Normal retina releases a diffusible factor stimulating cone survival in the retinal degeneration mouse

The role of cellular interactions in the mechanism of secondary cone photoreceptor degeneration in inherited retinal degenerations in which the mutation specifically affects rod photoreceptors was studied. We developed an organ culture model of whole retinas from 5-week-old mice carrying the retinal degeneration mutation, which at this age contain few remaining rods and numerous surviving cones cocultured with primary cultures of mixed cells from postnatal day 8 normal-sighted mice (C57BL/6) retinas or retinal explants from normal (C57BL/6) or dystrophic (C3H/He) 5-week-old mice. After 7 days, the numbers of residual cone photoreceptors were quantified after specific peanut lectin or anti-arrestin antibody labeling by using an unbiased stereological approach. Examination of organ cultured retinas revealed significantly greater numbers of surviving cones (15–20%) if cultured in the presence of retinas containing normal rods as compared with controls or cocultures with rod-deprived retinas. These data indicate the existence of a diffusible trophic factor released from retinas containing rod cells and acting on retinas in which only cones are present. Because cones are responsible for high acuity and color vision, such data could have important implications not only for eventual therapeutic approaches to human retinal degenerations but also to define interactions between retinal photoreceptor types.     

A typology of photoreceptor gene expression patterns in the mouse

Mutations in photoreceptor-enriched genes have been implicated in dozens of human retinal diseases, yet no systematic analysis of rod and cone gene expression patterns has been carried out. In addition, although cone photoreceptor loss accounts for much of the morbidity of retinal disease, relatively few cone-specific genes are known. In this study, we carried out microarray and in situ hybridization analyses of the mouse Neural retina leucine zipper gene (Nrl) mutant, which shows an en masse conversion of rods into cones, to establish a typology of photoreceptor gene expression and to identify novel cone-specific genes. We found a total of 18 new cone-enriched genes, some of which map near uncloned retinal disease loci. Several of these genes have a dorsal-ventral (D-V) pattern of expression similar to that of short- or medium-wavelength opsins. We carried out microarray analysis of dorsal and ventral microdissected WT retina and found additional photoreceptor genes with an asymmetric distribution. Overall, we found that photoreceptor genes fall on an expression spectrum from rod-specific to cone-specific, with many showing varying degrees of rod and cone coexpression. These expression patterns can be reliably predicted from microarray data alone. Our results demonstrate definitive molecular differences between rods and cones that may underlie the physiological differences between these two classes of photoreceptors.     

Receptor interacting protein kinase mediates necrotic cone but not rod cell death in a mouse model of inherited degeneration

Retinitis pigmentosa comprises a group of inherited retinal photoreceptor degenerations that lead to progressive loss of vision. Although in most cases rods, but not cones, harbor the deleterious gene mutations, cones do die in this disease, usually after the main phase of rod cell loss. Rod photoreceptor death is characterized by apoptotic features. In contrast, the mechanisms and features of subsequent nonautonomous cone cell death remain largely unknown. In this study, we show that receptor-interacting protein (RIP) kinase mediates necrotic cone cell death in rd10 mice, a mouse model of retinitis pigmentosa caused by a mutation in a rod-specific gene. The expression of RIP3, a key regulator of programmed necrosis, was elevated in rd10 mouse retinas in the phase of cone but not rod degeneration. Although rd10 mice lacking Rip3 developed comparable rod degeneration to control rd10 mice, they displayed a significant preservation of cone cells. Ultrastructural analysis of rd10 mouse retinas revealed that a substantial fraction of dying cones exhibited necrotic morphology, which was rescued by Rip3 deficiency. Additionally, pharmacologic treatment with a RIP kinase inhibitor attenuated histological and functional deficits of cones in rd10 mice. Thus, necrotic mechanisms involving RIP kinase are crucial in cone cell death in inherited retinal degeneration, suggesting the RIP kinase pathway as a potential target to protect cone-mediated central and peripheral vision loss in patients with retinitis pigementosa.     

Retinal degeneration is rescued in transgenic rd mice by expression of the cGMP phosphodiesterase beta subunit.

The beta subunit of the cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE) gene has been identified as the candidate gene for retinal degeneration in the rd mouse. To study the molecular mechanisms underlying degeneration and the potential for gene repair, we have expressed a functional bovine cGMP PDE beta subunit in transgenic rd mice. One transgenic mouse line showed complete photoreceptor rescue across the entire span of the retina. A second independently derived line showed partial rescue in which photoreceptors in the superior but not the inferior hemisphere of the retina were rescued. In the latter animals, intermediate stages of degeneration were observed in the transition zone between rescued and diseased photoreceptors. Pathologic changes in the retina ranged from vesiculation of the basalmost outer segment discs in otherwise structurally intact rod cells to photoreceptors with highly disorganized outer segments and intact inner segments. Totally or partially rescued retinas showed a corresponding restoration of cGMP PDE activity, whereas nonrescued retinas had minimal enzyme activity, characteristic of the rd phenotype. These transgenic animals provide models for studying the molecular basis of retinal degenerative disease and conclusively demonstrate that the phenotype of rd mice is produced by a defect in the beta subunit of cGMP PDE.     

Selective loss of cone function in mice lacking the cyclic nucleotide-gated channel CNG3

Two types of photoreceptors, rods and cones, coexist in the vertebrate retina. An in-depth analysis of the retinal circuitry that transmits rod and cone signals has been hampered by the presence of intimate physical and functional connections between rod and cone pathways. By deleting the cyclic nucleotide-gated channel CNG3 we have generated a mouse lacking any cone-mediated photoresponse. In contrast, the rod pathway is completely intact in CNG3-deficient mice. The functional loss of cone function correlates with a progressive degeneration of cone photoreceptors but not of other retinal cell types. CNG3-deficient mice provide an animal model to dissect unequivocally the contribution of rod and cone pathways for normal retinal function.     

Functional interchangeability of rod and cone transducin α-subunits

Rod and cone photoreceptors use similar but distinct sets of phototransduction proteins to achieve different functional properties, suitable for their role as dim and bright light receptors, respectively. For example, rod and cone visual pigments couple to distinct variants of the heterotrimeric G protein transducin. However, the role of the structural differences between rod and cone transducin α subunits (Tα) in determining the functional differences between rods and cones is unknown. To address this question, we studied the translocation and signaling properties of rod Tα expressed in cones and cone Tα expressed in rods in three mouse strains: rod Tα knockout, cone Tα GNAT2^cpfl3 mutant, and rod and cone Tα double mutant rd17 mouse. Surprisingly, although the rod/cone Tα are only 79% identical, exogenously expressed rod or cone Tα localized and translocated identically to endogenous Tα in each photoreceptor type. Moreover, exogenously expressed rod or cone Tα rescued electroretinogram responses (ERGs) in mice lacking functional cone or rod Tα, respectively. Ex vivo transretinal ERG and single-cell recordings from rd17 retinas treated with rod or cone Tα showed comparable rod sensitivity and response kinetics. These results demonstrate that cone Tα forms a functional heterotrimeric G protein complex in rods and that rod and cone Tα couple equally well to the rod phototransduction cascade. Thus, rod and cone transducin α-subunits are functionally interchangeable and their signaling properties do not contribute to the intrinsic light sensitivity differences between rods and cones. Additionally, the technology used here could be adapted for any such homologue swap desired.     

Reprogramming of adult rod photoreceptors prevents retinal degeneration

A prime goal of regenerative medicine is to direct cell fates in a therapeutically useful manner. Retinitis pigmentosa is one of the most common degenerative diseases of the eye and is associated with early rod photoreceptor death followed by secondary cone degeneration. We hypothesized that converting adult rods into cones, via knockdown of the rod photoreceptor determinant Nrl, could make the cells resistant to the effects of mutations in rod-specific genes, thereby preventing secondary cone loss. To test this idea, we engineered a tamoxifen-inducible allele of Nrl to acutely inactivate the gene in adult rods. This manipulation resulted in reprogramming of rods into cells with a variety of cone-like molecular, histologic, and functional properties. Moreover, reprogramming of adult rods achieved cellular and functional rescue of retinal degeneration in a mouse model of retinitis pigmentosa. These findings suggest that elimination of Nrl in adult rods may represent a unique therapy for retinal degeneration.     

Nonvisual light responses in the Rpe65 knockout mouse: rod loss restores sensitivity to the melanopsin system

Intrinsically photosensitive retinal ganglion cells (ipRGCs) expressing the photopigment melanopsin (OPN4), together with rods and cones, provide light information driving nonvisual light responses. We examined nonvisual photoreception in mice lacking RPE65, a protein that is required for regeneration of visual chromophore in rods and cones. Although Rpe65 knockouts retain a small degree of rod function, we show here that circadian phase shifting responses in Rpe65(-/-) mice are attenuated far beyond what has been reported for rodless/coneless mice. Furthermore, the number of melanopsin-immunoreactive perikarya and the extent of dendritic arborizations were decreased in Rpe65 knockout mice compared with controls. To assess the nature of the photoreceptive defect in Rpe65 null mice, we eliminated either rods or melanopsin from Rpe65(-/-) retinas by generating (i) Rpe65(-/-) mice carrying a transgene (rdta) that results in selective elimination of rods and (ii) double knockout Rpe65(-/-);Opn4(-/-) mice. Surprisingly, rod loss in Rpe65 knockout mice resulted in restoration of circadian photosensitivity. Normal photoentrainment was lost in Rpe65(-/-);Opn4(-/-) mice, and, instead, a diurnal phenotype was observed. Our findings demonstrate that RPE65 is not required for ipRGC function but reveal the existence of a mechanism whereby rods may influence the function of ipRGCs.     

Progressive photoreceptor degeneration, outer segment dysplasia, and rhodopsin mislocalization in mice with targeted disruption of the retinitis pigmentosa-1 (Rp1) gene

Retinitis pigmentosa (RP), a common group of human retinopathic diseases, is characterized by late-onset night blindness, loss of peripheral vision, and diminished or absent electroretinogram (ERG) responses. Mutations in the photoreceptor-specific gene RP1 account for 5-10% of cases of autosomal dominant RP. We generated a mouse model of the RP1 form of RP by targeted disruption of the mouse ortholog (Rp1) of human RP1. In Rp1(-/-) mice, the number of rod photoreceptors decreased progressively over a period of 1 year, whereas that of cone photoreceptors did not change for at least 10 months. Light and electron microscopic analysis revealed that outer segments of Rp1(-/-) rods and cones were morphologically abnormal and became progressively shorter in length. Before photoreceptor cell death, rhodopsin was mislocalized in inner segments and cell bodies of Rp1(-/-) rods. Rod ERG amplitudes of Rp1(-/-) mice were significantly smaller than those of Rp1(+/+) mice over a period of 12 months, whereas those of Rp1(+/-) mice were intermediate. The decreases in cone ERG amplitudes were slower and less severe than those in rods. These findings demonstrate that Rp1 is required for normal morphogenesis of photoreceptor outer segments and also may play a role in rhodopsin transport to the outer segments. The phenotype of Rp1 mutant mice resembles the human RP1 disease. Thus, these mice provide a useful model for studies of RP1 function, disease pathology, and therapeutic interventions.     

Hepatic precursors derived from murine embryonic stem cells contribute to regeneration of injured liver

We established an efficient system for differentiation, expansion and isolation of hepatic progenitor cells from mouse embryonic stem (ES) cells and evaluated their capacity to repopulate injured liver. Using mouse ES cells transfected with the green fluorescent protein (GFP) reporter gene regulated by albumin (ALB) enhancer/promoter, we found that a serum-free chemically defined medium supports formation of embryoid bodies (EBs) and differentiation of hepatic lineage cells in the absence of exogenous growth factors or feeder cell layers. The first GFP+ cells expressing ALB were detected in close proximity to "beating" myocytes after 7 days of EB cultures. GFP+ cells increased in number, acquired hepatocyte-like morphology and hepatocyte-specific markers (i.e., ALB, AAT, TO, and G6P), and by 28 days represented more than 30% of cells isolated from EB outgrowths. The FACS-purified GFP+ cells developed into functional hepatocytes without evidence of cell fusion and participated in the repairing of diseased liver when transplanted into MUP-uPA/SCID mice. The ES cell-derived hepatocytes were responsive to normal growth regulation and proliferated at the same rate as the host hepatocytes after an additional growth stimulus from CCl(4)-induced liver injury. The transplanted GFP+ cells also differentiated into biliary epithelial cells. In conclusion, a highly enriched population of committed hepatocyte precursors can be generated from ES cells in vitro for effective cell replacement therapy.     

Guanylate cyclase-activating protein (GCAP) 1 rescues cone recovery kinetics in GCAP1/GCAP2 knockout mice

Mediated by guanylate cyclase-activating proteins (GCAPs), cytoplasmic Ca2+ levels regulate the activity of photoreceptor guanylate cyclase (GC) and the synthesis of cGMP, the internal transmitter of phototransduction. When GCAP1 is expressed in transgenic mice on a GCAP null background, it restores the wild-type flash responses in rod photoreceptors. In this communication, we explored the role of GCAP1 in cone photoreceptors by using electroretinograms (ERGs). Under cone isolation conditions, ERGs recorded from mice lacking both GCAP1 and GCAP2 had normal amplitudes of the saturated a-wave and b-wave. However, recordings from these mice demonstrated a widened b-wave and increased sensitivity of both M- and UV-cone systems. Paired-flash ERGs revealed a delayed recovery of both the cone driven b-wave and a-wave and suggest that the delay originated from the photoreceptors. To test whether GCAP1 could restore normal cone response recovery, mice that expressed only transgenic GCAP1 in the absence of wild-type GCAP expression were tested. Immunohistochemical analysis demonstrated that cones of these mice expressed high levels of GCAP1. Paired-flash ERGs showed that the recovery of the cone-driven a-wave was restored to normal, whereas recovery of the cone-driven b-wave was slightly faster than that observed in wild-type mice. These studies reveal that, similar to rods, deletion of GCAP1 and GCAP2 delays the recovery of light responses in cones and GCAP1 restores the recovery of cone responses in the absence of GCAP2.     

Evolutionary transformation of rod photoreceptors in the all-cone retina of a diurnal garter snake

Vertebrate retinas are generally composed of rod (dim-light) and cone (bright-light) photoreceptors with distinct morphologies that evolved as adaptations to nocturnal/crepuscular and diurnal light environments. Over 70 years ago, the “transmutation” theory was proposed to explain some of the rare exceptions in which a photoreceptor type is missing, suggesting that photoreceptors could evolutionarily transition between cell types. Although studies have shown support for this theory in nocturnal geckos, the origins of all-cone retinas, such as those found in diurnal colubrid snakes, remain a mystery. Here we investigate the evolutionary fate of the rods in a diurnal garter snake and test two competing hypotheses: (i) that the rods, and their corresponding molecular machinery, were lost or (ii) that the rods were evolutionarily modified to resemble, and function, as cones. Using multiple approaches, we find evidence for a functional and unusually blue-shifted rhodopsin that is expressed in small single “cones.” Moreover, these cones express rod transducin and have rod ultrastructural features, providing strong support for the hypothesis that they are not true cones, as previously thought, but rather are modified rods. Several intriguing features of garter snake rhodopsin are suggestive of a more cone-like function. We propose that these cone-like rods may have evolved to regain spectral sensitivity and chromatic discrimination as a result of ancestral losses of middle-wavelength cone opsins in early snake evolution. This study illustrates how sensory evolution can be shaped not only by environmental constraints but also by historical contingency in forming new cell types with convergent functionality.How complex structures can arise has long fascinated evolutionary biologists, and the evolution of the eye, as noted by Charles Darwin (1), is perhaps the most famous example. Within the vertebrate eye, the light-sensing photoreceptors are complex, highly specialized cellular structures that can be divided into two general types based on their distinct morphologies and functions: cones, which are active during the day and contain cone opsin pigments, and rods, which mediate dim-light vision and contain rhodopsin (RH1) (2–4). The visual pigments contained in cone photoreceptors are classified into four different subtypes that mediate vision across the visible spectrum from the UV to the red (2). Although most vertebrate retinas are duplex, containing both cones and rods, squamate reptiles (lizards and snakes) are unusual, not only in having highly variable photoreceptor morphologies, but also for several instances of the absence of an entire class of photoreceptors, resulting in simplex retinas composed of only cones or rods (4).In a seminal book published in 1942, Walls (4) hypothesized that, during evolution, vertebrate photoreceptors could transform from one type to another, a process that he termed photoreceptor “transmutation.” As key examples of his theory, Walls (4) highlighted anatomical changes in the photoreceptors of snakes and geckos, two groups within which there have been significant shifts in diurnal and nocturnal activity patterns. Although several subsequent studies have investigated this hypothesis in geckos (5–9), whether the evolutionary transmutation of photoreceptors can happen in snakes remains an open question (10). Walls also noted a number of peculiar morphological adaptations in snake eyes, which he proposed were due to a subterranean phase early in snake evolution that led to degeneration of the ophidian visual system, resulting in loss of features common to other terrestrial vertebrates (4).Colubrid snakes are an ideal group to study Walls’s hypothesis of transmutation, due to their highly variable photoreceptor morphologies that range from all-cone in, at least some, diurnal species, such as Thamnophis (garter snakes), to all-rod in some nocturnal species, as well as species with the presumed ancestral condition of duplex retinas (4, 11). Previous studies in the diurnal colubrid Thamnophis have demonstrated an all-cone retina (4, 11–14), consisting of double cones and large single cones that express a long-wavelength pigment [presumably long wavelength-sensitive opsin (LWS)], and two classes of small single cone, one with a short-wavelength pigment [presumably short wavelength-sensitive 1 opsin (SWS1)] and the other with a middle-wavelength pigment, the identity of which is unclear (14). However, the ancestral condition for colubrids is likely to have been a duplex retina containing both rods and cones, similar to snakes such as pythons and boas, which have rods that express RH1, large single cones that express LWS, and small single cones that express SWS1 (Fig. 1) (4, 10, 11, 15, 16). The SWS2 and RH2 opsins, present ancestrally in vertebrates, appear to have been lost early in the evolution of snakes, perhaps as a result of their proposed fossorial origins (10, 17, 18).Open in a separate windowFig. 1.Illustration of evolutionary pathways for two alternative hypotheses for the evolution of an all-cone retina from a duplex ancestor in diurnal colubrids. In hypothesis 1 the rod photoreceptors, along with RH1, are lost, and an additional cone type is derived from duplication of an existing cone or retained from an ancestral condition that was lost in other snakes. In hypothesis 2 the rod photoreceptor is evolutionarily modified into a cone photoreceptor, maintaining expression of RH1 and other rod-specific phototransduction machinery.Based on these findings, we can formulate two main hypotheses for the evolution of the all-cone retina of diurnal colubrids from the duplex ancestral condition (Fig. 1). The first is that the rods were lost, and RH1 and other components of the visual transduction cascade unique to rod photoreceptors were either lost or targeted to cones. The second hypothesis is that the rods were evolutionarily modified to resemble the appearance, and presumably the function, of cones. If the rods were modified to resemble cones, we might expect a subset of cones to possess molecular components, such as RH1, and morphological features consistent with a rod ancestry. To test these hypotheses, we examined the photoreceptors and visual pigments of a diurnal garter snake (Thamnophis proximus) by combining multiple methodologies including sequencing and molecular evolutionary analyses of opsin genes, microspectrophotometry (MSP) of intact photoreceptor cells, in vitro expression of visual pigments, and scanning and transmission electron microscopy (SEM and TEM) and immunohistochemistry of T. proximus retinas. The combined results of these experiments provide strong evidence that RH1 and other components of the rod visual transduction machinery are expressed in a subset of cone-like photoreceptors with rod ultrastructural features, and that the RH1-expressing “cones” are not true cones, as previously thought, but rather are modified (i.e., “transmuted”), cone-like rods. Our results shed new light on the evolutionary origins of the all-cone retinas of diurnal colubrid snakes, demonstrating how ancestral losses can be compensated by evolutionary modification of existing cellular structures.     

Dendrites of rod bipolar cells sprout in normal aging retina

The aging nervous system is known to manifest a variety of degenerative and regressive events. Here we report the unexpected growth of dendrites in the retinas of normal old mice. The dendrites of many rod bipolar cells in aging mice were observed to extend well beyond their normal strata within the outer plexiform layer to innervate the outer nuclear layer where they appeared to form contacts with the spherules of rod photoreceptors. Such dendritic sprouting increased with age and was evident at all retinal eccentricities. These results provide evidence of retinal plasticity associated with normal aging.     

Morphological, physiological, and biochemical changes in rhodopsin knockout mice

Mutations in rod opsin, the visual pigment protein of rod photoreceptors, account for ≈15% of all inherited human retinal degenerations. However, the physiological and molecular events underlying the disease process are not well understood. One approach to this question has been to study transgenic mice expressing opsin genes containing defined mutations. A caveat of this approach is that even the overexpression of normal opsin leads to photoreceptor cell degeneration. To overcome the problem, we have reduced or eliminated endogenous rod opsin content by targeted gene disruption. Retinas in mice lacking both opsin alleles initially developed normally, except that rod outer segments failed to form. Within months of birth, photoreceptor cells degenerated completely. Retinas from mice with a single copy of the opsin gene developed normally, and rods elaborated outer segments of normal size but with half the normal complement of rhodopsin. Photoreceptor cells in these retinas also degenerated but did so over a much slower time course. Physiological and biochemical experiments showed that rods from mice with a single opsin gene were ≈50% less sensitive to light, had accelerated flash-response kinetics, and contained ≈50% more phosducin than wild-type controls.     

Inhibition of the visual cycle in vivo by 13-cis retinoic acid protects from light damage and provides a mechanism for night blindness in isotretinoin therapy

Isotretinoin (13-cis retinoic acid) is frequently prescribed for severe acne [Peck, G. L., Olsen, T. G., Yoder, F. W., Strauss, J. S., Downing, D. T., Pandya, M., Butkus, D. & Arnaud-Battandier, J. (1979) N. Engl. J. Med. 300, 329-333] but can impair night vision [Fraunfelder, F. T., LaBraico, J. M. & Meyer, S. M. (1985) Am. J. Ophthalmol. 100, 534-537] shortly after the beginning of therapy [Shulman, S. R. (1989) Am. J. Public Health 79, 1565-1568]. As rod photoreceptors are responsible for night vision, we administered isotretinoin to rats to learn whether night blindness resulted from rod cell death or from rod functional impairment. High-dose isotretinoin was given daily for 2 months and produced systemic toxicity, but this caused no histological loss of rod photoreceptors, and rod-driven electroretinogram amplitudes were normal after prolonged dark adaptation. Additional studies showed, however, that even a single dose of isotretinoin slowed the recovery of rod signaling after exposure to an intense bleaching light, and that rhodopsin regeneration was markedly slowed. When only a single dose was given, rod function recovered to normal within several days. Rods and cones both showed slow recovery from bleach after isotretinoin in rats and in mice. HPLC analysis of ocular retinoids after isotretinoin and an intense bleach showed decreased levels of rhodopsin chromophore, 11-cis retinal, and the accumulation of the biosynthetic intermediates, 11-cis and all-trans retinyl esters. Isotretinoin was also found to protect rat photoreceptors from light-induced damage, suggesting that strategies of altering retinoid cycling may have therapeutic implications for some forms of retinal and macular degeneration.     

Transducin translocation contributes to rod survival and enhances synaptic transmission from rods to rod bipolar cells

In rod photoreceptors, several phototransduction components display light-dependent translocation between cellular compartments. Notably, the G protein transducin translocates from rod outer segments to inner segments/spherules in bright light, but the functional consequences of translocation remain unclear. We generated transgenic mice where light-induced transducin translocation is impaired. These mice exhibited slow photoreceptor degeneration, which was prevented if they were dark-reared. Physiological recordings showed that control and transgenic rods and rod bipolar cells displayed similar sensitivity in darkness. After bright light exposure, control rods were more strongly desensitized than transgenic rods. However, in rod bipolar cells, this effect was reversed; transgenic rod bipolar cells were more strongly desensitized than control. This sensitivity reversal indicates that transducin translocation in rods enhances signaling to rod bipolar cells. The enhancement could not be explained by modulation of inner segment conductances or the voltage sensitivity of the synaptic Ca²⁺ current, suggesting interactions of transducin with the synaptic machinery.     

Genetically engineered mice with an additional class of cone photoreceptors: implications for the evolution of color vision

Among eutherian mammals, only primates possess trichromatic color vision. In Old World primates, trichromacy was made possible by a visual pigment gene duplication. In most New World primates, trichromacy is based on polymorphic variation in a single X-linked gene that produces, by random X inactivation, a patchy mosaic of spectrally distinct cone photoreceptors in heterozygous females. In the present work, we have modeled the latter strategy in a nonprimate by replacing the X-linked mouse green pigment gene with one encoding the human red pigment. In the mouse retina, the human red pigment seems to function normally, and heterozygous female mice express the human red and mouse green pigments at levels that vary between animals. Multielectrode array recordings from heterozygous female retinas reveal significant variation in the chromatic sensitivities of retinal ganglion cells. The data are consistent with a model in which these retinal ganglion cells draw their inputs indiscriminately from a coarse-grained mosaic of red and green cones. These observations support the ideas that (i) chromatic signals could arise from stochastic variation in inputs drawn nonselectively from red and green cones and (ii) tissue mosaicism due to X chromosome inactivation could be one mechanism for driving the evolution of CNS diversity.