Measuring the rate of progression in Friedreich ataxia: Implications for clinical trial design

Friedreich ataxia is an autosomal recessive neurodegenerative disorder characterized by ataxia of all four limbs, dysarthria, and arreflexia. A variety of measures are currently used to quantify disease progression, including the Friedreich Ataxia Rating Scale, examiner‐rated functional disability scales, self‐reported activities of daily living and performance measures such as the timed 25‐foot walk, 9‐hole pegboard test, PATA speech test, and low‐contrast letter acuity vision charts. This study examines the rate of disease progression over one and two years in a cohort of 236 Friedreich ataxia patients using these scales and performance measure composites. The Friedreich Ataxia Rating Scale and performance‐measure composites captured disease progression, with a greater sensitivity to change over 2 years than over 1 year. The measures differed in their sensitivity to change and in possible bias. These results help to establish norms for progression in FRDA that can be useful in measuring the long‐term success of therapeutic agents and defining sample‐size calculations for double‐blind clinical trials. © 2010 Movement Disorder Society     

A0001 in Friedreich ataxia: Biochemical characterization and effects in a clinical trial

This study tested the ability of A0001 (α-tocopheryl quinone; EPI-A0001), a potent antioxidant, to improve in vitro measures, glucose metabolism, and neurological function in Friedreich ataxia. We used an in vitro study of protection from cell toxicity followed by a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial of 2 doses of A0001 in 31 adults with Friedreich ataxia. The primary clinical trial outcome was the Disposition Index, a measure of diabetic tendency, from a frequently sampled intravenous glucose tolerance test, evaluated 4 weeks into therapy. Secondary neurologic measures included the Friedreich Ataxia Rating Scale. A0001 potently inhibited cell death in Friedreich ataxia models in vitro. For the clinical trial, mean guanine-adenine-adenine repeat length was 699, and mean age was 31 years. Four weeks after treatment initiation, differences in changes in the Disposition Index between subjects treated with A0001 and placebo were not statistically significant. In contrast, a dose-dependent improvement in the Friedreich Ataxia Rating Scale score was observed. Patients on placebo improved 2.0 rating scale points, whereas patients on low-dose A0001 improved by 4.9 points (P = .04) and patients on a high dose improved by 6.1 points (P < .01). Although A0001 did not alter the Disposition Index, it caused a dose-dependent improvement in neurologic function, as measured by the Friedreich Ataxia Rating Scale. Longer studies will assess the reproducibility and persistence of neurologic benefit.     

Evaluating the progression of Friedreich ataxia and its treatment

Friedreich ataxia is characterised by slowly progressive neurodegeneration and cardiomyopathy. Currently, no treatments have been proven to delay, prevent, or reverse the inexorable decline that occurs in this condition; however, several pharmaceutical agents are undergoing clinical assessment. Because initial beneficial therapies are likely to slow disease progression rather than reverse morbidity, the need for accurate measurement tools that will detect such subtle benefits is critical. The impact of Friedreich ataxia on the nervous system has been assessed largely through the use of rating scales and functional composite measures, and a number of patientreported outcome measures in Friedreich ataxia have been studied. However, on the basis of published reports on the performance of these measures, none clearly stands out as the best for use in clinical trials. Refinement of existing tools and development of new tools will be needed to maximise the chance of detecting small but clinically significant benefits of therapeutic agents in patients with Friedreich ataxia.     

Friedreich ataxia clinical outcome measures: natural history evaluation in 410 participants

Friedreich ataxia is an autosomal recessive neurodegenerative disorder characterized by ataxia, dysarthria, and areflexia. The authors report the progress of a large international noninterventional cohort (n = 410), tracking the natural history of disease progression using the neurologic examination-based Friedreich Ataxia Rating Scale. The authors analyzed the rate of progression with cross-sectional analysis and longitudinal analysis over a 2-year period. The Friedreich Ataxia Rating Scale captured disease progression when used at 1 and 2 years following initial evaluation, with a lower ratio of standard deviation of change to mean change over 2 years of evaluation. However, modeling of disease progression identified substantial ceiling effects in the Friedreich Ataxia Rating Scale, suggesting this measure is most useful in subjects before maximal deficit is approached.     

Childhood ataxia: clinical features, pathogenesis, key unanswered questions, and future directions

Childhood ataxia is characterized by impaired balance and coordination primarily because of cerebellar dysfunction. Friedreich ataxia, a form of childhood ataxia, is the most common multisystem autosomal recessive disease. Most of these patients are homozygous for the GAA repeat expansion located on the first intron of the frataxin gene on chromosome 9. Mutations in the frataxin gene impair mitochondrial function, increase reactive oxygen species, and trigger redistribution of iron in the mitochondria and cytosol. Targeted therapies for Friedreich ataxia are undergoing testing. In addition, a centralized database, patient registry, and natural history study have been launched to support clinical trials in Friedreich ataxia. The 2011 Neurobiology of Disease in Children symposium, held in conjunction with the 40th annual Child Neurology Society meeting, aimed to (1) describe clinical features surrounding Friedreich ataxia, including cardiomyopathy and genetics; (2) discuss recent advances in the understanding of the pathogenesis of Friedreich ataxia and developments of clinical trials; (3) review new investigations of characteristic symptoms; and (4) establish clinical and biochemical overlaps in neurodegenerative diseases and possible directions for future basic, translational, and clinical studies.     

A comparison of three measures of upper limb function in Friedreich ataxia

Friedreich Ataxia (FRDA) is the commonest inherited ataxia. Clinical trials of pharmaceuticals are increasingly being conducted in this condition. This requires the most accurate outcome measures to enable trials to be conducted with a minimum number of subjects in the shortest time frame and to minimize the risk of false negative results. Upper limb function is a major area of morbidity in FRDA. We therefore have compared the performance of three tests of upper limb function in FRDA: the Nine Hole Peg Test (9HPT), Box and Blocks Test (BBT) and Jebsen Taylor Hand Function Test (JTHFT). This study was undertaken to ascertain the best test for inclusion in a Friedreich Ataxia Functional Composite (FAFC) test for use in clinical studies and therapeutic trials. The three tests were administered to the dominant and non-dominant upper limbs of 38 individuals with genetically proven FRDA on two occasions, 12 months apart. The results of testing were correlated with the following disease parameters; age at disease onset, disease duration and score for the Friedreich Ataxia Rating Scale (FARS). The responsiveness to change of each test was assessed by measuring the effect size and calculations of the number of subjects required for similarly powered therapeutic trials. Results for all tests correlated significantly with disease duration and FARS score. The only test scores that changed significantly over 12 months were those for the non-dominant 9HPT and BBT. Scores for these two tests also had the largest effect sizes and required the fewest subjects for similarly powered therapeutic trials. We conclude, therefore, that the non-dominant 9HPT and BBT are the best tests for inclusion in a FAFC. Since the 9HPT has already been suggested for inclusion in a FAFC, we recommend that this test is used but that it is the non-dominant limb that is tested.     

Effect of vitamin E supplementation in patients with ataxia with vitamin E deficiency

Ataxia with vitamin E (Vit E) defciency (AVED) is an autosomal recessive disorder caused by mutations of the alpha tocopherol transfer protein gene. The Friedreich ataxia phenotype is the most frequent clinical presentation. In AVED patients, serum Vit E levels are very low in the absence of intestinal malabsorption. As Vit E is a major antioxidant agent, Vit E deficiency is supposed to be responsible for the pathological process. Twenty-four AVED patients were fully investigated (electromyography, nerve conduction velocity (NVC) studies, somatosensory evoked potentials, cerebral computed tomography scan, sural nerve biopsy, genetic studies) and supplemented with Vit E (800 mg daily) during a 1-year period. Clinical evaluation was mainly based on the Ataxia Rating Scale (ARS) for cerebellar ataxia assessment and serum Vit E levels were monitored. Serum Vit E levels normalized and ARS scores decreased moderately but significantly suggesting clinical improvement. Better results were noted with mean disease duration < or = 15 years. Reflexes remained abolished and posterior column disturbances unchanged. Vitamin E supplementation in AVED patients stabilizes the neurological signs and can lead to mild improvement of cerebellar ataxia, especially in early stages of the disease.     

Contrast letter acuity as a measure of visual dysfunction in patients with Friedreich ataxia.

BACKGROUND: Friedreich ataxia is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder affecting afferent cerebellar pathways and other neuronal systems, including afferent visual pathways. A systematic clinical outcome measure for examination of visual dysfunction in Friedreich ataxia has not been identified. We sought to identify a simple, reliable method for assessing clinical and subclinical visual dysfunction in patients with Friedreich ataxia. METHODS: Contrast letter acuity was measured binocularly in Friedreich ataxia patients and age-matched visually asymptomatic volunteers (control group) using the Low-contrast Sloan Letter Charts at three different low-contrast levels (5.0%, 1.25%, and 0.6%). Binocular high-contrast visual acuity (100% level) was also determined for each participant. RESULTS: Despite equal median binocular high-contrast visual acuities between the two groups, patients with Friedreich ataxia had significantly lower (worse) Low-contrast Sloan Letter Chart scores compared with controls, particularly at the lowest contrast levels (1.25% and 0.6%). Ambulation status significantly predicted Low-contrast Sloan Letter Charts scores in linear regression models accounting for patient age, suggesting a potential complementary role for Low-contrast Sloan Letter Chart testing in the assessment of disease status as well as visual function in Friedreich ataxia. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates that Low-contrast Sloan Letter Chart testing may provide a useful clinical outcome measure for Friedreich ataxia and other neuro-ophthalmologic disorders.     

Unanswered questions in friedreich ataxia

During the past 15 years, the pace of research advancement in Friedreich ataxia has been rapid. The abnormal gene has been discovered and its gene product characterized, leading to the development of new evidence-based therapies. Still, various unsettled issues remain that affect clinical trials. These include the level of frataxin deficiency needed to cause disease, the mechanism by which frataxin-deficient mitochondrial dysfunction leads to symptomatology, and the reason selected cells are most affected in Friedreich ataxia. In this review, we summarize these questions and propose testable hypotheses for their resolution.     

Association between genetic polymorphism of angiotensin-converting enzyme gene and Parkinson's disease

Fifteen Moroccan families with a phenotype resembling Friedreich Ataxia (FA) were studied. Seven families (13 patients) had the 744 del A mutation in the alpha-tocopherol transfer protein (alpha-TTP) gene, characteristic of ataxia with vitamin E deficiency (AVED). The other eight families (16 patients) had GAA expansions in the first intron of the frataxin gene. The clinical differences between the two groups differed. AVED caused by the 744 del A could be distinguished by head titubation, lower frequency of the neuropathy and slower disease progression, decreased visual activity and retinitis pigmentosa, which has also been associated with a His(101) Gln missense mutation in the alpha-TTP gene. The neurological disorder associated with vitamin E deficiency can be improved by the alpha-tocopherol treatment.     

Late-onset Friedreich ataxia: phenotypic analysis, magnetic resonance imaging findings, and review of the literature

BACKGROUND: Friedreich ataxia (FA), the most common hereditary ataxia, is caused by pathological expansion of GAA repeats in the first intron of the X25 gene on chromosome 9. Since the discovery of the gene, atypical features are increasingly recognized in individuals with FA, and up to 25% of patients with recessive or sporadic ataxia do not fulfill the Harding or Quebec Cooperative Study on Friedreich's Ataxia criteria for FA. Late-onset FA (LOFA) is defined as onset after age 25 years. OBJECTIVES: To describe and further delineate the clinical and magnetic resonance imaging findings in patients with LOFA and to review the literature. DESIGN: Clinical evaluation and comparison of clinical data and investigations. SETTING: Ataxia clinics at UCLA and Cedars-Sinai Medical Center. PATIENTS: Thirteen patients with LOFA with 13 sex-matched and Inherited Ataxia Progression Scale-matched patients with typical FA. RESULTS: Gait and limb ataxias were seen in all the participants. Dysarthria, loss of vibration sense, and abnormal eye movements were also common in both groups. Patients with LOFA more often had lower limb spasticity (40% vs 0%; chi2 = 4.0; P = .04) and retained reflexes (46.1% vs 7.7%; chi2 = 3.46; P = .05). They had no complaint of sphincter disturbances, and there was no evidence of cardiomyopathy on echocardiograms (chi2 = 4.0; P = .04). Five of 9 patients with LOFA had cerebellar atrophy on neuroimaging. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with gait and limb ataxias, dysarthria, loss of vibration sense, and fixational instability after age 25 years should be considered for molecular testing for GAA expansion in the FA gene. In contrast to previous studies, cerebellar vermian atrophy is not an uncommon finding.     

Ocular Motor Fixation Deficits in Friedreich Ataxia

Friedreich ataxia (FRDA) is the most common genetic cause of ataxia with a prevalence of approximately 1 in 29,000. Ocular motor abnormalities are common in FRDA and include fixation instability, saccadic dysmetria, and vestibular dysfunction. It has not yet been determined whether aspects of spatial attention, which are closely coupled to eye movements, are similarly compromised in FRDA. This study examined attentional engagement and disengagement of eye movements in FRDA using a gap overlap task. Thirteen individuals with genetically confirmed FRDA and 12 age-matched unaffected controls participated in the experiment. The gap overlap paradigm was used to examine the effect of early (gap condition), simultaneous (null condition), or late (overlap condition) removal of a central fixation on saccadic latency to a peripheral target stimulus. Although the FRDA group showed a larger gap effect (i.e., difference in saccadic latencies between the overlap and gap condition), these participants demonstrated a greater difference in latencies in the overlap relative to the null condition, suggestive of deficits within the disengagement process of attentional orienting. We propose a role for the cerebellum in these deficits in the disengagement of spatial attention based on evidence of cerebellar connectivity with regions involved in exogenous shifts of attention. The significant correlations between saccadic latency and disease severity as measured by the Friedreich Ataxia Rating Scale further support the proposal that saccadic latency might be useful as a surrogate marker of disease severity and progression in future clinical trials in FRDA.     

Friedreich ataxia: effects of genetic understanding on clinical evaluation and therapy

The discovery of the genetic cause of Friedreich ataxia has significantly affected our understanding of the disorder at both the clinical and basic science levels. Friedreich ataxia results from a deficiency of functional frataxin, a protein that appears to be involved in mitochondrial iron homeostasis. This leads to iron accumulation and mitochondrial abnormalities with consequent oxidant damage. The clinical spectrum of Friedreich ataxia has also expanded with the recognition of broader phenotypic features, including the absence of classical Friedreich ataxia features, later age at onset, and spasticity instead of ataxia. Although no proven therapy is yet available, antioxidants are a potential method for therapeutic intervention.     

Rationale for the development of 2-aminobenzamide histone deacetylase inhibitors as therapeutics for friedreich ataxia

Numerous studies have pointed to histone deacetylase inhibitors as potential therapeutics for various neurodegenerative diseases, and clinical trials with several histone deacetylase inhibitors have been performed or are under way. However, histone deacetylase inhibitors tested to date either are highly cytotoxic or have very low specificities for different histone deacetylase enzymes. The authors' laboratories have identified a novel class of histone deacetylase inhibitors (2-aminobenzamides) that reverses heterochromatin-mediated silencing of the frataxin (FXN) gene in Friedreich ataxia. The authors have identified the histone deacetylase enzyme isotype target of these compounds and present evidence that compounds that target this enzyme selectively increase FXN expression from pathogenic alleles. Studies with model compounds show that these histone deacetylase inhibitors increase FXN messenger RNA levels in the brain in mouse models for Friedreich ataxia and relieve neurological symptoms observed in mouse models and support the notion that this class of molecules may serve as therapeutics for the human disease.     

How does performance of the Friedreich Ataxia Functional Composite compare to rating scales?

Progression of Friedreich ataxia (FRDA) is often measured using neurological rating scales such as the Friedreich Ataxia Rating Scale (FARS). Performance scales comprising functional measures have been used in other conditions due to their increased sensitivity and reproducibility and may replace examination-based measures. The aims of this study were to examine the relationship between the Friedreich Ataxia Functional Composite (FAFC) measures and characteristics of FRDA to determine if the FAFC is more sensitive to clinical change over time compared to its components. One hundred and twenty-two individuals completed the timed 25-foot walk (T25FW), 9-Hole Peg Test (9HPT) and the low-contrast letter acuity (LCLA) test at baseline, 63 at year 1, 34 at year 2 and 25 at year 3. Composite scores, Z2 (T25FW and 9HPT) and Z3 (T25FW, 9HPT and LCLA) were created. Correlation analyses were conducted. Change in FAFC components were examined over 1, 2, and 3 years. The FARS, Z2, Z3 and 9HPT showed significant change over all time points compared to baseline. The T25FW only demonstrated significant change over 3 years. The LCLA demonstrated no significant change over any of the time points. The FAFC shows significant change over time and indicates disease progression, however, this may result from individual components driving the differences. The LCLA showed no change over time, rendering Z3 redundant. The FAFC is of limited value in cohorts with non-ambulant individuals as it leads to skewing of the dataset and is better suited to less affected populations.     

Recessive ataxia with ocular apraxia: review of 22 Portuguese patients

BACKGROUND: The recessive ataxias are a heterogeneous group of neurodegenerative disorders characterized by cerebellar ataxia associated with a number of different neurologic, ophthalmologic, or general signs. They are often difficult to classify in clinical terms, except for Friedreich ataxia, ataxia-telangiectasia, and a relatively small group of rare conditions for which the molecular basis has already been defined. OBJECTIVES: To study the clinical presentation and to define diagnostic criteria in a group of Portuguese patients with ataxia and ocular apraxia, an autosomal recessive form without the essential clinical and laboratory features of ataxia-telangiectasia. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We reviewed 22 patients in 11 kindreds, identified through a systematic survey of hereditary ataxias being conducted in Portugal. RESULTS: Age at onset ranged from 1 to 15 years, with a mean of 4.7 years. The duration of symptoms at the time of last examination varied from 5 to 58 years. All patients presented with progressive cerebellar ataxia, the characteristic ocular apraxia, and a peripheral neuropathy. Associated neurologic signs included dystonia, scoliosis, and pes cavus. Magnetic resonance imaging was performed in 16 patients, all of whom showed cerebellar atrophy. CONCLUSIONS: Ataxia with ocular apraxia may be more frequent than postulated before, and may be identified clinically using the following criteria: (1) autosomal recessive transmission; (2) early onset (for most patients in early childhood); (3) combination of cerebellar ataxia, ocular apraxia, and early areflexia, with later appearance of the full picture of peripheral neuropathy; (4) absence of mental retardation, telangiectasia, and immunodeficiency; and (5) the possibility of a long survival, although with severe motor handicap.     

Jaw reflex in Friedreich ataxia

Twenty-one patients with Friedreich ataxia were examined and found to have a brisk jaw reflex. This previously unreported clinical finding contrasts with the impairment of tendon reflexes in the limbs and should not rule out the diagnosis of Friedreich ataxia.     

Clinical and genetic analysis of 188 families with spinocerebellar degeneration. Friedreich's disease and P. Marie's hereditary ataxias]

Based on the hereditary ataxias concepts and a large field survey, the authors analyzed 392 cases of spino-cerebellar degeneration belonging to 188 families. Two main clinical groups were identified: 227 cases of Friedreich ataxia and 74 cases of cerebellar hereditary ataxia of P. Marie type. The association in the same patient of peroneal atrophy of Charcot Marie type with Friedreich ataxia (17 cases) or P. Marie cerebellar hereditary ataxia (13 definite cases and 13 probable) was the most striking finding. "Forme fruste", incomplete form or complex form of Friedreich ataxia were present in some families while in some others there was spastic paraplegia or pure Charcot Marie Tooth disease. This clinical heterogeneity in families of spino-cerebellar degeneration is discussed.     

Hereditary ataxias-overview]

Many of autosomal dominant spinocerebellar ataxias (SCA) are now shown to result from the expansion of unstable trinucleotide repeats. In most SCAs, these repeats are present within coding sequences of the causative genes and translated into polyglutamine tracts. In this overview clinical and molecular genetic features of newly identified group of diseases in this category are briefly summarized. Expanded polyglutamine repeats are supposed to mediate some toxic effects on a certain population of neurons that result in neuronal dysfunction. The current progress in these molecular biological studies on their pathophysiology is also reviewed. In Japan, Friedreich ataxia with intoronic GAA repeat expansions has not been known. Instead, early onset ataxia with Friedreich phenotype, associated with ocular motor apraxia in childhood and with hypoalbuminemia in adult, is the predominant ataxia with Friedreich phenotype, the causative mutation of which was very recently identified.     

Therapeutic developments in friedreich ataxia

Friedreich ataxia is an inherited, severe, progressive neuro- and cardiodegenerative disorder for which there currently is no approved therapy. Friedreich ataxia is caused by the decreased expression and/or function of frataxin, a mitochondrial matrix protein that binds iron and is involved in the formation of iron-sulfur clusters. Decreased frataxin function leads to decreased iron-sulfur cluster formation, mitochondrial iron accumulation, cytosolic iron depletion, oxidative stress, and mitochondrial dysfunction. Cloning of the disease gene for Friedreich ataxia and elucidation of many aspects of the biochemical defects underlying the disorder have led to several major therapeutic initiatives aimed at increasing frataxin expression, reversing mitochondrial iron accumulation, and alleviating oxidative stress. These initiatives are in preclinical and clinical development and are reviewed herein.