An Immunological Investigation of Hemophilia B with a Tentative Classification of the Disease into Five Variants1

Abstract. 23 patients with hemophilia B have been investigated by means of several immunological methods. 16 patients (69.9%) had no detectable factor XI antigen. Five had a normal factor IX antigen and the electrophoretic mobility of this abnormal factor IX was similar to that of its normal counterpart. One of these five patients had hemophilia BW, since ox brain thromboplastin clotting time was severely prolonged. The remaining two patients had reduced or decreased factor IX antigen. Several patients showed a slight prolongation of ox brain thromboplastin time due to an associated slight factor VII deficiency. On the basis of these results, a tentative classification of hemophilia B into five variants is proposed, namely: hemophilia B, or with no factor IX antigen; hemophilia Bt, or with normal factor IX antigen; hemophilia BRA, or with reduced factor IX antigen; hemophilia BM, or with normal factor TX antigen and severely prolonged ox brain thromboplastin; hemophilia B, usually B-, with associated mild factor VII defect. A complete evaluation of the hemophilia B patients is feasible only by means of a battery of tests, namely: factor TX activity assay, factor IX antigen determination, ox brain thromboplastin clotting time, factor VII activity assay.     

Prenatal diagnosis of hemophilia B by an immunoradiometric assay of factor IX

An immunoradiometric assay of factor IX was developed based on homologous antibodies that arose in a hemophilic patient. With this assay, 11 of 12 patients with severe hemophilia B had factor IX antigen levels below 1 U/dl and 6 patients with mild hemophilia B had various levels. Factor IX antigen in 8 fetuses (16th-20th gestational week) aborted for therapeutic reasons ranged from 1.8 to 10.0 U/dl. Six amniotic fluids contained 0.28-1.2 U/dl factor IX antigen. Using the immunoradiometric assay, we could diagnose hemophilia B prenatally in one fetus at risk. No factor IX antigen (< 0.2 U/dl) was detectable in the fetoscopic sample. After termination of the pregnancy, analysis of blood from the abortus confirmed the diagnosis of severe hemophilia B. We conclude that very sensitive immunologic assays, such as the one described here, will prove useful in prenatal diagnosis of severe hemophilia B, since determination of factor IX activity in fetoscopic samples is unrealiable because of possible contamination with thromboplastic material.     

Production of human factor IX in animals by genetically modified skin fibroblasts: potential therapy for hemophilia B

Inherited diseases might be treated by introducing normal genes into a patient's somatic tissues to correct the genetic defects. In the case of hemophilia resulting from a missing clotting factor, the required gene could be introduced into any cell as long as active factor reached the circulation. We previously showed that retroviral vectors can efficiently transfer genes into normal skin fibroblasts and that the infected cells can produce high levels of a therapeutic product in vitro. In the current study, we examined the ability of skin fibroblasts to secrete active clotting factor after infection with different retroviral vectors encoding human clotting factor IX. Normal human fibroblasts infected with one vector secreted greater than 3 micrograms factor IX/10(6) cells/24 h. Of this protein, greater than 70% was structurally and functionally indistinguishable from human factor IX derived from normal plasma. This suggests that infected autologous fibroblasts might provide therapeutic levels of factor IX if transplanted into patients suffering from hemophilia B. By transplanting normal diploid fibroblasts infected with the factor IX vectors, we showed that human factor IX can be produced and is circulated at readily detectable levels in rats and mice.     

Adeno-associated virus-mediated gene transfer for hemophilia B

Hemophilia is the bleeding diathesis caused by mutations in the gene encoding factor VIII (hemophilia A) or factor IX (hemophilia B). Currently, the disease is treated by intravenous infusion of the missing purified clotting factor. The goal of gene transfer for treating hemophilia is to achieve sustained expression of factor VIII or factor IX at levels high enough to improve the symptoms of the disease. Hemophilia has proven to be an attractive model for those interested in gene transfer, and multiple gene-transfer strategies are currently being investigated for the hemophilias. The most promising preclinical studies have been with adeno-associated viral vectors (AAV); introduction of AAV vectors expressing factor IX into skeletal muscle or liver in hemophilic dogs has resulted in the long-term expression of factor IX at levels that are adequate to improve disease symptoms. Efforts to translate these findings into the clinical arena have proceeded slowly because of the lack of prior clinical experience with parenteral administration of AAV. In a staged approach, AAV-factor IX (AAV-F.IX) was first administered at doses of up to 1.8 x 10(12) vector genomes/kg (vg/kg) into the skeletal muscles of men with hemophilia B. This trial established the safety of parenteral administration and also showed that general characteristics of AAV transduction were similar in mice, dogs, and humans. In an ongoing trial, AAV-F.IX is being administered into the hepatic circulation of men with severe hemophilia B. The goal of these studies is to identify a safe dose that reliably yields circulating levels of factor IX >2% of normal levels in all subjects. This goal has already been achieved in the hemophilia B dog model; the ongoing study will determine whether a similar result can be achieved in humans with hemophilia B.     

Two allotypes of factor IX present in haemophilia B

Factor IX antigen (IX:Ag) was measured with three different immunoradiometric assays (IRMAs) in 30 healthy people and 43 patients with haemophilia B of varying severity. Two of the IRMAs were based on monoclonal antibodies capable of differentiating between two genetically determined molecular variants of normal factor IX. Most patients with severe hemophilia B lacked demonstrable IX:Ag. The factor IX variant that is undetectable with one of the monoclonal antibodies used was present in 2 out of 6 families with moderate haemophilia B and in 1 out of 6 families with mild haemophilia B. The existence of allotypes of factor IX in hemophilia B may have practical implications for carrier detection and prenatal diagnosis.     

Cost-effectiveness in establishing hemophilia carrier detection and prenatal diagnosis services in a developing country with limited health resources

The cost-effectiveness of carrier detection and prenatal diagnosis for hemophilia at the International Hemophilia Training Center, Bangkok, Thailand was studied. From 1991 to 2002, 209 females from 124 families with hemophilia A and B were included. There were 180 hemophilia A carriers and 29 hemophilia B carriers which could be classified into 78 obligate and 131 possible carriers. The phenotypic analysis for possible carriers involved the determination of levels of factor VIII or IX clotting activity (FVIII:C, FIX:C) and the ratio of FVIII:C and von Willebrand factor antigen. The result revealed that 49 females (37.4%) were diagnosed as carriers, 65 females (49.6%) were normal and 17 females (13%) were undetermined. Additional genotypic analysis was provided to 46 families with 74 females with obligate, proven or undetermined carriers within the reproductive life. The polymorphisms associated with factor VIII and IX genes were used including Bcl I for the factor VIII gene and combined use of Mse I, Sal I, Nru I, Hha I and Dde I for the factor IX gene. The informative rate was 59.4% (44/74). Consequently, 12 prenatal diagnoses for fetus at risk were performed. Sex determination was initially determined and followed by the diagnosis of hemophilia through informative gene tracking and/or the measurement of fetal levels of FVIII:C or FIX:C. The result revealed that 3 male fetuses were affected. The total cost of carrier detection and prenatal diagnosis that the families had to pay in the government hospital was 238,600 Baht (US dollars 5,965). It was compared to the estimated cost of minimal replacement therapy using lyophilized cryoprecipitate for the survival time of 30 years in one patient with hemophilia of 1,012,500 Baht (US dollars 25,312.5). The cost of prevention was much less than the replacement therapy. In conclusion, it is cost-effective to establish the service for carrier detection and prenatal diagnosis for hemophilia especially in developing countries with limited health resources.     

Aminoglycoside suppression of nonsense mutations in severe hemophilia

Aminoglycoside antibiotics exhibit their bactericidal effect by interfering with normal ribosomal activity. In this pilot study, we have evaluated the effect of the aminoglycoside antibiotic gentamicin on the factor VIII (FVIII) and IX levels of severe hemophiliacs with known nonsense mutations. Five patients were enrolled and each patient was given 3 consecutive days of gentamicin at a dose of 7 mg/kg intravenously every 24 hours. Two patients (patient no. 1: hemophilia A, Ser1395Stop; and patient no. 5: hemophilia B, Arg333Stop) showed a decrease in their activated partial thromboplastin time (aPTT), an increase in their FVIII (0.016 IU/mL, 1.6%) or FIX (0.02 IU/mL, 2%) levels, and an increase in thrombin generation. The remaining 3 patients (patient no. 2: hemophilia B, Arg252Stop; patient no. 3: hemophilia A, Arg2116Stop; and patient no. 4: hemophilia A, Arg427Stop) showed no response in the aPTTs or factor levels, but one (patient no. 2: hemophilia B, Arg252Stop) showed an increase in the factor IX antigen level (2%-5.5%) that persisted throughout the period of the study and was concordant with an increase in thrombin generation. Gentamicin is unlikely to be an effective treatment for severe hemophilia due to its potential toxicities and the minimal response documented in this report. This study, however, does provide a proof of principle, suggesting that ribosomal interference with a less toxic agent may be a potential therapeutic mechanism for severe hemophilia patients with nonsense mutations.     

Hemophilia B in a female.

Hemophilia B is rare in females and only a few cases have been reported. In this report, we describe a girl with a clinically severe course of hemophilia B but with a normal 46,XX karyotype. She had no signs of Turner's syndrome or any other dysmorphic features. She was demonstrated to have moderately decreased factor IX levels (factor IX:C, 1.5 units/dl; factor IX:Ag, 2.2 units/dl). Her father and paternal uncle were also found to be deficient in factor IX and her mother seemed to carry a factor IX gene mutation with intermediate factor IX:C and factor IX:Ag levels (factor IX:C, 46 units/dl; factor IX:Ag, 39 units/dl). The maternal grandmother also showed mildly decreased factor IX:C and factor IX:Ag levels (factor IX:C 41 units/dl; factor IX:Ag 32 units/dl), further confirming the mother's carrier status, which was indirectly confirmed by DNA segregation analysis using the polymorphic markers of the factor IX gene, as none of her other family members were found to be deficient in factor IX. However, the DdeI polymorphic marker of the factor IX gene for which the mother was informative showed the inheritance of a '369-bp' allele in the mother, which was different from the '319-bp' allele found in all of her 3 brothers who had normal levels of factor IX. Intermediate levels of factor IX in the mother and the maternal grandmother, severe deficiency of factor IX in the child and the polymorphic allele different from that of the normal subjects in the family are all consistent with a homozygous or double-heterozygous condition in this child.     

Comparison of the behavior of normal factor IX and the factor IX BM variant hilo in the prothrombin time test using tissue factors from bovine,human, and rabbit sources

A subset of hemophilia B patients have a prolonged bovine-brain prothrombin time. These CRM⁺ patients are classified as having hemophilia Bm. The prolongation of the prothrombin time has been reported only with bovine brain (referred to as ox brain in some literature) as the source of thromboplastin; prothrombin times determined with thromboplastin from rabbit brain or human brain are not reported to be prolonged. Factor IX from a hemophilia Bm patient (factor IX Hilo) was isolated. The activity of factor IX Hilo was compared to that of normal factor IX in prothrombin time assays when the thromboplastin source was of bovine, rabbit, or human origin. Factor IX, either normal or Hilo, prolonged a prothrombin time regardless of the tissue factor source. However, unless thromboplastin was from a bovine source, this prolongation required high concentrations of factor IX. Further, factor IX normal was as effective as factor IX Hilo in prolonging the prothrombin time when rabbit or human thromboplastin was used. With bovine thromboplastin, factor IX Hilo was significantly better than factor IX normal at prolonging the prothrombin time. The amount of prolongation was dependent on the amount of factor IX Hilo added. In addition, the prolongation was dependent on the concentration of factor × present in the sample. The prothrombin time changed as much as 20 seconds when the factor × concentration was varied from 50% to 150% to normal (fixed concentration of factor IX Hilo). These results demonstrate the difficulty of classifying the severity of a hemophilia Bm patient based on the bovine brain prothrombin time unless both the factor IX and factor × concentrations are known.     

Factor IX and prothrombin in amniotic fluid and fetal plasma: constraints on prenatal diagnosis of hemophilia B and evidence of proteolysis

Potential limitations of prenatal diagnosis of hemophilia B, as compared to hemophilia A, include (1) occurrence of far more frequent defects with abnormal circulating antigen, (2) lower levels of factor IX in fetal plasma at 16 to 20 weeks gestation, and (3) the presence of factor IX antigen in amniotic fluid. In addition, proteolysis could occur, especially with amniotic fluid contamination of fetal plasma. A sensitive polyclonal immunoradiometric assay for factor IX antigen was used to characterize the range of levels in amniotic fluids and fetal plasma samples. To assess for altered forms, factor IX species were compared to those of a homologous clotting factor, prothrombin. Fourteen postmortem abortus blood samples from fetuses of 14 to 23 weeks gestation had factor IX antigen levels that averaged 5.1 U/dL and ranged from 1.7 to 15 U/dL. Amniotic fluid factor IX antigen averaged 2.9 U/dL, with a range from 1.4 to 8.5 U/dL in 19 separate amniocentesis samples. Thus, in a male fetus at risk of hemophilia B and with a low circulating level of gene product, mixture of fetal plasma with amniotic fluid could severely limit prenatal diagnosis, assuming that the amniotic fluid factor IX is of maternal origin. Despite rapid processing of amniotic fluid samples, the prothrombin was extensively cleaved, suggesting that it had been activated in vivo. On gel electrophoresis of amniotic fluid samples, however, factor IX was only minimally cleaved. In the postmortem fetal blood specimens, prothrombin was partially cleaved. On crossed-immunoelectrophoresis, fetal plasma prothrombin showed decreased migration in calcium, compared to EDTA, indicative of mature gamma-glutamyl carboxylation. The latter presumably resulted from fetal hepatic synthesis.     

Phenotypic correction of factor IX deficiency in skin fibroblasts of hemophilic dogs.

Primary skin fibroblasts from hemophilic dogs were transduced by recombinant retrovirus (LNCdF9L) containing a canine factor IX cDNA. High levels of biologically active canine factor IX (1.0 micrograms per 10(6) cells per 24 hr) were secreted in the medium. The level of factor IX produced increased substantially if the cells were stimulated by basic fibroblast growth factor during infection. Additionally, we also report that endothelial cells transduced by this virus can produce high levels of biologically active factor IX. We propose that skin fibroblasts and endothelial cells from hemophilia B dogs may serve as potential venues for the development and testing of models for treatment of hemophilia B by retrovirally mediated gene replacement therapy.     

Factor IX New London: substitution of proline for glutamine at position 50 causes severe hemophilia B

We describe a novel point mutation in the fourth exon of human factor IX (encoding the first EGF-like domain) in which cytosine is substituted for adenosine at position 10,401, resulting in the substitution of proline for glutamine at position 50 in the polypeptide chain. Sequence analysis of all eight exons, all exon-intron junctions, 160 base pairs (bp) of DNA 5' to the proposed translation start site, and 60 bp 3' to the translation termination site shows no other difference from the normal factor IX gene, with the exception of a previously described benign polymorphism at position 148 in the protein (Ala----Thr). The affected subject has severe hemophilia B with no detectable factor IX activity despite normal factor IX antigen levels. We purified the abnormal factor IX by immunoaffinity chromatography and demonstrated that its activation by factor Xla is markedly delayed compared with normal factor lX. Once activated, the abnormal factor lX binds antithrombin III in a 1:1 molar ratio, and the activated protein demonstrates catalytic activity, suggesting an intact active site. The mutation creates a new Bst Yl restriction endonuclease cleavage site. Restriction with Bst Yl shows the mutation in maternal DNA and offers the possibility of direct carrier status analysis and prenatal diagnosis in kindreds with this mutation. We designate this new mutation factor lXNew London. This is the only reported mutation in the first EGF-like domain that causes severe hemophilia B.     

A deletion mutation causes hemophilia B in Lhasa Apso dogs

Hemophilia B is a bleeding disorder caused by a deficiency of clotting factor IX (FIX). A colony of FIX deficient Lhasa Apso dogs has been established and the molecular basis of hemophilia B has been determined. The plasma factor IX levels were < 1% of normal canine levels in affected dogs. A complex deletion mutation at nucleotides 772- 777 was found when hepatocyte cDNA from a hemophilia B dog was sequenced. The sequence was identical to the normal canine sequence except for a deletion including nucleotides 772-776 and a C-->T transition at nucleotide 777. The mutation results in mRNA instability and a premature termination codon in the nucleotide sequence encoding the activation peptide. The mutation was verified by sequencing genomic DNA from an FIX-deficient dog. A genetic test for the detection of heterozygous animals was established using heteroduplex analysis. Although hemophilia B has been described in many dog breeds, this is only the second mutation to be sequenced. The Lhasa Apso dog model should be valuable for evaluating novel strategies for treating hemophilia B such as gene therapy.     

Sustained correction of bleeding disorder in hemophilia B mice by gene therapy

Mice generated by disrupting the clotting factor IX gene exhibit severe bleeding disorder and closely resemble the phenotype seen in hemophilia B patients. Here we demonstrate that a single intraportal injection of a recombinant adeno-associated virus (AAV) vector encoding canine factor IX cDNA under the control of a liver-specific enhancer/promoter leads to a long-term and complete correction of the bleeding disorder. High level expression of up to 15-20 microgram/ml of canine factor IX was detected in the plasma of mice injected with 5.6 x 10(11) particles of an AAV vector for >5 months. The activated partial thromboplastin time of the treated mice was fully corrected to higher than normal levels. Liver-specific expression of canine factor IX was confirmed by immunofluorescence staining, and secreted factor IX protein was identified in the mouse plasma by Western blotting. All treated mice survived the tail clip test without difficulty. Thus, a single intraportal injection of a recombinant adeno-associated virus vector expressing factor IX successfully cured the bleeding disorder of hemophilia B mice, proving the feasibility of using AAV-based vectors for liver-targeted gene therapy of genetic diseases.     

Haemophilia B in a female caused by skewed inactivation of the normal X-chromosome

Hemophilia B (factor IX deficiency) is an X-linked recessive disorder with a prevalence of 1:30,000 male births, which rarely affects females. A missense mutation T38R (6488C>G) of the factor IX (FIX) gene was characterized in a young female with moderate-to-severe hemophilia B. She is heterozygous for this mutation, which she inherited from her carrier mother. Analysis of the methyl-sensitive HpaII sites in the first exon of the human androgen-receptor locus indicated a de novo skewed X-chromosomal inactivation. This indicates that the paternal X-chromosome carrying her normal FIX gene is the inactive one, which has led to the phenotypic expression of hemophilia B in this patient.     

Immunologic aberrations, HIV seropositivity and seroconversion rates in patients with hemophilia B

Because there have been reports that factor IX concentrate is less immunosuppressive and therefore factor IX users have less immunologic aberrations, we have studied a group of 22 patients with hemophilia B and six patients with factor VIII deficiency and high titer inhibitors with respect to lymphocyte numbers and function, human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) serology, and factor usage. This group was compared to 111 patients with hemophilia A and a group of 28 healthy male volunteer controls. When the study began in 1983, the majority of patients with hemophilia B and with higher titer factor VIII inhibitors were seronegative, 77% and 83% respectively, as compared to only 30% of patients with hemophilia A. At that time the factor IX users also had milder immune aberrations than the hemophilia A group. However, with time and increasing clotting factor concentrate usage, seroconversion and more striking abnormalities in immune function have occurred in the hemophilia B group. In a subgroup of 16 patients with hemophilia B studied twice, the incidence of seropositivity increased from 31% in 1983 to 69% in 1985. We thus conclude that factor IX concentrate in itself is not less immunosuppressive than factor VIII concentrate. Seroconversion in factor IX concentrate users appears to be lagging behind seroconversion in factor VIII concentrate users, perhaps secondary to the lower cumulative dosage of concentrate that patients with hemophilia B utilize.     

Induction of split tolerance and clinical cure in high-responding hemophiliacs with factor IX antibodies.

An approach to the problem of inducing tolerance in patients with hemophilia complicated by high-responding antibodies is described. Thus, in four patients with severe hemophilia B and high-responding antibodies against factor IX, it has been possible to modify the immune response by giving high doses of intravenous IgG in combination with cyclophosphamide and factor IX, followed by regular factor IX treatment. In three of the patients, the in vivo recovery and half-life of infused factor IX coagulant activity (IX:C) are now normal, while the fourth patient has been converted to a low responder. Hip replacement surgery has been performed successfully in one patient. The tolerant state in these four patients is characterized, and they have all been found to have complexes between factor IX antigen and a "new" antibody without IX:C inhibitory activity. The disappearance rate of the complexed factor IX antigen (i.e., lacking IX:C activity) is considerably prolonged, and the persistence in the circulation of this (probably modified) factor IX molecule may be crucial, since tolerance to factor IX treatment was only induced when immunocomplexes were produced. Since earlier treatment of the patients with cyclophosphamide and factor IX, but without IgG, failed to induce tolerance, it appears to be the IgG that is the prerequisite.     

Orthotopic liver transplantation in a patient with combined hemophilia A and B

A 38-year-old man with severe factor IX and mild factor VIII deficiencies complicated by cirrhosis secondary to chronic non-A non-B hepatitis underwent orthotopic liver transplantation as treatment for both the cirrhosis and his congenital coagulopathy. Intraoperative hemostasis was obtained with factor VII-depleted prothrombin complex concentrate and fresh frozen plasma. Factor VIII and factor IX levels were assayed frequently in the perioperative period, and both returned to normal within 24 hr and remained normal postoperatively. Liver transplantation can be considered as definitive therapy for hemophilia A and/or B with transfusion-related liver disease.     

Severe hemophilia and physiologic inhibitors of coagulation.

Patients with hemophilia demonstrate quite variable clinical phenotype even in cases with the same level of deficient factor or the same molecular abnormality. Different interacting factors including congenital and acquired alterations of coagulation inhibitors can modulate both clinical expression and severity of hemophilia. In this study, plasma levels of factor VIII (FVIII), factor IX (FIX) as well as protein C (PC), protein S (PS), and antithrombin (AT) plasma levels were measured in 80 patients with severe hemophilia A and B. Patients were divided into two groups according to the risk of bleeding: the first group (n = 32) with mild bleeding (< 2 bleeds/year), and the second group (n = 48) with severe bleeding (> or = 2 bleeds/year). Both hemophilia groups showed significantly decreased PC plasma levels compared to levels in healthy control subjects (the first group: p < 0.0001 and second group: p < 0.01). The difference in PC plasma levels between the first and second hemophilia group was significant (p < 0.05). Moreover, there was positive correlation between age and the functional PC in both hemophilia groups. Our results suggest that decreased PC plasma levels can testify to a slightly protective effect of the PC pathway on the severity and frequency of bleeding in patients with severe hemophilia A and B.