Evaluation of Japanese encephalitis virus DNA vaccine candidates in rhesus monkeys [Macaca mulatta

We have previously described DNA vaccine candidates against Japanese encephalitis virus (JEV) that were immunogenic in mice. Present study was conducted to evaluate their immunogenicity in rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) and compare it with the commercial mouse brain-derived, formalin-inactivated vaccine. Groups of four monkeys were immunized with either pMEa (expressing the anchored form of the envelope protein along with the pre-membrane protein of JEV) or pMEs (expressing the secretory form of the envelope protein along with pre-membrane protein of JEV) by intra-muscular (IM, using needle) or intra-dermal (ID, using gene gun) routes. Following primary immunization with 1mg plasmid DNA given IM, or 5 microg plasmid DNA given ID, the monkeys were boosted after 1 and 2 months with 0.5mg DNA given IM or 5 microg DNA given ID, and observed for a period of 6 months. After the second booster, most of the monkeys sero-converted and developed JEV neutralizing antibodies, albeit of low titer. Importantly however, following a sham challenge with the mouse brain-derived inactivated JEV vaccine given 6 months after immunization, the neutralizing antibody titers rose rapidly indicating a vigorous anamnestic response. Based on the JEV neutralizing antibody response following the vaccination and the extent of anamnestic response generated in the immunized monkeys, plasmid pMEa was superior to pMEs. This study indicates that the JEV candidate DNA vaccine is capable of generating protective levels of JEV neutralizing antibodies in rhesus monkeys and prime the immune system effectively against a subsequent exposure to JEV.     

DNA vaccination of mice against rabies virus: effects of the route of vaccination and the adjuvant monophosphoryl lipid A (MPL)

Adjuvants are known to strongly enhance immune responses generated by traditional vaccines, but less is known about the effects of adjuvants on vaccination with DNA. In this study, we investigated the use of the immunostimulant monophosphoryl lipid A (MPL(R)) as an adjuvant, and analyzed three routes of DNA vaccination to determine if this adjuvant could enhance anti-rabies virus neutralizing antibody responses. Compared with antibody titers elicited with DNA only, antibody titers were enhanced after initial intradermal (i.d.) and gene gun immunizations with the combination of DNA and MPL(R). Antibody was not detected after primary intramuscular (i.m.) immunization unless MPL(R) was included with the DNA. Surprisingly, antibody titers of MPL(R)-treated mice decreased after i.d. or i.m. booster vaccinations, but increased after gene gun booster vaccinations. In contrast to these varied responses, booster immunizations without MPL(R) via the three different routes consistently increased antibody titers. All mice with detectable levels of neutralizing antibody at the time of challenge survived virus infection. There was no difference in the survival rate between groups of mice that received similar vaccinations with MPL(R)/DNA or DNA only. The data suggest that MPL(R) can enhance the neutralizing antibody response when used with the initial injection of DNA. Suppression of neutralizing antibody responses after i.d. or i.m. booster vaccinations that included MPL(R) suggests that the number of vaccinations, and the route of vaccination, should be carefully considered when MPL(R) is used with DNA vaccines.     

One-time gene gun or intramuscular rabies DNA vaccination of non-human primates: comparison of neutralizing antibody responses and protection against rabies virus 1 year after vaccination.

We have previously shown that Macaca fascicularis (Cynomologus) monkeys receiving a primary and either one or two booster rabies DNA vaccinations are protected against rabies virus. In this study, we determined whether monkeys that had been vaccinated only once via gene gun or intramuscularly (i.m.) with different concentrations of DNA would be protected against rabies virus challenge. Neutralizing antibody responses were assayed for 1 year before the monkeys were challenged. Neutralizing antibody was detected at least 50 days earlier in gene gun vaccinated as compared to i.m. vaccinated animals. Prior to viral challenge, all (6/6, 100%) gene gun vaccinated animals, but only 3/6 (50%) i.m. vaccinated animals seroconverted. In general, antibody titers of the gene gun vaccinated animals were higher than the titers of the i.m. vaccinated animals. There was no correlation between the concentration of DNA used for vaccination, the neutralizing antibody responses elicited and protection against viral challenge. Seven days after viral challenge, a rapid and strong anamnestic antibody response was elicited in 100% of the gene gun vaccinated monkeys and in four i.m. vaccinated monkeys. Neutralizing antibody remained undetectable in two i.m. vaccinated monkeys. Overall, 60% (3/5) of the gene gun vaccinated animals and 87% (5/6) of the i.m. vaccinated monkeys survived viral challenge. This study is the first, to our knowledge, to show long-term protection of non-human primates against a human viral pathogen using a DNA vaccination protocol that did not include a booster immunization.     

Immunogenicity and protective efficacy of the current inactivated Japanese encephalitis vaccine against different Japanese encephalitis virus strains

Mouse brain-derived, inactivated Japanese encephalitis (JE) vaccine has been internationally used for many years. It is believed that this vaccine made a great contribution to the reduction of JE patients in several countries. Mouse brain-derived, Beijing-1 and Nakayama JE vaccines induce high levels of neutralizing antibodies. High levels of induced antibodies are maintained at least for 3-4 yr. The induced antibodies are cross-reactive to heterologous strains; however, the neutralizing antibody titers against heterologous strains are usually lower than those against homologous strains. Considering that both Nakayama and Beijing-1 JE vaccines showed high levels of protective efficacy in Taiwan and Thailand where strains other than Nakayama and Beijing-1 were circulating, we conclude that the current inactivated JE vaccine can induce high levels of protective immunity against heterologous JE virus strains.     

Japanese encephalitis protein vaccine candidates expressing neutralizing epitope and M.T hsp70 induce virus-specific memory B cells and long-lasting antibodies in swine

Swine are an important amplifier of Japanese encephalitis (JE) virus in the paradomestic environment. In this study, two JE protein vaccine candidates were evaluated for immunogenicity in swine. Both vaccine plasmids are based on a prokaryotic vector pET-32a(+). One plasmid, designated pET-32a(+)-epitope, encode a cassette consisting of a neutralizing epitope on envelope (E) protein of JE virus, whereas the other plasmid, designated pET-32a(+)-epitope-hsp70, express the fusion protein of the epitope and M.T hsp70. Some differences were detected in the immunogenicity of these two proteins in swine. Swine immunized twice with 2000pmol of the neutralizing epitope or the fusion protein developed neutralizing antibody titers of respectively, 154 and 300, and anti-neutralizing epitope antibody titers of 10(4.25) and 10(6.0) by 3 weeks after the second immunization. In addition, swine immunized with the neutralizing epitope emulsified with adjuvant S206 or with imported mineral oil and Tween-80 induced neutralizing antibody titers of 196 and 244, and anti-neutralizing epitope antibody titers of 10(5.25) or 10(5.6) at the same time point. However, swine administered two doses of a commercial JE vaccine (attenuated virus preparation; JEV SA14-14-2 strain) developed less favorable antibody responses with neutralizing antibody titer 40 and anti-neutralizing epitope antibody titers 10(3.7). The anamnestic response was followed by monitoring titers 1 week after boosting with a viral antigen; swine immunized twice with the fusion protein showed a 177-fold increase in anti-neutralizing epitope titer, indicating a strong recall of the antibody response. The animals maintained detectable levels of anti-neutralizing epitope antibody for at least 105 days after two immunizations, indicating that these four protein antigens are able to stimulate virus-specific memory B cells and long-lasting antibodies at higher levels than is achieved using a current commercial attenuated JEV vaccine. The group immunized with the epitope fused to M.T hsp70 made the strongest proliferation of lymphocytes. Through the assay of the amount of interferon (IFN)-gamma and interleukin (IL)-4 in the serum, swine immunized with the fusion protein increased IFN-gamma in the serum which showed that M.T hsp70 potentiated Th1 immune response.     

Re: Natural infection with Japanese encephalitis virus among inhabitants of Japan: a nationwide survey of antibodies against nonstructural 1 protein

Investigations to assess episodes of any natural Japanese encephalitis (JE) infection following prior immunizations with JE inactivated vaccine in Japan are commendable. Employing differential production of nonstructural 1 protein NS1, during a natural infection and not by inactivated JE vaccine [Konishi E, Shoda M, Yamamoto S, Arai S, Tanaka-Taya K, Okabe N. Natural infection with Japanese encephalitis virus among inhabitants of Japan: a nationwide survey of antibodies against nonstructural 1 protein. Vaccine 2006;24:3054-956], natural infection was manifest in eight selected prefectures in Japan. Moreover, it would be possible to detect any foreign pathogenic JE virus (JEV) or any native strains associated with any major shift in JE clinical presentations. On the opposite, any NS1 antibody screen might be invalid among recipients of live JE vaccines.     

Immunogenicity and protective efficacy in monkeys of purified inactivated Vero-cell SARS vaccine

BACKGROUND: In 2003, severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) resulted in hundreds of infections and deaths globally. We aim to assess immunogenicity and protective efficacy of purified inactivated Vero-cell SARS vaccine in monkeys. METHODS: The cultures of SARS coronavirus (SARS-CoV) BJ-01 strain infected Vero cells were inactivated with beta-propiolactone. Sequential procedures, including ultrafiltration, gel filtration and ion exchange chromatography, were performed to obtain purified inactivated SARS vaccine. The purified SARS vaccine was analyzed with electron microscope, HPLC and Western blotting. We immunized three groups of cynomolgus macaques fascicularis with adjuvant-containing purified vaccine, purified vaccine and unpurified vaccine, respectively, and a fourth group served as a control. Antibody titers were measured by plaque reduction neutralization test. The vaccinated monkeys were challenged with SARS-CoV BJ-01 strain to observe protective efficacy. Additionally, three groups of rhesus monkeys were immunized with different doses of the purified inactivated SARS vaccine (0.5, 1 and 2mug/time/monkey) on days 0 and 7, and the monkeys were challenged with SARS-CoV GZ-01 strain. We assessed the safety of the SARS vaccine and observed whether the antibody dependent enhancement (ADE) occurred under low levels of neutralizing antibody in rhesus. FINDINGS: The purity of SARS vaccine was 97.6% by HPLC identification and reacted with convalescent sera of SARS patients. The purified SARS vaccine induced high levels of neutralizing antibodies and prevented the replication of SARS-CoV in monkeys. Under low levels of neutralizing antibody, no exacerbation of clinical symptoms was observed when the immunized monkeys were challenged with SARS-CoV. In this preliminary animal trial, no side effects were detected when monkeys were immunized with purified SARS vaccine either at normal or large doses. INTERPRETATION: The purified inactivated SARS vaccine could induce high levels of neutralizing antibody, and protect the monkeys from the challenge of SARS-CoV. The SARS vaccine prepared in the study appeared to be safe in monkeys.     

Non-clinical and phase I clinical trials of a Vero cell-derived inactivated Japanese encephalitis vaccine

The safety and effectiveness of a Vero cell-derived inactivated Japanese encephalitis (JE) vaccine were compared with those of a current JE vaccine in non-clinical studies and a phase I clinical trial. The single-dose toxicity study showed no toxicity of either the current JE vaccine or the investigational Vero cell-derived JE vaccine. In a local irritation study, the degree of irritation caused by both vaccines was determined to be the same as that induced by normal saline. To investigate genotoxicity, a chromosomal aberration test was conducted and the results were negative. Both JE vaccines were administered to a group of 30 subjects who were seronegative (neutralizing antibody titer <10(1)) for JEV virus (Beijing-1 Strain). Each subject was subcutaneously inoculated twice at an interval of 1-4 weeks, followed by an additional booster inoculation 4-8 weeks later, and clinical reactions and serological responses were subsequently investigated. Adverse drug reactions of local reaction, headache and malaise were mild, occurring at a rate of 6.7 and 20.0% after administration of the Vero cell-derived JE vaccine and the current JE vaccine, respectively. The seroconversion rate after three doses of both JE vaccines was 100%, while the geometric mean titer for the Vero cell-derived and current JE vaccines was 10(2.35) and 10(2.03), respectively. These results suggest that the safety and effectiveness of the Vero cell-derived inactivated JE vaccine are equal to those of the currently available conventional vaccine in humans, and that the Vero cell-derived vaccine could be a useful second-generation JE vaccine.     

Partial protective effect of inactivated Japanese encephalitis vaccine on lethal West Nile virus infection in mice

The effect of mouse brain-derived, inactivated Japanese encephalitis (JE) vaccine on West Nile virus (WNV) infection was examined using a murine model. Mice were immunized with JE vaccine twice and challenged with lethal doses of WNV. When mice were intracranially challenged with WNV, none of the immunized mice were protected. When mice were intraperitoneally challenged, the immunized mice were protected at higher immunization levels. Cross-reactive neutralizing antibodies to WNV were induced by immunization with JE vaccine; however, the levels were much lower than those to JEV. These results indicate that the currently available mouse brain-derived inactivated JE vaccine can induce partial protective immunity to WNV in mice.     

A 3-year follow-up of antibody response in HIV-infected children with immune recovery vaccinated with inactivated Japanese encephalitis vaccine

Among HIV-infected children who had immune recovery after received antiretroviral therapy (ART), good responses to revaccination with childhood vaccines have been observed. However, the rate of long-term persistence of antibody response remains unknown. The objective of this study is to determine whether HIV-infected children still have protective antibody against Japanese encephalitis virus (JE) 3 years after receiving revaccination with two doses of inactivated JE vaccine. Plasma JE neutralizing antibody titer was determined by a plaque reduction neutralization assay. An antibody titer of more than 1:10 was defined as being protective. Fifty HIV-infected children with a mean age of 10.3 years (SD 2.2) and mean CD4 percentage of 25 (SD 5) were revaccinated with two doses of inactivated JE vaccine. Forty-three children had been followed-up for 3 years. The JE neutralizing antibody at 1 month and 3 years after revaccination were detected among 38 (88%) and 35 (81%) children, respectively. The geometric means titer significantly dropped from of 306 (min 13–max 163,617) to 106 (min 11–max 4645). This data show that the majority of HIV-infected children had persistent antibody 3 years after revaccination. JE revaccination in HIV-infected children with immune recovery after ART should be carried out in endemic areas.     

Antigenic characterization of the live attenuated Japanese encephalitis vaccine virus SA14-14-2: a comparison with isolates of the virus covering a wide geographic area.

In China, a live attenuated Japanese encephalitis (JE) vaccine, based on strain SA14-14-2, has been derived from the wild-type strain SA14 as an alternative to the current inactivated vaccines such as Nakayama-NIH and P-3. SA14-14-2 has been characterized using monoclonal antibodies derived in mice, using HAI and neutralization tests, and compared with other Chinese live vaccine clones and 14 wild-type strains of JE virus. Wild-type strain SA14 was found to be a poor immunogen and antigenically distant from all other viruses examined. The vaccine derivatives SA14-5-3 was more immunogenic than its wild-type parent, while SA14-14-2 (derived from SA14-5-3) was more immunogenic than SA14-5-3 and elicited a cross neutralizing antibody response. Our studies indicated that JE virus strain Nakayama elicited as good a neutralizing antibody response in hyperimmunized mice as the SA14-14-2 vaccine clones grown in either primary hamster kidney (PHK) or primary dog kidney (PDK) cells. A single dose of live SA14-14-2 (PHK) also elicited a good antibody response. Antigenic variation between wild-type and vaccine clones of JE virus were detected but were not considered significant in terms of controlling JE virus infections by vaccination.     

Trial of inactivated Japanese encephalitis vaccine in children with underlying diseases

Two shots of inactivated Japanese encephalitis (JE) vaccine were given to children, 139 with underlying diseases and 42 healthy, and their antibody responses were studied by the neutralization test. Before vaccination, most of the vaccinees did not have antibody against JE virus. One month after the second vaccination, they were all seroconverted and showed considerably high neutralizing titres. One healthy child developed fever on the day of vaccination without any severe symptoms afterwards, and no side reactions were observed in the handicapped children. These results suggest that the current JE vaccine is safe and can induce a strong immune response even in handicapped children.     

Rabies vaccination: comparison of neutralizing antibody responses after priming and boosting with different combinations of DNA, inactivated virus, or recombinant vaccinia virus vaccines

Long-term levels of neutralizing antibody were evaluated in mice after a single immunization with experimental DNA or recombinant vaccinia virus (RVV) vaccines encoding the rabies virus glycoprotein (G), or the commercially available inactivated virus human diploid cell vaccine (HDCV). Anamnestic antibody titers were also evaluated after two booster immunizations with vaccines that were identical to or different from the priming vaccine. Five hundred and forty days (1.5 year) after a single immunization with any of the three vaccines, neutralizing antibody titers remained greater than the minimal acceptable human level of antibody titer (0.5 International Units (IU)/ml). In addition, either an HDCV or DNA booster elicited early and elevated anamnestic antibody responses in mice that had been primed with any of the three vaccines. In contrast, RVV boosters failed to elevate titers in mice that had been previously primed with RVV, and elicited slowly rising titers in mice that had been primed with either DNA or HDCV. Thus, a single vaccination with any of the three different vaccines elicited long-term levels of neutralizing antibody that exceeded 0.5 IU/ml. In contrast, different prime-booster vaccine combinations elicited anamnestic neutralizing antibody responses that increased quickly, increased slowly or failed to increase.     

Effect of current Japanese encephalitis vaccine on different strains of Japanese encephalitis virus

Inactivated Japanese encephalitis (JE) vaccine was given to healthy children and their neutralizing antibody titres against nine JE virus strains were measured. After two shots of the vaccine in the first year, most of the children showed seroconversion, but their neutralizing antibody titres were not high, and one year after vaccination their titres had decreased to low levels. However, a booster dose of vaccine in the second year had a marked effect on the antibody response. The neutralizing antibodies induced by the vaccine reacted to almost the same extent with nine different JE virus strains, though significantly higher titres against the Nakayama strain, the vaccine strain, were observed after vaccination in the second year.     

Immune response to immunostimulatory complexes (ISCOMs) prepared from human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) or the HIV-1 external envelope glycoprotein (gp120)

In mice, immunostimulatory complexes (ISCOMs) prepared from HIV-1 B external envelope glycoprotein (gp120) induced 10-fold higher antibody titres than gp120 emulsified in depot adjuvant, as measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Rhesus monkeys immunized with gp120 ISCOMs produced precipitating and virus neutralizing antibody titres equivalent to those seen in HIV-infected chimpanzees and humans. After multiple immunizations with HIV-1 B gp120 ISCOMs, a rhesus monkey developed a neutralizing response to the HIV-1 isolates RF and MN, but not to the CC isolate. Antisera from ISCOM-immunized rhesus monkeys recognized gp120 on the membranes of HIV-1 B-infected H9 cells, indicating the preservation of epitope structure in the ISCOMs matrix.     

Assessment of neutralizing antibodies elicited by a vaccine (Nakayama) strain of Japanese encephalitis virus in Taiwan.

A total of 368 blood specimens were resampled from a serum collection containing 2914 blood samples which were collected by a random sampling in Taiwan in 1991. The plaque reduction neutralization test was applied to evaluate the neutralizing ability to two strains of Japanese encephalitis viruses, i.e. Nakayama (the present vaccine strain) and JE5 (a Taiwan isolate). The result revealed that antibodies against JE virus were present in each stratified age group. Antibody positive rates were both highest in the group older than 70 years although the lowest rates were located in different groups. In addition, the result showed that the immunogenicity potency of the antibody induced by the vaccine strain did not have a good coverage against JE5. The rate of neutralizing antibodies above the level of protective efficacy of the present vaccine was limited as low as 37.93%. Efficacy of the vaccine used at present was apparently not efficient. Consideration of a more promising vaccine may be necessary.     

Simultaneous immunization with DNA and protein vaccines against Japanese encephalitis or dengue synergistically increases their own abilities to induce neutralizing antibody in mice

Gene-based and protein-based vaccines are two distinct types of vaccines. In this report, we examined if combined use of DNA and protein vaccines would increase their own abilities to induce neutralizing antibody in murine models for Japanese encephalitis (JE) or dengue type 2 (DEN2). DNA vaccines for JE (pcJEME) or DEN2 (pcD2ME) were inoculated intramuscularly, and protein vaccines consisting of subviral extracellular particles (EPs) containing JE (JEEP) or DEN2 (D2EP) virus antigens were inoculated subcutaneously with Freund's adjuvant. Two immunizations of ICR mice with pcJEME and/or JEEP in the prime-boost protocol indicated that levels of neutralizing antibody induced by the pcJEME prime-JEEP boost vaccination were two to eight-fold higher than those induced by pcJEME alone, but were equivalent to those induced by JEEP alone and slightly higher than those induced by the JEEP prime-pcJEME boost regimen. On the other hand, simultaneous immunization of ICR mice with pcJEME and JEEP provided synergistically higher neutralizing antibody titers than those provided by immunization with either immunogen. Immunization with graded doses of pcJEME and JEEP confirmed the synergism. The synergistic increase in neutralizing antibody titer by simultaneous immunization with DNA and protein vaccines was also shown by immunization with pcD2ME and D2EP in ICR and ddY mice. Both IgG1 and IgG2a antibodies were induced by combined immunization with pcJEME and JEEP.     

Canine rabies DNA vaccination: a single-dose intradermal injection into ear pinnae elicits elevated and persistent levels of neutralizing antibody

Rabid dog exposures cause >99% of human rabies deaths world-wide. In developing countries, where dogs are the viral reservoir, the 30-50% vaccination coverage of dog populations is insufficient to break the disease transmission cycle. In addition, many vaccines currently used in developing countries fail to maintain detectable levels of neutralizing antibody. The poor vaccination coverage with inadequate vaccines, in addition to the difficulty in locating dogs for booster vaccinations, suggest that an inexpensive vaccine that elicits long-term immunity after a single-dose vaccination could improve control of canine rabies in developing countries. One solution could be a DNA vaccine. This study was designed to evaluate in dogs the ability of different methods of a single-dose DNA vaccination to elicit enhanced levels of neutralizing antibody. Intradermal (i.d.) vaccination into ear pinnae elicited elevated and long-lasting levels of neutralizing antibody. Minimal or undetectable levels of neutralizing antibody were detected after vaccination into quadriceps muscle, gene gun vaccination into ear pinnae or i.d. vaccination into the neck. Intramuscular (i.m.) or gene gun vaccinations did not "immunologically prime" a majority of dogs vaccinated by these routes. The passive transfer of sera from dogs that had been vaccinated i.d. in ear pinnae protected mice against rabies virus challenge. A single-dose i.d. rabies DNA vaccination into ear pinnae could aid in the control of canine rabies in developing countries.     

Rabies DNA vaccination of non-human primates: post-exposure studies using gene gun methodology that accelerates induction of neutralizing antibody and enhances neutralizing antibody titers

Pre-exposure DNA vaccination protects non-human primates against rabies virus. Post-exposure protection of monkeys against rabies virus by DNA vaccination has not been attempted. Presumably, post-exposure experiments have not been undertaken because neutralizing antibody is usually slow to be induced after DNA vaccination. In this study, we initially attempted to accelerate the induction of neutralizing antibody by varying the route and site of DNA vaccination and booster frequency. Gene gun (GG) vaccinations above axillary and inguinal lymph nodes or in ear pinnae generated higher levels of neutralizing antibody than intradermal (ID) needle vaccinations in the pinnae. Concurrent GG booster vaccinations above axillary and inguinal lymph nodes and in ear pinnae, 3 days after primary vaccination, accelerated detectable neutralizing antibody. GG booster vaccinations also resulted in higher neutralizing antibody levels and increased the durability of this response. Post-exposure vaccination with DNA or the human diploid cell vaccine (HDCV), in combination with an one-time treatment with human rabies immune globulin (HRIG), protected 50 and 75% of the monkeys, respectively, as compared to 75% mortality of the controls. These data will be useful for the refinement, development, and implementation of future pre- and post-exposure rabies DNA vaccination studies.