Study on motion artifacts in coronary arteries with an anthropomorphic moving heart phantom on an ECG-gated multidetector computed tomography unit

Acquisition time plays a key role in the quality of cardiac multidetector computed tomography (MDCT) and is directly related to the rotation time of the scanner. The purpose of this study is to examine the influence of heart rate and a multisector reconstruction algorithm on the image quality of coronary arteries of an anthropomorphic adjustable moving heart phantom on an ECG-gated MDCT unit. The heart phantom and a coronary artery phantom were used on a MDCT unit with a rotation time of 500 ms. The movement of the heart was determined by analysis of the images taken at different phases. The results indicate that the movement of the coronary arteries on the heart phantom is comparable to that in a clinical setting. The influence of the heart rate on image quality and artifacts was determined by analysis of several heart rates between 40 and 80 bpm where the movement of the heart was synchronized using a retrospective ECG-gated acquisition protocol. The resulting reformatted volume rendering images of the moving heart and the coronary arteries were qualitatively compared as a result of the heart rate. The evaluation was performed on three independent series by two independent radiologists for the image quality of the coronary arteries and the presence of artifacts. The evaluation shows that at heart rates above 50 bpm the influence of motion artifacts in the coronary arteries becomes apparent. In addition the influence of a dedicated multisector reconstruction technique on image quality was determined. The results show that the image quality of the coronary arteries is not only related to the heart rate and that the influence of the multisector reconstruction technique becomes significant above 70 bpm. Therefore, this study proves that from the actual acquisition time per heart cycle one cannot determine an actual acquisition time, but only a mathematical acquisition time.     

Influence of heart rate and temporal resolution on left-ventricular volumes in cardiac multislice spiral computed tomography: a phantom study

PURPOSE: We sought to investigate the influence of heart rate and temporal resolution on the assessment of left-ventricular (LV) function with multislice spiral computed tomography (CT). MATERIAL AND METHODS: A dynamic cardiac phantom was repeatedly scanned with a 64-slice CT scanner using a standardized scan protocol (64 x 0.6 mm, 120kV, 770mAs(eff), 330 milliseconds rotation time) at different simulated heart rates, ranging from 40 to 140 beats per minute. Images were reconstructed with an algorithm utilizing data from 1 to 4 cardiac cycles (RR intervals). Ejection fraction (EF), end-systolic, end-diastolic, and stroke volume as well as cardiac output were calculated. Results of the measurements were compared with the real volumes of the phantom. Interscan and intraobserver variability were calculated. RESULTS: Using a monosegmental reconstruction algorithm, the temporal resolution was fixed to 165 milliseconds. With bi-, tri-, and quad-segmental image reconstruction, mean temporal resolution was 128.3 +/- 33.2 milliseconds, 103.3 +/- 49.2 milliseconds, and 87.8 +/- 81.5 milliseconds, respectively. Multisegmental image reconstruction resulted in a lower deviation when comparing measured and real volumes. Using mono-, bi-, tri-, and quad-segmental image reconstruction, the percent deviation between measured and real values for EF was 8.2%, 4.5%, 3.3%, and 3.4%, respectively. Applying multisegmental image reconstruction with improved temporal resolution the deviation decreased with increasing heart rate when compared with mono-segmental image reconstruction. Interscan and intraobserver variability for EF were 1.1% and 1.9%, respectively. CONCLUSION: Enhanced temporal resolution improves the quantification of LV volumes in cardiac multislice spiral CT, enabling reliable assessment of LV volumes even at increased heart rates.     

Efficacy of pre-scan beta-blockade and impact of heart rate on image quality in patients undergoing coronary multidetector computed tomography angiography

OBJECTIVE: While beta-blockers are routinely administered to patients prior to coronary computed tomography angiography (CTA), their effectiveness is unknown. We therefore assessed the efficacy of beta-blockade with regards to heart rate (HR) control and image quality in an unselected patient cohort. METHODS: We studied 150 consecutive patients (104 men/46 female; mean age, 56+/-13 years) referred for coronary CTA. Intravenous metoprolol (5-20mg) was administered to patients with a HR >65 beats per minute (bpm). The goal HR was defined as an average HR <65 bpm without a single measurement above 68 bpm. RESULTS: Overall, 45% (68/150) of patients met the HR criteria for beta-blocker administration of which 76% (52/68) received metoprolol (mean dose 12+/-10mg). Of the 52 patients who received beta-blocker versus the 98 who did not, 18 (35%) versus 62 (64%) patients achieved the goal HR, respectively. All patients who achieved the target HR had an evaluable CTA while five patients who did not achieve the target HR had at least one non-evaluable coronary artery due to motion artifact. There was also a significant reduction in any motion artifact among those who achieved the goal HR as compared to those who did not (p=0.001). Logistic regression revealed an increase in the odds of stair step artifact of 11.6% (95% CI: 2.4% decrease, 27.5% increase) per 1 bpm increase in the standard deviation of scan HR. CONCLUSION: Overall, efficacy of beta-blocker administration to reach target HR is limited. Improvements in CT scanner temporal resolution are mandatory to achieve consistently high image quality independent of HR and beta-blocker administration.     

The impact of scan length on the exposure levels in 16- and 64-row multidetector computed tomography: a phantom study

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Higher patient exposure levels have been reported for 64-row multidetector computed tomography (MDCT) compared to 16-row MDCT. The objective of this study was to make a thorough comparison by evaluating the impact of scan length on the exposure levels at 16-row MDCT and 64-row MDCT. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Dose-length product (DLP) values were determined to compare exposure levels in 16- and 64-row MDCT. This phantom study does not deal with a possible reduction in image quality induced by an increase in scattered radiation in 64-row MDCT compared to 16-row MDCT. RESULTS: The exposure levels of 64-row MDCT (scan slice thickness, 0.5 mm) are up to 18% lower than those of 16-row MDCT at slice thickness 0.5 mm when scanning an object larger than 12.3 cm. At this value, the plots of the 16- and 64-row DLP values versus scan length cross. The DLP curves of 1- and 2-mm slice thickness 16-row MDCT are in closer resemblance to those of 0.5-mm 64-row MDCT. The respective exposure levels of 1- and 2-mm slice thickness 16-row MDCT exceed those of 0.5-mm 64-row MDCT by up to 4% and 3%, with intersections of 30 and 25 cm, respectively. CONCLUSION: Lower effective doses are obtained in 64-row MDCT compared to 16-row MDCT (0.5-mm slice thickness) provided that scan length exceeds 12.3, 30, and 25 cm, for 16-row MDCT slice thickness of 0.5, 1, and 2 mm, respectively. Reduced effective dosage in 64-row MDCT compared to 16-row MDCT has not been demonstrated before. Differences in object size may thus explain discrepancies between previous studies with regard to the exposure levels at 64-slice CT compared to 16-slice CT.     

Calcium score of small coronary calcifications on multidetector computed tomography: Results from a static phantom study

Introduction

Multi detector computed tomography (MDCT) underestimates the coronary calcium score as compared to electron beam tomography (EBT). Therefore clinical risk stratification based on MDCT calcium scoring may be inaccurate. The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility of a new phantom which enables establishment of a calcium scoring protocol for MDCT that yields a calcium score comparable to the EBT values and to the physical mass.

Materials and methods

A phantom containing 100 small calcifications ranging from 0.5 to 2.0 mm was scanned on EBT using a standard coronary calcium protocol. In addition, the phantom was scanned on a 320-row MDCT scanner using different scanning, reconstruction and scoring parameters (tube voltage 80–135 kV, slice thickness 0.5–3.0 mm, reconstruction kernel FC11–FC15 and threshold 110–150 HU). The Agatston and mass score of both modalities was compared and the influence of the parameters was assessed.

Results

On EBT the Agatston and mass scores were between 0 and 20, and 0 and 3 mg, respectively. On MDCT the Agatston and mass scores were between 0 and 20, and 0 and 4 mg, respectively. All parameters showed an influence on the calcium score. The Agatston score on MDCT differed 52% between the 80 and 135 kV, 65% between 0.5 and 3.0 mm and 48% between FC11 and FC15. More calcifications were detected with a lower tube voltage, a smaller slice thickness, a sharper kernel and a lower threshold. Based on these observations an acquisition protocol with a tube voltage of 100 kV and two reconstructions protocols were defined with a FC12 reconstruction kernel; one with a slice thickness of 3.0 mm and a one with a slice thickness of 0.5 mm. This protocol yielded an Agatston score as close to the EBT as possible, but also a mass score as close to the physical phantom value as possible, respectively.

Conclusion

With the new phantom one acquisition protocol and two reconstruction protocols can be defined which produces Agatston scores comparable to EBT values and to the physical mass.     

Characterization of a computed tomography iterative reconstruction algorithm by image quality evaluations with an anthropomorphic phantom

Objective

This study aims to investigate the consequences on dose and image quality of the choices of different combinations of NI and adaptive statistical iterative reconstruction (ASIR) percentage, the image quality parameters of GE CT equipment.

Methods

An anthropomorphic phantom was used to simulate the chest and upper abdomen of a standard weight patient. Images were acquired with tube current modulation and different values of noise index, in the range 10–22 for a slice thickness of 5 mm and a tube voltage of 120 kV. For each selected noise index, several image series were reconstructed using different percentages of ASIR (0, 40, 50, 60, 70, 100). Quantitative noise was assessed at different phantom locations. Computed tomography dose index (CTDI) and dose length products (DLP) were recorded. Three radiologists reviewed the images in a blinded and randomized manner and assessed the subjective image quality by comparing the image series with the one acquired with the reference protocol (noise index 14, ASIR 40%). The perceived noise, contrast, edge sharpness and overall quality were graded on a scale from −2 (much worse) to +2 (much better).

Results

A repeatable trend of noise reduction versus the percentage of ASIR was observed for different noise levels and phantom locations. The different combinations of noise index and percentage of ASIR to obtain a desired dose reduction were assessed. The subjective image quality evaluation evidenced a possible dose reduction between 24 and 40% as a consequence of an increment of ASIR percentage to 50 or 70%, respectively.

Conclusion

These results highlighted that the same patient dose reduction can be obtained with several combinations of noise index and percentages of ASIR, providing a model with which to choose these acquisition parameters in future optimization studies, with the aim of reducing patient dose by maintaining image quality in diagnostic levels.     

Ultra-high resolution C-Arm CT arthrography of the wrist: Radiation dose and image quality compared to conventional multidetector computed tomography

ObjectiveObjective of this phantom and cadaveric study was to compare the effective radiation dose (ED) and image quality (IQ) between C-arm computed tomography (CACT) using an ultra-high resolution 1 × 1 binning with a standard 16-slice CT (MDCT) arthrography of the wrist.MethodsED was determined with thermoluminescence dosimetry using an anthropomorphic phantom and different patient positions. Imaging was conducted in 10 human cadaveric wrists after tri-compartmental injection of diluted iodinated contrast material and a wire phantom. IQ of MDCT was compared with CACT reconstructed with a soft (CACT1) and sharp (CACT2) kernel. High and low contrast resolution was determined. Three radiologists assessed IQ of wrist structures and occurrence of image artifacts using a 5-point Likert scale.ResultsED of MDCT was comparable to standard CACT (4.3 μSv/3.7 μSv). High contrast resolution was best for CACT2, decreased to CACT1 and MDCT. Low contrast resolution increased between CACT2 and MDCT (P < 0.001). IQ was best for CACT2 (1.3 ± 0.5), decreased to CACT1 (1.9 ± 0.6) and MDCT (3.5 ± 0.6). Non-compromising artifacts were only reported for CACT.ConclusionsThe results of this phantom and cadaveric study indicate that ultra-high resolution C-Arm CT arthrography of the wrist bears the potential to outperform MDCT arthrography in terms of image quality and workflow at the cost of mildly increasing image artifacts while radiation dose to the patient is comparably low for both, MDCT and C-Arm CT.     

MSCT检查对阴性阑尾切除率的影响

目的：通过前瞻性观察研究评估MSCT检查对急性阑尾疑诊患者阴性阑尾切除率的影响。方法：78例急性阑尾炎临床疑诊患者纳入研究。由急诊科医师根据临床资料（包括实验室检查）结合Alvarado评分做出临床诊断,分为两组：临床典型组（Alvarado评分≥7分）和临床不典型组（Alvarado评分〈7分）。所有患者均行MSCT检查,由放射科医师做出CT诊断。治疗方案由外科医师综合参考临床与CT诊断结果后制定,最终诊断以手术病理和临床随访为准。计算临床与CT诊断的阴阳性结果及相关评价指标,并进行统计学处理。结果：MSCT检查的各个评价指标（准确度94.9%,敏感度95.6%,特异度93.9%,阳性预测值95.6%,阴性预测值93.9%,阳性似然比15.8,阴性似然比0.05）均明显优于临床诊断。78例患者中,35例属临床表现典型组,其中9例（25.7%）证实为急性阑尾炎阴性,此9例患者MSCT诊断结果全为阴性。结论：术前MSCT检查可明显降低急性阑尾疑诊患者的阴性阑尾切除率,避免不必要的剖腹探查。     

How image quality can be improved: our experience with multidetector computed tomography coronary angiography

PURPOSE: The objective of this study was to investigate the factors that may influence image quality on multidetector computed tomography (MDCT) coronary angiography (CA). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two hundred twenty-four consecutive patients (161 men and 63 women; mean age, 52 years; age range, 34-76 years) evaluated with MDCT CA were included in the study. The evaluation of the quality of the patients' images was mainly based on the contrast material phase (early phase, optimal phase, or late phase) and the level of stepladder artifact (none, acceptable, or unacceptable). In addition, factors such as patient selection, patient preparation, scanning, processing, and steps of analysis, which may be affecting the quality of a final image, were examined independently. RESULTS: Patients who could not achieve sufficient breath-holding despite multiple breath exercises, those with a calcium score of 500 or higher, those with a heart rate greater than 90 bpm after metoprolol administration (because of shortening of the diastolic phase in the most still period), and those whose scanning was not completed were excluded from the study. The results for the remaining 224 patients were evaluated. Based on the contrast phase, there were 66 (29.5%) patients in the first group (early), 93 (41.5%) in the second group (optimal), and 65 (29%) in the third group (late). Among the 224 patients, the images of 152 (67.9%) had no stepladder artifact, those of 67 (29.9%) were of acceptable image quality, and those of 5 (2.2%) were of unacceptable image quality. CONCLUSION: It is important to obtain high-quality images to achieve correct interpretation with coronary artery CT angiography. This study aimed to describe a technique performed on 224 patients based on an array of factors ranging from patient selection to postprocessing. The results show that patient selection, cooperation with the patient, and breath-holding exercises play a very important role in obtaining the best images. In addition, a proper scanning technique (e.g., placement of electrocardiographic electrodes and contrast material phase) and postprocessing (e.g., reconstruction interval) may also contribute to obtaining high-quality images.     

Prospective study comparing two iodine concentrations for multidetector computed tomography of the pancreas

Purpose

The authors sought to determine the influence of two different iodine concentrations of nonionic contrast media (cm) on contrast enhancement in pancreatic computed tomography angiography (CTA).

Materials and methods

Sixty patients with clinically suspected or known pancreatic disease underwent pancreatic CTA. The patients were randomly assigned to group A (n=30) and group B (n=30). The contrast agent was injected with iodine concentrations of 400mgI/ml (Iomeron 400) in group A and 300mgI/ml (Iopamidol 300) in group B with the same total iodine dose (36 g). Arterial and portal venous phase contrast enhancement of the vessels, organs and pancreatic masses was measured, and blinded qualitative image assessment was performed by two expert radiologists.

Results

In the arterial and portal venous phase, the highly concentrated cm led to significantly greater enhancement in the abdominal main vessels, pancreas and pancreatic carcinoma than did the low concentrated cm. No statistically significant attenuation differences were measured between pancreatic carcinomas and the pancreatic parenchyma in the arterial and portal venous phase between group A and B. The overall trend for both readers was to assign higher scores to group A than group B.

Conclusions

The higher iodine concentration leads to greater contrast enhancement of abdominal vessels and organs in pancreatic CTA. Detection and demarcation of hypovascular pancreatic carcinoma was not found to be improved by the higher iodine concentration.     

A new method for measuring temporal resolution in electrocardiogram-gated reconstruction image with area-detector computed tomography

The purpose of this study was to design and construct a phantom for using motion artifact in the electrocardiogram (ECG)-gated reconstruction image. In addition, the temporal resolution under various conditions was estimated. A stepping motor was used to move the phantom over an arc in a reciprocating manner. The program for controlling the stepping motor permitted the stationary period and the heart rate to be adjusted as desired. Images of the phantom were obtained using a 320-row area-detector computed tomography (ADCT) system under various conditions using the ECG-gated reconstruction method. For estimation, the reconstruction phase was continuously changed and the motion artifacts were quantitatively assessed. The temporal resolution was calculated from the number of motion-free images. Changes in the temporal resolution according to heart rate, rotation time, the number of reconstruction segments and acquisition position in z-axis were also investigated. The measured temporal resolution of ECG-gated half reconstruction is 180 ms, which is in good agreement with the nominal temporal resolution of 175 ms. The measured temporal resolution of ECG-gated segmental reconstruction is in good agreement with the nominal temporal resolution in most cases. The estimated temporal resolution improved to approach the nominal temporal resolution as the number of reconstruction segments was increased. Temporal resolution in changing acquisition position is equal. This study shows that we could design a new phantom for estimating temporal resolution.     

Gauging effective spatial resolution in multirow helical cardiac computed tomography with a dynamic phantom

PURPOSE: To devise a numerical indicator of image quality for multirow helical cardiac computed tomography (CT) and its relation to temporal resolution. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A pulsatile cardiac assist device was used to simulate cardiac wall motion by mechanically transmitting the device dynamics to a piece of tungsten wire. Wire motion induced by different device rates was captured with an 8-row subsecond helical CT scanner operating with various scanning parameters. Image artifacts were visually assessed and compared with the image point spread function (PSF) using the full width at half maximum (FWHM) area as a numerical estimate of spatial accuracy. RESULTS: At rest, the FWHM area was determined as 1.3 mm2. At a device rate of 60 bpm, the FWHM area ranged from 1.51 mm2 to 21.62 mm2, depending on the time of image reconstruction. Mean reproducibility of the FWHM area measurements was determined as 0.05, whereas visual estimates of motion artifact were highly variable between different readers (kappa = 0.19). Visually determined image quality correlated closely with the FWHM area metric (Spearman's rank correlation, P = 0.0001, rho = 0.841). At a device rate of 100 bpm, the minimum FWHM area was 2.00 mm2 using a single-sector algorithm, 1.41 mm2 using a 2-segment algorithm, and 1.37 mm2 using a 4-segment algorithm. CONCLUSIONS: Use of a pulsatile cardiac assist device could serve as an in vitro test bed for cardiac CT imaging methods. Area FWHM of the PSF correlates well with visually determined image quality of a dynamic phantom, but provides better reproducibility than visual analysis.     

An audit of image quality of three dental cone beam computed tomography units

Critical analysis of cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) image quality is recommended as part of a quality assurance program.^1,2 There are few papers³ in the literature concerning subjective image quality on CBCT imaging.This study, performed as part of an audit, reviewed all images of the jaws performed on three different CBCT units over a twelve month period. Images were graded according to an agreed standard¹ and reasons for image rejection recorded.The results demonstrated that the main reasons for image rejection were motion artefact and problems with field of view size and positioning.The need for reducing the number of rejected images in order to optimize patient dose, and ways to achieve this, are discussed     

A model for temporal resolution of multidetector computed tomography of coronary arteries in relation to rotation time, heart rate and reconstruction algorithm

A model is presented that describes the image quality of coronary arteries with multidetector computer tomography. The results are discussed in the context of rotation time of the scanner, heart rate, and number of sectors used in the acquisition process. The blurring of the coronary arteries was calculated for heart rates between 50 and 100 bpm for rotation times of 420, 370, and 330 ms, and one-, two-, three-, and four-sector acquisition modes and irregular coronary artery movement is included. The model predicts optimal timing within the RR cycle of 45±3% (RCA), 44±4% and 74±6% (LCX), and 35±4% and 76±5% (LAD). The optimal timing shows a negative linear dependency on heart rate and increases with the number of sectors used. The RCA blurring decreases from 0.98 cm for 420 ms, one-sector mode to 0.27 cm for 330 ms, four-sector mode. The corresponding values are 0.81 cm and 0.29 cm for LCX and 0.42 cm and 0.17 cm for LAD. The number of sectors used in a multisector reconstruction and the timing within the cardiac cycle should be adjusted to the specific coronary artery that has to be imaged. Irregular coronary artery movement of 1.5 mm justifies the statement that no more than two sectors should be used in multisector acquisition processes in order to improve temporal resolution in cardiac MDCT.     

The influence of heart rate, slice thickness, and calcification density on calcium scores using 64-slice multidetector computed tomography: a systematic phantom study

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to investigate the influence of heart rate, slice thickness, and calcification density on absolute value and variability of calcium score using 64-slice multidetector computed tomography (MDCT). METHODS AND MATERIALS: Three artificial arteries containing each 3 lesions with varying density were scanned using a moving cardiac phantom at rest and at 50 to 110 beats per minute (bpm) at 10-bpm intervals on a 64-slice MDCT. Images were reconstructed at slice thicknesses (increment) of 0.6 (0.4), 0.75 (0.5), 1.5 (1.5), and 3.0 (3.0) mm. The amount of calcium was expressed as an Agatston score, volume score, and equivalent mass. RESULTS: Absolute coronary artery calcium (CAC) scores decreased [average -37% for low density calcification (LDC)] or increased [average +32% for high density calcification (HDC)] at heart rates over 60 bpm depending on slice thickness and scoring method. Thinner slice thicknesses yielded higher CAC scores. Variability of the CAC scores increased with increasing heart rates especially for low density calcifications (8% at rest vs. 50% at 110 bpm). Variability also increased for thicker slices (average 6% for 0.6 mm vs. 18% for 3.0 mm). Variability was lower for HDC compared with LDC (approximately 5% for HDC vs. 27% for LDC at 70 bpm, averaged over all methods and slice thicknesses). CONCLUSION: CAC-scoring is strongly influenced by cardiac motion, calcification density, and slice thickness. CAC scores increase for high density calcifications and decrease for low density calcifications at increasing heart rates. Heart rate should be reduced on 64-slice MDCT to obtain a lower degree of variability of CAC-scoring, preferably below 70 bpm. A thinner slice thickness further enhances the reproducibility.     

Radioanatomical study of a true tracheal bronchus using multidetector computed tomography

Purpose  

True tracheal bronchus (TTB) is a rare anomaly in which a lobar or segmental ectopic bronchus arises from the trachea. We examined the frequency and multidetector computed tomography (MDCT) appearances of TTB.     

Effect of acquisition technique on radiation dose and image quality in multidetector row computed tomography coronary angiography with submillimeter collimation

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: We sought to examine effects of tube voltage and current on radiation dose and image quality for minimally invasive coronary angiography with a 16-slice multidetector row computed tomography (MDCT) scanner. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We scanned the phantom used in the American College of Radiology Computed Tomography Accreditation Program at tube voltages of 80 and 120 kVp at 550, 650, and 750 mAseff, with and without a reduction in radiation dose by electrocardiographically (ECG) controlled tube current modulation (ECG pulsing). RESULTS: Without ECG pulsing, the effective dose was 3 to 13 mSv. On average, a 50% increase in tube voltage led to increased radiation dose (215%), contrast-to-noise ratio (150%), and decreased image noise (-48%). On average, a 17% increase in mAseff led to increased radiation dose (17%) and contrast-to-noise ratio (4%) and decreased image noise (-9%). Dose reduction by ECG pulsing (simulated heart rate, 70 beats per minute) was 28%. With ECG pulsing, noise in images reconstructed during ventricular systole was double that in images reconstructed during ventricular diastole. CONCLUSIONS: These quantitative findings about the relationships among scan acquisition parameters, radiation dose, and image quality have practical implications for using ECG pulsing to reduce radiation doses in MDCT coronary angiography.     

Accelerating image acquisition in 64-MDCT: the influence of scan parameters on image resolution and quality in a phantom study

Computed tomographic (CT) image resolution and quality were evaluated utilizing varying scan protocols with accelerated image acquisition. A resolution phantom with hole diameters from 0.2 to 1.0 mm was scanned in axial, coronal, and sagittal plane using a 64-slice multidetector CT with varying scan parameters. No relevant differences in image resolution and quality were detected between the fastest scan protocol, with the shortest rotation time and highest pitch, and the slowest protocol. Accelerated CT protocols resulted in diagnostic images with adequate resolution and quality.