Upper Lid Entropion Post Ptosis Correction: Is Tarsal Buckling the Cause?

Purpose: To report two cases of the rare complication of entropion following involutional ptosis surgery and its successful management.

Methods: Clinical findings and management of the patients are presented.

Results: Case 1: An 89-year-old female underwent aponeurosis advancement surgery for left involutional ptosis. Post-operatively she achieved good lid height, but had developed entropion of the upper lid which resulted in a persistent corneal epithelial defect. The patient underwent repeat surgery during which the aponeurosis was found to be inserted into the lower part of middle one third of tarsus with the tarsus itself being extremely thin. The aponeurosis was reinserted into upper third of tarsus, followed by greyline split with anterior lamellar repositioning. Post-operatively the patient achieved good lid height with correction of the entropion.Case 2: A 70-year-old male who had previously undergone bilateral brow lift and ptosis correction two years ago, was referred with right upper lid entropion. During surgery the aponeurosis was found to be inserted into the lower part of middle one third of tarsus, with a very thin tarsus. This patient was also managed by reinserting aponeurosis into upper third of tarsus with grey line split and anterior lamellar repositioning following which he achieved good lid height and correction of the entropion.

Comment:Entropion has rarely been reported as a complication of ptosis surgery. This case series highlights the importance of taking special care when advancing the aponeurosis, in cases where the tarsus is thin, as it may result in vertical buckling of the tarsus.     

Everting suture correction of lower lid involutional entropion

AIMS: To assess the long term efficacy of everting sutures in the correction of lower lid involutional entropion and to quantify the effect upon lower lid retractor function. METHODS: A prospective single armed clinical trial of 62 eyelids in 57 patients undergoing everting suture correction of involutional entropion. Patients were assessed preoperatively and at 6, 12, 24, and 48 months postoperatively. The main outcome variables were lower lid position and the change in lower lid retractor function. RESULTS: When compared with the non-entropic side, the entropic lid had a greater degree of horizontal laxity and poorer lower lid retractor function. These differences however, were not significant. At the conclusion of the study and after a mean follow up period of 31 months, the entropion had recurred in 15% of the patients. There were no treatment failures in the group of five patients with recurrent entropion. The improvement in lower lid retractor function after the insertion of lower lid everting sutures did not reach statistical significance. There was no significant difference between the treatment failure group and the group with a successful outcome with regard to: the degree of horizontal lid laxity or lower lid retractor function present preoperatively; patient age or sex; an earlier history of surgery for entropion. There was neither a demonstrable learning effect nor a significant intersurgeon difference in outcome. The overall 4 year mortality rate was 30%. CONCLUSIONS: The use of everting sutures in the correction of primary or recurrent lower lid involutional entropion is a simple, successful, long lasting, and cost effective procedure.     

Involutional entropion of the upper lid

Involutional entropion is an inturning of the eyelid margin caused by changes of lid tissues due to aging. Two patients with the uncommon finding of involutional entropion of the upper lid were treated with surgery based on the principles used to treat common lower lid entropion. The causes of lower lid entropion include increased horizontal and vertical lid laxity, and correcting these same factors in the upper lid resulted in a satisfactory repair of the entropion. Treatment of involutional entropion in the upper lid is compared and contrasted with that of the lower lid.     

Lid retractors desinsertion in acquired ptosis and involutional lower lid entropion: surgical implications.

BACKGROUND: An association exists between upper and/or lower lid retractors' desinsertion and acquired ptosis and/or involutional lower lid entropion. METHOD: By highlighting the similarities that exist in the anatomy of the upper and lower lid retractors a possible pathophysiological mechanism leading to acquired ptosis and involutional lower lid entropion is suggested. As a logical consequence, in case of desinsertion, it is proposed to reattach the lid retractors to the tarsus. RESULTS: With this simple "physiological" surgical approach it is possible to treat with success a great majority of acquired ptosis and/or involutional lower lid entropion. CONCLUSION: Repairing upper and/or lower lid retractors' desinsertion can cure acquired ptosis and/or involutional lower lid entropion.     

Management of upper eyelid cicatricial entropion

Purpose: There is a paucity of published data on the management of upper eyelid cicatricial entropion. We report on our results using such techniques as lamella repositioning, recession or augmentation and terminal tarsal rotation. Design: Observational retrospective case series. Participants: Consecutive cases of upper eyelid cicatricial entropion of two specialist oculoplastic centres (Corneoplastic Unit, East Grinstead, UK and South Australian Institute of Ophthalmology, Adelaide, Australia) were reviewed over a 7‐year period. Methods: All patients underwent anterior lamellar repositioning or terminal tarsal rotation. Main Outcome Measures: Success was defined by two definitions: anatomical success was defined where the lid margin was restored to its normal position. Complete success was defined where there were no eyelashes touching the globe. Gain or loss (≤ or ≥2 Snellen lines) in best corrected visual acuity using a Snellen chart and resolution of any corneal epitheliopathy at final follow‐up were also recorded (as graded by experienced oculoplastic consultants). Results: Fifty‐two procedures were performed on 41 patients (11 bilateral). All patients underwent either an anterior lamellar repositioning or a terminal tarsal rotation. Trachoma, previous upper lid surgery, Stevens–Johnson syndrome and meibomian gland dysfunction were the commonest underlying diagnoses. Ninety‐eight per cent of the group had a normal anatomical lid position at follow‐up. Nine eyelids (17%) of the group had recurrence of trichiasis. Conclusion: This large case series demonstrates that upper eyelid cicatricial entropion is managed effectively utilizing procedures that involve recession and reposition. We recommend that excision of tissue is avoided, especially in pathology that has a progressive immunological cicatricial drive.     

Surgical outcome of involutional lower eyelid entropion correction using transcutaneous everting sutures in Chinese patients

To evaluate the clinical efficacy of transcutaneous everting sutures for lower eyelid involutional entropion in Chinese patients. A retrospective, non-comparative, interventional case series. This retrospective study consecutively reviewed the medical records of all patients with involutional lower eyelid entropion who underwent transcutaneous everting suture for entropion correction at the Department of Ophthalmology, Caritas Medical Centre, from 1st January 2010 to 31st October 2013. Exclusion criteria included concurrent eyelid pathologies such as malignant tumor, infection, cicatricial entropion, post-operative follow-up period of <3 months, significant horizontal lid laxity, and aged <60 years at the time of surgery. The primary outcome measures were recurrence rate and complications. Secondary outcome measures included patient demographic data, type and number of everting sutures, duration of operation, timing of stitch removal, duration of follow-up, as well as each patient’s medical history and current medications. Thirty-four eyelids of 28 patients were included. The average age was 78.2 ± 7.3 years and the male to female ratio was 4:3. In this series, 26.5 and 2.9 % of eyelids underwent entropion correction whilst receiving aspirin and warfarin, respectively. The mean duration of post-operative follow-up was 13.2 ± 10.5 months. The recurrence rate was 11.8 % at a mean of 9.0 ± 6.0 months. There were no peri-operative or post-operative complications observed. A transcutaneous everting suture was found to be a quick and effective means to correct senile involutional lower lid entropion in Chinese patients with no complications despite the continued use of anti-coagulation therapy in >25 % of our cases.     

Transconjunctival Entropion Repair – The Backdoor Approach

Abstract

Purpose: To present a modified transconjunctival approach for involutional entropion repair.

Methods: This study is a retrospective consecutive single surgeon case series using a transconjunctival approach for involutional lower lid entropion (ILLE) repair.

Results: Eleven eyes were operated for involution entropion with 9 cases of complete resolution. Two patients required further Jones’ retractor plication.

Conclusion: Transconjunctival involutional lower lid entropion repair is a time-efficient, safe, and efficacious technique. The scar free technique described leads to full restoration of lower lid anatomy. In contrast to other reports we found a relatively low rate of recurrence on follow-up.     

Clinical study of single-suture inferior retractor repair for involutional entropion

PURPOSE: To evaluate the clinical efficacy of a simplified single-suture inferior retractor repair technique for involutional entropion. METHODS: A retrospective study of 20 patients (26 eyelids), followed for 6 months at our hospital, who showed no severe horizontal lid laxity were operated on for involutional entropion. After subciliary incision, the inferior retractor was identified and repaired by reattaching the superior edge of the inferior retractor to the inferior edge of the lower tarsus by a single suture using 5-0 prolene. RESULTS: 26 eyelids of 20 patients (80.8%) were treated successfully without recurrence. Complications were seen in 5 eyelids, 2 were overcorrections and 3 were recurrences of entropion. Recurred cases were reoperated on and showed good postoperative results after the second surgery. CONCLUSIONS: The simplified single-suture inferior retractor repair had good results in patients with involutional entropion without severe horizontal lid laxity. Moreover, this procedure had a short operation and recovery time. In unilateral cases, we could achieve more symmetric appearance when compared with bilateral surgeries.     

Correction of lower lid retraction combined with entropion using an ear cartilage graft in the anophthalmic socket

PURPOSE: To investigate the surgical results of an ear cartilage graft and supplemental procedures for correcting lower lid retraction combined with entropion in anophthalmic patients. METHODS: We reviewed retrospectively the medical records of 7 anophthalmic patients with lower lid retraction and entropion, who received a posterior lamellar ear cartilage graft and one or both of lateral tarsal strip or eyelash-everting procedure between March 1998 and March 2003. Preoperative and postoperative lid and socket statuses were also investigated. RESULTS: Ear cartilage grafts were performed in all 7 patients, lateral tarsal strips in 6, and eyelash-everting procedures in 5. Postoperative follow-up durations ranged from 4 to 28 months (average 12.6 months). Retractions were corrected during follow-up in all patients. There were no cases of entropion immediately after surgery. However, the eyelashes of the lower lid returned to an upright position in 4 patients, but not so severe as to touch the ocular prosthesis, and thus did not require surgical correction during follow up. CONCLUSIONS: Lower lid retraction combined with entropion in anophthalmic patients can be corrected effectively using an ear cartilage graft with selective, supplemental procedures.     

Cautery for lower lid entropion.

A prospective study was undertaken to evaluate a simple cautery technique for the correction of involutional lower lid entropion in 50 patients. After a 12 month follow-up period all patients were free of entropion. Only one patient needed to have the procedure repeated because of recurrence. The technique was found to be simple, effective, safe, and required very little time and skill.     

Modified grey line split with anterior lamellar repositioning for treatment of cicatricial lid entropion

To determine the success rate of surgery of modified grey line split with anterior lamellar repositioning in patients with cicatricial lid entropion and to determine the risk factors of failure of the procedure, 40 patients (84 lids) with either lid involvement caused by cicatricial lid entropion of different etiologies were enrolled in this study. All the lids were operated on using the technique of modified grey line split and anterior lamellar repositioning. The success of the procedure was assessed by restoration of anatomical and physiological functioning of the lid without any residual symptom to the patient. Patients were examined initially at weekly intervals for 1 month and subsequently followed up at 2, 3, and 12 months following surgery. Among the various causes for cicatricial lid entropion, infectious etiology (72/84 lids) was found to be the most common one. A success rate of modified grey line split with anterior lamellar repositioning was 88.09% (74/84 lids). The underlying etiology of cicatricial lid entropion was the sole predictor of failure of surgery. Those with the etiology of infection had more than 6 times the odds of surgery failure (OR: 6.73; 95% CI: 2.79-16.73) as compared to a patient without infectious etiology. The role of other factors such as the age of the patient, degree of entropion, previous entropion surgery, the lid (upper or lower) involved, irregular lid margin, and defective lid closure were statistically insignificant. The underlying etiology of cicatricial lid entropion is the only risk factor that significantly influences the outcome of surgery with this technique. Otherwise, this procedure gives good results with fewer complications in patients with cicatricial lid entropion.     

Amniotic membrane transplantation in entropion surgery.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the role of amniotic membrane transplantation in the management of cicatricial eyelid entropion. DESIGN: Prospective, noncomparative interventional case series. PARTICIPANTS: Eighteen consecutive patients with cicatricial entropion. METHODS: A gray line lid split procedure with vertical anterior lamella repositioning was performed on 25 eyelids (upper or lower) of 18 patients with moderate to severe cicatricial entropion. Preserved human amniotic membrane (AM) was used to cover the bare tarsus up to the lid margin and secured with running 7-0 Vicryl. Impression cytology of the AM was performed at various stages postoperatively to study the epithelialization process. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: (1) Reepithelialization of bare tarsus, (2) extent of tarsal shrinkage, (3) recurrence of entropion. RESULTS: All the AM grafts took well. The most common complication was hemorrhage below the graft, which occurred in six cases. Complete success with no lashes touching the globe was achieved in 22 of 25 (88%) lids after a minimum follow-up of 12.0 months. The mean follow-up was 17.8 months. Two cases (qualified success) had recurrent trichiasis treated successfully with electrolysis. One case with severe trachomatous upper lid entropion recurred 14 months after surgery. The AM accelerated the epithelialization of bare tarsus; this was demonstrated by lack of fluorescein staining and reversion to skin color within 2 to 3 weeks. However, AM could not prevent tarsal shrinkage. Impression cytology demonstrated that features of conjunctival epithelium were present for the first postoperative month, but this was gradually replaced by squamous metaplasia, with keratinization appearing as early as 3 weeks postoperatively. CONCLUSIONS: The use of AM in a lid split procedure for correction of cicatricial entropion helps the bare tarsus epithelialize rapidly and improves the initial cosmetic result of surgery.     

Correction of Involutional Entropion by Excising Redundant Skin and Pretarsal Orbicularis Muscle without Vertical and Horizontal Tarsal Fixation

PurposeThis study evaluated the effect of the excision of redundant skin and pretarsal orbicularis muscle, without vertical or horizontal tarsal fixation, on the correction of involutional entropion.MethodsThis retrospective interventional case series recruited patients with involutional entropion who underwent excision of redundant skin and pretarsal orbicularis muscle, without vertical or horizontal tarsal fixation, from May 2018 to December 2021. Preoperative clinical characteristics and surgical outcomes, including recurrence at 1, 3, and 6 months, were determined by reviewing the medical charts. Surgical treatment included the excision of redundant skin and pretarsal orbicularis muscle, without any tarsal fixation, and simple skin suture.ResultsAll 52 patients (58 eyelids) attended every follow-up visit and were thus included in the analysis. Among 58 eyelids, 55 (94.8%) had satisfactory results. The recurrence rate was 3.45% (two eyelids) and the overcorrection rate was 1.7% (one eyelid).ConclusionsExcision of only redundant skin and the pretarsal orbicularis muscle, without capsulopalpebral fascia reattachment or horizontal lid laxity correction, is a simple surgery for correcting involutional entropion.     

Tarsal strip combined with modified Quickert-Rathbun sutures for involutional entropion

BACKGROUND: Involutional entropion is a common problem in the elderly population. The author describes a method of repair of involutional entropion that is a combination and modification of two existing surgical techniques. METHODS: Review of the cases of 20 consecutive patients (22 lids) who underwent surgery for involutional entropion. All surgical procedures were performed by the author. Repair consisted of a tarsal strip procedure combined with a modification of the Quickert-Rathbun suture technique. All patients had at least 1 year of follow-up. RESULTS: Surgery was successful in 21 (95%) of the 22 eyelids. One patient was noted to have recurrent entropion at 21 months. The average length of follow-up was 33.3 months (range 12 to 79 months). INTERPRETATION: The surgical technique described is straightforward and reliable for the correction of involutional entropion.     

Severe cicatricial entropion repair using mucous membrane graft in Stevens–Johnson syndrome

Background:Severe cicatricial entropion in Stevens–Johnson syndrome (SJS) patients is difficult to treat and is associated with a higher recurrence rate. Also, entropion in the presence of lid margin mucous membrane graft (MMG) further complicates the surgical anatomy and approach.Purpose:To report a modified surgical technique of repairing severe upper eyelid cicatricial entropion in an SJS patient with history of lid margin MMG.Synopsis:Cicatricial entropion in patients with SJS is entirely different from trachomatous cicatricial entropion. The involvement of the lid margin with keratinization, tarsal scarring, persistent conjunctival inflammation, and unhealthy ocular surface affects the surgical approach and outcomes. Conjunctiva-sparing surgery with reconstruction of the lid margin using MMG, flattening and repositioning the anterior lamella, and covering the bare tarsus with MMG rather than leaving it raw are the necessary modifications in this technique from conventional anterior lamellar recession. The video demonstrates the surgical technique for harvesting and preparation of a labial MMG, the splitting of the anterior and posterior lamella of the lid margin, scar tissue release between the lash line and the tarsus, repositioning of the anterior lamella, and anchoring of the labial MMG.Highlights:Anterior lamellar recession combined with MMG wrapping the lid margin and bare tarsus offers good cicatricial entropion repair outcomes. Removal of fat and submucosa from the mucosal graft should be done for better cosmesis. Adequate separation of the scar tissues from the lash line and the tarsus is essential.Video link: https://youtu.be/6HsKgeZQCyY     

Retractor plication for lower lid entropion in ocular cicatricial pemphigoid

The surgical treatment of lower lid entropion in ocular cicatricial pemphigoid has previously met with limited success and conventional techniques have in some cases caused disease progression. We have treated lower lid entropion in this condition with retractor plication, avoiding surgery to the conjunctiva in five patients (seven eyelids) over the past five years with successful correction of the condition and symptomatic improvement in all patients. It has not led to an acute exacerbation of the condition in any patient and we recommend it as the procedure of choice in the surgical management of entropion in this disorder.     

Lateral canthal tendon tuck.

Senile and involutional entropion is occasionally associated with a marked relaxation of the canthal tendons. A simple adjunctive procedure to the imbrication of the lower lid retractors for the correction of senile entropion is described. This adjunctive procedure--the lateral canthal tendon tuck--should further reduce the remarkably low recurrence rate associated with the imbrication surgical procedure that directly corrects the pathophysiology of senile entropion.     

Orbicularis oculi muscle transposition for repairing involutional lower eyelid entropion

Purpose

To describe a simple technique for involutional entropion correction and to present the findings of a retrospective interventional case series study.

Methods

We studied a consecutive series of 414 patients (609 eyelids). Patients presenting with involutional entropion in the absence of lateral canthal tendon laxity underwent orbicularis oculi muscle (OOM) transposition from pretarsal position to corresponding preseptum without horizontal shortening or resection of the orbicularis muscle.

Results

Immediate resolution of entropion and associated ocular symptoms was achieved in 607 eyelids (99.67 %). An early postoperative complication was localized lid swelling that gradually subsided within one week. Over-correction occurred in six cases and resolved with pressure dressing, mostly one or two days post-operation. At final follow-up, a significant improvement in eyelid position was achieved in 579 eyelids (95.07 % ). There was mild recurrence of entropion in 30 eyelids (4.93 %). The mean follow-up was 6.84 months (range, 6–12 months).

Conclusions

Orbicularis oculi muscle transposition is a reasonably successful procedure with a high success rate, and is particularly suitable for patients for whom there exits overriding of the preseptal OOM over the pretarsal OOM.     

Transconjunctival lower eyelid involutional entropion repair: long-term follow-up and efficacy

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the safety and long-term efficacy of a modified transconjunctival involutional lower eyelid entropion repair. DESIGN: Retrospective, noncomparative case series and survey. PARTICIPANTS: Eighty-nine consecutive patients with involutional entropion (114 eyelids). METHODS: Modified transconjunctival involutional lower eyelid entropion repair technique was performed on 114 eyelids of 89 consecutive patients over a 7-year period. All cases had a minimum of 3 months of initial office follow-up, with extended follow-up obtained via standardized telephone interviews. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Surgical success and entropion recurrence. RESULTS: Surgery was completed successfully with no complications in all 114 cases. All cases demonstrated correction of entropion at the 3-month office follow-up. Long-term follow-up (mean, 38.3 months; range, 4-85 months) was obtained in 75% of cases. Recurrence was noted in only one patient (two eyelids [2%]). CONCLUSIONS: Modified transconjunctival lower eyelid entropion repair is a time-efficient, safe, and efficacious technique. In contrast to a recent report using another transconjunctival technique, we found a relatively low rate of recurrence on extended follow-up.     

Modified retractor plication technique in lower lid entropion repair: a 4-year follow-up study

BACKGROUND: Lower eyelid entropion is an eyelid malposition characterized by inward rotation of the eyelid margin associated with potentially significant discomfort and, occasionally, keratopathy. In this study we evaluated and compared the efficacy of two surgical techniques of retractor plication for involutional lower lid entropion repair. METHODS: Sixty-two consecutive patients (62 eyes) with involutional lower lid entropion were included. Of the 62, 34 underwent the Jones retractor plication technique, and 28 underwent a modification of this technique that simplifies the procedure. We evaluated horizontal lid laxity, medial canthal tendon laxity and lower lid excursion before and after surgery, and determined the rate of entropion recurrence in the two groups. All measures were obtained before and 1 month, 6 months, 1 year, 2 years, 3 years and 4 years after surgery. RESULTS: Preoperatively, there was no statistically significant difference between the two groups in any of the measures studied. Postoperatively, the mean amount of horizontal lid laxity was significantly less in the modified technique group than in the Jones technique group (6.86 mm [standard deviation (SD) 0.41 mm] vs. 7.30 mm [SD 0.64 mm]) (p < 0.05). Similarly, the mean amount of medial canthal tendon laxity in the resting position was significantly less in the modified technique group than in the Jones technique group (1.90 mm [SD 0.56 mm] vs. 1.25 mm [SD 0.43 mm]) (p < 0.05). The rate of entropion recurrence was significantly lower in the modified technique group (7.1%) than in the Jones technique group (14.7%) (p < 0.05). INTERPRETATION: The modified retractor plication technique showed encouraging results in terms of successful and long-lasting lower lid entropion repair.