Proposals for health reform and equity in Uruguay: a redefinition of the Welfare State?

This article reviews and analyzes health sector reform proposals in Uruguay and the possible effects of such reforms in terms of equity, the health sector's institutional structure, and the power relationship between the various actors in the process. The authors contend that a highly structured yet simultaneously fragmented system has conspired against any attempt to introduce major reforms into the system. Thus the only possibility for reform resides neither in the consolidation of the so-called Institutions for Collective Medical Care (IAMCs) nor in the move towards a residual model. Rather, Uruguay is witnessing the system's passive restructuring (i.e., reform by default). In this context and given the system's built-in inequities, the current trend is towards an even more regressive distribution of goods and services. The authors use qualitative and quantitative techniques to show that inequities in expenditure, access, and quality have resulted from long-term developments and adaptive movements of an IAMC system in fiscal stress and the public system's declining quality. Thus, in the absence of changes in state policy that redefine the actors' power or in the absence of system collapse, the country should expect this same regressive trend to deepen.     

Social capital: a strategy for enhancing health?

The idea of social capital is currently being discussed as a source of support for health, though it is often argued that the concept should not be used in an attempt to evolve neutral policy strategies but underlines the need for moral and political debate in health policy. This article, first, supports this argument by indicating the complex and culturally diverse nature of social capital. Its components react with their social contexts to produce a range of variants which differ from each other along several dimensions. Social solidarity and support involve different conventions in different places, with results which need appraisal before they can be supported. The article explores these issues by drawing on ethnographic material illustrating aspects of social relatedness in a variety of settings. Secondly, writers who treat social capital as invariably positive tend to associate it with conditions in the neo-liberal societies of late capitalism, even though they also see it as threatened there. Again examining social contexts, the article locates the reasons for this paradox in the cultures and structures of the societies concerned. Large-scale institutions in the West-including both those required to implement public health measures and those in which the majority of people work-are organised via neo-liberal processes which are not all conducive to the types of social relatedness which the social capital debate seeks to explore. In particular, significant aspects of social trust are difficult to support in neo-liberal organisations. The assumption that social capital can be promoted via social engineering which relies upon these very institutions is thus questionable. This, together with more positive aspects of the debate, draws attention to the need for further research on social relatedness if it is to be supported by public policy.     

Arab immigrants: a new case for ethnicity and health?

Community-based studies of Arab Americans point to significant health problems among the immigrants, a finding that runs contrary to theories of immigrant selectivity. This study is the first to use nationally representative data to test this question. Using new questions that identify region of birth in the 2000 and 2001 National Health Interview Surveys, we compare the self-rated health and activity limitation of Arab immigrants to US-born white Americans and test the extent to which social, demographic, and immigrant characteristics account for observed disparities. The results find that Arab immigrants do not significantly differ from US-born whites in their self-rated health and are less likely to report limitations in activity. Length of time in the US has no composite effect on health; however, US citizenship does. Compared to the most recent immigrant arrivals, Arab immigrants who are citizens report worse health while their peers who are not officially American (non-citizens) do not, regardless of their duration of US residency. Contrary to prior studies on Arab health, we find that Arab immigrants are not uniformly disadvantaged in their health outcomes and that their health profile is more diverse than currently documented. The results also suggest that controlling for years of US residency may be insufficient for capturing the cumulative effects of acculturation on immigrant health. We conclude by suggesting avenues of future research for capturing heterogeneity among emergent ethnic populations such as Arab Americans.     

Can the vulnerability concept support the construction of knowledge in collective health care?

The term vulnerability has been frequently used in scientific literature, especially after the 80's, in some epidemiologic studies, mainly focusing the risk perspective. The purpose of this article is to review the vulnerability concept through a systematic study of national and international circulation newspapers, to support knowledge and practices in the collective health care field. Furthermore, it indicates how this concept has been revisited in studies conducted in Brazil, mentioning issues which support the structural dimension of reality, linking them to the needs of a program for patients, health care users and their families. It is important to study the vulnerability concept due to the fact that an understanding of this concept will contribute to support the delivery of care, of collective health care including individual health care programs and health care policies.     

The experiential knowledge of patients: a new resource for biomedical research?

Both governments and patients' movements are increasingly making a plea in favour of the active participation of patients in biomedical research processes. One of the arguments concerns the contribution that patients could make to the relevance and quality of biomedical research based on their 'experiential knowledge'. This article reflects on the validity of patients' experiential knowledge in the context of biomedical research processes. Since a conclusive argument on the validity of patients' experiential knowledge could not be reached on the basis of theoretical reflection alone, a pragmatic approach was chosen that assessed the validity of patients' experiential knowledge in terms of its practical usefulness for biomedical research. Examples of patient participation in biomedical research were sought through literature research and more than 60 interviews with (bio)medical scientists, patients, representatives from patients' organisations, and health professionals in the Netherlands and the United Kingdom. These examples were analysed for a concrete contribution by patients to the research process. Twenty-one cases of patient participation in biomedical research were identified. After further analysis, concrete use of patients' experiential knowledge could be traced for nine of these cases. These findings suggest that patients' experiential knowledge, when translated into explicit demands, ideas, or judgements, can contribute to the relevance and quality of biomedical research. However, its deliberate use would require a more structural and interactive approach to patient participation. Since the implementation of such an approach could face various obstacles in current biomedical research practices, further research will be needed to investigate its feasibility.     

Whole health: a prescription for the new millennium☆

Good health is not a miracle or a stroke of luck. In addition to genetic factors, a number of commonsense lifestyle changes can influence the quality of life. These include diet, exercise and stress reduction. In addition, the role of yoga, meditation and spirituality as adjuncts to promotion of healthy living is being explored. A holistic preventive approach will ensure good health in the majority of individuals and it is never too late to start. Such measures will alter the biological gradient of physiological decline commonly associated with aging and premature death. At the same time, it is to be emphasized that the essential goal is to improve the quality of years lived, not necessarily to add years to life. Truth and correct knowledge will help to identify the true paths to good health.     

Men's health promotion: a new frontier in Australia and the UK?

The field of men's health has grown markedly over the past few decades. Increased activity specifically relating to men's health promotion in both Australia and the UK has been noted during this period. There has, however, been a reticence to critically examine men's health promotion work within a broader discourse relating to gender and gender relations. Indeed, the vast majority of health-related gender discussion to date has been focused on women's health experiences and their health practices. In this paper, we argue that grounding men's health within this broad gender discourse is important for building an evidence base in, and advancing, men's health promotion work at a range of levels. We specifically explore the research, practice and policy contexts relating to men's health in Australia and the UK, and describe the facilitators for, and barriers to, promoting men's health. We conclude by suggesting that a critical gender lens ought to be applied to current men's health promotion work and provide strategies for researchers, practitioners and policy makers to move towards this new frontier.     

Perceived health and migration: a new sanitary approach?

BACKGROUND: Six percent of the French population is foreign. Paradoxically, there are in France few recent data about the health of these communities. Because a lot of different foreign communities are living in Marseille, it seemed important for us to examine the health of one of these populations. The difficulties encountered in studying the health status in the general population allow us to propose a measure based on perceived health opinion. Our first objective was to state that perceived health status of one community differs between its original country and its emigration country, taking into account the level of morbidity. Our second objective was to show that the perceived health status in the emigration population was close to the one observed in France. METHODS: Two cross-sectional studies were performed in the Comoro Islands and in Marseille, a French south eastern city. The perceived health was assessed with the Duke Health Profile (DHP); the objective health was assessed by a specific questionnaire developed in the USA: the Ridit. The comparisons were conducted, taking into account the major confounding factors. RESULTS: Emigrated people relate higher perceived health status, than those living in the Comoro Islands, for the main dimensions assessed by DHP: physical (71.0 +/- 23.8 vs. 55.9 +/- 23.0), mental (74.6 +/- 19.3 vs. 50.0 +/- 18.5), general health (68.3 +/- 16.3 vs. 61.4 +/- 12.7) and perceived health (62.7 +/- 32.9 vs. 57.1 +/- 48.2). Social health score is the only one which is lower (59.2 +/- 21.8 vs. 77.6 +/- 18.3). The health status levels of the emigrated people are close to those reported in France. The variations of perceived health scores are coherent with those of the objective health indicators. CONCLUSIONS: If these results were confirmed, then this approach, based on self perceived health assessment, could be recommended to study health needs, and the management care, prevention and health promotion impact among these specific communities.     

Brazilian policy for the distribution and production of antiretroviral drugs: a privilege or a right?

This article focuses on the Brazilian National AIDS Program and its policy of distributing and producing antiretroviral drugs, emphasizing links between local decisions and global HIV/AIDS policies. Emphasizing recent developments in the Brazilian and international scenario with regard to access to treatment for people with HIV/AIDS, the article highlights the participation by the pharmaceutical industry, governments, civil society, and UN agencies in establishing responses to the pandemic. The author concludes by identifying transnational activism as a key response to both the power of pharmaceutical corporations and the law of the market (including patent laws), thus fostering global solidarity for people with HIV/AIDS.     

Doing mini-health technology assessments in hospitals: a new concept of decision support in health care?

OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this project was to evaluate local decision support tools used in the Danish hospital sector from a theoretical and an empirical point of view. METHODS: The use of local decision support was evaluated through questionnaires sent to all county health directors, all hospital managers, and all heads of clinical departments in cardiology, orthopedic surgery, and intensive care. In addition, respondents were asked to submit whatever decision support tools they were using (including mini-HTAs, other forms or checklists, and special procedures for decision making concerning new health technologies). A theoretical analysis of the decision support tools (decision theory) was performed as well as a comparison with the business case method used in private companies. Finally, the Danish mini-HTA was compared with foreign production and use of HTA and HTA-like assessments as local decision support. RESULTS: The response rate was high (87 percent, 94 percent, 85 percent, respectively). We collected sixty different forms (of which forty-nine were mini-HTAs) and twenty variants of written procedures. We found theoretical and empirical evidence that local involvement in the process of making the HTA could be important for the use of the results from the HTA and for the process of implementing the new technology. CONCLUSIONS: Doing mini-HTA in hospitals seems to balance the need for quality and depth with the limited time and resources for assessment.     

‘Self-care without a self’: Alzheimer’s disease and the concept of personal responsibility for health

The article focuses on the impact of the concept of self-care on persons who are understood as incapable of self-care due to their physical and/or mental 'incapacity'. The article challenges the idea of this health care concept as empowerment and highlights the difficulties for persons who do not fit into this concept. To exemplify this, the self-care concept is discussed with regard to persons with Alzheimer's disease (AD). In the case of persons with AD, self-care is interpreted in many different ways-depending on the point of view, for instance as an affected person or a carer. To prevent a marginalisation of the growing group of elderly persons with dementia, the article argues that concepts such as those of personhood, wellbeing, autonomy, rationality and normality have to be re-thought with regard to an increasingly ageing population. Taking into account that AD as a socio-medical construct has to be understood in the context of power relations, the article focuses on the mutual influence between the concepts of self-care and of AD and its possible impact on governing dementia and AD in particular. Michel Foucault's considerations on 'technologies of the self' provide the basis for the discussion of the self-care concept within existing societal power relations.     

Women and heart transplantation: an issue of gender equity?

Heart transplantation (HT) is increasingly commonplace in countries with advanced health care systems. A review of the family and HT literature points to a gender inequity in the field: Men are more likely to be heart transplant recipients; women are more likely to contribute as their caregivers. In this critique, we argue that there are not only physiological but also social and economic issues that contribute to inequitable access to HT for women. Further, we point out that another invisible inequity in the heart transplant field is the lack of acknowledgment of, and support for, women whose contributions as family caregivers to the heart transplant process often ensure the success of heart transplant procedures. The authors call for recognition of these inequities and the development of policies that have the potential to ensure that women have equitable access to cardiovascular care in general and HT in particular, and that woman are recognized for, and supported in, their role as caregivers.