Value of the computerized analysis of ST segment depression during exercise without myocardial infarction. Apropos of 807 cases

The diagnostic value of ST segment changes on exercise were reassessed by computerised analysis in 807 patients without myocardial infarction who underwent coronary angiography. All the stress tests were carried out according to Bruce's protocol with a system of continuous averaging of the ST segment in V5, V2 and VF. An abnormal response was defined by the association of the following three criteria: 1) ST depression less than or equal to 1 mm, 2) the algebraic sum of the depression + ST slope less than or equal to -1, 3) changes occurring during exercise or the first minute of recovery. A significant coronary lesion was defined as at least 50 per cent narrowing of the vessel lumen. In the study population the prevalence of lesions was 55 per cent in men and 18 per cent in women. The sensitivity of exercise stress testing was 69 per cent but the specificity was only 65 per cent. The positive predictive value was 70 per cent in men, 29 per cent in women; the negative predictive value was 90 per cent in women compared with 62 per cent in men. The predictive values depended on the interpretation of the amplitude, morphology and topography of the ST depression. The low sensitivity and specificity were independent of the coronary angiographic criteria and not related to the bias usually encountered in the correlation between stress testing and coronary angiography. These results show that the quantitative analysis of ST changes during computerised stress testing is not sufficiently accurate in itself to detect atherosclerotic coronary artery disease.     

Changes of Q wave amplitude during exercise for the prediction of coronary artery disease

We have examined the changes of Q wave amplitude during exercise in 156 patients with chest pain with a view to improving the accuracy of stress testing for the diagnosis of coronary artery disease. Coronary arteriography showed significant disease in 127 patients and normal arteries or minimal disease in 29. The Q wave amplitude was measured in lead CM5 from the computer-derived average of 25 consecutive beats immediately before and at the peak of maximal treadmill exercise. The amplitude was greater in the normal subjects at rest and increased with exercise, but the reverse occurred in those with coronary disease. Using the criterion of decrease or no change of Q wave amplitude during exercise as indicating a positive test, the discriminative capacity of Q wave changes was equivalent to that of ST segment depression and was maintained when patients with myocardial infarction were excluded. Using either an abnormal Q wave or ST segment response to exercise improved the test's sensitivity with a loss of specificity but no change of predictive value. In 42% of patients with coronary disease when both the Q wave and ST segment exercise responses were abnormal coronary disease was predicted with an accuracy of 91%. Analysis of subgroups of patients with coronary artery disease suggested a possible explanation for the observed changes in Q wave amplitude, measurement of which can improve the stress test's accuracy for predicting obstructive coronary artery disease.     

Changes in the electrocardiographic response to exercise in healthy women.

Changes in the P wave, QRS complex, ST segment, and T wave during and after maximal exercise were quantitatively analysed in 116 healthy women with a mean age of 39. The corrected orthogonal Frank lead electrocardiogram was continuously recorded and computer processed during bicycle ergometry. With exercise, maximal spatial P wave vectors shifted downward. The Q wave amplitude became more negative and the R wave amplitude diminished considerably in leads X and Y: the S wave amplitude decreased only slightly in these leads. The QRS vectors shifted towards right and posteriorly during exertion and a further shift in the same direction was seen in the recovery period. The ST segment amplitude 60 ms after the J point decreased with exertion and became negative at heart rates above 140 beats per minute, in particular in lead Y. ST segment depression increased with age. The T wave amplitude decreased during exercise and increased sharply in the recovery period. Though mean R wave amplitude in leads X and Y became more negative with exercise, this response was unpredictable in individual women. The exercise induced changes in QRS vectors in women resembled those described in men. Changes in the amplitude of the R wave should not be used for the diagnosis of coronary disease in women. ST segment depression was more pronounced in the inferiorly oriented lead Y than in lead X but it was unrelated to changes in the QRS vectors in these leads.     

Changes in the electrocardiographic response to exercise in healthy women

Changes in the P wave, QRS complex, ST segment, and T wave during and after maximal exercise were quantitatively analysed in 116 healthy women with a mean age of 39. The corrected orthogonal Frank lead electrocardiogram was continuously recorded and computer processed during bicycle ergometry. With exercise, maximal spatial P wave vectors shifted downward. The Q wave amplitude became more negative and the R wave amplitude diminished considerably in leads X and Y: the S wave amplitude decreased only slightly in these leads. The QRS vectors shifted towards right and posteriorly during exertion and a further shift in the same direction was seen in the recovery period. The ST segment amplitude 60 ms after the J point decreased with exertion and became negative at heart rates above 140 beats per minute, in particular in lead Y. ST segment depression increased with age. The T wave amplitude decreased during exercise and increased sharply in the recovery period. Though mean R wave amplitude in leads X and Y became more negative with exercise, this response was unpredictable in individual women. The exercise induced changes in QRS vectors in women resembled those described in men. Changes in the amplitude of the R wave should not be used for the diagnosis of coronary disease in women. ST segment depression was more pronounced in the inferiorly oriented lead Y than in lead X but it was unrelated to changes in the QRS vectors in these leads.     

Useless diagnostic value of exercise-induced R wave changes in coronary artery disease

To investigate the usefulness of exercise-induced R wave changesin the diagnosis of coronary artery disease and detection ofleft ventricular contraction abnormalities, 105 patients werestudied. Among 64 patients who had significant coronary arterydisease ( 70% narrowing), 43 showed an increase or no changein the R wave amplitude and 55 showed ST segment depression(sensitivity 67 versus 86%). Among 41 patients without significantstenosis, 11 had decreased R wave amplitude and 36 had no changein ST segment (specificity 27 versus 88%). Twenty-five of 64coronary disease patients had left ventricular contraction abnormalities,and the R wave amplitude changes gave a sensitivity of 80%,specificity of 41% and a predictive value of 47%. There wereno differences in the variables of exercise intensity and ejectionfraction between patients who had decreased R wave amplitudeand those in whom it increased or did not change. We conclude that R wave amplitude change during exercise isnot a useful variable for the diagnosis or evaluation of patientswith coronary artery disease.     

Diagnostic value of changes in Q wave amplitude in left thoracic leads during physical loading

The informative value of stress-induced changes in Q wave amplitude and ST segment for the diagnosis of coronary heart disease was compared in records from left chest leads. Bicycle ergometry was conducted in 74 patients with coronary angiographically documented stenosis (more than 70% of the lumen) of one or more coronary arteries, and 28 subjects showing no apparent coronary arterial changes. The lack of increment in Q wave amplitude was shown to be a fairly sensitive sign of myocardial ischemia. Yet, its specificity is relatively low, much inferior to that of ST changes. The predictive value of changes in ST segment is significantly higher, as compared to that of changes in Q wave amplitude during exercise. Simultaneous assessment of ST and Q wave changes in response to stress failed to improve the predictive accuracy, as compared to the interpretation of ST changes alone.     

Factors influencing R wave amplitude in patients with ischaemic heart disease.

R wave amplitude changes during exercise have been ascribed to alteration in left ventricular volume and their measurement advocated for the improved diagnosis of coronary disease. The reproducibility of exercise QRS changes and their relation to ST segment depression, respiratory pattern, and left ventricular volume during ischaemia were studied in 10 patients with angina and coronary disease. QRS amplitude was measured in a 16 lead precordial map during three identical exercise tests in each patient and left ventricular volume assessed continuously using gated blood pool imaging with a single scintillation probe during manoeuvres to provoke ischaemia. During exercise, QRS amplitude increased or remained unchanged in four patients and fell in six patients in a consistent manner for each patient. R wave amplitude was not affected by changes in respiratory pattern. R wave amplitude did not alter in 33 of 39 episodes of left ventricular volume increase (mean 32%) or decrease (mean 36%) in end-diastolic counts. These findings suggest that precordial R wave changes during ischaemia are not determined primarily by alteration in left ventricular volume or the respiratory pattern. Though reproducible in each patient and following a definite relation to ST segment depression, the variable directional response during exercise suggest that R wave amplitude changes have little diagnostic value.     

Accurate detection of triple vessel disease in patients with exercise induced ST segment depression after infarction

The severity of coronary artery disease is an important determinant of prognosis after acute myocardial infarction. The ability of a symptom limited exercise test to predict the presence of triple vessel disease was assessed in 221 patients three weeks after infarction. Coronary angiography was performed in patients with exercise induced ST segment depression. The presence of ST segment depression alone was poorly indicative of triple vessel disease; however, some specific features of ST segment changes on exercise were of predictive value. Downsloping ST segment configuration alone or horizontal ST segment depression associated with an early onset and a late recovery time after exercise correctly identified 30 (90%) of 33 patients with triple vessel disease whereas it incorrectly identified only 6 (15%) of 39 patients with single and double vessel disease. An abnormal blood pressure response was also predictive. In patients with ST segment depression after infarction triple vessel disease can be detected accurately by a combination of the electrocardiographic and haemodynamic variables attained on exercise.     

The ST segment of the ambulatory electrocardiogram in a normal population.

The behaviour of the ST segment in everyday life was studied by ambulatory electrocardiography in 111 normal volunteers. Fifteen were excluded because of abnormal exercise responses (10 subjects) and significant postural ST segment shifts (five subjects). This left 62 men and 34 women, mean (SD) age 40.5 (12.6) years (range 20-67 years). Ambulatory monitoring of leads CM5 and CC5 for 24 hours was followed by a maximal treadmill exercise test. The tapes of the ambulatory monitoring were analysed by a computer aided system. The computer printed trend plots of the ST segment (measured both at the J point and at J + 60 ms) to detect episodes of ST segment elevation and depression, which were confirmed by visual analysis of real time printouts. Twelve subjects showed "ischaemic" ST segment depression and nine subjects showed ST segment elevation. Eight people with ambulatory ST segment changes were studied during exercise by radionuclide ventriculography and thallium-201 imaging scans. Although seven of the eight thallium studies were normal, radionuclide ventriculography showed functional impairment in five cases. Seven of the 10 subjects with abnormal exercise tests were similarly investigated and their results followed the same pattern, with normal thallium images in six and functional impairment in four. Ambulatory electrocardiography was repeated in 20 people after a median of 20 days. The ST segment changes were reproducible. ST segment changes of an apparently ischaemic nature occur even in a carefully defined normal population but they do not necessarily represent latent clinically significant coronary artery disease. This indicates that ST segment changes seen in patients with known obstructive coronary artery disease should be interpreted with caution.     

The ST segment of the ambulatory electrocardiogram in a normal population

The behaviour of the ST segment in everyday life was studied by ambulatory electrocardiography in 111 normal volunteers. Fifteen were excluded because of abnormal exercise responses (10 subjects) and significant postural ST segment shifts (five subjects). This left 62 men and 34 women, mean (SD) age 40.5 (12.6) years (range 20-67 years). Ambulatory monitoring of leads CM5 and CC5 for 24 hours was followed by a maximal treadmill exercise test. The tapes of the ambulatory monitoring were analysed by a computer aided system. The computer printed trend plots of the ST segment (measured both at the J point and at J + 60 ms) to detect episodes of ST segment elevation and depression, which were confirmed by visual analysis of real time printouts. Twelve subjects showed "ischaemic" ST segment depression and nine subjects showed ST segment elevation. Eight people with ambulatory ST segment changes were studied during exercise by radionuclide ventriculography and thallium-201 imaging scans. Although seven of the eight thallium studies were normal, radionuclide ventriculography showed functional impairment in five cases. Seven of the 10 subjects with abnormal exercise tests were similarly investigated and their results followed the same pattern, with normal thallium images in six and functional impairment in four. Ambulatory electrocardiography was repeated in 20 people after a median of 20 days. The ST segment changes were reproducible. ST segment changes of an apparently ischaemic nature occur even in a carefully defined normal population but they do not necessarily represent latent clinically significant coronary artery disease. This indicates that ST segment changes seen in patients with known obstructive coronary artery disease should be interpreted with caution.     

Accurate detection of triple vessel disease in patients with exercise induced ST segment depression after infarction.

The severity of coronary artery disease is an important determinant of prognosis after acute myocardial infarction. The ability of a symptom limited exercise test to predict the presence of triple vessel disease was assessed in 221 patients three weeks after infarction. Coronary angiography was performed in patients with exercise induced ST segment depression. The presence of ST segment depression alone was poorly indicative of triple vessel disease; however, some specific features of ST segment changes on exercise were of predictive value. Downsloping ST segment configuration alone or horizontal ST segment depression associated with an early onset and a late recovery time after exercise correctly identified 30 (90%) of 33 patients with triple vessel disease whereas it incorrectly identified only 6 (15%) of 39 patients with single and double vessel disease. An abnormal blood pressure response was also predictive. In patients with ST segment depression after infarction triple vessel disease can be detected accurately by a combination of the electrocardiographic and haemodynamic variables attained on exercise.     

Significance of Lead Strength during Exercise Testing

Background : The aim of the study was to evaluate the contribution of relative lead strengths to exercise‐induced ECG changes (ST depression) to predict the degree of myocardial ischemia as compared to the angiograms. This was accomplished by comparing the magnitude of ST depression to the ST/R ratio. Studies have shown that the diagnostic strength of a lead is directly related to the R wave amplitude 1 and that sensitivity is significantly improved. Methods : Three hundred patients, who underwent treadmill exercise testing and coronary angiography revealing significant coronary narrowing (≥70% luminal diameter narrowing), were studied, along with 150 patients clear of significant coronary artery disease (<70% luminar diameter narrowing). Our goal was to determine the correlation between the relative lead strengths, using a constructed ST/R ratio, to exercise induced ECG changes (ST depression) to predict the presence of myocardial ischemia as compared to angiographic findings. Using a cutoff of 0.1 for the ST/R ratio, our data were compared to the sensitivity and specificity of 1.0 mm ST depression. Results : Overall sensitivity was improved for the ST/R ratio (84% vs 78%), while specificity was slightly decreased (81% vs 92%) in comparison to standard ST depression. When differentiating between R wave amplitudes, those with R wave ≤ 10 mm showed significantly improved sensitivity (88% vs 54%) and a minor decrease in specificity (90% vs 92%). In those with R wave ≥ 20 mm, the sensitivity of ST depression was higher (88% vs 71%) but the ST/R ratio was much more specific (88% vs 46%). No significant difference was observed when differentiating between male and female patients. Conclusion : We found that the correction of ST depression for R wave amplitude results in improved sensitivity in patients with low R waves and specificity in patients with very tall R waves (R ≥ 20 mm).     

R wave amplitude during exercise. Relation to left ventricular function and coronary artery disease.

Change in R wave amplitude (mean delta R) was measured sequentially during and after 12 lead maximal treadmill exercise tests in 14 subjects with normal coronary arteries and 62 patients with coronary artery disease. In normal subjects mean delta R decreased maximally one minute after exercise and returned to control levels within three minutes. In contrast, mean delta R increased in patients with coronary artery disease, the greatest change occurring in patients with either triple vessel or left main disease or those with an akinetic region on the left ventriculogram. R wave amplitude returned to resting levels in five minutes. Increase in R wave amplitude was not directly related to changes in the ST segment. Changes in R wave amplitude during maximal treadmill exercise may improve the discrimination between patients with and without coronary artery disease and may help to identify those patients with abnormal left ventricular function.     

Comparative evaluation of exercise ST response in healthy males and females. A computer study

In order to evaluate both quantitatively and qualitatively exercise ST response in females, we have studied 232 healthy subjects (age range 35-59 years): 82 women (mean age 45.8 years) and 150 men (mean age 46.1 years). All subjects had performed a maximal treadmill exercise in 1976 and were followed up for 6 years in order to exclude the presence of subclinical coronary artery disease. Exercise ST segment responses were evaluated in a single bipolar lead (CB5) and were classified as 'positive' by visual interpretation when a 1.0-mm or greater 'ischemic' ST depression occurred. A computer system was employed to evaluate exercise ST changes quantitatively. The following ST parameters were evaluated: ST depression at R + 80 ms point (ST2); mean ST depression (STmean), and ST time-voltage integral (STarea). Computer analysis of resting ECG has shown lower ST voltages in females than in males. ST2, STarea, and STmean changes from basal to maximal exercise values were not significantly different in men and women. A similar prevalence of 'positive' responses in males and females was also found by ECG visual interpretation. In conclusion, our data show that in healthy subjects exercise ST segment response is comparable in males and females and indirectly suggest that the lower predictive value of exercise ECG in women is likely to be related to different coronary artery disease prevalence.     

R wave amplitude changes during stress testing. Comparison with ST segment depression and angiographic correlation

One-hundred and seven exercise stress tests and coronary angiograms were reviewed retrospectively, in order to evaluate the usefulness of R wave amplitude changes (ΔR) during exercise compared with ST segment depression in the screening of patients with coronary artery disease (CAD).We also attempted to correlate ΔR with the severity of CAD as expressed by coronary arteriography and left ventriculography.Thirty-six patients showed no coronary artery narrowing (0-V); the remaining 71 patients with stenosis of 70% of at least one of the major coronary arteries were divided into three groups.Sixteen patients had single vessel disease (1-V); five (31%) in this group showed abnormal left ventricular wall motion. Thirty-one patients had two-vessel disease (2-V); 22 (71%) of the 31 demonstrated abnormal left ventricular wall motion. Twenty-four patients had three-vessel disease (3-V); 20 (83%) of the 24 showed abnormal left ventricular wall motion.We considered ΔR values ≥ 0 and ST segment depression ≥ 1 mm. significant for diagnosis of CAD.The sensitivity of the ΔR method in predicting CAD was superior to the method based upon ST segment depression; however, the latter was significantly (P < .02) more specific than the former. The predictive accuracy of these two criteria was similar.We found ΔR values ≥ 0 more frequently in the 2-V and 3-V groups as compared with the 1-V group. Patients of the 2-V and 3-V groups had a significantly higher incidence of abnormal left ventricular wall motion (P < .01, P < .0002, respectively) in comparison with 1-V patients. Thus, ΔR values ≥ 0 during exercise stress testing are very likely related to left ventricular impairment.Even though the accuracy of the ΔR method was greater in more severe CAD, it seems to be offset by a concomitant decrease in specificity.     

Recovery-phase patterns of ST segment depression in the heart rate domain. Identification of coronary artery disease by the rate-recovery loop

Although the time course of ST segment depression after exercise has been related to the presence and severity of coronary artery disease, recovery-phase patterns of ST segment depression with reference to changing heart rate have not been quantified. We have found distinct recovery loop patterns of ST segment depression that distinguish subjects without coronary disease from patients with coronary artery disease when ST segment depression is examined in the heart rate domain. Continuous plots of ST segment depression and heart rate were constructed throughout treadmill exercise and recovery in 100 clinically normal subjects, in 124 patients with coronary artery disease proven by catheterization, and in 17 patients with no significant coronary disease at catheterization. Among clinically normal subjects, 95% (95 of 100) had normal (clockwise) rate-recovery loops, and 5% (five of 100) had abnormal (counterclockwise) rate-recovery loops. In these normal subjects, the resulting 95% specificity of a normal rate-recovery loop was similar to the 93% (93 of 100) specificity of standard end-exercise ST segment depression criteria. Among patients with coronary disease proven by angiography, 93% (115 of 124) had abnormal (counterclockwise) rate-recovery loops, and 7% (nine of 124) had normal rate-recovery loops. In contrast was the significantly lower 74% (92 of 124) sensitivity of standard ST segment criteria (p less than 0.001 vs. the rate-recovery loop). Specificity of a normal rate-recovery loop (71%, 12 of 17) and standard ST segment depression criteria (71%, 12 of 17) were similar in the patients with normal coronary arteries at angiography.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Spatial R wave amplitude changes during exercise: relation with left ventricular ischemia and function

Thirty patients who exhibited increased and 65 patients decreased spatial R wave amplitude during exercise testing were compared for left ventricular function and ischemic variables. Spatial R wave amplitude was derived from the three-dimensional Frank X, Y, Z leads using computerized methods. All patients had stable coronary artery disease and they were classified into two groups: one that attained a higher (n = 48) and one a lower (n = 47) median value of maximal heart rate during exercise (161 beats/min). Within these two groups, patients with increasing or decreasing spatial R wave amplitude during exercise were analyzed for differences in oxygen consumption, exercise-induced changes in spatial R wave amplitude, ST segment depression laterally (ST60, lead X), ST displacement spatially, left ventricular ejection fraction at rest, change in left ventricular ejection fraction with exercise and thallium-201 ischemia during exercise. Significant differences were demonstrated only in exercise-induced spatial R wave amplitude changes (p less than 0.0001). There was no significant correlation between exercise-induced change in heart rate and change in spatial R wave amplitude in either the group with increasing or the group with decreasing spatial R wave amplitude. It is concluded that changes in spatial R wave amplitude during exercise are not related to ischemic electrocardiographic or thallium-201 imaging changes or to left ventricular ejection fraction determined at rest or during exercise.     

Giant R wave, convex ST-segment elevation, and negative T wave during exercise treadmill test

The giant R wave syndrome is characterized by giant R wave accompanied by widening of the QRS complex, marked ST segment elevation, QRS axis deviation, and the formation of monophasic QRS-ST complex with obliteration of S wave in leads facing the ischemic zone. This report describes a 65-year-old-man with variant angina who had a transient giant R wave syndrome during an exercise treadmill test. Initially, at peak exercise, there was a convex ST segment elevation ending in a negative T wave in the same (inferior) leads which showed giant R waves. Later, in the recovery period and coinciding with an amelioration of myocardial ischemia, there was a less marked increase of R wave amplitude associated with concave ST segment elevation and positive T wave in the inferolateral leads. Subsequently, a ST segment depression in the inferolateral leads preceded the ECG normalization. The patient had also a concave ST segment elevation and positive T wave in inferolateral leads during a spontaneous episode of variant angina at rest. An emergency coronary arteriography showed a dominant right coronary artery with an 80% and a 75% diameter stenosis of the middle and distal segment, respectively; the other arteries and left ventriculogram were normal. The underlying mechanisms of the different shapes of ST segment elevation and T waveform in the setting of acute transmural myocardial ischemia are discussed.     

R wave amplitude changes during stress testing in ischemic patients with normal epicardial coronary arteries

R wave amplitude changes during stress testing were validated in 12 ischemic patients with normal coronary angiograms. The data were compared with findings obtained from 10 patients with clinical and angiographic evidence of coronary arterial disease and 10 normal controls. An abnormal R wave amplitude response occurred in 83.3% of the group with normal coronary angiography, in 80% of the group of patients with clinical and angiographic evidence of coronary arterial disease, and in only 10% of the control group. The similarity of R wave amplitude changes in the first two group suggests that these changes are related to ischemia. If so, then R wave amplitude response to exercise could be of value in the electrocardiographic diagnosis of ischemia in patients with angiographically normal coronary arteries.     

Relation of exercise-induced physiologic S-T segment depression to R wave amplitude in normal subjects

Exercise electrocardiography was performed in 100 asymptomatic male volunteers with a mean age of 42.6 years. The R wave and total RS amplitude and the magnitude of physiologic S-T segment depression at the J junction were quantitated for a modified bipolar CC₅ lead and a vertically oriented bipolar lead (VL) using computer-averaged groups of 25 consecutive QRS complexes from each of seven stages of rest and exercise. Computer-generated X-Y plots were used to examine the correlations between the magnitude of S-T depression and the R wave and total RS amplitudes. The magnitude of S-T depression and of the R wave amplitude were unrelated at standing rest but showed increasing correlation with progressive increases in exercise heart rate (correlation coefficient = 0.425, p <0.00001 at maximal exercise). The total RS amplitude was also related to the magnitude of S-T depression during exercise, but the correlations did not improve progressively with increases in exercise heart rate. The magnitude of S-T depression was more closely related to R wave amplitude and total RS amplitude in the vertically oriented lead than in the CC₅ lead.These data demonstrate a significant relation between the magnitude of R wave and total RS amplitudes and the magnitude of physiologic S-T segment depression in normal subjects during exercise. They suggest the need for evaluation of S-T depression corrected for R wave amplitude in an attempt to improve the diagnostic accuracy of the exercise electrocardiogram. The data also suggest that the criteria for abnormal S-T depression should take into consideration the different R wave voltages reflected by different types of recording leads.