raised against monovalent and multivalent liposomes also showed cross-reactive bactericidal activity against heterologous strains. These data demonstrate that multivalent liposome vaccines, containing multiple PorA serosubtypes, have the potential to provide protection against a broad range of meningococcal strains.     

Recombinant meningococcal PorA protein, expressed using a vector system with potential for human vaccination, induces a bactericidal immune response

The PorA protein of Neisseria meningitidis (subtype P1.7,16) was expressed as a recombinant protein using three vectors; pTWIN, pQE30 and pRSETA, which introduce different sized N-terminal leader sequences to the mature protein. The immunogenicity of these proteins was compared following incorporation into liposomes and ZW-micelles. All of the recombinant PorA (rPorA) preparations induced high titres of antibody that recognised the homologous PorA within the outer membrane (OM) and on the surface of meningococci. Antisera raised against liposomes and micelles containing the different rPorA proteins induced high and comparable levels of complement-mediated killing of the homologous, but not heterologous, strain. Furthermore, the bactericidal effect was greater when rPorA were incorporated into liposomes rather than detergent micelles. The minimal addition of three N-terminal amino acids in rPorA purified from the pTWIN vector represents a significant improvement over rPorA purified from vectors pQE30 and pRSETA, plus other previously purified rPorA, when considering use of these proteins in vaccines for human use.     

Interspecific neisserial high molecular weight proteins able to induce natural immunity responses are strongly correlated with in vitro bactericidal activity

Human sera from healthy volunteers and patients convalescent from meningitis were used to search for widely cross-reactive antigens implicated in vivo protective responses. Using the type strain Neisseria meningitidis B16B6 and a wide variety of both N. meningitidis and N. lactamica strains, several cross-reactive antigens and bactericidal sera were found, although the cross-reactivity patterns did not correlate with bactericidal activity, a total correlation was found between bactericidal activity and reaction with one or two high molecular weight proteins (162 and 138 kDa), and a mouse serum against the purified proteins showed a high bactericidal activity. Our results suggest that the high molecular weight proteins found are immunogenic and cross-reactive, eliciting bactericidal responses during infection and as a result of natural immunity. These proteins should be taken into account in studies for future vaccine formulations.     

PorB3 outer membrane protein on Neisseria meningitidis is poorly accessible for antibody binding on live bacteria

It is reported here that the PorB3 porin proteins of serotype 4 and 15 are poorly accessible for antibody binding on live Neisseria meningitidis bacteria, whereas the allelic PorB2 and the PorA outer membrane protein appear to be highly accessible. This was revealed by flow cytometry analysis using several mouse monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) as well as PorB3 specific antibodies isolated from post vaccination and patient sera. However, strong antibody binding to the PorB3 protein was observed after killing the bacteria with ethanol. The reason for the lack of epitope exposure could be a shielding effect of the carbohydrate chains of lipopolysaccharides (LPS) possibly combined with short extra-cellular loops in the PorB3 protein. The findings indicate that the PorB3 protein is not an optimal target for protective antibodies induced by vaccination.     

Improving the immunogenicity of a trivalent Neisseria meningitidis native outer membrane vesicle vaccine by genetic modification

Trivalent native outer membrane vesicles (nOMVs) derived from three genetically modified Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B strains have been previously evaluated immunologically in mice and rabbits. This nOMV vaccine elicited serum bactericidal activity (SBA) against multiple N. meningitidis serogroup B strains as well as strains from serogroups C, Y, W, and X. In this study, we used trivalent nOMVs isolated from the same vaccine strains and evaluated their immunogenicity in an infant Rhesus macaque (IRM) model whose immune responses to the vaccine are likely to be more predictive of the responses in human infants. IRMs were immunized with trivalent nOMV vaccines and sera were evaluated for exogenous human serum complement-dependent SBA (hSBA). Antibody responses to selected hSBA generating antigens contained within the trivalent nOMVs were also measured and we found that antibody titers against factor H binding protein variant 2 (fHbpv2) were very low in the sera from animals immunized with these original nOMV vaccines. To increase the fHbp content in the nOMVs, the vaccine strains were further genetically altered by addition of another fHbp gene copy into the porB locus. Trivalent nOMVs from the three new vaccine strains had higher fHbp antigen levels and generated higher anti-fHbp antibody responses in immunized mice and IRMs. As expected, fHbp insertion into the porB locus resulted in no PorB expression. Interestingly, higher expression of PorA, an hSBA generating antigen, was observed for all three modified vaccine strains. Compared to the trivalent nOMVs from the original strains, higher PorA levels in the improved nOMVs resulted in higher anti-PorA antibody responses in mice and IRMs. In addition, hSBA titers against other strains with PorA as the only hSBA antigen in common with the vaccine strains also increased.     

Broad vaccine coverage predicted for a bivalent recombinant factor H binding protein based vaccine to prevent serogroup B meningococcal disease

Factor H binding proteins (fHBP), are bacterial surface proteins currently undergoing human clinical trials as candidate serogroup B Neisseria meningitidis (MnB) vaccines. fHBP protein sequences segregate into two distinct subfamilies, designated A and B. Here, we report the specificity and vaccine potential of mono- or bivalent fHBP-containing vaccines. A bivalent fHBP vaccine composed of a member of each subfamily elicited substantially broader bactericidal activity against MnB strains expressing heterologous fHBP than did either of the monovalent vaccines. Bivalent rabbit immune sera tested in serum bactericidal antibody assays (SBAs) against a diverse panel of MnB clinical isolates killed 87 of the 100 isolates. Bivalent human immune sera killed 36 of 45 MnB isolates tested in SBAs. Factors such as fHBP protein variant, PorA subtype, or MLST were not predictive of whether the MnB strain could be killed by rabbit or human immune sera. Instead, the best predictor for killing in the SBA was the level of in vitro surface expression of fHBP. The bivalent fHBP vaccine candidate induced immune sera that killed MnB isolates representing the major MLST complexes, prevalent PorA subtypes, and fHBP variants that span the breadth of the fHBP phylogenetic tree. Importantly, epidemiologically prevalent fHBP variants from both subfamilies were killed.     

Application of a Neisseria meningitidis antigen microarray to identify candidate vaccine proteins from a human Phase I clinical trial

Meningococcal meningitis is a rare but serious condition affecting mainly children and young adults. Outer membrane vesicles (OMV) from Neisseria meningitidis have been used successfully as vaccines against the disease, although they only provide protection against a limited number of the many existing variants. There have been many attempts to identify suitable protein antigens for use in defined vaccines that provide broad protection against the disease, such as that leading to the development of the four component 4CMenB vaccine. We previously reported the use of a protein antigen microarray to screen for IgG antibodies in sera derived from human recipients of an OMV-based vaccine, as part of a Phase I clinical trial. Here, we show that computational methods can be used to cluster antigens that elicit similar responses in the same individuals. Fitting of IgG antibody binding data to 4,005 linear regressions identified pairs of antigens that exhibited significant correlations. Some were from the same antigens in different quaternary states, whilst others might be correlated for functional or immunological reasons. We also conducted statistical analyses to examine correlations between individual serum bactericidal antibody (SBA) titres and IgG reactivity against specific antigens. Both Kendall’s tau and Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient statistics identified specific antigens that correlated with log(SBA) titre in five different isolates. The principal antigens identified were PorA and PorB, RmpM, OpcA, and the type IV pilus assembly secretin, PilQ. Other minor antigens identified included a lipoprotein, two proteins from the BAM complex and the efflux channel MtrE. Our results suggest that consideration of the entire antigen composition, and allowance for potential interaction between antigens, could be valuable in designing future meningococcal vaccines. Such an approach has the advantages that it uses data derived from human, rather than animal, immunization and that it avoids the need to screen individual antigens.     

Immunogenicity of various presentation forms of PorA outer membrane protein of Neisseria meningitidis in mice.

In this study we compare different vaccine formulations containing meningococcal PorA outer membrane protein; purified PorA, outer membrane vesicles (OMV) and immune-stimulating complexes (iscom). Bactericidal antibodies could be generated by the OMV and iscom formulation but not with purified PorA using either A1PO4 or Quil-A as adjuvant. OMV and iscom formulations revealed similar immunogenicity when tested in a dose response manner, with respect to bactericidal as well as OMV-binding antibodies. The anti-OMV IgG subclass response induced by PorA in OMV formulation was found in all subclasses IgG1, IgG2a, IgG2b, IgG3. OMP-iscoms induced very high IgG1 anti-OMV antibodies but almost no IgG3 response. Also, OMP-iscoms appeared to be a potent inducer of antibodies directed against linear peptides corresponding to surface exposed loops of PorA. In addition, iscoms as well as purified PorA with Quil-A as adjuvant (but not with A1PO4) induced high levels of antibodies against purified PorA. In summary, in addition to the OMV formulation, only iscoms containing PorA are able to generate an anamnestic and bactericidal antibody response.     

Immunogenicity of a meningococcal native outer membrane vesicle vaccine with attenuated endotoxin and over-expressed factor H binding protein in infant rhesus monkeys

We previously investigated immunogenicity of meningococcal native outer membrane vesicle (NOMV) vaccines prepared from recombinant strains with attenuated endotoxin (ΔLpxL1) and over-expressed factor H binding protein (fHbp) in a mouse model. The vaccines elicited broad serum bactericidal antibody responses. While human toll-like receptor 4 (TLR-4) is mainly stimulated by wildtype meningococcal endotoxin, mouse TLR-4 is stimulated by both the wildtype and mutant endotoxin. An adjuvant effect in mice of the mutant endotoxin would be expected to be much less in humans, and may have contributed to the broad mouse bactericidal responses. Here we show that as previously reported for humans, rhesus primate peripheral blood mononuclear cells incubated with a NOMV vaccine from ΔLpxL1 recombinant strains had lower proinflammatory cytokine responses than with a control wildtype NOMV vaccine. The cytokine responses to the mutant vaccine were similar to those elicited by a detergent-treated, wildtype outer membrane vesicle vaccine that had been safely administered to humans. Monkeys (N=4) were immunized beginning at ages 2-3 months with three doses of a NOMV vaccine prepared from ΔLpxL1 recombinant strains with over-expressed fHbp in the variant 1 and 2 groups. The mutant NOMV vaccine elicited serum bactericidal titers≥1:4 against all 10 genetically diverse strains tested, including 9 with heterologous PorA to those in the vaccine. Negative-control animals had serum bactericidal titers<1:4. Thus, the mutant NOMV vaccine elicited broadly protective serum antibodies in a non-human infant primate model that is more relevant for predicting human antibody responses than mice.     

Stability of mono- and trivalent meningococcal outer membrane vesicle vaccines

The stability during storage of outer membrane vesicles (OMVs) of Neisseria meningitidis group B was studied. Three types of OMVs were compared for their stability, containing either one (monovalent) or three different PorA subtypes (trivalent), the latter with and without class 4 outer membrane protein (OMO, RmpM). Aqueous formulations were stored freeze-dried (4 degrees C), frozen (-70 degrees C) and in liquid form at 4, 37 and 56 degrees C. Physico-chemical properties and immunogenicity of the OMVs as well as PorA conformation and antigenicity (P1.7-2,4, the subtype present in all formulations) were monitored during 1 year. At -70 or 4 degrees C, the structure and immunogenicity of OMVs was preserved. Storage of OMVs at high temperatures (37 or 56 degrees C) induced destruction of the OMV structure and denaturation of PorA, followed by chemical degradation. Immunogenicity decreased or was lost completely. Changes observed in the fluorescence spectra of degraded OMVs were also seen in tryptophan (Trp) and tyrosine (Tyr) derivatives incubated at 56 degrees C, indicating the occurrence of chemical degradation of tryptophan and tyrosine residues in PorA. Trivalent OMVs were slightly more stable at 37 degrees C than monovalent OMVs as assessed by in vitro methods, but these differences did not result in differences in the immunogenicity. The stability of trivalent OMVs was not affected by the presence of RmpM. Both trivalent and monovalent OMVs could be freeze-dried with preservation of their immunogenicity. In conclusion, OMVs are sensitive to elevated temperatures, but are stable in the frozen or freeze-dried state or when stored at 4 degrees C in the liquid state.     

Recombinant outer membrane secretin PilQ(406-770) as a vaccine candidate for serogroup B Neisseria meningitidis

Secretin PilQ is an antigenically conserved outer membrane protein which is present on most meningococci. This protein naturally expressed at high levels and is essential for meningococcal pilus expression at the cell surface. A 1095 bp fragment of C-terminal of secretin pilQ from serogroup B Neisseria meningitidis was cloned into prokaryotic expression vector pET-28a. Recombinant protein was overexpressed with IPTG and affinity-purified by Ni-NTA agarose. BALB/c mice were immunized subcutaneously with purified rPilQ(406-770) mixed with Freund's adjuvant. Serum antibody responses to serogroups A and B N. meningitidis whole cells or purified rPilQ(406-770) and functional activity of antibodies were determined by ELISA and SBA, respectively. The output of rPilQ(406-770) was approximately 50% of the total bacterial proteins. Serum IgG responses were significantly increased in immunized group with PilQ(406-770) mixed with Freund's adjuvant in comparison with control groups. Antisera produced against rPilQ(406-770) demonstrated strong surface reactivity to serogroups A and B N. meningitidis tested by whole-cell ELISA. Surface reactivity to serogroup B N. meningitidis was higher than serogroup A. The sera from PilQ(406-770) immunized animals were strongly bactericidal against serogroups A and B. These results suggest that rPilQ(406-770) is a potential vaccine candidate for serogroup B N. meningitidis.     

Immunization of mice with Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B genomic expression libraries elicits functional antibodies and reduces the level of bacteremia in an infant rat infection model

The feasibility of expression library immunization against the pathogenic bacterium Neisseria meningitidis was studied. A genomic library of N. meningitidis serogroup B strain CU385, containing 6000 individual clones, was constructed and divided into 10 sublibraries. Immunization of BALB/c mice with plasmid DNA from six sublibraries induced a humoral response, with recognition of several meningococcal proteins by Western blot. Three of these sublibraries elicited bactericidal antibodies against the homologous strain, and sera from mice immunized with one of these sublibraries reduced significantly the number of viable bacteria in blood of infant rats challenged with N. meningitidis. In addition, after DNA immunization, mice were boosted intraperitoneally with 5 x 10(2) colony forming units of strain CU385. Mice immunized with nine of the 10 libraries developed bactericidal antibodies 1 week after the boost and controls did not, demonstrating the priming capacity and specificity of our immunization strategy. Our study demonstrates, for the first time, that genomic immunization offers a novel approach for screening possible vaccine candidates against N. meningitidis.     

Improved immunogenicity of a H44/76 group B outer membrane vesicle vaccine with over-expressed genome-derived Neisserial antigen 1870

A broadly protective vaccine against meningococcal group B disease is not available. We previously reported that an outer membrane vesicle (OMV) vaccine containing over-expressed genome-derived antigen (GNA) 1870 elicited broader protective antibody responses than recombinant GNA1870 or conventional OMV vaccines prepared from a strain that naturally expresses low amounts of GNA1870. Certain wildtype strains such as H44/76 naturally express larger amounts of GNA1870 and, potentially, could be used to prepare an improved OMV vaccine without genetic over-expression of the antigen. We transformed H44/76 with a shuttle vector to over-express variant 1 (v.1) GNA1870 and compared the immunogenicity in mice of OMV vaccines prepared from wildtype H44/76 (v.1), the mutant, and a recombinant v.1 GNA1870 vaccine. Mice immunized with OMV with over-expressed GNA1870 developed broader serum bactericidal and/or greater C3 deposition activity on the surface of encapsulated strains of N. meningitidis than control mice immunized with the OMV vaccine prepared from the wildtype strain, or the rGNA1870 vaccine. When a panel of group B strains from patients in California was tested, sera from mice immunized with the OMV vaccine containing over-expressed GNA1870 were bactericidal against 100% of the v.1 strains. In contrast, only 20% of isolates that expressed subvariants of the v.1 GNA1870 protein were susceptible to bactericidal activity of antibodies elicited by the rGNA1870 or conventional OMV vaccines. Thus, even a modest increase in GNA1870 expression in a strain that naturally is a high producer of GNA1870 results in an OMV vaccine that elicits broader protection against meningococcal disease.