Electrosurgical methods for arthroscopic meniscectomy: A review of the literature

Purpose: To outline the development of electrosurgical (radiofrequency) devices, explain the basic principles, and review the current orthopaedic literature regarding the application of electrosurgery to arthroscopic partial meniscectomy. Materials and Methods: The history and principles of electrosurgery were obtained from various pertinent texts and journal articles. A literature search was performed using MEDLINE; reviewed articles consisted of articles in the English language cataloged between 1966 and January 1999. Results: The history and principles of electrosurgery are reviewed. The articles pertaining to arthroscopic electrosurgical meniscectomy are discussed with a separate discussion on the potential complications of using radiofrequency energy for meniscal ablation, including articular cartilage damage, osteonecrosis, and damage caused by irrigant. Conclusion: Electrosurgery has been shown to be an effective tool in arthroscopic meniscectomy. Further research and refinement is warranted because it may show superiority to other methods in certain situations.Arthroscopy: The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related surgery, Vol 16, No 8 (November-December), 2000: pp 813–821     

The effect of technique on histology of arthroscopic partial meniscectomy with electrosurgery

Fifty-one patients had arthroscopic partial meniscectomies with electrosurgery between 1982 and 1985. Two patients who had undergone prior meniscectomies with electrosurgery had biopsies of the old excision site at repeat arthroscopy, necessitated by new injuries. Three different combinations of electrocautery tips and either a standard electrocautery generator or a new electrocautery generator specifically designed for arthroscopic electrosurgery were used in different combinations. Depth of damage as defined by the Trichrome stain was measured by a micrometer. A rating summary of the quality of resection technique was also performed. Overall, the newly developed electrocautery generator and the newly developed electrocautery tips were not beneficial in reducing the depth of damage. The average depth of damage was .29 mm. Forty-seven percent of patients showed no histologic evidence of damage from the electrosurgical resection. The two individuals with repeat biopsies showed normal histology. Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy with electrosurgery causes a very thin layer of tissue damage. This appears to resolve with time. Recently developed instruments specifically designed for arthroscopic electrosurgery do not appear to decrease the depth of damage.     

A comparative study of medial versus lateral arthroscopic partial meniscectomy on stable knees: 10-year minimum follow-up

Purpose: Our goal was to compare results of partial medial arthroscopic meniscectomy with results of partial lateral arthroscopic meniscectomy and to determine prognostic factors. Type of Study: Retrospective comparative study with statistical analysis. Methods: In this study, 362 medial and 109 lateral isolated arthroscopic meniscectomies are presented with a minimum follow-up time of 10 years. All knees were stable with no previous surgery or traumatic lesion. Results: In this study, 95% of the patients were very satisfied or satisfied with the results of the medial meniscectomy, and 95.5% with results of the lateral meniscectomy (P = .32). According to grades 1 and 2 of the Intenational Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) form, 85.8% of the medial meniscectomy group were free of any symptoms, as were 79.7% of the lateral meniscectomy group (P = .11). Radiologic changes after medial and lateral meniscectomy were found in 21.5% and 37.5%, respectively (P = .11). The rates of radiologic changes in patients in whom the contralateral knee was radiologically normal were 22.3% and 39%, respectively (P = .016). The rate of repeat surgeries for osteoarthritis was less than 0.2%. Conclusions: Subjective and clinical results after medial or lateral meniscectomy are quite similar, but radiologic results are significantly worse after lateral meniscectomy. The most accurate way to determine the degeneration caused by the meniscectomy is to evaluate joint space narrowing in patients in whom the contralateral knee was radiologically normal. Otherwise, partial medial or lateral meniscectomy are well tolerated. A better prognosis can be predicted for a patient with an isolated medial meniscal tear with one or more of the following factors: age less than 35 years, a vertical tear, no cartilage damage, and an intact meniscal rim at the end of the meniscectomy. With an isolated lateral meniscal tear, a better prognosis can be predicted if the patient is young and has an intact meniscal rim at the end of the meniscectomy.     

Arthroscopic partial and total meniscectomy: A long-term follow-up study with matched controls

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to compare the clinical and radiographic outcome of arthroscopic partial and total meniscectomy. Type of Study: Retrospective outcome study. Methods: Thirty-six male patients with stable knees, no previous knee injury, and arthroscopic meniscectomy were matched into 2 groups: partial or total. In addition, a group of individuals with no known history of knee injury was matched to each patient with meniscectomy. All patients were re-examined by a clinical and radiographic examination 14 years after surgery. Results: At follow-up, radiographic changes, including Fairbank changes and joint space narrowing, were seen in 6 of 18 patients (33%) after partial meniscectomy and in 13 of 18 patients (72%) after total meniscectomy (P <.05). Joint space narrowing >50% of the joint space was seen in 1 patient after partial meniscectomy but was present in 7 patients after total meniscectomy. In the healthy controls, 4 of 36 patients (11%) had radiographic changes but none had joint space narrowing. Fourteen years after surgery almost 70% of patients had a Lysholm score >94 (i.e., normal). Only 5 of 36 patients (14%) in the total meniscectomy group had knee symptoms during activities of daily living. A similar decline in activity levels according to Tegner was seen over time in the control group and in the 2 meniscectomy groups. Conclusions: The frequency of radiographic changes 14 years after meniscectomy is related to the size of the meniscus removed, but the grades of these changes are low and have little influence on activity and knee function.Arthroscopy: The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery, Vol 18, No 2 (February), 2002: pp 183–189     

Juxta-articular bone marrow signal changes on magnetic resonance imaging following arthroscopic meniscectomy

Purpose: Postmeniscectomy osteonecrosis of the knee has been reported in the past decade but the etiology remains unclear. Some investigators have indicated that bone marrow signal changes evident on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) could be early warning signs of osteonecrosis. The purpose of this study was to determine the incidence rate, location, and magnitude of such changes in bone marrow of the knee after arthroscopic meniscectomy, using MRI. Type of Study: Cohort analytic study. Methods: Ninety-three patients with no bone marrow signal abnormalities on preoperative MRI were examined after isolated arthroscopic meniscectomy. There were 51 men and 42 women with an age range of 11 to 62 years (mean, 36.6 years). Of the total, 57 patients underwent partial meniscectomy (34 medial and 23 lateral) and the others total meniscectomy (10 medial and 26 lateral). MRI examinations were performed independently of postoperative knee symptoms, 1 to 24 months after surgery. Bone marrow changes of the treated knees were evaluated by T1- and T2*-weighted MRI. Results: Thirty-two of 93 patients (34%) had bone marrow signal changes in femoral or tibial condyles shown on postoperative MRI. No patients had these changes in the femoral or tibial condyles opposite from the meniscectomy side and, in the majority of cases, the size was less than half that of the condyle. Fifteen of the 44 patients who underwent medial meniscectomy and 17 of the 49 patients who underwent lateral meniscectomy had such changes. The meniscectomy side did not affect the incidence rate, and frequently both femoral and tibial condyles were involved. Age, gender and articular cartilage condition at the surgery were not risk factors. In contrast, the extent of meniscectomy affected the incidence rate. Conclusions: This study suggests a positive correlation between arthroscopic meniscectomy and postoperative bone marrow signal changes of the knee.Arthroscopy: The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery, Vol 18, No 3 (March), 2002: pp 238–245     

Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy in patients over 70 years of age

Purpose: This study was conducted to determine the importance of age as a limiting factor as well as to assess the role of age in combination with cartilage damage or osteoarthritis as predicting factors for the outcome after arthroscopic partial meniscectomy. Type of Study: Case series. Methods: We reviewed 97 patients over 70 years of age who underwent an arthroscopic partial meniscectomy between 1992 and 1996. At the time of evaluation, 5 patients had died and 1 patient was unavailable, leaving 91 patients (95 knees) suitable for assessment. There were 56 women and 35 men. The average age at time of surgery was 74 years (range, 70 to 84 years). The mean follow-up period was 4 years (range, 2 to 6 years). Assessment of the cases by 1 investigator included medical records and preoperative radiographs of the knee joint, with the main interest focused on evidence of osteoarthritis using the classification of Kellgren and Lawrence. Evaluation of cartilage damage was performed on surgical videotapes according to Outerbridge. All 91 patients were personally interviewed by telephone. The questionnaire included influence of the operation on knee pain, quality and duration of satisfaction, requirement of further surgery, and whether the patient would undergo the same operation again. Results: According to the Kellgren and Lawrence classification, 80% of patients had radiographic evidence of osteoarthritis grade 0-2, and 20% had grade 3-4. According to Outerbridge, 43% of the patients had cartilage damage grade 0-2 and 57% had grade 3-4; 81% of the patients with osteoarthritis grade 0-2 and 83% of the patients with cartilage damage grade 0-2 had a satisfactory outcome when followed-up for more than 2 years. Among the patients with osteoarthritis grade 3-4 or cartilage damage grade 3-4, 55% and 69%, respectively, were satisfied when followed-up for more than 2 years; 45% and 37%, respectively, required a further surgery after 1 to 4 years. The grade of osteoarthritis had significant influence on satisfaction (P < .01), on whether the patients would have the operation done again (P = .01), and on whether they required further surgery (P = .04). The severity of cartilage damage only had a significant influence on whether the patients would undergo the operation again (P = .01). Conclusions: Pre-existing degenerative changes appeared to affect the outcome more than the patient’s age. However, arthroscopic partial meniscectomy was followed by satisfactory results in more than two thirds of our cases even if performed in the presence of moderate degenerative changes. But two thirds does not correspond with the good results usually obtained in a younger population. Therefore, the indication for surgery and the expected outcome have to be evaluated carefully in elderly patients.Arthroscopy: The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery, Vol 17, No 7 (September), 2001: pp 732–736     

Basic and clinical studies of percutaneous radiofrequency ablation of osteoid osteoma using a standard electrosurgical generator

 For percutaneous radiofrequency ablation of osteoid osteoma for pain management, we used a standard electrosurgical generator instead of the radiofrequency generator system. First, we used the standard electrosurgical generator to determine the diameter of the coagulated area of normal femurs and humeruses of dogs under general anesthesia and to detect damage to normal tissue around the bone. We then used a standard electrosurgical generator to perform percutaneous radiofrequency ablation of the osteoid osteoma. All three patients were almost pain-free within the first 24 h after the procedure, and they were discharged the day after the operation, being hospitalized for only 2 days. We thus confirmed that percutaneous radiofrequency ablation using a standard electrosurgical generator produced results similar to those achieved with the radiofrequency generator system. Received: August 19, 2002 / Accepted: January 11, 2003 RID="*" ID="*" Offprint requests to: A. Takeda     

Substantial disability 3 months after arthroscopic partial meniscectomy: A prospective study of patient-relevant outcomes

Summary: To our knowledge, this is the first prospective study using validated questionnaires to assess patient-relevant outcomes after arthroscopic partial meniscectomy. Data from the Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS), the SF-36 Medical Outcomes Study Short-Form Health Survey, and the Lysholm Knee Scoring Scale were available for 74 consecutive patients (50 males, 24 females; mean age, 45 years) with isolated meniscus tear (n = 47) or meniscus tear combined with cartilage damage (n = 27). At postoperative follow-up (mean, 14.4 weeks) significant improvement was seen, but despite only minor pain and other symptoms postoperatively, significant physical disability and handicap were reported. Postoperatively, 30% of patients were active in sports compared with 63% before injury. A sedentary lifestyle was reported by 38% compared with 9% before injury. We conclude that patient-relevant outcomes provide additional information and should be assessed after arthroscopic partial meniscectomy. We further suggest that preoperative information for the meniscectomy patient should include a realistic expected functional outcome.Arthroscopy: The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related surgery, Vol 16, No 6 (September), 2000: pp 619–626     

APPLICATIONS OF ELECTRICAL ENERGY TO THE PROSTATE: AN EVOLUTIONARY PERSPECTIVE

Purpose

We review modern electrosurgical treatments for removing benign prostatic tissue based on an historical perspective of medical applications of electrical energy.

Materials and Methods

We reviewed historical reports and landmark observations concerning the evolution of medical applications of electrical energy in the literature, with a special focus on the development of principles pertinent to the transurethral electrosurgical removal of prostate tissue.

Results

Modern transurethral electrosurgery of the prostate in a fluid medium has been well founded on key electrosurgical principles. Traditionally, the best clinical results and the least complications have been obtained through an understanding of the important precepts of this form of energy. These precepts have included distinctions between the reliability of effect and safety with direct and alternating current, and how different tissue effects can be achieved, either with selective current modes (cutting and coagulating waveforms) or by varying the size and configuration of the active electrode and its application time.

Conclusions

This review chronicles the prominent role of electrosurgery in our efforts to debulk an enlarged prostate in patients with symptomatic voiding dysfunction. History reminds us that many of today's “new ideas” are merely updated variations on a theme, have often been tried before in a fashion by our predecessors and have for one reason or another fallen by the wayside. The conundrum of the perfect combination of electrosurgical variables that can fulfill our goal of making this an efficient and complication-free treatment continues to stimulate and challenge us as we move towards the next millennium.     

Management of discoid lateral meniscus tears: Observations in 34 knees

Purpose: The goal of this study was to evaluate arthroscopic partial resection of discoid lateral meniscus tears with an emphasis on radiographic evidence of degenerative changes after this procedure. Type of Study: Retrospective clinical study. Methods: Of 41 patients with an arthroscopic diagnosis of discoid meniscus over an 8-year period, 34 symptomatic lateral discoid meniscus tears in 33 patients were analyzed at an average follow-up of 5.6 years. The average age at operation was 19.8 years and most patients had vague and intermittent symptoms that caused delay in clinical diagnosis. Results: Eight patients were lost to follow-up and were excluded from the study. Magnetic resonance imaging, performed in 12 cases, and arthroscopy in all of these patients provided the precise diagnosis. All of the knees with symptomatic torn discoid menisci underwent arthroscopic partial meniscectomy. Only 1 Watanabe Wrisberg ligament type of discoid meniscus with posterior instability was totally meniscected. Based on Ikeuchi's grading, 39% of the knees had an excellent result, 46% had a good result, and 15% had a fair result; none of the results was poor. Conclusions: At an average 5-year follow-up, partial meniscectomy in patients with a Watanabe complete or incomplete discoid meniscus showed 85% good or excellent clinical results. However, a significant percentage of patients show femoral condyle flattening on radiography.Arthroscopy: The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery, Vol 19, No 4 (April), 2003: pp 346–352     

Active electrode monitoring

Background: In recent years, the use of minimally invasive surgery (MIS) has expanded to a wide variety of surgical specialties. The increased popularity of the procedure, however, has been accompanied by its share of complications, including trocar lacerations and inadvertent thermal injuries to nontargeted tissues during monopolar electrosurgery. Methods: A survey on electrosurgical thermal injuries and three case studies are presented. The new technology of active electrode monitoring (AEM) is described. Results: AEM eliminates stray currents generated by insulation failure and capacitive coupling. Conclusions: To reduce the incidence of injury by monopolar electrosurgery at laparoscopy, there is a need for advanced technology, such as AEM. In addition, laparoscopic surgeons should be encouraged to study the basic concepts of the biophysics of electrosurgery. Received: 26 June 1997/Accepted: 10 December 1997     

Principles and safety measures of electrosurgery in laparoscopy

Background:

Electrosurgical units are the most common type of electrical equipment in the operating room. A basic understanding of electricity is needed to safely apply electrosurgical technology for patient care.

Methods:

We reviewed the literature concerning the essential biophysics, the incidence of electrosurgical injuries, and the possible mechanisms for injury. Various safety guidelines pertaining to avoidance of injuries were also reviewed.

Results:

Electrothermal injury may result from direct application, insulation failure, direct coupling, capacitive coupling, and so forth.

Conclusion:

A thorough knowledge of the fundamentals of electrosurgery by the entire team in the operating room is essential for patient safety and for recognizing potential complications. Newer hemostatic technologies can be used to decrease the incidence of complications.     

Common myths about electrosurgery.

The electrosurgery device market is lucrative and highly competitive. Several device manufacturers exist, and many creative techniques are used to differentiate products. Some device manufacturers make claims in marketing campaigns that are difficult to reconcile with the laws of physics or basic physiology. The variety of claims may be confusing to surgeons desiring to purchase new electrosurgical products. Understanding a few basic principles of electrosurgery physics can allow a surgeon to be a more informed consumer of electrosurgical products. This article discusses the basic physics of electrosurgery and then addresses several common misconceptions about electrosurgery and electrosurgical devices.     

Structural analysis of meniscal allografts after immediate and delayed transplantation in rabbits

Purpose: To compare long-term performance of meniscal allografts transplanted immediately after meniscectomy and allografts transplanted 6 weeks after meniscectomy. Type of Study: Experimental study. Methods: Twenty-one rabbits were subjected to meniscectomy and divided into 3 groups of 7 animals. Immediate meniscal transplantation was performed in group A (6-week follow-up) and group B (1-year follow-up). Group C underwent delayed transplantation 6 weeks after meniscectomy. One animal in group B developed infective arthritis and was not included. Six nonoperated knees served as controls. Four other knees were subjected to a sham procedure. Menisci were examined macroscopically and histologically at 6 weeks (group A and 2 sham- operated animals) and 1 year (group B, C, controls, and 2 sham-operated animals). Results: Capsular ingrowth was observed in all allografts. At 1 year, osteoarthritic changes in the delayed transplant group were more pronounced than in the immediate transplant group. Menisci in nonoperated controls and sham-operated knees appeared normal. No differences in shrinkage of allografts were observed between groups A and B. Group C showed significantly more shrinkage than allografts in both group A (P = .004) and group B (P = .005). Two allografts in group C were completely degenerated. Differences in architecture of the allografts were not found between groups A, B, and C. In both the peripheral and central areas of transplanted menisci, the number of cells was frequently increased because of repopulation even at 6-week follow-up. Conclusions: Delayed meniscal allograft transplantation causes distinct structural damage to menisci in comparison with immediate transplantation.     

Are there risk factors for the clinical and radiological results after arthroscopic partial medial meniscectomy? Gibt es pr?disponierende Faktoren?

In a retrospective study 100 patients underwent a clinical and radiological follow-up 7 years and 7 months after an arthroscopic partial medial meniscectomy. None of these patients had associated intraarticular lesions apart a minor chondral damage of the medial compartment. The follow-up showed excellent clinical results in 96 % of patients according to the modified Marshall Score. The radiological results demonstrated a deterioration or development of osteoarthritis of the operated knee joint in 33 % of patients, with a statistical significance between radiological and clinical results (p < 0.05). The age of the patients at time of operation and any angular deformity of the knee joint had no statistical significant influence on the radiological results. Women had a statistically significant higher risk to deteriorate or develop gonarthrosis after partial medial meniscectomy than men (p < 0.05). The arthroscopic partial medial meniscectomy leads to excellent subjective and functional results, but it could not totally prevent the increase or development of degenerative changes in the medial knee compartment.     

Port site electrosurgical (diathermy) burns during surgical laparoscopy

Background: Direct and capacitive coupling of diathermy current have been reported as causes of occult injury during surgical laparoscopy. Methods: In order to determine the incidence of electrosurgical injury adjacent to metal and plastic cannulas, skin biopsies at 19 port sites used for monopolar electrosurgery were analyzed for coagulative necrosis. Prior to surgery the cannulas were randomized to either metal or plastic. Results: Coagulative necrosis was observed at nine electrosurgery port sites compared to only one control (χ²= 4.872; df= 1; 0.05 > p > 0.02). Plastic cannulas afforded no greater protection from skin burns than metal cannulas. Conclusions: Burns may be the result of direct or capacitive coupling to metal cannulas or capacitive coupling to the skin edge across plastic cannulas. The potential exists for burns to other tissues also in close proximity to a cannula used for electrosurgery. Received: 12 August 1996/Accepted 26 November 1996     

Complications and recommended practices for electrosurgery in laparoscopy

BACKGROUND: Electrosurgery is one of the most commonly used energy systems in laparoscopic surgery. Two major categories of potential complications related to electrosurgery in laparoscopy are mechanical trauma and electrothermal injury. The latter can result from unrecognized energy transfer in the operational field or, less commonly, to unnoticed stray current outside the laparoscopic field of view. Stray current can result from insulation failure, direct coupling, or capacitive coupling. METHODS: We reviewed the literature concerning essential biophysics of electrosurgery, including electrosurgical waveform differentiation, tissue effect, and variables that determine tissue effect. The incidence of electrosurgical injuries and possible mechanisms responsible for the injuries are discussed. Different types of injuries may result in different clinical manifestations and histopathological findings. Gross and microscopic pathological check-ups of the injury sites may distinguish between different mechanisms, and thus provide further clues postoperatively. RESULTS: Several recommended practices are proposed to avoid electrosurgical injury laparoscopically. To achieve electrosurgical safety and to prevent electrosurgical injuries, the surgical team should have a good understanding of the biophysics of electrosurgery, the basis of equipment and general tissue effects, as well as the surgeon's spatial orientation and hand-eye coordination. Some intraoperative adjuvant procedures and newly developed safety devices have become available may aid to improve electrosurgical safety. CONCLUSIONS: Knowledge of the biophysics of electrosurgery and the mechanisms of electrosurgical injury is important in recognizing potential complications of electrosurgery in laparoscopy. Procedures for prevention, intraoperative adjuvant maneuvers, early recognition of the injury with in-time salvage treatment, and alertness to postoperative warning signs can help reduce such complications.     

Open and closed meniscectomy. A comparative analysis

We reviewed 230 patients an average of 34 months after they had undergone partial or total meniscectomy by surgeons of different experience in a busy unit. Open and arthroscopic meniscectomies were compared. Arthroscopic partial meniscectomy resulted in a significant reduction of inpatient stay and earlier return to work and sport. Analysis of the type of meniscal damage showed that arthroscopic removal of "bucket handles" achieved better results than open techniques. Comparatively poor results were found for lateral meniscectomy.     

Surgical therapy of traumatic shoulder dislocation. Are there evidence-based indications for arthroscopic Bankart operation?

Introduction. For young athletic patients with a primary traumatic shoulder dislocation a surgical treatment is recommended. The operation of choice is the Bankart-Repair. Question. Are there evidence-based indications for an arthroscopic Bankart repair. Methods. Based on the criteria of the “Cochrane Collaboration” a systematic literature search was performed using medline (1966 to 9/2000). 172 publications were found with the key words “shoulder dislocation” and “Bankart”. All relevant articles were ranked and analysed by the criteria of “evidence-based medicine”. Results. There are 12 prospective studies (evidence grade Ib/IIa) and another 28 retrospective studies (evidence grade III). For open Bankart-Repair a recurrence rate of 0 to 8% is reported (prospective/retrospective studies). For arthroscopic Bankart-Repair, 19 of 40 studies and 8 of 12 prospective studies, show a recurrence rate of <10%; however in other studies (prospective/retrospective) an atraumatic recurrence rate of up to 38% is reported. The reasons for these differences in the recurrence rate are not obvious from the given data. In particular, there seems to be no correlation between the type of arthroscopic fixation technique and the recurrence rate. Concerning the postoperative range of shoulder motion, the reported data suggest that external rotation is less limited after arthroscopic than after open Bankart-Repair (arthroscopic: 5–12°, open: 5–25°). However, there is no evidence that patients are more likely to return to their previous level of sporting activities when operated on in an arthroscopic technique than in an open technique (arthroscopic: 42–100%, open: 72–94%). Conclusion. In the surgical treatment of a traumatic shoulder dislocation, the open Bankart-Repair remains the “gold standard”. In reviewing the literature, arthroscopic Bankart-Repair has not been shown to be equal or superior to the open technique.