Cells, matrix, growth factors, and the surgeon. The biology of scarless fetal wound repair.

OBJECTIVE: This review updates the surgeon about the cellular, matrix, and growth factor components of scarless fetal wound repair. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Fetal skin wound healing is characterized by the absence of scar tissue formation. This unique repair process is not dependent on the sterile, aqueous intrauterine environment. The differences between fetal and adult skin wound healing appear to reflect processes intrinsic to fetal tissue, such as the unique fetal fibroblasts, a more rapid and ordered deposition and turnover of tissue components, and, particularly, a markedly reduced inflammatory infiltrate and cytokine profile. Scarless fetal wounds are relatively deficient in the inflammatory cytokine, transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta). In contrast, the fibrosis characteristic of adult wound repair may be associated with TGF-beta excess. Recent experimental studies suggest that specific anti-TGF-beta therapeutic strategies can ameliorate scar formation in adult wound repair and fibrotic diseases. Inhibitors of TGF-beta may be important future drugs to control scar. CONCLUSIONS: Based on the scarless fetal wound repair model, a number of ways in which the matrix and cellular response of the healing adult wound might be manipulated to reduce scarring are reviewed.     

Exogenous transforming growth factor-beta amplifies its own expression and induces scar formation in a model of human fetal skin repair.

OBJECTIVE: Fetal skin wounds heal without scarring. To determine the role of TGF-beta 1 in fetal wound healing, mRNA expression of TGF-beta 1 was analyzed in human fetal and adult skin wounds. METHODS: Human fetal skin transplanted to a subcutaneous location on an adult athymic mouse that was subsequently wounded heals without scar, whereas human adult skin heals with scar formation in that location. In situ hybridization for TGF-beta 1 mRNA expression and species-specific immunohistochemistry for fibroblasts, macrophages, and neutrophils were performed in human adult wounds, fetal wounds, and fetal wounds treated with a TGF-beta 1 slow release disk. RESULTS: Transforming growth factor-beta 1 mRNA expression was induced by wounding adult skin. No TGF-beta 1 mRNA upregulation was detected in human fetal skin after wounding. However, when exogenous TGF-beta 1 was added to human fetal skin, induction of TGF-beta 1 mRNA expression in human fetal fibroblasts occurred, an adult-like inflammatory response was detected, and the skin healed with scar formation. CONCLUSIONS: Transforming growth factor-beta 1 is an important modulator in scar formation. Anti-TGF-beta 1 strategies may promote scarless healing in adult wounds.     

Scarless human fetal skin repair is intrinsic to the fetal fibroblast and occurs in the absence of an inflammatory response

The fetus heals skin wounds without scar formation. Human fetal skin that is transplanted to a subcutaneous location on an adult athymic mouse and subsequently wounded heals without scar formation, whereas the same skin heals with scar formation when transplanted to a cutaneous location. In situ hybridization with species-specific DNA probes and immunohistochemistry were performed to characterize the healing process of human fetal skin in these two locations. Species-specific human and mouse DNA probes were constructed and used to probe graft wounds under high stringency in situ hybridization conditions. Immunostaining for species-specific fibroblasts, macrophages, and neutrophils was also performed. We found that the cutaneous human fetal grafts healed with scar and showed an influx of mouse fibroblasts and macrophages. In contrast, subcutaneous human fetal grafts showed exclusively human fetal fibroblasts in the wound environment, an absence of inflammatory cells, and scar-free repair. We conclude that the highly organized collagen deposition in scarless human fetal wound repair appears to be intrinsic to the human fetal fibroblasts and occurs in the absence of an adult-like inflammatory response.     

Fetal wound healing: an in vitro explant model

The ability of fetal skin wounds to heal without scar formation is remarkable. The mechanisms that endow the fetus with this unique healing ability remain unknown. We have developed an in vitro explant model using fetal sheep skin to investigate fetal wound healing. This model eliminates the complex systemic mechanisms that modulate in vivo wound healing. We demonstrated that using an enriched medium, midgestation fetal sheep skin explants following wounding reepithelialized within 4 days. By 7 days after wounding the confluent epidermis was thicker, but the dermal wound remained open. This model demonstrates that it is possible to achieve conditions in culture that maintain tissue viability and support reepithelialization. This model may allow us to resolve some of the individual components that participate in the process of scarless fetal skin healing.     

Permissive environment in postnatal wounds induced by adenoviral-mediated overexpression of the anti-inflammatory cytokine interleukin-10 prevents scar formation

Wound healing in the mid-gestation fetus is scarless with minimal inflammation and a unique extracellular matrix. We have previously documented the relative lack of inflammatory cytokines in this environment. We demonstrate that interleukin (IL)-10 is highly expressed in mid-gestation human fetal skin but is absent in postnatal human skin. We hypothesize that overexpression of IL-10 in postnatal skin may replicate a permissive environment for scarless healing. To study the mechanism underlying this process we performed immunohistochemistry for IL-10 in human mid-gestation fetal and postnatal skin. We also determined if adenoviral-mediated overexpression of IL-10 could allow for scarless wound healing in a murine incisional wound model. Wounds were analyzed at 1–90 days postwounding for effects on scar formation, inflammatory response, and biomechanical properties. Ad-IL-10 reconstitutes a permissive environment for scarless healing as shown by reconstitution of a normal dermal reticular collagen pattern and distribution of dermal elements. Compared with controls, Ad-IL-10 treated wounds showed reduced inflammatory response and no difference in biomechanical parameters. Therefore, overexpression of IL-10 in postnatal wounds results in a permissive environment for scarless wound repair, possibly by replicating a fetal wound environment.     

Interleukin‐33 encourages scar formation in murine fetal skin wounds

The magnitude of the inflammatory response after skin injury is important for determining whether wounds in developing fetal skin will heal scarlessly (minimal inflammation) or with prominent scars (robust inflammation). One class of inflammatory mediators gaining attention for their role in wound inflammation is alarmins. In the current study, the alarmin interleukin‐33 (IL‐33) was examined in a mouse model of fetal wound healing. IL‐33 expression was elevated in scar‐forming embryonic day 18 wounds compared to scarless embryonic day 15 wounds. Furthermore, injection of IL‐33 into embryonic day 15 wounds caused scarring when wounds were analyzed at 7 days postwounding. The introduction of IL‐33 into embryonic day 15 wounds did not induce statistically significant changes in the number of neutrophils, mast cells, or macrophages in vivo. However, IL‐33 treatment enhanced collagen expression in cultured fibroblasts derived from adult and fetal murine skin, suggesting that IL‐33 may directly stimulate fibroblasts. In vitro studies suggested that the stimulation of collagen production by IL‐33 in fibroblasts was partially dependent on NF‐κB activation. Overall, the data suggest an association between IL‐33 and scar formation in fetal wounds.     

Adult skin wounds in the fetal environment heal with scar formation.

OBJECTIVE: This study investigated the influence of the fetal environment on the healing characteristics of adult skin. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: The remarkable ability of the fetus to heal without scarring is poorly understood. The unique qualities of fetal wound healing may be caused by the fetal environment, the fetal tissues, or a combination of both. There are numerous differences between the prenatal and postnatal environments that may play a role in the unique fetal response to injury. METHODS: Full-thickness adult sheep skin was transplanted onto the backs of 60-day-gestation fetal lambs (term, 145 days of gestation). The adult skin grafts were thus perfused by fetal blood and bathed in amniotic fluid. Previous work has demonstrated that, before midgestation, fetal lambs do not reject allogenic skin grafts. Forty days later (100 days of gestation), incisional wounds were made on both the adult skin graft and the adjacent fetal skin. The wounds were harvested 14 days postwounding and analyzed by both light microscopy and immunohistochemical testing using antibodies to collagen types I, III, and VI. RESULTS: The wounds in the adult skin grafts healed with scar formation. This observation contrasts strongly with the scarless healing of the incisional fetal skin wounds. CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that scarless fetal skin healing properties are intrinsic to fetal skin and are not primarily the result of the fetal environment.     

Is fetal tissue the only factor responsible for the properties of fetal wound healing?

Fetal skin wounds heal without inflammation, collagen deposition or wound contraction. The mechanism of this process is unknown, but may be unique to fetal cells, the fetal environment, or an combination of both. In order to determine whether fetal cells are the only factor responsible for scarless wound healing, an experimental study was performed on ten cats who were in the last trimester of their pregnancy. Skin grafts were transferred from mother to fetus and fetus to mother. The fetal skin grafted to the mother was biopsied between the eighth and tenth postoperative days and was evaluated histopathologically on days 18–20. Biopsy revealed scar formation in both the fetal grafts in the adult and maternal grafts in the fetus. We can conclude that scarless wound healing in the fetus is not solely due to fetal cells.     

Novel differences in the expression of inflammation‐associated genes between mid‐ and late‐gestational dermal fibroblasts

While cutaneous wounds of late‐gestational fetuses and on through adulthood result in scar formation, wounds incurred early in gestation have been shown to heal scarlessly. Unique properties of fetal fibroblasts are believed to mediate this scarless healing process. In this study, microarray analysis was used to identify differences in the gene expression profiles of cultured fibroblasts from embryonic day 15 (E15; midgestation) and embryonic day 18 (E18; late‐gestation) skin. Sixty‐two genes were differentially expressed and 12 of those genes are associated with inflammation, a process that correlates with scar formation in fetal wounds. One of the differentially expressed inflammatory genes was cyclooxygenase‐1 (COX‐1). COX‐1 was more highly expressed in E18 fibroblasts than in E15 fibroblasts, and these differences were confirmed at the gene and protein level. Differences in COX‐1 protein expression were also observed in fetal skin by immunohistochemical and immunofluorescence staining. The baseline differences in gene expression found in mid‐ and late‐gestational fetal fibroblasts suggest that developmental alterations in fibroblasts could be involved in the transition from scarless to fibrotic fetal wound healing. Furthermore, baseline differences in the expression of inflammatory genes by fibroblasts in E15 and E18 skin may contribute to inflammation and scar formation late in gestation.     

Fetal wound healing. The ontogeny of scar formation in the non-human primate.

OBJECTIVE: This study determined how scar formation develops in a non-human primate model of fetal skin repair. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: A transition from healing scarlessly to healing with scar formation characterizes skin repair in rat and sheep fetuses. New knowledge of the regulatory processes occurring in the fetal wound at the initial stages of scar formation may provide insights into the early mechanisms of scar formation. METHODS: Full-thickness wounds were made in fetal rhesus monkey lips from 75 through 114 days gestation (n = 6, term = 165 days). Wounds were harvested at 14 days postwounding and processed for histology (hematoxylin & eosin, Masson's trichrome) as well as immunohistochemistry (human type I or type III collagen). RESULTS: Wounds healed with complete restoration of normal tissue architecture in the 75-day gestation fetus. However in the 85-100 day gestation fetuses, wounds healed with an absence of hair follicles and sebaceous glands, but the dermal collagen pattern remained reticular and similar to that in unwounded dermis. At 107 days, a thin scar was present in the wound, thereby demonstrating a transition to scar formation between 100 and 107 days gestation (early 3rd trimester) in the non-human primate. CONCLUSIONS: In the non-human primate fetus, a transition from scarless repair to adult-type repair with scar formation occurs in the early third trimester. These data provide insight into the transition process; the ontogeny of scar formation is characterized initially by wounds healing without the presence of epidermal appendages but with a normal reticular dermal collagen pattern, which we term the "transition wound."     

Fetal diaphragmatic wounds heal with scar formation

Fetal wound healing is fundamentally different from wound healing in the adult. Although experimental work in mice, rats, rabbits, monkeys, and sheep has demonstrated that fetal healing occurs without inflammation and scarring, all of these studies have been limited to fetal skin wounds. Whether all fetal tissues heal in a regenerative-like fashion is unknown. Amniotic fluid exposure may play an important role in scarless fetal skin wound healing, but the effect of amniotic fluid on fetal mesothelial wound healing has not been characterized. To investigate these questions we created bilateral linear diaphragmatic wounds in 100-day gestation fetal lambs (term = 145 days). The right thoracotomy was closed to exclude amniotic fluid. In contrast, the left thoracotomy was fashioned into an Eloesser flap which permitted the left diaphragmatic wound to be continually bathed in amniotic fluid. Wounds were harvested after 1, 2, 7, or 14 days and analyzed by light microscopy and immunohistochemistry with antibodies to collagen types I, III, IV, and VI. Whether bathed in or excluded from amniotic fluid, the mesothelial-lined diaphragm healed with scar formation and without evidence of muscle regeneration. Interestingly, diaphragmatic wounds exposed to amniotic fluid were covered by a thick fibrous collagen peel similar to that seen in gastroschisis bowel. These findings indicate that not all fetal tissues share the unique scarless healing properties of fetal skin.     

The altered mechanical phenotype of fetal fibroblasts hinders myofibroblast differentiation

During the dermal wound healing process, the mechanical rigidity of the newly deposited extracellular matrix and transforming growth factor‐β1 promote the transition of fibroblasts into myofibroblasts. Myofibroblasts generate large cellular forces that contract and remodel the extracellular matrix leading to scar formation. In contrast, myofibroblasts are not detected in fetal dermal wounds which are more compliant and contain less transforming growth factor‐β1 than adult wounds. Instead, fetal fibroblasts orchestrate scarless healing of dermal wounds resulting in healed tissues that resemble uninjured dermis. While these biomechanical differences suggest that the fetal wound environment promotes smaller cellular forces which enable regeneration, previous studies indicate that fetal fibroblasts have unique contractile properties that may facilitate scarless dermal repair. Therefore, we tested whether physiologic wound rigidities and transforming growth factor‐β1 induce contractile forces and myofibroblast differentiation of fetal dermal fibroblasts. In comparison to their adult dermal counterparts, we found that fetal fibroblasts exhibit a deficient contractile response to rigid extracellular matrix and transforming growth factor‐β1. Our data suggest that the contractile phenotype of fetal dermal fibroblasts limits their cellular force production and prevents their ability to differentiate into myofibroblasts.     

胎儿和成人皮肤及其创面愈合过程中碱性成纤维细胞生长因子的表达及意义

目的　探讨胎儿和成人皮肤及其创面愈合过程中碱性成纤维细胞生长因子 (b FGF)的表达及其意义。方法　将孕龄 2 0～ 2 4周胎儿皮肤移植至 BAL B/ C裸鼠背部皮下 ,皮片成活后制造创面 ,建立胎儿无瘢痕愈合动物模型 ,定期获取相应标本。对临床所取正常成人皮肤及创面愈合皮肤标本 ,采用免疫组织化学染色方法 ,观察 b FGF的表达情况。　结果　正常胎儿皮肤及创伤后胎儿皮肤中均未见明显的 b FGF阳性表达。正常成人皮肤中血管周围可见阳性表达 ;创伤后成人皮肤也可见阳性表达 ,尤其成纤维细胞和血管内皮细胞创伤后表达明显增强。高倍镜视野随机观察计数b FGF阳性表达细胞数 ,正常胎儿皮肤为 2 .1± 0 .1,创伤后 12小时 ,1、3天和 1周胎儿皮肤分别为 2 .2± 0 .1、2 .1± 0 .3、2 .1± 0 .3和 2 .0± 0 .1;正常成人皮肤为 2 3.2± 4 .2 ,创伤后成人皮肤为 4 0 .5± 3.6 ,胎儿正常皮肤和创伤皮肤 b FGF表达与正常成人皮肤和创伤后皮肤 b FGF表达比较 ,差异有统计学意义 (P<0 .0 1)。　结论　 b FGF的阴性表达可能是胎儿皮肤无瘢痕愈合的重要原因之一。     

Hydrogen peroxide disrupts scarless fetal wound repair

Cutaneous wound healing is a complex process that leads to the formation of a permanent scar in adult skin. In contrast, early gestation fetal skin undergoes scarless repair. Normally, the repair process in the skin begins with an acute inflammatory response. However, one of the most important aspects of scarless fetal wound repair appears to be a lack of inflammation, suggesting that inflammation promotes scar formation in the skin. While it is well accepted that inflammation causes scar formation in the fetus, it is not known what specific factors produced during inflammation are responsible for these effects. Oxidants released by activated inflammatory cells have the potential to be involved, although this has never been examined. The present studies, using a murine fetal wound repair model, show that hydrogen peroxide interferes with scarless healing, possibly through the induction of transforming growth factor-beta1. Hydrogen peroxide also increased the proliferation of fetal fibroblasts, which could contribute to an increase in the fibrosis seen with hydrogen peroxide. Defining the factors produced during the inflammatory response that contribute to scar formation could be important for the development of new therapies designed to minimize scarring.     

Fetal mouse skin heals scarlessly in a chick chorioallantoic membrane model system

In mammals, the early-gestation fetus has the regenerative ability to heal skin wounds without scar formation. This observation was first reported more than 3 decades ago, and has been confirmed in a number of in vivo animal models. Although an intensive research effort has focused on unraveling the mechanisms underlying scarless fetal wound repair, no suitable model of in vitro fetal skin healing has been developed. In this article, we report a novel model for the study of fetal wound healing. Fetal skin from gestational day 16.5 Balb/c mice (total gestation, 20 days) was grafted onto the chorioallantoic membrane of 12-day-old chicken embryos and cultured for up to 7 days. At 48 hours postengraftment, circular wounds (diameter = 1 mm) were made in the fetal skin using a rotating titanium sapphire laser (N = 45). The tissue was examined daily by visual inspection to look for signs of infection and ischemia. The grafts and the surrounding host tissue were examined histologically. In all fetal skin grafts, the wounds completely reepithelialized by postinjury day 7, with regeneration of the dermis. Fetal mouse skin xenografts transplanted onto the chorioallantoic membrane of fertilized chicken eggs provides a useful model for the study of fetal wound healing. This model can be used as an adjunct to traditional in vivo mammalian models of fetal repair.     

Biology of fetal wound healing: collagen biosynthesis during dermal repair.

The rapid restoration of tissue integrity and breaking strength in healing fetal wounds is mainly a function of fetal wound collagen. In this study, the fetal and adult tissue responses to injury were characterized in terms of changes in collagen biosynthesis. Linear wounds and unwounded skin were incubated with radioactive proline, and collagen synthesis was measured as isotope incorporation into collagenase-sensitive protein. Likewise, noncollagen protein synthesis was represented by isotope incorporation into collagenase-resistant protein. Adult wounds demonstrated a preferential stimulation of collagen as compared with noncollagen protein synthesis after wounding. In contrast, both collagen and noncollagen protein synthesis were significantly elevated in the fetus during the first 5 days postwounding. Despite marked increases in fetal wound collagen synthesis above both unwounded fetal skin and adult wound levels, fetal wounds exhibited no evidence of excessive collagen deposition or scar formation after wounding. These findings suggest that the fetal response to tissue injury is a function of the distinctive qualities of fetal fibroblasts associated with the extracellular wound matrix and may involve rapid collagen turnover and degradation.     

Midgestational excisional fetal lamb wounds contract in utero

Clinical observations and experimental data suggest that fetal wound healing is very different from adult wound healing. An understanding of the biology of scarless fetal wound healing has tremendous clinical potential for modulating postnatal wound problems. In this study, the fetal lamb model was used to assess excisional fetal skin wound contraction in utero. Full-thickness 9-mm punch biopsy wounds were created on fetal lambs at 100 days' gestation (term, 145 days). Half of the wounds remained exposed to amniotic fluid, whereas the other half were covered by a silastic patch to exclude amniotic fluid. Wounds were harvested 3, 7, or 14 days later and wound areas were calculated. Exposure to amniotic fluid retarded wound contraction significantly at 3 days, but by 14 days all wounds had completely contracted and reepithelialized. Myofibroblasts are an important cellular element of wound contraction. The presence of wound myofibroblasts was documented by both transmission electronmicroscopy and immunocytochemistry with antimuscle actin antibody. It is concluded that fetal lamb wounds contract in utero and exposure to amniotic fluid appears to retard fetal skin wound contraction only during the early healing process.     

Wound healing in oral mucosa results in reduced scar formation as compared with skin: Evidence from the red Duroc pig model and humans

Scar formation is a common, unwanted result of wound healing in skin, but the mechanisms that regulate it are still largely unknown. Interestingly, wound healing in the oral mucosa proceeds faster than in skin and clinical observations have suggested that mucosal wounds rarely scar. To test this concept, we created identical experimental wounds in the oral mucosa and skin in red Duroc pigs and compared wound healing and scar development over time. We also compared the pig oral mucosal wound healing to similar experimental wounds created in human subjects. The findings showed significantly reduced scar formation at both clinical and histological level in the pig oral mucosa as compared with skin 49 days after wounding. Additionally, the skin scars contained a significantly increased number of type I procollagen immunopositive cells and an increased fibronectin content, while the oral mucosal wounds demonstrated a prolonged accumulation of tenascin-C. Furthermore, the pig oral mucosal wounds showed similar molecular composition and clinical and histological scar scores to human oral mucosal wounds. Thus, the reduced scar formation in the pig oral mucosa provides a model to study the biological processes that regulate scarless wound healing to find novel approaches to prevent scar formation in skin.     

Reduction of scar formation in full-thickness wounds with topical celecoxib treatment

Adult wound repair occurs with an initial inflammatory response, reepithelialization, and the formation of a permanent scar. Although the inflammatory phase is often considered a necessity for successful adult wound healing, fetal healing studies have shown the ability to regenerate skin and to heal wounds in a scarless manner in the absence of inflammation. The cyclooxygenase-2 (COX-2) enzyme, a known mediator of inflammation, has been shown to contribute to a variety of inflammatory conditions and to the development of cancer in many organs. To examine the role of COX-2 in the wound healing process, incisional wounds were treated topically with the anti-inflammatory COX-2 inhibitor celecoxib. Acutely, celecoxib inhibited several parameters of inflammation in the wound site. This decrease in the early inflammatory phase of wound healing had a significant effect on later events in the wound healing process, namely a reduction in scar tissue formation, without disrupting reepithelialization or decreasing tensile strength. Our data suggest that in the absence of infection, adult wound healing is able to commence with decreased inflammation and that anti-inflammatory drugs may be used to improve the outcome of the repair process in the skin by limiting scar formation.     

Fetal wound healing current perspectives

Early in gestation, fetal wounds are capable of healing scarlessly. Scarless healing in the fetus is characterized by regeneration of an organized dermis with normal appendages and by a relative lack of inflammation. Although there is a transition period between scarless and scar-forming repair, scarless healing also depends on wound size and the organ involved. The ability to heal scarlessly, furthermore, appears to be intrinsic to fetal skin. Unique characteristics of fetal fibroblasts, inflammatory cells, extra-cellular matrix, cytokine profile, and developmental gene regulation may be responsible for the scarless phenotype of early gestation fetal wounds. With the current knowledge, only minimal success has been achieved with the topical application of neutralizing antibodies, antisense oligonucleotides, and growth factors to improve wound-healing outcomes. Thus, further investigation into the mechanisms underlying scarless repair is crucial in order to devise more effective therapies for scar reduction and the treatment of cirrhosis, scleroderma, and other diseases of excessive fibrosis.