The effectiveness of thymectomy on seronegative generalized myasthenia gravis: comparing with seropositive cases

OBJECTIVES: To investigate the efficacy of thymectomy between patients with seronegative myasthenia gravis (SNMG) and seropositive myasthenia gravis (SPMG). METHODS: We present here the first Taiwanese retrospective paired cohort study comparing the effectiveness of thymectomy among 16 seronegative and 32 seropositive MG patients after matching for age-of-onset and time-to-thymectomy, and following up over a mean of 35 +/- 20 (7-86) months. Clinical characteristics and complete stable remission (CSR) rates were compared and analyzed between the groups. RESULTS: There were no major clinical differences between the two groups except for our finding of a lower percentage of SNMG receiving preoperative plasmapheresis or human immunoglobulin than SPMG (31% for SNMG vs 72% for SPMG, P = 0.007). CSR rates calculated using the Kaplan-Meier method were similar in the two groups (38% for SNMG vs 50% for SPMG, P = 0.709). The median time for CSR was 47.4 months for SNMG and 48.2 months for SPMG. Thymic hyperplasia were the most common pathology (69% for SNMG vs 88% for SPMG, P = 0.24). During the follow-up period, we found no group difference on prednisolone or pyridostigmine dosages. Significant postoperative dosage reductions on pyridostigmine, but not on prednisolone, were found in both groups. CONCLUSIONS: Thymectomy has a comparable response among SNMG and SPMG in our study. Thymic hyperplasia is prevalent in our SNMG patients and thymectomy may also be a therapeutic option to increase the probability of remission or improvement in SNMG. More prospective controlled trial will be helpful in the future.     

Effect of sera from seronegative myasthenia gravis patients on neuromuscular junctions

About 85 % of patients with generalized myasthenia gravis (MG) have anti-nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) antibodies in their sera (seropositive MG; SPMG). The other 15 % (seronegative MG; SNMG) are also considered to have antibody-mediated disease, but the nature of the antibodies in SNMG is not fully understood. We investigated the effect of sera from patients with MG on spontaneous muscle action potentials and acetylcholine (ACh)-induced potentials, and we examined the localization of epitopes recognized by SPMG sera or SNMG sera. SPMG sera and SNMG sera inhibited spontaneous muscle action potentials and ACh-induced potentials in the spinal-muscle co-culture system. However, spontaneous muscle action potentials and ACh-induced potentials in the neuromuscular junctions were strongly blocked by SPMG serum, whereas they were weakly blocked by SNMG serum. Both types of sera reacted strongly with the neuromuscular junctions in normal rat muscles, as shown by double immunostaining with serum and α-bungarotoxin. The SPMG epitope remained in the neuromuscular junctions, whereas that of SNMG disappeared after denervation of the sciatic nerve. Therefore, we suggest that the skeletal muscle weakness in SNMG may be due to an interaction with presynaptic neuromuscular transmission and nAChR.     

IgG from "seronegative" myasthenia gravis patients binds to a muscle cell line, TE671, but not to human acetylcholine receptor

Antibodies to acetylcholine receptor (AChR) are found in 85% of patients with myasthenia gravis (seropositive MG [SPMG]) and are thought to be pathogenic; but in 15% of MG patients, the standard immunoprecipitation test for anti-AChR is negative (seronegative MG [SNMG]). Here, we used a novel approach, fluorescence-activated cell sorting analysis, to measure binding of SPMG and SNMG IgG antibodies to rhabdomyosarcoma cell lines that express human adult (TE671-epsilon) or fetal (TE671-gamma) AChR, and to human embryonic kidney (HEK) fibroblasts that express adult human AChR (HEK-AChR). We found that whereas most SPMG antibodies bind to all three cell lines, IgG from 8 of 15 SNMG sera/plasmas bind to the surface of both TE671 cell lines but not to HEK-AChR cells. These results indicate that SNMG antibodies bind to a muscle surface antigen that is not the AChR, which strongly supports previous studies that suggest that SNMG should be considered a distinct subtype of MG.     

Acetylcholine receptor antibodies in myasthenia gravis are associated with greater risk of diabetes and thyroid disease

OBJECTIVE: Myasthenia gravis (MG) may be associated with the presence of acetylcholine receptor antibodies (AChRAb) [seropositive MG (SPMG)] or their absence [seronegative MG (SNMG)]. Along with features of MG, the presence of the AChRAb may relate to the existence of other immune-mediated diseases. We sought to determine the association of SPMG with other potential autoimmune diseases. METHODS: A retrospective evaluation of prospectively identified MG patients at a tertiary care center was performed, with patients separated into SPMG and SNMG. Prevalence of other immune-mediated disorders, as well as the epidemiology, sensitivity of diagnostic testing, and thymic pathology, was contrasted between both patient groups. RESULTS: Of the 109 MG patients identified, 66% were SPMG. SPMG was associated with a greater likelihood of significant repetitive stimulation decrement, the presence of either thymoma or thymic hyperplasia, and the presence of thyroid disease. In addition, all patients with a diagnosis of diabetes, concurrent with MG, were found to be SPMG. CONCLUSIONS: AChRAb and SPMG impart not only a distinctive clinical and electrophysiological phenotype of MG, but are also associated with the heightened presence of endocrinological disease.     

重症肌无力被动转移动物模型的研究

目的 :探讨血清阳性 (SPMG)和阴性重症肌无力 (SNMG)被动转移动物模型 (P EAMG)的异同。方法 :用ELISA法将重症肌无力 (MG)患者分为SNMG和SPMG两组 ,然后分别用两组患者血清制作P EAMG ,观察两组小鼠的临床表现、电生理及神经肌接头(NMJ)的改变。结果 :SPMG和SNMG组小鼠均表现出明显的肌无力症状 ,低频重复电刺激出现明显衰减反应 ,但SNMG组小鼠肌无力症状较SPMG组明显为轻 ,SPMG和SNMG组小鼠NMJ处棕黄色沉积物明显减少、变细短。结论 :SNMG和SPMG均是自身抗体介导的自身免疫性疾病 ,但两者不完全相同     

Seronegative myasthenia gravis: disease severity and prognosis

Around 10-20% of myasthenia gravis (MG) patients do not have acetylcholine receptor (AChR) antibodies (seronegative), of whom some have antibodies to a membrane-linked muscle specific kinase (MuSK). To examine MG severity and long-term prognosis in seronegative MG compared with seropositive MG, and to look specifically at anti-AChR antibody negative and anti-MuSK antibody negative patients. Seventeen consecutive seronegative non-thymomatous MG patients and 34 age and sex matched contemporary seropositive non-thymomatous MG controls were included in a retrospective follow-up study for a total period of 40 years. Clinical criteria were assessed each year, and muscle antibodies were assayed. There was no difference in MG severity between seronegative and seropositive MG. However, when thymectomized patients were excluded from the study at the year of thymectomy, seropositive MG patients had more severe course than seronegative (P < 0.001). One seropositive patient died from MG related respiratory insufficiency. The need for thymectomy in seronegative MG was lower than in seropositive MG. None of the seronegative patients had MuSK antibodies. This study shows that the presence of AChR antibodies in MG patients correlates with a more severe MG. With proper treatment, especially early thymectomy for seropositive MG, the outcome and long-term prognosis is good in patients with and without AChR antibodies.     

Seronegative myasthenia gravis: a plasma factor inhibiting agonist-induced acetylcholine receptor function copurifies with IgM.

Anti-acetylcholine receptor antibodies cannot be detected by standard radioimmunoassay in 10 to 15% of patients with generalized myasthenia gravis (seronegative myasthenia gravis). We investigated the effect of seronegative myasthenia gravis plasma on 22Na+ flux through acetylcholine receptors and voltage-gated sodium channels in the human rhabdomyosarcoma cell line, TE671. Fourteen of 19 seronegative MG plasmas inhibited acetylcholine receptor 22Na+ flux; none inhibited voltage-gated sodium channel flux. The inhibitory activity was found in the IgG-depleted fraction, and copurified with IgM after gel-filtration chromatography. Inhibitory activity was absent from the plasma of 8 healthy control subjects and of 6 patients with the Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome, but was present in the IgG-depleted plasma fraction of 4 of 6 seropositive patients with myasthenia gravis and all 5 patients with demyelinating polyneuropathy. We conclude that a low-affinity serum factor, probably an IgM antibody, found in a high proportion in patients with seronegative and those with seropositive myasthenia gravis may contribute to the muscle weakness in myasthenia gravis, but its role in these and other neuroimmunological disorders requires further investigation.     

Myasthenia gravis with anti-acetylcholine receptor antibody or anti-muscle specific kinase antibody

Patients with myasthenia gravis (MG) are divided into 3 groups: anti-acetylcholine receptor antibody-positive MG (AChR MG), anti-muscle specific kinase antibody-positive MG (MuSK MG), and AChR-and MuSK-negative MG (double seronegative MG; double SNMG). A recent study on the detection of low-affinity antibodies binding to AChR showed the presence of AChR antibodies in about 70% of double SNMG patients. There is accumulating evidence that double SNMG patients are similar to AChR-MG patients with respect to clinical features and thymic pathology. Since most MG patients are thought to belong to the AChR-MG or MuSK-MG group of patients, this article reviews the pathophysiology, clinical features, and treatments in these 2 groups of MG patients. The pathophysiology of AChR-MG is closely related to the abnormal thymic pathology, such as thymic hyperplasia or presence of thymoma, and thy(mo)mectomy is recommended in patients with generalized AChR-MG. On the contrary, little thymic abnormality in patients with MuSK-MG discourages thymectomy; however, MuSK-MG patients do respond to thymectomy and therefore studies to define the indications of thymectomy in MuSK-MG patients are required. The responses to cholinesterase inhibitors are poor in patients with MuSK-MG, and these patients tend to show hyperactivity to the Tensilon test, such as fasciculation of facial muscles and stuffy sensation in the throat. The adverse responses to a small dose of intravenous edrophonium chloride injection may support the clinical diagnosis of MuSK-MG. Further, only small doses of acetylcholinesterase inhibitors are administered to patients with MuSK-MG in order to avoid cholinergic hyperactivity. In general, both types of MG patients respond well to treatments with immunosuppressants, including steroids, but some patients with MuSK-MG show persistent bulbar symptoms.     

Clinical and experimental features of MuSK antibody positive MG in Japan

We investigated the presence of antibodies (Abs) against muscle-specific tyrosine kinase (MuSK) in Japanese myasthenia gravis (MG) patients. MuSK Abs were found in 23 (27%) of 85 generalized seronegative MG (SNMG) patients but not in any of the ocular MG patients. MuSK Ab-positive patients were characterized as having female dominance (M:F, 5:18), age range at onset 18 to 72 (median 45) years old, and prominent oculobulbar symptoms (100%) with neck (57%) or respiratory (35%) muscle weakness. Limb muscle weakness was comparatively less severe (52%), thymoma absent. Most patients had good responses to simple plasma exchange and steroid therapy. MuSK IgG from all 18 patients was exclusively the IgG 4 subclass and bound mainly with the MuSK Ig 1–2 domain. Serial studies of 12 individuals showed a close correlation between the variation in MuSK Ab titers and MG clinical severity ( P  = 0.01 by Kruskal–Wallis). MuSK Ab titers were sharply decreased in patients who had a good response to early steroid therapy or simple plasma exchange, but there was no change, or a rapid increase on exacerbation after thymectomy. Measurement of MuSK Ab titers aids in the diagnosis of MG and the monitoring of clinical courses after treatment.     

Autoantibody detection by a live cell-based assay in conventionally antibody-tested triple seronegative Myasthenia gravis

Autoantibody testing is the mainstay in confirming the diagnosis of autoimmune myasthenia gravis (MG). However, in approximately 15% of patients, antibody testing in clinical routine remains negative (seronegative MG). This study aimed at assessing the prevalence of “clustered” AChR- and MuSK- and LRP4- autoantibodies using a live cell-based assay in a large German cohort of seronegative myasthenia gravis (SNMG) patients. A total of 67 SNMG patients were included. Clustered AChR-ab were identified in 4.5% (n = 3) of patients. Two out of the three patients showed binding to the adult AchR as well as the fetal AchR. None of the patients was positive for MuSK- or LRP4-autoantibodies. There were no differences in clinical characteristics between the patients with and without clustered AChR-ab detection. Comparison of clinical data of our cohort with clinical data from the nationwide Myasthenia gravis registry showed broad similarities between seronegative MG patients of both cohorts.     

MuSK-positive myasthenia gravis is rare in the Polish population

Background and purpose:  MuSK-positive myasthenia gravis (MG) is diagnosed in 0–48% of cases with generalized seronegative MG in different populations. The presence of anti-MuSK antibodies generally relates to a severe course and lack of response to thymectomy. We analyzed for the first time the serology and clinical characteristics of MuSK-positive MG in the Polish population.
Methods:  One hundred and fifty-one patients were tested for the presence of anti-AChR and anti-MuSK antibodies: 62 with seronegative MG, including 14 with ocular seronegative MG, 48 age-matched patients with seropositive MG and 41 controls.
Results: All patients with seropositive MG and the disease controls were MuSK-negative. Anti-MuSK antibodies were detected only in four patients with seronegative MG (8.7% of generalized seronegative cases): three women and one man. All four had predominantly bulbar involvement, and underwent thymectomy, with no apparent benefit. All of them improved clinically after immunosuppressive treatment with remissions lasting up to 7 years.
Conclusion: MuSK-positive MG is rare in Polish population accounting for only 8.7% of seronegative cases with generalized MG. This is consistent with emerging evidence for lower MuSK antibodies at more northerly latitudes.     

重症肌无力患者酪氨酸激酶抗体的检测

目的探讨酪氨酸激酶抗体（MuSKAb）在血清阴性重症肌无力（SNMG）发病中的作用。方法采用放射免疫法检测198例重症肌无力（MG）患者血清中抗乙酰胆碱受体抗体（AChRAb）水平，筛选出SNMG血清样本再行MuSKAb水平检测。结果MG患者血清AChRAb浓度明显高于对照组（P〈0．05），其阳性率为81．3％，SNMG患者血清MuSKAb均为阴性。结论MuSKAb可能在中国SNMG患者中的检出率较低。     

Myasthenia gravis in children: Long-term follow-up

We report observations made on 149 patients with juvenile myasthenia gravis studied from onset of disease for as long as 40 years. Median follow-up was 17 years; minimum was 4 years. Eight other patients with congenital myasthenia gravis were studied separately. Of the juvenile myasthenic patients, 85 (57%) underwent thymectomy because of disease severity. In juvenile myasthenia gravis, a spontaneous remission rate of 22.4 per 1,000 person-year was observed, regardless of disease duration. A remission rate of 260 per 1,000 person-years was seen during the first year after thymectomy, with a rate of 95 per 1,000 person-years during the next 2 years. Early surgery, presence of bulbar symptoms, absence of ocular signs or generalized symptoms, onset of symptoms between ages 12 and 16, and presence of other immune disease were associated with increased postoperative remission rates. Epilepsy (4 patients) and neoplasia (7 patients) were the most frequent associated nonimmune disorders; rheumatoid arthritis (5 patients) and neoplasia diabetes mellitus (3 patients), asthma (3 patients), and thyroid disease (3 patients) were the most frequent associated immune diseases.     

Anti-alkaline phosphatase antibody positive myasthenia gravis

Anti-alkaline phosphatase antibody (AP Ab) was specific in 9% of 249 anti-acetylcholine receptor (AChR) Ab-positive myasthenia gravis (MG) (SPMG) patients but not in patients with AChR Ab-negative MG (SNMG), other neurological and immunological diseases, or healthy volunteers. No cross-reactivity and no significant titer correlation were found between AP Ab and AChR Ab. We confirmed immunologically by radioimmunoassay and western blot analysis the presence of antibodies directed against AP. AP Ab-positive SPMG patients were characterized clinically as having female predominance and a more severe form of generalized MG than AP Ab-negative SPMG patients, and about half required artificial ventilation at maximum severity. AP Ab's pathogenic role in MG is yet unclarified, but our findings show AP to be a novel antigen among the various autoantigens present in MG patients and in whom AP Ab may modify clinical symptoms.     

Detection and characterization of MuSK antibodies in seronegative myasthenia gravis

Antibodies to rat muscle specific kinase, MuSK, have recently been identified in some generalized "seronegative" myasthenia gravis (SNMG) patients, who are often females with marked bulbar symptoms. Using immunoprecipitation of (125)I-labelled-human MuSK, 27 of 66 (41%) seronegative patients were positive, but 18 ocular SNMG patients, 105 AChR antibody positive MG patients, and 108 controls were negative. The antibodies are of high affinity (Kds around 100 pM) with titers between 1 and 200 nM. They bind to the extracellular Ig-like domains of soluble or native MuSK. Surprisingly they are predominantly in the IgG4 subclass. MuSK-antibody associated MG may be different in etiological and pathological mechanisms.     

Fewer thymic changes in MuSK antibody-positive than in MuSK antibody-negative MG

In generalized myasthenia gravis (MG) patients without detectable acetylcholine receptor (AChR) antibodies (SNMG), the thymus is often reported as "normally involuted." We analyzed thymic compartments in 67 patients with generalized MG, with AChR antibodies (AChR+, n = 23), with muscle-specific kinase (MuSK) antibodies (MuSK+, n = 14) or with neither (MuSK-, n = 30), and in 11 non-MG controls. Four of 14 MuSK+ thymi had rare small germinal centers, but overall they were not different from age-matched controls. However, approximately 75% MuSK- samples showed lymph node-type infiltrates similar to those in AChR+ patients, but with fewer germinal centers. These variations may explain some apparent differences in responses to thymectomy in SNMG.     

Modulation of acetylcholine receptor expression in seronegative myasthenia gravis

In a previous study, we demonstrated a compensatory mechanism for regulating acetylcholine receptor (AChR) gene expression in muscle biopsies from seropositive and seronegative (SN) myasthenia gravis (MG) patients. To further characterize the AChR regulation mechanisms involved in SNMG disease, we investigated the effects of MG sera on nicotinic AChR expression (at the protein and messenger RNA [mRNA] levels) in cultured human muscle cells. Sera from SNMG patients induced an in vitro increase in the level of nicotinic AChR beta-subunit mRNA but did not cause a decrease in AChR protein level. This apparent discrepancy was not due to a higher level of AChR synthesis as demonstrated by analysis of AChR turnover. In SN patients, the increase in beta-subunit mRNA level was followed after 48 hours by a slight increase in the amount of AChR surface protein. This regulation of nicotinic receptor expression was due to the purified IgG-containing fraction. Thus, sera from SNMG patients contain an immunoglobulin that induces an increase in AChR mRNA without causing a decrease in AChR protein level, suggesting an indirect regulatory mechanism involving another surface molecule. This model is therefore useful for defining the targets involved in the pathogenesis of SNMG disease.     

Seronegative myasthenia gravis

Of 221 patients with myasthenia gravis, 18.5% had no detectable antibodies to acetylcholine receptor. Seven of 14 patients (50%) with only ocular symptoms for more than 2 years were seronegative, and 25 of 145 (17%) patients with generalized myasthenia were seronegative. The clinical characteristics of seronegative patients did not differ from patients with high antibody titers. No seronegative patient had a thymoma, but that difference did not reach statistical significance. Lack of serum antibodies did not preclude favorable response to thymectomy or plasmapheresis.     

Seronegative myasthenia gravis: comparison of neurophysiological picture in MuSK+ and MuSK− patients

The aim of this study was to compare the neurophysiological and clinical pictures of a large sample of seronegative myasthenia gravis (SNMG) patients with and without anti-MuSK antibodies. Fifty-two consecutive SNMG patients were retrospectively evaluated. They had undergone an extended neurophysiological evaluation: repetitive nerve stimulation (RNS), single fiber EMG (SFEMG), and electromyography (EMG) with nerve conduction study. A muscle biopsy was performed in 11 of 52 patients, the edrophonium test in 44 of 52 patients and anti-AChR antibodies and anti-MuSK antibodies were tested in all patients. Anti-MuSK antibodies were detected in 25 SNMG patients (48.1%). The number of women in the MuSK+ group was significantly higher (P = 0.01) than in the MuSK- group. Seronegative MuSK+ patients are more severely affected and the deficit often involves the bulbar and the respiratory muscles. No statistically significant differences were observed in the edrophonium test between MuSK+ and MuSK- groups. The RNS test was abnormal in a significantly higher number of MUSK- patients than MUSK+ patients (P < 0.00001). With regard to SFEMG data, MuSK- patients were characterized to have more severe neurophysiological pattern. Our observations showed several differences between the clinical and neurophysiological pictures of MUSK+ and MUSK- patients.     

Myasthenia gravis: treatment with thymectomy, corticoids and plasmapheresis

This paper reviews a 12 year experience with myasthenia gravis management (surgical and drug therapy). A total of 27 patients were submitted to thymectomy, and 12 out of 13 showed fairly good results with this only form of therapy (15.3% with complete remission, 46.15% with marked improvement and 30.7% with moderate improvement). The other 14 need either a combination of surgery and plasmapheresis or corticosteroids with the cummulative results of: 14.8% of remission (4 out of 27), 74% of improvement (20 out of 27), 7.4% of worsening (2 out of 27) and 3.7% without change (1 out of 27). Two other patients not submitted to surgery showed either a stable state of their symptoms or a mildly worsening. Another eight patients not submitted to surgery could not be bollowed up. The authors also conclude by the validity of the use of plasmapheresis in myasthenic crises leading to a transient relief of the symptoms and suggest the use of corticosteroids as a second choice, due to their undesirable side effects and difficulty in their reduction and elimination without worsening the symptoms. Other immunosuppressive drugs could be used in cases in which those above cited therapies showed unsuitable results.