Evaluación de estrategias de implantación del Proyecto Centros Comprometidos con la Excelencia en Cuidados en España

ObjectiveTo identify favourable elements and barriers to implementation in the Program of Best Practice Spotlight Organization® that establish clinical practice guidelines of the Registered Nurse’ Association of Ontario, so that future experiences could benefit from the assessments presented here.MethodEvaluation research study of the process of implementing guidelines in institutions that make up the first two cohorts of the programme in Spain, through analysis of contents of implantation reports and inductive process, reading, interpretation, coding and categorized according to SWOT structure: Strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats.ResultsReports from 18 centres in 12 Autonomous Communities have been analyzed, including 22 different guidelines. As weaknesses, problems related to information systems and their exploitation stand out for frequency and intensity. Other elements related to dissemination of results, to professionals, care and factors related to the institution are presented. Standing out as threats are the instability of staff and continued changes in Senior Management or corporate policies. Among the strengths, the exclusive dedication of personnel to the project and its link to institutional objectives are distinguished. As opportunities, the possibility of standardized comparison of own results with others, as well as the dissemination of results are highlighted.ConclusionA useful pattern is set up to approach implementation in other scenarios, where changes in professional culture, training, communication and leadership, as well as aligning interests of managers and politicians, facilitate ideal conditions for Evidence-Based Practice.     

Implantación de la Guía de buenas prácticas: valoración del ictus mediante la atención continuada en pacientes hospitalizados

IntroductionStroke is an important cause of morbidity and mortality in adults and implies high social and healthcare costs due to the consequences it causes. To minimize these, it is important to apply best practice guidelines that ensure evidence-based care and reduce clinical variability. The objective of the study is to evaluate the results of implantation of the Ictus Best Practice Guideline for attending in-hospital stroke patients.MethodQuasi-experimental pre-post intervention study. Over 18 years of age admitted to the University Hospital Complex of Albacete and Hospital Complex of Navarra with a diagnosis of stroke. Process variables: Neurological assessment (Canadian Scale and the National Institute of Health Stroke Scale), dysphagia assessment (Water Test and the Volume-Viscosity Clinical Exploration Method), risk falls (Downton Scale), pain detection (Numerical Scale), pressure injury risk (Braden Scale), health education. Outcome variables: Aspiration pneumonia, falls, independence of daily life activities (modified Barthel and Rankin index), pressure injuries and pain intensity.Results1270 patients were evaluated in CHUA and 627 in CHN, most were men and the average age was over 69 years, with a higher incidence of ischaemic strokes. In CHUA 16 pressure sores, 17 falls and 20 cases of aspiration pneumonia were recorded and 15 cases of pressure sores were identified in CHN. An increase of cases could be attributed to the greater number of patients evaluated and the increased nursing awareness about recording adverse events.ConclusionsApplication of guideline recommendations improved statistically significantly throughout the implementation time. Some possibilities for improvement are detected, so it is necessary to continue working on both the quality of care provided and the health outcomes of patients.     

Implantación de la Guía de buenas prácticas en prevención de lesiones por presión: desarrollo,resultados y sostenibilidad

AimTo assess the impact of implementing the “Risk Assessment and Prevention of Pressure Injuries (PI)” guideline on adherence to its recommendations, the prevalence of PI and the sustainability of results, and to analyse the implementation strategies, sustainability and barriers detected.MethodsA retrospective observational study (June 2015 to December 2018). Two periods were studied (P1: Preparation and P2: Sustainability). The programme reports and data from the medical records of patients discharged from the 4 participating hospitals were analysed with regard to adherence to preventive recommendations and health outcomes in terms of the presence of pressure injuries per centre.ResultsA total of 13,515 patients were included, of whom 4,523 were at risk for PI and 722 had PI. Of the patients, 82.9% underwent a risk assessment for PI on admission. A decrease in this assessment on admission was observed between P1:89.1% vs. P2: 81% P<.001. Of the patients at risk, 42.1% were reassessed during their admission and a significant increase was observed between the periods P1: 30.7% vs. P2:46%; P<.001. 63.2% had a special pressure management surface, with a significant increase between P1:55.3% vs. P2: 65%; P<.001. The overall prevalence of PI was 5.5% and a significant decrease was observed on comparing P1: 6.6% vs. P2:5.1%; P=.003. The prevalence of nosocomial PI remained constant at 2.1%, P1:2% and P2:2.1%; P=.708.Institutional commitment, the appointment of leaders, drawing up of action plans, and training are outstanding strategies in all the centres.ConclusionsThis study shows that there is adequate adherence to the main recommendations of the guideline. A statistically significant improvement was observed in adherence to 2 out of the 3 recommendations assessed. The implantation and sustainability strategies implemented have been contributed to maintenance and/or improving results over time.     

Experiencia en la implantación y consolidación de las Guías de buenas prácticas de la Registered Nurses’ Association of Ontario (RNAO) en el ámbito clínico y académico en Colombia

This paper describes the results of the implementation, consolidation and future projection of the Best practice guidelines of the Registered Nurses’ Association of Ontario (RNAO) in clinical and academic scenarios in Santander, Colombia. The tool proposed by the RNAO was used for the implementation of the guidelines in both clinical and academic settings. Preliminary results on the implementation of the guidelines are presented in this paper. In the clinical setting, the implementation of the guidelines has made it possible to start the process of standardizing care across the institution, with systematic follow-up based on indicators. This has allowed decision-making and visualization of the quality of nursing care provided by nurses in their different roles. In the academic scenario, implementing the guidelines has strengthened teaching and research functions, and, to a lesser extent, continuing education and social projection processes. In the consolidation phase, advances were achieved in 10 components, relevant to teachers, students, and practice scenarios of public / private health institutions, users (patients/caregivers), health personnel and other nursing programmes at a national and international level. Implementing the clinical practice guidelines has reduced the gap between the clinical and the academic scenarios, where collaborative and inter-institutional work is enhanced to obtain better patient outcomes, based on the available evidence.     

Implantación del nuevo modelo de formación práctico-clínica en Andalucía: una evaluación cualitativa en las titulaciones de Enfermería y Fisioterapia

ObjectiveThe design of new Bachelor degree courses, together with the agreement reached between the Regional Government of Andalusia and Andalusian universities shape the new clinical training model for Health Science students. The aim of this project is to present a qualitative evaluation of the implementation of the new model in Nursing and Physiotherapy degrees at the University of Almeria and the Andalusian Public Health System.MethodAn exploratory qualitative study using document content analysis techniques, by analyzing 12 reports from teachers and those responsible for Practicum in Nursing and Physiotherapy degrees at the University of Almeria. The reports included opinions and proposals from university and clinical placement teachers, healthcare professionals or clinical placement tutors, students, and those in positions of responsibility as regards clinical placements.ResultsThree categories emerged in the data analysis: Health system organization, with sub-categories of disparity between shifts, difficulties with supervisor coordination, feelings of a lack of control, disparities in evaluation criteria and geographic distribution; academic organization, with sub-categories of short rotations, a lack of information received by the clinical placement tutor, and carrying out placements without studying the theory; and management of the work agreement, with sub-categories of being discouraged by what is received in return, extra work for those in charge, and delays in evaluations.ConclusionThe study suggests a need to support and guide clinical tutors, to increase coordination between the university and health services, to organize the students’ theoretical and practical training and to provide the management of the model with flexibility and transparency.     

Satisfacción del paciente con la atención de enfermería

Patient satisfaction is one of the outcomes of health care. We determined the level of satisfaction with nursing care among hospital patients, measured as a differential score between expectations and perceptions, and analyzed the relevant socio-demographic and care-related characteristics.A cross-sectional study was performed by sending a postal survey with the SERVQUAL scale to all patients discharged from the hospital in 5 distinct periods over 2 years.The psychometric characteristics were validated for their reliability and validity. The determinant variables on the SERVQUAL score were analyzed by ANCOVA. The overall differential score was −0.74. Determinants of satisfaction were sex (p < 0.001), level of education (p < 0.019), the overall evaluation of the hospital (p < 0.001) and knowing the name of the nurse (p < 0.001).     

Fiabilidad del uso de fotografías en la clasificación de heridas relacionadas con la dependencia

ObjectiveTo examine the reliability of the classification of dependence-related lesions using photography.MethodA panel of 5 experts carried out a blind, anonymous and independent assessment of 24 photographs. Images were sent by electronic mail, together with an anonymous questionnaire that was sent back to a referee of the research group. We suggested 8 options for classification: pressure ulcer (categories I, II, III, IV, or ‘suspect of deep-tissue damage’), moisture-associated damage, pressure-moisture combined aetiology and multifactorial lesion. Concordance index was calculated for every photography. Cohen‘s Kappa index with ‘jackknife’ technique were calculated for every photograph and category. We used the statistical programme Epidat 4.2.ResultsObserved agreement was variable, between 4 and 1 depending on the photography. A consensus of 100% was observed in 6 images. Global Kappa resulted as moderate: 0.5202 (IC95%: 0.3850- 0.6542). Intra-group concordance resulted moderate in 4 categories, low in 3, and high only for pressure ulcer category II (Kappa 0.8924. IC 95%: 0.7388-1.0456). Inter-observer concordance was 0.6602 (IC 95%: 0.4969-0.8081).ConclusionsThe reliability of the use of photographs for the categorization of dependence-related lesions is moderate, being higher for category II pressure ulcers and low for more complex wounds. This method must be used with care, and education on the subject is required.     

Género y profesión en la evolución histórica de la Enfermería Comunitaria en España

Community and public health is probably the field where nurses have achieved the highest levels of professional independence, and their contribution is most valued. However, there are still major obstacles to full development, some of them linked to gender. It is therefore important to analyse the historical background of this situation in Spain in order to gain a better understanding of the many problems and shortcomings that still persist in Community Nursing today. Community nurses contributed to the development of Public Health in contemporary Spain, starting in the 1920s and culminating in the Second Republic. However, the Franco regime brought a halt to the process of professionalisation. By analysing the public conflict between visiting female nurses and practicantes (professional male medical auxiliary technicians) during the Second Republic and throughout the Franco regime, we examine the impact of gender on the development of nursing in Spain as one of the conditioning factors, and how it continues to influence the structuring of competencies and the distribution of responsibilities and power in this field.     

Comparación de la solución salina con la heparina en el mantenimiento de la permeabilidad del catéter arterial en las Unidades de Cuidados Intensivos: una revisión sistemática

ObjectiveTo find the best scientific evidence on the effectiveness of the saline solution compared with heparin in maintaining patency of the arterial cannula in intensive care units.MethodA review of the evidence was made using the databases: MEDLINE, CINAHL, CUIDEN and Cochrane Library. The criteria that limited the search were: the type of study (randomised control trials (RCTs), systematic reviews and/or meta-analysis), the year of publication of studies (1990–2009) and language, English and / or Spanish. Finally, a critical appraisal of selected papers was carried out.ResultsTwo meta-analysis and six RCTs were identified and analysed. Results from one of the meta-analysis and two RCTs supported the use of heparin for maintaining peripheral arterial catheter patency. In the rest, however, no significant differences were found regarding the arterial catheter patency between the control (saline) and intervention (heparin).ConclusionsRecent studies suggest that it is not necessary to use heparin to maintain a patent arterial catheter. From this review the performing of a nationwide multicentre study is proposed to implement the use of saline in Spain.