Predicting factors of long-term results of OKT3 therapy for steroid resistant acute rejection following cadaveric renal transplantation

In this retrospective study, we evaluated the histological and biological predictors of long-term response of renal transplant (RT) patients treated with orthoclone OKT3 for steroid resistant acute rejection (AR). Seventy-three patients, aged 37 +/- 12 years, were included in this study between March 1987 and December 1996. All the patients but one had received sequential quadruple immunosuppression (polyclonal antilymphocyte globulins; steroids; azathioprine, and cyclosporin A). OKT3 (5 mg/day for 10 days) was administered for biopsy-proven steroid resistant AR i.e., after 3 consecutive pulses of methylprednisolone (10 mg/kg each). This was the first AR in 46 cases, the second AR in 22 cases and the third AR in 4 cases. Renal histology (Banff) showed borderline (BL) changes in 18 patients, grade I AR in 28 patients; grade II AR in 22 patients, and grade III AR in 5 patients. When treatment with OKT3 commenced (107 +/- 18 days post-transplantation) the mean serum creatinine (SCr) level was 325 +/- 195 micromol/l; this had decreased to 191 +/- 106 micromol/l by the end of OKT3 therapy. The immediate response to OKT3 therapy i. e., within the first month, was not dependent on the histological score. Twenty-six patients (35%) subsequently experienced at least one more AR episode of whom 4 were retreated with OKT3. The overall patient's survival was 94.5% at last follow-up. The overall cumulative graft survival was 64.5% at 2 years, 52.5% at 5 years, and 40.5% at 8 years. The graft survival (5 years) tended to depend on the initial histological score, i.e. BL 30%; grade I 66%; grades II and III 55.5% (p = 0.08). In a multiple logistic regression analysis we tried to identify independent factors that would predict that a graft would still be functioning at least 2 years after OKT3 therapy. We therefore analyzed the following parameters: donor and recipient's age; gender; cold ischemia time; HLA matching; panel reactive antibodies (PRA) prior to grafting; previous transplantation(s); total number of AR episodes; the time of onset of the AR treated by OKT3 compared to the other AR; the time of onset of the AR treated by OKT3; SCr levels at days 0, 10 and 30 after OKT3 therapy; histological score (Banff) i.e., the magnitude of AR and the presence or absence of chronic lesions. The only independent factors which would predict that a graft was still functioning 2 years after OKT3 therapy were: PRA <25% (Odds ratio (OR) 7.68 (1.15-51.3); p = 0.035); a grade I AR (OR 10.52 (1.18-93. 5); p = 0.035); SCr level 1 month after OKT3 therapy (OR 0.935 (0. 87-1.002); p = 0.05). HLA matching and the presence of histological chronic lesions were nearly significant (p = 0.06 and 0.09 respectively). In conclusion, this retrospective study shows that independent predictors of the long-term response to OKT3 therapy for AR in RT patients are the magnitude of pre-transplant PRA, the histological score, and the SCr level one month after OKT3 therapy. Copyright Copyright 1999 S. Karger AG, Basel     

OKT3治疗移植肾难治性排斥反应

为了解ＯＫＴ３对移植肾难治性排斥反应的治疗效果，１９９３年１月至１９９６年６月，我们对４４例肾移植术后移植肾难治性排斥反应（其中加速性排斥反应７例，急性排斥反应３７例）应用ＯＫＴ３治疗。结果：６例加速性排斥反应及３１例急性排斥反应逆转，总逆转率为８４．６％。２５例对ＯＫＴ３治疗产生迅速反应，平均逆转时间为７±４天，１２例发生延迟性反应，平均逆转时间为３４±３天（Ｐ＜０．０１）。作者认为：ＯＫＴ３治疗难治性排斥反应效果显著。巨细胞病毒感染及细胞因子释放综合征是ＯＫＴ３治疗的主要副作用。患者对ＯＫＴ３治疗的延迟性反应与细胞因子释放综合征及排斥损害有关。产生低滴度抗ＯＫＴ３抗体的患者可再次接受ＯＫＴ３治疗。     

OKT3 treatment of steroid-resistant renal allograft rejection

The monoclonal antibody, Orthoclone OKT3 (OKT3), has been used with great efficacy in a prospective multicenter trial as therapy for first rejection episodes in cadaveric donor (CD) renal allograft recipients treated with azathioprine (AZA) and prednisone (P). However, although almost all rejection episodes were reversed, recurrent rejection occurred in approximately two-thirds of OKT3-treated patients in this earlier trial; infections also occurred in about two-thirds of patients, often related to the additional immunosuppression necessary to reverse the rerejection episodes. In the current series of patients, OKT3 was used to treat rejection in CD renal graft recipients in a protocol differing from the multicenter trial in two respects: baseline immunosuppression was cyclosporine (CsA) and P or CsA, AZA, and P (probably more potent immunosuppressive combinations than the AZA and P in the multicenter trial); and OKT3 treatment was reserved for rejection episodes resistant to 3 bolus infusions of methylprednisolone (MP), 5-10 mg/kg, rather than as primary therapy for first rejection episodes. Using this protocol, 46 of 74 rejection episodes (62%) diagnosed between 3/85 and 3/86 in CD renal allograft recipients were treated successfully with MP. Of the remaining 28 steroid-resistant rejection episodes, 27 (96%) were reversed with a 7-14-day course of OKT3, 5 mg/day. Only 5 recurrent rejection episodes (19%) have been observed in the 2-14-month follow-up period after OKT3 treatment; infections have occurred in 10 patients (36%), and three grafts (11%) have been lost in OKT3 treated patients. These results suggest that recurrent rejection and subsequent infection after OKT3 is used to treat rejection may be reduced in a protocol where CD renal allograft recipients are treated with baseline immunosuppression regimens including CsA and where OKT3 is reserved for steroid-resistant rejection. This approach appears to be both more cost-effective than, and as effective therapeutically as, treating all first rejection episodes with the monoclonal antibody.     

The risk of infection following OKT3 and antilymphocyte globulin treatment for renal transplant rejection: results of a single center prospectively randomized trial

Some 43 of 60 (72%) renal allograft recipients who were prospectively randomized to receive either OKT3 monoclonal antibody (n = 30) or ALG (antilymphocyte globulin) polyclonal antibody (n = 30) for steroid-resistant rejection suffered from infection, 25 (83%) following OKT3 and 18 (60%) following ALG treatment (P < 0.05). Clinically evident herpes infection was most frequently seen (9 and 7, respectively), followed by pneumonia (6 and 1, respectively P < 0.05), urinary tract infection and wound infection (2 of each in both groups) fungal (Candida) and multibacterial infections. One patient died in each group due to cytomegalovirus (CMV) pneumonia, giving a mortality of 4.3% in each group. Actuarial 1-year graft and patient survival rates were 80% and 97% in both groups, respectively. It is concluded that ALG and OKT3 are equally effective in renal allograft rejection resistant to steroid treatment, however, the risk of infection appears to be higher with OKT3.     

Use of a brief steroid trial before initiating OKT3 therapy for renal allograft rejection

OKT3 (Ortho Pharmaceutical, Raritan, NJ) has been employed in a protocol where all patients received cyclosporine as part of their baseline immunosuppressive regimen and, after the diagnosis of rejection was established, were treated with up to three pulses of methylprednisolone before monoclonal antibody therapy was initiated. Use of this protocol has allowed 46% of rejection episodes encountered to be treated on an outpatient basis without resorting to inpatient use of OKT3, but has avoided delaying OKT3 therapy until after all other methods of rejection treatment were found to be ineffective. Of 83 rejection episodes treated with OKT3 between March 1985 and May 1987, 78 (94%) were reversed. Overall graft survival is 84% and patient survival is 96% in OKT3-treated patients. Of the 17 rejection episodes where OKT3 treatment was a second or third exposure to the drug, rejection was successfully reversed in 15 (88%). In cadaver donor allograft recipients transplanted between March 1985 and May 1986, actual 1-year graft survival is 80% for 30 patients requiring no rejection therapy, 80% for 20 patients with rejection episodes responding quickly to steroids, and 82% for 28 patients with OKT3-treated, steroid-insensitive rejections. Mean serum creatinine at 1 year posttransplant is 1.5 +/- 0.5; 1.9 +/- 0.7; and 2.1 +/- 0.8, respectively, for these groups of patients.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Influence of low-dose cyclosporine on the outcome of treatment with OKT3 for acute renal allograft rejection

The outcomes of 51 consecutive patients who received OKT3 for acute renal allograft rejection were analyzed. Thirty patients (group 1), previously maintained on cyclosporine, continued to receive 50% of their maintenance dose of CsA during OKT3; 21 patients (group 2) either never received CsA or temporarily discontinued CsA during OKT3. All patients received low doses of azathioprine and prednisone during OKT3. Rejection was reversed by OKT3 in 90% of patients in group 1 and in 62% of patients in group 2. Continuation of CsA during OKT3 did not increase the incidence of serious infections following OKT3. Serum creatinine concentrations in groups 1 and 2 were comparable before, during, and after therapy with OKT3 suggesting that low doses of CsA do not induce graft dysfunction during therapy with the monoclonal antibody. In a subset of 22 prospectively studied patients, anti-OKT3 antibodies developed in 2 of 13 patients (15%) who continued low-dose CsA during OKT3 and in 6 of 9 patients (67%) in whom CsA was temporarily discontinued during OKT3. We conclude that administration of low doses of CsA during therapy with OKT3 may reduce the formation of anti-OKT3 antibodies without compromising reversal of rejection by the monoclonal antibody and without increasing the short-term risk of infection or graft dysfunction.     

High or low dose steroid therapy for acute renal transplant rejection after prophylactic OKT3 treatment: a prospective randomized study

In this prospective randomized study, acute renal transplant rejections occurring in patients who received prophylactic OKT3 therapy were treated with either 3 pulses of 8 mg/kg methylprednisolone (MPS) in an alternate-day regimen (total dose 25 mg/kg in 1 week, H group, n = 24) or 5 daily pulses of 3 mg/kg MPS (total dose 17 mg/kg, L group, n = 22). Acute rejection was proven by biopsy in more than 85% of cases in both groups. No difference was observed in rejection reversal (H 88%, L 91%), graft losses in the following 3 months (H 11%, L 4%) or the time evolution of the serum creatinine levels. The number (H 14, L 21) as well as the nature and severity of infections were similar in both groups. Only one death occurred in a patient who received OKT3 rescue therapy for corticoresistant rejections and developed Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-related lymphoma. In conclusion, low dose MPS pulses appear as effective and safe as a higher dose to reverse acute rejection occurring after OKT3 prophylaxis. Thus, we favour the use of the low dose regimen in these patients.     

Evolving use of OKT3 monoclonal antibody for treatment of renal allograft rejection

OKT3, a monoclonal antibody reactive with a surface glycoprotein present on all postthymic T cells, was used to treat the initial acute episode of rejection in 30 recipients of cadaveric donor renal allografts. The first 16 patients received 1-5 mg daily for a period of 10-21 days during which the azathioprine and prednisone dosages were sharply reduced. Circulating T cells were eliminated within minutes after the first OKT3 infusion. T cells reactive with OKT3 remained depressed throughout the period of treatment, although a significant number of cells reactive with other T cells subset reagents became detectable after several days of OKT3 treatment. In all instances, the established rejection episode was reversed in 2-8 days without the addition of other immunosuppressive measures. Recurrent rejection occurred in 12 of 16 patients, but with further conventional immunosuppression, 50% of the renal allografts remain functional 20-44 months after transplantation. Fever, chills, and, in some instances, dyspnea following the first dose of OKT3 were the only side-effects observed. Most patients developed antiidiotypic or antimouse immunoglobulin antibodies without apparent clinical sequelae. In the subsequent 14 patients, modifications in the protocol included a steroid bolus prior to the first OKT3 infusion, limitation of therapy to 10 days, resumption of maintenance levels of azathioprine and prednisone prior to discontinuing OKT3, and addition of 3 i.v. doses of cyclophosphamide at the termination of treatment. Respiratory symptoms after the first infusion of the reagent have been eliminated. Antibody responses to OKT3 have been reduced, occurring in 38% as compared with 73% of patients treated previously. Recurrent rejection episodes observed in 8 of 14 patients have been reversible in all but one case. Allograft survival is 86% at 6-17 months posttransplantation. In the entire series of 30 OKT3-treated patients, only 4 grafts (13%) have been lost because of recurrent episodes of rejection.     

Long-term outcome of the use of OKT3 to treat steroid-resistant acute renal allograft rejection

OKT3 was used to treat steroid-resistant acute renal allograft refection in 30 of 496 adult patients transplanted over a 6-year period. Rejection was reversed (defined as a fall in serum creatinine by 50% or more within 30 days of treatment with OKT3) in 40% of cases. Successful reversal was significantly more likely when rejection occurred shortly after transplantation (t ratio-2.53; P=0.019). The long-term outcome was disappointing; the actuarial graft survival at 1 year from the start of treatment with OKT3 was 42%, and no grafts have thus far survived longer than 3 years. Graft survival was horter in older patients (coefficient/standard error 2.226; P<0.05), and no other predictor of long-term outcome was identified. Patient survival at 3 years was 88%. Serious infection occurred in 33% of patients, with two deaths. Our experience suggests that treatment with OKT3 is unlikely to reverse acute renal allograft rejection in more than half of patients where rejection is resistant to steroids. Although long-term graft survival occurred in a few cases, the overall long-term outcome was disappointing, particularly in older patients. Finally, our analysis indicates the difficulty of predicting which patients will derive long-term benefit when OKT3 is used to treat steroidresistant rejection.     

The role of microvascular injury on steroid and OKT3 response in renal allograft rejection

BACKGROUND: The authors' aim is to understand the influence of human leukocyte antigen-DR positive microvascular (MV)-DR destruction on steroid and OKT3 response in acute rejection (AR). METHODS: Twenty of 40 patients had steroid-resistant AR (group 1) and received OKT3 treatment, and the other 20 patients had AR that responded to steroid treatment (group 2). A renal biopsy specimen was obtained from each subject during the AR episode. The degree of MV-DR destruction and the peritubular capillary (PTC) leukocyte infiltration were recorded in each case, using three-tiered scales. The follow-up biopsy specimens of all cases were evaluated for the development of interstitial fibrosis (IF). RESULTS: Seventy-eight percent of the cases with severe MV destruction and 45% of those with moderate MV destruction did not show response to steroid therapy, whereas 74% of the cases with mild MV destruction responded to steroid therapy. Group 1 patients showed higher frequencies of vascular rejection (80%) and high-grade PTC leukocyte infiltration (85%) than the group 2 cases (P<0.01 for both). Seventy percent of the patients in group 1 responded to OKT3 therapy. The biopsy specimens from the six individuals who were resistant to OKT3 had shown severe MV destruction, vascular rejection, and high-grade PTC leukocyte infiltration. Severity of MV destruction in the initial AR diagnostic biopsy was positively correlated with development of diffuse IF and chronic allograft nephropathy in the follow-up biopsy specimens (P<0.001) CONCLUSIONS: Analysis of MV destruction may be helpful for diagnosing rejection and predicting graft prognosis. This type of assessment may be useful for determining the immune response and thus identifying the most appropriate treatment.     

Frequent salvage of ruptured renal allografts: a large single center experience

Our experience with 22 renal allograft ruptures (AR) in 4418 transplant recipients over a 20-yr period was reviewed. Fourteen of the 22 ruptured allografts were repaired and eight underwent nephrectomy. All of the repaired AR functioned for 1 yr and 64% functioned at 5 yr. Human leukocyte antigens (HLA) matched and living donor cohorts were predictive factors of salvage. In this large group, renal AR was frequently rescued by primary repair with excellent long-term outcome.     

Effectiveness of a second course of OKT3 monoclonal anti-T cell antibody for treatment of renal allograft rejection

A second course of OKT3 monoclonal anti-T cell antibody was given to 21 recipients of kidney transplants. Rejections reversed in 43% of patients in whom 95% of rejections had reversed with their initial OKT3 course. Reversal was highly dependent upon the timing of rejection, anti-OKT3 antibody production, and T cell CD3 modulation. Rejections treated greater than 90 days after transplantation were resistant to OKT3 reversal. High-titer anti-OKT3 antibodies prevented OKT3 reversal of rejection, and effective CD3 (the cell surface target of OKT3) modulation was necessary for successful OKT3 reversal of rejection. Reexposure to OKT3 further stimulated anti-OKT3 antibody production and broadened the specificity of the antibodies produced. OKT3 can effectively and safely be used a second time for treatment of early T cell-mediated renal allograft rejections if high-titer anti-OKT3 antibodies have not been made.     

Reversal of acute glomerular renal allograft rejection: a possible effect of OKT3

A major cause of renal allograft loss is glomerulovascular rejection. This case report is about an episode of histologically proven acute glomerular rejection that was successfully reversed. Monoclonal antibody OKT3 may have been the effective agent.     

Reversal of acute glomerular renal allograft rejection: a possible effect of OKT3

Abstract. A major cause of renal allograft loss is glomerulovascular rejection. This case report is about an episode of histologically proven acute glomerular rejection that was successfully reversed. Monoclonal antibody OKT3 may have been the effective agent.