Which health services reduce maternal mortality? Evidence from ratings of maternal health services

We report cross-national regressions for maternal mortality in 49 developing countries, using indices of the adequacy of maternal health services derived from ratings by at least 10 experts per country. As in previous such regressions, a socioeconomic factor - in this case per capita income - has a significant effect, but having a trained attendant at delivery does not. Instead, the ratings index for access to services has a consistent, significant effect regardless of which estimates of maternal mortality ratios are predicted. Further analysis suggests that access to treatment for pregnancy complications and to services that help avoid pregnancy and birth are most closely related to lower mortality. Service ratings are interdependent, however, so that focusing only on individual services may not be productive.     

Does patient-centered care improve provision of preventive services?

OBJECTIVES: While patient-centered care (PCC) is desirable for many reasons, its relationship to treatment outcomes is controversial. We evaluated the relationship between PCC and the provision of preventive services. METHODS: We obtained facility-level estimates of how well each VA hospital provided PCC from the 1999 ambulatory Veterans Satisfaction Survey. PCC delivery was measured by the average percentage of responses per facility indicating satisfactory performance from items in 8 PCC domains: access, incorporating patient preferences, patient education, emotional support, visit coordination, overall coordination of care, continuity, and courtesy. Additional predictors included patient population and facility characteristics. Our outcome was a previously validated hospital-level benchmarking score describing facility-level performance across 12 U.S. Preventive Services Task Force-recommended interventions, using the 1999 Veterans Health Survey. RESULTS: Facility-level delivery of preventive services ranged from an overall mean of 90% compliance for influenza vaccinations to 18% for screening for seat belt use. Mean overall PCC scores ranged from excellent (>90% for the continuity of care and courtesy of care PCC domains) to modest (<70% for patient education). Correlates of better preventive service delivery included how often patients were able to discuss their concerns with their provider, the percent of visits at which patients saw their usual provider, and the percent of patients receiving >90% of care from a VA hospital. CONCLUSION: Improved communication between patients and providers, and continuity of care are associated with increased provision of preventive services, while other aspects of PCC are not strongly related to delivery of preventive services.     

Is language a barrier to the use of preventive services?

Objective

To isolate the effect of spoken language from financial barriers to care, we examined the relation of language to use of preventive services in a system with universal access.

Design

Cross-sectional survey.

Setting

Household population of women living in Ontario, Canada, in 1990.

Participants

Subjects were 22,448 women completing the 1990 Ontario Health Survey, a population-based random sample of households.

Measurements and Main Results

We defined language as the language spoken in the home and assessed self-reported receipt of breast examination, mammogram and Pap testing. We used logistic regression to calculate odds ratios for each service adjusting for potential sources of confounding: socioeconomic characteristics, contact with the health care system, and measures reflecting culture. Ten percent of the women spoke a non-English language at home (4% French. 6% other). After adjustment, compared with English speakers, French-speaking women were significantly less likely to receive breast exams or mammography, and other language speakers were less likely to receive Pap testing.

Conclusions

Women whose main spoken language was not English were less likely to receive important preventive services. Improving communication with patients with limited English may enhance participation in screening programs.     

Physician, heal Thyself? Regular source of care and use of preventive health services among physicians

BACKGROUND: Little is known about the regular source of care (RSOC) among physicians, a group whose self-care may reflect the attitudes and recommendations they convey to their patients. METHODS: We performed a cohort study of physicians who graduated from the Johns Hopkins School of Medicine from 1948 through 1964 to identify predictors of not having an RSOC, and to determine whether not having an RSOC was associated with subsequent receipt of preventive services. The RSOC was assessed in a 1991 survey; use of cancer screening tests and the influenza vaccine was assessed in 1997. RESULTS: The response rate in 1991 was 77% (915 respondents); 35% (312) had no RSOC. Internists (odds ratio [OR], 3.26; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.58-6.74), surgeons (OR, 2.42; 95% CI, 1.17-5.02), and pathologists (OR, 5.46; 95% CI, 2.09-14.29) were significantly more likely to not have an RSOC than pediatricians. Not having an RSOC was inversely related to the belief that health is determined by health professionals (OR, 0.45; 95% CI, 0.29-0.68) and directly related to the belief that chance (OR, 1.90; 95% CI, 1.28-2.82) determines health. Not having an RSOC in 1991 predicted not being screened for breast, colon, and prostate cancer, as well as not receiving an influenza vaccine at 6 years of follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: A large percentage of physicians in our sample had no RSOC, and this was associated with both medical specialty and beliefs about control of health outcomes. Not having an RSOC was significantly associated with failure to use preventive services several years later. Arch Intern Med. 2000;160:3209-3214.     

Do all services provided as part of a clinical trial require research ethics and governance review?

Appropriate ethical oversight underpins the conduct of all clinical trials in Australia. In addition, clinical trials require a suitable approach to research governance in order to ensure that research is appropriately governed. However, such governance processes are often onerous and time‐consuming and are not required when trial practices are more appropriately understood as standard of care clinical services.     

How are surgical theatres in rural Africa utilized? A review of five years of services at a district hospital in Ghana

Although the extent of the unmet need for surgeries is well-known, little is known about the surgery performed in district hospitals in sub-Saharan Africa. We review five years of utilization of theatre services at the Kintampo Hospital in rural Ghana. The source of data was the theatre logbook and other hospital records for the period 2005-2009. During this time, 1391 surgeries were performed in the theatre. This approximates a rate of 250/100,000 population. Fifty-two percent were performed in patients aged 18-35 years. The most frequently performed surgeries were: caesarean sections (46%); hernia repair (41%); and other laparotomies (10%). The major indications were cephalopelvic disproportion, right inguinal hernia and typhoid perforation, respectively. Typhoid perforation was the main indication for surgery in children aged less than 10 years. The potential for an expansion of the scope of services should be explored in order to improve access to essential surgery for this population.     

Front-line service providers’ appraisal of Saskatchewan’s HIV services and strategy: A qualitative study

This qualitative study examined front-line health care providers’ understandings of the Saskatchewan Ministry of Health’s 2010–2014 HIV strategy, their capacity building needs, and perspectives on how well they were implementing HIV services. Providers’ experiences of engaging people living with HIV, community leaders, and communities affected by the epidemic reveal a need to strengthen interprofessional networks. Our findings also indicate the need for HIV services to respond to coexisting challenges, including substance use, violence, and mental health care for people living with HIV. Programs in rural northern Saskatchewan should also address homelessness, disparities in access to care, and HIV stigma issues.     

Quality of sexually transmitted infections services for female sex workers in Abidjan, Côte d'Ivoire

OBJECTIVES: To assess the quality of sexually transmitted infections (STI) care in health care facilities in Abidjan attended by female sex workers. METHODS: A cross-sectional study was conducted in June 2000 in the 29 health care facilities and 10 pharmacies, which were reported as points of first encounter for STI care by female sex workers in a previous study on health seeking behaviour. Evaluation components included: (1) checklists of equipment and STI drugs in the facilities; (2) interviews with health care providers and pharmacists; (3) direct observation of the provider/client interaction; (4) exit interviews with women attending with STI or genital problems. RESULTS: Private health care facilities were more expensive, had fewer clients, and had less equipment and medical staff than public facilities, with the exception of the special female sex worker clinic. A total of 60 health care providers and 29 pharmacists were interviewed. There was no difference in their scoring on syndromic approach case studies, with the exception of the nurse assistants, who scored less. Overall scores for correct treatment were lowest for the pharmacists. We observed 513 provider-client interactions, of which 161 related to STIs or genital problems in women. Questions about recent sexual contacts were asked in only 20% and preventive messages were given in only 9% of the cases with STI/genital problems. Of 161 clients interviewed, 44% complained about a long waiting time, and 39% thought the health care provider had adequately explained the problem to them. CONCLUSIONS: The opportunity for improvement of STI case management in health care facilities in Abidjan where female sex workers go for STI care is enormous. Public and private health care facilities should be made more accessible for sex workers, and their services should be upgraded to better respond to the sexual health needs of high risk women.