Unilateral vocal fold paralysis: causes, options and outcomes.

BACKGROUND: This study presents the current aetiology of and management options for vocal fold paralysis. METHODS: One hundred and eight patients with unilateral vocal fold paralysis, managed by The Sydney Voice Clinic from 1989 to 1996, are reviewed. Aetiology of the palsy was classified as iatrogenic (45 of 108), idiopathic (36 of 108) and other defined causes (27 of 108). Nineteen patients were observed with the rest being managed with speech therapy alone (38 of 108), surgery (24 of 108) or surgery with adjuvant speech therapy (27 of 108). Surgical techniques included vocal fold augmentation (n = 43), thyroplasty (n = 20) and laryngeal re-innervation (n = 12). RESULTS: Overall 78 of 108 patients had restoration of near normal to normal voice with an additional 14 attaining a very good voice or better (voice outcome <2). CONCLUSIONS: Early intervention for symptomatic patients was found to be rewarding and safe. Vocal fold augmentation with autologous fat was particularly successful in achieving sustained improvement of voice.     

Autologous fat injection laryngoplasty for unilateral vocal fold paralysis

Background: Fat injection laryngoplasty has been used at the Sydney Voice Clinic for selected cases of unilateral vocal fold paralysis since 1989. Methods: Forty‐five consecutive cases deemed suitable for treatment by this technique are presented in this paper. Results: Mean follow up for this group of patients was 33 months. Over the period of follow up, 39 of the 45 patients achieved normal or near normal voice, with four patients requiring additional surgical intervention. Conclusion: Fat injection laryngoplasty is a quick, simple, inexpensive and reliable procedure, with few complications and good long‐term results in suitable selected cases of unilateral vocal fold paralysis.     

Acoustic assessment of the voice quality before and after medialization thyroplasty using the titanium vocal fold medialization implant (tvfmi)

OBJECTIVE: This study was designed to objectify the vocal outcome in patients with unilateral vocal fold paralysis. Acoustic parameters were evaluated and compared to perceptual voice sound assessments before and after medialization thyroplasty using the titanium vocal fold medialization implant (TVFMI). STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Twenty-eight patients underwent external medialization thyroplasty using TVFMI. Prior to and after surgery videostroboscopy, perceptual voice evaluation and acoustic analysis based on the computerized "hoarseness diagram" were performed. RESULTS: In videostroboscopy, most patients showed an almost complete glottal closure after thyroplasty. The statistical analysis revealed a significant improvement in the perceptual voice parameters (p<0.001). The acoustic measurements could objectify the positive impact on the voice after thyroplasty (p< or =0.001). CONCLUSION: The results confirm that the TVFMI is an excellent and individually adjustable device for medialization thyroplasty. The "hoarseness diagram" allows the vocal outcome after surgery to be documented and objectified in an easy and reliable manner.     

Benign parathyroid cyst causing vocal fold paralysis: a case report and review of the literature

BACKGROUND: Parathyroid cysts are uncommon, frequently asymptomatic lesions of the neck and superior mediastinum. Symptomatic parathyroid cysts are very rare, with roughly only 200 cases reported in the literature. Of these, only nine cases have been reported with recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) paralysis METHODS: We report a case of a 49-year-old man initially seen with a 6-month history of worsening hoarseness. Physical examination revealed a palpable 3-cm, firm, smooth, nontender mass of the right thyroid lobe. Fiberoscopic laryngoscopy showed right vocal cord immobility consistent with RLN paralysis. After CT and fine-needle aspiration of the mass, the patient underwent a right thyroid lobectomy. During surgery, the recurrent laryngeal nerve was found to be stretched and adherent to a right inferior lobe mass. RESULTS: Histologic analysis of the surgical specimen revealed a benign parathyroid adenomatous cyst. Postoperatively, the patient's voice improved markedly. This case represents an extremely rare return of function of the RLN after cyst removal. CONCLUSION: Parathyroid cysts should be included in the differential diagnosis for vocal fold paralysis.     

Vocal fold paralysis and progressive cricopharyngeal stenosis reversed by cricopharyngeal myotomy

Three infants with progressive upper esophageal stenosis had bilateral vocal fold paralysis. The patients were apparently normal at birth and without neurologic abnormality. Cricopharyngeal myotomy, followed by serial dilatations, relieved esophageal stenosis and restored the swallowing function. Vocal fold mobility, to the authors’ surprise, also recovered after myotomy in 2 patients. Vocal paralysis persisted in the first patient encountered, although this case was complicated by longstanding tracheostomy. Decannulation in this case was successful at 4 years only after arytenopexy and cricoid interposition grafting. Direct laryngoscopy findings showed weak abductive motion of 1 vocal fold at 14-year follow-up. Loss of vocal function secondary to constriction by a cricopharyngeal band has been previously undocumented. The potential reversibility of both vocal paralysis and esophageal stenosis by surgical cricopharyngeal myotomy is of significant clinical importance.     

Management of bilateral vocal fold paralysis: experience at the University of Athens.

The treatment of patients with vocal fold paralysis presents a challenge to the otolaryngologist-head and neck surgeon. Many techniques have been proposed to manage individuals with unilateral or bilateral vocal fold paralysis. We herein describe the experience of our department in dealing with bilateral vocal fold paralysis. At the University of Athens, patients presenting with symptomatic bilateral paralysis are treated with a posterior cordectomy by using the CO2 or KTP-532 laser. During the last 5 years, we have treated 20 patients (8 men and 12 women) presenting with symptomatic bilateral vocal fold paralysis. For augmentation of the glottic airway, a modification of Kashima's cordotomy was used, completing a partial posterior cordectomy of one or both true and false vocal folds with the CO2 laser (15 patients) and the KTP-532 laser (5 patients). An elective tracheotomy was done before the cordotomy. Complications, such as infection, stridor, or dyspnea, were minimal. Although no objective voice analysis was performed, all patients were able to communicate without any phonation device and were satisfied with the result of the surgery. When compared with other techniques, the advantages offered by the posterior cordectomy included rapidity and simplicity in concept, reliability of outcome, short hospitalization, low risk of complications, and the possibility for revision when necessary (posterior cordectomy). From the successful postsurgical results of this study, it can be concluded that the posterior cordectomy is a reliable treatment option for the management of patients with bilateral vocal fold paralysis.     

Pediatric vocal fold paralysis after cardiac surgery: rate of recovery and sequelae.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the rate of recovery of pediatric vocal fold paralysis (VFP) after cardiac surgery. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Retrospective case series from January 2000 to 2005 at 4 tertiary care pediatric hospitals. RESULTS: A total of 109 children with VFP were identified. Of 80 patients with follow-up >3 months, 28 (35%) recovered vocal fold function with a median time to diagnosis of recovery of 6.6 months. Fifty-two (65%) patients had persistent vocal fold paralysis with a median follow-up time of 16.4 months. Twenty-five (45%) of 55 patients demonstrated aspiration or laryngeal penetration with modified barium swallow. Twenty-nine (27%) of the 109 patients underwent surgical intervention for their airway, feeding, or voice. CONCLUSIONS: Pediatric VFP is not an uncommon complication after cardiac surgery and can result in serious sequelae. This study demonstrates a 35% rate of recovery, 45% rate of aspiration, and 27% rate of complications that require surgical intervention.     

Perceptual voice characteristics in pediatric unilateral vocal fold paralysis.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the voice characteristics of pediatric unilateral vocal fold paralysis (UVFP). STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Retrospective series from a children's hospital, 1996 to present. RESULTS: Forty-two patients with a mean age of 7.1 years were diagnosed with UVFP in our voice clinic (prevalence = 5.4%). Paralysis was left sided in 88%, and was most commonly seen after cardiac surgery (28.5%) and prolonged intubation/prematurity (16.7%). Voice analysis showed a moderate degree of breathiness, mild-to-moderate hoarseness and straining, mild muscle tension, and soft loudness. Twenty-six percent of patients required surgical intervention, including injection into the paralyzed fold (7 patients) and medialization thyroplasty (4 patients). Pre-operatively, breathiness was worse (P < .05) in patients undergoing surgical intervention. CONCLUSIONS: Voice characteristics of pediatric UVFP include increased breathiness, hoarseness, straining, muscle tension, and soft loudness. One-fourth of patients underwent surgical intervention; breathiness was the predominant abnormal voice characteristic in the operative cohort. SIGNIFICANCE: The voice characteristics of pediatric patients with UVFP are described. EBM rating: C-4.     

Video-Assisted Thyroidectomy Significantly Reduces the Risk of Early Postthyroidectomy Voice and Swallowing Symptoms

Background Voice and swallowing symptoms are frequently reported after thyroidectomy even in absence of objective voice alterations. We evaluated the influence of the video-assisted approach on voice and swallowing outcome of thyroidectomy. Methods Sixty-five patients undergoing total thyroidectomy (TT) were recruited. Eligibility criteria were: nodule size ≤30 mm, thyroid volume ≤30 ml, no previous neck surgery. Exclusion criteria were: younger than aged 18 years and older than aged 75 years, vocal fold paralysis, history of voice, laryngeal or pulmonary diseases, malignancy other than papillary thyroid carcinoma. Patients were randomized for video-assisted (VAT) or conventional (CT) thyroidectomy. Videostrobolaryngoscopy (VSL), acoustic voice analysis (AVA), and maximum phonation time (MPT) evaluation were performed preoperatively and 3 months after TT. Subjective evaluation of voice (voice impairment score = VIS) and swallowing (swallowing impairment score = SIS) were obtained preoperatively, 1 week, 1 month, and 3 months after TT. Results Fifty-three patients completed the postoperative evaluation: 29 in the VAT group, and 24 in the CT group. No laryngeal nerves injury was shown at postoperative VSL. Mean postoperative MPT, F ₀, F _low, F _high, and the number of semitones were significantly reduced in the CT group but not in the VAT group. Mean VIS 3 months after surgery was significantly higher than preoperatively in CT group but not in the VAT group. Mean SIS was significantly decreased 1 and 3 months after VAT but not after CT. Conclusions The incidence and the severity of early voice and swallowing postthyroidectomy symptoms are significantly reduced in patients who undergo VAT compared with conventional surgery. Presented at the ISW2007—IAES free paper session, Montreal, Canada, August 26–30, 2007.     

Utility of voice therapy in the management of vocal fold polyps and cysts.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the efficacy of voice therapy in the management of vocal fold polyps and cysts. STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING: Retrospective review of vocal fold cysts and polyps undergoing voice therapy in a tertiary care center. Symptom resolution or persistence resulting in surgical intervention was the main outcome measure. RESULTS: Fifty-seven patients were identified, of which 49.1% achieved symptom resolution with voice therapy alone. Patients with complete glottal closure and muscle tension dysphonia did not have a better response than those with incomplete glottal closure and without muscle tension dysphonia (P = 0.1, chi(2), respectively). Patients with translucent polyps more commonly responded to voice therapy than fibrotic, hyaline, or hemorrhagic polyps, 81.8% versus 15.4% and 25.0% response rate, respectively (P = 0.002, chi(2)). CONCLUSIONS: Voice therapy is an effective treatment modality for vocal fold polyps and cysts. SIGNIFICANCE: A multidisciplinary approach including a trial of voice therapy is warranted.     

Vocal fold augmentation with calcium hydroxylapatite.

OBJECTIVES: Voice disorders affect more than 3% of the general population. Vocal fold atrophy is a part of the normal aging process, with up to 60% of 60-year-old individuals displaying evidence of glottal insufficiency. A safe, effective, and durable substance for injection augmentation of the vocal folds is not currently available. The purpose of this investigation was to describe our preliminary experience with calcium hydroxylapatite (CaHA) for vocal fold augmentation. METHODOLOGY: All patients undergoing injection augmentation of the vocal folds with CaHA between January 1, 2002 and June 1, 2003 were prospectively evaluated. Data concerning indications, technique, functional outcome, and complications were collected. In addition, the larynx donated from a woman who underwent vocal fold augmentation with CaHA and subsequently died from terminal cancer was histologically examined. RESULTS: A total of 39 vocal folds in 23 individuals were injected with CaHA. The mean age of the cohort was 62. Fifty-two percent were male. The indications for augmentation were unilateral vocal fold paralysis (9/23), unilateral vocal fold paresis (5/23), presbylarynx (3/23), Parkinson's (3/23), bilateral vocal fold paresis (2/23), and abductor spasmodic dysphonia (1/20). There were no adverse reactions. All individuals reported improvement on a self-administered disease-specific outcome measure (P < 0.001). The pathology from the donated larynx 3 months after injection revealed intact CaHA spherules in good position with a minimal, monocellular inflammatory reaction to the gel carrier and no evidence of implant rejection. CONCLUSIONS: Initial experience with vocal fold augmentation using CaHA is promising. Long-term safety and efficacy needs to be established.     

Laryngeal framework surgery for the management of aspiration

BACKGROUND: During the past decade, laryngeal framework surgery has become the treatment of choice for the management of adductor paralysis of the vocal fold. The primary impetus for the use of this technique has been on the rehabilitation of voice. The purpose of this study was to ascertain the effectiveness of laryngeal framework surgery, including medialization laryngoplasty with silicone (MLS), with or without arytenoid adduction (AA), on eliminating aspiration, improving diet, and aiding in the subsequent decannulation of individuals with glottic insufficiency secondary to vocal fold palsy. METHODS: A retrospective chart review was performed on all patients initially seen with vocal cord paralysis who were treated with laryngeal framework surgery from June 1992 to April 1996. The study comprised 70 patients, including 31 women and 39 men, with a median age of 57 years. Clinical information was obtained regarding the etiology of the lesion, characteristics of the vocal cord deficit, history of aspiration, the presence of other neurologic deficits or concurrent pulmonary disease, treatment, and outcome. To determine the effectiveness of MLS, with or without AA, we assessed the final outcome regarding the presence and degree of aspiration, diet, history of aspiration pneumonia, and decannulation. RESULTS: Seventy patients underwent 77 MLS (three bilateral, four revisions), and 21 AA. Decreased aspiration was obtained in 96% of our patients. Seventy-five percent of those patients who had required a tracheotomy were decannulated. CONCLUSIONS: These results support the use of laryngeal framework surgery for the effective treatment of aspiration in selected patients initially seen with deficits of the glottic closure secondary to vocal fold paralysis or paresis.     

Quality of life and voice in patients after laser cordectomy for Tis and T1 glottic carcinomas

BACKGROUND: Laser cordectomy is gaining popularity for treatment of early glottic carcinoma, but little is known about vocal and quality of life (QOL) outcomes as a function of extent of resection. We prospectively examined QOL and vocal function of patients with carcinoma in situ (Tis) or T1 glottic carcinomas after laser cordectomy. METHODS: Patients (n = 75) were grouped into those who underwent unilateral subepithelial or subligamental resection (group A, n = 45); those who underwent unilateral transmuscular or total cordectomy (group B, n = 17); and those who underwent extended or bilateral cordectomy including the anterior commissure (group C, n = 19). The European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer head and neck cancer specific module (QLQ-H&N35), voice handicap index (VHI), and objective vocal function were examined before and 1 year after cordectomy and compared among the groups. RESULTS: No major complications were encountered, but local recurrence occurred in 10 patients, with group C showing the highest rate (6/19, 31.6%). Patient-reported speech and social contact scores of QOL questionnaire and VHI scores after surgery were higher in groups B and C than in group A (p < .05). The scores and perceptual and acoustic data were generally improved in all groups after surgery, but were statistically significant only in group A (p < .03). CONCLUSION: Our data suggest that early glottic cancers with a limited extent and infiltration depth have improved outcomes, both oncologically and functionally, compared to those lesions requiring extensive laser resection.     

Vocal cord paralysis following carotid endarterectomy: The paradox of return of function

In a series of 411 consecutive carotid endarterectomies 29 patients were identified with vocal cord paralysis. All patients were symptomatic, although in many these symptoms were subtle and rapidly resolved. There was a statistically significant predominance of left-sided paralysis. Excluding three patients who died during the initial year of follow-up return of normal voice was noted in 22 patients, but complete return of vocal cord function was present in only 15. Apposition of the contralateral vocal cord against a paralyzed vocal cord allowed for production of normal voice in five patients. Less than 1% of patients remained with symptoms at one year following endarterectomy. We conclude that vocal cord paralysis is a common complication of carotid endarterectomy; the voice becomes an unreliable guide as to its resolution. We recommend laryngoscopic examination of all patients who undergo bilateral carotid endarterectomy.Presented at the Thirteenth Annual Meeting of the New England Society for Vascular Surgery, Dixville Notch, New Hampshire, September 26, 1986.     

Mechanical and dynamic aspects of voice production as related to voice therapy and phonosurgery.

Laryngeal framework surgery can change the position and tension of the vocal folds safely without direct surgical intervention in the vocal fold proper. Some 23 years of experience with phonosurgery have proved its usefulness in treating dysphonia related to unilateral vocal fold paralysis, vocal fold atrophy, and pitch-related dysphonias. Meanwhile, much information about the mechanism of voice production has been obtained through intraoperative findings of voice and fiberscopic examination of the larynx. Based on such knowledge together with information obtained through model experiments, the human vocal organ was reconsidered mainly from the mechanical view point, and the roles of voice therapy and singing pedagogy were discussed in relation to phonosurgery. The vocal organ may not be an ideal musical organ and is rather vulnerable, but its potential is enormous.     

Laryngoscopic techniques to assess vocal cord mobility following thyroid surgery

Background: Assessment of vocal cord mobility using Macintosh laryngoscope is frequently performed after extubation following thyroid surgery to rule out laryngeal nerve palsy. This study compared patient comfort and assessment accuracy of post‐operative vocal fold mobility with Macintosh laryngoscope and fibreoptic endoscope. Methods: One hundred four physically fit patients undergoing thyroid surgery were included for the study. Tele‐laryngoscopy was done to rule out pre‐existing vocal cord palsy. Direct laryngoscopy (DL) was performed to each patient after extubation, followed by nasal fibreoptic endoscopy (NFE) to assess the vocal cord mobility. Tele‐laryngoscopic assessment was repeated after 1 week to compare the DL and NFE findings. Patient reactivity score (PRS) and haemodynamic parameters were recorded with each technique. Results: Macintosh laryngoscope could pick up 4 (50% sensitivity and 88% specificity) and fibreoptic endoscope 7 (87.9% sensitivity and 98.9% specificity) out of the 8 vocal cord palsies identified by tele‐laryngoscopy. Patients had significant discomfort during DL (PRS median 3) when compared with NFE and tele‐laryngoscopy (PRS median 2), P < 0.05. Grade 1 view of larynx in 92.1% patients during intubation worsened to grade 2 (76.3%) and grade 3 (15.8%) during extubation with DL, and a significant rise in mean arterial pressure and heart rate was observed from the baseline value till 5 min and when compared with NFE (P < 0.05). Conclusion: NFE provides accurate assessment of vocal fold mobility with reasonable patient comfort in the immediate post‐operative period. Macintosh laryngoscope fails to give optimum visualization and predisposes the patient to significant discomfort and stress.     

Laser tenotomy and vocal process resection for bilateral midline vocal fold fixation

Background: The present retrospective study presents the outcomes of a group of 21 patients with laryngeal obstruction caused by bilateral vocal fold fixation. All of these patients were treated by laser assisted muscle tenotomy and vocal process resection ? a modification of the technique described by Michael and Eugene Rontal in 1994. 1 Methods: Between January 1997 and March 2002 the senior author performed muscle tenotomy and vocal process resection for bilateral vocal fold fixation on 21 patients. Results: The mean follow‐up time was 2.3 years. The technique was successful in achieving an adequate airway and good voice with no aspiration in every case. Conclusions: Laser assisted muscle tenotomy and vocal process resection is a proven treatment for bilateral medial vocal fold fixation with the provision of a good airway, good voice and the avoidance of aspiration.     

The Use of Polydimethylsiloxane for Injection Laryngoplasty

BACKGROUND: Injuries of the recurrent laryngeal nerve with consecutive vocal cord paralysis is a typical complication in chest, esophageal, thyroideal, and neck surgery. Glottic insufficiency secondary to such a lesion can be treated by endolaryngeal vocal cord augmentation (injection laryngoplasty). Many different substances have been used, often showing complications or disadvantages. This study reports on the use of injectable polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS), with special regard to the long-term results. METHODS: In this prospective study, 21 patients with unilateral vocal cord paralysis underwent injection laryngoplasty using PDMS at a volume of 0.5-1.0 ml. Preoperatively, 6 weeks and 12 months after the injection the following parameters concerning patients' voice were evaluated: Glottic closure by videolaryngostroboscopy, maximum phonation time, voice range, voice dynamic, jitter, shimmer, noise-to-harmonic-ratio, and roughness, breathiness, and hoarseness (RBH). In addition, patients were asked to give their own evaluation of how satisfied they felt with their voice and of the handicaps it caused them. RESULTS: Postoperatively an improvement was evident in all the parameters that were investigated, and this significant improvement was still in evidence for most of the parameters more than one year after the injection. In our study no complications were observed more than one year after injection. CONCLUSION: PDMS is a safe substance for injection laryngoplasty in unilateral vocal cord paresis. Objective and subjective parameters confirm its effectiveness. It is suitable for obtaining satisfying results in the reestablishment of the patient's voice and communication ability.     

Vocal fold injection of collagen for unilateral vocal fold paralysis caused by chest diseases.

BACKGROUND: Patients having malignant chest diseases sometimes suffer from vocal fold paralysis. Treatment for vocal fold paralysis is important for such patients, because vocal fold paralysis causes lack of the versatility of the human voice which is essential for our communication. METHODS: Seventeen patients suffering from unilateral vocal fold paralysis were treated with vocal fold injections of collagen. Three patients received twice, and 20 treatments were conducted. A flexible bronchofiberscope was used under local anesthesia in order to observe the whole procedure of vocal fold injection. Using an injector and a long needle, collagen was injected with transcutaneous technique mainly through the cricothyroid membrane. The amount of collagen was determined with bronchoscopic findings. RESULTS: During and after treatment, no complication was observed. Of 20 treatments, a marked improvement was observed in 8, and moderate improvement was observed in 9 treatments. CONCLUSIONS: Vocal fold injection of collagen is a very useful and safe treatment for unilateral vocal fold paralysis caused by chest diseases.     

Diplophonia in unilateral vocal fold paralysis and intracordal cyst

Diplophonia is the production by the voice of 2 separate tones through quasiperiodic variations in the vocal fold vibration (Ward PH, Moore GP. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1969;78:771-7). Clinically, diplophonia can be observed in patients with unilateral vocal fold paralysis with incomplete glottal closure and a mass lesion of the vocal fold, intracordal cyst, and granuloma (Kiritani S, et al. Ann Bull RILP 1991;25:55-62; Hirano M, et al. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1989;98:791-5). In this study we report 16 subjects with unilateral vocal cord paralysis or an intracordal cyst characterized perceptually by diplophonia. Diplophonia during tension imbalance may occur after surgery and is characterized by an improved perceptual score, a reduced number of vibratory cycles in each quasiperiodic waveform, and a reduced occurrence rate of the diplophonic waveform. During mass imbalance, no diplophonia occurred after surgery. Regarding the relationship of diplophonia with glottal condition at production of stops, in our study diplophonia varied significantly according to the different phonologic environments of stops during tension imbalance. We presume that there is a close relationship between the occurrence of diplophonia and the glottal conditions in tension imbalance, but not in mass imbalance.